The URL can be used to link to this page

88-436 WHITE - CiTV CLERK PINK � - FINANCE G I TY O F SA I NT PA U L Council CANARV - DEPARTMENT /��j/G� BI,UE - MAVOR File �O. u v � � C i solut ' � n �� Presented By �l ' Referred T Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, Midwest Fence Company on ehalf of Tom and Sandy Prudhomme applied for a variance from the strict pplication of the provisions of Section 61.101 of the Saint Paul Legisl tive Code pertaining to building setback in an R-3 zoning district so as to permit the construction of an attached garage for property located at 1343 N. Dale Street on property legally described as the south 12 feet f Lot 10 and Lot 11, Block 1, Warren and McDowell Subdivision; and WHEREAS, following a public hearin with notice to affected property owners, the Board of Zoning Appeals by 'ts Resolution No. 10221 adopted October 27 , 1987, varied the provisions of Section 61.101 of the Legislative Code to allow a setback of five feet fr m the south property line and a 26 foot 8 inch setback from the front prop rty line for the proposed construction of the attached garage; and WHEREAS, pursuant to the provision of Section 64.205, Josephine Palermo, 1341 North Dale, duly filed with the Ci y Clerk her appeal from the determination made by the Board of Zoni g Appeals requesting that a hearing be held before the City Council for the pu pose of considering the actions taken by the said Board; and WHEREAS, acting pursuant to Sectio s 64.205 through 64.208, and upon notice to Appellant and the affected pr perty owners, a public hearing was duly conducted by the City Council on D cember 3, 1987 where all interested parties were given an opportunity to be heard; and WHEREAS, the Council having heard he statements made and having considered the variance application, th report of staff, the minutes and findings of the Board of Zoning Appeals does hereby COUNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Dimond �� In Favor Goswitz Rettman B Scheibel A ga i n s t Y Sonnen � Wilson Form Approved by Ci Attor y Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By� . t#pprove� by iNavor: Date Appr b Mayor Eor Submis n t ounci� By WHITEr - CITV CLERK PINK - FINANCE COUI1C11 (//� CANARV - DEPARTMENT GITY OF AINT PAUL 1 /� BLUE - MAVOR - Flle NO• " � � - � Council esolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVE, that the Council of the Cit of Saint Paul does hereby reverse the decision of the Board of Zoning Appe ls in this matter regarding the side yard setback based upon a finding and de ermination made by the City Council that the Board did commit an error, that there are reasonable alternatives to � construct the attached garage without ha ing to require a setback from the side yard zoning requirements and that a garage 12 feet in width could be built without requiring any such varianc s; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Coun il does hereby uphold the decision of the Board in this matter in regards t front yard setback based upon the finding by the City Council that a varia ce of front yard setback is necessary for the construction of a garage because of the location of windows in the existing house; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the appeal of Josephine Palermo in regards to the side yard setback be and is hereby grant d; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that all work need d to bring the garage into compliance with the required seven foot ideyard setback shall be completed by June 30, 1988; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the appeal of Josephine Palermo in regards to front yard setback be and is hereby deni d; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Cler shall mail a copy of this resolution to Midwest Fence Company, Tom and Sandy Prudhomme, Josephine Palermo, the Zoning Administrator, the Planning Commission and the Board of Zoning Appeals. 2. COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond Planning and Economic Development Long In Favor � Goswitz �� '� Sche'►beY� � A gai n s t BY �'/� �C�T �� t.�c:�-�� Sonnen� Wilson MAR 2 g lggg Form Approve y 'ty Att ey Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passe o ci Secre y BY By �' Approved by 'Vlavor. Da�e� Approved Mayor for Submission to Council 1 By �_ � - �g=`°- __o� BY PU9lISNED �',�� - 2 198 _ . �,.,°� .. -""" s ..��"�c :�W�E�,('�� '!�^r..:1 v.t-� � - �:: ,1,� :; _ .,,/St� .-s s ':�, ._.s x., ' � sdL ��.; � i +�., ;::� �r �.;x '''°z�.�., " �� - �_�- s- +a�i ; � '4. „ a.,._. j a� �' �.-:r' �-n, �. --� ��, . L-�. ..F_ - :: .. 'b 1* �y,"�`y ,T} Ry �' fi 1 ^�`�.�y b '�'+. j ��(` ,�dl'. � � , � � �l ,jb ��!L��" �.., -- 4�l � 7�-, � .��s .r ►,w"� x,fR.�^m. �� a't K: ,�;, "'q� � �r r .. '.'F:, a.�-.+y �+t �s.r. ��: �c'� �pY� ' .t� :�\\ . �,g� � ,r'y��-r-�'�� . � �� ... '� . t a'.,�r�---�� ,_,,..a t �7". M„� ' 'r4 . �" .. 't°�ti'�. .s.d- 6.. - ��`` � :�' �`�"4 r..—„�,,hv � ,As��' __ ,`�:.� . _ „�ti 2 ' � ,.�� - _ � �R �i' .� � _ -' \ ' ' ' � ��' ',.;�y . , , ,, . � _ . , , . . , —,__ • . ---�-�,m._ �. _ . . . . ,, .: , ___ _ ,� � . ;..- , _ ---- __..__ , � _ . � ' - . . -�:- " _ _ _ ,. - _„ - ••, _,�,= ., . �'� , - �� ._ � Z �.��, � M �ARCH. 1988 ; " --_ . Yeas Nays -� ��/- . : � — � � ` _ �d � � . MAN , _- __ —�=s ' SON EI�I"�" - -- � . -= _ . - �IL ON 'DI � _ \ - ' GOS TZ • . � � , . : �. . . . � . . � - , � � `.,1: � � - � . . . . � � :.'.�.. .. MR. PRESID T� SCHEIBEb--�\ ` __ -----...�--:s,...a.�........�;_..._„_,.,,� . . �--.-.-.--A-,,,.T. µ.. ....., � ._,...>_ . ::.,, , . �_�: -` �.-- y s�r `' ��I�� q�>�� : � - *. . �,�� ` .{�y i ,.,„ .._: � : r �,• -: =. ; �; � . : f;� . 1 3 �. . � .-� .� , . ; ; ,,,...: . _ _ . , , • '��_. _ . . . ..... � . .. ; -.- - � � _ _ ,,,r t / ' \ ��t , _ - _.� r"�.�4`t .� .�"� �- _ , . e� _ . . _ . . :'c` _ ,��i� 1, � ' � � � '�� .�I° 013�14 � DEPARTMENT . - - - - - - CONTACT NA�dE � PHONF� � DATE ASSIGP N'tTMBER FOR xQIITING OitDER: (See reve e side.) ��'� c�� ' �,1�\� �9- _ Department Director Mayor (or Assistant) Finance and l�anagement Services Diractor � C� ty Glerk Budget Director � „�, City Attorney ++ � �'�► 1 -s^ TOTAL NUMBER OF SIGNATURE PAGES: (Clip all location� for signature.) i1 NG ? (Purpose/Rationale) " {IRi �di 4 rl�S��qTr�n �1► A Ci� �NCa� �a�'if�l '�0 /bYtY'�n►� '1 ZdN�+1� v�r��c�. �'�'a► �t s�b.c k� �w��.� 6r �J�. �.an�.l e� Zewny AP,�� n Gu��;t 1�1 � 1�r�� e►� tZl�/�� COS PERSO C S ��C��V�D MA� -� 1 198g � � a1AY �R�S QFFj�E IN C CTTV GED 0 (Mayor's aignature not required if under $10, 00.) _ _g Total Amount of TransBction: �� Activity Number: Funding Source: ATTACHMENTS: (List and number all attachment .) �iDMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES � _Yes _No Rules, Regulations, Procedu es, or Budget Amendment xequired7 _Yes _No If yes, are they or timetab e attachedY DEPARTMENT REVIEW CITY ATTORNEY REVIEW ' _Yes _No Council ra�oiution re4uired? Resolution requiredt _Yes _No _Yes _No Insurance rec�uixed? Insurance sufficient? �Yes _No Yes No Insurance attached? t �� , ,`��'t�,, . CITY OF SAINT PAUI _�:.�,�, o. � ' �'' � OFFICE OF 7'HE CtTY ATTORNEI �� O y, `� Ilill,illll �•: : ��1��1�� EDWARD P. STARR. CITY ATTORNE` ''"y.•...;,';�°'�� 647 City Hall, Saint Paul,Minnesota 551Q GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-51? MAYOR January 11 , 1988 Tom Beach Department of Planning and Economic Development llth Floor ; City Hall Annex j Dear Tom: � � I You have asked that I prepa e another draft of the resolution , for the Josephine Palermo a peal regarding the garage at 1343 ' North Dale so as to grant the variance for the front yard setback, while denying the variance for the side yard variance. The resolution which I had pre iously prepared at the request of , the City Clerk denied �311 va iances because that was the request of the Clerk (and I �3ssume the request of the City Council ) . Now you tell me that Jani e Rettman and you agree that the Council did not intend to eny the front yard variance, and if that is the case then it should be so reflected in the reso- lution. If you have any further q estions or changes , let me know. I am sending a copy of thi letter to the City Clerk and to Council Member Rettman so tha they will know where the resolution is in the process. Your very truly, , , i �f JERO � . SEGAL Ass ra t Ci�ty Attorney � JJ : g � ' Encl . cc: City Clerk�s. Council Member Rettman � -� ! � � .,1� � , ��,-�-� ,,,- ------ ----- ------- - ------------ -- w►�i'- . .� C�rv CLEwK .� . -- ---------- PI!!K � FINANCE CO{lllCll / /C/ ��/. CANARY - p�p�RTMENT G I TY . O F SA I NT PAIT L � - �y„�� ' B��E _M��oR File NO. , - _ ounci Resolution . Presented By ��'�� . Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By ' Date . WHEREAS, Midwest Fence C mpany on behalf of Tom and Sandy Prudhomme applied for a var' ance from the strict applicatian of the provisions of Section 1.101 of the Saint Paul .Legislative Code pertaining to building etback in an R-3 zoning district so as to permit the constr ction of an attached garage for property located at 1343 N. Dale Street on property legally " described as the south 12 f et of Lot 10 and Lot 11 , Block 1 , Warren and McDowell Subdivi ion; and VJHEREAS, following a pub ic hearing with notice to af'fected property owners, the Board o Zoning Appeals by ,its Resc�lution No. 10221 adopted dctpber 2 , 1987, varied the provi�ic�ns of Section 61.101 of the Legis ative Code to allow a setback of five feet from �he south pr perty line and a 26 foot ,9 inch setback from the front �ro�ert line for the proposed constr�uction of the attached garage; and WHEREAS, pursuant to t e provisions of Section E�4.205, Josephine Palermo, 1341 Nort Dale, duly filed with the� City Clerk her appeal from the etermination made by the Bo��rd of Zoning Appeals requesting t at a hearing be held befoi^e �he City Council for the purpos of considering the actions taken by the said Board; and - WHEREAS , acting pursuant to Sections 64.205 through 64.208 , and upon notice to Appellant and the affected property owners, � a public hearing was duly onducted by� the City Counc:il on December 3, 1987 where all interested parties . were given an � opportunity to be heard; and WHEREAS, the Council aving heard the statements made and having considered the variance application, the report of staff, the minutes and fin ings of the Board of Zoning F�ppeals does hereby • , COUNCILMEN Requested by Department oE: Yeas Nays [n Favor Against BY Form Approve�r City Attorney Adap;e� by Council: Date ( � � / Certified Uassed by Council Secretary BY ey � Approved by i4lavor: Date � Approv d by Glayor for Submission to Council • ._ . ' � � �� w�+ITE - C�Tr CIERK • .. ' ' . -'--� f ' PINK � FINANCE G I TY O SA I NT PA U L Council �%��(�� . CANARY -DEPI.RTMENT °"'E _"""`'°" File N O. Counci Resolution Presented By ' Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date - RESOLVE, that the Counc ' 1 of the City of Saint Paul does hereby reverse the decisio of the Board of Zoning Rppeals in this matter regarding t e side yard setback based upon a finding and determination m de by the City Council that the Board did commit an error, t at there are reasonable alternatives to construct the attached garage without having to require a setback from the side ya d zoning requirements and that a garage 12 feet in width co ld be built without requiring any such variances; and, be it � FURTHE� RESOLVED, that he City Council does hereby uphold , the decision of the Board i this matter in regards to front yard setbar.k based upon the finding by the City Council that a variance of front yard setb k is necessary for the construction of a garag? because of the ocation of windows in the existing house; and, be it FURTHE:R RESOLVED, that the appeal of Josephine Palermo in regards to the side yard setback be and is hereby granted; and, be it FURTHE:� RESOLVED, that the appeal of Josephine Palermo in regards to front yard set ack be and is hereby denied; and, be it FURTHE;� RESOLVED, that he City Clerk shall mail a copy of this r��solution to Midw st Fence Company, Tom and Sandy Prudhomme, Josephine Palermo, the Zoning Administrator, the � Planning Commission and the Bo rd of Zoning Appeals. 2. COUNCIL MEMBERS �� N� Requested by Department of: Dimond �� In Favor Gosw;tz Rettman Scheibel A gai ns t BY Sonnen VVilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Appr��ved by Mavor: Date ' Approved by Mayor for SuDmissior, to Council '1 ;. 7' /. � ;.. ': �wS"A � �I ,�'ri` . Y .� - �.�t �• � "� ' l �.' �y �: � .;. :,� � �� `� �� • a� � \�, t � _�.� r!. �/ �� >.:+�i�,� ''z� � ' 'Y" . . .� ✓ .-y. � u ��y,�� f ,� � . ,. t � � d, �r � � � _ ` � � � F � ( ' / � '\�- "� �` � r ''f .!� , � ./ � �y� �4 - . �'' �Y` �1 .. ,� / _ t �,° � . r � � 1 .A _ � ��" "/' ' f�� ,'I^ i• i � /�� , - � { ,� ; � }y' f t � ;� F ,"�� '� , ;-�� , .a �;,j .t ��. `�i �,I � �Y v '; � �� 5 �j� � �—��{ �':=r, � � � ¢ P' ��e � t �3✓� `� '�� 4:" � a-<;�. -t � `� - � -;� „ � _ 1 K-� � ` l � �' �� ' ��# \„e rf J � �t".�y Y,� �� •:� .!. ' E q �" :� ,}. � - [ \'� , r.z �� / � _ � - t f� F I 1 - , /' � i" - '�i � ' �_� 4 � f� 4 _ ;A f¢' tl�..� �•t` _.t _�' .'r� � � ��: *.r r. �� c � I> s i� !; � .1 r r �t..�� ,^ , t ,-�\ � �; �TM { � Y� , � ; ..'. � � .. - . ^ , . - � " , +' � , ,. ...,, . ,,. ,.. -, . ,� „ .. �,... :. .a'. k�! t�` - ' -{ � � -� '''. < � ,' .r _ �„ � .-t . fi i� � F ,'<' �i _ f.. � � � ��i'.'�{1'�� , '` ,t !� ' � '^��;iA ��y�+� � � �l j �' 4 .�� _ � �:�� R �� 1 � , ��'+�s ��''�� F* �''° -� # � ,. , , . , . ' , : . �- :� � i . ; . , �_ < . _ , . , . ,,, .`.: . .. , .. . , _. :' . .. � f _ ,. ,, , ,.; _, . . „ � � � z � �•,: � f '..r r - ' � '� � ti � � ^ �. , _ ' � - x� % � �f�� < ' " , u. w - � ~ �. , r ti .; � �, , , . . . . - _. 4 _ - �-T �. .�� , . �� a�, y� � �ti � �� "�"�� 1��{'ir ��`� Y�fMi1�y^� y1e� �`��,,�� ''�'� � � �` -, �� ` �� t ; � ' � � �!��ti1�e- f�t'�4 fi�'i: a �ci� � o .�.LfiNe �a4� �i`..'�� 6t q ��.� :,� '�a� a :�ari�� f``::��i� �ng!� ��4f+br��r:`��- '. , : ,, � , . {/��y}��. .`{].(��j}� •s' � �.�. . '.: , i s;t , �'_T_" �, � � . ":� �� r�'"��- �I }��Y� ,...! ..�,` '. ,! Y � �tC�' �"'i '�it"� 1'L 8.�,� �$ $�`r. i, , f _ , - - - - ` - . � ,,, E"-f" �'^' � �:, . :; j - . .��:�.` , �� ' � ., . � ,� `�S i . . � _ .. �. . � `�. Y, , , , Tt�" 8�t#:��`,Wd S ��,t�r�.��h�; �`# c�i ng '��t �.h� ��'�3 t�'��Lt��i� � ` '��1� ��rred �and� ther�� Gr� a�t r�n$ti�r+�t��'°'npp �t'��'p��d .� � r } ; � ' t (' �8i '� GC�k��d �p�';��'�,t��Yf�. r ,y � ' _, s, �� ,�, �'t.�i'�' y�v'pT��rS@.��3!''�pa're .tfie-�pEr�o ��,',�1i�f� :��fi��fl'i`� ��t� . ; A �.5 F - � �7��. (,� � F� 5 � �' ,. y �� , J �� r _ 1 : ,- . . , . : � f .. � ;� *r � ' { ;,y'� t t 'j't '^i:S �� ' T �- , L �.y�; - �� y�� }�,� ��.y�� °' �`�� i � � � �l. � ��1i irFir i��. ��3i7� t �i �. �] � �� ' � �' V��:� 4�� f � ' � � � � ,.. � _ �t �z '�_��. � f. � s3 y #' ��R �� a � � 1 � 'K ' C '� T�, "� ? -..,' �, � �. {� � . .. �:: . : ��. .. . ' �. / r � . J�.� jy, - T \ A � C � � + � l;� /"i � nr � ` '� ':. ,�� '`�..1 t �y�_. F"� � ;�� t [�� ti x ;_- � ..� )'. . . � I V^� .t^4�,jN ' ,. � �� / ;� � � �1 � 4 � t �. / J' S � � � 0 ; h — t yf.� � t � ��1 J� � '' k 1 � �t *3 ' / i V, �' f �. . }` . 1 y { �Y �' � � ' `'\ • i Y -.�>v ' '�1'� } ,=r T �h � � � '' ` �. `1kk,�' _ . ,. i .. 'j'� �e1` � kt�� '�%, � i .�t� �'� �� '� � y {J �� .t� �� e,' 1 "�d.� � .t' � r.� �' �'�- �� . C � � �` a, k � �Y i t� 1 �.�✓ i ,. �.. v .R / � �� t' L � f J f 1 �{� ,( �i ��.J F`"� ,�. �� F,. } e i f'\i \ / � fi � � �'` .`.' ' i `* . � �� _?'� � a',ti ��r� + `Y r�� ,��, � ^'�� . � /��f t i �,�� kn � ;Y � r fi � �„y_�u.; � ' F ] �� I � f * � � �t • �4� ..i _ :,' .�..� f, -�. t r�,.�� 'x ;i r ��,g ` .. . r �v � � �f n'', ��1 `' � ��"h �.N �'�, y7. `� < 1 �. A ` i,; � :w� -l.: ., �, 'k.: - , . �s, o� i : 1 a � x, a� ^ 7' ., � y x � � 'f �` � � t � 1 a ' �,�Sx"'{�. �'S s r �� ;�i- � y:.l y y t � ;�' � �.: , - � i � �'��; �.. , � �.. � � r�g',c . ,r * ;: .. a t �' } r � .`,' u 1� h� ,.� f `' x `��' �-� _� .. r x , - :. .�, , �.. . �. .. .�F .ri, � , _ . . . . . ..,.—.. ... .. :'�. ... . ... . .. .. ... .. .. .... .:�. _. . ...,. . _`_ ..i .,� . I.. ..., � .. .,_. , . ..,.. ._ _. � � �,�. � � :m �, �. ��+� �^ '�": y S c "p' - -�� -�:x-��a� �s.�':z rs„ _ ` �, ,�,,,c°."'��+5 A ,, � � �',.y�7' �F y � -. . : rt • .. K"-n.� �,-��..r .. �..- ., 'q�'e+ � t i 2 > �8w�'�' �, ; _ f_' ��es�.� '" �, ,�'r'( � . � �^��,�- '`y,,,� . � "' � '��, �'r >IF ° � . •��.e��*��„ �.�� 1 "M+lo ! f y�-.�t;t ,� `x-c�Z �" ��.��'. .. :. �+.,.�,1(�r� 3_�'4 �+1 .:� tr �e� � ,�� \ • . � �c �,+��di� ,,..Y...;. Y. ��' n p r ��, '+i4 � A, . � � f \3 , -�� ..:is,.�&+ ,.; +� .b h J � . ��,r°-�` �• ��°� �� '� <,_: i' � . � ia:,. \`- � ' ��F.��'-"�'N�` '�,a�� '`� Lfi.4 �� ': � �� ;��r , . �... . , . �. . �• . ti Y.._ .:-' '. � ' -� .� . . ' '. . . . a.� � � ..� ., .. , .. �c .-�.,, �,- - ' i * � '_ ' F. . . . . . � �__� - � , . . �:_ .- . � . y ..._""-�, �. -- _ -_ y . , �: _ . ., _. - -- . . . .. _. . . . �.... . '„' .., _� . F.�. . � . , .� . - �� .-, � : . ��......�. .. . "._ - 'L . . . �-- .. . . ... . , ..,_� .. �.: . .. . . -. '..,__ -� �_ . ... , �.!. . �- . _ t , . � � . . . - � _:,.. � ... .. . ..� ..._._ - � . . . . .. � ., .. .__._.. . . . .. � . _ � � . }'- r - . . . , . , � . . .:�\. �. , , - , . . . .. ' ..y» ". � ..... — - .. , �. - .. . _ � � - � .__ ::�c s ,;v-. . �. _._. ... . _ . ,�.. �. .�..-. ._ . . . .. �.. . , . ..1.1•,,�. .��„.�. . D�CEMBER� 1987 Yeas . . _ _ _ Nays ' ' �IDA . _/ � / _ -- \�L � Co C�� — _ ,�s;i '� �ICOS � _ SCHEI Ir—".-,� , . -_ � PR�SIDENT� SONNEh-�,,,; � • .� ___ -�. �. ..�,.- ��.,..�.. ...�.�__.. l . � . �.-'a•� . �; � � � � .' .��... ;, I,I I . 7��` . � � - �,�. �%" � ` � r 3 . . . . :��,��^� . . � ...�.' .. �� ; ,¢, - , _ . - r - r�- - . .. , . � _ . . _ . . . , � . � .�.. . . ... , ��:�. ,. .. . . -- � .., � . -- _ _ .. � . ,, . . . --�_.n ,� _ . :. " ;: � _ � /'` � `� � ,, � . ; . � ,� ., ___.__ ,.. ' :-� h ;:.,; :_: . , _ �..... ,�, �� _ _ _ _ _ ,....._ . - , �-� .. u _ , _ _ . . ...._�.� ._._:�:..�.0 .0,...