99-1132Council File # � -,�3a�
ORIG{NAL
Presented By
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
� . ����`�'�a ,�3�°�
Green Sheet #
�3
Referred To
Committee:
RESOLVED, that the license application submitted by Ra s Auto Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's
Auto Body (License ID Number 940004184) for the premises 1 ated at 353 Lazch Street is
hereby denied for failing to provide all required information cessary to process the license
application and for failing to installed an approved spray bo th.
This Resolution and the action taken above are based
1999, Notice of Violation letter to the licensee. The ]
violation. �
the facts contained in the October 12,
;e did not contest the facts of the
Requested by Department of:
/I/��r". / , "J�'
Adopted by Counc'1
/
Adoption Cex�E' ied
�
By:
Approved by Mayor:
By:
Date
by Council Secretaxy
Date
Form Approved b�3' City Attorney
By: (/ 2-L � �
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Office of LIEP
Robert Kessler
November 24. 1999 — Consent
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
�q-t13�.
No 1 G4j-31
�
m�roRecrae Urnrea�aci_
u�v�na�eEr ❑ ane�aut
twwcw��ort ❑ wux�uLLaE.�e�ccro
r�vo¢Pu�nwrl �
(CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Resolution recommending denial of the Auto Body Repair Garage and AuYo Repair Garage License
Applications by Ray's Auto Body, Inc., 353 Larch Street.
dOAl10N ApproVe (A) w K¢�%
PIP.NNlNG CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CMl SERVICE COMMISSION
.._ • 3.
IF APPROVED
IF NOT
TRANSACTION t
Fiac tivs P�� erer Morketl untiv e arA�act fartlec dePeNment9
YES NO
Flas mis P�rm e�er Geen a tlry emvbYKT
YES NO
Dcee M(s persoMmm D� a sW'W not �wrmelMP�ssed M�Y ��� �Y �MWoYY�
YES NO
b ihis D��T�m a �arpMed veMaYt
YES NO
COET/REVENUE BUOGEfED (GRCLE ONt� YES
ACTrvITY NUMBER
NO
INFORMATION (IXPW�
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton M. Robinson, Jr., City Attorney � q.�`,� �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
November 2, 1999
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Larch Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
c:vit Divisiors
400CityHa11 Te7ephoxe:651266-8710
ISWestKe7loggBlyd Facsimile:657298-56I9
Saint Paul, Minnesata 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
'�; �`sCvF
��as.s?��;���,�_..�, •
�,� � � q ��,
i <. :? '1 `o' � 4.3�
RE: Auto Body Repair Gazage and Auto Repair Garage License Applications by Ray's Auto
Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body for the premises at 353 Larch Street in St. Paul
License ID #: 990004189
Deaz Mr. Holbrook:
Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting
scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 24,1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third
Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
concerning the failure to submit information necessary to process your license application and
the failure to complete installation of an approved spray booth have not been denied. The
recommendation of the license office will be for the denial of your license application.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
VL M-c�� , Q�R�.-u�
Virginia�Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER aq � 1�3a.
Licensee Name: Ray's Auto Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body
Address:
Council Date:
Violation:
Place:
353 Larch Street
November 24, 1999
Failure to Provide Information Necessary to
Process License Application
Failure to Complete Installation of an Approved
Spray Booth
Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Denial of License Application
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. 9/13/99 letter from Christine Rozek to Hager Holbrook
5. 9/3/99 letter from Christine Rozek to Hager Holbrook
6. License information
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
October 12, 1999
OFFICE �° THE CITY pT'I'pgNgy
Clayton N. �irsson, Jr., Ciry A[forney
c�q.. ! t3a�
Civi! Divisian
400 Ciry Ha1T Telephone: 651266-8710
I S West Kellogg E(vd F¢csimile: 651298-56I9
Sain! Pau1, ,Llinnesafa SSIO2
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Lazch Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Auto Body Repair Garage and Auto Repair Garage License Applications by Ray's Auto
Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body for the premises at 353 Larch Street in St. Pau1
License ID #: 990004189
Deaz Mr. Holbrook:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environxnental Protection has recommended that
the license applications listed above be denied. The basis for the recommendation is as follows:
On September 3,1999 and September 13,1999, you were sent
letters by the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection that your license applications were still incomplete.
You were advised on both occasions that you still needed to
submit a copy of your lease or purchase agreement, a sife plan,
a signed license application and a copy of your State of
Minnesota Tax Identification Number Certificate. As of
today's date you have still not provided the signed application
or the State of Minnesota Tas ID Certificate. Additionally, the
Fire Department will not approve your license application for
an Auto Body Repair Garage until you have completed the
installation of an approved spray booth. This had not been
done as of October 6,1999.
If you do not want to dispute the matter, you must send me a letter admitting the facts stated
above and ask that the matter be set in front of the City Council to determine what penaity, if
any, will be imposed. You wili have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or
to have someone appeaz there for you.
Page 2
Mr. Hager Holbrook
October 12, 1999
ctq-tl3a
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, you may request an administrative
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge. If you wish to have a hearing, you must let me
know that in writing. I will then schedule the hearing and send you a notice w�ith the time, date
and place of the hearing, the name of the administrative law judge who will preside, and a brief
description of the procedures to be followed.
Please let me know in writing no later than Friday, October 22, 1999 how you would like to
proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I will assume that you are not
contesting the facts indicated above. The matter will then be scheduled before the City
Council on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended denial of your license application will be imposed.
Please be on notice that your business location does not currently have a license to operate an
Auto Repair Garage or an Auto Body Repair Garagebusiness at this locarion, and you aze not
permitted to operate without such a license. You must, therefore, immediately cease all
operations at this location. If you continue to operate evidence of that fact may be used in
addition to other evidence to deny your license.
If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attomey call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� J/ ✓u.��`�J ��utll
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
aq-<<3�
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly swox'n, deposes and says
that on October 12, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Larch Street
St. Paul, MN. 55117
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the Unit�e�'SL�tes mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota. / 1 ., � ,
Subscribed and sworn to be£ore me
this 12th day g€� Octp�er, 1999.
Notary P NOTARYPUBLIC-MINNES�TA
"'' My Comm. Expires Jan. 37, 2JC1
a9 - i 13a.
lo �
n�
W�
N I
O C I
�- m p
y U�
R � Lo
a �o
r
0
C
�
t
O
«
m
E
L
�
C
d
N
C
d
U
J
�
�
m
�
N p�
N �
C �
U �
-' a
N
�
N �
c6
O_ (,
H �
m
N�N
c �
U O
J �
Q
� I
a> �
� �i
o �I�
Z i, �
c ° o
U �
J �
a
(0
�
H
y
mU
i �
�
Q ^
M �
��
fl
�
m
� �
m �
Z Q
Q
0 }
�
U
Z
}
0
O
m
m �
Z �
C Q
o �
a¢
�
�U
C
�
O
U
C
�
� o
a�
m
0
a
x
w
N
C
N
�
E
�
Z
U
O
a
U
c
�
�
W
C
E
m
�,
c
m
a
U
U
C
�
3
N
C
N
Q
�
�
Z
N
C �
O �
= n
a
N �
`� r
m ^
C
� �
m �
� z
~Z
W
�
2
U
g
M
�
C')
C
N '�q L
a � .0 � O
� "a = a
�N a�i o 3 �^
'o N N � � fl.
� � N �= N
� � dc 3
�� 3 N'- O
a�- - c � r
—� . �O_ 3
¢� a�ic�a; >.
