The URL can be used to link to this page

89-1725 �� e%.if City of St.Paul COUNCIL,FILE NO.- — �..Y– RESOLUTION RATIFYING ASS SSMENT ay f' �� ' ' �"' "r� ' �ile No. 18Si3 ' ' �-�. Voting Assessment No: 2�� Ward In the matter of the assessment of ben fits, cost and �xpenses for 1 � 5 th�r Constr�ction of the 8ylvax�ldcl�es irea Stors �e�er P�rojsct. Preliminary Order �$"18�� approved �1ot►�ts 22• 19$� FinalOrder approve�i Jaanar� �l, 1989 A public hearing having been had u on the assessment for the above improvement, and said assessment having been further considered by the Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, therefore,by it RESOLVED, That the said assessme t be and the same is hereby in all respecta ratitied. RESOLVED FURTHER,That the said ssessment be and it is hereby determined to be payable in one thru 20 equal installments. as per Section 4.04 of the Saint Paul Administrative Code. COUNCILPERSON Adopted by the Council: Date s�P Z b � Yea� Nays r�� Certified Coun ' Secretar � In Favor By LLta�n ��1 4 Against `�"�"�-' � Mayor �'°° P��l� 0 C T 7 1989� 2 � 1989 City of St.Paul COiJNCIL FILE NO. ` j�—� �-�� ._.t� Office of The Director of inance , By : - REPORT OF COMPLETION O ASSESSMENT V� File No. �� Voting Assessment No. �13 Ward In the matter of the assessment of be efits, cost and expenses for i i 3 t�e Grast�t�. af tba Bjrl�/�+a�r Jlrea ft� iauur�s t�re�a�t. ., ��. Preliminary Order �"`�� approvecL �+'�'�'��' �Z• 2�� FinalOrder �"'�� approve� .1a�rac,�r 21. 14�9 ,' To the Council of the City of St. Paul: The Director of Finance hereby report to the Council the following as a statement of the expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connection with the ma ing of the above improvement, viz: Total construction costs. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 2�181,215.00 Engineering and Inspection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 409,419.00 Valuation and Assessment Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 8�689.32 Process Setving Charge . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ Abatement Service Charge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ TOTAL EXPENDITURES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 2�599,323.32 Charge To . . . .Miscellaneous Ai , g 2,310,016.85 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ Net Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 289,306.47 Said Director further reports that he h s assessed and levied the total amount as above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $ upon each nd every lot, part or parcel of land deemed benefited by the said improve- ment, and in the case of each lot, part or p rcel of land in accordance with the t3enefits conferred thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that here attached, identified by the signature of the said Director, and made a part hereof, is the said assessn►ent as completed y him, and which is herewith submitted to the Council for such action thereon as may be considered proper. Dated Director of Finance .� � ,� .� �►. � 8�2�89 r.