The URL can be used to link to this page

89-2110 P A-.iE - �INANCE RK t . CANARV - D,£'PARTMENT GITY OF SA NT PAUL COUIICII BI.UE -MAVOR File �0. ��y(/� � Ordin /`CG �Ordinance N 0. �` ?d� . � r �� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning e�aps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, 462.357 and § 64.400 of the Legislative code, Michael D. Killa duly titioned to rezone 2047 Grand Avenue located on the north side of Grand Avenu between Cleveland and Prior Avenues, from RM-2 to B-2C for the purpose of con rting part of the existing structure for general office use, the petition hav' g been certified by the Planning Division on March 2, 1989 as having been onsented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the area of the propert to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous roperty within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on April 2 , 1389 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning etition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submi ted its recommendation to the Plannir►g Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEBEAS, The Planning Commission conside ed the rezoning petition at its meeting held on May 26, 1989 and reco�me ded that the City Council deny the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing befo e the City Council on said rezoning petition was duly published in the offic'al newspaper of the City on June 17, 1989 and notices were duly mailed to eac owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly withi 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and COUNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Dimond �� In Favor Goswitz Rettmao Scheibel Against By Sonnen Wilson Form App ove by City Attorn Adopted by Council: Date CertiEied Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Appro d Mayor for Submission to Council � By BY WHITE - CITY CLERK PIAI�K -�INANCE GITY OF S INT PALTL Council CANARV -DQPARTMENT File NO. � ,�/� BLUE -MAVOR • • Or Zn nce Ordinance N 0. �,,�� 1 Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, A public hearing before the Cit Council, having been conducted on July 3, 1989 wherein all interested pers ns were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendat ons concerning the petition; now, therefore, THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Sectio 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet No. 17, as incorporated by reference in Secti n 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as a�ended, is h reby further amended as follows: That property located on the north side of Grand Avenue between Cleveland and Prior Avenues, being more particularly described as Lot 2$, Block 2, Rosedale Park Additio be and is hereby rezoned fro� RM-2 to B-2C. Sectio 2. This ordinance shall take effect d be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passa�e, approval an publication. COUNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Dimond �� In Favor Goswitz Rettman .� s�be;t�l Against By Sonnen Wilson Adopted by Council: Date D�� Form Ap ro d by City Attorne Certified Pas Counci re BY , By 1 9 Approved Ma r a �C � ' Approve y Mayor for Submission to Council �. sy By pUBtl�D D t C � � 19�9 . � ^ � L�� /J��i�' � , -c ► ' � /�� (J � �//� �PARTMENT/OFF�CEIOOUNqI �ATE INITIATED ` PED/PI,ANN�NG 11/l�s� REEN SHEET No. �� /`77e� OONTACT PER80N 6 PHONE INITIAU DATE INITIAUDATE Charl es L. McGu i re - 3364 � �TMENT DIRECTOR �CITY COUNdL �� C ATTORNEY �CITY CLERK MUST 8E ON COUNdL A(�ENDA BY(DAT� ROU71N0 ET DIRECTOR �FIN.A IM�T.SERVI�S DIR. As soon as possible. [] YOR(ORAS8ISTANT) � TOTAL#�OF SIGNATURE PAQES 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATI N8 FOR SIONATUR� ACT10N REQUE8TED: Approve/adopt ordinance amending the Zoning ode. RECOMMENDATIONB:MP��W o►�.iea(Fry OOUNCIL COM SEARCM REPORT OPTIONAL _PLANNIN(i COAAN118810N _pVIL SERVICE COMMI3810N �� PNONE NO. _pB COMMITTEE _ _8TAFF _ COMMENTS: _�� The atta hed ordinance formalizes an action by ��E�, City Cou cil at a pu6lic hearing on June 17, 1989. wrru►nrxj�oe�M,�seue.o�oRluNrtv�wno,wn.e,wna,.wn.r.,wny�: . �� -Z.� �` � � �� ADVANTA(iE8 IF APPROVED: ��1�� r,,� ,�,� �i�I' I DISADVANT/KiE8 IF APPROVED: � � / iC� �f C�/�4�� t ��i6�(,�'� �� CEIVED e� � �� N� DIBADVMITI�EB IF NOT APPROVED: ��-� C�,�I`�� 7�C.. �:�uncU I�esearch Cente� � NOV 2 �1989 TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION = COST/REVENUE B!lDOETED(qRCLE ON� YE8 NO FUNDINO 80URCE ACTIVITY NUMBER flNANGAL INFORMATION:(EXPLAII� ��/ 'v :J" O �^ pWp ►-�r r�-+ � c+ ��t� z °' � � (D fL '�1.^+ C n � c-1� � � �--I � r �.! � � -< m -v � � � � � � n� � -s �n r � r � c O r Q, � � N �"yS � � t�h 1-' !, N � F� � � � O � � � N N 0 � � . fD n . ''d �, (�p c+ '� p' rr � � . � 3 rt N N "� � � � ' �l C c'> � o � c n z -��G p, � � � O m C c� cD o • � � m , � V �� ` � � � � � � N ' �� • ' ,„ � . -�� _ �,. �� #.��. � ,�.,, .x� ::..: -�•� -;,r�-3,�� C0. ��C)=�i�� .: , , � ��. � , �.'��' CO�Ur�iT�' �;M CEi�T. �ttCaRt�ED Qg� ;. � . _ . 1 � ; _ .. � u�c !U 9 �3 �� c�5 3 . . . i _ _ _ � � � �E� ��.�� ..�� - � r -�t ,�- ti ,c ,��,,�°� �J j � . . . . � . � �.� �._�� ,:.��,, ,. �.�� ., � �� .�< r„_ a t,� _ � t � � 4'r � RECORDED ON STATE OF MINNESOTA D E C 1 0 1990 County of Ramsey ss. CITY OF SAINT PAUL Albert Olson I, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ ... . . . . . .City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, Mi nssota, do herebp certify that I have compared the attached opy of Council File No. . .��,-?110... ... . . . . as adopted by the City Council..., December. l9.. . . . � , . �.� .Z989�. . . and approved by the Ma or. . ....... December. 21:. � .. . . �. ,..1989.. _ . with the original ther of on file in my o€fice. ♦ I further certif that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and e whole thereo€. � [i .�h Ta i` �.�a� C a a. C n,t p.. � w�Trr�L.� �, - - �� ,��.� �� ,.r.� c�,.y oL s.��n� .4��, Minnesota this . . . . , 3 th , . . , day of .., November. ...� . .A.D. 1990. . . . . . �✓.��r' � GSr...f:: :. .V:��.?�-. .... ... . .. City Clerk. �; ,; - .;':,��ctl ` 3 rn ��, � ...� _ r. �� . �o,� . �,({� t�,.-%�� .��. - , `;,°� ,,:h � j. �/�i,`yy�_.. �_� 9. ,��' I"/ � . � ,� -� , �j � �: ��.�- ��-�. :� F �� . , �,, ,,� . � '.`".^, 4 5... `� �� u 4 q � 4 \�a '�e t++�s� . .`�'.C3`.�J`" R� . P Ni:E ...:�iTa�NCE RK COl1I1C11 CANARY — iDE'PAR7MENT GITY O� SA NT PAUL File NO. L� BLV.1�, —MAVOR c • - � / Ordin /L�G c��Ordinance N 0. ` ��d� �_ �� Presented By . � Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the � zoning maps thereof. � WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, 462.357 and � 64.400 of the � Legislative code, Michael D. Killa duly p titioned to rezone 2047 Grand Avenue � located on the north side of Grand Avenue between Cleveland and Prior Avenues, � from RM-2 to B-2C for the purpose of conv rting part of the existing structure for general office use, the petition havi g been certified by the Planning Division on March 2, 1989 as having been onsented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least 67% of the wners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous p operty within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on April 26 1989 conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning p tition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submit ed its recommendation to the Planning Commission tha� the petition be