Ea a�ny��N v
LL @ � . tn �"O �
�1 p �C O� O
U C LL E� N N �
mN � d� U N `�
�a O ° � >
o� Q �� a � o
pm U �crn °-
d a
¢ 000��o �
Uii
a d���m �
a�o v _
�rn�mc��„` 3
o�4�a.. • ��
� mV ac�� c.a�iUc:
O) �i uI���01 �
rn- rnrnrnrn� rn
rn:a $rnrnrnrn �-3rn
<cn� .-rr N o�
� C�(7M�� �('7
O'O N�ON� N
O L»m��� �n
O OOOW..O
a9 -�«a-
�
w
�
0
a
x
N W
� N O
N d O
d V N
A � O
a �co
0
�'
0
17.
�
C
O
w
R
E
L
O
C
N
�,
c
N
�
_1
N
'
Y
�
�
N �
c �
� 'a
U C
J �
a
N
rn
m
c�
�n m
T �
F-
N �
C �
m
U O
J j
Q
� LI
�
� �
� �I�
� I�
Z
a� io
c ° o
U �
J �
�
N
�
F
�
N =
mU
� �
Qgn
�
� �
��
�
O
m
� �
m ~
Z �
4 a
� }
LY
U
Z
�
�
m
z�
c ¢
o�
a ¢
�
�U
C
�
O
U
i
N
� o
a>
m
�
L
X
N
C
N
�
E
�
Z
�
O
a
N
c
�
N
C
E
m
Z
C
Q
�
U
m
N
C
N
E
�
z
N
G �
L �
�
N
m
w �
N ^
C
7 �
�
� C�
Z
m p
Z
W
a
F
�
_
U
�
g
�
C
N m �p .�.
� a .0 � O
, � 0. a
m
'p N � �
N � N ( p = y
N...O p)
� � N N � O
� _ � = c .c
—m -° . m .
.rna 3
¢ O .u�i���
�Q Qt�y� V� O
LL � O N= O� O
U = � E � N N �
mN ����N �
pv O'v v�� o
c d a--
c° ( °-
a
U ii o o p>.$ m
m
N V (�j � � C
�m�NC��L
O � A `���n..rC �
s
�`�cma`�3�
�'m oc�.- nyV�:
� 3 �j��m�Y W
rn= y rnrnrn rn� rn
rn:� �rnrnrnrn �-3rn
��n� .-�c-� N o�
� �mMMC� �ch
O'O �N
O ` 3m0)01�� �n
00000co.,.,o
OFFlCE OF LICE\SE, I\SPECTIO\S A\D
EXVIRO\�iL-\T.4L PROTLCTIO\
P,oGert Krss(er, DireUOr
CIrY OF SAINT PAUL
,\'orm Cole�r.rn, i!n)'or
Sep;zmber 13, 1949
19990004159
?�4r. Aaszr Rzy Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body Inc
DB_A Ray's Auto Body
353 Larch Street
Saint Paul'��I�I 5� 117
LOI:'P.YPP,OFESSIO\�AL BL'/LDL\'G
Sui:e i 00
JJO SL PelerSireel
Saint Pnul, .L'inr.esom »IG?-1510
Re: New License Application at 3�3 Larch Street (Second :Votice)
Dear Applicant:
aa.i�3a-
Telepl;mve: 6�/-?66-9090
Fr. csinr,"le: 6� I-]66-9099
651-I66-91?4
9fter extensive re�ie«�, I hace determined yow license application _19990004189 (from
Ju]y 12, 1999) is stil] incomplete. At this time, your business license record (I.D.
119990004189) for an Auto Repair Garzee and Auto Body Repair GaraQe license has
been inactivated until the followin� item(s) are recei��ed:
• Copy of }�our Property Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of O��mership or Bill
of Sale
• Site plan - A detailed description of the desi�n, location, and square foota�e of
the premises to be licensed
• Signed license application
• Copy of your State of Minneso:a Tax Identification Number Certificate
1'our license has not been issued. If you are conducting an Auto Repair Gara�e and
Auto Body Repair business, you are doing so without a valid City of Saint Paul license
and may be subject to adverse action and penalties. Ifyou k�ish to continue to operate
your business, you must submit the aforementioned requirements by September 22,
1999.
Please let us Imow, in writing, before September 22 whether or not you intend to
continue with this application or wish to permanently withdraw. After this date, this
office �•ill begin the administrative hearing process to drny your license request. You
have the opportunity to appeal the City's decision through this proceeding.
Ifyou have any questions regarding this action, p]ease contact me at (651) 266-9108.
Sincerely
(�I�Za�.o�:v �, �
Christine Rozek �
LIEP Deputy Director
CAR/cam
SYtxS
?hnL
�
eeee
CI1Y OF SAINT PAUL
j'ornr Colen:mr, I.Sn�'or
September 3, 1999
19990004159
?�4r. Ha�er Ray Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body Inc
DBA Ray's .4uto Body
3�3 Larch Strezt
SaintPaul�1N 5�117
Re: \'ew License Applicztion at 3�3 Larch Street
Deaz Applicant:
OFFICE OF LIC[\SE, I\SPEC710\S A\D
E\VIRO\\:ESTALPROTLCTIOV �Q
RaGcri K� cs(n', DirtUOr �
LONRY PROFES90.\!SL Telephm�e: 651-;E6-9090
BL%ILD!\'G Fr.csimile: 65l-'66-9l24
3�0 St. Pcler S:reet
Sui�e 300
Sr.ir;tPnuLAfinr.esctn 55/02
This letter is to formally notify you of documentation our office still requires in order to complete
your application. Your license application for an Auto Repair Garaee and Auto Body Repair
Garase located at 353 Larch Street can not be processed until our office recei� es the follo���ing:
• A copy of your lease agreement or proof of oi;Tership or bill of sale of the property
• Site Plan - A detailed deseription of the design, ]ocarion, znd square footzee of the
premises to be Iicensed. �
• Si�ned license application (refer to attached application)
• A copy ofyour State ofMinnesota Tax Identification I�TUmber Certificate
Insurance certificates, Lezse Agreements�Bill of Sale, site plans, Articles of Incorporation and
lists may be faxed to our office at (651) 266-9124. ��e must obtain the required
paperw�orkJpayment before «�e can complete processin2 your license application.
At this rime, your license hzs not been issued; therefore, you are not authorized to operate in the
City of Saint Paul. You will not receive your license until all information and(or payments are
received in our office.
Ifyou have any questions or concems, please contact Corinne Dlartens, LIEP Project Facilitator
at (651) 2b6-9106.
Re�ards,
��
Christine A. Rozek � ��
LIEP Deputy Director
CARlcam
Attachment
a�
p$ , �''�1Sm I"�
Licensee F2AY'S AUTO
DBA Al^S AUTO
License Licensee � Uc. Types l Inswance , Bond 1 Requiremzrrts I
Licensee Name: AY'S AUTO BODY MC (y,-�.,�;�z.: �'
DBA: AY'S AUTO BODY
Seles Tax Itl: ENDMG Non-Profrt: (— VVOrker's Comp: OiU0N000 Properties...
AA Co�rac[ Rec'd. ONO10000 AA Training ftec'd: OlOON900 .
