Loading...
89-1271 WHITE - C�TY CIERK COI1flC1I PINK - FINANCE G I TY F SA I NT PA U L CANARY - DEPARTMENT �/��/ BLUE - MAVOR File NO• City Attny/TJ��T Co n i Resolution �� r/ � Presented By ��i�� Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVED, that the On a e Liquor, Sunday Liquor , Restaurant and Entertainment licenses e d by Leo H. Gadbois dba Sweeney' s Saloon, for the premises at 9 North Dale Street in St . Paul are hereby suspended for a peri d of ��-�.� �=:__����- _ _ day�, -ee�e�$ on -� v �Y ' I K This resolution and th ction taken above are based upon the facts contained in the t ached police report dated , April 14, 1989 , and allegat'o s contained in the notice of hearing dated May 17 , 1989 . uch facts are not contested by the licensee, as evidenced y the attached letter signed by Leo H. Gadbois , President o . Gadbois , dba Sweeney' s Saloon. The action taken is also ba e on the facts , circumstances , and arguments presented by and n behalf of the licenseholder . COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays � Dimond Lo� '-5 In F vo Gosw;tz Rettman � �6Q1�� _ A gai s t BY -�� ��u'� JUL � 81989 Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date p � �,-,�c 1� —19 g Certified Pa s d y Council� etary By By � '� �, A►pprov d iVlav : [xaT-e—, 19 9 Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council �-----� l� g '� BY Y pUg1lS�E8 J U L 2 9 198 ����mi� ���� ���� -�J��T� �.� CITY OF SAINT PAUL 3`�� ''�' RECEIVED OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY p� i(�. ,, �����������' 7' . `:�'s I�III I Il�lli ^= >;. JUN 2 01989 EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY "'`�n�„�«� �����"� 647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612-298-512� GEORGE LATIMER CITY CLERK MAYOR June 19, 1989 Mr. Leo H. Gadbois Sweeney' s Saloon 96 No . Dale Street St. Paul, MN. 55102 RE: City of St. Paul v. S e ey' s Saloon Notice of Council Hea in Dear Mr. Gadbois : Enclosed please find copies o the proposed resolution and attachments . The hearing as been scheduled for Tuesday, July 18, 1989, before the 1 City Council . Council hearings begin at 9: 00 a .m. , owever, you might want to call the City Clerk at 298- 2 1 to determine where this matter will be placed on t e genda. If you have any questions , 1 ase don' t hesitate to call me at 298-5121 . Sincerely, THOMAS J. WEYANDT Assistant City Attorney Encs . cc : A1 Olson City Clerk Joseph Carchedi License Director � a :�:--� ... . ._. ... ,.. __ . ... . . , . . . .. . ..,..., . .....M .�.� _. ....� _�._.. ... ..a� . • s:: �' .�fL a +'W�..,�c Va. �b ,r�. �..�.w. . . " ..r i . W. .,� . 1:« . _ . Y. �^ *.'� � i'.3�i.� �w_} �� F i. Yb• IAF'.s.• .• �\ v� . ,� . . . � � .� q i�r 3. .7 . . � .,� t: -c�;. , , Y � � `.. f ��T fi��- . ,� -,., + s " ��,. Y:fa � ��; K '1 - � : ' � ^ �' f`� �'. »- ` � ' .. �n . �'' ' r A"hy. � ' , ' ��{.� , 4C • � y .�'} � -Y ' Q'•. �� � ' - � , �,[ � �� � X �f� � y ' .�.� Y. � Z .. ' �( { , �}— . ' ; Y �6 " � . y v � . c ' . � '� . i �.. � �i � •O • �.�. g.:� 8 y Y _• y • � w•'a _ � - . .. `.�a� � ; � ��J S� .-. . { � � � ' � 1`}� � z • T � .�� . � i � j a'���� -. ..� � t s � r [ ;t � \ . _ .. ��� ,. : � '� u `�:���. -3. �i 3',� i:� i L 0 � ' tNa • . . x ' � c i � - � � + 1 � � D .;:f- � _ . � . � : � ' � �. . ` . � . » h � s t �, u < '� ,, � • . _ V�-�: U �� Y � �i� � � 1 ,.� . .� � ! �� � �p Y ❑ • O i < - .. 1 S : . � � . Jl .. � � � � �: . � M � j r U � , ; ' '� - - � ` � " � � +� t O f � � J � 0 � Yp [ - ; � �.� {: .{ .a . .p ^[ i�3. � : Y Y �,.. � � � v `F a * ; �, J _ � .. ,.r � [ t .V M F • �� . ' t ':. `� y�, �/ � ``v` -J � . ` � • 1 (� � y `' . ;, ' �" � ��1, g � ` � � � ; � d .