� �-i�a�' DEPApTMENT/OFFICEICOUNdI INITiATED Finance/`Real Estate Division /24/89 GREEN SHEET NO. 3�6 9� CONTACT P 3 PNONE { �DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR �CITY COUNqL Peter White 298-��Z�-_� � _ � ❑cm��r �c,m cx��nc MUBT ON COUNqL AOENDA BY(DATE1 H/g H9 �BUDOET DIi�C'rtOR �FlN.d MQT.SERVICEB DIR. ust be in City Clerkis Of�ice no ; �MAYOR(ORA8818TMIT) � Council Research TOTAL�OF SIQNATURE PA � � ( ALL LOCATION8 FOR SIQNATUR� ACTION REQUEBTED: 1. Setting hearing date fc{r atification of assessments. 2. Ratify assessments for ;th SYLVAN/ACKER STORM SEWER PROJECT 3. File No. 18542 Assessment No. 2213 RECO�NO�TioNS:�vw�•W a►�.c�tR) i L REPORT OPTIONAL _PLANNINO COMMI8810N _CIVIL SERVICE COMMI88�lN YST PNONE NO. _q8 COMMITTEE _ �STAFF _ ! MMENTB: _DIBTRICT OOURT _ SUPPORTS WNICM OOUNpL OBJECTIVE? INITIATINO PROBLEM.188UE.OPPORTUNITY pNho.Nlh�t.Whsn.�NFN►�. Pro�ect is comglete. ' tification is necessary in order to begin collecting assessments o help pay for the project. ADVANTAC�ES IF APPROVED: Same as abbve DISADVANTI�E8 IF APPF�VED: ' Benefitted pro erty owners have assessments payable via property taxes. DISADVANTAtiEB IP NOT APPROVED: To not assess tlhe enefits would be inconsistent with City policy. , y��:��E1 Research Center A U G 3 �989 TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION 2 C08T/REVENUH SllDOETED(qRCLE ONE) �ES NO ► Ru�p�o sou� ACTIVITY NUMBER 802-60953-6001 FlNANGAL INFORMA'110N:(EXPUUN) Total P�ro� ct Costs - $2,599,323.32 Funded By: Assessments - $289,306.47 Other Funds - $2,310,016.85 244 parcels � �`i Jx � ,. NOTE: COMPLETE DIRECTION3 ARE INd.UDED IN THE(�iREEN 3MEET IN3TRUCTIONAL MANUAL AVAILABLE IN THE PURCHASING OFFICE(PHONE NO. 288-4225). ROUTING ORDER: Below are preferred routings for the flve most frequent types of dxuments: CONTRACTS (assumes authorized COUNCIL RESOLUTION (Amend, BdgtsJ budget exists) Accept. Grents) 1. Outside Agency 1. Department Director 2. Initiating Department 2. Budget Director 3. City Attomey 3. City Attomey 4. Mayor 4. Mayor/Aasistant 5. Finance&Mgmt Svcs. Director 5. City Councfl 6. Finance Axounting 6. Chlef/1xouMant, Fin 8�Mgmt Svcs. ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER (Budget OOUNCIL RESOLUTION (all others) Revision) and ORDINANCE 1. Activity Manager 1. Initiating Department Director 2. Department Axountant 2. Cfty Attomey 3. DepartmeM Director 3. MayodAssistant 4. Budget Director 4. Gry Council 5. City Clerk 6. Chief Accountant, Fin &Mgmt Svcs. ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS (all others) 1. Initiating Department 2. City Attorney 3. Meyor/Assistant 4. City Clerk TOTAL NUMBER OF SIGNATURE PAGES Indicate the�of pages on which signatures are required and 8p�e� each of these pages. ACTION REQUESTED Descrfbe what the project/request aeeka to acc:omplish in either chronologi- cal order or order of importance,whichever is most appropriate for the issue. Do not write�mplete sentences. Begin each item in your list with a verb. RECOMMENDATIONS Complete if the iss�e in question has been preseMed before any body, public or private. SUPPORTS WHICkI COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? �ndicaee wrdcn counci�objective(s)your proJecUreyuese supports by�isting the key word(s)(HOUSING, RECREATION, NEIGHBORHOODS, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, BUDGET, SEWER SEPARATION).