The URL can be used to link to this page

88-283 ` f�J,�a�a WHITE - C�TV CL K COURCII /� Gy-.�/y 3 P�INK + FINANCE G I TY O SA I NT PA U L �.. Q a �--0 CANARV - DEPART EN7 / BIUE - MAVOR File NO• Counc l Resolution ,��,� 13 Presented By Referre To Committee: Date Out of ommittee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That th Council of the City of Saint Paul her by certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Boa d of Appeals and Review ertaining to the following listed pro- per y and as shown by the Ex erpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and Review, dated January 12, 1988 and marked, EXHIBIT A, and attach- ed ereto and made a part th reof by reference : DAT OF BOARD INUTES CASE NO: PROPERTY APPELLANT Ol/ 2/88 90-86-H 44 Lynnhurst Reentry Services, Inc. Ann McDirmad BOA D ACTION: Board grante a variance pertaining to deadbolt locks. PRO ERTY DESCRIPTION: Hinkel Second Amendment to Union ark Lots D E and Lot F ----------------------- --------------------------- Ol/ 2/88 90-86-H 55 W. 7th Street Reentry Services , Inc. Ann McDirmad BOA D ACTION: Board grante a variance pertaining to room size, allowing occ pancy to cap at 26, with the condition that this va iance is granted only for the time that Reentry Servi ces , Inc. , manages the property. COUNCIL ME BERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �ng In Favor Goswitz Rettman B Sc6eibel A gai n s t Y Sonnen Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Counc 1: Date Certified Passed Council Secretary BY By, Approved by Mavo : Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By _ BY I /�',�`,�`�'� � ��FJ PRO ERTY DESCRIPTION: Stins�pn Brown & Ramsey' s addition to St. Paul part of � Lot 6 7 8 and 9, NWLY of 7th St. � and S}nTLY of line running NWLY at Rt. angle with NWLY line of 7th S . from part of 40 5/6 Ft. SWLY hereon from W. line of Oneid� St. and all of Lots �l thru 15 Blk 17 -------------------- ------------------------- DAT OF BOARD INUTES CASE 1V0: ROPERTY APPELLANT Ol/12/88 119-87-H 41 E . Third St. Dale R. Carmichael BOAR ACTION: Board grante a variance for the tub/shower require- ments for ap rtment at 943 , with the condition that only one adul�t occupy the unit at any given time , and that the Iother tenants do not use this shower, and no chi ldrlen. PROP RTY DESCRIPTION: Richar & McCarricks subdivision of Block 8$ of Lym n Dayton' s addition Lot 18 Blk 88 --------------------------------------------- O1/1 /88 120-87-H 3�33 Atwater St. Alan W. Weinblatt BOAR ACTION: Board granted a variance pertaining to present deadbolts , wi h the condition that when the deadbolts need replacem nt that they are replaced with the one (1 ) inch proj ction. •;��r�PROP RTY DESCRIPTION: Alabama l Addition Number 2 ` Saint P�ul , Minnesota Lots l0l & 11 Blk 3 ;. -------------I------- ---------------------- Ol/12/88 111-87-H ,1 76 Agate St. Janice Rae Arcand BOARD ACTION: Board granted a variance pertaining to deadbolts with the condition that when these need replacement that the lock� are replaced with one (1 ) inch pro- jection, this variance is granted for as long as it remains a sec rity building and Ms . Arcand owns the building. PROPE TY DESCRIPTION: Whittier� Division Subject Ito alley Vac Alley accruing� & Fol Lots 3 thru Lot 8 ,Blk 1 ----------------------I-------------------------- WMITE - C�TV CLE K PINK - FINANCE COURCII Q � CANAijV � DEPARTMENT G I TY O SA I NT PA IT L File NO• "� -�� lUE -MAVOR � Counc l Resolution Presented By Referre To Committee: Date Out of ommittee By Date DAT OF BOARD M NUTES CA5E NO: ROPERTY APPELLANT Ol/ 2/88 111-87-H 040 Agate St. Janice Rae Arcand BOA D ACTION: Board grante a variance pertaining to deadbolts with the con ition that when these need replace- ment that th locks are replaced with one (1 ) inch projection, his variance is granted for as long as it remains a security building and