ranted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission consider d the rezoning petition at its meeting held on May 26, 1989 and recommen ed that the City Council deny the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing befor the City Council on said rezoning petition was duly published in the offici 1 newspaper of the City on June 17, 1989 and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond ��s In Favor Goswitz Rettman Sc6eibel A gai n s t BY Sonnen Wilson Form App ove by City Attorn Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Appro d Mayor for Submission to Council By BY / WMITE ,�TY CLEfiK � PI�1K -..pIN'S1NCE G I TY O F S I NT PA U L Council ('j� ��yyy/ CANRRY -O�PARTMENT _/ BLUE� � j=�lyIAYOR File HO. d �� b ` . �� O'�GIiZ �•n�,� Ordinance N 0. l� 7d� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS, A public hearing before the Cit Council, having been conducted on July 3, 1989 wherein all interested pers ns were heard, and the Council having � considered all the facts and recommendat'ons concerning the petition; now, � therefore, � THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: � I/y Sectio 1. � That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet Ivo. 17, as incorporated by reference in Secti n 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is h reby further amended as follows: That property located on the north side of Grand Avenue between Cleveland and Prior Avenues, being more particularly described as Lot 2$, Block 2, Rosedale Park Additio be and is hereby rezoned from RM-2 to B-2C. Sectio 2. This ordinance shall take effect a d be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval an publication. COUNCIL MEMBERS Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Dimond ��g In Favor Goswitz Rettman .� Sc6eibel A gai ns t BY Sonnen Wilson � Adopted by Council• Date �� i � � Form Ap ro d by City Attorne B � Certified Pas Counci re Y BY Approved May r . Da e� �� , � Approve y Mayor for Submission to Council By BY Pti�t� D t C � �, 1��9 � +q�.q�r° ,� r .I �i I �'" . .,y K,� '4`` �` � `y.' . . . � , Q Cv �a; R �� }" ��gi#rr e�� "k�`r:. �� fi1� �y''t, i a : �.. � _ ` ,� ^ '° < , } }a ; �' " � t ,� �° �y'�- . ,� �1 r� �. _ ! � . �,� r� m�,.�� t� � ; � � � � -*� �.��, 4��+, G3�g�,. � , � �xc �.,P�S� 'st' 3 4� �:.r ' . = ,s' �� ?� ��M aa.�'a��''k� +-.o � ,` v'� a .;,1 n��+, m. � ;� � r�. ^`z�"x� , � TM� r b� � ' � �� > � � . � � ,u� � .* ��wq'��n4r�i"�c 3 � _ �s �� e� a-. i f� � `K�fa.�'� '+ 3 � ��: „� ` ; � c' ..F �� -'�`.b"k'� { r ��k,.'zv� a•�T+r�9 j>� > �h �, C N y r .`�bv � ' . '� "` ¢ z f � 5 '� � "f �.E �* q,y� ; �r � � f a_. i �,s.6 � `� � fi,�; 's ��' � �'� � t � c �1� k+•.` a, . i '� r A, � ��':,. �y . I � �* �y Y ,.K �. �' r �T9 r . � 5 � : � ". � _y��>� �u�f. � �i� �nar '' �� + �^ s�� .,i�.t ' $ � , a t� p ' � z t 14`' ',, 1 � `�, t 4` � �l �. �s:r � y; � '� r � � : �,�t , ; r x ��a u,� � ,� � z y,�� f:.� ��, . � '� .-r ..� R.�c 3'� 1 ..e� ��-�-'�'a.�' .u �a � ��r o �� rS"�.�'� � ',� � . . �'i h t«`�� '� "; �' P �r r'� " � � �, .F 3 2 ��;, '� .at.k aY'� *K: �' �. � t�. � o e .'- I� 4�"' �0++ � �� s�.rt Y' :y� � ' � .�,,,�� ,�,�"yy` e�� a a .. ^1 > bs . 7 4 � [�'df p� f x, � i`Zt�t plrr`' .!,�.T.k�7.a: k �r;��5„{ � ,, 3� . 3 � �'s-� . , A �. � . 4`f i�,�,� k r i t r. � � y r _ f s ,,� 2 . '+'�� . s 5 i`7i'�X.h �4 � , t i `. _ x=�.. 'ro p , r � �.! . '+�, � '^� : '#a s- �� . # .r 4 t ,� �, di., r�! r� � i �� .s1 � . !�� M . �ir �. x £ .,. ' � ? ��''� 'S��}�R w'S�'�� , ,�F ��' % .l�t:: r; � t, � f �A � ,� 4 V l �S t�nt� 4.; r �t � Y" °x �`�,t e s#Y �` 7�.� �> }�` ? ��`G��'�� l ¢yl�r f'. ^" ...P� �''` v�»: e � �'��§ i}� }{ , � �. � �� rr � p: 7�> r +�2'.�3 �e�` t 4'��'rf � .� -{i.':sz,�"+� . r 7.. va �7 t*ie � rt t��P� �:� ��f�:x l �. F h.�� :s �, .� ��'� '':t "� v� i�w >.�� k... ,; f . -�� '�f' _�- �. � �,al �.4 {h {;;��`e<1'� ° �., 4 t 1 :, . . , 'k t � k, _�x{� �c��y . ix_ � r . � � a .'. {�'Y � ¢._ +,.a �k ,� 6 y`�� - b.�� a_.6 �. � � 7 j, c y � _ �� 3 +�+ ,y�� y 7` � ., f k �c , � i ' �`w"t + �i� '�T � 4�2 y � �.�sY y, .._ '� ��t � - � n,i .�? r ��. a � i.� � � g,'4 ��-�� k�fk+P[ 5 ��'� �.a't$' �' - '' *`�: t i '�? �.� i ,�` ��-:. � f � ' i�'z�^�y �P � a 4 ,�> r c �,,,�t"5 .� a : i ua �'�� a =�'' -s a r *.�s ti ,� � � � }t Kr y a s 4 � s a a � ' i� '� �,9� 3 i7 �'f "`'fi``'R l�� tSvr; v v 5° � , � � C ' �''{ fi t ' t � S ."�. ,z� 339. 'C�a�, ,� �,� . y x f a' y ,l" say `a z:.,r�, r � �tY• Y#MR r � ! i �a '� $�t„ ` A "`�aY t .�g,r A �d'w, T. 'Y' �4J �' . c"� 4 i f ° �^Y �. kf �,ra, �� y _ `�`,�`��.P��a 2�rF�L� r �t4.c � � + �, �`1 ` �' ,, .�, >Y�f� t � 3 � , .� y ' J � >� '4r�3 i Y y,d� Y �A �} .�". � :._ 7 '� _, �a � � Y, i.� _t ,� t - �! �3 �,;�� s �;��'�� °�C �`t t ��'� �� '- Ir A:� d ��k -zV� �t'�� ; J J ,�yi�'� ° �.., � �x �, {c r.� x: , �. z ��',�e, 4 r � - , -� 'r'� � 1� .e: 3� '�i� ��s3 r �"�• - l - ' � . �' � h`z 4#-� `� }� � 6 t�� `t � 3Y * �.�.s� 'aK i � F�_' �' � .�.�..� �,c. � ��:�,�n }3 � /3� �"-i G_�'Y�� k�x�, y,y c ,{.�.. � � a. :'��r y � -Y � `t,?� �, .: r fi r °k x �`'.� `�`'� . 'r.cY��e' �.�,�, `��'i �.�' � :>� - ! �� ` a� '�y� „_ e�,�f �"lY, � �z� : , ?. �,�"�: H � ^ � 'S t r��e g f ar . a}lr !. � .. �• � �� 5, v �1 �� >�vrc �� ?. � � � ti�. F✓ �.,i �.� ,9� �1 3�� * t { � i� -� i- t j �:. 4� s +�� ' q.G'� d � x . �t � t t i ��' h .}�� '�"1 � 5 k ± 4 wC� c f s '" �b �� . �• ,\ ( �3 Y �5 � � ,ny. *y� "_ ,r' A � �� „T�� r �• ,{,�z�K 4 s.:� i o �� ' � �r�f 4 * �7,a� . 'i�q � ,� h�� ir d r rre� s�� .c - � k � y ; s : � �.r y � � . �t`K .` h ' S��r� e 3 � : �3 4 ' � �! �y �i � ��l'9w a „ 3 i �"u�Y fi s ��k't � t �� 4�N 4. q[ �� i ` 7 �'�.gL�}�'.�"; ��'�' 2 Y�.J. .� .Y�' T y :: � X,�i. i u._� �-tF�, $ �.1' .+xa�� ,`J � $$: � �r ��F r 9� L 1��w �� t y 3..,yc zi rn��:. i � _ 5.._y 3 * r t �_ � ,� �� '"� ,_�, �x.�'' g� �} � t : ,�.o- •�`"f { � ,� �`� �` - r � '"„Y�i " t : fi - -r S " }�i ��"'�'� �yaa*�,- e ,. � � A� x. j v }�� ,'�v� ?Jr � i'�`� �� f ''1" 7'r1'i '�' JCF �: 4: � r c� t : i ." `'' t .3 '?� � r �:. .� M yF � .ti�,t L,�, �, r�_ ..�f � .... ti� S � y . 3 j;� '4 - � t� �yd ntY r�. 4[ ��*y°.f» i - g �# r y � ;� ,r� �r:i Sa}.,; 'F��, �, ��. Y. •.- .a,'� a;" a.,^w k' : �,ha �. i , . c '�?�A�}. �E4{"C�z : M , x e�� '� 9" � �;,� � r !� k .d a„ kf^�' a*, Y x s. ,�i: f�x � �� M�. re s i a rt� � {�,v�x�1� y. } ,,.,�, i�� 'E, � _➢� �' e: '�'"� ��. k � 1 w+y ^� _. �II .�� . ��' . � ,+n�.. � � �, p x t .-,+sY a -� t�F 5' r_ � � '�, w�{$ C �'.�4� C�� a ��` � [ F• .-a t '� � �y,.� � x •f � s � �x � �� rs f5 �r �a � � � rr�B v ��+ .g � ,g � Y"^ �� n . '+F 1 �{�� Ys �� .r � C. p z �.y�ts. fi� � � z� �, Su ,� � � �� ,�� Ck ... � �� .� � M1 "e y �� p x �; ...y > � n,� .�� ` y� '"4 �'4� �" � w .� uk � =x� �. {'�^,�1.J � i'd.`„�f �t� x �� .�;.: J,'-� +n /:�,'C�„! h i,v'k5 r �. �h"a s ;� r .. T,r .Y z'"�� a'�"�;,I �s� �� r "� �� ,�` :W 3 f 1 �'4 �,r'� � �i �ra �a ''*%� �v �6 .� y �F4.� r a . '^'� 'a{"" #.�3�. '� S F; Rs,�4. n« y �;` '� ,g 4 '� �.- �t }��5,a 4 #� ��"^�'R'-� ' d z ��^:-.� �� '� a'�+^� �� C "" l y� � "i�' ^«: Z �"' a�,�' �• �� ,�'° �k�7 ` -'�";�'X`�p �� -' � -� �� . x� t,� f 2 1 -' k �n..�c ti,'�-�c w�tt { �:ti� t �'�_- v 4 ''r� z ;;s f w�'".�.n�, ,ti-�� r 4 �x. ��t�'� Lz A�l�.`� � aa :- !r �^ h +��'.. �,�;X}j c� ��,..r+'o �iY}��.��y.a,7i � �K t �'�... �� :� e i � .� �41 a - '�J4� ��`/x n ? �^* h�' y`-r�v.,i rt� �' l.� }� £,, .� � � ty.'f�°b .a i t��'-�+.t �s� j ,� �'4 `�4�9. 4 lf t' D t �'�-F ' Y j � � 0. �' ..�� S �`�'. �t�a s. �.,+.� fk . � + }, '7 �y,, a(��'��. u� -} _. �1� r ��'^'�,g � { ff�} i 'x� �`A a.