89-1575 WHITE - CITV CLERK COLLI1C11
PINK �- FINANCE
�LUERV- MAVOR�MENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL File NO. '��7�
• �j
� � �� ndnce Ordinance N 0. ! ��0�
Presented By
Re erred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
-2-
based on the s uare foota e of the retail area
o t e esta is men :
2, 000 square feet o less . . . . . $ 500 .00
, - , squar eet . ,
, - , squa e eet ,
, square ee more . . , "
ection 3
This ordinance shall tak effect and be in force thirty (30)
days after its passage, appro al and publication.
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond `�^
��g� � In Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
s�he;ne� _� Against By
Sonnen
�V'�lso�r-
N�V — � � Form App oved by City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date ,
Certified Pas ed y� ncil Se tary BY
���'�
By
Appro Ma,or: Date � V � 3 17� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
gy By
pUBtiS�D ��'�`�; y il 1989
` � . . . � � � . . • �. � ' �Y9--�,5�s
s��?'��@ CITY OF SAINf�Ay�L
�~� ''r' OFFICE OF 7HE CITY ATTORNEY
;; �-
'� �nill'lllu ;=
`,;� m 1�111 11 ^`�
<;m EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY
""�„�,n.°:'m'°'� 647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102
612-298-5121
GEORGE LATIMER
MAYOR
.�-��*
August 22, 1989 `f p��`�,
__ _.u.d � .� �
r/ -� � �.����,
('7:�,.�4, (_F I..��....
To : Bill Wilson
From: Phil Byrne � , �
,,, ,
i.i i'_.�.._ v�r�L���.:. ;
Re: Off-Sale Fines
I enclose a signed draft ordi ance allowing fines to be imposed on
off-sale licensees on the sam basis as for on-sale licensees .
The square footage figure has been left blank, to be filled in
after committee work on it . would suggest asking the committee
staff to call John Berglund t get the square footage figures of
his membership, and whether t ere is any relationship or constant
relating gross sales to squar feet of retail space.
If you want a number in the b anks before introduction, my
preliminary rough guesstimate �.were:
2 , 000 square feet o less . . . . . . $ 500 . 00
2 , 001 - 5 , 000 squar feet . . . . . . $1 , 000 . 00
5, 001 - 10, 000 squa feet . . . . . . $1 ,500. 00
10, 001 square feet o more . . . . . . $2 , 000. 00
I' d be happy to revise the dr t if you want .
Enc . ���— �� GGC 1�J , �
C�'��� ����uac
��o�i s �yes-----
��
_ . . , ,� � � ' . �d't-�5��5
DEPARTMENT/OFFl NpL DATE I ITIAT D
CITY COUNCIL 8 4i GREEN SHEET No. 5 3 2 8 /7�/�
CONTACT PERSON 6 PHONE INITIAU DATE INITIALIDATE
�DEPAR7UAENT DIRECTOR �CITY COUNCIL
Councilmember Bill Wilson x4646 NuM ❑CITY AITORNEY �CITY CLERK
MU8T BE ON WUNpI AOENDA BY(DA7� ROUTI �BUDQET DIRECTOR �FIN.Q MOT.8ERVICEB DIR.
�MAYOR(OR A8818TMIT) �
TOTAL N OF SIQNATURE PAOES (CLIP LL OCATIONS FOR SIONATUR�
ACTION REGUESTED:
Approval of ordinance permitting fines n lieu of suspensions as penalty for off-sale
liquor license violations. ;
RECOMMENDATIONS:Approve(N a►�(R) COUN L MMITTEE/RESFARCH REPORT OPTIONAL
ANALY PHONE NO.
_PLANNINO OOMMISSION _qVIL SERVICE COMMI3810N I
_qB OOMMITfEE _
COMM TS:
—STAFF _
_DISTRICT WURT — �
$UPPORTS WHlpi CaINpL OBJECTIVE9 �
�
INITIA71NC3 PROBLEM,ISSUE,OPPORTUNI7Y(Who,Whet,Whsn,Where,Wh�: I
�
Council recently adopted fines in li�u f suspensions for on-sale liquor license viola-
tions; this would allow the same op io for off-sale establishments.
I
�
�
�
i,
I
ADVANTAOES IF APPROVED:
1. Consistency.
2. Greater flexibility in dealing w th liquor license violations.
3. Additional revenue to city from in s.
DISADVANTA(iE3 IF APPHOVED:
None.