Ms. Arcand owns the building PRO ERTY DESCRIPTION: Virgil a Division No par of Vac N-S alley adj to Lots 9 10 & 11 , the Fol , ot B & Lots 6 thru Lot 11 Blk 1 -------------------- ------------------------ and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, Th t upon passage of this resolution, the Cit Clerk, is hereby author zed and directed to transmit a copy of thi resolution for recordin to the Ramsey County Office of the Register of Deeds. COUNCIL E[V Requested by Department of: Yeas DimOnd Nays Goswitz � �n Favor Long Rettman a Against BY Scheibel Sonnen Wilson �R ' � �9a8 Form rove by it tor Adopted by Counc'1: Date c Certified Pas d ncil , c t BY � By A►ppro IVlavor D � �(� - � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY PUBIISHED h�h� 1 ? 1988 _ _ . . _ . / . , � . , C uncil Research Center ��°� � FEB 2319� , -�° 013551 � �� Jose in P. Pa ermo ' CONTACT IQAME 2 9 8 j`416 3 FHONE ' 19 B 8 DATE , S G U D R: (See re er e side.) � _ Departme t Director Mayor (or Assistar►t) _ Finance d 1�Ianagement Services Direc or 3 City Clerk Budget rector ✓� Gil Research � City At rney - TO ( ip all location r signature.) � V 0 4 (Purpose/Rationale) ; . Approvin the actions. of the Boa f Appeals & Review meeting of Januar�r 2, 1988. Number of cases 6 - variance g anted. C U 0 C N/A � , N C NUM R C G R D (Mayor's si ature not required if under $1 ,000.) � Total Am t of Transgction: N/ � Activity Number: N/A ' Funding S nrce: N/A ATTACHrtENTS (List and number all attac e ts.) 1 Resolution. with minut s ttached. � . ADI+I NI V OC _Yes No Rules, Regulations, Pr ce ures, or: Bud$et Amendment required? _Yes No If qes, are they or t et ble attached? D P T T VIEW CITY ATTQRNEY .REVIEW _Yes No Council resc�lution requi ed Resolution required7 _Yes _No _Yes No Insurance required? Insurance"sufficient? �Yes ____Ro Yes No Insurance attached? . ��G � . � DOCU�� Q. '�f'i.� AF�f�� (` � ; c RAMS� :i `TY . ,'... C�f:; �r�,� ;;- �� N � -� ��-�-�6�-- `'� Ocr I 3 3 oz PP� '8� � c� �� - .; � �' C°��.'�.�,�, . .� �;��R �Y-`�---�-------_ �'=�'G"i�Y I I STATE OF MINNES A ) County of Rams y ) ss. CITY OF SAINT PA ) lbert B: Olson I, . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . .. . .. . ... ..City Clerk of the City of Saint Pa�31, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the atta�ched copy of Council File No.$$.283. .. . . . . .. . . .. as adopted by th City Council. . , March. l:. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .�9 88 . . . and approved by he Mayor. . . . .. , , March. l2:. . . .. . . . . . ...„ i9 88 . . . with the origina thereof on file in my office. I further c rtify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my and and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this . 14th . . . . . . . day of . ,�tober_ . .. . . . _ ,A.D. I9 88 . � . . . . .�.. f `��`". .�. .�� . . . . . . . . City Clerk. �`/�j � � .� � � �� , , `f^ , � � � ; �` �'�`�� ; _.. : � - � � � f `� ' �r` � . ,� ��`�� , ti�� — . " :�y,.° �'C� �; � ' `�� .; _ ..o � �� t/ ��° yrv*=�GD �nnte=r»GyL�S[�"'�s�Ci.i y,.nr � .'�� .� .. .. s _ v+.r�....�:� v+�.'a�we . .av'v . . � ��,D.-�az a wr��TE — C�ar cIER PINK -� FINANCE CO�IRC11 GAN�GRK — DEPAI7TME T GITY OF SAINT PAUL ��-� 3 BLUE —MAVOR File NO• � Counci � Resolution Presented B ��z�� - �Z464rZ�Z (� . Y Referred o Committee: Date Out of C mmittee By Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul here y certifies and approves the action of the City of Saint Paul Boar of Appeals and Review p rtaining to the following listed pro- pert and as shown by the Exc rpted Minutes of said Board of Appeals and eview, dated January 12, 1988 and marked, EXHIBIT A, and attach- ed h reto and made a part the eof by reference: DATE OF BOARD M NUTES CASE NO: ROPERTY APPELLANT O1/1 /88 90-86-H 4 4 Lynnhurst Reentry Services, Inc . Ann McDirmad BOAR ACTION: Board granted a variance pertaining to