AA Fee Collectetl. ON�N000 DiscouM ReC'd: r
Othzr A enc Licenses Financiai Holtl fteasons
Other Liwnsmg Agency Neme f License Type �License #; Expiratidn Reason . '�' '`�'�ACtive �� Date �
Mail License To: —
r Mail To Corrtact
C�, License Address
Me0lnvoice To:
r Mal To Cnntact
_..,, „ _. .„ � _ � C L�cense AtltlreSs
�I lr . _ _ y .�
Background Check Required �� � CpritaC[ Propethes:.��
License #
� SaveCha�gestoHistary
,�Start `�3Grou: ¢�CoreL.-, �Custo:' �ECLI:,;; �ECLI, {�jLacen.;_�Prop.:..}���'�°�`�4�._945AR�I:_..�,
ag- ti
L3 Licer
p� b � in.'am .� S�
DHA
License I Licensee 1 Lic Types 1 Insurence l Bontl l RequiremeMS l
C•� Property � Licensee r Unofficiai Project Faaldetor. MARTENS, CORINNE
Street #. 53 I A Action CommeMs
Street Namc PACH ��1 mm �
Street Type. ST D'vechon: � I p � ;
Llndind �— Und#. r �'_"___________'_.._ _.____`__ ' __ J
Cdy T PAUL � Commerrts.
��e� �— Zip. 55��� � 929fl999forwardedtoCAOfarFOrmA.
��"� ; 9p 311999 2ntl nohce far requiremeMS serR, due 9R2.
Wartl' � '�Bron%se� � 9N3M9991st notice for requiremerits serM1.
DiK Council �76 � ER4f1999 per frre, Rsy in process of putting in spray
i oath . ' ' " _"_.' '
Licensea: �AY'S AUTO BODY INC CommeMS.
DBA' AY'S AUTO BODY
Sates iae ltl NDMG Bus Phone: 651) 771-2704
License # �90004189 �
-�_� � _� � � �;�.-��� �
�Start 6�Csou.:. Corel.� �Custo �" �ECLI::_ �EGLI... �Lieen ; �Prop... �6N���C�� 9�4AM .
%vY m �
aa-i►s.z.
� � �
Licensee
PaY Priirc," 'M'am Hin Su� DBA
License I Licensee I Lic.Types ' Insurance , Bontl
Licznse Type� uto Repair Garage
f
avs NNdicffiian
Pian
�rd Chzck
Requiremerds
�- � �Delete
W
0
0
0
�
mi
Candrtions CommeMs
IRE - Approved Auto repair warK (mechanicap only.SJJY
"' '_.__ _"_, —... '_'._'. . _.._.____ _.
'" _ '___... _._.._ � 2of2 '.:.'� ..�
License # �90004789 ' Save Lhangesto History
i� Stazt � �nu : �,Cpre1. �� Custo `„ ,�.. ECI;I :. � EGLI � kn �j Lic'ea;:: � Prnp . � j�j N, � -°�- �� `� AM �t':
qq•�t��
CandM1ions Cammerds �'�
8R471999 Per Fve, PF, in process of putting in a
praybouth. CAM
ire - Denied - Auto 0ody is a change af occupancy antl �.
- hus requires BID approval antl currerHry hes no spray '���..
' � ooth. S.NV '
�,
""._ . _..� _ "__ "__�___..._ � _.._ __.._._...___.,_..
!y s�`� 1 Of 2 ,.» j k I
_ _..—..__.. � __...
License #�90004189 _ Save Changes to His[ory
"i�Start �Grou_. E�Corel.,` < <`�,..Ciuto.. �ECL;I.. fJ„ECL[.� �Lic'eg._ �Prop._'��N�'S�
� $ � � � , �7 Licensee AV'S AUTO 60DY MC
Pay , Prim 'i^u'am Nst Summ � DBA AYS AUTO BODY
License , Ucensee l Lic. Types l Insurance l 6ontl ftequ�remerRS �
License Type: ^ u[o Botly Reparc Garage Atld ' - Delete
License Group Commentr Text
Licensee: Rq1^S AUTO BODY INC
�BA� RAY'S AUTO BODY
License#: �9990004'189
09/29/1999 forv✓arded to CAO for Form A.
09/'13lt999 2nd notice foc requirements sent. due 9/22.
09/03/1999 �st no6ce for requirements seni.
08/24/1999 per Fire, Ray in process of putting in spray booth.
8/9/99 spoke with Ray to gei lease and site plan in. He will mail tomortow. CAM
07/23/1999 fire will not approve (auto body) without spraybooth.
09/27/1999
�l °t `l L'JO.
Requirement Comments Text
Licensee: R,qy�S AUTO BODY INC
09/27N 999
DBA: Rqy'S AUTO BODY /� C� `' �� ^
_` ` �
License#: �ggg0004189
08/24/1999 Per Fire, PF, in process of putting in a spraybooth. CAM
Fire - Denied -Auto body is a change of occupancy and thus requires BID approval and curtently has no spray booth. SJW
Requirement Comments Text
Licensee: qp,Y'S AUTO BODY INC
�BA� RAY'S AUTO BODY
License #: �ggg0004189
09/27I7999
��(.L1�2-
FIRE-Approved. Autorepairwork(mechanical)only.SJW
Council File # � -,�3a�
ORIG{NAL
Presented By
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
� . ����`�'�a ,�3�°�
Green Sheet #
�3
Referred To
Committee:
RESOLVED, that the license application submitted by Ra s Auto Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's
Auto Body (License ID Number 940004184) for the premises 1 ated at 353 Lazch Street is
hereby denied for failing to provide all required information cessary to process the license
application and for failing to installed an approved spray bo th.
This Resolution and the action taken above are based
1999, Notice of Violation letter to the licensee. The ]
violation. �
the facts contained in the October 12,
;e did not contest the facts of the
Requested by Department of:
/I/��r". / , "J�'
Adopted by Counc'1
/
Adoption Cex�E' ied
�
By:
Approved by Mayor:
By:
Date
by Council Secretaxy
Date
Form Approved b�3' City Attorney
By: (/ 2-L � �
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Office of LIEP
Robert Kessler
November 24. 1999 — Consent
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
�q-t13�.
No 1 G4j-31
�
m�roRecrae Urnrea�aci_
u�v�na�eEr ❑ ane�aut
twwcw��ort ❑ wux�uLLaE.�e�ccro
r�vo¢Pu�nwrl �
(CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Resolution recommending denial of the Auto Body Repair Garage and AuYo Repair Garage License
Applications by Ray's Auto Body, Inc., 353 Larch Street.
dOAl10N ApproVe (A) w K¢�%
PIP.NNlNG CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CMl SERVICE COMMISSION
.._ • 3.
IF APPROVED
IF NOT
TRANSACTION t
Fiac tivs P�� erer Morketl untiv e arA�act fartlec dePeNment9
YES NO
Flas mis P�rm e�er Geen a tlry emvbYKT
YES NO
Dcee M(s persoMmm D� a sW'W not �wrmelMP�ssed M�Y ��� �Y �MWoYY�
YES NO
b ihis D��T�m a �arpMed veMaYt
YES NO
COET/REVENUE BUOGEfED (GRCLE ONt� YES
ACTrvITY NUMBER
NO
INFORMATION (IXPW�
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton M. Robinson, Jr., City Attorney � q.�`,� �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
November 2, 1999
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Larch Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
c:vit Divisiors
400CityHa11 Te7ephoxe:651266-8710
ISWestKe7loggBlyd Facsimile:657298-56I9
Saint Paul, Minnesata 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
'�; �`sCvF
��as.s?��;���,�_..�, •
�,� � � q ��,
i <. :? '1 `o' � 4.3�
RE: Auto Body Repair Gazage and Auto Repair Garage License Applications by Ray's Auto
Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body for the premises at 353 Larch Street in St. Paul
License ID #: 990004189
Deaz Mr. Holbrook:
Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting
scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 24,1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third
Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
concerning the failure to submit information necessary to process your license application and
the failure to complete installation of an approved spray booth have not been denied. The
recommendation of the license office will be for the denial of your license application.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
VL M-c�� , Q�R�.-u�
Virginia�Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER aq � 1�3a.