�� ���i. � y � ' T <� I � Ft:F' � �� i � - `'' , ' � .-� � F� i,� � � o �r- y���� Y = = o � � � { .r- w r ��C L �t F i!�, S O `; u . f. . :I� ,���:j � Y; 1 %� 5 �•� 1 ti� •5 '�sG � t+. � \ � �. ^ �/ S f . ' v i.s � .� Q Q � 4� �. �° �� �c • Irf rl = Z '. . � � •. t r •S �� �0�•�� �, 4 _ :y �i g�� �i � � • , , ` � � � W ti. �.� I+t �.:'�' t -��:. o �` ':; � : • � �. _�,' �' _� ~ '. , ` -r O - - � � '� _ �a � ^ , _ • � � 1 � 0�;�.: i:� �� T��3 a ° ._ �v —{. - . ,� rn �;_ t1 � � �rw'-, �;;. .�- � �� .� 1 � . -- . '; .._ + ,_.� �— � U �; � ' :. '° ; 1' �'.� `CG i �y"d �.�:,; (�j �/� ➢ ('' � •ye ;� �.t ": . �� � T� � \J Y � :, + Cr. � , ' . . ' 'Yr `� . 0 ► ; 11 ' .. -,. � y'. . ��,ff Y �J � � •F � •. � �/ r ` \� � � ~ Z� i . w 2 0 ` . ��. . t � , �L. �.rr. O�•�. � y ,� � i ��° �.�••' �/JJ t� � � �,.J �H� � ♦ Y p Y �. � � � i . i .. � af � � ♦ • ; yyi t _ , . - \ �• ��'} � : '��y i , ' 0 _ ' � _ � ';�'• j �<"� 3 t•�' ;' �' . �i i/ . t ��}�� �;, �t 7 :t� :, i :� - � w�� 1 ��� +� . 'V tt_� i f i i u � , � �� .< t u < o � �' � � • � _ _ 4� W� �k''• a " i � � ' � '� ' , � .�. �"' . } Z = , 3 s z ��.�� � • � �� o ► �! J� p ��.. p r o: i . � - /� . LJ �. . *r�y = 'i��t• � �: � � . S • Z ��t. ( . � s� ` • • ; r:J: ^ .�j � i � u �r � r= � a:k$ � 1 ; \ . ' �r i �'��*- g� o o { � F Y t > " � ,�,� p r� � �.' J �� y 3 Y K.3 V . � 3 fL_ , � : .eZ."}'tu O � �� O � r ��'..� .� . � � {� . '�I ' � ' � , [ ! � . :,r,=:.. — r v � F��{:.3 � /� � � F-- �. ,�� y ���: . �. , � � �� � ` U ; � '°� g'�. W:a �"c� . ::i:- Q ' � r _�, ` � � �� . � ��. �C�f � � � i � �_�: • ' ` • J; �. ' �3 '�' � > o ' �Y�. . �' . �.,?r . °" � _ .� v o r � � . � r► c� y • o�� • o � ;�.� � ' +�� �l' � , `' � . Q Y i ): � � j � � �}� j � � � z �..� y_' ' ' /�7, (`� '�1 r`, o-,� :,n , .Q r"ti*j. � �•.i ��' ,�(� ' `� \ 1 (,' .r �. ] � � � � � �'� � r s" � � h .,;} " 1 � t �a. �Yf ,,;Y' � • u r � /� : .. � ; .. wn..T"� . �.. �.: O . Y ..� ��•(//�� � � . ..��..{. �j y��`!Ilf'� *.I��.' •' � • �•r, ,�> . ' I 1 .. �� •i^N�, hiN� `wlc� � ,� �1 � � � �' �• � � �i�7�� �� �-i: t }�k l '.1 � ��_ • t� � ' .��.!� �. Y" \ . • � 0 jt � .. � �� 1 `�V � , f� R �i. � y� � • = t 0 J, �� �� 1 �� . G , V � � �.i. � ��:�. � � � ' . ,, ' ^ {� F �^ ^ � � �\ .i �, a. .7' F �� � � Y � ' i '� �. �i � . �.. V♦ . a;: �".j '�� � �, d ,: i� - Y- s • ;c� t .�`.( ' I > r . �� •i. /1� (� - / � � ��` w- . .� Y ' • .r.: � U ` F . . = V •,- ` ` , `� � Q�'. Y � , ' �F > � � � � a � � �� � ,,.1 � � �,, � YQ•• � � ..t. l, ' —�� � ` � � �_. . � �� . �. :� �.. �� � • T `L . ' " � F p h��' �� � ! � �l, , : —^ � �` / � k',j� . ir• . Y Y t p y:.) i� !. _ � �� � � . ` ,.! . j �t� ' . h — Y r �U �� tr: ��—"� �. < � . � „ � � :`i ` _ �� r. S � O Q � ! � r , r o c ,� . , � �' � �� u� F F w = �A, ; '; ,� ., Y � � ,� � �_ Cj�: k o � � � > ' • � , ,; i► '.� i. ; �' o : {+��f� j O r- , F;, ��_ � � s.• v}3� " .e �• � ` p . lS3y� � � � � `. . `. f �' � :'�] � l� ' .( , F , 1 " •�(� 1�. J . Y . Q. . ' .� f . r � � �� C : . GL, ,. . L ��5. < E • � i �.1• � �" ,�� '� .;, .) . �' � ' =a�,' `�;:, 4� < � s o : Z . c �{- �'_.`1 � �. �j � �.. i '� V� O J < I .�' 1 �. : +... . ��'i `� _.�.�e, N 17 �I \: t _ .r, (�f O� .+ .r � ��i . . � , . ` .�„�/� _. . .. ._ .e . �~ , .... ,. � �...+. .. � - _. _ :; _: .. , , , ,. . _ _ _. .. .. _ . ..: - .. . . .... . :. .. . ,.-,,,... , ; �?+='h�';���.#r��.t'x�4r+"�.sa'.z"''..����r;�"'j =�;r�.,�:''- •t^: ' . ? :s: «-.r i Jr�. �' _ �.. :�a. r ;' .. ` � � ��:" . � e. .� . `^� . , �� . . . . �• �, ,K':h� , - . `' . .. .+:� . . ... . � � � , ' . � . . .a�w-. . ��� n� * . .. �i � � � - � . .! . y'l (�A '�-.�L .2.�r . � `f � v,� ;.t .