� ' �'�-+r.. ,r �' � �ti r�,(�7 � � } � ao-`k � x w ,.,'r � 5 ��r� �� 'j ...'� 3 .° �^"3 ��+ti �`r k � ; a °N'� ; tT; � a. ,� l � Ir> S F3 +t 1 n -" i14. ,4.,: 4 t .- f�i^`�'� " �..t ;� �a k � ''� .x b}`, s ,•.,3 t � :+ k �: ,�' < ` y F ` k i t k. ��4 ��. � et : < S ,�-Y k�:� ,+' �i� : .,t � �.j s3a ._�:.� r � n �^�A�p � . k t r x,t,,. �� s 1 q � �: ,� r a : A; .��t�� x t4 `�,;�� :: ara� � � . y �4,,��,,y �4�k�.,+7E 4 � .�' '�-&�" a., S k �as '°"�.t £ :,d'$y�q'� "�' X,� ;,f .ty � �x �� r�,w:; t S ' _ t t.�r �'` i�' .'' .y ' 1 �' g�� p� 4 F ��:? ��. }'i �� ?'��Y� Ys�. � �. 6� � � ��,�W e. t t �. � � �.� �ti 'k T *��ti-;? w i f 4��.- � }r� .� � >i,J . r '[iK �_,+' J q�' -�,�.' ��t.sk t� ` ' � ��l'�.- x.?"'" -. 1 ��. -s t .��a�{ Mir� �f�r, y� 1 � .. � g �' ,� r - �f�� i�� . ��t" a �._ � . 4 a t ° ,� �k § 'f ts 4 �, �. 4 . T�k f ; t ��d <� t A;. �i ;{ �'�is'`�'�,�': �, ��.'�`9 t 4�` '�{y ��t� �� •g,yi�1 a � � � � ��,��°""4� r: c. i t�` t�' ,r .^� :/ � - � �� ,�� _ ' f{ T ' .Y y � * k. y �.A R �' � '�� `t� Y .r ,:� {�1�T �a�,:, r�x �,�� ta ��,�� 4 � . .r '�nx� `� `F xk k ti, � ti fi�c +,$ f j `r��, � �`� � ° �x�� s 4,:; J ° .�t�� a'�� 'r ��,af�} ,'^� . "` � '.�+� ��,,�"'� '. xa�� i��i r a,�. V r, A c♦ s r�>�#'�y � �� d ��'f# %+' �r� x �'�'�� rl 7Tl.3.�+t �. 'Y ,i 'c. ;�.jct,.i�' � F`f T> � ��: �'�� .� � .Z ��x� �'� e_� t��.a ,� ��y t,�� y s � �,�w.s.�i'�t 3 ° � �° �;�n� i ,. "-�' � .yk ,�M� t�:_ � T w�Q -a�� ` �';` ^�^f (:a"�. r `� � +�� y� i r. � . ��+�an,� _ n ��.i x .� � .i, ��RLt �{h a. � 1 ry} �. &� r� �a t r a ��.�� 4 } s _. J .'� n kl A ? ;� '6' . l : ! -4 � � �Ti � � � ��_ � A� °i�„ * �.'x.`,��exf � r ft {?';an�i� a�,u t� y�� '�� '��4 %�*"` �� 4 4.:s' X£wt ��n l. r rs a,4�M � 1,,:�,`lP X�� ttr� £� _. �ai ,�" t_..'; �w .�n •�3 .e � �.a,� �o- z.��. '' ��`y�"'- � �'.r ��.��,�.�?� ��.�,��.,#, � � '�4;"�� f,� -�:' � F ��Y�� 1R �:Y��,@'�9 ' A'h� �J �,°�i��3 � ��YF� �vP �y,�'£! �."y'�t X '��.S ? 4 r,M r��, ,.y��?1',t.�] k�t Y .� ,�f �� - � C �� { i �F Y �x � :.� `aQrJ e � �, 1�"y; -� ?r� � a. �` t�� 7 ? �xr�'1� �t. � It �:�l� i +` r '� �}rx; x � � �'7,��4� t �,��g,r'�� i �,� , "�� t�, s��,''>��#;�°s�k�� '' � v , . x c, . �, f F A �i �7 � ,�7 S�, S 1 t � r� { }� r`��`�'� 4 Q G o s x `�t z .� ' � ti' j� � ,� s� s, �s ;y. '�` '�� '.y � �� k ��. r r .�y . w � � a :�, , t f �.,_; .i ,� x .,� � i ��S �qF .� ¢ a? '��7 �� 3 �� # r s � � �#' i �'" r � ; s � m 1 P x �'� 3sa. R � b � � t �� "��' Y , r� ^S��,k v l � rt �rP rr' j �, �. A �. Sl�r� � �r � .� 4F # �� a� i � � ' � = �'" r :h* �ay+.}.a � y, - a rr.v� n r �'� e y,�� ` :,� �'� '��,��i� � � ., �. �`� t �� a �`��_ _ � ,�d ,+& � -�'� F ,'� . a F 'r3 �'�S., 6� ��1 S �� r .. ,��. e f �"�{ � k �,,t ♦ � ��K ( ; r ��w �` ' � s y , , '.. �tv_.,t°��`�tt�'.�,. '��",t ' "'k {w, s�' k 'f e "�.� � �'1 �: a �� f '�'`�X �' :��, ""i a�, � � �" $SO s a d. .tt�a��' ., �l+, y.:rE .�{rY� ��' .r ,� i� � �k f,�y `°` 1 3SF x � ` �' t � � -� �.`Y; � � � g � � r, b v��.� , "}' a i" � rl�C�i� �'s��? "�: ' 3 t �s ��f��v t t z � S *; +r �J ,J"�.: p '� �1 � r� � �v S � '� �, �, k ��. 1 v ��x �; ' ; ��,> ,4 � ,�. �_.� : r � �� -� a �� t� q�.�a7 rF '��f� w° W` Zs��"�i� rft n Y �✓ ;1 � �. � A r F.� .f: � r r +' � t4! 7 ; t r �,i n r �. «". 'ix ,y� �e. . ✓ M1 e .��v ...x � .,,� ��k+. � -> � � +g� . t #"> t�'��.�,w,�' �ixi r 7 .t�` .�,�., a','�r n�jr: 1 s. �,• J^r,�r h . a ,. Va�,� ! . t RY �. n�� k�'�� - � � � a � �s�.: > �: . d« � ' 4�3,-:� i ` -c �."t � 5 '+r , -�'r r �� : ,,,,� �'a f ,� :fi t� `fr-� d �F. , xz� j �� iti F .M��s rF�x,� � + �" �Rt �, 'y.,,{ ''i, + � s , _ � .. x< s � 1, F 'e� {«.� y s�: 3 a s F .a a?�yc e e �" � ; } {.$ y y��1eG � � r� � y � �,� ��g� k� f � 4. F i-�� ; '�� %'S,. ��i � �� , t ` a �:�� a � �3��'y'e��.'�k`' :.�q �., �..g�i � �6 ,S {�� 5.��' 6�� .° �� # ��"b��c� � �y L "* Z �� .��: �' 3Fw 'S° �. t�,� '�' � Y ".��;.,! �. � ��fl T � w. � { . ( s{"�4'�r�.;t �,..�,: ., r�, � ,;..�,. . � .:�:�1 �r'� :.�." `.� �`��..�� . x•`c � - h ,� �� :. 3�t�.} ,�u�,� x e?�t , . . + j a:x . ; ;��t� `�,� 8.s�.k�ct r : *�`� q � � t r t��tfit ..; � 'q�, �C,�.ty�� t�4;i�" L .:� t i� ryA y ;� E �, �:�.� y j��_ ��p.;*�f�,�`¢�,�,"�,'`�-i, �t�,i ., � *. > z t �9 + + ,a t � ,i: '�4`'.. i ;k i : r a�. �,, � Tf'e a t�`ra-��„h^�b�Td r¢ . �*"• �� '{� �� rt,� .�.�5'ytaf�� w � � �� .� � t i rs_ '��'., �`�r�'�"Er�zi �+� �„�1'��l ,. 1 ;�s i H, � ; ) � �a`.� a �f c �- �� E ?�i �� 4 �' '�%� vti� k a i k k P %4 . ,.� r N 3a ; � � '�" t t a& ,�`�"�`o x�t`` u�+�#ry n : � . - . � . �" d c ��.�- s . 31. �ad .r "+, Ac ,� 3 .�r .� f t;�tn�' � . �.. 1 u 3 $4 � ' 1 €# } H � .�'" c'� ,�' �'h�� n�� a 4wh b Y � { i � f � ; s. t ' l N i z ro * �� ,,�.W�; e ,� t }`�� :e ��' � n �� r �. i � . �f,� �� . � g �� -�'�rt §�,: S' � _ i9 ., i ��r Y:,,_t� � x �.� fi �' `� 4�'L° i'�r,��r+��.;9 + � . �: { f4F . C� i r 3` p +$,3 M1 q- M > fr S �7' r� ,y�. � ,5,t ; . ♦ s t�r,+I P... � t°".$�y a : f+' ,�� " 4 a i� a , �r4.-}+ x �r f �i'� I"t?�}a� �; ��.��` 'l:�- r q .�. t . ; � � �yF��a � � � �, b�,. ��k�� r �+ � +,�y 5 M1 �i (��'r�"�F�� {,}t(✓k °h�T '�.� i>'J� �"�.� t � � t • , �,,�� 1 ��Jh' 1 �`�'.tY`� '$Lt e,�s"'"�'�i��.e.� 9 � .',, x � ax . �+'t '�s .... �7��r � � y, r s�� :�� s t,;�Y 5 `Yz: f 'N§� �Y{ �t� X ?�' fiy x r -Ja �^.�.-� 'l' ��` ��y 5 � P'v4�'� #s., �{y �,�_�X r .�,5�y� p ,q r t .��k,}r j i2�,�r�' �; �. ,y .s'�p�,3},�" t 7 � n i�.»S 1 A yy,_"+,�, G t�g.., p v T""�� ,,� �-,�"§'�''�a."'a.:. �s�,� `si �t}qsi�'P�i�� ,�R?�.�y� �"i a�;. t`� a �,?'F`�u ; } t �i� �'�� 4-s$'w�„f.r �" 'Y+ {s1�'�C "'i" �i� Y 'di � ;� s4 � S x T.:,�' .. . x ��,. � � "'T�" fi Y�4:��.'� �`�' $A,�,pC �y• �� r i f'�'['t �.., 'F x�7 ° � F t '�F's. 'r�t � 1t .>1 & j� y q .� ti,„� ��ul .� � � t .,A �y� fik'�� j� ��4� i'�v...k ��.y�+x;'�.9t�y '� c a 3� '�. at 7x x, r ��'i�` 'ry��fS` t � �,�� .�'t3'��l l��il }%3,1t%tiq�.`+��'}. s .i �x�'�.��i�� . z"t��.� � ��".'`.•.a. sx x t �� it " r, as,�°.+�i.�._.,c _�..:�T6.a,r�xs:�_�'"f.:c��Jc`�&iF"S,e"� 1��. ;F.». F` �,�-S�.�c� ��.�..�,_i .s,�,x. .,. ,x,e. z,'�i.� #*�,��x"�'�«r�� xz�.e��kd.'i_ '�� , u �,e�._ , _--s ,.tr ,�, ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL �'a� �� PUB�IC H ARING NOTICE __.. 0 N I N� RfCEIVED �uN 211989 CITY CLERK T0: Property owners within 350' ; FIL E N 0. 10444 Representati ves of P1 anni ng Di tri ct 14 PAGE PURPOSE To consider petition to rezone the property from RM-2 to 6-2C to p rmit use of a portion of the structure as an office. LOCATION 2047 Grand Av nue PETITIONER P•1ICHAEL KILLA HEARING Thursday, �ui 6, 1989 9:0o A.r�. - Citv Council hambers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House QUESTIONS zoning Contact Chuck Mcauire, 228-3364 Cot�tact the Z ning SecCion of the Planning and Economic Development D partment, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Str et, St. Paul, Minnesoia 55102 Legal Descri tion: On file Notice sent 6/20/89 NO?�CE OF PI�BL �'�EAftIN6i i A Pet�tio�D,h+txin$been filed requesting at the 2bning prciinance of the City of St.Paui be amended so as to rezone fro RM-2 to B-2C,p;:ppe�tY deseribed as � ' L°t�8�Block Z,Rosedale Park Addition. is properEy'is Tocated'at 2047 Gratid Av.e.