Licensee Name: Ray's Auto Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body
Address:
Council Date:
Violation:
Place:
353 Larch Street
November 24, 1999
Failure to Provide Information Necessary to
Process License Application
Failure to Complete Installation of an Approved
Spray Booth
Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Denial of License Application
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. 9/13/99 letter from Christine Rozek to Hager Holbrook
5. 9/3/99 letter from Christine Rozek to Hager Holbrook
6. License information
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
October 12, 1999
OFFICE �° THE CITY pT'I'pgNgy
Clayton N. �irsson, Jr., Ciry A[forney
c�q.. ! t3a�
Civi! Divisian
400 Ciry Ha1T Telephone: 651266-8710
I S West Kellogg E(vd F¢csimile: 651298-56I9
Sain! Pau1, ,Llinnesafa SSIO2
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Lazch Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Auto Body Repair Garage and Auto Repair Garage License Applications by Ray's Auto
Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body for the premises at 353 Larch Street in St. Pau1
License ID #: 990004189
Deaz Mr. Holbrook:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environxnental Protection has recommended that
the license applications listed above be denied. The basis for the recommendation is as follows:
On September 3,1999 and September 13,1999, you were sent
letters by the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection that your license applications were still incomplete.
You were advised on both occasions that you still needed to
submit a copy of your lease or purchase agreement, a sife plan,
a signed license application and a copy of your State of
Minnesota Tax Identification Number Certificate. As of
today's date you have still not provided the signed application
or the State of Minnesota Tas ID Certificate. Additionally, the
Fire Department will not approve your license application for
an Auto Body Repair Garage until you have completed the
installation of an approved spray booth. This had not been
done as of October 6,1999.
If you do not want to dispute the matter, you must send me a letter admitting the facts stated
above and ask that the matter be set in front of the City Council to determine what penaity, if
any, will be imposed. You wili have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or
to have someone appeaz there for you.
Page 2
Mr. Hager Holbrook
October 12, 1999
ctq-tl3a
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, you may request an administrative
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge. If you wish to have a hearing, you must let me
know that in writing. I will then schedule the hearing and send you a notice w�ith the time, date
and place of the hearing, the name of the administrative law judge who will preside, and a brief
description of the procedures to be followed.
Please let me know in writing no later than Friday, October 22, 1999 how you would like to
proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I will assume that you are not
contesting the facts indicated above. The matter will then be scheduled before the City
Council on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended denial of your license application will be imposed.
Please be on notice that your business location does not currently have a license to operate an
Auto Repair Garage or an Auto Body Repair Garagebusiness at this locarion, and you aze not
permitted to operate without such a license. You must, therefore, immediately cease all
operations at this location. If you continue to operate evidence of that fact may be used in
addition to other evidence to deny your license.
If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attomey call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� J/ ✓u.��`�J ��utll
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
aq-<<3�
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly swox'n, deposes and says
that on October 12, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Larch Street
St. Paul, MN. 55117
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the Unit�e�'SL�tes mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota. / 1 ., � ,
Subscribed and sworn to be£ore me
this 12th day g€� Octp�er, 1999.
Notary P NOTARYPUBLIC-MINNES�TA
"'' My Comm. Expires Jan. 37, 2JC1
a9 - i 13a.
lo �
n�
W�
N I
O C I
�- m p
y U�
R � Lo
a �o
r
0
C
�
t
O
«
m
E
L
�
C
d
N
C
d
U
J
�
�
m
�
N p�
N �
C �
U �
-' a
N
�
N �
c6
O_ (,
H �
m
N�N
c �
U O
J �
Q
� I
a> �
� �i
o �I�
Z i, �
c ° o
U �
J �
a
(0
�
H
y
mU
i �
�
Q ^
M �
��
fl
�
m
� �
m �
Z Q
Q
0 }
�
U
Z
}
0
O
m
m �
Z �
C Q
o �
a¢
�
�U
C
�
O
U
C
�
� o
a�
m
0
a
x
w
N
C
N
�
E
�
Z
U
O
a
U
c
�
�
W
C
E
m
�,
c
m
a
U
U
C
�
3
N
C
N
Q
�
�
Z
N
C �
O �
= n
a
N �
`� r
m ^
C
� �
m �
� z
~Z
W
�
2
U
g
M
�
C')
C
N '�q L
a � .0 � O
� "a = a
�N a�i o 3 �^
'o N N � � fl.
� � N �= N
� � dc 3
�� 3 N'- O
a�- - c � r
—� . �O_ 3
¢� a�ic�a; >.
Ea a�ny��N v
LL @ � . tn �"O �
�1 p �C O� O
U C LL E� N N �
mN � d� U N `�
�a O ° � >
o� Q �� a � o
pm U �crn °-
d a
¢ 000��o �
Uii
a d���m �
a�o v _
�rn�mc��„` 3
o�4�a.. • ��
� mV ac�� c.a�iUc:
O) �i uI���01 �
rn- rnrnrnrn� rn
rn:a $rnrnrnrn �-3rn
<cn� .-rr N o�
� C�(7M�� �('7
O'O N�ON� N
O L»m��� �n
O OOOW..O
a9 -�«a-
�
w
�
0
a
x
N W
� N O
N d O
d V N
A � O
a �co
0
�'
0
17.
�
C
O
w
R
E
L
O
C
N
�,
c
N
�
_1
N
'
Y
�
�
N �
c �
� 'a
U C
J �
a
N
rn
m
c�
�n m
T �
F-
N �
C �
m
U O
J j
Q
� LI
�
� �
� �I�
� I�
Z
a� io
c ° o
U �
J �
�
N
�
F
�
N =
mU
� �
Qgn
�
� �
��
�
O
m
� �
m ~
Z �
4 a
� }
LY
U
Z
�
�
m
z�
c ¢
o�
a ¢
�
�U
C
�
O
U
i
N
� o
a>
m
�
L
X
N
C
N
�
E
�
Z
�
O
a
N
c
�
N
C
E
m
Z
C
Q
�
U
m
N
C
N
E
�
z
N
G �
L �
�
N
m
w �
N ^
C
7 �
�
� C�
Z
m p
Z
W
a
F
�
_
U
�
g
�
C
N m �p .�.
� a .0 � O
, � 0. a
m
'p N � �
N � N ( p = y
N...O p)
� � N N � O
� _ � = c .c
—m -° . m .
.rna 3
¢ O .u�i���
�Q Qt�y� V� O
LL � O N= O� O
U = � E � N N �
mN ����N �
pv O'v v�� o
c d a--
c° ( °-
a
U ii o o p>.$ m
m
N V (�j � � C
�m�NC��L
O � A `���n..rC �
s
�`�cma`�3�
�'m oc�.- nyV�:
� 3 �j��m�Y W
rn= y rnrnrn rn� rn
rn:� �rnrnrnrn �-3rn
��n� .-�c-� N o�
� �mMMC� �ch
O'O �N
O ` 3m0)01�� �n
00000co.,.,o
OFFlCE OF LICE\SE, I\SPECTIO\S A\D
EXVIRO\�iL-\T.4L PROTLCTIO\
P,oGert Krss(er, DireUOr
CIrY OF SAINT PAUL
,\'orm Cole�r.rn, i!n)'or
Sep;zmber 13, 1949
19990004159
?�4r. Aaszr Rzy Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body Inc
DB_A Ray's Auto Body
353 Larch Street
Saint Paul'��I�I 5� 117
LOI:'P.YPP,OFESSIO\�AL BL'/LDL\'G
Sui:e i 00
JJO SL PelerSireel
Saint Pnul, .L'inr.esom »IG?-1510
Re: New License Application at 3�3 Larch Street (Second :Votice)
Dear Applicant:
aa.i�3a-
Telepl;mve: 6�/-?66-9090
Fr. csinr,"le: 6� I-]66-9099
651-I66-91?4
9fter extensive re�ie«�, I hace determined yow license application _19990004189 (from
Ju]y 12, 1999) is stil] incomplete. At this time, your business license record (I.D.