+ ` - -y �•�. _ . . . Q ('i'�r� ♦�, - },y� `� : % d . \\ `) . �, , •. ; �, `,, � �. �. ;:- �,'� �, �q^i�.. ��r ` � .� . �' �:. t ` (� - ` � ��i � . �� ��^`��` ,n � �..�. 'i ? ,�} r F i ��Y �. �� �, � . ' . � . \/ � . _ . � '- .. .� �.�. , - � ' " . - . .. - r - r� - • . � " !. ,•Y � [� ' -� • � � v � � . 4 _'i �+�try Y , u ' ` ' , . � .' A ��:�C � -�� . v/� "' ' , .. . 1 • � �ti a w • .I f i �V '� s �S K• � y'. o : .e��, .V �.::j t, � � � _ .. t ,,..�,-� �y £ Y-` .. -� � � • . � �� , . M1, #i.� 1' � ..� • . . , .� � t�i ! . :t . t. . � ...� R i /-� . ;`� :I\ .} Sf_ �. ' . �• . . . I C� - 1 .i: ' 1'� . . �t . �� �� ' • ' ...�7� � �}�. }r {�ya�� � y . . _- ` 1 � .. . _ ,J .r r9_ ,'1'� ��� ` ! ,i !, �/ ' f �� �{" � �'?•FJ� , { �.i`t. ' . ��, . i •� � . . L - '`e. � �.Ye �r.-• �_P. f .a[�k ! y 1 ' + ` � _ . . "� L +t ^� ` .. ���1 �i"f ��.. ,'�h �.�''L e _ .:,�� f � '�, V.r ; _�" -..�.C\�bj •: � k �r; ' . . . . � . . � +!L , �'"�.^9'• y�{u� .{'._ ^ r � � � .. . { � " �� ,���Yy��f i� �h\'j": � ' .. . S}� !'. .. .. .. : � � ;�M �.fr� f t: y � t . r'r 'ti � x " t� � . � - t ._ � ��.�N�� �. +rc-r;` � . v +� � . . 7 Y! ; j:��' Y T'{i�'. ' -_ � t � � 1 -. . . ��.rT Q k Q:� � • �, � � tl.�A , . � ���:� w V� � �. � r , . ' 7; � � � , `_ x i�. � _ V '° �`,� W'� t '�j . _ . ; �' '� . � � � � _�_.r .�� 4�" .. .• �� :-�'_ %� . , � • A: � . , f� 4 : :,f. � - l. � .�:C� .�l .1 � �� f � T�'� � �. � 1 -.. . . . ,� 1'� E'' l� � .� : � J Y v�' _,J'{.J .�', �l. r', • .�' . —. ��� : .�. . � . y/f • . � •r .'T! Y, o^ �`} ,�' ri .� � 1 . v � x �� �7� w . �-� �X ��4 Z` � ,. ,_.l_ t t ` � w! � 1 j M .; S'f �� �` .Z ,. • � . `{.. � ; y = a � . - --- , 't 3 k,i� � o� . �i . 3 ��. �. ., � �: � U�'q"' . � , -' ` �.... ° . � - •�:..�s� � c^�."+� �.-.; :..i ' � � � � _ i� ` iC,! r t ' - \ +� r s^c' ': •� y' r Q \ r ., , . � - y ;7 c G Y•,� ' � � ` • . `. . _ . � • ?"t �+ � v;,. '�., (�: ` r,,, , r i . �ti�N' �.. � Y . i � ri� t .i � . . y L. �,�' 'i F 1 }.f f 1l y � � �, - 1 . � ''7'' , _ ��y r . t^' . '�/`�.� r;i; 1, V � '� . '� yi i� �.t:- �((�� a-�- • .r � 1 ' , , � � T .�t / — j I � . � ! �L��. L 'g-= : i. . ` . � a., � . r _ tN � ' � . i I � •Tt ��+r , i a ;E . ;? '-� �t: `•J \J _r��" . •h., t���+�i. -t �({ � .��' v ' L ' V . �•- i ylJ i r,4 {� ' - �. ...� �y w.�s¢� , ti` � . � . a -,f h�'i� ? ;.. � 1 ! ^ -�►� � ' n � , . � .� t�z"� ' : �CJ ` S�+ : T i_ � � ' • - �= . ���'�, !Y Z � � {j7 � � • •� � ��:. � �I.. � _ . �' , . v �. . ., , •�`�. .: . � '�, . �.. : �., �. . • � . , b�i };�i� } : �s. 1 � � � , . _ ' . ,�n y `'; 'r. - } i ' � �J•: . ��. •. . . 1 _�'y'" 3.. � + . � 1 { j• � . - � ~� :: ' . • - � � �i4�i � �;- ; ; , � t +:.� . � ` �� , ,.�`�j��i"�� . �.'!+ � � t : � \i •��' � � L " . . t � 1 1.��'. V� 7C. / .• . . �L � , r' _I � . . � 4 � �';yiH �k��r.i ` .... � � r . . ,t � a , :, .. .. �: :l. 1 ..7'���i . ; , r �~ � � �. ' .�c•d.. ''_:. �_ ^:"-�rtia� f� \ ` �—E ', " � � .�T: ,, . ��,� ��=' CITY OF SAINT F�� � �;4' �s�. ` OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNt� �o a; �� �u�rum ., . � . �� ���� ����� �= EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY .,• �'��„ ,... r' 647 City Hall.Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 "'�.,u�'' 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER n MAYOR / ,��-�� 7I �.