�. . � � (d,,��`—�� 4�6 ctT! o' �4 , ' , • CITY OF SAINT PAUL a �_��;��°,U y DEPART ENT OF PLANNING A ��ONOMIC DEVELOPMENT `v '�� ' �-' � DIVISION OF PLANNING • �° ...• • 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 612-22&3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR November 25, 1987 Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall ` .- Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 - ° RE: Zoning File # 1032 - Josephine alermo i Property located at 1343 North ale Street 4 Cit Council Hearin : Thursda December 3 1987 PURPOSE: To consider an appeal of a decision by the Board of Zoning Appeals ` to grant a setback variance for cons ruction of an attached garage for an a existing single-family home. ` BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS DECISION: A prove (5-0) , October 27, 1987 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve SUPPORT: None OPPOSITION: One person testified Dear Sir: On October 27, 1987 the Board of Zoni g Appeals held a public hearing on a request by Midwest Fence Company on b half of the property owners, Tom and Sandy Prudhome, for a variance to per it construction of an attached, one-car garage on the south side of the Prudh me's home. The BZA granted variances for a front yard setback of 26' 8" (27' normally required) and a side yard setback of ' (7' normally required) . On November 6, 1987, an appeal of the BZA's decision was filed by Josephine Palermo who owns the house directly s uth of the Prudhome's property. She contends that the BZA erred and its d cision violated the intent and pupose of the Zoning Code to insure adequate li ht and air, conserve property values, prevent harmful encroachment by incom atible uses and prevent overcrowding of land with buidlings. The appeal is scheduled to be heard b the City Council on December 3, 1987. Please contact me by December 2 if any member of the Council would like slides presented at the public hearing. Sincerely, �� Tom Beach Z�ning Section . ��'�� , . ; .. ; , ;i ''� �, APPLICATION FOR APPEAL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY : ��' CITY OF SAINT PAUL : i F i 1 e # � 0�. � 1-- � RECEIVED °� ' ' Application Fee S �U l �' I'i NOV s �981 Tentative Hearing Date � /.� �7 � � �; ZONING � �. ';; Application is hereby made for an Appeal o the �-eu c i �; under the provisions of Chapter 64, Secti n .�-E� , Par graph o the oning ode '.: ;; to appeal a decisian made by the � Boar o oning Appeals :� '� . � Plan ing Commission on � �? , 19 6.7 .` :�� _ Zoning Administrator (date o decision) ;, _ Pla ning Administrator .; .. — Oth r R " ` ' A. APPELLANT . ' Name ��S� �. �� c �Cs, v-`o Daytime phone 7�� (�° � .� Address � �. � Zip Code � � � � � B. DECISION 6EING APPEALEQ , ' Zoning fi le name � d ► Co toning Fi le � /O 7� ( Property Address/Location � J �o �� : Legal description � 2� - �. •- ( - � `��«� � - ..��. � ; : a � . � C. GROUNOS FOR APPEAL (Use additional s eets if necessary. ) (Explain why you feel there has been an error in any requirement, permit. decision or refusal made by an administrative official, or an error in fact, procedure or finding made by the Board of Zoning Appeals r the Planning Commission.) ; s' � , , ' __ �� . � I f- X c-c(�, f'�- � o ,( ' � o� �.�.G�.c� �� - �i-.�: �.c..c•� �� . , . � . � If you have any questions, please cont ct: c:-u, � � ��'Z-�--- plic t's signature St. Paul Zoning Office � ''; 1100 City Hall Annex � � Q � 25 West Fourth Street �� " ��`�-- �,�'� Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 Oate City agent � (298-4154) g/82 ; : ., � x� a+ � •..+ ' r �� ,z�� F � r; � . .. � ' � . . . . i. � . ..� �r� .�5; ; . . 1. �` � ,t 4 .i. . ,• . ��-� hj j��'_I�I L . 1 .1� �'��'�.1� . t , 1• �� : . . . . �. . '1 � ,r r 'IR ��. . ' . . , r . ..: ' h�e � � � � �-.��`��. ' '� �'�-�,' � . � . . �� 'i , � � t ��:,��aµr5�'. �� -�. 1 , ^ � u}I I , ' �;� '�`�..� � , 1 �. � � � �h��' . ,�� '" � � F�i�� ,. T �� ' �� , �� ' • ' .� 'I '� ,. Lt 1' f i' . . _i �.F.�� .�. . . . , 1 ip 1� i �� . � , ; �ri � TI� , .�' . . . . � . 1 ,1 �r' l�.e.i�{ �1. . . � `r. ' '��_,; k .. � . , . . . . . , 1.. �, �.. • � r :�+ ,k � :'., `1, ,u �;.;. � •j: , , :� '� �4;�� I . , � � �, t 4 Ir � ' 'i� � � � �r 1 1 Y�� }. . ! y�d;i�" t .i ��'• .' - � � . 'r . . . � � .. .. 1 t.f� ,��'��, �' ' � �•.1 ,�`��. �i,�; �4� .��F '�::� . �:; ). .' . � � . . ' . . n� �. f<�.xa�1d�''� • .'.i f r �t l�i . � ' . � • . . � . . � �� 1 'f•N, .�JI 1 ,f � : F 1 ` � t. 4 r �i� . ' . . � - : ' , �'M 1.' +. � f I�A t. • . . �•11'•. r � t ti ' i� ' �� r � ' �a r , k � qylh �' ' , ' i � '. � � . i. _ .�'1� :A71 �` �' , , . ' , ' i ' . � . . ��.� ��y-1j �Fi� . � . ,t. }. Y ' p ' . Y ��/ 1 4 . . �. . ' . . .: I 1;..'� ;I y�i .' � . } 'M : 1 �'��, .', �iA� �. T5 ,�� i �!,; s`:.i. ,_:, : • r �_ ,. � � F i:,i � - . `�'.'� i .4�, �.. . � . � . � . . . � . '.M ,� , � ' . � . , � .� �� d�, �1. , � � 4 ,�4 � 4f '! . ' r } . '� � , . i: �' � , . . , � ,'. 't, � . , ; iw��, . , . � •c' �' , '. : � 'i:a.�;�. ;. , � � , y.:� ' # F�,` ` , e �. ,i��':! '' ' ' �, , i7✓ �� • � �� .; , . , , . ,,. ', ; ' �, � :; 60.101 • i ZONING CODE ` Chapter ' Pa�e 60. Zoning Code—Ad ption; Purpoae;Definitions; Dixtrid i� Uses and Requi ements. .................... . .................218 - � � 61. Zoning Code—Sc edule of Regulations Limiting Height, ` ' Bulk,Density,a d Area Ay Zoning Districta.. ...2B9 62. 7.oning Code—Ge eral Provieione.................................. .297 , j 63. Zoning Code—Ge eral Ezceptions................... .............�318-4 ' 64. Zoning Ccide—Ad iinixtration and Enfurcement Amendment; �:` _•: Miei:ellaneoua oviaions ...........................................320 : �. 65. Zoning Code—Ri er Corridor....................................... 328-2 � `..: 66. Zoning Code—Sig a ............................................... 342-6 67. Zoning Code—Su ivieion liegulatione............... .. ....... 372-1 Zoning Code—Ap endices A, B,&C ................. following page 3T2-28 '< ; Maps........... ...................................following sppendiues ' CHAPTER 60.ZONING CODE—ADOPTION;PURP03E; ' � ' DEFINITION ;DI9TRIGT USES AND REQUIREMENTB 80.100.Short titl Chapters 60 through 67 shall be known and may . � be cited as the aint Paul Zoning Code. (Code 1956, as amended, 960.100; jurlhe amended: Ornl. 16919, May 27. 1982.J i,, � .' 80.101. Intent an purpose. This code is adopted by the city of � . `� Saint Paul for e following purposes: : ,:� (1) To promote and to protect the public health. safety� morals ' and general welfare of the community. (2) To promote the conservation of energy and the utilization of renewable e ergy resources; (3) To classify all property in such manner aa to retlect ita ' peculiar sui bility for particular usea; ,� . , (4) To regulate he location,construction�reconstruction�altera- tion, and of buildings, atructures� and land; �' '' (6) To insure e eaua,e,' t�t. air, privacy, and convenience of ac- cesa to pro rtY; ; `�; (6) To conserve�roperty values; ; � (? To protect a 1 areas of the city from harmful encroachment by . incompatibl uses; . ,� r-- (8) To prevent overcrowding of land with buildinga; (8) 'I'o avoid u due congestion of population; � ' ��i , �1/� 218 �, .� r: ;` -._...a rl •� .. � rq k . .. . . . . . �,....�wWi�IW . �� +1. � . � •..E � !'l.Pl� T . '., . � � �� . : � a� .- � J��:.�� . . . � '`� 4 i � _. . y f� � ,. i�,� , ` �_ : � ♦ f. f, �. .�. . . , � � � '.� +� f;' � - �� r r, 5 , ��y, 1 ,�)� ! . �' � '1 IR � ��f��#jY� � �'� i �� i '� } I e 7�! a• . i••`li.t � t I: f � �.� �'�� S!I� �� '�7�1 , 7. . , �. 5 �, a . ►. 3 ' . ,' . q 1�.p . . � � �, � � A . �. . 5 ''T 'i ;`�ti.i � '��e.a �� i# � ? ��.:.; 1 � . � . ' . . • �i . � } �� i � S� �� .. . . + , �� '. �.� t �)�C:! . } � � im��, '�i � i1 � _ �' . , . - �� . i i ~�� Y"�� + If' f '.Y i� . , . . . r . . . �f � .�.}'MI.a.� {� t` . #E�T:�• . r � , 2� i.�,�` �� •'.-� . ' . . , . . �� , - �, . ,r'. .lf t �,*� .a . � - . � , • 1, . . . ��,"T. . '� _ . .. ' ! 1� .1" ��' 1 �y � . . i � � � ��.� . ej��.�' i � S . � � ` ; . . .,� ',�t '.�,i'�.�!" 'y� .{� e 1 i 1� �'' � - � ( -t , � �`i1..ir. s � � � . � � . . � ; , . S S.�.� a` .. .. f � { �� t t ` �� ' t�, f �+.� � ; -.F = �; . . . . . . � ,� r:r.i . � � r - ' � ..�- i %' r' � . • � ' ' . � �. } ' � i, � �� .."`R y �.. ) '� !s � e i � ' . . . . �'�� . � � k �. .�f?' . � . �j '•�� !t; 6 '�p s ' �..`r � . r , , �. . ; .� � �'_7 l � t.I . , r '� . t Rr�1f �'v:. ' (., . •� . I c . ,r J � . ► � . ' y,►ti�„ ' � , l � . � i� . 'y1. • 'r' < � i „�a:�;� . p.; .. . . , ' . . � '�',�' f. j � .yn.I • , . . . �� , < : ; +':; 1� � , � , . '' . • . �y�,' �` ,a,,., ' ,, , �{' � . t 'k. . '}�• r�., y� � . � � � +;��' �.� . .: � , �ry ' t \ , �� ' 4 �'� K I� � � : . , �� . i� �• . . • , . .. � . , . �•v. . •r 'b� . �a� . -n., �a� :•'% � . . . ��,�� ' �� '' � CITY� OF SAINT PAUL , . � . BOARD OF ZONING A PEALS RESOLUTION ' �� , �' ZONING FILE NUMBE : io22i � '; ; DATE: occobcr 2�, �98� WHEREAS, Midwest Fcnce Co paay (for Tom and Sandy Prudhomme) have applied for a � .. variancc from tht strict application of the provisions of Section 61.101 of the Saint Paul , �; Legislative Code pertaiaing to uildiag setback in the R-3 zoning district; aad % ,- ` • WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Boar of Zoning Appeals conducted a public heariag op . � ' � October 27, 1987, pursuant to id appcal in accordance with the requirCments of Sectioa , , . 