deadbolt locks. PROP RTY DESCRIPTION: Hinkels Second Amendment to Union P rk Lots D and Lot F � ------------------------ -------------------------- O1/1 /88 90-86-H 8 5 W. 7th Street Reentry Services, Inc. . Ann McDirmad BOAR ACTION: Board granted a variance pertaining to room size, allowing occu ancy to cap at 26, with the condition that this var ance is granted only for the time that Reentry Servi es , Inc. , manages the property. COUNCIL MEM RS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �� In Favor Goswitz Rettman �h�;� A gai n s t BY Sonnen Wilson Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Councii Date Certified Passed by Council Secretacy BY By. Approved by Yfavor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY . �/ � .. , , • ��•,�tf .�`'�-�J " 2464232 PROP RTY DESCRIPTION: Stinso Brown & Ramsey' s additi n to St. Paul part of Lot 6 7 8 and 9, NWLY of 7th St. and S Y of line running NWLY at Rt. angle with NWLY line of 7th St. from part of 40 5/6 Ft. SWLY t ereon from W. line of Oneida St. and all of Lots 1 thru 15 Blk l7 --------------------- ------------------------- DATE OF BOARD M NUTES CASE N0: P OPERTY APPELLANT O1/1 /88 119-87-H 9 1 E. Third St. Dale R. Carmichael BOAR ACTION: Board granted a variance for the tub/shower require- ments for apa tment at 943, with the condition that only one adul occupy the unit at any given time, and that the ther tenants do not use this shower, and no childr n. PROP RTY DESCRIPTION: Richard & McCarricks subdivi ion of Block 8$ of Lyma Dayton' s addition Lot 18 Blk 88 --------------------- ----------------------- Ol/12 88 120-87-H 3 3 Atwater St. Alan W. Weinblatt BOARD ACTION: Board granted a variance pertaining to present deadbolts , wi h the condition that when the deadbolts need replacem nt that they are replaced with the one (1 ) inch proj ction. `��'J'PROPE TY DESCRIPTION: Alabama Addition Number 2 ;,v�i.. "� Saint P ul , Minnesota Lots 10 & 11 Blk 3 �i --------------------- ---------------------- O1/12 88 111-87-H ,l 76 Agate 5t. Janice Rae Arcand BOARD ACTION: Board granted a variance pertaining to deadbolts with the cond' tion that when these need replacement that the lock are replaced with one (1 ) inch pro- jection, this variance is granted for as long as it remains a sec rity building and Ms . Arcand owns the building. PROPE TY DESCRIPTION: Whittie Division Subject to alley Vac Alley accruin & Fol Lots 3 thru Lot 8 lk 1 � � ^ WMITE - CITY GLER � PINW - FIj�IANCE COUnC1I G � CANqRY •- OEPARTME T G I TY O F SA I NT PAU L /f �� @LU,E, -MAYOR , . . , FII@ �O. �`� � Cou�ci - Resolution � _ z4s�z�2 Presented By - Referred o Committee: Date Out of C mmittee By Date - DATE OF BOARD MI UTES CASE N0: P OPERTY APPELLANT O1/1 /88 111-87-H 1 40 Agate St. Janice Rae Arcand BOAR ACTION: Board granted a variance pertaining to deadbolts with the cond' tion that when these need replace- ment that the locks are replaced with one (1) inch projection, t is variance is granted for as long as it remains a ecurity building and Ms. Arcand owns the building. PROP RTY DESCRIPTION: Virgili Division No part of Vac N-S alley adj to ots 9 10 � 11 , the Fol , L t B & Lots 6 thru Lot 11 Blk 1 --------------------- ----------------------- and e it FURTHER RESOLVED, Tha upon passage of this resolution, the City Clerk, is hereby authori ed and directed to transmit a copy of this resolution for recording to the Ramsey County Office of the Regis er of Deeds . COUNCILM N Requested by Department of: Yeas DiIC10nd Nays Goswitz � �n Favor Long ' Rettman a Against BY � Scheibel Sonnen WilsOn �R - 1 1988 Form rove by it tor Adopted by Council: Date c Certified Yas d ncil , c t BY By . A►ppro �Navor: D � � � ° Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By BY P��SHED P,�I',� 12 19 88 _ . �,� _:.�� . � , � N I .4 ' ' � . � I Li� � � . � 01 r1 w � � -;H W .� p � � O � � W d' . i� �� . � � � F- � � .I.