� : May 17, 1989 Mr. Leo Gadbois � NOTICE OF HEARING Sweeney' s Saloon 96 No. Dale Street St. Paul, Mn. 551f�2 RE: City v. Sweeney's Saloon Dear Mr. Gadbois: _ This is to notify you that h hearing will be held concerning all the licenses held at t e premises stated above at the following time, date and plac : � Da te: June 3 4J, 1 8 � Time: 9:�!d a.m. _ � Place: Room 15�3= � . City Hall n ex 25 W. Four h Street � St. Paul , n 551�2 The judge will be an Adminis r � tive Law Judge from the State of Minnesota Office of Administ at ve Hearings: � Name: Mr. Ric a Mosman Fifth o r , Flour Exchange Building 31�6 Fo t Avenue South Minnea 1 s, Mn. 55415 Telephone: 339-151 The Council of the City o aint Paul has the authority to provide for hearings conce n ng licensed premises, and for adverse action against s ch licenses , under Chapter 310 , including . sections 314J. �5 nd 31 �.06 , of the Saint Paul Legislative Code. In the c s .of licenses for intoxicating and non=intoxicating liquor , au h ritX is also conveyed by section 34�A.415 of the Minnesota St t tes. Adverse action may include revocation, suspension, fine a d other penalties or conditions. Evidence will be presented t t e judge which m ay lead to adverse action against all the licen e you hold at the above premises as follows : - . . ,'.�..�...r...�.........�.c.-.-.-'_-re...�f..«r...- .......��..�.s-,. .�.R.N_P i�...e.:'v�� �+v..T . � ..>1�.. . ___.__._ . __ _.......... ....._._..._..____"-._..�.��__....�._'��'.-�-� . . � . . . .. . ..�__ a!I .._. .. ° . '�� � ��� �--/�y/ . . . .� (,ri��'1 The basis for adverse a t ' on is that on April 14, 1989, at about 1:50 a.m., you and or your employee allowed persons to display and consume al oh lic beverages after closing , as well as serving or dis e sing such beverage. Two weeks earlier officers observ d mployees who had been drinking, on the premises at abou 6 4!4! a.m. You have the right to be re re ented by an attorney before and during the hearing if you so choose, or you can represent yourself. You may also hav a person of your choice represent you, to the extent not proh bited as unauthorized practice of law. _ The hearing will be conducted i accordance with the requirem ents of sections 14.57 to 14.62 o t e Minnesota Statutes, and such parts of the procedures und r ection 316.05 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code as may be a pl cable. � At hearing , the Administrat v Law Judge will have all parties identify them selves for the e ord. Then the City will present its witnesses and evidence, ac of whom the licensEe or attorney - may cross=examine. The lice s e may then offer in rebuttal any witnesses or evic]ence it ma ish to. present, each of whom the City attorney may cross=exa in . The Administrative Law Judge may in addition hear relevant a d m aterial testim ony from persons not presented as witnesses w ave a substantial interest in the outcome of the proceeding; f r example, the owners or occupants of property located in close p oximity to the licensed premises � may have substantial intere t in the outcome of the proceeding. Concluding arguments may be ma e by the parties. Following the hearing, the Judge will prep r Findings of Fact, Conclus.ions of Law, and a specific recommen a ion for action to be taken. You should bring to the h a ing all docum ents, records and witnesses you will or ma eed to support your position. Subpoenas m ay be available t ompel the attendance of witnesses or the production of docum n s in conformity with Minnesota Rules, part 140g.70B0. If you think that this matte an be resolved or settled without a formal hearing , please co t ct or have your attorney contact the undersigned. If a stipu at on or agreement can be reached as to the facts , that stipu a ion will be presented to the Administrative Law Judge o incorporation into his or her recommendation for Council a t 'on. - . - � _ _ � ���� ��� --/Z 7'� . ,�i��1 If you fail to appear at the e ring, the allegations against you which have been