(SEE COMPLETE LIST IN INSTRUCTIONAL MANUAL.) COUNCIL COMMITTEE/RESEARCH REPORT-OPTIONAL AS REQUESTED BY COUNCIL INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE,OPPORTUNITY Explain the situation or conditbns that created a need for your project or request. ADVANTAGES IF APPROVED Indlcate whether this is simply an annual budget procedure required by law/ charter or whether there are speciflc wa in whkh the City of Saint Paul and its citizens wfll beneflt from this pro�action. DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED What negative effects or major changes to existing or psst processes might this projecUrequest produce if It is passed(e.g.,traffic delays, noise, tax increases or assessments)?To Whom?When4 For hoMr long? DISADVANTAOES IF NOT APPROVED What will be the negative consequences if the promised actbn is not approved? Inability to deliver service? Continued high trafNc, noise, accident rate7 Loss of revenueT � FINANGAL IMPACT - Although you must teilor the information you provide here to the issue you are addressing, in general you must answer rivo questions: How much is it going to cost?Who is going to payt I CF $9 ' �r�5 ORIG OF THIS DOCUMENT WAS SERVED IN R. THIS COPY IS FILED AS � STATE OF MINNESOTA � OR GINAL. a.�-t DISTRICT COURT � 0 l� COUNTY OF RP►MSEY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT ----------------------- -- �.,i � se T e: ASSESSMENT APPEAL � � YP . Lawrence H. Smith, S�p271989 J�: C,�C�KOWSKI Court File No: C�-89- /D?�j13 P e t i t i o RT ADMINISTRATOR vs. OF OBJECTION TO ASSESSMENT City of St. Paul, ' Respondent. -------------------------- ----------- TO: THE CITY OF ST. AUL, and Albert Olson, it' s City Clerk, 347 City Hall, . Paul, Minnesota, 55102. . , The above-named LAW CE H. SMITH appeals to the District Court of Ramsey County from the adoption of the assessment on September 26, 1989, in the amount of $1 , 177 .13 against his premises at 195 E. Minnehaha, in the City of Saint Paul, County of Ramsey and State of Minnesota, and further identified as Parcel I.D. #30-29-22-43-0153, upon the grounds that the said assessment grossly exceeds economic benefit to his premises. Dated: September 27 , 1989 J . Daub ey #21 tto ey for Lawrerice H. mith 700 andmark Towers 5 t. PetPr Street Saint Paul, MN 55102 � (612) 224-4345 0 .� a .o � � z � � r � Q rltl� tl) ocCAoro � o �lc �' � a � a -q °o ~ o � oo orwc,� -i crw � w � � ►., �.+r� a.� � ,�,,� � � � -°o � � �Z -v � � � � �a � � s.n o co o �s .. � �7 . . . . �./ [� �p o � o 0 0 0 0 �! o a o 0 0 c F �q _ ��a 5 _ ' ___-- � Iq%�—AIpJ�.it �1 Se..ic� (�l�•1��1 N71) , • �11A�►iIAM��►11li. IGIAIR�MINN �t�te o� ��itttte�ot�t, ,,, Court 'F�le. Noi ��4-89- �� : • co�,��er �� .......R��n�.�y.............. . ....:� ...... . .....�4k��.. -�:::�n.��.�.ng..x:..;;:._.. ...:..:.::�.+.:.....►:.:, 6.rnt a�rr . ruorn, orl oo[h �ayf; �bnl on lhs...........»....._. �.._.... _......_..._ . ....��j+'of•..:::�4$�.�.:::.:....u.........j �9_.8.�� . '�e �ervtd !lie arra�hsd........NAt1C�E...IIf..O.�].��.� .I1...�t1..A.SS�II1�U.�.--»»::-.:--..--.»---»»«--.+.----►- �p�►..............A1b��t..