�i ,� ' O • � �,I U w � � O W � � N ' � . � ; OC :0�p ' O � ,� • � � i i •r- . U � . N .� v � 0 V � � I , � C � . � M ' � i � +� N • � � � �i C pp . � M . �"'� N � ,` Ei d' � a f d J A� I �o M� � V1 L Y 1-S ` r ' � � 0.' N S.. � i d. E J Lt. F- .C] ' � ��p +� .' Z C� O U ? W � r0 al � � � Z � • +� C ►r � Op ', C O C.� t� M � C,�j' d - ��-�� SAINT PAUL BO RD OF APPEALS AND REVIEW 7 5A City Hali 5t. Pa l , Minnesota 55102 Minutes. mee ing of January 12. 1988 ME BERS PRESENT: Ron Gl ssman, Chairman Harold Knutson Oavid chultz Sean C rey Glenn ausman ME BER5 ABSENT: Willia Tilton Rosann Bostrom OT ERS PRESENT: Sherry Webb, St. Paul Fire Prevention Pat Fi h, St. Paul Fire Prevention ' Hope A rams, St. Paul Fire Prevention Jim Prill . Vacant Buildings Donatd E. Ostrum John Krost John W. Rihm Dennis Davidson Gloria Weinblatt Anne McDirmad Bruce levdenen Dale Carmichael Janice Rae Arcand Th meeting of the Boar of Appeals and Review was called to or er by Chairman Ron Glass an, at 1 :30 p.m. January 12, 1988. Mr Glassman welcomed he Appellants and explained the pr cedures, stating that w t the Board does is recommends action to the City Councii . Mi utes of the December 8, 1987 meeting were approved as su mitted in writing. CA E NO: PROPERTY APPEALED APPELLANT 12 -87-H 586 Van Bure Ave. Grace V. Murphy (vacant bld . ) AP EARANCE: Peter Fooshe, r. SU JECT: Appellant is requ sting a waiver of the vacant building fe s in the amount of �370. 0. as per letter dated December 15, 19 7. PR CEEDINGS: Mr. Fooshe rep esenting Grace Murphy, the fee ow er of the property loc ted at 586-586 1/2 Van Buren. Ms. Mu phy has a Contract for eed on the property which was sold to La bert W. & Karen L. Mot . They as Contract purchasers were re ponsible for taking care of the property and have failed to do so. The rear property has been vacant for a long time and is in ve y much need of repair, the building has been condemned and pl - carded by the city. Mr. Motz failed to response in anyway to th notices and they have ccumuiated for a considerable length of time. The amount outsta ding is in the amount of $480. 00. A 1 notice of cancellatian on the Contract for Deed has been f91ed. It was expected that by this time Ms. Murphy would be the owner of right. Ms. Murphy has paid delinquent taxes and presently has hired an Electrician to do the electrical work to try and bring the building up to code. Jim Prill , from Vacant Buildings stated that the ordinance reads, all delinguent vacant building fees shali be paid prior to any transfer of ownership interest in a vacant building. Mr. Fooshe feels that Ms. Murphy is a victim of circumstances, therefore, would like the fees waived. BOARD ACTION: Motion made by Ron Glassman to waive the fees of $480.00 with the condition that if Ms. Murphy retains title within 90 days and has a permit then work is started to bring building up to code. Seconded by David Schultz. THE VOTE: Yeas 4 Nays 0 Abstension 1 (Gausman) ------------------------------------------------------- 114-87-H 847 Agate St. LeRoy Smithrud ( 1 unit) APPEARANCE: NONE SUBJECT: Appeilant is appe�ling the orders from a letter dated November 10, 1987 pertaining to EXTERIOR: Cement steps broken; INTERIOR: Room addition, north side ceiling is water damaged, South Bedroom ceiling water damaged, Kitchen ceiling on east wall is sagging, Basement vent stack to chimney is not secured, Bathroom walis are water stained, Bathtub wall area has cracked tile and needs caulking around tub, No smoke detectors. EKTERIOR: North wall damaged, Front Porch inside east wall is unfinished. Repair floor, beca�se of the unreasonable time to comply. BOARO ACTION: Motion made by David Schultz to deny the request for a variance pertaining to EXTERIOR: Cement steps broken; INTERIOR: Roorn addition, north side ceiling is water damaged, So. bedroom ceiling water damage, kitchen ceiling on east