stated earl er in this notice may be taken as true and your ability to chal e ge them forfeited. If non=public data is received into evide c at the hearing, it may become public unless objection is m de and relief requested under Minnesota Statutes, section 4. fd, subdivision 2. Sincerely, THOMAS J. WEYANDT Assistant City Attorney � _ cc: Joseph F. Carchedi License Inspec tor Lt. DonaZd Winger . Vice Unit � Albert B. Olson City Clerk - - - - -- - . _ _ Paige Purcell Office of Administrat've Hearings Greg Finzell Community Organizer Summit=U Planning Cou ci . � ����ov�� C,��—��7� .91 .4 7�� , .� JUN 191989 ���,, °'�� � ��. ••• o�o ��`� f t"i i y���A��� t• `'' r, o �... . �.- •,F��,,,�J . � ' �``- • , . �Y��Y� � �� Nuni Sun S� \'� ������ _��� 96 North Dale Street, Saint aul Minnesota 55102 . 221-9157 Jvwc I� � I ��`� � � � �� ���T� � A� 1�..- ��,r� o G Sc���.�t S ���� W��c.�. �-S �� � iT��O �n � Lt c�uvn� Lic�; n�S�s �1(o c�`1,�� 6 nl � � �f r L G�`ty I .�.�� �-�-p � ��u�.�.� �cP��,� C� �.��r�r4�� �n� ST�-��F �►�D � Ca�C�v�� ��- � �f 01���� �ccc�,�-�-�D f ��,`�r� � ��- -4� c� �c�-L 1�-�cr-.- �4�Wtc �4��C � (r��r.����`�1 �-�°t���p ��C A�W�- �-�`� �-+P .�r� Jcn�t 3�� �r�-!. t n���T�A-D� ( t�t S -�-� ��� ��---�� d.7(����� � �-�.�� Cc t-f � cc� N4q(�W k �n� �}-cS �n�--�E�� - L �c�S�-�o �c� R�1�-�n�c�/ rs . ��-��� `5 R-�C,� �( C��-�- �(z�N� q�� c�.sc�x.� �v � ,� Wlkc�- �S I N`�1���D�.D �� �(t-�..���j �, ►� ��,�� V Ca c�-��� , �C�,��y . c� � . �A��z-e��S - lJ�� � . � i��i _ ,,.,., ������� �, :, �F. , . . �•:. � � .��. .,. o ., . . ro •f o �4�J �� e••': � . � � S�eeae s �� hnnl!tm f� � ����J�� ,� ' 96 North Dale Street, Saint a 1, Minnesota 55102 . 221-9157 LABT CALL DRINK D CL08IN0 POLICY � In eccordance with Miri►'�pved at last• calllinabothtth�f5�lac+n�und � procedures will be obse • Cafe' each ar�d every nioht : ► i. When anno�mcinq la t all �t each table. wait st�ff will inform c��stomers a z ornxirnrte currer�t time ar�d p�+litely warn cust me s tn�5tab� bemaved�tarcc+mplvnwith 1 �00 t12tQ0 ari suri �y ) , t he 1 aw. 2. Custc+mer�' drinks em iriing at 1sQ0 will bp remcved it-c+rn tableg c�r bar sp�c i � as c�urteo��s and casu�l a wav as possible. "Reluct nt ' custamers will be dealt with or� �n individual b�si , ith 5taff avaidino "c�ttle-call" demands tc+ tt�rr► in dt, nks or ledve. P�rtenderg wi 11 assist as necess�r, . 3. All serv�r� and ot er 3�A'Ff will or�der and en,t�y their after-shift cackta 1 ftet� servino thefr last ra��nd af � last c�l l, and bef re 1 n00 (12��0 S�_�nday�) sharp. Staff will turn in � -cf-shift c�+cktails pr�mptly �+t la@0 �12t00 5�.�nday ) , clear remainir�g beverages fr�m rustamer tables' �t t at time, and refrain frc�rn cansuminq alcoholic beverage fter tha� time. , 4. Barter�ders �f each s ift are ultimately respc►nsible for ' - enfarcing the abov a�t-call pr-oced«res. � � � . r' � �° � � r-+ • ..�d o0 � uai O U �U rn � •rl •r-1 �' /1 00 � 'd G m cd .o • '� � � m •� N Ri �o � N U "d � � m a0 � ia 1-� p. � N ,.._1 � O � � •� O rn }a � � a v� a • .,� s� c� rn .0 ..� oo a� � � �-+ o � � a��-+ � � � � � 3 �� s� 000nc� .i".. � �A � O '�' �„ H O •rl ia O�i' � •rl �'-+ f�"� v� �t cd � •� �-I tn N v] •�� 3 W •r� t� �+ � a+� � a a � � � a a� �� � �+�--� � o ca cn • V .0 � � ,--� o N � cn N �.n , a-► U'd F�+ U • ri � ,f�+ O D, � - � L�++� � �t u-a � a� +� �,, � a - � o ao, � �n�+-� � �, d �23 ch 4-t cn cn � � cn 4-� � �I �n oo cd � cd aocv .,.� � �.-. c�l N a ��n cn v� r-t V a cn o. i .� � v� � cn cn � O.. .. �� o�o � N c�� � 'd'd'C°O � 'd r-I f=+ !-� �-+ •d W •^ w �� � � U cti N U N r-I N rn U td � M ri � .