•O�.�o.n.,....Ci.�.g..-C1.e�k...o ..th$...Gi.t.}r...,o.£ �t� �au:7.._......_._... .. herein naiqed, f►ulonall�+, ol........��.�...�1�rV.._.��a.�.. .��.�...P�.17.�.a...�...��.�.�».».............. »..�....... 'n thc Countr.o......."Ramsey._....-�„_�,.�»�„_,,,�._,�,_� .,.,..»..._,�Stot� oj Minaaots� �y handin�to end�J�aninj w1�h • . .................... .�l..f.�r.1�....��5�'yt....._....:._............ ......................,-- ..:... ._............._...................._........ • t.ue and�eo.rect co/�..y................tl�ercof,.......................... .............._....... ».......» • _.._.........:� ».......'.1s:»...».. �+v • —... . . � S��1„c,�b.d eud� orn to br. ore rn� �lur ' � ......2.7....�h..... � _ .. k�,�?�° : � `' �.�� . Daubn ' � r�o?H�r a�;,��c-;r;;,,.:�scr.a WASHtNGI'04 COU`;Ty . � My Ccmmi�5�on rr;;i�?c �.:'.1-9C' � , .. • .",,,�,.n11,vw,,,,.,,,,,,N,,,,Y,,�,�Y,,y,,. .. No a r Pub 1 i c � r ...� f;�'=. ��' ��.�• :..' t --.'.\�J� ' � ' `� �i ,4 . vvr � � J IMI CIVICI V I vi rn r cn i i iHn If thls box is checked,you owatlellnquent taxee and may I I PAYABLE IN 1 89 rat.apah!tor,tne woaerh�tax;,retur,d. ";' . U ,coPY PLEASE READ BACK OF FORM FOF ; ..JR RECORDS RqMSEY COUN Y,MINN. PENALTY AND PAYMENT INFORMATI� � PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION NO. yyTp g,g SCHOOL L SEC TWN RGE QTR ID C/D�D CaDE DIST. C P. 30 29 22 43 0153 6 C 625 TOTAL TAX ON RENTAL PORTION OF PROPERTY. $ SEFtVICE CHARGES ANO SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS NAME NO. AMOUNT THE STATE PAYS AIDS TO IOCAL UNITS OF GOVERNM RED CTION FROM STATE PAID TAX E�L EFPROPERTY �'�'r � 1 STR MAINT 0032 336.00 15� 7�650.74 ST SWR CHO 0080 1 ,4i6.00 WST/RCYCLE 0098 62. 56 PROPERTY ADDRESS WASTE MGMT 0099 11 .44 19S MINNEHAHA AVE E PROPERTY OWNER LAWRENCE H SMITH ' 17 POINT ROAD BAYPORT MN SS0031603 • NAME OF TAXPAYER /5; %Z Pd s"/s/�' 9 '� �y 7 3 TOTAL-SEE ITEM 11 1 ,826.00 253 .400 13 ,3 4 LAWRENCE H SMITH 17 POINT ROAD YOUR ITEMIZED STATEMENT BAYPORT MN SS0031603 3.STATE•SEE REVERSE SIOE.............. .0 4.COUNTY..................................... 2 ,9 76.4 S.TOWNSHIP OR CITY....................... 2 ,8 3 7.2 B.SCHOOI DISTRICT......................... 4 ,919.1 7.OTHER TAXIN(3 DISTHICTS................ S 69.9 NOTICE OF 1989 VALUE FOR TAXES PAYABLE IN 1990 A. fISCAL DISP. TAX 2 ,6gg,� 1988ESTIMATEDMARKETVALUE 253 �400 '1989ESTIMATEDMARKETVALUE UNOE_R_.REVIEW ' -- .._ --- .__ _ _ _. . PROPERTY CLASSIFICATION COMMERCIAL EXEMPT B.TAX BEFORE CREDITS..................... 1 3 ,991 .S property pescription—for tax purposes only(7he legal de��Uan o/your property may diNer) 9.CREOfTS WHICH REDUCE YOUR TAX... SECTION 30 TOWN 29 RANOE 2.2 8 TH S 78 DEO 27 MIN 21 STATEPAIDHOMESTEADCREDIT.......... .0 PART 8E0 AT INT OF SL OF SEC E 235.48 FT TH S TO A SE 1/4 AND EXTENOEO WL OF L BEARINO N 79 DEG 18 MIN L'ORIENT ST TH W ON SD SL S3 SEC E FROM A PT ON TO PT DIST 2324.45 fT W OF EXTENDED WL OF L'ORIENT ST SE COR OF SD SE 1/4 TH N S4 FT N FROM BEO TH S 79 10.TAXAFTERCREDITS....... 13 ,991 .5 148.04 FT TH N 72 DEO 26 DEO 18 MIN 53 SEC W 92.3 71.SERV CHGS&SPEC ASSESSMENTS M I N 2 3 S E C E 1 S 9.8 S F T T N F T T 0 S D E X T E N D E D W L T H S A.PRINCIPAL.............................. 