watl is sagging, basement vent stack to chimney is not secured, bathroom walls are water stained, bathtub wall area has cracked tile and needs cauiking around tub, no smoke detectors. EXTERIOR: North wall damaged, front porch inside east wali is unfinished, repair floor. Seconded by Harold Knutson. THE VOTE: Yeas (5) Nays (0) Abstension {0) ---------------------------------------------------------- 2 , �� 90 86-H 444 Lynnhur t 8 Reentry Services, Inc. 855 West 7t Street Ann McDirmad (Group Hom ) � AP EARANCE: Ann McDirmad 5U JECT: Appellant is requ sting a variance for 444 Lynnhurst and 85 West 7th Street p rtaining to deadbolt locks. Also re uesting a variance o the room size for the number of re idence as per letter da ed October 29, 1987. PR CEEDINGS: Ann McDirmad, stated that the building has dead bolt lo ks on presently. The cost of replacing the locks would be ve y costly. Also, because of the nature of our facility it would be very difficult for the children to open the dead bolts with a on inch projection. It is extremely rare for all the women and ch ldren to be home all at one time. No representation from the City. BO RO ACTION: Motion made by Glenn Gausman to grant a variance pe taining to dead bolts a 855 W. 7th St. also the requirement fo 60 square feet per p rson, allowing occupancy of 26, at 444 Ly nhurst, with the condi ion that this variance is only granted fo the time that Reentry Services, Inc. manages the property. Se onded by David Schultz. TH VOTE: Yeas (5) Na s (0) Abstension (0) --------------------- ---------------------------------- 11 -87-H 1753 Randol h Ave. Dennis M. Davidson (4 units} AP EARANCE: Dennis Davids n SU JECT: Appellant is re uesting a variance pertaining to Item #5 Install Door Closures and ltem #6-Deadbolt locks, from a le ter dated October 28, 1987 because it is unnecessary and a ha dship. PR CEEDINGS: Mr. Davidso stated that the building has dead bo ts. Fire Department m asured the dead boits and they measure 1/ inch. The building d es not have corridors, each unit has a fr nt and rear entrance, o ly common stairwells. Pa Fish, from Fire Pre ention stated that door closures are re uired on all apartment oors. 3 BOARD AC7ION: Motion made by Gienn Gausman to deny the variancz pertaining to dead boit locks and door closures, instead giving an extension of time for 9� davs to cornplete the work. Seconded by David Schultz. THE VOTE: Yeas (3) Nays (2) Abstension (0) -------------------------------------------------------- 119-87-H 941 East third St. Dale R. Carmichael (4 units) APPEARANCE: Dale Carmichaei SUBJECT: Appellant is requesting a variance on Item #2-Provide Tub and Shower for Apartment 943, as per letter dated Novernber 17, 1987. PROCEEDINGS: The unit at 943 E. 3rd st does not have a shower or tub within the unit, but a shower has been installed in the basement. Pat Fish. from Fire Prevention stated that the only issue is the inconvenience to the tenant, if tenant is willing to live with this, than there is no objection. BOARD ACTION: Motion made by Harold Knutson that a variance be granted with the condition that the unit be rented to only one adult, no children, and only the tenant in this unit be allowed to use the bath facilities for as long as Mr. Carmichael owns the building. Seconded by Sean Carey. THE VOTE: Yeas (5) Nays (0) Abstension (0) -------------------------------------------------------- 120-87-H 333 Atwater St. Alan W. Weinblatt ( 10 units) APPEARANCE: Gloria Weinblatt SUBJECT: Appellant is requesting a variance from St. Paul Legislative Code 34. 