�ue.The Council of the`City of St.Paul as`fixe+d tlie` h da of Jul ,39�-�at 9�A.M.in t$e Council Chambers on the 3 floor of City a ,an �a sa i ; and piace, the''Council will hear all persons ai�d all ob�ections aa�d� recommendatio3�s relative to the propoaed endment. Dated June 12, 1989. ' ALBER.T B. OI.SON;City Cierk _ (June 17, 1 9) . /J/ / �� / ✓ 4�y C i T* O' �i CITY OF SAINT PAUL a u��iiuu� ro DEPARTME T OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT vo �� ho' DIVISION OF PLANNING 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 iss• 612-228-3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR June 15, 1989 R�CEIVED �u�u 2 01989 Albert Olson, City Clerk ClTY CLE�t�C Room 386, City Hall Saint Paul, MN 55102 RE: Zoning File #10444 - Michael D. illa City Council Hearing: July 6, 1 89 PURPOSE: A Rezoning from RM-2 to B-2 for property located at 2047 Grand Avenue to permit use of one-half of t e two-family dwelling as an office. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: eny ZONING COMMITTEE RECOI�Il�IENDATION: App ove STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve SUPPORT: District 14 sent letter of onditional support. One letter received. OPPOSITION: One letter received. Dear Sir: On April 6, 1989, the Zoning Committe of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on this rezoning. The petiti ner testified. At the close of the public hearing, the Committee voted 3 to 2 to approve the rezoning based on staff findings. On May 26, 1989, the Planning Commiss'on reversed the Zoning Committee's recommendation and voted to deny the ezoning on a vote of 12 to 1. This rezoning is scheduled to be hea by the City Council on July 6, 1989. Please notify me by July 3, 1989, if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing. Sincerely, �� ' /� � � / ----_� �%�,,�,,/ ;, ,,/-��'� � � � Peggy A. Reichert Deputy Director for Planning PAR:rm Attachments city of saint paul pianning commission resolut file number 89-46 �.J�tE] May 26, 1989 WHEREAS, Michael D. Killa, file #10444, h s petitioned to rezone 2047 Grand Avenue, situated on the north side between Clevel nd and Prior Avenue, from RM-2 to B-2C for the purpose of permitting the operation o a small business office in one portion of the building and allow the remainder to b used as residential property; and WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Plan ing Commission on April 6, 1989, held a public hearing at which all persons prese t were given an opportunity Lo be heard pursuant to said application in accordanc with the requirements of Section 64.400 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, Saint Paul Planning Commission, ased on the evidence presented to its Zoning Committee at the public hearing as substantially reflected in the minutes, made the following findings of fact: The rezoning requested constitutes an ext nsion of commercial use into an area that is residentially zoned and occupied and a such is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan for this portion of th city. The rezoning of the site to B2-C would pe it use of the entire property for future commercial uses and this is not in the be t interests of neighboring residential property. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Sa'nt Paul Planning Commission that the petition of Michael D. Killa to rezone pr perty at 2047 Grand Avenue, more particularly described as Lot 28, Block 2, Rosedale Park Addition, from a RM-2 zoning classification to a B-2C zoning cl ssification is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan for the City; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Saint Pa 1 Planning Commission does hereby recommend to the Couricil of the City of S int Paul that rezoning of the property located at 2047 Grand Avenue be rezoned f om RM-2 to B-2C in accordance with the petition for rezoning on file with the Sa nt Paul Planning Division be denied. moved by seconded by ZIEMAN in favor- against 1 MINtiTES OF THE ONING C0."L►�IITTEE CITY COUNCIL CHA.*iBERS, SAIh'T P UL, MI1vTlESOTA ON APRIL 6, 1989 PRESEtiT: Mmes. Hirte, Morton, Tracy a d Zieman; Messrs. Christenson, Levy and Repke of the Zoning Comm ttee; Mr. Segal, Assistant City Attorney; Ms. Lane of the Bu lding Inspection and Design Division; Mr. Harvey, Mr. rlcGuire and s. Murray of the Planning Division staff. ABSEI�'T: Mr. Neid. The meeting was chaired by Gladys Mort , Chairman. Michael D. Killa (#10444) : A Rezoning rom RM-2 to B-2C for property located at 2047 Grand Avenue to permit use of e-half of the two-family dwelling as an office. The applicant was present; there was n opposition present at the hearing. Mr. McGuire showed slides of the site d reviewed the staff report with a 'recommendation for approval. He said at District 14 sent a letter of conditional support, that the Grand Av ue Business Association sent a letter in support and that one letter in oppo ition was received from a Summit Avenue �neighbor. Bill McCrum, 1133 Palace Avenue, state that he is Michael Killa's partner in their general construction and archite tural firm specializing in residential remodeling. He said that their Grand enue neighbors hsve agreed to the rezoning pending a deed restriction to limit the amount of the. rear yard to be paved and that the remainder of the ba ard will be used for green space in order to maintain the residential char cter of the house. Ms. Zieman inquired about the rental its in the house. Mr. McCrum replied that there are three apartments and on office in the structure and described the configuration. Ms. Hirte asked about signage and mate ials which could be used for paving of the parking lot. Mr. McGuire outlined signage restrictions and zoning code requirements for the paving of parking lots. There being no further testimony, Ms. orton closed the public hearing. Committee discussion followed regardin the number of parking spaces needed. Mr. Repke moved to recommend approval f the Rezoning from RM-2 to B-2C based on staff report findings. Mr. Levy se onded the motion. The motion passed on a roll call vote f 3-2 (Zieman, Hirte) . Submitted by: Approved by: - � . � ' .�' �;; -�/� �; .� /�I��I�� ,_�!c_-t; ` ,_. ��, �' .. � > �- � � // ' Charles L. McGuire � Gladys Mor�On, Chairman �9- �� _:�:�. �� _ _ 2�_ . ,�� _ _;� '"'c�":�.: "�i F�k= � . April 5, 1989 �� : ;�; Zoning Committee of St. Paul Planning Commiseion 25 West Fourth Street St. Paul, &IN 55102 Dear Zoning Committee� M�, REi Zoning File lvo. 10�+44 � <,r � .� - - �:�: .�'` On April �F� 1989, the Board of Dir ctora of the ' Avenue .�usinesa Association voted in favor of the ezoning reques the name of Mike Killa. We approve the rezoning of his eai ting duplez f� -2 to �2C to permit the operation of a small bu iness office � _ ne unit of the building and allow the remainder t be used as re:, _ ential property . y :. . Sincerely, -,.:�: �� &Iimi Doran �� Executive Director �� __=_ . ��.�. ��_ .��":. � ;��.� - ��-�r+ �� „ . , � � 1 ; •� ,s3i',a . . . - -t .h, . . , � . � 5',K.M 1 +ra y?�` . �� :t�..++ I �.� � �-�lp� �'� �i .,,'�,n-Y � J - .::i�E�.-.�� . � . � . � . . . .>>,�:. i: � . . , �� :.:.:. .. .. . "'..."�.