1 ,826.0 ElY 700.85 FT ON A 1379.71 0 DEO 16 MIN 07 SEC E TO B.INTEREST .............................. .0 fT RAD IUS CURVE CONCAVE TO ADD'L DESC — CALL 298-4711 *RECENT PROPERTY REVIEW.MAY RESULT IN A CORRECTED NOTI� 12:TOTAL TA�� F � 1 5 }8�7:�S �,��' ..�s_�. .�,,..,cn,� ��r��'-��"-�� ;"�r� � STATE COPY -:,:,� �°'' � � �� STATEMENT OF ROPERTY TAX NEw EsnMA�� aaoss ENCLOSE THIS COPY=WITH FORM M=1P �' pAYABLE IN 1989 IMPROVEMEN75 MARKET VALUE TAX CAPACITY WHEN FIUNQ FOR R� UND FROM MINN y�� MSEY C NTY,MINN. 2 5 3�4 00 13 ,3� DEP,..jkQF REVENU:E�,, ��.�;�� . , ,� � PROPEFiTY IDENTIFICATION N . 7 SCHOOL l.OAN NAME OF TAXPAYER SEC 7wt� RGE oTa io C/pSHD DIST. COMP. �AWRENCE H SMITN 30 29 22 43 0153 4 C 625 t� POIIJT ROAD BAYPORT MN SS0031603 ARE YOU ELIGIBLE FOR A REFUND? To find out if you're eligible , for one or both of these refunds... The Minnesota Property Tax Refund � and � If this bo�t ta c�cedr�u'A�defirq M ta�s�and may , The Special Property Tax Refund �',��'��Qr��se�, ��r�.�,�;��`�� ;�;��' '�� . .fill out FORM M-1PR using these amounts: TAX SUMMARY 1.Fill in this amount on line 11 �3 ,9 91 .S 4 and also on line 27 schedule 2 TAXES LEVIED 13 991 54 ..................................... , 2.Fill in this amount on line 13 LESS CREDITS . ............................... .00 .00 TAX AFTER CREDITS .............................. 13 .991 .54 and also on line 28 schedule 2 SERVICE CHGS AND SPECIAL ASSMTS......... t ,8 2 6.0 0 Need a FORM M-1PR7 Read the back ot this imm. � ..- -- f . ='' ?e•oi�'.•-�� rvf ; � _ `� ..`I�a.,.�� '- �. � � v � �`� N��f: + �� i b •��!'M7j7--�� v z � -O r� ,. -��-- '') !� � _ •1+.+- �C�YI:Ti'{j'►�""^—'.� r A� � � � ` � '� �;� �' „ .n T � � r_7i ��r �� p Q �` �-� � s � �I � ' � i � ' • � j ° � = y m .� � . J y., I � I� y I S w � � � � � � w 1 � � , - i � : �� Q � �i- w z � � � °'� W (` !� I ; � z �' �, Q t` j = i I � �,�+,..��...,.�\ o (�, o N � Q � ! I Ir '� ff I� -s . • � (' � i ,� f`' � � � _�� -: =�i I� p � r , , �' ��.!'Li� (/t� �. I!� � � � ' b � • . . . _ � � � � ` ' � 1 i G I�! � � a ' fi : �\ � �� i� � W a : I �i y _ .._ .. .__ . .._ � � I u I a rc � � i� • ; � 2 I;` � � � � � •fd•�•� '48 'rbt ! ,v �`, � .� � i� � �� '4ts •:�t• �•tin•.F +. . .� � . . . __ ... � ,� , y � • . -• ,. yl �� V I, I ! : � w : � I, . . • �.uw,LT��»�.�i�+3S , �g � � I !I !I I L � 4 � Q i; D r. �� ......__..._._ _._.. �s zt' - - ,1 � 'I �� •7 ?�� " r � �� v '�. � 1c �(� �• .� .i , ;; •;y -p .�° 3'��'"..�� ` q 1 =�b ~ � ,i � � � � + � �Q ; � � „_� �I � i� - �' s � .� � � j �, � :I : i '� .�i (i '�S . �b o � J '; .�1. � 1s e�� i . i i h li ' , � �� '1 �' � R q -" � � � i '.� ' i i G: � , . . y ' i �� ' y ;Iln { � � '1 l �n � ^� .Of Q \ � " ,. � . .�� . � . �� .. ' � � �� T � �.:p « x � ., � Vw ( � � 1 I .,I e .�� 1- � , „ i! + � •t i � '•, b �/ �� p :� � •� � 1 � . 'II ' II �,l��' . �II� ��1. 't10.► i � � �1 � � I i:` :',•..'��14ra�I'Mf w�'tts Q � � � �� °fi:'' i �' " � ''� � � � ':��►' 'r�i,i�.q.�i �� r.i v ��11\Y LL I\ �� '�� }�1 Mi. �uwlIN,114► 4` . . � �x, I !� � �i��l'��.�rt 1�,� � � � a ,,�•� •-.. xR � � � � � � '� �� j �t .x, � � x� y � �. �. � 1 I � '; k i `�• �'^�. \ �I ' W� Z � � � !