88-501 /
WHITE - CITV CLERK .
PINK - FINANCE GITY OF' AINT PAUL Council �,5.��
CANARV -DEPARTMENT
BI.UE - MAVOR File NO.
' ° 0 ndnce Ordinance N 0.
Presented ! ` � �
� �
Referre o '�m ' '" Committee: Date �� l���
Out of Committee By Date
An Ordinance amendi g Sections 411 .01 and
411 .04(b)2 of the S int Paul Legislative -
Code pertaining to ntertainment.
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAIN PRUL DOES ORDAIN:
Se tion l .
That Section 411 . 01 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is here-
by amended to read as follows :
Sec. 411 .01 . License req ired.
No person licensed under Chapter 409 or Chapter 410
shall provide or furnis entertainment on or adjacent
to the licensed premise without first having obtained
a license so to do as her inafter provided.
S ction 2.
That Section 411 . 04(b)2 o the Saint Paul Legislative Code is
hereby amended to read as foll ws :
(2) Consent of Owners a d Occupants within �Two Hundred
Feet: The applicant sh 11 present with �°r�s- application
a statement in writing with the signatures of as many
of the owners and occu ants of all property, including
private residences , d ellings and apartment houses
located within two hund ed (200) feet of such premises
the applicant as/�re- can obtain to the ffect that they have no ob j ection
to the granting of su h entertainment license or the
operation of the busin ss of conducting entertainment
at the location proposed
COUNCIL MEMBERS � �
Yeas Nays � Requested by Department of:
Dimond �' "
�� ,..�� � � ,t�� [n Fav r
Goswitz �t ;`t�/
�n�i�t ��3 s �- Against gv
Sonnen ��.�'
Wilson �t�'
� Form Approved City Attor y
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
WHITE - CITY CLERK �
PINK - FINANCE COUflCll c
CANARV -DEPARTMENT GITY OF SA NT PAUL '7 I
BLUE -MAVOR File NO. ��_`� D
Ordin nce Ordinance N 0.
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
If the applicant obtains the ignatures of ninety (90)
percent or more of such persons , the council may grant
the license. If the appli ant obtains the signatures
of sixty (60) percent to ninety (90) percent of such
persons , the council may gr nt the license upon finding
that issuance of the licen e would not interfere with
the reasonable use and enjo ment of neighboring property
and residences and would ot bear adversely on the
health, safety, morals and eneral welfare of the com-
munity. Such finds shall be based on the following
considerations if the licens were to be granted:
a. The effect on the sur ounding community and insti-
tutions ;
b. Noise and likelihood of dverse effect on residential
occupants ;
c . The possibility of increa ed traffic ;
d. The character of the neig borhood;
e. Other like uses in the ne ghborhood.
If the applicant fails t obtain the signatures of
sixty (60) percent of su h persons , the license shall
not in any case be granted.
Section 3.
This ordinance shall take e fect and be in force thirty days
from and after its passage , appr val and publication.
2 .
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
�ng [n Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
�he;be� Against BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Appr d by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY `'
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by ayor for Submission to Council
sy By
_ -r .s.. - . . . . ' , �
. �-'� _ �.� • . , .� .. . :.- ""i' ��� ` .. .:.....,.,� . . .. � . . ,,
WMITE - CIT�( CLERK -.. . . . � . � , . .
.. RINK �� FIN�f'�lJCE. T '-. � ..., . .,�OUI1Cl1� �
B�UERr-MAVORTMENT � � �jTY OF S INT�� �PA.iTL File NO. � ���� ���� � -
� .
f Ord� I`CG Ordinance N�.
� Presented By .
Re�erred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
Z f !� a�lieaot obta#.�s tt�e siyrsatusea �f �tp t g4}
�t�e�'C ,�►r �t�e +�f sucl� , t�re �cil a� Qrar�t
�` 2�.�. 3f tt� aip�l c�►t obtsi� t.�` si9ast�s- -- -.:_.,
� ��1r t$a3 �erc.nt to irret�r f'�� p�rae� ot ,�rcb .
per�s. #.2�s ecwncii �I � L t!� lft�e� vpeR fizidi� _ ;., _,.
t.b�tt is� of tt�s li �rould mot i�tt�rtfrs Mitb► �
tt�e reis�bi� wie aedt �rnl +a�, asit,�b+oar'i� Prr�Pt�'tl► ;
�d r�sid�aas ae�d �o�l� �t b+rsr �rsely e� !�
� t�rsl'!�� saf�ty, �rals a�d �1 �r�!'� �f tht cwr-
�ity. S�b fl�ds �I b� mas�d on th�e iail+owfnq
consi�rativns f! tbe � �rere to be q�r�t�td s ' ��`'� �
a. T'�t affect can tbe oo�itj► �d 3�sti- !
tutie�e�s; �:
b. �ioise �! likalitsood of �e �tl�at ce� rfaid�e�t.ial
. cN.wcupants: Y
c. 3� possibS�it�r at iAC �rsflic;
d. ?ht c�traatec of tt�f �i ;
- e. 4thfr li�ar �ses i� tt�e i+�fbortiood.