�?;f.y.,.... . . GYaritl AV�nue B � ASSOCIa 1422 Ashland Avenue • Saint Paui,M nnesda 55104 • (812j ��: �:� . �:_ 2056 summit �venue St, Paul, r� ,5105 April 3, 1Q�� Zoning Committee 25 iJest Fourth Street St. Paul, MI�T 551(�2 Dear Members of the Committee; We are writing to ,you to express ou onposition to rezoning the propert.y at 20lt7 Grand Avenue as re ested b,y the present owner� Michael Killa, It is our understan ing that r�zoning the property fx�m R1�I-2 to B-2C would ch e the propertv's designation from residential to commercial and s such, change its use from a dunlex to a business. As homeowners within 350 feet of th s property, we are very concerned about the colrmiercializati n of our neighborhood and the proliferation of businesses in primarily residential area. We believe that our neighborhood al eady has too many businesses within it and too much traffic, con estion, and parking problems as a result of these businesses. �Je realize th at the intent of B-2C oning is to retain the residential character of a p roperty while permi ting the operation of a business. However, the logical consequences o co�Yerting a proaerty from residential to business use are the creation of additional parking spaces and erection of signs, Zhes are both unsightiv and destructive to the residential character of the neighborhood. �ere is also the possibility that major modification would be made tc the prooerty as business needs change. In addition there is the uncertainty about how the property will be used and w at businesses wi.il be o�erated by future owners of the property. We are residents of a ciistinctive d historical neighbo�hood and we pa,y very high taxes i.n order to liv in this particular residential area. We oppose ari,y additional th ats to our neighborhood's residential character. It is our h pe that the Zoning Committee will take serious note of our concerns a d concur with our o�position to the proposed rezoning. Yours tYUly� � /��J%�%Klrl� Luanne P. La rents, Ph.D. and Dalla D. Laurents II �� .��.� �� a �� Distri 14 Communi Council Sert�ing the Macalester-Crroveland and Ra lph Heights neighborhoods of Saint Paul March 29, 1989 James Christensen, Chair St . Paul Planning Commisson 1100 City Hall Annex St . Paul, MN 55102 Dear Jim, This is to advise you of the District 14 Community Council' s support for re—zoning 2047 Gran from RM2 to B2C, providing that a deed restriction is placed o the propertq insuring that the property will meet RM2 rear yar parking restrictions as long as the property is zoned B2C. The community council supports he position of the neighbors that a business use is appropria e in this building . We are concerned, however, about the rovision in B2C that would allow parking in up to 90� of the rea yard of this property. It is our understanding that t e applicant is in the process of having such a restriction place upon his deed. Thank you for your consideratio of our position on this matter. Sincerely� _ �i� . l, � Ka hie Tarnowski Community Organizer , �.� �� ! �� 320 SOUTH GRIGGS STREET • SAINT PAUL, INNESOTA 55105 • PHONE 612 G98-7973 ZONING COMMITTE STAFF REPORT FILE #10444 1. APPLICANT: Michael D. Killa DATE OF HEARING: 4/06/89 2. CLASSIFICATION: Rezone from RM-2 to B- C 3. LOCATION: 2047 Grand Avenue (north sid between Cleveland and Prior Avenues) 4. PLANNING DISTRICT: Fourteen 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 28; Block 2, Ro edale Park Addition 6. PRESENT ZONING: RM-2 Multi-family ZON NG CODE REFERENCE: Section 64.400. 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT: DATE: 3/28/1989 BY: Charles L. McGuire A. PURPOSE: To rezone an existing duplex rom RM-2 to B-2C, to permit the operation of a small business office i one portion of the building and allow the remainder to be used as residential property. B. PARCEL SIZE: The property has 50 feet f frontage on Grand Avenue, and a depth of 160 feet. The area of the parcel is 8,000 square feet. C. EXISTING LAND USE: The site is curre ly occupied by a wood frame structure originally built as a duplex. A two � ar garage occupies a part of the rear yard. D. SURROUNDING LAND USE: North: Single family residences along Summit Avenue. The College of St. Thomas lies to the northwest. East: Properties to the east are gen rally developed with mixed density residential uses. South: Properties to the southeast ar mixed density residential. To the southwest, property is develop d with B-2 Commercial uses. West: A Seven-Eleven store occupies he next site to the west. E. ZONING HISTORY: Prior to 1975 the sit was zoned commercial, but occupied by a duplex residential use. F. �ISCUSSION: The rezoning site abuts o cupied B-2 property which has some adverse influence on this property. N wspaper collection boxes on the adjacent site abut the front yard area of the s te, and the convenience store use of the adjoining property is noisy. The owne believes that use of the side of the duplex closest to the B-2 property by low intensity office use will help buffer the tenant on the oppisite side of the building, and the residential area to the east. File #10444 Page Two Plans provided with the application ndicate that the total floor area of the structure which will be devoted to a commercial use will provide 362.75 square feet of space, enough for one small ffice. The property owner and neighbors have agreed to a deed restriction li iting the amount of the rear yard which will be paved. The paved area and th existing garage structure will provide sufficient off-street parking space or the uses proposed under the terms of Section 60.573. Required Conditions. for uses in B-2C zones. G. STAFF RECONIl�IENDATION: Although the roposed use of the site is an extension of commercial use into a residential ar a, such use relationships are not uncommon along Grand Avenue. The rezoning ca also be viewed as a logical expansion of an existing commercial area. The mi ed use character of the B-2C zone will provide reasonable buffering between the more intensive B-2 uses to the west. The provision of off-street parking roposed for the site is adequate, and the area neighbors most impacted by the roposal feel adequately protected provided the agreed to deed restrictions are place when the property is rezoned. The Staff recommends approval of the req ested rezoning to B-2C. LIST OF ATTACHMENTS (FILE #10444) Page Application for Rezoning 1 Application Support Materials 2-9 Site Plan 10 Floor Plan 11 Location Maps 12-13 Land Use Map 14 t t PETITION TO AMEND ZONIN6 CODE CITY OF SAINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY File # � a�� _ RECEIVED Application Fee $ � �5 0`�� JAN 3 ? 1989 Tentative Hearing Date y Number of Lots or Size of Parcel: ZONING TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL DATE /V��, / 19 8'8 c/o Zoning Office, 1100 City Hall Annex Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.210 of the St. P aul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357(5) of the Minnesota Statutes, ' ,¢ , the owner of all of the land proposed for rezoning, ereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: Street Address: d ,� � v Legal Description: � L from a Zoning District to a - C Zoning District for the purpose of S L u � . � Subscribed and sworn to By: , \ a�C.J. �'.�.��c, before this �yday of �� _ 19� T i t 1 e: �r,.j� `��I Ir_V_ t ��.�u _ •.�/y�J S3bIdX3 N ISSIWWO�AW P age � �� n � I� 1 N(1G`:J A 3S 11{b�tl 4 Notar f V ��C. r10S3NN��pi'1y/7d AtlYl �- • O�O .,v.�.uy..r....�.�.�...,�...,. 2/85 � l i�.:'�� N.. STOE B 3�1' �d 3S3M3H 1 - <;'� t � ' niu;.,:.v N1�9!iC-MINNE80TA 4 '%•�� ",t"� A.>;.i3F-+ COUNTY t ..,r,.:.' / � '' . MY[',pA�M�Cq.rrJ =Y�IPE�MAY 3 1990 �� /rYV��./�� . �-n9--�� CONSENT OF ADJOINING PR ERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchased or sold by Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowl dge that we have been furnished with the following: 1 . A copy of the Petition of � name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections �Q, S''7r�. through ��, S'7,S , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that we are aware of all of the ses permitted under a J� �, � District z�ning classification and we are aw re that any of these uses can be established upon City Council approval of th rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Petiticn of /r'�rc�l �c.