62.204 of tbc Legislative Code; nd `: .. WHEREAS, the Saiat Paul Boar of Zoning Appcals based upon evidence proscnted at the � �; public hearing. as substantially eflcctcd ia the minutes, made the following findings of �` ` `' ' fact: �'� ' l. The applicants are doing a n mbcr of improvcments to their home iacludiag a thrce- : : season porch on the back of he house and the garage under consideration. The • � dimensions oP the proposed g rage are 20' deep and 15' wide. lt would sit 4' from the � � side property liae aad 9' fro the neighboriAg housc. :: ,,: �� 2. The area where the garage w uld bo built is currently paved as part of the driveway , � snd used as a parkipg space. : •. 3. lt is not practical to build a aragc behind thc housc bccause of the change in grade in the back yard. Moving the p oposed attachod garage back further from tho strcet would ' � block existing windows oa th housc. ..� .� ': 4. The adj�ccnt aeighboring pr perty to the south has a picture window which f�ccs thc ��! locatioa of the proposed gara e. � . �, � _� S. Under the Zoning Code thc a pticant could build a garage 12' wide and still maintaia �.�; ' the required 7' sideyard sctb ck. Stnff tniked with a representative from Sussei Garage '�� , Company about what was a r asonable minimum width for a single-car garage. He said that 12' is gcaerally consider d the minimum width. However in this case a 14' width • would be a rcasoaable rainim m width because there would be a set of steps on onc side ' : � of thc garage Icadiag froau a existiag back door of the house. ' � 6. The variance, if granted� wo !d not permit any use that is not permitted in the zoning • '� ; ; . district where the property is locattd. { ' , � ; .�� 7. Thc rcqucst for varianco is b scd primarily on a dcsire to fully utilize the site rathcr • , than �conomic gain. '� ' NOW, THEREFORE, BE 1T RE OLVED, by the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appcals that � , the provisions of Scction 61.101 c hereby waived to allow a setback of S' from the south ', property liae and 26' 8" from th front property line for a proposcd building expansion on ; property located at 1343 North alc Street and Icg311y dcscribed as south 12' of Lot 10 and ' Lot 11, Biock 1� Warren and Mc owcll Subdivision; in accordance with the epplication for :�'' variance and thc site plan on fil with the Saint Paui Planning Division. � ; . ', , 1 °; ,., • MOVED BY: Horak � SECONDED BY: Osborn `' �� IN FAVOR: s ;�, : � �� AGAINST: o , ; .: � •� � �� MAILBD: October 28. 1987 � ' �� SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR: TIM L.iM1T/APPEAL/CERTIFlCATION '. � • , , �� MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS IN CITY COUNCIL ClUMBERS� S . PAUL� MINNESOTA� OCTOBER 27� 1987 ��; Mme. Maddox; Nessrs. G aia� Osborn� Horak� and iioods of the Board � � of Zoning Appeals; Mr. Segal. Asaistant City Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Division of Buildi g Inspection and Design; Mr. Beach. Ms. Synstegaard and Mr. By n of the Planning Division Staff. � :� � ' �,��: Messr�. Zinniewicz and Kirk. �. '� The meeting was chaired by Sam G a1a, Chairman. �i . Z1i,pj�EST FENCE COMPANY (#10221): Setbeck variances for an attached garege. i: .� The applicant was present. Ther was opposition pre�ent at the hearing. . Mr. Beach showed slides of the e te and reviewed the ctaff report with a : � �� rscom�aendatlon for approval. • , � ' Mr. Grai� a�ked if the two parti a were in agreement. Mr. Beach replied no. �� -- � .; Sandy Prudhomme, 1343 North Dale stated that she knew Josephine Palermo was ; ��, against the variance. : .i ' �� Josephine Palermo� 1341 North Da e. stated that she is opposed to the garage . because it would block the view rom her living room window. Her home i� for ` �ale and with the garage spoilin the view from the living room window� it },; �i would be a detriment in selling he home. . ;: , � Hearing no further testimony� Mr Grais closed the public portion of the • neeting. G, ' :; . • Nr. Horak noved to approve the v riance and resolution based on findings 1 � ,' through 7 and staff recommendati n for a S' aide yard setback and 14' wide ��. •� garage. Mr. Osborn aeconded tha ootion� which passed on roll call vote of 5 � to 0. " � Submittod by: Approved by: . .� � ,�� . Toa Beach Sam Gra � , , ;� . i i .. ` :i � ' � . '.):�. , y`. � ' , • f. ,� .. �, ,: . � , �, � . � ; ,.� . , f� ; � ,, ,, � ' . � � , � . G,9 '•'.�. � i r � � � x, . , ' : ; .+.�;': , � , �..p , '1 .� a� ; !''� � . .11� . � , � F.��I i_��.• �� ; � . . . •� ,1 .'•.' +.t, ,i� J.I� 1r,, . �i ��i��.a�j�� . � 1��i.�i �I � i. - . � � . .� . _ . � .. ��. �- I �. J.- � . � , I. �� ,1 , . � iF. H�i .'e' : � � ' ' ' - .1. '�.7 ��y i:.f . ' . ' . �,� �� . �� . . � . . . �� . �'�, �i�,ia �i� � �!�� ' � . �. �. . , . ',, , ��h �1+, '� . . � � � '.��t' , � : ��M. ��r k � ' �,.� � ..' .1' `,.�.,y 'r1'�,��+• . _.� - ' ,��r� r }, . ; w , ��'� :.t i: ' ;�� ''",; . . . ,;, , �; ,y r , a�;�, i � � �' � ,�.� � . �. . �� .� . , .� .., �i. � �� i�� .� . f ' . , . _ � ! , . .i� � ► 1 r '� F'��•� . � . �tl.. ' t , ' ' l� .f{ ;� �''�.�.' , ' !� � '� ' � �. 1}w4�^ . . , � �.�j . � r . .. ,. 'J'." j .l. � r . �� . . . . � . � �.. ,'�y►�1r ,:.a; ��-�� . ' . 1 yJ '.�. ' '_I li�� . f i . . . . .1 1 'I `C,�.� N �.. . c \ , � l� � � l� . ,� . i I•, � • �� ' � � � • . 1. 1. . f �� ` � . ' . t �. .. r i . - � , ly i•� � • . - . , . . . . .. . �,i � � .'� 1 � •I:�i' ' � _ , �•• '� � � �. � . � �• i ! i _1 ' .,' '. , . . ,; . .�r4; �-,',:' � ' j,.. '�� :.�fr . . � }. i;. i �_. .� � . ; ,. ::a I,,. .. . . .c . � . � '� �. , . . •� ' � � � � i '� . � : .` . � ,. . ..;. ..:r• � .5• i� . � �� . . �� . � � . . , � ' . . ,� ' � j � . ' • , ��-�' .� . � �'. '. � ' ' �,. �ti ' , � � _ �, , K '�, .' ; , , � � , ��",��'`�/� ' BOARD OF Z NING APPEALS STAFF REPORT � �� . FILE #10221 DATE OF HEARING: 10/27/87 ,., :. 1. APPLICANT: Midwest Fence Comp ny (for Tom and Sandy Prudhomme) - `. ; ' 2. CIASSIFICATION: Minor Varianc „ 3, LOCATION: 1343 North Dale Str et (west side between Wheelock and Cottage) 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: South 12' f Lot 10 and Lot 11� Block 1, Warren and McDowell Subdivision ' � 5. PLANNING DISTRICT: 10 �5� 6.' PRESENT ZONING: R-3 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: 61.101 ' � '�� 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT DATE: October 19� 1987 BY: Tom Beach A. PURPQ,�,: To build a new attac ed garage along side an exiting single-family house. B. ACTION REOUESTED: Variances f r: � � � 1.Side yard setback: 4' reque ted, 7' required. ; 2. Front yard setback: 26'8" requested, 27' required. �:' ; _' ,. :�. C. SITE AND AREA CONDITIONS; Lot area is 6�384 square feet. (48' x 133') The ` '�'" existing setbacks are 5' on th north and 19' on the south where the garage is , :� proposed. The lot drops off a ong the side of the house so that the backyard is approximately 5' lower than th front yard. An existing driveway runs �long the . south side of the house. `' , The eurrounding land use is s ngle-family houses, The houses on either side have garages along side the ho se with a driveway out to the street. . D. FINDINGS: -�� 1. The applicants are doing a number of improvements to their home including a three-season porch on the ack of the house and the garage under consideration. The dimens ons of the proposed garage are 20' deep and 15' wide. It would sit 4' fro the side property line and 9' from the : � � neighboring house. � � 't'' 2. The area where the garage ould be built is currently paved as part of the � driveway and used as a par ing space. � 3. It is not practical to bui d a garage behind the house because of the change in grade in the back yard. Moving the proposed attached garage back further � :S from the street would bloc existing windows on the house. r, :,.i �' �� 4. The ad�acent neighboring p operty to the south has a picture window which � �' faces the location of the roposed garage, � � '':`� 5. Under the Zoning Code the pplicant could build a garage 12' wide and still maintain the required 7' s deyard setback. Staff talked with a � ' � representative from Sussel Garage Company about what was a reasonable minimuw width for a single-car garage. He said that 12' is generally `, ;. considered zhe mini[�um wi h. However in this case a 14` width would be a :. �`� reasonable minimum width cause there would be a set of steps on one side ; ; of the garage leading fro an existing back door of the house. ; � '_� 6. The variance if ranted ould not :..., � g � permit any use that is not permitted in : the zoning district where the property is located. ,.;,` '�: � . 