119990004189) for an Auto Repair Garzee and Auto Body Repair GaraQe license has
been inactivated until the followin� item(s) are recei��ed:
• Copy of }�our Property Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of O��mership or Bill
of Sale
• Site plan - A detailed description of the desi�n, location, and square foota�e of
the premises to be licensed
• Signed license application
• Copy of your State of Minneso:a Tax Identification Number Certificate
1'our license has not been issued. If you are conducting an Auto Repair Gara�e and
Auto Body Repair business, you are doing so without a valid City of Saint Paul license
and may be subject to adverse action and penalties. Ifyou k�ish to continue to operate
your business, you must submit the aforementioned requirements by September 22,
1999.
Please let us Imow, in writing, before September 22 whether or not you intend to
continue with this application or wish to permanently withdraw. After this date, this
office �•ill begin the administrative hearing process to drny your license request. You
have the opportunity to appeal the City's decision through this proceeding.
Ifyou have any questions regarding this action, p]ease contact me at (651) 266-9108.
Sincerely
(�I�Za�.o�:v �, �
Christine Rozek �
LIEP Deputy Director
CAR/cam
SYtxS
?hnL
�
eeee
CI1Y OF SAINT PAUL
j'ornr Colen:mr, I.Sn�'or
September 3, 1999
19990004159
?�4r. Ha�er Ray Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body Inc
DBA Ray's .4uto Body
3�3 Larch Strezt
SaintPaul�1N 5�117
Re: \'ew License Applicztion at 3�3 Larch Street
Deaz Applicant:
OFFICE OF LIC[\SE, I\SPEC710\S A\D
E\VIRO\\:ESTALPROTLCTIOV �Q
RaGcri K� cs(n', DirtUOr �
LONRY PROFES90.\!SL Telephm�e: 651-;E6-9090
BL%ILD!\'G Fr.csimile: 65l-'66-9l24
3�0 St. Pcler S:reet
Sui�e 300
Sr.ir;tPnuLAfinr.esctn 55/02
This letter is to formally notify you of documentation our office still requires in order to complete
your application. Your license application for an Auto Repair Garaee and Auto Body Repair
Garase located at 353 Larch Street can not be processed until our office recei� es the follo���ing:
• A copy of your lease agreement or proof of oi;Tership or bill of sale of the property
• Site Plan - A detailed deseription of the design, ]ocarion, znd square footzee of the
premises to be Iicensed. �
• Si�ned license application (refer to attached application)
• A copy ofyour State ofMinnesota Tax Identification I�TUmber Certificate
Insurance certificates, Lezse Agreements�Bill of Sale, site plans, Articles of Incorporation and
lists may be faxed to our office at (651) 266-9124. ��e must obtain the required
paperw�orkJpayment before «�e can complete processin2 your license application.
At this rime, your license hzs not been issued; therefore, you are not authorized to operate in the
City of Saint Paul. You will not receive your license until all information and(or payments are
received in our office.
Ifyou have any questions or concems, please contact Corinne Dlartens, LIEP Project Facilitator
at (651) 2b6-9106.
Re�ards,
��
Christine A. Rozek � ��
LIEP Deputy Director
CARlcam
Attachment
a�
p$ , �''�1Sm I"�
Licensee F2AY'S AUTO
DBA Al^S AUTO
License Licensee � Uc. Types l Inswance , Bond 1 Requiremzrrts I
Licensee Name: AY'S AUTO BODY MC (y,-�.,�;�z.: �'
DBA: AY'S AUTO BODY
Seles Tax Itl: ENDMG Non-Profrt: (— VVOrker's Comp: OiU0N000 Properties...
AA Co�rac[ Rec'd. ONO10000 AA Training ftec'd: OlOON900 .
AA Fee Collectetl. ON�N000 DiscouM ReC'd: r
Othzr A enc Licenses Financiai Holtl fteasons
Other Liwnsmg Agency Neme f License Type �License #; Expiratidn Reason . '�' '`�'�ACtive �� Date �
Mail License To: —
r Mail To Corrtact
C�, License Address
Me0lnvoice To:
r Mal To Cnntact
_..,, „ _. .„ � _ � C L�cense AtltlreSs
�I lr . _ _ y .�
Background Check Required �� � CpritaC[ Propethes:.��
License #
� SaveCha�gestoHistary
,�Start `�3Grou: ¢�CoreL.-, �Custo:' �ECLI:,;; �ECLI, {�jLacen.;_�Prop.:..}���'�°�`�4�._945AR�I:_..�,
ag- ti
L3 Licer
p� b � in.'am .� S�
DHA
License I Licensee 1 Lic Types 1 Insurence l Bontl l RequiremeMS l
C•� Property � Licensee r Unofficiai Project Faaldetor. MARTENS, CORINNE
Street #. 53 I A Action CommeMs
Street Namc PACH ��1 mm �
Street Type. ST D'vechon: � I p � ;
Llndind �— Und#. r �'_"___________'_.._ _.____`__ ' __ J
Cdy T PAUL � Commerrts.
��e� �— Zip. 55��� � 929fl999forwardedtoCAOfarFOrmA.
��"� ; 9p 311999 2ntl nohce far requiremeMS serR, due 9R2.
Wartl' � '�Bron%se� � 9N3M9991st notice for requiremerits serM1.
DiK Council �76 � ER4f1999 per frre, Rsy in process of putting in spray
i oath . ' ' " _"_.' '
Licensea: �AY'S AUTO BODY INC CommeMS.
DBA' AY'S AUTO BODY
Sates iae ltl NDMG Bus Phone: 651) 771-2704
License # �90004189 �
-�_� � _� � � �;�.-��� �
�Start 6�Csou.:. Corel.� �Custo �" �ECLI::_ �EGLI... �Lieen ; �Prop... �6N���C�� 9�4AM .
%vY m �
aa-i►s.z.
� � �
Licensee
PaY Priirc," 'M'am Hin Su� DBA
License I Licensee I Lic.Types ' Insurance , Bontl
Licznse Type� uto Repair Garage
f
avs NNdicffiian
Pian
�rd Chzck
Requiremerds
�- � �Delete
W
0
0
0
�
mi
Candrtions CommeMs
IRE - Approved Auto repair warK (mechanicap only.SJJY
"' '_.__ _"_, —... '_'._'. . _.._.____ _.
'" _ '___... _._.._ � 2of2 '.:.'� ..�
License # �90004789 ' Save Lhangesto History
i� Stazt � �nu : �,Cpre1. �� Custo `„ ,�.. ECI;I :. � EGLI � kn �j Lic'ea;:: � Prnp . � j�j N, � -°�- �� `� AM �t':
qq•�t��
CandM1ions Cammerds �'�
8R471999 Per Fve, PF, in process of putting in a
praybouth. CAM
ire - Denied - Auto 0ody is a change af occupancy antl �.