�
DISADVANTAOE8 IF NOT APPROVED:
Possible confusion and perception of un airness regarding liquor license penalties on
the part of licenses. �
� Council Research Center
� AUG 24��'8:9
�
�
I
TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION s � WST/REVENUE BUDQETED(CIRCLE ONE) YES NO
i
I
FUNDIN�i SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER
FlNANdAL INFORMATION:(IXPWN) i
i
i
� �
, ' /5�
� � � - . � � ��'
/��4`�
Community and Human Services Committee
COMMITTEE REPORT
October 19, 1989
Page Two
5. Cit Council A enda 9/12/89, Item o. 20: Second Readin - 89-1575 -
ordinance amendin Cha ter 409 of he Le islative Code allowin fines in
off-sale intoxicatin li uor estab ishments in lieu of sus ensions.
(Ref.erred to the Communit and Hu n Services Committee.)
Recommended for approval on 3-0 vo e.
6. Child Care Finance Pro ram, as re ested b Gre Davidson, Nei hborhood
Develo ment Division of P.E.D. (C ntinued from Au ust 2, 1989.)
Resolution was prepared. Amended . uidelines and breakdown of costs to
be prepared. Will be brought dire tly to Council.
7. Re uest of James P. Stodolka: To ear before the Communit and Human
Services Committee to d�scuss a ne' hborhood rat roblem. (Laid over
from Se tember 6, 1989 for Cit De artment's in ut.) (Laid over to
October 18, 1989. Communit Servi es will re are ordinance amendment.)
Jerry Segal will prepare an ordina ce which is to be introduced directly
to Council.
cc: A1 Olson
Ed Starr
� �,=�C_ �--�1�'-�"'ti,
" � �Members:
� � �, "'� Janice Rettman, chair
' � � �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL
- t��,,;:, Bill Wilson
• ����tt:�i
,
OFFICE OF THE C[TY COUNCIL Bob Long
'h�' �.�,. .
Date: October 19, 1989
JANICE RETTMAN
Counc�7person Co m m ittee Report
To: Saint Paui City Council
From : Community and Human Services Committee
Janice Rettman, Chair
A meeting of the Community and Human Services Committee was held on Wednesday,
October 18, 1981. ,
1. Approval of Minutes of Qctober 4, 1989 meetin�.
Minutes approved on 3-0 vote.
2. City Council Agenda 8/24/89, Item No. 4: Letter of Steve Rice submitting
the 1989 St. Paul Overnight Shelter Board report.
A motion was made that a resolution be drafted for acceptance of this
report. This was recommended for approval on a 3-0 vote.
3. City Council Agenda 9/12/89, Item No. S: Resolution - 89-1608 - Authorizing
proper City Officials to promulgate an approved list of eligible organizations
for the charitable gambling Ten Percent Club. (Referred to Community and
Human Services Committee.)
Recommended for approval, with amendments, on 3-0 vote. Amendments include
changing of "Mariucci Hockey Skate Club" to "Mariucci Inner City Hockey"
(page 1) , and the addition of "Phalen Youth Club", on page 2.
4. City Council Agenda 9/5/89, Item No. 30: First Reading - 89-1574 - An
ordinance amending Chapter 409 Af the Legislative Code pertaining to hours
and days of sale for intoxicating liquor licenses in conformity with recent
State law changes. (For referral to the Community and Human Services
Committee.)
City Council Agenda 10/17/89, Item No. 15: First Reading - 89-1881 - An
ordinance amending Section 409.07 of the Legislative Code to change the
hours of sale for intoxicating liquor licenses on Sundays in conformity with
recent State law changes. (For referral to the Community and Human Services
Committee.)
Ordinance Numbers 89-1574 and 89-1881 moved out of committee with no
recommendation. -
CTTY HALL ROOM NO.'718 SAINT PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102 612/298-5�'
a.�.4e
_ � - lst ,��d'/ . - 2::d� �� �� /-�'�
� - 3rd "' ��.,�-� � � Adopted ��—�`,y_.�
- - � _��_�j ;� -a �: - �
� Ye • Nays
DIMOND //�����J�'f�
�i�
GOSWITZ ��/�,�%.(�'
�f' /
LONG. . � �
RETTMAN
SONNEN
- WILSON
MR. PRESIDENT� SCHEIBEL
,
WHITE , - CITV GLERK COUIICll /J
Fi:NK � FINANCE
CANARV -��PARTMENT GITY O� SAINT PAUL �/
�BLJE „-�„�AVOR ..--.� Fll@ NO. � /�"
r indnce � + J\0 rdinance N�. � ��od 7
�. /
Presented By
//Referred To � � Committee: Date '�'��—°1
Out of Committee By Date
An ordinance amending Chapter 6 , sections 213M, 218R, .522, .532,
.544 and .773 and Chapter 62, s ctions .103(g) and .104 of the Saint
Paul Legislative Code pertair�in to the Zoning Code - Restaurants.
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAIfL OES ORDAIN:
Sect on 1.