7. The request for variance s based primarily on a desire to fully utilize the ' site rather than economic gain. , � � � . . �� y�� , � File #10221 : Page 1�to E. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based o findings 1 through 7� staff recommends approval of the 4" variance for front y d setback and that a variance to permit a 5' , sideyard setback (and 14' wide arage) be approved rather than the 4' setback � (and 15' wide garage) requeste by the applicant. ,. .� �• , . � : j , , � �� ,. ,:•• , �. � , � . i , i : � .•� : ' ,.' :.� „� i i i � . � r u • � � V►. , �� . _9. : . j�;'F, , . , ' Y . ' . { '��. • ' � (, ,y� �' j 4 . . . . ,.�,• j J i .. � l t.l l . . � I \w� . . , ' . �t�. � •' aT' . , �� ' . . � ;bt.I.f� . � . ' t . 1. � .) J � • � � � �., � ,t 1 t '' ' + ` ' ,��x' � Y �il�� i i �`� � � r � ; �, . ; ZONING BOAR A E '� , I . ,�� '. ' ; ' ,h��';; qpPLIC � , ' � :� �' � �� ) ,�"w� CITY OF SAINT PAUL � , � �� 9��; a N / � �PARAGRAPH� y � � :' � ', , ' � ' • 4 �, SECTION ' � � • � ',i � , E GHAPTER_(L1�—� ` r � ; ,7 ,� A VARIANCE OF ZONING C �. .� � r..: ' - J 5 rptl.�{hy � . .�' � ' ;� * 1 �'.�" REnUESTED IN CONFOR ITY WITH THE PO ERS VEST�D„IN THE BOARD OF ZONING AP- ; y; y� IS µ ON PROPERTY , ,', r�� ., , . �� ,�.�.� � � , , � ,.� ' ' - r��4r b,', PEAI.S TO PERMIT TNE . � , ,. � '.+ �y' ��. S ' . iuY,'�'' DESCRIBED BELOW. , � -, c ,��•,J;:�� r�r�,�� . ,' ��' ' �.:� �`•ri � . , ' .� �! �� A. APPlicent; NAME: � C 'N .�' �.' ' '' y '� I. . .. �: E ';� i , � 4 i �, ., ADpRESS � ��''�� , y� � • ti ti , ZIP CODE e��-'.."""�' � '' ..• '.� ,�' �S-� - ��.�--- 1 . ..� r , �;''� pAYTIME EIEPHONE NO., �— �tc.) � , �'�u�� •� • F� �E.: ; owner,contract pu�chaser, I ,� � , . �fA'• � 1. PropertY interest of apPlicant: ( �NCIZ ' , ` / f/'�' �— - ` � � '��...#} r, ` I I�"4 r t" �l7L�L� �0��0� ,:��'. �•�.: � '��"�. � � r i' {,; `+ '�� i �r r�A' , 2. Nama of ow�er lif differen 1 r I l, t' An.'�. � .�.� ► � . .�� a t'�. .� � 'r � •� ) r,� !�. f �. � �,,JHww��J � :�', '• ProPem Oescription: D�DRESS Jr �J � � ' r�c l�o�� 'E1 . • :r a t, • ADD. �...6,Q 'J�'sJ^� � ' j► ; _, �; •y '� ~ at'oS �' ' BIOCK � � �jl-v--w 'f { ';t.� ' � _� ,. : i r '��`�� . 1. Lepe�description: LOT�--J-�---�-- �t ;. . -! • : � �� ,� ��` � � � ' � ;r K� 1 , � � ;��;� Z.� �.oc c�:e• / �_� ily : .. 7r ��' S�N �Q Tlli'''� / , • �'*rF ' ,,- P�ese�t Zoning Di�t. Present Use t � - , L � ,�-{ �s � ? ��ti�� h: 3. n � , ct t; ,:' ; ;; . " p�,,r '' C, Reaso�s for Requost' �O �-C�,�,f-- e�-�� _:, ;� ,� � , �{ `, 4 ,�. '� �. P�o��f C:u�C�� '`'°2� � . . _ ' b �� c� � ' . - •�jt¢, P�f,C�,tLvrc� S��.�b�'4"�„ ,. ,' � ; ' � � a t� � ; C�O--� '�" � , � � . � ; 1 ' ,, '�� , �',. ; -1� �j�x, N ravent its be�n9 uced for any of the Psrn^�tt°d uset , ' ';, , j ; i ,+,� '�� '� : Z, What physica�c ar teristia�i�n�°ons,s ze and�hape of lot,etc.1 �, I � �, y� �' �'�h ' in Your zone? toP�ePhY. �J� ��A�'L . �� ,o Fl <<ty . , � � � . �a � , ,.,o,,� . . � a , . �. {;.r d6 �� ,�4 : � � •, , " „i� :J y� riate. � � � .� t ivin9 discanca where ap oP n _ . ,' � � � 3 cif c variacion reque:ted.p _ • O� ,GVr►�v ' � 1 a ��- 3. Stete the�Pe � 1w.-v�.�. , e, �.(' }=rvr� �f � ' E . ��t ^� R� �,,,��/ J b �" ,Y,�,r_ �n�,rJf"' . ' t .�G.c.MC.. Alo �A -Q-" i 1' n',, ` i +`�� j. .�. ��0� � � qpl�(.l(�QJ � 9D�! A� �/^ r (� � �,;lQy`.�S�-�� . �� , � ; '` . ��t� �� F • ,�-� t� °` sidle a`f�o�'-�_... � tQa , , e follownnp , i �6�� /� � �t.� ' `. `;� �'�� 4. ExPlain how Y ur cASa eo�fwm�to �,o�r�"� �LOrdiancs Nawu d rew t in Peculiar "� � . A de �c�►�,}f -F �''' ,.�~ , ,k ,'' '��r� * ;� a. That the s ict aPplicetion of tha prdvisio�s of tha mng . � ,• , ` ` 7 i;,'; � '" or ez c e P t i n a l p r a c t i c at difficulties,or axceptional undua h d��iP�• _ - n ��-��9-� q.ea-� � _ � � �� ,,�Q,ut� �+-f�(��n .(r-�.�a.e�o►►� � � 1,� :: , . � f �p,f"v�/� [� ��• /l,p m e-i+a+ ,f ',� < < .• �� r t, r �' � �► .t1,^�p�'!L Q ly�,C�LM 4N�'� PP�j' : '� � � i i f 1 r� �D�� J'�'r'B i �� ,�rtl, i 4 ,. �` C� Mp� , .'. , , , � �,��' � � w�'`J` S�,at �y, CASHIERSUSEONLY �':� � `'�,�'1�';'� •�� '��n°� 10/Ob/87oo00411�21W1 CLFR�; 1 ;� ; . , ` '`�+i`��«,: �� ;� b. Thet the rentinp of a veriance will � Y � . .�1 �� ,a':. � .; not bo e substantial dotriment to 40U1 VARiF�ICE �140.00 �• . � � •' r� �.i ;c, or s subctantial imPair- �140 tlll �� 1 ':.' �,. ,.p , :+ public po of SllBTTL • • i� . �w��;9 � ' nt of h� inte�t and PurPa° 1 t � T0 O�dinenc�. li1G�F: tNI� * 40.1�0 y � . t � f w' � �, ,.i the Zo�i y ( !t lll� . � � , � �y �� . `-- , t .� �w v� r,,•,,�� CN�rI[;E. ' � . ;�j ,�� - Ir 1 1 � q. / � �y � . I " �I�.� � �ir�I ��. � I,. "r • i/��. � � �, ' � ,'� '� ! ° °`� l�; �a ` t • �;r. • � r�� ,t ; , � � , �. '',�� I � �' . �. � ;;�!�' � THIS II.L NOT BE� RO ESSED WITHOUT A COMPLETE SITE P�NI � � I � ,�, � F. NOTE> \ G '- � �s S �' , I 1 : �� ;i �\ )., t {ay9 , • .'� 1.'. F. ' 1 .. � L :� � �', - (� � ', !3 � 'f ' �'1i K � �•I �7��8t « C�� . t � -� � �. ,' '^� �� . -; �� .- ; ,_.._.---- .+ , � , - , �• '- Dau Fbcaved : . '_ 1 '. . � Y.l .�a.. ' `1 !' , ,� ' ' . � . ..•.4 . . �...� � .� � . . .., �� i .--�f:�t .. � � � 3......_ _ _ .�_ .i�k � :,•Y: , � , . �. + 't �-r + i ' 1 � ____ .. . + '. 1 'r� �.� � 3 � :l„r.r _.�..+ i'e ..3 ��; i, � ' � 1 �� - i _ _._ , . . . � i .i� �� 1'�• , . ' i ' a �q � . , �j� . � 4�R�1� � s. _ .. . . � .� , ' � � I'.�1Tt �9� � �, • �. '{ : � .. ; _� .�. � . . 7 � . � S � : � : i � .f � � 1� .•i r� . � � � . � . . . � j, '; � Ify y � ' , . � ' j'� . � S . . ' . ' � . . � . 1 �].� � '�� .�i` � . � ..'. { 1 I � � { � . . ' . � � .t •�.(; � . � ; � ,• y � f: i r� , �. . , � � � ' I�i '� ��'/ � . ' � . � , � � � ,� , t4 , � , � - � 4� s�' � ; � `t� '' i t t � • 4 i: r, 4 1 �:, � a.; � �� !r ;� ° . +��; . '�P ! , �•, . ,'� r �� :`; �1 i f� • !�y'� i I ' �f i '�• t �(y c' i� . � �1 , . � � � �i��'. � ...�". . . . . . � .,. . , . - i . �� ' .t �/I�t�. i ' . ;.� + �. �, .� � � i r � � . . . , ��1 n •.1 . . � ' ' r. � �� r :.'. , , „ � �� ,. ; - � ,� �r� . � � �r •: , . � .'� �5. �zt�. ;� � �, 4 � � ' ,� � ,�.a . ` � i �+, ., - , , , j �Y � . 1 � �.� �.��1�I•I '<<.. '.Y i. ' . . . . i.�i» ' �,_ : "�'. .. L i� i i a �� . �� 1.'T'� � i . . . . •a . � � �,i , � . , . 1' . ' . . - � . 7 1 . . � � � . �'1 . • .. � � �.. � . � '' II . . . � � � � �x .1 ; . . ' � , . • . �� , . . . . �� . .� : , . . . 1, . . ' � . , r � . • ' � S . . . . ' . ' � . ' ''� �I: ' � ' � ' . . ' l. 1 , . . . . � � . '} . . . , . , . � 1 . �� . . . . . . . . ' . . ' � � . t` . � _ � . i _ � � , . . . . �--�-�� ; ;; ;. �� ' Uctober 27, 19t37 :, : My name i s Ja�er�h i n� P�i l errno. I I i ve at I ]41 No. D�I e. My propertv ��.: ad,io i ns !343 No. Ua 1 e� the t.�rc�pPr v i n ��.�Pst i ori. ; � � l ob.ject t� tlie variance for the f- Ilowinq reason: Referrinq to the slir.ies. ynu will notP thaf. my hnuse has two bay w(ndows ' n�easur i ng 96 i nches w i cle on the n� th s i de of the IIOUSP.. (f Mr. Prudhrxne ,� � �� i s a 1 I owed to bu i 1 d thP qaraUe as �ror��sed. my v i ew to tlie st�eet wou 1 d ' be c�xnpletely blocked. Also, I �uld always be lookiny at a solid wall , from the bay wind��ws which are abc� t 8 ft. frc,m my Iinuse. . ' Presently� my home is for sale nd [ f�el this wr�uld be detrimental to �. � the selling of mv home and nK�st �� ob�bly wnuld dPCrease the value of my ' : property. ' I feel Mr. Prudhoine has or_f�Pr o �tions �s to where a yaraye r.ould be � constructed. : i� � � ,. l :,, , � ; � , .. , � , , � i j ; , �y � , . : � � „ k � � � . ��: •'1 '_,i �. I . . °. � ,}� �: �:� {� r� . ... , . . -. � � � . � ? • ry i'...1�� ;.- i . � .i j. ,, � �r � r , k�'� , a , ,� � F i' . . ' ' '� � �'.� `' .;'' .., . , . . . , t- t � �� )�f5.n, , . � ' , . . ' +•; JS �� r r , � � �� ,� �� • ` , �� t �4 I .1�'� � � �� '�, `I . }�'. . '1 ' . . ' . 1 1 ' I�� L �..6 , ' . J I 1A'� I � � ' • 1, � � � � . . :. � Y I ; � 7 . . . , I i i � x . ,' ,� ; - ;' �� ., � . �i� ,.i � . . � , . . . � . �� ..� h '' ;� � . .; �,,.f . �.. � . I �� ,; i . .�,; : � . . .. . . � , ��i�..�' ,,.� ��..� ;�t��: . .. . , `' 'i . , ; , � �: I . 9 �� I'" ,II ' � . � y ,;: � ,��: � ,. x� � � • � . i d �J � , � ,� ', � . r 9 �j'. I .. � , s �:. " � . , I �� b�. . ' � � r v � . +.�. , � ' .��1 `�I �i . _. . ' . ; . . ' . . ..7� i ��..ty� �t . �� ., . � i � � �1, ' , � ��f . �h . �n� . . Y'�rin '`� �� +• . ' . � .. . � � . � r � i. . Li � t�:'� � . � ,r ' �� . � . � � ii �i'.'�� '��1. ' ... ' . . . �� k�. .F.� 'h ' , . t .. . ' ` �..., ; � � t; ' i , ' ' ' 'i �. �;� . r . ' , ► ; � ' � , � : : . x� � � � . • � . , ,�. . , . � �;, , . + . .. �� . . • . ; . ..�� . , � .. i . . r' � . . . , , n � �i � . s ��. . . �.. .. . . . . � . �1� � �i.��t,"�j ' � � i . . . . . . . .. . . - ..i � . . � �.� � . � . � �'�-��;� ,, l '. �;: M& S �R�ssA REAL ESTATE "MISSY" ;� BONGIOVANNI : 9ROKER . ; 774-0747 7 . 