�- � to a �- �� District. name of petitioner LOT BLOCK ADDITION RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE DATE �g' /� �% , � ` � 7 —�� .- [;l �.�, �' � � c� r�L� L r.i % �� 4V'!� - C�C..��—�-4—�—�.�� i�v /p.,��'� -�� — / / �q- 3t � ic,w-�-�co �r'v. No2�z � //li�< �� o�� 3 � A/Nt�' l � -- —�Q � � Z ese � e .a ' �� -a ' �� — � :'� ��- � � Ip Y k ��f � �<< � 3 �� rw �` . � �s— 88' ,t Ro�e o�,.,� oD� �s�,� �.� G� r 16 � �1 � ` � �d Petitions shall not be considered as officiall filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Off'ce. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written request within that time. _ , _---- - f ,:� -- - Id��' p ge 2 of � �� •� } � � �� C uJ�71fi S7��Fut�Tio�vs � �� • . ♦ •. COrISENT OF IIDJOINING ROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONIN6 Me, the undersigned, ov+ners of prope ty within 100 feet of the total contiguous 0escriptions of real estate o�med, purcha ed, or sold by Petitioner Nithin one year preceding the date of this petition, ackn ledge that we have been furnished with the folloMing: 1. A copy of the Petition of C� 1�"��` name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections �. �� through �� . ��7� , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and �knor+ledge that we are� aware of al l of t uses permi tted under a �M—Z Oistritt zoning classification and we are ware that any of these uses can e est aDlished upon City Council approval of he rezoning; and rre hereby consent to the resoning of the Froperty �escribed in the Petition of L to a C� Distritt. mm�e o petit oner LdT BLOqC ADDITION RECORD ONNER 6NATURE DATE � 2 � w�s � �� ' � � , . NINC� Petitions shall not be considered as offiti lly filed untij the lapse of 7 Norking days after a petition is received in the Zoning ffice. Any signator of any petition may withdraN his name therefrom by written requ st within that time. � � Z��IIV� F�LE ��=�- - � � 2 `P°`� �b _� � � February 2, 19�y Lisa F`rize St. Paul "Loniny Board 11U0 City Hall Annex 25 W. 4th 5t. St. �aul , Mn. 551U2 Uear Ms. E'rize, We would like to recind our iynatures on the petition regardiny the rezoniny of the �ro erty at 2047 Grand Ave. We were under the mistaken impressio that a site plan would give the neiyhbors some control over t e number of parking spaces in the rear of the building. We now understand that the site plan could be ammended, i.e. , the park ' ng could be ex�anded, without our approval as long as it isn ' t gainst the zoning code. There is yuite a larye yard in the rear of this buildinc� and we do not want to see it turned into a park ' ny lot. The current owner has yiven s assurances that he will limit the �arkinc� but that will not pre ent future owners from doiny what they want. What we, the nei hbors, are askiny for is that a restrictive covenant be attached o the property ' s deed, limiting the �arking spaces and providing or some yreen space in the rear of the buildiny. It is not our intention to � event Authentic Construction from operating out of this buildi y but we do want some input regarding the maintenance ot the roperty. We see this as a �ositive step for both the neiyhb rhood and the buildiny owner, since the Planniny Commission may consider such a covenant in its rezoning decision. 5incerely, Catherine� Ples� 2038 S mmit A e. C��.��'� Todd wadsworth '1U48 Summit Ave. , s� .__ G � Z�� _ . � � �,,� STATE OF MINNESOTA) : SS COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) L��l�i � �,�.�Uf� , being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition and consent, consisting of � pages; that affiant is inf ormed and believes that the parties described are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately before eac name, that affiant is infornied and .believes . that each of the parties described abcve s the a�mer of property which is Nithin 100 feet from any property oM►ned or purch sed by petitioner or sold by petitioner - within one (ij year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property described in the petition; that� xcept for none of the parties described above has rchased 'or s purc as n property from petitioner contiguous to the above descri _ property within o�e �1) year of the date of the petition; that this- caa�sent ras si ne� by-�each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct� signatures of each and all of the parties so described. �� P�D �f�< ress �o�o - � lS� e epho�e Nwnber Subscribed and sworn Lo before �e this a�.� day of ��, 19� ^ - Notary ub i "��? THtRESE A. STOELB � R ��F.�� NC7ARY PUDLIC.MINNEBOTA . �`��'� . . (�r;��.y� RAMSEY COUNTY MY CCMMISSICN FXPIRE3 A'TAY 3. 1990 R E CEI VED FEB 21 i989 � _ ��Nllrt+� Z N��J� �-�L�:� ._.�.- Appro�red as to tv�a - feb. 85 of� Planning Deptrt�ent , _ � ` �� ._ ... . . \ . CONSENT OF AOJOINING PR ERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of propert within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned, purchase , or sold by Petitioner Nithin one year p�eceding the date of this petition, acknow edge that we have been furnished with the folloaing: 1. A copy of the Petition of � ��`� name of petitioner 2. A copy of Sections 0. � � through �'j . S'7� , inclusive of the St. Paul Zoning Code; and acknowledge that Ne are aware of all of the uses permitted under a �M�2 District zoning classification and we are a are that any of these uses can be est ablished upon City Council approval of t e rezoning; and we hereby consent to the rtzoning of the Froperty described in the Petition of �L �- to a L� District. nart�e of petitioner LOT BLOCK AODITION RECORD OWNER GNATURE DATE . 2� 2 ��,� w�s� ��r -z� 2 � � . � 1 � �i�� Petitions shall not be considered as offic ally filed until tfie lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by written req est within that time. � � ZC�I�i' �� lDu�ui��. �e..�,�--- � �� 2 ., � - , ; . -- STATE OF MINNESOTA) : SS COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) �� •�'�4�"^�'` , being first dul sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition and consent, consisting of 3 pages; that affiant is informed and believes that the par ies described are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately before each na e, that affiant is informed and believes tnat each of the parties described above is t e owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned or purchased by petitioner or sold by petitioner within one (1 ) year preceding the date of thi petition which is contiguous to the propert�/ described in the petition; that exce t for none of the parties described above has purch sed or is purchasing property from petitioner contiguous to the above described roperty within one (1 ) year of the date of the petition; that this consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signa�ures are the true and c�rrec� signutures of each ard all of the parties so described. 2oq-� �;� � �r�� ,�o -�tSs �elephone Number Subscribed and swo before me thi s �L�day of , 19� � �� otary Public .�r,h��+.^.� .�,�; n,.a;�tnt�nr,nh� - ��,�: ��=:Bl��WOu y;�'?'F411 � T��.'�� n J��1.��U�ft��'y`�`1� iJi:'s 5 � � ��'�� fiY Ct�iu`��.a`:;S��F�1�iY �J, �`:''rU y � . ��J�i�NI..�J\'s�41'tfdVm�Y'✓+r:a�.�.irn �r!:+wJ'MirV�.'' �y, �i. � F5 � '�� i �fw _.__l.�- 4 I�L ._.__ � � --� ._ 1; � �...��..