- hus requires BID approval antl currerHry hes no spray '���..
' � ooth. S.NV '
�,
""._ . _..� _ "__ "__�___..._ � _.._ __.._._...___.,_..
!y s�`� 1 Of 2 ,.» j k I
_ _..—..__.. � __...
License #�90004189 _ Save Changes to His[ory
"i�Start �Grou_. E�Corel.,` < <`�,..Ciuto.. �ECL;I.. fJ„ECL[.� �Lic'eg._ �Prop._'��N�'S�
� $ � � � , �7 Licensee AV'S AUTO 60DY MC
Pay , Prim 'i^u'am Nst Summ � DBA AYS AUTO BODY
License , Ucensee l Lic. Types l Insurance l 6ontl ftequ�remerRS �
License Type: ^ u[o Botly Reparc Garage Atld ' - Delete
License Group Commentr Text
Licensee: Rq1^S AUTO BODY INC
�BA� RAY'S AUTO BODY
License#: �9990004'189
09/29/1999 forv✓arded to CAO for Form A.
09/'13lt999 2nd notice foc requirements sent. due 9/22.
09/03/1999 �st no6ce for requirements seni.
08/24/1999 per Fire, Ray in process of putting in spray booth.
8/9/99 spoke with Ray to gei lease and site plan in. He will mail tomortow. CAM
07/23/1999 fire will not approve (auto body) without spraybooth.
09/27/1999
�l °t `l L'JO.
Requirement Comments Text
Licensee: R,qy�S AUTO BODY INC
09/27N 999
DBA: Rqy'S AUTO BODY /� C� `' �� ^
_` ` �
License#: �ggg0004189
08/24/1999 Per Fire, PF, in process of putting in a spraybooth. CAM
Fire - Denied -Auto body is a change of occupancy and thus requires BID approval and curtently has no spray booth. SJW
Requirement Comments Text
Licensee: qp,Y'S AUTO BODY INC
�BA� RAY'S AUTO BODY
License #: �ggg0004189
09/27I7999
��(.L1�2-
FIRE-Approved. Autorepairwork(mechanical)only.SJW
Council File # � -,�3a�
ORIG{NAL
Presented By
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
� . ����`�'�a ,�3�°�
Green Sheet #
�3
Referred To
Committee:
RESOLVED, that the license application submitted by Ra s Auto Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's
Auto Body (License ID Number 940004184) for the premises 1 ated at 353 Lazch Street is
hereby denied for failing to provide all required information cessary to process the license
application and for failing to installed an approved spray bo th.
This Resolution and the action taken above are based
1999, Notice of Violation letter to the licensee. The ]
violation. �
the facts contained in the October 12,
;e did not contest the facts of the
Requested by Department of:
/I/��r". / , "J�'
Adopted by Counc'1
/
Adoption Cex�E' ied
�
By:
Approved by Mayor:
By:
Date
by Council Secretaxy
Date
Form Approved b�3' City Attorney
By: (/ 2-L � �
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
Office of LIEP
Robert Kessler
November 24. 1999 — Consent
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
�q-t13�.
No 1 G4j-31
�
m�roRecrae Urnrea�aci_
u�v�na�eEr ❑ ane�aut
twwcw��ort ❑ wux�uLLaE.�e�ccro
r�vo¢Pu�nwrl �
(CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Resolution recommending denial of the Auto Body Repair Garage and AuYo Repair Garage License
Applications by Ray's Auto Body, Inc., 353 Larch Street.
dOAl10N ApproVe (A) w K¢�%
PIP.NNlNG CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CMl SERVICE COMMISSION
.._ • 3.
IF APPROVED
IF NOT
TRANSACTION t
Fiac tivs P�� erer Morketl untiv e arA�act fartlec dePeNment9
YES NO
Flas mis P�rm e�er Geen a tlry emvbYKT
YES NO
Dcee M(s persoMmm D� a sW'W not �wrmelMP�ssed M�Y ��� �Y �MWoYY�
YES NO
b ihis D��T�m a �arpMed veMaYt
YES NO
COET/REVENUE BUOGEfED (GRCLE ONt� YES
ACTrvITY NUMBER
NO
INFORMATION (IXPW�
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Clayton M. Robinson, Jr., City Attorney � q.�`,� �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
November 2, 1999
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Larch Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
c:vit Divisiors
400CityHa11 Te7ephoxe:651266-8710
ISWestKe7loggBlyd Facsimile:657298-56I9
Saint Paul, Minnesata 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL MEETING
'�; �`sCvF
��as.s?��;���,�_..�, •
�,� � � q ��,
i <. :? '1 `o' � 4.3�
RE: Auto Body Repair Gazage and Auto Repair Garage License Applications by Ray's Auto
Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body for the premises at 353 Larch Street in St. Paul
License ID #: 990004189
Deaz Mr. Holbrook:
Please take notice that this matter has been set on the Consent Agenda for the Council meeting
scheduled for 3:30 p.m., Wednesday, November 24,1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third
Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to
the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested matter, in that the facts
concerning the failure to submit information necessary to process your license application and
the failure to complete installation of an approved spray booth have not been denied. The
recommendation of the license office will be for the denial of your license application.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours,
VL M-c�� , Q�R�.-u�
Virginia�Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
UNCONTESTED LICENSE MATTER aq � 1�3a.
Licensee Name: Ray's Auto Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body
Address:
Council Date:
Violation:
Place:
353 Larch Street
November 24, 1999
Failure to Provide Information Necessary to
Process License Application
Failure to Complete Installation of an Approved
Spray Booth
Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Denial of License Application
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. License Information Report
4. 9/13/99 letter from Christine Rozek to Hager Holbrook
5. 9/3/99 letter from Christine Rozek to Hager Holbrook
6. License information
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
October 12, 1999
OFFICE �° THE CITY pT'I'pgNgy
Clayton N. �irsson, Jr., Ciry A[forney
c�q.. ! t3a�
Civi! Divisian
400 Ciry Ha1T Telephone: 651266-8710
I S West Kellogg E(vd F¢csimile: 651298-56I9
Sain! Pau1, ,Llinnesafa SSIO2
NOTICE OF VIOLATION
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Lazch Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117
RE: Auto Body Repair Garage and Auto Repair Garage License Applications by Ray's Auto
Body, Inc. d/b/a Ray's Auto Body for the premises at 353 Larch Street in St. Pau1
License ID #: 990004189
Deaz Mr. Holbrook:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environxnental Protection has recommended that
the license applications listed above be denied. The basis for the recommendation is as follows:
On September 3,1999 and September 13,1999, you were sent
letters by the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection that your license applications were still incomplete.
You were advised on both occasions that you still needed to
submit a copy of your lease or purchase agreement, a sife plan,
a signed license application and a copy of your State of
Minnesota Tax Identification Number Certificate. As of
today's date you have still not provided the signed application
or the State of Minnesota Tas ID Certificate. Additionally, the
Fire Department will not approve your license application for
an Auto Body Repair Garage until you have completed the
installation of an approved spray booth. This had not been
done as of October 6,1999.
If you do not want to dispute the matter, you must send me a letter admitting the facts stated
above and ask that the matter be set in front of the City Council to determine what penaity, if
any, will be imposed. You wili have an opportunity to appear and speak on your own behalf, or
to have someone appeaz there for you.
Page 2
Mr. Hager Holbrook
October 12, 1999
ctq-tl3a
On the other hand, if you wish to dispute the above facts, you may request an administrative
hearing before an Administrative Law Judge. If you wish to have a hearing, you must let me
know that in writing. I will then schedule the hearing and send you a notice w�ith the time, date
and place of the hearing, the name of the administrative law judge who will preside, and a brief
description of the procedures to be followed.