1 To whom it may concern; ,i � I am the listing Real Estate Broker for Josephine Palermo, ' whose home is located at 1 41 North Dale Street. I am a member - of the St. Paul Area Board of Realtors and the Multiple Listing Service. � ��; During the time the h me has been listed on the market, I :`; have received negative co ents regarding the distance between Mrs. Palermos' home and th property to her north side known as 1343 North Dale. A commen was made in reqards to the neiQhbor buildinq a future qaraqe a d that it would be detrimental to mv � subject propertv. � � � I personallv feel tha Mrs. Palermn mav suffer a loss in `: �;� pr.operty value if a struct re stands ten feet outside her living - r, room bay windows. Based on the above me tioned, I request that this variance not be granted to the prop rty located at 1343 North Dale. ;: � ; ; . �,, ; . f,: ; � � ' Sincerely, , .� , �� , ^ � ......-� ��'•:��"�� _i •,, /%�,,�..�� ; ' '..; Marisse Bong' anni, Broker `� M & S Real Estate ' 41 � � ' i'. . '1'.' ':. :' ' � 1 /. t ,'1 f - 4 t . ��. � p: �.' ,. . - ,. �+j' A ,� . �, -� . ��` � i .��1� 1 � .� i,. . � .. ��; . � . �� i w I .'',�'I'��.a�.. �. ' �. r � ..�� , ,�. �:� � r �� , . ' , f � ,� _ � '. �� . i �'.� � � . . . . �r '�� ,, n t c � a X ! ��t�d " � L � �� .., t . . .r. �'q• l��}4r�yr . �i � • ; , � . . . - :�. i�: 1f J i4 w �� i . � � '. 'l� / . i 1. , '1 �`A� 'i �. .11.. � . �. . . � ,� .' .. � . . 1 ' � 7.�. ..:1 , A1, {.i i�+�d'1'j�_ - �. . . .,'. '�1- ii:. � '.��p �•1 .�t�' . . }: . � , ' .. ��'i� ly . ..,'. �4.'ky t � C � P" �'h :� it,. ` ' ' {H w�t �t - '. n �'i ,-.! . .�i y � '�a k '�� ' , '-rj�¢' ,. � • . . , ' , � ►�"� � .� , ' f ' � � {' ,' ,;. � -e 4 � . - . .�� , Ir r �T 6 � t' r ;'�.'. , � 1 � � t �i � P , i i' r "� �� .. �� •f 3 � � �''� ' . � . ' I'. . � i,�� . ��.1rfy� ��A ' � � �,'' � '1 L � . . ' r ` rl e.` � � � . � _ . , � ' 1 e t � !1 ty �''�. ' . /!`� . , , . � 0 p . ) � . 1 ` -. y 1 -I � : x `..'i.ts'.;� � ,y t � � . . � .' � 1 �r.l! , � S� � � � � ' � .'y � y�i � � . . . � . � i. . ��y'( " . � . ��, . i . : ',; . ., i,p . , ,� . . . . . , ,. . � ,: ��,..��„ F�.� ..�. 'y� � ��'. . a 1 � � . . �� - . � ,.�t t+ � if• f �°r�� 4 r�� . � � . . . r � ... Lti �°i��! IC 1 . � . �� i�t.'. . �� y .� 'A.l� � �.'� � , ' ' . �. . �� ' � � � �t'� ' y �� 1 1.�! . � . , � .'�: � �i;� � , � . ' y! .� �i�� }�� , . ; , , � � �� .At•�'Z�K� rti � . , • � . .� . . . t� �_ . ; . � . . . . L ♦.; .�1t �t�. . . �+ . , � i t-. , , '. . . . .I � . 1'• , . ' � � , • � � .j . , , r • , p�� • '� •:� , � �� :�. 'r.y � . , ` � 1 . ' u { . � �'� '.4 ! : , . ,� , , �'� ��' ''� , + °��. ��y.� ': i 1.�'1 � ' . � . . .. . . � , . ' i . . . � . , . � .. .. . �.4� ...r. � ' � , ' ' . . ��_�'�� , .��,{, ' � 1 - �;� ,`�` � . � `�1, o . � � :�_� � � : � - ; � � E rV ,� �. I � � ��w�rr (?•S et.w Pancn r: T... l,�.a I�. • �;� � _ � ,— _ �-��'�" s 1"_ I �:. ' t u•l ' : ��; J�fh . � •-- , �s � . - r � . , , ' i-- �✓��U i '-ti '''� � . . ; ` ,� • •- • . �•., _...r.,:.wa,e..• .- �. -.. '-• ` �. �� ►: ' ,_, 1 1,. M� � .�. � _ , tXiiT� 4 'I�° ' • .`, ' � (7�u. c . '�� " � ' ' . ' ` � � .;,.: ,.f . ., > NE� . . ,,. .. t . � ^ �O,y ' ,� � ► .`�•, � I�AQAr(. �-�._. `' .Z , /s'0 � �_J �q" y� • ,_ . _ . . . . - �� r � , � � � , � `��.��. ; , �� ,:' � ,� ,,. . . g d .,'�' ' ,d�•8 ' � ; � � � � �'.� . ' . ��. ' . •� . , , . ; , . . i., .�ur c..cn.4�.-.�-_. _ ; �-,,,,.!_t'��NM�R-~ �.-� . , r -�—�"'.�"�- - . -...-.,.----_ � �,rY'. �q: ••l.� ,1�� . � ; ;�•,, . ,..^ ��T� /. . ! . , � ......_.�,.�_�.,.;,,. �_--___._--.�:._.......r- -----�-- _„__,..�..�-.,�..r..._...,.-;---.----.� . . - . '� . � '; �. -. . � � R M .� , :��-�� -�'°' � ��.,,^_,..�.____.__---- ��, _��.�:. �E__--� .�:�-�---�+�---��- . . . ; ;� . . . . . . . � . z�4 � . � . : � � . . , � � �, , ,'fi� .G, �' 1� , ;;,:;„ � ,�c; �� . f �,.� . � ,r t.: � . '� .` .` :, '�-� ;�. ',�� `��'� `r: . , • , •.� , � � , 1 /L � � . . C�-S� -��-:�� . , r ITIZEN PAR ICIP TI I RI S ..,..... .. �O� M �� ` �, i s w ynG'O.�M ��r � � � � R tid 10 � 3 � � �� 2 1� • .o.. *j \i ' e. � � � �w �a � . r 5 �� .wwrc .t E � t s ��wn.�o r � � 4 M f w - � 'o'' V � � — Wt H � � S r t�!! � �L � f 'I� ' ■� � ` � _ � � ! ,►•'1 S � + � s� � f ��M+r� M �d. i � E E r.�,.w �� • ! [. 7+ f r, � � r�a e � 1 ` ..�.�.. � � 4 ° 4 . � : � • • . i �\ E f �•M �\ FM IM � : Y V e ��h� M �M M �\ , � i �,� .i �--_. �.o l � � � / • �� ar � � �, • �u." re F '� `� y �� ij 4Y � � r.n.� r� i ��+ �r �i P } a O � � • . 3 R . �A.� i14 =•.�. .� �, ` g ` � �� s. � ; � ��.ppr �[ �' S A � � r � � _ ' '` ' � F p � � � � : p q : f t p p 1 � i ! �o � D f e � � �...�� R.. � .o b,.. �z p .�...a6 � ' p o .00 '... � A o ��4 R � � � � � 4. ` �.•.. .. � "� , *� i ��.. ic s .. � �� \ r f"�p � / ,' \ M __�___�' � „ � NI . � .� _.�, �W CI7IZEN PARTICIP ION PLANNING DISTRICTS 1.SUNRAY-BATTLEC EEK-HIGHld00D 2.GREATER EAST S DE 3.WEST SIDE 4.DAYTON'S BLUFF S.PAYNE-PHALEN 6.NORTH END 7.THOMAS-DALE 8.SUMMIT-UNIVERS TY VENTH 11.NAMLINE-MIDWAY 12.ST. ANTHONY 13.MERRIAM PK.-LE INGTON HAMLINE 14.GROVELAND-MACA ESTER 15.HIGHLAND 16.SUMMIT HILL 17.DOWNTOWN - . �� -J'�� . , ri�Q�Oi� ._ � _ . . .. .. , . . --- - - _ _ _ _ - --- Hti . .:� ., .� �� ; -, � -: . OS1 �.y � �� o; o ' ' 1A,, �' "ti v1 •� . ��1 � f` D �. V { � � I� Q '� •... , J J �* "'i .�J � '`;; , ,� � ,,� fJ !j .� %^' ,�:� �� ' I � I F. � ; --� ;_i� ,Z J � .1 . _ � ! ---; ; ' i •� ,� f• � t;' � '�. • � • '� A '� .' .� •� '' � P s• � { � ��/� ; , `:�� J�� r• � • ,, � j' � -.►- -� 1-- - - --- � � � /� �7 `�•� • � � � `. •• . ^) - - - � h�� O - � � � .�; ..� � � � � • �� '� I ,.:��. . � � 1 �i � �J ., -� t i - .. -.. 1 ..__ �----� t" '',�.. : ,�� ,1 .. .��[� .!y 1 -' .�� - --� r - p � �- � i , y� � I ✓ . � � � '� �� ` `�.11�, � � 1 �J ( . ._•� '-- � � � �.� �.� �_ O _ "'� �.- �� i -. �} > .� �:, _ r "� ' � '� r I �.�� -1 . ,��i�� '� � � > "� � ' l� 1 ^ . . .�f�j ,� �1 �� ,� � ,.� . ( Q � --� � .� '�+1T- '� � .� � , � � I' � �� • . O O � ,' � • �'► , '7 :J � .� � < ` W. COTTAGE � A� � ' . o a � �, o- - - -a -_a___rto � �_ o ° - . � ' o 0 � o__ _�__ o 0 0 , . �: - -Q a-- � - � �; _ Q _ _ _ o .. o 0 0 _ -a o-- � � , o o �- � � �- - _� a- - _ o Q -c� o � �- . �., _" e- - - � -o- - � . o w� o ° = - - � � , o .�� - - --- � - -o a- - o ; o o _ ; , o o _ _ � � - -- o- - ! o � � ,,; _ Q '_ _-e �-- ' o .o- . _ �` ,( T �- - � O �; - � O , f ,�`'t;1 ,!i � � 1 1 � . . , � - O�O O O O O' O O �� 1 � � o � ob .0 1 � '• � 1 ��',� � �II H E E LO C K PA R K WAY . . . P-�� ; �; o :�� .. � _. . ► _ ~ o , �Q o � ' . o o � =_Q: " � o o � o , _�;{,.. � �� ► ' � �� .� r ��_ ' ` � , O _ � r � � � .�"�. � 1 ; .. �...� � t ,� � O + � � ; � _ --_--� r_-_0 �� i � ":-� � f _ 9. . ' ° _ .. ` . _6_� __ - ° - � - ��n� � o �~ �-�. � ----. ._.-� ^ .' _.�� A _ _� -_ � - . � . � � � V ST. PAUL ITY COUNCII. y ��.�� PUBI.iC H ARING NOTICE Z NING - To: Property ow:�ers within 350' ; FILE N0. 10232 Representatives of District 10. PAGE P U R P 0 S E The City Coun il will hear an appeal of a decision by the Board of Zoni g Appeals to grant a variance of required building setb cks for a proposed one-car, attached garage. The variance ould permit a setback of 5' from the south property line (7' required. ) L 0 C A T I 0 N 1343 N.Dale S reet (West side between Wheelock Pkwy. & Cottage) PETITIONER �OSEPHINE PAL R�•10 H E A R I N 6 Thursday, Decemb r 3, 1987 9:�� A.M. . Cit Council Cham ers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House Q U E S TIO N S Zoning z9s-4154 (Tom B2ach) Contact the Zoning Sectinn of the Planning and Economic Development Depart ent, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, t. Paul, Minnesoia 55102 Legal Description: On file Notice aent 11-20-87 („�°��'(��t% C"�K/ "��"""�"°°� CITY OF SAINT PAUL ��`�\C�t* 0�`L� _�"• ��`= OFFICE OF THE ClTY CLERK ;o� .; ,,il l t�rn ,: 5 0�� I ^` ALBERT B. OLSON, ClTY CLERK ��'' ��:��"� 386 City Hail,Saint Paui,Minnesota 55102 GFOi2CE UTIMER 612-248-4231 MAYOR December 22, 1987 ��C�� DEC 2 � 1987 Honorable George Latimer �� ,�:�� Mayor Roo� 347, City Hall At�ention: LeeAnn Turchin, Deputy Ma or Uvar N,s. Turchin: Th� attar_hed ordinance/resolution is ereby referred to you for review grior to pZacement on the City Counci agenda pursuant to Section 2.0'1 of the St. Paul Administrative C e. '�ery tr.uly yours, �;��.v.�!�� ,��?n�-�-%,?,��..... A1bPrt B. Olson C�tv C1Erk �s'30:th cc: �o'�rtcilmember Weida � ✓ �� -�� '°��;� ,� WHITE - C�TV CLERK PINN - FINANCE G I TY O F A I NT PA U L Council CANARY - DEPARTMENT � BLUE - MAVOR . � . � F1L@ NO. � , ouncil Resolution or; ,,�,,� i r�� ,��/�-� a .�,�� r Present.ed By �� Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WI�EREAS , Midwest Fence Co pany on behalf of Tom and Sandy Prudhomme applied for a vari nce from the strict application of the provisions o� Sec�ion 61 . 101 of i,he Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to building s t��ack in an R-3 zoning district so as to permit the constru tion of an attached aarage for property located at 1343 N. Dale Street on property legally described as the south 12 fe t of Lot 10 and Lot 11 , Block 1 , Warren and McDowell Subdivis ' on; and WHERERS , following a publ ' c hearing with notice to affected property owners , �che Board of Zoning Appeals by its Resolution No. 10221 adopted October 27 , 1987 , varied the provisions of Section 61 . 