+I �� Approved as to form - Feb. 85 Page -5 of � Planning Department �� _ .GtT• 0. �•' �. CITY OF SAINT PAI.I ; _�_�� DEPARTMEN OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPME�T • �� DIVISION OF PLAti11�v � 25 West Fourth Street,SaiM Paul,Ml�nesota 5,it02 ,.•• 612-228-32'0 GEORGE UTIMER MAYOR Februarv 14, 1989 Michael D. Killa 2047 Grand Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55105 RE: Rezoning of property at 2047 Grand �venue Dear Pir. Killa: The staf� p� the Zoning Sect�on o� the lanning Division has checked the signatures on your �ezoning petition �g �ngt the property ownership records provided by the Ramsey County Departmen of Taxation. We have determined that 12 parcels are eligible; 9 parcels are eeded; and 7 parcels have been verified. You must resubmit 2 additional signatur s before we can continue to process your request for rezoning. Th� petitio will be held for one month so any new signatures may be submitted. If no ew signatures are submitted, the file will be administratively closed and a re und will be granted. The reason for the insufficient petition is that 2 signatures have been removed from the petition and therefore the peti ion is insufficient. A copy of the petition showing the signatures accepted and a new notary sheet is attached. If you have any questions, please call m at 228-3390. Sincerly, � ��. � c'��. � �,��.:..,... Daniel K. Bayers Zoning Section � �� .... - �}V- �i� � �, UFFICIENCY CHECK SHEET OR REZONING PETITIONS DATE PETIT ON SUBMITTE : � � �' �� DATE OFFIC ALLY RECEIVED 3 'o? — �� PARCELS EL GIBLE: f � PARCELS NE DED: + PARCELS SI NED: � CHECKED 8Y �• �G'«/-��J DATE: - � -- � -i t� ,'_` � �► �-'- . -� ��tfL,� �� - �•�n� � � .._:� l _ 9_ ��' . � { i � I I i � � _ °� � I '. I �� I � j � ' � � i i � 1 I I I ; � , ! } ia�w btf�l�: � ' ' �v i , . : � y -t , , I `u � _ : I � 12�p� •�7 i �.p I � i ; �1- �-� � ; � , � � . : r�" ' � I, i . � . �� , - � i _ _ _ _ � . � = � _-- __-=-_ _ � � -�, --= =- . � � �' � - S ��- � J � � Y--�.—,.� � . _. ._ � � r-- d � � � � � � N -� p : � 0 � � � Q � = � ,°',�( � � - � � � -� ; �i � � i� I - - - - - - -- / ' i � --�.o:---- � � �•� „ � � � � � 14 ?� � ; , _� , O .9 1 � � o i h I ' � — ' r � s C __._. �h ---_ _-- -- ° �� -- /� �� TIZFN PA I I A I S .,.,.... ; o�• � r � � J O j N N:'n. ,M i � �� 7 � � �. .�.� I � _ ' a r� w 12 � _� '- �.,.� ; �� - 5 � � � 1 ` i� - � � � .Q., � : _ � r # ,,.■ , s ' 11 ~ s ; - � �p � s o,�a i „c,w� " "�w. . T wtn.. .a t sr � : i �-, i 4 _ � i �a � ,�_.. � - 4 . � . { # �.M � ��M � � "s � YM��u �( I �M M � l I s tlw' rE t�D � � ,�t sa�� + � � �i � n 1� r ~� } � � r �� s ' 1 r ar rc �r y SP P.' } a e 1 . 4 � ' 3 ; ' � °'$ , 1 �...� ,� 9 � ' � � ; ' �.. � � s � � e : r � ; � s Q = � E �t• !Y � � � � � YO� �tw. i O Y 6 w 0.6 F A t , 1 � y �00 � �11� � �� K 9 A ��F � E -'�� d+Ah �E Q �1 1 J 1 �{ fOa��E �O �r ` � \ •'� - _ � � �� 1 �''� �1 r � '� l-�j �� , �1 �OOL RE� � CITIZEN PARTI IPATION PLANNING DISTRICTS 1. SUNRAY—BA TLE CREEK—HIGHWOOD 2. HAZEL PAR HAYDEN—PROSPERITY HEIGHTS HILLCREST 3. WEST SIDE 4, DAYTON'S LUFF 5. PAYNE-PHA N 6. NORTH END 7. THOMAS—DAL 8. SUMMIT—tJNI ERSITY 9. WEST SEVE�� 10. COf� 11. HAM{LINE—MI AY 12. ST. ANTHON 13 N HAMLINE 14. ROYELANU—, ACALESTER . HIGHLAN 16. SUMMI7 HIL 17 , DOWNTOWN � ��_ ZQNlNG FILE ►Q`�..- � .... _ . .�...z � . . _ - . . . _ - . _ _ __ _ � . : -, _ _ . � -- — _�:..�._-- - ., . ... _ - � _ =a_�— . �`. — - , �. -- - - — -`�- - . --E � ; :\� _ - ....... _� _——-- �5.. ` — —,_ __� —... ._ `. --=K",.,.��---- --=;;_ s i —--- --^r== "'.-'•� -�_� —�— —a = _ — _"��_—� r-- �-��: ►--....�`_._—�._ �--r�— —�� —�.,, ,.� �_ ' ' _.L __ ___ � '_""" � "'_"� '�{`��'—' . . _" -� ° , � �.--;F-_ -- ---- — —..— � � Il � ,.... . �' __�, — _- '- =1 `_�_+ � ' .`_�^`�-7 .,•--�—_ — �\ t ,..,.... r—'• '— __ _ �_— =!_1�� L__�---�L-._.: C —��T- � — —._=r�-��—,� —� � .t`�--; ,'� ;�.�-!r-----i. -:�--�—_ �i Y. �"'.`, °�""` �_ '�i F—��. .s.��-..s_ , i �v— .r�� .�-` �� •.�� -� —�i `'"IJ7�6'---= adf—�' -�i�' �../ 'T .� � .�� . . � � I �-- _ �� i . ; -_= �� ,�.��j. -- ^--�,,� ,,,," „';;:�, — _,,-�"---�.. � I �� ---�=e.� — __ —,...,._ T-` ; – _, . — _� —:-- �� R 1 a; " � _��'��— �—— T-^ �� _!�1�;. �w r`°°-`,•__�. ri ^—�� L . ��.`_— - r�^ � �_ i--` , '�'+ �t_ `I�� T �. L�: , '� t a t'�� ^— ��—..._J_��' ��---�I . ( �,s°.�__-�_ >> -�_ ..�— � _�_�._� y....». i — '� �. ___;,1__��r�,.._.� � ��.1:.�.,1' ��[�_�� I � 1 �-- — ,. _'^„� � . ,�i,-�-�.-_ ._ '��_ — '� �....—��—,�;.� ' ; �, _ . � -- �-_IT� _�,r-_�:� . �� - ; � m � 4 -�'=:��-, - � TT ��:�=.��,� �, . " ; , 1 ;�; - �s�-. � T�=—r:,�._ �. =� �. i _' '1 r; ,l, i _'j ._. .._.. �;-� —.�``�-�-r!� M �`_.`_�r Jr-� .� I'I , I.. � .. . .... - . � 1_�,1 �� 1� ��'�` 'r—, � ,�� .. .. ... .. ....,., .-�i T ��r- , .I ..� �� :�-�-- ... �� .��, ;� 1 =;�_ GROVELAND–MACALESTER DIS'RICT 14 �N .� , �= ' � ._��,� ' .._.S'�..4'��..�:�.. �2 Y fC4l A L�l:e_/ 6"r-'r=� O �'�p�+ �;L�� " � r�l..i�a.G`.�'�//*'�^^--.oy'''r �:- ��'�= �' M'� �� r �� .E �� . �:�� /3---, • s • r • • • • • • • � � • • • • � . ' • ' i • � . .� �� - • • • • � • � • • � �ti� . . � • ' • • • •l�� „ . � , f� � � . � • • � � � � . �' �� • � • • • • � • • , � � �� i�iu � i . • • � • • • • �� • � � � o • • • � • • • • • �,.��ic ---__ �� r � / 1� ^► ,�� , ' I � ' H . • G'll�� ' i ' ' �' . ,� V . ' .�. ' '�i�lt�� ' . . . � w o . , ' � � r . � I , � a �^ . .' . �. �� ^ . � , p . . . H . . . . � . . • M p • 1� � ' � ►►� �! ■ � y , .� - -- � � . • • • • • • • • • • • ` • � � • • �' • • � • • • � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • w • • � • � • • • • o • • • • • � • • • . �. • • • • • � • � • � • • • • • . • • • • • . _,► r.. . • • , . . . • • • • • � • • • • • � w • � �� • • • • � • • • � • � • �� • o 1�1 • � • • • • • • • • • • •'• �� • • 1 • � • • • • � • • • 1► • � • � • • � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • � • • • i • I• � • � • � • • � • • � • � • • • � • • � � • : � � • • � •• � . � � , :• �� • c� � • � - � � � ' f• • • � . �� • • � • • - • � . NOTICE OF PUBLIC EARING . A petition has been filed requ�stiny th th� Zoning Ordinance of the City of St. Paul c�e ainended so as t rezone from Ft�'�-2 to B-2C, property described as Lot 28, Block 2, sedale Park Addition. This property is located at 2047 Grand Ave u . The Council of.the City � �(, �,�, oy of St. Paul has fixed th t 9:00 �A.i�1. in the Council Chambers on the 3r oor o Ci Hall, and at said tim� -�� ,�'ay and place, the Council will hear. all pe -ons and all obj�ctions and �`�� reccRUnendations relative to the propos� amendment. �'u�:� /�� Dated .�-k-7, 1989 Albert B. Olson City Cl�rk , �,]��N�� 7, ��9> . �, _ - - - - ;, . '��$C l i OA;i CITY OF SAINT PAUL 4 � a ��„„ ; DEPARTMENT F PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT `�m �� e' DIVISION OF PLANNING 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 +ss• 612-228-3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR �. L'L4" RECEIVED June 8, 1989 �� p 9�ggg c�Y� c;L�b�n� Mr. Albert B. Olson, City Clerk Room 386, City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr. Olson: This letter is written to confirm the he ring date for: Applicant: Michael Killa File Number: #10444 Purpose: A Rezoning from a RM-2 t B-2C for property located at 2047 Grand Avenue to permit us of one-half of the two-family dwelling as a office Legal Description of Property: 2047 Grand Avenue Lot 8; Blk 2; Rosedale Park Add. Previous Action: Planning Division Decision: denied, 4-13, April 14, 1989 Zoning Committee Recommenda ion:approved, 3-2, April 6, 1989 Board of Zoning Appeal: In order to allow time for the mailing of appropriate notices, please schedule the hearing date as soon as possible afte 7-6-89. Our preference would be 7-6-89. I will phone you within the next few days for schedule confirmation. Sincerely, � �:'^.