� �3 CV� �4-� r-I v o a �` � c� � r� '"� � .n � � � � � � •d � �-�+ ri � O � >C � N U � • � a � � � � � � � d o �+ b �� a�i � ° +°�.► o°o a � � � o � � +� �.° � � �� a� � �� •a�i� +� a� +, � o �+ .� o o � a u � � � . ._. _ � � a�..► u �.�� � a�i- . �a '� o � a��+-� +� a� �n -� °� a�i � � � ° • � � o �, � c� � a � cv � � cd cd N N � ...b� � .. � 'd'd � o z � � � z � �, � °� � � v p •rl U •rl O � � � o �d o o a � cd cd rl ? 1-� cd r-I � U � m rl O S-� cd r—I O '.�� a a � a�.� a �+-� a� � a� ao a�'i � � a� .n � -� a� a�i � c'-�d � .� � �d � � .� o cn 'd � .� 3 w v� � o a°�i w � ° � ° �' � �i � ° '� a� aa., �n � 3 c.� � a-► �+ �.► � a� •a �+ .0 �� d �+ c� b cn z � a � a or-+ � � a oa � ao � . � o � o � � a� o � o +� o � .� � � � 'd cn �-+ .� � �d N •cn ,.��—► �a �n v� � � � u� v� a� a. �n a� a r+ � a � a..� � w �+ � �+ � v� o � � � �+ o� a� a� a� w a� o a� o � � a� a� o �a a� � a� a� � � a� w a � � � � .� ..� +.� � .�,.� .0� a � � w � �+-� w -+.� �,-� +� � 4.a � � a � o � d �s � �ts 3 � o d �ts 3 0 � � •�+ o� ,��+ � �x � � ,� r+ �n �a � �+ bn�+ t� �n o wArn � � � 3 � � �� oO O •N O � � � a� �,2° � .N � � a � �+ a� G � � rn � m aa .�+ a�ua � � a� �s o � •.��oo a� r+ • � -d o � aa v �+ F7 U O� C!� � O c1� cd }-a O •^ � cd ,� � - �-1 cd 'd G3�I v� 'd'd cd � U1 � � � FA �+ 'd }.+ - �+ N „� W-rl Rf �d cd � � O � 9 +� N o � a� y a..► v� 3 +� a � 3 �+ b ai ai a� ro � � ai � �3 � v � � vi ��.► c`�i - .� a � .+� � � rx � o .0 �s t� o� o �+ O Z W cn C7�t3 G� A � � �, A o � d . ; �+ �' c�'d u�-i � ' � r-I �'b }-I OO n � � m O.U�C� O o0 +� � � � •rl •,� �i n •rl 00 � 4-I 1 1 O � � O � �� �o °� �� � a� a� `� -d o � tA •rl N cd �O U) N �,--I 'J � � �+ Rf - la 1.� P.N N �l � � O� /1 •rl N cd LT� U m � a � a • •.� s� �•,�o0 0, � 3 � � c� •a t� o � � aa,� o � o � • oo �t o •�� w a� .� � �n � o � � i-+ •�+ - � �+ v� •� �+ •� � cn �t cd � cn .� o �n � � m a � +� •� �+ � �,.� a o � � u� � a� � a�� ���+ a� o �t v, • v �+' a� c� o � o c� a� rx c� a��v .0 �b �+ � • � a a� � o � a �, -d va •a a� .0 � � �n � .fl u �n w . .,� �3 � �2f M 4-I C/] [n � � � m o0 N O � O �� •rl � cn �,00 � N � m bDrn N O V a c� a, ,.0 �+ c�ao .� � D,�d W oo � a.-� � v� � �+� � Sa •�I � ?i cd U cd td }a 1-� ��O � 'd O .{-� 'd ch� i� -.0 'd � +� 'b� a-.� .� � -rl r-� U �-t d-► O � �'i� U N ,i� �d �O � cd M.i"+ rl �ul N � W . cC � � .�'d -� �� o a � � �� � ; . .r., zs •�+ o� �� a�i � � � � � � � � �� � N ',�" ?, '� � - aUi.� �d � � a � � �d °� �n c�i o � � o o �+ .� o o • a�•� •�+ � b on �n oo. a�� +� ov�i � � �' � o � o o �n �,� �n o a m •� r-+ �+ o 0 � a�i � a�i °� •� �n o � a a� •� •�+ � op � � pa� � a�i a�i� � � �a � U U .� � N � � ,.�� vai � � .� H cn � cn rn H �d • � a1 U � � � � 3c�v � vb0 � cn � • D,�t •• � cd � �, � o t� � d .�.�� 'd N �� � 'd'd �-a � � z z 3� �-+ �n � 3 0 •� .o c� � � ° � :� ° a� :- �� an � � � oai o � �� � �' ai ,� � °,� �° °°.� � � •�� w o 'd a�•� �--� cd c0 • cn +�r-+ a-� bn m � cd cn ��-I � cd i v� � +� � •�I a.� N c�3 � •�-I a v� � }-� �I c�.� � � cn � •� � v� 'ti � � .�,.� O 'd � ..0 N R3 v� � � � o �d a-► o � �s +� .r..► .� � a� .0 a tw �a o � cn U � ct�� a) cn •v� bo � m v� co � v� ao }a cd U �1-� U � � � a-► �+ � cd � tn r-1 }-� 'Lj cn � �?3 •r�l•rl •rl ;� O r-I O U �i � O �t O•rl ^�rt � O � �C 3 �-1 O U ct3 cd � O U � �4-1 O cd }-i • � .� �, O O ..� b0 'd 4-I � .� ''d 'd � O ..d GO cd m N cd •r-I .1--� �t }-i � N � � �f � U) N a D +� � �,� .,-.+ � o a� N � �—+ �n a� t� � v� -d a� �+,—+ a� a� � u� a ar+ � a a� ��-+ �.� a� a� � �s � ,.o . a�r-+ � r+ a� w +-� cn zr o .� c� •� .a .� �d .0 �d•d � ro � •� a � �+ � •� �w •� �► w ,--� cv w � � o � .. � �, o �'d �noaa do.� � - � da�a � � +� � �u °� a � 3 a�i a�i 3 � a�'i °° ' a� � � � a� a� .� rn �� r+ �n c� � �.