05 pertaining to Itern #9-Deadbolt locks, as per letter dated October 17, 1987. PROCEEDINGS: Ms. Weinblatt would like a variance from requirement an deadbolts, the building has security locks on the front and rear doors. Each unit has dead bolts-5/8 inch. The cost would be $350.00 to change the dead bolts. Pat Fish, from Fire Prevention stated that the ones that have the 5/8 inch be replaced, probably 3 or 4. BOARD ACTION: Motion made by David Schultz to grant variance pertaining to present deadbolts, with the condition that when the 4 . • �`�_��3 de dbolts need replaceme t they are replaced with the one ( 1 ) in h projection. Seconded by Glenn Gausman. TH VOTE : Yeas (5) Na s (0} Abstension (0) --------------------- ------------------------------------ 10' -87-H 2108 Univer ity Ave. Rihm Motor Co (Commerica Bldg. John Rihm AP EARANCE : John Rihm SU JECT: This case has bee iaid over from the December Sth, 1y87 me ting. Appellant is equesting a variance from St. Paul Le istative Code pertain ng to Item #4-Provide automatic fire ex inguishing system in sp ay booth, from a letter dated October 1 , 1987 because it eco omically not feasible, nor pratical be ause of the building la out. PR CEEDING5: Appellant w uld like a variance from Fire Code pe taining to having to install Automatic Fire Extinguisher Sy tem in Spray room. Ther is only one painter at a time working in the spray room and oper ted only as a convenience. Rihm Motor Co. deals with trucks, 1 cated in the Midway area covering one sq are block. The buildi g is separated from any other business by the streets that surro nd it. The amount of spray painting th t is being done is s minimal , that it would not pay to i stalll the sprinkler sys em. The co$t factor is about $ 7,000.00. The buildi g is solid concrete blocks. The � v ntilation in the build'ng is calied the make-up air system. T is system is turned on before the spraying starts, stays on d ring spraying and then 1 ft on after the painting is completed. S erry Webb. from Fire P evention stated that the building has r oms for spraying, rathe than booths. The contention of Fire P evention Code is that all spray finishing areas are required to h ve Automatic Fire Extin uishers 5ystems, either Sprinklers or D y Chemicai . Ms. Webb tated that the Dry Chemical systems is 1 ss costly. The cost on the smail rooms would be about $ , 000. 00, in this case t ree sytems would be required. These r oms are ground level . M . Ostrum, MPH, CSP, Cons ltant spoke briefiy on his observation f om his inspection. The spraying area has a ventilation system with a volume of 60,000 cfm which exhausts the vapors to the o tside of the building. 7he ventilation system is designed to p event accumulation of flammable vapors and to keep the vapors b low the lower explosive limits . Based on the conclusion of Mr. O trums observation, the ventilation system has such a volume t at the accumlation af vapors would not occur. The cost of i stallation is excessive when compared to the amount of work b ing done. 5 Ms. Webb, from Fire Prevention stated that the ventilation must be vented directly to the outside. BOARD AC7ION: Motion made by Glenn Gausman to deny the variance, pertaining to Providing automatic fire extinguishing system in spray booths , instead giving the appellant an extension of 6 months to install automatic fire extinguisher; and 90 days for installation of venting system. Seconded by David Schultz. THE VOTE: Yeas (5) Nays (0) Abstension t0) --------------------------------------------------------- 122-87-H 615 Drake 5t. Thomas Finn Company (Commercial Bldg. ) J. James Waish SUBJECT: Appeliant is requesting a variance from Fire Code compliance regarding outdoor above ground fuel tanks-restrictions on type of fuel that can be burned, because this is unreasonable, as per letter dated Novernber 24, 1987. This case to be laid over to the February meeting. � -------------------------------------------- 121-87-H 1901 East Maryland Ave. Roger 8 Vicky Woitas (3 units) APPEARANCE: Vicky Woitas 5UBJECT: Appellant is requesting a variance from St. Paui Legislative Code 34. 