� i O. . � '\'4- � . :,�` } l��r'.. � �, � �� .II I�- �a �� c�'�� `� �� + N � � ��. � i � .., .'- •I. o` f C � � \ � } '•�• , � � � -- :R;_ i; ` � ��,' . � ' ks q � ° a i �. 1 � � ��% , ' � �+ ; � ez ° �:�•: :•n �,s i S I n ` ��I � �� . � � Q v • L 9 18 ` ` � ► y o N R � -b •bb�__. \ \ � i � �' L � � � � � � _..� � � �... .... _,_j_.__ \`� s , '�+��n_ '' t'r. � � a _ 0 E ' 1� �` ` °.• �, I � � � �:�'...i.f► i 11, � .1�: � �� :- �.�•� W� cl J :v:t;r� � . . '1,, �1 Q � �' �! � Lu Q . � . � �`a- . . ,.o. ��•. .-u . �� , � • - "'�'rd y�n/ lnr`Slf��ol 1 � .-._- '' ' � —��o�� .._ ., �;� :, . _.....� � .: - �. ► � � a 8 118 4`�� . — � CITY . . Saint aul City Council � ��/7ds - �� 9 Publi Hearing Notice ,�, � � r a t1111i11I1I ro Ratifica ion of Assessment 6 ull 1 II II ,� �, r � 183t RECEIVED COUNCIL pISTRICT �1,5 OWNER OR TAXPAYER PLANNING COUNCIL q6,7 SEP 011989 FILE q 18�4� > _ STATE OF MINNESOTA TRUST EXE �i'YY CLERK ASSESSMENT A >��f3 109 COURT HOUSE PROPERTY ADDRESS ST PAUL MINN 55102-1613 � P�NNSYLVANf�4 AVE'E _ PARCEL ID _.. ....._. . . .. .. _ _ _ _ _ __ 31 :2g �2-:12 b0y2 <; PROPERTY TAX DESCRIPTION ASHTON AND SHERBURNES ADDITION T SAINT PAUL WITH NO ACCESS TO HWY THE N 1 FT OF E 1/2 OF LOT 17 BLK 1 PURPOSE To consider ap roval of the assessment for: SYLVAN/ACKER TORM SEWER PROJECT PUBLIC TIME: WEDNES AY, SEPTEMBER 20, 1989, AT 9:00 A.M. WORKS COMMITTEE PLACE: ROOM 07 CITY HALL/COURT HOUSE MEETING This is where oblems should be discussed so they can be resolved before the public hearing. THE TIME: TUESDA , SEPTEMBER 26, 1989, AT 9:00 A.M. PUBLIC HEARING PLACE: City C uncil Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hail-Court House Written or oral statements by any owner will be considered by the Council at his hearing. ASSESSMENT The proposed ssessment for the above property is $ 2.s� INFORMATION Your final ass sment will be the amount approved by the City Council at the ublic hearing. The amount specified on this notice is the a ount that is being recommended to the City Council for ap roval. The proposed assessment roli for this project is avai ble for review in the Finance Dept. Room 218, City Hall. NOTE: THIS IS NOT YOUR BILL. OU WILL RECEIVE AN INVOICE AFTER THE HEARING SPECIFYING THE AMOUNT PPROVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL WITH INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO PAY THIS AS ESSMENT. CONTINUED ON REVERSE IDE NOTIFICATION DATE 08/31/89 � . . . 3 �� - �� Members: CiIT OF SAINT PAUL Roger J. Goswitz, chair � ,,,��„�„ - Janice Rettman �m tu n, OFFI P OF THE CITY COQNCIL Tom Dimond Date: Septem er 20, 1989 ' �'ECEIVED ommittee Report S�� 2 o��g To: Saint Paul City C uncil C1TY CLERK From :Public Works, tilities, and Transportation Committee Roger J. Gosw tz, Chair 1. Approval o minutes of September 6, 1989. Approved 3-0 Hearing Date 2. 10/3/89 Vacation: etition of Monica A. Polski and Gloria l. ates for the vacation of 1.2 Approved 3-0 foot strip along MARYLAND AND EARL STREETS (b unded by Cypress, Hawthorne, Earl and M ryland) . Purpose is to cure building e croachment. 