Please let me know in writing no later than Friday, October 22, 1999 how you would like to
proceed. If I have not heard from you by that date, I will assume that you are not
contesting the facts indicated above. The matter will then be scheduled before the City
Council on the Consent Agenda during which no public discussion is allowed and the
recommended denial of your license application will be imposed.
Please be on notice that your business location does not currently have a license to operate an
Auto Repair Garage or an Auto Body Repair Garagebusiness at this locarion, and you aze not
permitted to operate without such a license. You must, therefore, immediately cease all
operations at this location. If you continue to operate evidence of that fact may be used in
addition to other evidence to deny your license.
If you have any questions, feel free to call me or have your attomey call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� J/ ✓u.��`�J ��utll
�
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN
55117
aq-<<3�
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly swox'n, deposes and says
that on October 12, 1999, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Mr. Hager Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body, Inc.
353 Larch Street
St. Paul, MN. 55117
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the Unit�e�'SL�tes mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota. / 1 ., � ,
Subscribed and sworn to be£ore me
this 12th day g€� Octp�er, 1999.
Notary P NOTARYPUBLIC-MINNES�TA
"'' My Comm. Expires Jan. 37, 2JC1
a9 - i 13a.
lo �
n�
W�
N I
O C I
�- m p
y U�
R � Lo
a �o
r
0
C
�
t
O
«
m
E
L
�
C
d
N
C
d
U
J
�
�
m
�
N p�
N �
C �
U �
-' a
N
�
N �
c6
O_ (,
H �
m
N�N
c �
U O
J �
Q
� I
a> �
� �i
o �I�
Z i, �
c ° o
U �
J �
a
(0
�
H
y
mU
i �
�
Q ^
M �
��
fl
�
m
� �
m �
Z Q
Q
0 }
�
U
Z
}
0
O
m
m �
Z �
C Q
o �
a¢
�
�U
C
�
O
U
C
�
� o
a�
m
0
a
x
w
N
C
N
�
E
�
Z
U
O
a
U
c
�
�
W
C
E
m
�,
c
m
a
U
U
C
�
3
N
C
N
Q
�
�
Z
N
C �
O �
= n
a
N �
`� r
m ^
C
� �
m �
� z
~Z
W
�
2
U
g
M
�
C')
C
N '�q L
a � .0 � O
� "a = a
�N a�i o 3 �^
'o N N � � fl.
� � N �= N
� � dc 3
�� 3 N'- O
a�- - c � r
—� . �O_ 3
¢� a�ic�a; >.
Ea a�ny��N v
LL @ � . tn �"O �
�1 p �C O� O
U C LL E� N N �
mN � d� U N `�
�a O ° � >
o� Q �� a � o
pm U �crn °-
d a
¢ 000��o �
Uii
a d���m �
a�o v _
�rn�mc��„` 3
o�4�a.. • ��
� mV ac�� c.a�iUc:
O) �i uI���01 �
rn- rnrnrnrn� rn
rn:a $rnrnrnrn �-3rn
<cn� .-rr N o�
� C�(7M�� �('7
O'O N�ON� N
O L»m��� �n
O OOOW..O
a9 -�«a-
�
w
�
0
a
x
N W
� N O
N d O
d V N
A � O
a �co
0
�'
0
17.
�
C
O
w
R
E
L
O
C
N
�,
c
N
�
_1
N
'
Y
�
�
N �
c �
� 'a
U C
J �
a
N
rn
m
c�
�n m
T �
F-
N �
C �
m
U O
J j
Q
� LI
�
� �
� �I�
� I�
Z
a� io
c ° o
U �
J �
�
N
�
F
�
N =
mU
� �
Qgn
�
� �
��
�
O
m
� �
m ~
Z �
4 a
� }
LY
U
Z
�
�
m
z�
c ¢
o�
a ¢
�
�U
C
�
O
U
i
N
� o
a>
m
�
L
X
N
C
N
�
E
�
Z
�
O
a
N
c
�
N
C
E
m
Z
C
Q
�
U
m
N
C
N
E
�
z
N
G �
L �
�
N
m
w �
N ^
C
7 �
�
� C�
Z
m p
Z
W
a
F
�
_
U
�
g
�
C
N m �p .�.
� a .0 � O
, � 0. a
m
'p N � �
N � N ( p = y
N...O p)
� � N N � O
� _ � = c .c
—m -° . m .
.rna 3
¢ O .u�i���
�Q Qt�y� V� O
LL � O N= O� O
U = � E � N N �
mN ����N �
pv O'v v�� o
c d a--
c° ( °-
a
U ii o o p>.$ m
m
N V (�j � � C
�m�NC��L
O � A `���n..rC �
s
�`�cma`�3�
�'m oc�.- nyV�:
� 3 �j��m�Y W
rn= y rnrnrn rn� rn
rn:� �rnrnrnrn �-3rn
��n� .-�c-� N o�
� �mMMC� �ch
O'O �N
O ` 3m0)01�� �n
00000co.,.,o
OFFlCE OF LICE\SE, I\SPECTIO\S A\D
EXVIRO\�iL-\T.4L PROTLCTIO\
P,oGert Krss(er, DireUOr
CIrY OF SAINT PAUL
,\'orm Cole�r.rn, i!n)'or
Sep;zmber 13, 1949
19990004159
?�4r. Aaszr Rzy Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body Inc
DB_A Ray's Auto Body
353 Larch Street
Saint Paul'��I�I 5� 117
LOI:'P.YPP,OFESSIO\�AL BL'/LDL\'G
Sui:e i 00
JJO SL PelerSireel
Saint Pnul, .L'inr.esom »IG?-1510
Re: New License Application at 3�3 Larch Street (Second :Votice)
Dear Applicant:
aa.i�3a-
Telepl;mve: 6�/-?66-9090
Fr. csinr,"le: 6� I-]66-9099
651-I66-91?4
9fter extensive re�ie«�, I hace determined yow license application _19990004189 (from
Ju]y 12, 1999) is stil] incomplete. At this time, your business license record (I.D.
119990004189) for an Auto Repair Garzee and Auto Body Repair GaraQe license has
been inactivated until the followin� item(s) are recei��ed:
• Copy of }�our Property Lease/Purchase Agreement, Proof of O��mership or Bill
of Sale
• Site plan - A detailed description of the desi�n, location, and square foota�e of
the premises to be licensed
• Signed license application
• Copy of your State of Minneso:a Tax Identification Number Certificate
1'our license has not been issued. If you are conducting an Auto Repair Gara�e and
Auto Body Repair business, you are doing so without a valid City of Saint Paul license
and may be subject to adverse action and penalties. Ifyou k�ish to continue to operate
your business, you must submit the aforementioned requirements by September 22,
1999.
Please let us Imow, in writing, before September 22 whether or not you intend to
continue with this application or wish to permanently withdraw. After this date, this
office �•ill begin the administrative hearing process to drny your license request. You
have the opportunity to appeal the City's decision through this proceeding.
Ifyou have any questions regarding this action, p]ease contact me at (651) 266-9108.