° � a' � Ao 0o p . N � � � � � a�0� G �Zrn � x N � � � N� .� N 'O U-I O � T3'd tn � h U� c!] � � � .d O a-1 � 'd �� 7a W W-N �� � cd'd � Ri c�C � c�n P� � .. o A p �n 3 � � a� 3 .�u a�i �d Q, ai a� a� c� v a� �•� a� � � � � � +� a � +� � � n-� � o w Ao � H /�, t°�� o zw „ ;; WHITE - CITY CLERK PINK - FINANCE (�I TY OF s I NT �AUL Council g9-1272 - Substitute L.'�NARV�- DEPARTMENT BLUE - MAYOR FIl NO• C ' esoluti i g`; � � Presented By '��`"" Referred To � � om t e: Date Out of Committee By Date WHEREAS , the most rec t fire fighter examination given by the City of Saint Paul a been attacked by the Minnesota Department of Human Rights a being discriminatory to women; and WHEREAS , in conjunctio ith these charges the Minnesota Department of Human Rights in Rugust 1985 sought and received an order of the court preve t ' g the city from hiring any fire fighters until the trial the charges has been completed, and a determination and remed stablished; and WHEREAS , as a result o this hiring "freeze" the Fire Department is incurring serio s problems in regard to availability of personnel for the paramed c program, availapility of i�ersonnel for appointment to regular ire fighting duties and serious financial problems because o overtime required to meet the problem of the hiring freeze ; a d WHEREAS , it is clearl n the best interest of the City of Saint Paul and the cit z s of the City of Saint Paul to resolve this situation th u h discussion and settlement, if possible ; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED , that the Coun il of the City of Saint Paul declares its intent to continue nego ia ions with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights , the fire f' ghter ' s union, the applicants who passed the fire fighter ' s te t, the parties who did not pass the test and brought sui , and any other parties of record in an attempt to resolve th s issue through settlement ; and, be it FURTHER RESOLVED, tha the Council hereby requests the office of the City Attorne o review all issues closely with COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �ng In Fa or Goswitz Rettman B scee;bei _ A gai n t Y Sonnen Wilson Form A proved y City orney Adopted by Council: Date Certified Yassed by Council Secretary BY � g�. �pproved by Mavor: Date _ Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY - — BY WHITE - C�TV CLERK COU[1C11 ( ��'�1�� A P�NK - FINANCE 'L:A�JARY�- DEPARTMENT G I TY O A I NT PA U L !A r w( BLUE - MAVOR File NO. � 1 a ��t � Counc� esolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date the intent to identify any p oposals which might serve as a basis for settlement disc ss ' on and to continue settlement discussions with all of the p r ies. 2. COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �ng In Favo Goswitz Rettman D B �he1�� A gai n s t Y Sonnen Wilson ,�± AW 1 71989 Form pprov d ity Attorney Adopted by Council: Date �� . ! Certified Yass b uncil Se ta BY�}- � By Approv lWavor. Date � � �' Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By PUBUS� ��� 2 e 1989 . . ... . . . ... ...... . . .. .. .. . . _._. .. . .»_v....,..,.._ . . .... .. . ... . ... .. ___. ._. .� ._. �,<.,... ... � ,. . s j�'. - . -.. ...,..-... _��:.:;,e. -+oeraer� • . � - �- �.,,b<i s i. .r�..t.;�;%i GITY OF S INT PAUL � . . _- � �� -� r �.s� � uuaai�n ` . �' ��' ' O1� a i'�i OFFICF OF A CITY COUNCIL =� + � _�,?