If t� �pplicant � fail� c�#air tlr si�at�res +e�!' �
•K j �ixt�t �64) Per�t of perso�s.��ir ii�t sha�ii . ��
E�li� 1A �y Cis! b� IH!`a1'i�. - . , ''
}, i� 3.
t` ,
� ' 'i"�tis +e�r�2ia�ace �all 'tai�! l�ct a�d be 1�► fot�t thtrt�t Aays ,�
�froa �nd a►ltsr its P�assa►�e, : 1 �eid p�lit�atiaa. .,�
ii
- . , . . '-�---� .
COUI�CIL MEMBERS ' t Requested by Department of:
. Yeas Nays
Dimond
� ! �� In�Favor ��" � F�
Goswitz .
Rettman BY �
�
��� Against
� Sonnen
�Vilson
� Adopted by Council: Date Form Approved by City Attorney
Certified Passed by Council Secretary By
�
By
i .Approv¢d by Mayoc: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
,- By BY . .
� . . � , .(,;c��i
. - ��»,��t : � , . .
>�>���_• �';� • CITY OF SAINT PAUL
��0 ����
;; �:; OFFICE OF 7HE CITY ATTORNEY
';� iiii'iii'ii �`�
<,`m EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY
- "a;�L,��•�•fi,,.�`' 647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 5510�
612-298-5121
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
April 1 , 1988
Council Member William Wilson
Seventh Floor
City Hall
Re : Ordinance amending enterta nment license
provisions - Chapter 411 .
Dear Council Member Wilson:
You had requested that our of ice prepare amendments to Sections
411 .01 and 411 . 04 of the Legis ative Code dealing with entertain-
ment licenses . The amendmen to Section 411 .01 would specify
that a person licensed unde Chapter 409 or Chapter 410 who
wishes to provide entertainme t either on the licensed premises
or adjacent to the licensed p emises must also obtain an enter-
tainment license under Chapter 411 . I think that was the intent
of your request.
The change to Section 411 .04 would require the written consent
of owners of all property wit in 200 feet of the proposed enter-
tainment license . The pres nt ordinance requires the consent
of the owners or occupants of esidential property only.
If I can be of any furthe assistance , please feel free to
call .
You very tr ly,
�
J ROM . SE AL �
A si a t City Attorne,y
�
�
JJS g
Encl .
� , . . �
, RECEIVED
� COCHRANE & RESNAHAN, P.A.
ATTORNE S AT LAW MAY 121988
24 EAST th STREET
SAINT PAUL, MIN ESOTA 55101-1099 CITY CLERK
JOHN A.COCHRANE
JAMES R.BRESNAHAN TELEPHONE
STEWART C.IOPER 612/298-1950
MARY F.SEYMOUR CABI.E ADDRESS:COBRA
RONALD O.ALLEY'
BRIAN N.TODER"
'Also admillad in Texas
"Also admitled in Colorado May 11 , 1988 . �
City Attorney' s Office City Council of the
647 City Hall City of St. Paul
15 West Kellogg 7th Floor City Hall
St. Paul , MN 55102 15 West Kellogg
St. Paul, MN 55102
Attn: Ed Starr
Albert B. Olson,
City Clerk
386 City Hall
15 West Kellogg
St. Paul, MN 55102
Dear Couneilmembers and Me srs. Starr and Olson:
During the City C uneil meeting on Tuesday, May 10,
1988, Couneilmember Wilson indicated that the City Attorney' s
office had requested that tem 3 (88-501 )--an ordinanee
amending Chapters 411 .U1 a d �11 .04(b) (2) of the Legislative
Code pertaining to entert inment and consent petition
requirements--be laid ove for four (4) weeks. It is my
understanding that the ma ter will again appear on the
agenda on Tuesday, June 7, 1988.
As you know, I h ve prepared the Informational
Memorandum Coneerning the Constitutionality of the Regulation
of Expression by Entertai ment and Liquor Licenses whieh
has been submitted to the City Attorney� s Office and to the
City Couneil on behalf of some of those business owners who
would be adversely affeet d by the proposed amendments to
Section 411 . I am unavai able, due to a prior out-of-town
• �_ ` . - ' , • •
' Page Two
May 11 , 1988 '
commitment, on June 7, 1988. herefore, I hereby respeetfully
request that this item be remo ed from the agenda for
June 7, 1988 and placed on the agenda for June 9, 1988.
Thank you for your co sideration in this matter.