That section 60.213M of the Sai t Paul� Legislative Code be and is
hereby amended to-�-as follo s:
Multi-nse retail cerrter. A sin le uni ied develo ment on one zonin lot which
rovides commercial s ace to a variet of reta� uses and as at east 20 000
square feet of gross leasable area.
Sect on 2.
That section 60.218R of the Sai t Paul Legislative Code be and is
hereby amended to read as follo s:
Re��ab�aq��--A-��s�wess-es�a���sqr�ew�- qese-���ps��a�-��s�qess-�s-�qe-se����g
s€-�fl�ael�age�-€ee�-�e-�qe-s�s�e�ef-#�- -�ea��r-�e-seps��e-��a�e3-��a_�p���r��da�
se���qgs3-ef-�fl-�epd�s�esab�e-se��a�pe s3-aa�-wbe�e-�qe-s�s�e�e�-ee����es
�qese-€eeds-wq��e-sea�e�-a�-�a��es-e�- e���efs-�esa�ed-w��q�A-a-�b��d�flg�
,�' Restaurant. A ublic eatin lace whi h serves a substantial ortion of its
��;; food for consum tion at tables or coun ers located on the remises. This term
��-� s a inc u e ut not e imite to an esta is ment known as a cafe
�.�j smor asbord, diner or simi ar business An aci ities or carr -out shall be
c ear su or inate to the rinci a u e of rovidin foods for consum tion on
the premises.
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
rn�ona Planninn and Economic Develo ment
�� In Favor `j��
cosw;tz
Rettman
scbe;be� +� Against BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Approve y City Attorney
Adopted by Council: Date j
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY � ,'
� l �
eY / ;✓
Approved by Mayor: Date Approv � Mayor for Submis o
By B
. . , . C��'y=i..���
- ' � � i�G�9
f2��;-rtri�e-Yjr.--fl-�na3aea�-es ab�f��mer��-r��ese-�r3se3}�a�-�nsiness-�s
��e-se��3�g-af-fead;-€reser�-desser�a er-�e�►e�ases-�e-��e-ens�ee�e�r-��-a
read�-�e-eo�sn�e-s�a�e;-3a-�nd�iv�de�a -serv�it�g�;-and-K�ere-��e-eas�emer
eer�snmes-��ese-feeds;-€�ase�-ele�ser� -e�r-bere�n�e�-f�-an-anteme���e-�ar�Ceel
npoa-��e-pre�3ses:
� Restaurant carr -out. A retail oo service business which sells
�4�� } read -to-eat foods usuall in bu k uantities rimaril for consum tion off
� �; the remises. A carr -out restauran that has more than limited seatin 12
��' r' or fewer seats or 75 s uare feet o atron area shall be deemed to be a
�' l restaurant for zoninst purnoses.
itest�m^a�;-fa�-�-�ee�:--l�-�ns3ness- �a���s�►�ea�-N�ese-��3t�e3}�a�-�n�3sess-3s
��e-se��3ng-af-pre-�repared;-qn�e�C- eler;-a�d-pae#aged-�eeda-�r�-a
ready-�e-eensn�e-s�a�e;-�n-�r�d3�fda �-ser�r�s��;-fe�-eeasnmp��er�-er�-e�-e€€-��e
}�rem�se�;-sad-N�►ere-��e-�ae�Cage;-Kr }���ag-e�-eet��a�r�e�-�a-er-es-M��ie�-��e-�eed
3s-se�d-3s-�ape�;-}��as��e-er-e��er- a�s�a�ee-e€-a-r�er�re�a�r�ab�e-a�d-d3s�esa��e
na�n�e:
f
� ; Best urant f t-food. A blic at n lace desi ned for ra id food deliver
`; to customers seated in their aut mo iles or from a counter or drive-thru
f��'� window with minimal ersonal se vi e and for consum tion on or off the
�:; � remises. All restaurants with ri e-thru service are considered fast-food
�ti� �restaurants.
/ An restaurant whose desi n or rin i al method of o eration includes four or
; more of the followin characteristi s �hall be deemed a ast-fo d restaurant
for zonin ur oses: 1 45 erce or more of the floor area is devoted to
' food re aratian em lo ee work s e and customer service rea 2 a
ermanent nenu board is rovide f m which to select and order food 3 if a
chain or franchised restaurant st ndardized floor lans are used over several
�� locations 4 customers a for f od before consumin it 5 a self-service
condiment bar is rovided 6 tra h rece tacles are rovided for self-service
bussin 7 furnishin lan in ic tes hard finished stationar seatin
' arran ements and 8 moat main co rse food items are re- acka ed rather than
��made to order.
ection 3.