3. Vacation: etition of Richard Timmers for Laid over the vacati n of part of COTTAGE AVENUE indefinitely between Ar wright and Edgemont Streets. Purpose is to construct a 16-unit apartment uilding. (Laid over in Committee /2/89 and 8/30/89) . . 4. Vacation: roposed vacation of Lots 27 Laid over to through 30, Block 4, Aurora Addition for 10/18 property a 1889 and 1895 BUSH AVENUE. (Laid over in Committee 8/30/89) . . Ratificati n of Assessments: For the Approved 3-0 constructi n of the SYLVAN/ACKER AREA STORM SEWE PROJECT. Work to be completed �ring 1�98 construction year. 6. 9/26/89 Ratificati n of Assessments: For the Approved 3-0 constructi n of the SYLVAN/ACKER AREA STREET PAV G AND LIGHTING PROJECT. Work to be compl ted during the 1989 constructi year. CIT'Y HALL SEVEN FLOOR SAINT PAUI., MINNESOTA 55102 �ae � r e 7. 10/3/89 Ratification of Assessments: For the Approved 3-0 construction of the ALBERMARLE/NEBRASKA AREA STORM SEWER PROJECT. Work to be completed in 1989 construction year. 8. 10/3/89 Ratification of Assessments: For the Approved 3-0 construction of the ALBEMARLE/NEBRASKA AREA STREET PAVING AND LIGHTING PROJECT. Work to be completed in 1989 construction year. 9. 9/28/89 Ratification of Assessments: For the Approved 3-0 construction of storm sewer service stub connections in conjunction with the PAYNE/ARCADE EAST SEWER PROJECT and the FLANDRAU/IDAHO AREA STORM SEWER PROJECT. 10. 10/3/89 Ratification of Award of Damages: Approved 3-0 Condemning and taking permanent utility easements and temporary construction easements for the SYLVAN/ACKER AREA STORM SEWER SEPARATION PROJECT. 11. 9/26/89 Final Order: Improving the north-south Approved 3-0 alley in Dawson's Rearrangement of Block 76 of Banning and Oliver's Addition to West St. Paul by grading and paving alley from Winona Street to Curtice Street. Also, slope construction in the grading and paving of said alley. �"(bounded by CURTICE, CHIPPEWA, WINONA AND DELAWARE). 12. 9/26/89 Final Order: Sidewalk construction and/or reconstruction at the following locations: S89-69 - East side BIRMINGHAM STREET from Approved 3-0 E. Seventh Street to York Avenue, West side BIRMINGHAM STREET from E. Rescinded Seventh Street to Case Avenue and 3-0 South side CASE AVENUE from Clarence Approved 3-0 Street to Birmingham Street S89-70 - Southeast side W. SEVENTH STREET Laid over to from Walnut Street to Ramsey Street at 270 10/4 W. Seventh Street with integral curb. 13. 10/3/89 Final Order: Sidewalk reconstruction on Approved 3-0 the North side of Ford Parkway from S. Finn Street to S. Cretin Avenue and West side S. FINN STREET from Ford Parkway to Pinehurst Avenue. . . - 14. 9/26/89 Final Order: Condemning and taking a Approved 3-0 temporary co struction easement over and across Lots 0 thru 12, Block 2, Griebe and Brewster Addition to the City of Saint Paul i conjunction with the MARSHALL/HAM INE AREA SEWER PROJECT. 15. 9/26/89 Final Order: Condemning and taking a Approved 3-0 temporary co struction easement over and across the w sterly 50 feet of the easterly 60 eet of Lot 16, Block 4, Rice Street Villa in conjunction with the ALBEMARLE/NE RASKA AREA SEWER PROJECT. 