Yours truly,
OCHRANE & BRESNAHAN, P.A.
BY' � ��
ar F. Seymour
MFS/ple
- .. ;:,� � ,��
�
wH�.TE ..Ci rv C�EwK, � � � �.
o�~K _ F�N�~�E � G I TY OF A I NT PAUL CounciI
CANARr-OffPARTM[NT Q'F_SOi
OIUE _►�wrow, � File NO. �;n
•
' � ��nce o�inance N 0.
, ��� � g
PreseRted
Referre o '�m " " Committee: Date �"����
Out of Committee By Date
An Ordinance amendi g Sections 4I1.01 and
411 .04(b)2 of the S int Paul Legislative
Code pertaining to ntertainment.
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAIN PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Se tion 1 . �
That Section 411 .01 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is here-_
by amended to read as follows: .
Sec. 411.01 . License requ red.
No person licensed unde Chapter 409 or Chapter 410
shall provide or furnish entertainment on :or adjacent
to the licensed premises without first having obtained
a license so to do as here nafter pravided.
Se tion 2.
That Section 411 .04(b)2 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is
hereby amended to read as follo s: �. .
(2) Consent of Owners an Occupants with' Hundred
� Feet: The applicant sha 1 present with as application
a statement in writing ith the signatures of as many
of the owners and occupa ts of all property, including
private residences, dwe lings and apartment houses
located within two hundr d (200) feet of such premises
a e can obtain to the ef ect that they have no objection
�,�p p�'�D� to the granting of suc entertainment license or the
-�'" �� operation of the busine s of conducting entertainment
at the location proposed.
COUNCIL M�MBERS
Yeas ' Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
��g [n Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
scne;bei Against BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Appmved City Atto y
Adopted by Council: Date '
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
_�� . (RETUR'N''TO JEROIdi -S�G�IL-AFT�j� ADOPTION) --
MMtTE -� CITY CL�R,K ' � + ' � • � � ��� � _
P'�NK � FINAN�E �• � COUOCll /�Qw
GANARY —DEPIIRTMENT C I Ty p SA I NT PAU L �(/ �C� J�
oLVE �MAVOR File N0.— U !/ C/ ✓�
� .��
0 �n�nce Ordinance N�.
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
An Ordinance amen ing Sections 411 .01 and
411 .04(b)2 of the Saint Paul Legislative
Code pertaining t Entertainment.
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SA NT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
ection 1 .
That Section 411 .01 of th Saint Paul Legislative Code is here-
by amended to read as follows :
Sec . 411 . 01 . License re ired.
No person licensed und r Chapter 409 or Chapter 410
shall provide or furni h entertainment on or adjacent
to the licensed premise without first having obtained
a license so to do as her inafter provided.
S ction 2.
That Section 411 .04(b)2 o the Saint Paul Legislative Code is
hereby amended to reaci as foll ws :
(2) Consent of Owners a d Occupants within Two Hundred
Feet: The applicant sh 11 present with his application
a statement in writing ith the signatures of as many
of the owners and occup nts of all property, including
private residences, dw llings and apartment houses
located within two hundr d (200) feet of such premises
as he can obtain to the e fect that they have no objection
to the granting of suc entertainment license or the
operation of the busine s of conducting entertainment
at the location proposed.
COTJNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Reqvested by Department of:
Dimond
L0°g [n Favor
coswitz
Rettman
s�n�;bet Against By
Sonnen
V1�Ison
Adopted by Councit: Date Form Approved y City Attor y �
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY
By , •
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved Mayor for Submission to Council
^ ^-
_ _ _ _
, _ .
_ ..-, , �. � _
wH�TE -.C�TV CLEAK � � : • � •r ' -•
PIxIK _ F�N..N�•E '' � C I TY O SA I NT PA U L Council �1.
CI�NARr -OEPARTMENT File NO. �✓ �
OLVE -MAYOR
Or in�nce Ordinance N0.
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
If the applicant obtains he signatures of ninety (90) .
percent or more of such persons , the council may grant .
the license. If the pplicant obtains the signatures
of sixty (60) pErcent o ninety (90) percent of such
persons, the council ma grant the license upon finding
that issuance of the 1 cense would not interfere with
the reasonable use and njoyment of neighboring property
and residences and wou d not bear adversely on the
health, safety, morals nd general welfare of the com-
munity. Such finds s all be based on the following
considerations if the lic nse were to be granted:
a. The effect on the urrounding community and insti-
tutions ;
b. Noise and likelihood f adverse effect on residential
occupants ;
c . The possibility of inc eased traffic ;
d. The character of the n ighborhood;
e. Other like use� in the neighborhood.
If the applicant fails to obtain the signatures of
sixty (60) percent of uch persons , the license shall
not in .any case be grante .
S ction 3.
This ordinance shall take effect and be in foree thirty days
from and after its passage , ap roval and publication: �
2.