Sincerely
(�I�Za�.o�:v �, �
Christine Rozek �
LIEP Deputy Director
CAR/cam
SYtxS
?hnL
�
eeee
CI1Y OF SAINT PAUL
j'ornr Colen:mr, I.Sn�'or
September 3, 1999
19990004159
?�4r. Ha�er Ray Holbrook
Ray's Auto Body Inc
DBA Ray's .4uto Body
3�3 Larch Strezt
SaintPaul�1N 5�117
Re: \'ew License Applicztion at 3�3 Larch Street
Deaz Applicant:
OFFICE OF LIC[\SE, I\SPEC710\S A\D
E\VIRO\\:ESTALPROTLCTIOV �Q
RaGcri K� cs(n', DirtUOr �
LONRY PROFES90.\!SL Telephm�e: 651-;E6-9090
BL%ILD!\'G Fr.csimile: 65l-'66-9l24
3�0 St. Pcler S:reet
Sui�e 300
Sr.ir;tPnuLAfinr.esctn 55/02
This letter is to formally notify you of documentation our office still requires in order to complete
your application. Your license application for an Auto Repair Garaee and Auto Body Repair
Garase located at 353 Larch Street can not be processed until our office recei� es the follo���ing:
• A copy of your lease agreement or proof of oi;Tership or bill of sale of the property
• Site Plan - A detailed deseription of the design, ]ocarion, znd square footzee of the
premises to be Iicensed. �
• Si�ned license application (refer to attached application)
• A copy ofyour State ofMinnesota Tax Identification I�TUmber Certificate
Insurance certificates, Lezse Agreements�Bill of Sale, site plans, Articles of Incorporation and
lists may be faxed to our office at (651) 266-9124. ��e must obtain the required
paperw�orkJpayment before «�e can complete processin2 your license application.
At this rime, your license hzs not been issued; therefore, you are not authorized to operate in the
City of Saint Paul. You will not receive your license until all information and(or payments are
received in our office.
Ifyou have any questions or concems, please contact Corinne Dlartens, LIEP Project Facilitator
at (651) 2b6-9106.
Re�ards,
��
Christine A. Rozek � ��
LIEP Deputy Director
CARlcam
Attachment
a�
p$ , �''�1Sm I"�
Licensee F2AY'S AUTO
DBA Al^S AUTO
License Licensee � Uc. Types l Inswance , Bond 1 Requiremzrrts I
Licensee Name: AY'S AUTO BODY MC (y,-�.,�;�z.: �'
DBA: AY'S AUTO BODY
Seles Tax Itl: ENDMG Non-Profrt: (— VVOrker's Comp: OiU0N000 Properties...
AA Co�rac[ Rec'd. ONO10000 AA Training ftec'd: OlOON900 .
AA Fee Collectetl. ON�N000 DiscouM ReC'd: r
Othzr A enc Licenses Financiai Holtl fteasons
Other Liwnsmg Agency Neme f License Type �License #; Expiratidn Reason . '�' '`�'�ACtive �� Date �
Mail License To: —
r Mail To Corrtact
C�, License Address
Me0lnvoice To:
r Mal To Cnntact
_..,, „ _. .„ � _ � C L�cense AtltlreSs
�I lr . _ _ y .�
Background Check Required �� � CpritaC[ Propethes:.��
License #
� SaveCha�gestoHistary
,�Start `�3Grou: ¢�CoreL.-, �Custo:' �ECLI:,;; �ECLI, {�jLacen.;_�Prop.:..}���'�°�`�4�._945AR�I:_..�,
ag- ti
L3 Licer
p� b � in.'am .� S�
DHA
License I Licensee 1 Lic Types 1 Insurence l Bontl l RequiremeMS l
C•� Property � Licensee r Unofficiai Project Faaldetor. MARTENS, CORINNE
Street #. 53 I A Action CommeMs
Street Namc PACH ��1 mm �
Street Type. ST D'vechon: � I p � ;
Llndind �— Und#. r �'_"___________'_.._ _.____`__ ' __ J
Cdy T PAUL � Commerrts.
��e� �— Zip. 55��� � 929fl999forwardedtoCAOfarFOrmA.
��"� ; 9p 311999 2ntl nohce far requiremeMS serR, due 9R2.
Wartl' � '�Bron%se� � 9N3M9991st notice for requiremerits serM1.
DiK Council �76 � ER4f1999 per frre, Rsy in process of putting in spray
i oath . ' ' " _"_.' '
Licensea: �AY'S AUTO BODY INC CommeMS.
DBA' AY'S AUTO BODY
Sates iae ltl NDMG Bus Phone: 651) 771-2704
License # �90004189 �
-�_� � _� � � �;�.-��� �
�Start 6�Csou.:. Corel.� �Custo �" �ECLI::_ �EGLI... �Lieen ; �Prop... �6N���C�� 9�4AM .
%vY m �
aa-i►s.z.
� � �
Licensee
PaY Priirc," 'M'am Hin Su� DBA
License I Licensee I Lic.Types ' Insurance , Bontl
Licznse Type� uto Repair Garage
f
avs NNdicffiian
Pian
�rd Chzck
Requiremerds
�- � �Delete
W
0
0
0
�
mi
Candrtions CommeMs
IRE - Approved Auto repair warK (mechanicap only.SJJY
"' '_.__ _"_, —... '_'._'. . _.._.____ _.
'" _ '___... _._.._ � 2of2 '.:.'� ..�
License # �90004789 ' Save Lhangesto History
i� Stazt � �nu : �,Cpre1. �� Custo `„ ,�.. ECI;I :. � EGLI � kn �j Lic'ea;:: � Prnp . � j�j N, � -°�- �� `� AM �t':
qq•�t��
CandM1ions Cammerds �'�
8R471999 Per Fve, PF, in process of putting in a
praybouth. CAM
ire - Denied - Auto 0ody is a change af occupancy antl �.
- hus requires BID approval antl currerHry hes no spray '���..
' � ooth. S.NV '
�,
""._ . _..� _ "__ "__�___..._ � _.._ __.._._...___.,_..
!y s�`� 1 Of 2 ,.» j k I
_ _..—..__.. � __...
License #�90004189 _ Save Changes to His[ory
"i�Start �Grou_. E�Corel.,` < <`�,..Ciuto.. �ECL;I.. fJ„ECL[.� �Lic'eg._ �Prop._'��N�'S�
� $ � � � , �7 Licensee AV'S AUTO 60DY MC
Pay , Prim 'i^u'am Nst Summ � DBA AYS AUTO BODY
License , Ucensee l Lic. Types l Insurance l 6ontl ftequ�remerRS �
License Type: ^ u[o Botly Reparc Garage Atld ' - Delete
License Group Commentr Text
Licensee: Rq1^S AUTO BODY INC
�BA� RAY'S AUTO BODY
License#: �9990004'189
09/29/1999 forv✓arded to CAO for Form A.
09/'13lt999 2nd notice foc requirements sent. due 9/22.
09/03/1999 �st no6ce for requirements seni.
08/24/1999 per Fire, Ray in process of putting in spray booth.
8/9/99 spoke with Ray to gei lease and site plan in. He will mail tomortow. CAM
07/23/1999 fire will not approve (auto body) without spraybooth.
09/27/1999
�l °t `l L'JO.
Requirement Comments Text
Licensee: R,qy�S AUTO BODY INC
09/27N 999
DBA: Rqy'S AUTO BODY /� C� `' �� ^
_` ` �
License#: �ggg0004189
08/24/1999 Per Fire, PF, in process of putting in a spraybooth. CAM
Fire - Denied -Auto body is a change of occupancy and thus requires BID approval and curtently has no spray booth. SJW
Requirement Comments Text
Licensee: qp,Y'S AUTO BODY INC
�BA� RAY'S AUTO BODY
License #: �ggg0004189
09/27I7999
��(.L1�2-
FIRE-Approved. Autorepairwork(mechanical)only.SJW