101 of the Leaislacive Code �o allow a setback of five feet from �tihe south pro� er�y line and a 26 foot 8 inch setback from the front ;�ro;�erty line for the propose� construction of �he attached garage ; and WHEREAS , pursuant to th provisions of Section 64. 205 , Josephine Palermo, 1341 North Dale , duly filed witn the City Clerk her appeal from the de ermination made by the Board of Zoning Appeals requesting tha a hearing be held before -che City Council for tne purpose of considering the actions taken by the said Board; and WHEREAS , acting pursuant o Sections 64. 205 through 64. 208 , and upon no�tice to Appellant nd the affec�ed property owners , a public hearing was duly c nducted by the City Council on December 3 , 1987 where all 'nterested parties were given an opportunity to be hea•rd; and WHE�EAS , the Council ha ing heard the statements made and having considered the v riance application, �he report of stai'f, ��he minutes and findi gs of the Board of Zoning Appeals does hereby COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays [n Favor Against By Form Approv CitX Attorney Adopted by Council: Date � Certified Passed by Council Secretary By By � A►pproved by Mavor: Date Approv d by Mayor for Submission to Council Q� BY � ; �,�-�.--��..� I�G/al 0 '�G� 4� �►�' '1"",�+ R� � �uHc', I 1��sal�,�E -�av ar �r� I3�t3 !J �al�. � � 'S is �a- , C.�Se, �-�►'Gl�+cd, 4� ad� l�rac '�1x� a� /� ✓ (�c�!te,r��s o��ic.a�, , 1+,� ►�eso lw�ia�, as o� �(rG�t�J i t, c��.+��5 �� , r ��c y4r�. �� -�rcr+� �rd v�iv�a��,s , � ��Ic�1 � . ; �q�;�. 1Z r�w�,�, �Kd s�. a r�.e.� w,� r�.. �r� �. � Co�K�� ( s ��h�te�►t wa� -�a ��,Y �,Ir �.. s�d� y��d s��ac�. . �V�G �ehG��c�+ jh q Y V/scd reSa�h�itd�1 � Ve��e�L �G1%S. �� -� �� .� yo� � -�. �,a�dl� . � � Yau �r�-�� q rc��s�1 resol��c�, a� s�.�� p �o ��e. ��►.� J�a.. . y ��i,�n lcs, � T�, �� x 33�6� . ��d-�-�� `,::�°��""� CITY OF SAINT PAUL �,T. o;��,o -`� '-'°� OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY ''e •" J J . �� ' EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY ':: �-1ii1u_� w= � ��',�r n,•,��'��'� 647 City Nall. Saint Paul.Minnesota 55102 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR January 11 , 1988 Tom Beach Department of Planning and Economic Development llth Floor City Hall Annex Dear Tom: You have asked that I prepare nother draft of the resolution for the Josephine Palermo appe 1 regarding the garage at 1343 North Dale so as to grant the var' ance for the front yard setback, while denying the variance for the side yard variance. The resolution which I had previou ly prepared at the request of the City Clerk denied all varian es because that was the request of the Clerk (and I assume th request of the City Council ) . Now you tell me that Janice ettman and you agree that the Council did not intend to den the front yard variance, and if that is the case then it sho ld be so reflected in the reso- lution. If you have any further quest ' ons or changes, let me know. I am sending a copy of this 1 tter to the City Clerk and to Council Member Rettman so that th y will know where the resolution is in the process. Your very truly, ti .-'. i �� JERO ` . SEGAL Ass �ta t Ci;ty Attorney r ( `, J J :c�g ,/ Encl . cc : City Clerk Council Member Rettman (RETURN TO JEROME SEGAL AFTER ADOPTION) �� U 'd� __ — — __ — _ _ _ _ _--._. _ _ ------------ i3' . _—____----- —--- —-— - w�i1TE - GTr G�ERK �--------- ---- -•--- ---------- PINK � FINANCE COUQCIl C1�NARY - DEPARTMENT �GITY OF SAINT PAUL - ��/-c��'i �v ewe _►,��row File N0. � O � - ounci Resolution Presented By .��'=�-� ° � - , Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, Midwest Fence C mpany on behalf of Tom and Sandy Prudhomme applied for a var ance from the strict application of the provisions of Section 1 .101 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to building etback in an R-3 zoning district so as to permit the constr ction of an attached garage for property located at 1343 N. Dale Street on property legally described as the south 12 f et of Lot 10 and Lot 11 , Block 1 , Warren and McDowell Subdivi ion; and WHEREAS, following a public hearing with notice to affected property owners, the Board o Zoning Appeals by its Resolution No. 10221 adopted October 27 1987, varied the provisions of Sectian 61 .101 of the Legisl �ive Code to allow a setback of five feet from �he south pr perty line and a 26 foot 8 inch setback from the front ;�ro�erty lirie for the proposed construction of the attached garage; and WHEREAS , pursuant to th provisions of Section 64.205, Josephine Palermo, 1341 North Dale, duly filed with the City Clerk her appeal from the d termination made by the Board of Zoning Appeals requesting th t a hearing be held before �he City Council for the purpose of considering the actions taken by the said Board; and � WHEREAS , acting pursuant o Sections 64.205 through 64.208, and upon notice to Appellant and the affected property owners, � a public hearing was duly c ndt�cted by� the City Council on December 3, 1987 where all nte�rested parties were given an ' opportunity to be heard; and VJHEREAS, the Council ha in� heard the statements made and having considered the ariance application, the report of staff, the minutes and find'ngs of the Board of Zoning Appeals does hereby . COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: [n Favor Against BY Form Approv City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date � Certified Passed by C�uncil Secretary By By� � Approved by �lavor: Date • Approv d by Mayor for Submission to Council , - - ----- - __ - � . . _ _. _ ---- -- -- —----—--- ; w►uTE - c�rv CIERK i PINK - FINANCE GITY OF AINT PAUL Council ��j � � /// CANARY - DEPI,RTMENT File NO. �v / / � elUE -MAVOR ' � Council Resolution � � � � � Presented By �, ' Referred To Committee: Date I Out of Committee By Date � , i � RESOLVE, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby reverse the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals in this matter regarding the side yard setback based upon a � finding and determination mad by the City Council that the ,' Board did commit an error, tha there are reasonable alternatives I to construct the attached g rage without having to require � a setback from the side yar zoning requirPments ar.d that a i garage 12 feet in width coul be built without requiring any ; such variances ; and, be it i FURTHER RESOLVED, that th City Council does hereby uphold I , the decision af the Board in this matter ira regards to front i yard setback based upon the inding by the City Council that a variance of front yard setbac is necessary for th� construction of a garage because of the lo ation of windo�NS in the existing house; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that he appeal of Josephine Palermo ry�`�� in regards to the side yard etback be and is hereby granted; � and, be it �� FURTHER RESOLVED, that he appeal of Josephine Palermo � ��` in regards to front yard setb ck be and is hereby denied, and, � be it � �' � FURTHER RESOLVED, that t City Clerk :�hall mail a copy of this resolution to Midwes Fence Compary, Tom and . Sandy Prudhomme, Josephine Palermo, the Zoning Administrator, the ' Planning Commission and the Boar of Zoning Rpp��als. COUNCIL MEMBERS Y� N� Requested by Department of: Dimond ��x [n Favor �� xeccman ��;� Against gY Sonnen Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Certitied Passed by Council Secretary BY— By Approved by Mavor: Date " Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council _ -------------------------------- AGENDA ITEMS ------------------ ��1� --------------------------------- ------------------______________ � - � °• ID#: 87-[570 � DATE REC: [12/16/87] AGEND DA�TE: [00/UU/UU] ITEM #: [ ] SUBJECT: [OVERTURN ZONING BOARD UECISIUN RE:S TBACK FOR GARAGE 1343 N. DALE ] C.R. STAFF: [N/A �� «^ �j SIG:�F�fit�i�. ] OUT-[X] CLERK {89ffi�70�]�� l2/Z v ORIGINATOR:[ ] C NTACT:[ ] ACTION:[ 7 C 7 C.F.# [ ] ORD.# [ ] G.S. RETU NED [00/00/00] FILE CLOSED [ ] � � � � � � ,� +� � * � +� FILE INFO: [RESOLUTION (2PGS)/RELATED GOCUMEN S (5)/PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE/ ] [MAP ] [ ] ------------------------- - G I T�1 �GtAMGI�� DEPAR�MEN � �T� 0961`� ' � CONTACT �-� 3�0 PHONE . ` . ` .: � DATE � _ .. : ; �Q ASSIGN NUaBER FQR R011TING Q�DER Cli All Laca ions for :Si na.ture : � Department Director Director of �Management�Mayor Finance and Management Services Direc�or � City Clerk Budget Director ` . - City Attorney ' T WHAT WILL BE ACHIEVED BY TAKING ACTIOa ON THE A TACHED MATERIALS?�(Purpnse/ �� : --� � �,fo�i.r�d� wi l� D�l'T � �,� . �� C �tionale) : : "'° � � _� �.r a��rd �F L��v�Nj laC� - ,dr �. �.�< J�?'1��c�{_ rCow�r.:f � �,c�✓ , � �c��f bw �f �� v Ce�w,l�t� � l f� �.r- GOST BENEFIT BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS TICIPATEt?: , � � . . : s, �'INI�VCING SOURCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY Nt�MBER CH ED OR CREDITED: (Mayor's signa- ture not re- - Total Anwunt of"Transaction: quired if under: � �10,000) . Funding Source: � Activity Number: � �� ATTACHMENTS (List and Number Al1 Attachments) : . �+�; � DEC 15�198� (H't'1F� , , QEPARTMENT REVIEW CITY AT'fORMEY REYIEW �OI'es No Council Resolution Required? ' Resolutior� t�equired? �e�s No Yes No Insurance Required? 