COUNCIL MEMBERS �
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
�� [n Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
Scheibei A gai n s t BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Appr d by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date
Ce�tified Passed by Council Secretary BY `'
$y �
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by ayor for Submission to Counci2
.,__ o..
. ,
„�
.1____. _ .
� __._ ._..__.
�z� , . , �
..� . .. . ,
�' , �, ,
Comittee Report
Community and Human Services Co ittee
April 21, 1988
Page Two _ _ __ _ � ___ ___
_" _.. -- � ,�„d -�'�-s o/
6. City Council Agen 12 , Item No. 5: ""
a � �'� .._ �`��ce
!��i,� �� .,�4�1.Q;1, and 11.04 �i , 2) of the Legislativ Code
P��� �e�t����. ��,��, ;;:�����t't�n :}��;
� . _ _;, .
r�4' .h `4-0 Yes.
7. City Council Agenda 4/12/88, Item No. 6: First Reading - An ordinance
amending Section 191 of the egislative Code by adding a provision
pertaining to displaying nan of responsible operator on coin operated
machines. 4-0 Yes.
8. Civic Organizations Partners ip Program (COPP) Matrix. (Policy of
prioritizing.) Discussion.
cc: A1 Olson
Ed Starr
��� � ��
+, � ' ' . ,� • °... . . Members:
� Janice Rettman.chair
CITY OF SAINT PAUL gi�� ���son
:iii:%'iii�
OFFICE OF HE CITY COIINCIL Bob Long
Da#e: April 21, 198
7ANICE RETTMAN
��n���R - Com ittee Report
To: Saint Paul City Council
From : Community and Hu an Services Committee
Janice Rettman, C air
The meeting of the Community and Hu an Services Committee was held on
Wpdnesday, April 20, 1988.
The following were in attendance: anzce Rettman, Chair
ob Long, Councilmember
oger Goswitz, Councilmember
ill Wilson, Councilmember
om Dimond, Councilmember
erry Sullivan, City Attorney's Office
oe Collins, Legislative Assistant
im Murphy, Program Analyst
arbara Benson, Secretary
1. Bowling Centers. Terry Sulliva drafted substitute ordinance. 5-0 Yes.
2. Continuation of presentation by Irene 0'Ryan, Division of Public Health:
Day Care Licnesing Procedures. (Policy: Proposed Day Care Rules and
Regulations and Guidelines for ay Care Centers.) 5-0 Yes. (Policy
pending resolution and public c mment. Resolution not available at this
time.)
3. City Council Agenda 4/7/88, Ite No. 26: Resolution amending the Z988
budget by adding $60,114 to the Financing and Spending Plans for Publie
Health-Salaries. (Policy with ture budget implications.) 5-0 Yes.
4. Gity Council Agenda 4/7/88, Ite No. 29: Resolution providing that the
City`s Neighborhood Clean-Up Pro ram be funded, that a 20� funding �ncrease
over last year be added to acco odate increased participation, and
requesting the Mayor to prepare budget resoZution transferring necessary
funds needed to pay clean-up cos s. (Policy and which budget.) 4-0 Yes,
as anended: Addition of paragra h regarding recycling; include "street
maintenance or appropriate budge ; on page 2, change "fund" to "pragram".
5. City Council Agenda 4/12/88, Ite No. 4: First Reading - An Ordinance
amending Chapter 409.21(b) (1) of the Legislative Code pertaining to -
pulltabs and tipboards in bars b deleting the references ta charitable
organizations that support youth athletic activities. 4-0 Yes.
C[TY HALL ROOM NO. 704 AINT P1U(., MINNESO'TA 55102 6i2l298-5289
s..�.+a
. . _ .
. � ; � __
. _ . .
• , , .
. :---r... ` _
- _ - q���.'�
, ��E�,
. . .. � . � . 4 � �•� . •..
� {Y �i
�i,�t°;1�
.'
p�� -
. .;�,� �� :
;� .
_. _ _ _ .. _ .,.
._:__ .�_,,_
_.,_._._ _._ ,_....a. ._:._. . .._.
, t
� � ...-_ .�.__ _..
� - , ;5,:�,•,-�-,,�'.- y
�{ � ' �, S_ J ,' - -�
d .
Ist '� /o�—�'l •� - -- nd � 4% -
-� .
.., : _ � _
3rd `� -� - dopted _ , ,._"
Yeas Nays
DIMO D ���/° z��o�-
GOSWI Z �7.�✓��
LON .
" RETT _
SONN N
� WIL
M�. PRESIDEN � SCHEIBEL �
i " { �"�'
\� f Y• X �
{ �
+1�� ���.:
; �� ��� ._...
���� # :���
'{;���i�,
. ,
, / � �
��. _ . - _ � - . _