�,r�� ,t,�j-? --� Daniel K. Bayers �� Y Zoning Section cc: file # 10444 cc: Mary Jean d - -- r c;:d ,t� � � '" �;1 ': v'._ � ' �..�. �-, . f t,:.: F ,� ��` :=rr � , � t ,i,�• ``° !r.. t� � '��I"� 1 7 (+ �' � � .1 S S� � _ 3 �� , q / `� . ♦ t 5 .yy �' c _ �: ��l^ f t�-' '� 1 ti k �� r "':, � S �'�� ,, � t r ' a� ,�.,-�, �' ' � F t '�� ' � � _�+ � � , . �•.� �j . , o �. , Tr r� ��' r w- �. . �; a�' � . `. ) � � � � +' y. '� ',� , � . � G. F�t -�. � � ' ;� i. : ,, t t ...4. .c.� .� t ,�,.. � t 1 h� ; t t '' \ � � `� � x' . � �T � �r � , 1_ � if ^� t t. 1 � �� t ;fr� �TM `i � -� f.�`�'^��'�Z �. k� �'~ �.� '�� _ ;; ° �' �� ' � , i� t�, ' � f' � .''s, =j P;� ,��.:��:h� �ae'n i�iled'"�t� r ha'� � '�a��,ncJ�:�dii�t�'#�,�>Of� � _ --� �,r ': .�.��tg x,��. �f.ul. •k� � , '�� ;;��=� �b �=?�.�►t'' �"r, ` j � ` ��i�� a$.� �� y��,��.c�. '' �'t�3;s� , � �' ;, `�� s'.��2 �:,a,,q� �?c��' � � u+�• `�-:�1� b�._.��.�t��.� �-. . , �; i :�: ' �'►ZAry�-;'��.i�'`L�e�1C.1.�:�-Wi�c �.�SA�� I-.' {C';�F� 'a"'�,y��f i7,s -fAiC_ '' ! e, + � .. ,, . `� �� C4�IG'1� �`�� 'C?}3 � � �Q��' •� �."�'� � ��°R� S3fi�* t�?� ,' ' � ,'L��'�,C�,�, 'i�T��:= �., � �.��':�+��,`��#�� . r y y_� 4 , �.._ �� Y�.%��L�+4�� F«.'� �.5,_ �" , k f J d ` # '. i. `* '� . � s; Y y r.: i d0. .:' � 4 ��. :i; .. � ' •'v . ��a. � i{.� . 1 Z'. 1 - ,�y� f =Y . . . �� •� � � '� 4 � t �, � '� � � � �� . '� !. S_1� .F � '•� a :: . � .-.� , ' � � ._ �, ' . 1� . . . . � 1,.� ., . . � '�.�v . . ' , ' 4 '(. } ��L''�;$�, K�&�.� '� , � ' J � { �� . �r,sL�'`�'+��J,1� .1.. ' i y . ,,�� r; � ��` � �� 1 t / r ,�.- � , . 'F � � . . ' } � � '7 � ' .- . �. � -,l �} r, �� . _ �, � ... ��` �]�'►./ �4ie7.�� k �. _ � i � � . . . �, .. ..4 . �k Jf��./ , . . .., � � �u • . .� . ,. �. < ' Y' � ` ..t . , ... :� . . . ' -, , . t . �t=�7 . . ., -. -� < .. . ..; . • . .. � .� ��. i .s. . .. . '. . ' . .,��." ..�..� ` ' /_. •ti — � �,, � - � t I�. f,• , � s�� . ��','�� J ` � . �;~ Y !� � � " � , �1 ,ra� � . . , �.�e.� +3 : a'*qi h. '. . . �i 7 .F„�. � . � �: �, l• . 1 h Q f �l' ) . !. � } ! }� ' ., � , „ � " �. . . . . .. ,. �. � � . . 1 ��* 9 9� i -h4 i � � � � ! � ._� ( � �� i ' : ` � . t 'r Y i � "� { j �y s "' . �, � � � 1� ° ti4 � 4f ` \ "` .tt.� � �� •y� I F ��' � � . � 1 { ', i � ' t k g` +{�.. � k 9� ,, y , p: ,�» '+� t.: ,! \: 1 . \ 1 � �.�, d: 'r ; �;` ,'f a�',/ y � S � \ t r � e � � ,�;� r, t 4 t � � .1 � � � � �f �- ^ �)l � 4� j �� 1 �� t �t - r , � �i � �_ � ' �� Y � .r .. ' . / I #�e � , ` ( '' �.f ;„ ' �� „�r ! � � � ! . \� .«Zi . ,t '�t J :;.i �!i l. ' '' i . .c�. � /;`�r � ; � j, '{\, } � � ��.'� M k'� �' � ' � a: ° � � � .� . - , .. .' �I � .�d - i, i x � , _� ,� �t � � � � .-� � �S� �y: .�' _ .. �. ��- f - C i_ • r t p," # i. ' : { �� - i . - �" � '�'�, a;." v f� �' � : 4r � ° + r f f� i y�" ' � � ,� � �, , -,\ , � � , � � "" � � . i �., � �{�° s . }t ��` z. `.' �.'• F r a°.t;' w � '' ��" � i � - " } .�t... ti y � y._ • i-:. �. a .rr ' K . r �� .�� jh � .. �' f .; � � �. �� .�� .ti �� a ;. �� [ � �+.' v � � ��i • f. �S�ff xa�'4� t l. . 5 . } y �� i" 3 � r �t � � � . . � j � .'. !{ f k ' i i ��"�: r ;G t h q,,, ��,`#� S?: � � t k � ° py +. y � �. <..- t, '��r t � � � �� a i � i x . � '� �� a � �� C�� t� ��' •, ,�' ��r� �� d r? .� . � ,�p �. Y ;i> '� �:�' J` C.�.. ; }h` + ? y�+ � � e� � � � � 4d;:G 9� ti �^ �t�> + ' i i� � A ��' ; �l;� C t�� . � � i ' i i i r :�� t m �.; � F�'�'� . � ,�' � : r� ��. r / �`�' y,� 7t �r� ��.- �w �,�fiA �Y � � a. `l� � ( <t' �. w�� x'� ,�:'b . Y ,. . n � c ��1 ��'' �'.�..� ti"Y�,'7��, �.� e.�.r��f,..,.. � .. . .. �.., _,. ,+ . .+.,,.��2,�..`e�..s - �¢.nxiiY-: [....S.,S.. .. .�o't ��} .s.::�� ;:�,5�•�.lac�x�" n�:` .:,�ia�Ws€x._r.�� :.��K6,�1��.i.-P�`'�..r� .r` t �� - � / / J . � !�� ST. PAUL CIT COUNCIL PUBI. IC H ARING NOTICE O N I N G RECEIVED MAY 191989 CITY CLERK T0: Property owners within 350' ; FIL E N 0. 10444 Representatives of P1 anni ng Di st i ct 14 PAGE PURPOSE Rezone an exi ting duplex from RM-2 to B-2C to permit the operation of small business office for one unit of the building and llow the remainder to be used as residential property. LOCATION 2047 Grand Av nue (North side between Cleveland & Prior) PETITIONER MICHAEL D. KI LA H E A R I N G Thursday, June , 1989 9:0o a.M. Citv Council Ch mbers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House QUESTIONS Zoning 22g_33�6 (Chuck ��IcGuire) Contact the Zon'ng Section of the Planning and Economic Development Dep rtment, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Stree , St. Paul, Minnesoia 55102 Legal Descripti n : One file Notice sent 5/18/89 r_ . v . _ _ ' NOTICE OF PUBLI HFARING A petition has been filed requesting t at the Zoning Ordinance of the City of St. Paul be amended so as o rezone from RM-2 to B-2C, property described as Lot 28, Block 2, Rosedale Park Addition. This property is located at 2047 Grand Aven e. The Council of.the City of St. Paul has fixed the �� day t� , 1989 at 9:00 A.M. in the • Council Chambers on the 3rd floor of C'ty Hall, and at said time and place, the Council will hear all rsons and all objections and recommendations relative to the propos amendment. Dated May 17, 1989 Albert B. Olson City Clerk , (rlay 20, 1 89) . . � / �.. � ��1 . �G1TY DA � 1 _ i �'� °. �� "` `CITY OF SAINT PAUL k 't� a ��,,, b DEPARTMENT F PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT vm O11 �� C DIVISION OF PLANNING �a 6• 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 612-228-3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR RECEIVED May 16, 1989 MAY 161989 CITY CL��tK Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386, City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Mr. Olson: Please schedule a City Council hearing f r: Applicant: Michael D. Killa /��{� �G�-�-=-�'� ��`' File Number: #10444 Purpose: Rezoning from RM-2 to B- to permit use of one-half of the two family dwelling as an office. Legal Description of Property: Lo 28, Block 2, Rosedale Park Addition. Previous Actions: Planning Commission Recommen tion: Deny (4-13) - 4-14-89 Zoning Committee Recommendati n: (Approve (3-2) - 4-6-89 In order to allow sufficient time for the mailing of appropriate notices, please schedule the hearing date as soon s possible. Our preference would be .T u�ae 1, �4�1, Dan Bayers of our Zoning Staff will phone you within the next few days for schedule confirmation. Sincerely, ��'�i � i7 , Charles L. McGuire Planner IV - Zoning CLMcG:rm cc: D. Bayers . . - , � �� fiv NOTICE OF P BL�C HEARING ' ' A petition having been filed reques ing t�at tT�e Zoning Ordinance of the City of St.Paul be amended scr as to�sone RJI��ta�.2e�property described as Lot 28,Slock 2, Rosedale Park Addi�i n.�!'fi2s property is'1'ocated at 2U47 Grand Avenue.The Council of the City of St. aul�as fixed the lst dav of itne_ 1989 at 9:�0 in the Gounci�Chambers!om t e 3'rd flour�of-Gity Ha►11,and at saic3�ime_ an pl�"e, the. Go�#1� will hear a�� eri�o�s .and;. �kk ob�eetioas and recommendations relative to the prop ed amerbdme�t; . � Dated May 27, 1988. � ' ALBERT B. fJISON,Cit�r.Clerk � � , �� ; (�y :19�)' : . , :: >;. - .,,. _. , . _. _. _ _, s._ . ,.� ,..,._,. . e . 1st �,_ � •' . d � 2nd �- �_ �' 3rd �� .�� _ � � Adopted a - � - �9 Yeas Nays DIMOND GOS[�VI�Z C�� /<a /7i lC% I;ONG : : : RETTMAN SONNEN WILSON �• SIDENT, SCHEIBEL