14, pertaining to Item #3-Provide Escape window for interior sleeping room, as per letter dated October 13, 1987, becuase it would create a financial hardship. PROCEEDINGS: Pat Fish, from Fire Prevention stated that these are interior sleeping rooms and are required to have light and ventiiation as well as escape windows. Ron Glassman suggested that maybe rooms should be switched around. (Living room be made into a bedroom and bedroom be made into the livingroom. ) BOARD ACTION: Motion made by David 5chultz to deny the request for a variance from St. Paul Legislative Code pertaining to Provide escape window for interior sleeping room. Seconded by Harold Knutson. THE VOTE: Yeas (5) Nays (0) Abstension (0) -------------------------------------------------------- 6 . r �V� �� 115 87-H 550 Summit A e. Mary Gallivan (6 units) APP ARANCE: Mary Gallivan SUB ECT: Appellant is requ sting a variance on Item ##3-Instali Doo Closures-because of the Historic Vatue and size of the building. PRO EEDINGS: Ms. Gallivan stated that this being a smaller building and of Historica Value that door closures are not nec ssary. Pat Fish, from Fire Prevent on stated that this a requirement and th se doors enter a common hallway. These door closures are a mat er of 1 i fe safety. Se n Carey suggested that the appellant write to the National Hi torical Preservation Soc 'ety. and maybe they could advise the ap ellant as to where t e spring loaded hinges could be pu chased. BO RD ACTION: Motion made y Harold Knutson to deny the request fo a variance pertaining to having to install door closures, in tead giving the appell nt an extension of 90 days to locate th proper door closures. Seconded by Sean Carey. TH VOTE: Yeas (5) Nays (0) Abstension (0) ---------------------- ---------------------------------- 111-87-H 1076 Agate St. Howard & Janice Rae Arcand (23 units AP EARANCE: Janice Rae Arca d 5U JECT: Appellant is r questing a variance from St. Paul �e islative Code 34. 09, pertaining to having to install deadbolt lo ks. as per letter dated ctober 28, 1987. PR CEEDINGS: The building is a security building, presently the de d bolts are in good sha e. Pe Fish, from Fire Prevention stated that the dead bolts are 1/2 in h, the doors are metal rames. BO RD ACTION: Motion made by Glenn Gausman to grant a variance pe taining to the deadbolts with the condition that when these ne d replacement that th locks be replaced with one ( 1 ) inch pr jection, this variance is granted for as )ong as it remains a se urity building and Ms. Arcand owns the building. Seconded by Da id Schultz. TH VOTE: Yeas (5) Nay (0) Abstension (0) 7 117-87-H 1040 Agate Street Howard 8 Janice Rae Arcand (23 units) APPEARANCE : Janice Rae Arcand SUBJECT: Appellant is requesting a variance from 5t. Paul Legislative Code 34. 09, pertaining to having to install deadbolt locks, as per letter dated October 28, 1987. PROCEEDINGS: The building is security ]ocked, metal frames on all the doors. BOARD ACTION: Motion made by Gienn Gausman to grant a variance per-taining to the deadbolts, with the condition that when these need replacement, that the locks be replaced with one ( 1 ) inch projection, this variance is granted for as long as the buitding remains a security building and Ms. Arcand owns the building. ------------------------------------------------------- 59-87-H 189-1891/2-191 E 8th St. Gayle E. Stangeland (21 units} APPEARANCE: NONE SUBJECT: Appellant is requesting a variance from the St. Paul Legislative Code 34. 14 (Provide escape windows from sleeping rooms #4 and 20. ) from a letter dated December 15, 1987, becuase this buitding is a historical buildi�g. BOARD ACTION: Motion made by David Schultz to deny the request for a variance from St. Paul Legislative Code 34. 14, pertaining to having to (Provide escape windows from sleeping rooms #4 and 20. ) Secanded by Sean Carey. THE VOTE: Yeas (5) Nays (0) Abstension (0) ------------------------------------------------------ Meeting adjourned at 4: 10 p.m. 8