3nsurance��ufficient7 Y�s No Yes o Insurance Attached: (SEE •REVERSE SIDE FOR I �RUCTIONS) . Revised 12/84 ' , '.:':� HOW TO USE" THE C�$EEN SHEET . c. -.,. The GREEN SHEET has several PURPOSES: � � 1. to assist in �vutin+� documbhts and in securing required signatures 2. to .brief�the reviewers of.; doctaments on the unpacts of approval 3. to�•he'Ip`�ensure that necessaley `�upporting materials are prepared, and, if , . „ rs��t+�id.r attaclied.' . Providing co�►plete information under the listed headings enables reviewers to make decisions on the documents and eliminates follow-up contacts that may delay execution. The COST/BENEFIT,, BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPACTS headinq provides space to explain � the cost/benefit aspects of the decision. Costs and benefits related both to City budget (General Fttnd and/or Special Funds) and to broac�er financial impacts (cost to users, homeowners or other groups affected by the action) . Ti�e personnel impact is a descriptiom of change or shift of Fu11-Time Equivalent (FTE) positions. � . Zf a CONTRA T amo�nt is. less than $10,000,�the Mayor's signature is not reqtiired, if the depa�tment director.,signs. A contract must always be fi4rst signed by the ' ; outsid�.rt�gen,cY:befor��out,iiig t3�rouc�h`City offices. � . Below is the p�r@f#rred ItQUTING for the fiva moat frequen£ ty�es 'of doc�nts: . CONTRACTS (assumes authorized budget exists) ' � l. Outside Agency 4. Mayor , 2. Initiating Department 5. Finance Director _ 3. City Attorney 6. Finance Accounting ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER (Budqet Revision) ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS (all others) . 1. Activity Manager 1. Initiating Department 2. Department Accauntant 2. City Attorney 3. Departmeat Director 3. Director of Management/Mayor 4. Budget Director 4. City Clerk ' 5. City Clerk � 6. Chief Accountant, F&M5 COUNCTL RESOTATION (Amend. Bdgts./Accept. Grants) COUNCIL RESOLUTION (all others) 1. Department Director 1. initiating Department 2. Budget Director 2. City Attorney 3. City Attorney 3. Director of Management/Mayor 4. Director of Managen�nt/Mayor 4. City Clerk 5. Chair, Finance, Mngmt. & Personnel Com. 5. City Council 6. City Clerk 7. City Co�.��,j� 8. Chief A o C , �&MS SUPPORT11��.L�E�t 4 '. In the ATTACIiMENTS section, identify all attachments. If the Green Sheet is well done, no letter of transmittal need be included (unless signing such a le ;,�i j. of the requested actions) . . . � i��..,'� .�t � , � Note: If an agreement requires eviderice of insurance/co-insurance, a Certificate of X , Insurance should be one of the attachments at time of routing. Note: � Actions which require City Council Resolutions include: l. Contractual relationship with another governmental unit. 2.. Colleetive bargaininq contracts. � 3. Purchase,, sale or lease of'land. 4. Issua,nce of bon�ls by City. 5. E�minent domain. 6. Assumption of liability by City, or qrantfng by City of indemnific�tion. . 7. Aqreements with State or Federal Goverrnaent under whfch they are providing funding. 8. Budqet amendments. . , �. DEPARTMENT �T� _ 09613 � CONTACT PNONE � � . .. DATE� � � �� F , - ASSIGN NUhBER FOR ROUTING 0 DER Cl i Al l Lpcati ns for Si nature : - Department Director Director of ManagementJMayor Finance and Management Services Director � City Clerk _ _ - . 8udget Director City AttorneY '. :. ,, ;. . WHAT WILL BE ACHIEVED BY TAKING ACTION ON Tk�E AT ACHED MATERIALS? (ParpaseJ . � Rationale) : COST BENf FIT BUDGETARY AND PERSONNEL IMPaCTS AN ICIPATED: �INANCING SOURCE AND BUDGET ACTIVITY NUNBER CHAR ED OR CREDITED: (Mayor's signa- ture nat re-�. Tatal Amount of "Transaction: quired �if �un�#e�. Y � $10,00Q) � Funding Source: Activity Number: . , ATTACHMENTS (List and Number All Attachments) : : DEPARTMENT REVIEW . ' .CiTY AT�'�tNEY REYi�Ii' Yes No Council Resolution Required? ` Resoiuti�n Required? � '� Y�s No �Yes No Insurance Required? Insurance Sufficient? "' Yi�s No �Yes No Insurance Attached: . � (.5EE •REVERSE SIDE F'�R I TRUCTIONS) Revised 12/84 j . r:' . -.� :�'..:_ HOW TO USE THE .G,�tBEN �SHEET � The GREEN SHEET h�s several PURPOSES: � ' � ' 1. to �ssist in xouting docu�ents .and in securing requir� signatures 2. to l�fef the reviewers of docw�ents on the impacts of approval 3. to help ensure that necess8zp sup�orting materials are prepared, and, if x �rard, :�tta�hed. "^ - !u�u , . Providing complete� information under the l�sted headings enables reviewers to make decisions on the documents and eli.minates follow-up contacts that may delay execution. The COST/BENEFIT, B[IDGETARY AND PERSONNEL .IMPACTS heading provides space to explain � the .cost/benefit aspects of the decision. Costs and benefits related both to City budget (General Fund and/or Special Funds} and to broader financial impacts (cost .. to users, homeownexs or other groups affected by the action) . The personnel impact is a description af:change or shift of Fu11-Time Equivalent (FTE) positions. � If a CONTRACT amount is less than $10,000, the Mayor's signature is not required, ` if the department director signs. A contract must always be first signed by the outside agency before routing through City offices. Below is the preferred ROUTING for the five most frequent types of documents: CONTRACTS (assumes authorized budget exists) ' � 1. Outside Agency 4. Mayor 2. Initiating Department 5. Finance Director : % 3. City Attorney 6. Finance Accountinq ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER (Budget Revision) ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS (all others) 1. Activity Manager 1. Initiatinq Department 2. Department Accountant 2. City Attorney 3. Department Director 3. Director of Management/Mayor 4. Budget Director 4. City Clerk ' 5. City Clerk 6. Chief Accountant, F&MS COUNCIL.RESOT�UTION (Amend. Bdgts./Accept. Grants) COUNCIL RESOLUTION (all others) l. Department .Director 1. Initiating Department 2. Budget Director 2. City Attorney 3. City Attorney 3. Director of Management/Mayor _ 4. Director of Manaqement/Mayor 4. City Clerk 5. Chair, Finance, Mngmt. & Fersonne], Com. 5. City Council 6. City Clerk 7. City Council 8. Chief Accountant, F`&MS SUPPORTING MATERIALS. In the ATTACHI�NTS section, identify all attachments. If the Green Sheet is well done, no letter of transmittal need be included (unless signing such a letter is one of the requested actions) . Note: If an aqreement requires evidence of insurance/co-insurance, a Certificate of Insurance should be one of the attachments at time of routing. ' Note�s Act�on�i"`which require City Council Resolutions include: 1. Contractual relationship with another governu�ental unit. 2.. Collective bargaining contracts. • 3. Purchase, sale qr lease of land. 4. "";Issuance of bonds by City. 5. Eminerit doma�.n. 6. Assu�tion of liabiliCy by City, or qrantinq by City of indemnific�tion. : :7. A�7re�aents azith State or Federal Goverr�ent under which they are providinq fundinq. 8. Budget amendments. . ��'--��-c!_��7 MEM�EA � :�:irri.idraiii;ir:i'rv:�:�: � .::.: REAITOp•...•..�..�.� � �' �'�� 1345 ARCADE ST. 5T.PAUL.MN 55106 TELEPHO E 774-9541 '�/l /$� �� 1 �� ' ��..i 1 'JC�� ` �✓' ` � , s��- -� �� " � � �� o�- �� .�� , � .Jc�h;�, � , c�- -� r � o�... C��1� ` �C1c.u�t- �- _ 3 3 1-� ^��- �.5� . � �,� � ��.. � �. ...�� v� - � � � � � �.�... °�`-� �"�`�.�.�� ' °,►�.� ��..�.�,..�.°`�`� � � � �.Q. a.9-�. ��x.�. ��.s�,�.- � > C�-6�.- C�� , c��. �x� � � � � `�j �. ,..�s-- , i� � �. � , �-. u�-�sLQ .�� - _ �.- � . �, � � �� -Q�,.sL c� l3� t ►�. . !�.s�. t� c�n_ �o�,�.�. C1� C� �Q�� ` c� � ► �l�o . c�.��'L �..��.,a l�a..Q�,�, c�-� �'�� . � ��►-� -�C� �P� L� o�ti- ,.�(SV�.��o . � �� c� �� i � , o 0 0 .°o .�c� �. � � G � � �-,�, 1°l� � � h � F l�`3 S �. �o�.lC� �c�� w C� �� c�r b`-`� ,..�O o ,o 0 ��'� . . �o�.� �. -�-,� �-w� � _ � . `�'`'�� .,�.�_�.� C�--c�c�- C�-w.�L -�-e� ` .� . � �. � (�..0��— ' � l��_ C9-� ��, s �, . . �.LL� �� ` (�s,o� �.� ch�� 1h�t�cR�, � , . � � � � �� -�- ��-�- � - P a- .��. ��Y+�. .Q,�.,�.9..�., � � c� .�`� . � �. . 0 ,�-��,,o o�. a� -� � , . . . . _ � � � ��,�� . . �c�.. Lo, n � � V-- V . �_ ��-�. �- � � � � �-,,� 13�� -��- � . c� � ►- s .� , , � a� �..:Q.� �,� �� ..�,�. . c��-� � `�� ° D`��yt � - r � , .C� S , � �/ S . ��i� SS� � � /�� .�� 'a'�S � � � ��8' � � . . ''�' , )o � 9 gr � � 333 � � �� _ _ _- _ _ _ _ _ _ - ��? __�1 _$_� _ _- - - - - - _. � _ _ _ ___ - - - - -_ _ _ _ ---------- , ---- ___--- --- � _ _ - - -- -- .- i- - -/�',�_ _ Q�v_h� r. __ r� ��t __ r P ._G�e.r�.7' ____O�_ _�.�_`f 7 �1-�--R-'-Q/� . �T j_------ � � � _ - - _ T �.�� e ►�o- - _o�� c�, p✓.._ ___�o __ �____ C�e.��r�.i.� �a� -- _ _ _ _ _ Q� __ ct _.�Q_r Gt q �_ _ G�[ _ : 1�_`��_-./_V• �q ��. �-.7- • _ - - -- --- - _ ,J -- _ _ _ ___ - - — -- __ _ . __ __ - --- C r r ` - � � _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.. _ i + _ _ I