16. Resolution 8 -1496: Adopting the study of Laid over to the STREET L GHTING in St. Paul , directing 10/4 its transmit al to the neighborhood contact list Long Range CIB Committee, Planning Com ission and appropriate city staff, and a lowing District Councils to create stree lighting plans which identify exc ptions, and requesting the Planning Co ission to establish criteria as stated. (Laid over in Committee 8/30/89) . 17. Letter of DI TRICT ENERGY submitting rates Laid over to to be charg to hot water customers 10/4 effective 0 ober 1, 1989. (Laid over in Committee 8/ 6/89) . R�CEIV��7 NOTICE OF OB ECTIONS OF BETHESDA LUTHERAN �7GP 2 P 19g9 MEDICAL CENT R TO PROPOSED ASSESSMENT FOR SYLVAN/ CKER STORM SEWER PROJECT ��T'( �' r� ' BY T E CITY OF SAINT PAUL Pursuant to Minn. Stat. 549.061, Bethesda Lutheran Medical Center (BLMC) , 559 Capitol Boulevard, St. Paul , Minnesota, 55103, objects to proposed assessment number 22 3, File No. 18542, for the following properties: PIN: 31-29-22-24-0086 PIN: 31-29-22-23-0068 PIN: 31-29-22-23-0011 BLMC objects to the proposed assessments for the following reasons: A. the proposed asses ments constitute an unconstitutional taking of BLMC's property without just compensation in violation of the Fourteenth Amendm t to the United States Constitution and Article I, Sectio Seven of the Constitution of the State of Minnesota; B. the proposed asse sments are not uniform upon the same classes of property in vi lation of Article X, Section One of the Constitution of t e State of Minnesota; C. the proposed asse sments constitute an unfair, disproportionate, arbitrary and ex ssive proportion of the costs of the improvement; D. the proposed ass ssments exceed the special benefits conferred on the property; and E. the assessment p ocedure followed by the City of St. Paul is in violation of Min . Stat. § 429.061. WHEREFORE, BLMC requests hat the City deny approval of the proposed assessments and that a reasse sment be made, reduced and limited to such amounts as are proper and in ccordance with applicable law. Dated: �-S f� �/� J n G. atterson ttorney License No. 144320 Of MOORE, COSTELLO & HART 1400 Norwest Center 55 East Fifth Street St. Paul , Minnesota 55101 Telephone: (612) 227-7683 Attorneys for Bethesda Lutheran Medical Center 30645.7 - 2 - C-� $�l-17�s' �BSO �4 ASSE3�SbIENT/�iID . . '� '"Y v.�+�:: �� 7ui�� _4• . �,�,i 1 „'�i� , ta;' ..t._ . �,�,,,'. ' . sy�f ' �Ot7IICi'1��I��1 '��ls�-��-i��r �.�� `,:: � ?'i�k� , ., � . �-.c � 'A,��t�'�0��C�}� �� lE COlfi�lt1� � � Cl�• +.oaVrQa SEWBT�p . '1�11� 8l�S 1 and5; 1'der 88-1�ap!��diveY� ,�'Order' , S9-7i ,�ianu ry 3 i989. _ ;� .: �,. � .�;•-._ o co� (I��put'�ii�'�o�-�vnit�►the a � f �� t1�u �l�tihe�l i� -.� , ,� •,.',, �° �t y��,,,;�,� „, `, :,. . ��M��le.be� - � 'F" - r.•, ::- f F'�o,��i�e z. -' . E li��;is�ll�l##�t b�►°8ti�l m4� �4�►�1R a12. � 1�C8�1 ,' r �'"t ,�" z ��'s:;�. }�.:�' ' �S�'� t �� be� �n i�� /��y�, � " y� -`�:otj�9�O'Clo�cyk�.�., . � y :=:�+�knccil �..lialB � I p ' . 7�M�11��aaabs�I?rai�C: �i'.° `��18t I �1C��!! �# . ��'�� .AS� �t� T+ St8t�,�" �t�� , �H�,� ', T�t�r... •�12 � jlrijl �{��'$��y .��s.�*�!H'�f31!�" �• 1' � .�� ,WiR�V3 r,:�a s.y�r...:y. . ,4: ��.€ �:.r� ft�,- " � .. ,�}x�. 5 r c ? . File Na 1 isas.8�i3 ` . �c�:°� "�?- iA�6�rt��'We Auguat i�.19aB. � �, � ��`.. Id. 989. . . . � (�1ugt�s�`� 19� - . ,.,