�� Comm tt e Report �� Finance Mana eme t & Personnel Committee JU Y 1, 1989 1. Approval of minutes of July 1 , 1 89, meeting. Approved FINANCE AND MANAGEMENT 2a. Resolution 89-351 - amending he 1989 budget by Approved transferring $32,062 from Con in ent Reserve to Police Administration for ful -time position to oversee license renewal and a pl cation process. (Referred from Council March , aid over July 10 for amendment) 2b. Resolution 89-1004 - amending th 1989 budget by Approved as amended adding $112,000 to the Financ ng & Spending Plans for Community Services Utilit N eds. (Referred from Council June 6, laid ove J ly 10 for amend- ment) 2c. Resolution 89-1024 - amending th 1989 budget by Approved as amended adding $23,500 to the Financi g Spending Plans for Community Services Divisi n f Libraries Maintenance Services. (Refer ed from Council June 8, laid over July 10 for am ndment) 2d. Resolution 89-862 - amending he 1989 budget by Approved substitute adding $196,888 to the Financ ng & Spending Plans resolution � for Public Works performance mp ovements activaties. (Referred from Council June 2 , aid over July 10 for amendment) 2e. Resolution 89-1153 - amending th 1989 budget by Withdrawn : addding $17,068 to the Financ ng and Spending Plans for `Fire and Safety Services dm nistration. (Referred from Council June 2 , ithdrawn by Administration) 3. Resolution. 89-1272 - declaring in ent to reopen Approved substitute negotiations in an attempt to es lve firefighters resolution issue. CTTY HALL SE E TH FLOOR SA1NT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 46 . ............... ,o-m,...v ....�.._r,,.:r ..,.....-....,. .�. .;...,:v-�. <_..^T•�..a... ...;�,-xin+:rRl��+••:--..,. ._�y_�,..._ ....-. +�.v9w+errn.�.a....ow..p1.,T...>�- . - -•--....,,w.»�........� 4. Discussion of Police and Fire Pension Consolidation. No action required 5. Resolution 89-1138 - directing the Port Authority Laid over to use funds from its net income to refund to St. Paul taxpayers $1,639,504 collected in 1989. (Referred from Council June 22) 6. Resolution 89-1218A - amending the 1989 budget by Laid over to 8/21 adding $15,733 to the Financing & Spending Plans for Special Projects-Police, Uniform Crime Reporting Grant; (Referred from Council July 11); and Resolution 89-1218B - authorizing a Federal Uniform Laid over to 8/21 Crime Reporting agreement with the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. (Referred from Council July 11) 7. Ordinance 89-895 - amending Chapter 33 of the Admin- Laid over to 8/21 istrative Code pertaining to reimbursement for car expense by providing a monthly increase for elected officials. (Referred from Council June 15) 8. Ordinance 89-1040 - amending Section 13 of the City Laid over to 8/21 Charter pertaining to procedures for the acquisition and improvement of property (Referred from Council June 13) 9. Ordinance 89-1041 - amending Section 14 of the City Laid over to 8/21 Charter pertaining to special assessments. (Referred from Council June 13) 10. Ordinance 89-897 - amending Chapters 369 and 370 Denied of the Legislative Code pertaining to building (presenter is requested trades business licenses and certificates of to withdraw resolution) competency. (Referred from Council May 23, laid over July 10) PERSONNEL 11. Resolution 89-860 - amending the Salary Plan and Approved substitute Rates of Compensation Resolution regarding Unclas- resolution � sified Positions. (Referred from Council May 18, laid over July 10) 12. Resolution 89-1181 - granting wage and benefit Approved provisions of contracts between the City and the Supervisors Organization to non-represented managers who elected not to be covered by the new Manager's Wage and Benefit Policy. (Referred from Council July 6) 13. Resolution 89-1238 - amending Section 28.B of the Approved Civil Service Rules concerning compensation. (Referred from Council July 13)