That section 60.522 of the aint Paul Legislative Code be and is
hereby amended as follows:
(2) Retail businesses which suppl commodities on the premises, such as, but
not limited to, groceries, me ts, dairy products, baked goods or other
foods, drugs, dry goods, clot ing and notions, hardware, books,
stationery, plants, carr -out restaurants and hobby supplies.
10-►9-��1
. . . . ��-i.���
� �� ,����
Section 4.
That section 60.532 of the Saint Paul Le�islative Code be and is
hereby amended as follows:
d. Restaurants e�r-e��er-p�aee -ser�3r�g-€eed-a�-�everages;-exeep�-d��ve-3r�
er-€as�-foad-res�an�ar��s:a d fast-food restaurants when incor orated
within a multi-use reta'1 enter or lanned sho in center and which
do not rovide drive-th u indow service.
Section 5.
That section 60.544 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code be and is
hereby amended as follows:
(4) Restaurants, fast food ar��-d ��►e-3a, subject to the following conditions:
d. Site shall ave a mini� m f 100 feet of street fronta e on its
Drincipal access street.
e. Trash rece tacles shall be housed in a three-side masonr enclosure
six feet hi h or e ual i hei ht to the dum ster whichever is
reater and have an entra ce ate constructed of a durable o a ue
material.
f. A litter collection lan s all be develo ed and submitted to the
Plannin Commission whi h bli ates the restaurant o erator to kee
the area surroundin sa'd estaurant ree of restaurant litter f r a
reasonable s ecified dista ce.
g_S eaker box sounds from dr ve-thru lane shall not be lainl a dible
so as to unreasonabl d'st rb the e ce uiet and co�fort of abuttin
residential bronertv.
h. A landsca ed area not 1 ss than 15 ercent of the im ervious surface
area of the lot shall be ovided and maintained.
e1ri. Impact on adjoining proper y by use of the site may not result in the
following:
1. Loud, boisterous, and disturbing noise levels.
2. Hazardous traffic con itions.
3. Offensive, obnoxious, and disturbing odors.
4. Excessive litter.
5. Excessive artificial i�hting.
6. Substantial decrease ' adjoining property values.
�.- fln�r-e��e�-eer►e13��e�t-3 eetts3s�er��-M3�#�-��e-reasena��e-ase-artd
en�e�►�en�-e€-ad3e���r� -pre�e���-and-tneens���er��-w3��-�#�e-�ea��i�;
aa€e��►;-ese�a�s;-ar�el-g ne�a�-Me��are-e�€-��e-ad3e�r��r►g-ee��e���i��:
) o—I 9-��
, . , . . �dr�j'-,cs��
- � � 7l��'l
Se tion 6.
That section 60.773 of the Sa nt Paul Legislative Code be and is
hereby amended to read as fol ows:
(6) Restaurants, fast-food, subject to the following conditions:
d. Site shall have a minimum of 00 feet of street fronta e on its
vrincinal access street.
e. Trash rece tacles shall be ho sed in a three-sided masonr enclosure
six feet hi h or e ual in he' ht to the dum ster w ichever is
reater and have an entranc ate constructed of a durable o a ue
material.
f. A litter collection lan sha 1 be develo ed and submitted to the
Plannin Commission which ob i ates the restaurant o erator to kee
the area surroundin said re taurant free of restaurant litter for a
reasonable s ecified distanc .
�. S eaker box sounds from d iv -thru lane shall not be lainl au ible
so as to unreasonabl dis ur the eace uiet and co�fort of abutti
residential vroperty.
h. A landsca ed area not less t an 15 ercent of the im ervious surface
area of the lot shall be ro ided and maintaine .
dsi. Impact on adjoining property by use of the site may not result in the
following:
1. Loud, boisterous, and d sturbing noise levels.
2. Hazardous traffic condi ions.
3. Offensive,. obnoxious, d diaturbing odors.
4. Excessive litter.
5. Excessive artificial 1'ghting.
6. Substantial decrease i adjoining property values.
�.- An�-e��e�-eendi�ier�-3r► a���s�e��-Ni��-��e-rea�ena��e-�se-a,�el
e��e�►mer��-e€-sel3e�r��ag p�eper��-a.�d-�neer�s3a�er►�-����-��e-�ea���;
sa€e��;-me�a�s;-and-ge e�a�-He�€are-e€-��e-a.rl�e�ie�3�g-ee�mna���*:
ection 7.
That section 62.103(g) of t e Saint Paul Legislative Code be and is
hereby amended as follows:
(3) Business and commercial.
e. �s�ab�3s�men�-�er-�a�e-at�d e�'a�}��fer►-er�-��e-p�emi�ea-e€-�e�erages;
€eed-e�-re�'�es�e�e��s:
1 �-- ► 9-c� �