The URL can be used to link to this page

89-949 I WHITE - CITV CLERK � ///�� PINK -.fINANCE COIlIICIl� G// �� BLUEQV - MAVORTMEN7 GITY OF SAI PAUL File NO. � � - 9 Cou cil R s lution j��; Presented By Referred To ommittee: Date Out of Committee By Date ; WHEREAS , Robert L. Walsh, 2 6 . Seventh Stree�, Saint Paul , Minnesota, applied to the Plan in Commission of� the City of Saint Paul for permission to i st 11 a sign whic� exceeds the height restrictions for the zo i g district (B-5i) by approxi- mately six feet, pursuant to he provisions of $ection 66.409 of the Saint Paul Legislative C de, for property lbcated on Lots 10 and 11 , Block 26 , Rice and r ine ' s Addition �o the City of St. Paul ; and � WHEREAS, following a he r 'ng conducted y the Zoning Committee, the Planning Commi s on by its Re� lution 89-22, adopted March 31 , 1989, denied t e application f r modification of the provisions of the Zoning Co e ; and i WHEREAS , pursuant to the p o ' sions of Sectio 64. 205, Robert Walsh duly filed with the City C rk his appeal fiom the determi- nation made by the Pl.anning C m ssion requestinc� that a hearing be held before the City Coun il for the purpos� of considering the action taken by the said C sson; and WHEREAS, acting pursuant t Sections 64.20� through 64. 208 and upon notice to appellant an other affected property owners a public hearing was duly co d ted by the City� Council on May 11 , 1989, where all intereste arties were givejn an opportunity to be heard; and WHEREAS, the Council ha i heard the sta;`tements made and having considered the modif c ion applicatior'1, the report of staff, the minutes and find'ng of the Planni�g Commission and the Zoning Committee, does he eb COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Depart�nent of: Yeas Nays Dimond � Lo� In Favo `� Goswitz Rettman Scheibel A g8i n s t BY �Sonnen Wilson Form App ov d by !�ity Attorn y Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary By g�, A�pproved by Ylavor: Date _ Ap rov by Mayo� for Submission to Council gy — BY WNITE - CITV CLERK ' PINK -�INANCE G I TY SA I NT PA LTX, Council �,� C/lNARV - DEPARTMEN7 ^�- BLUE - MAVOR , Flle NO• � Cou c Resolution Presented By Referred To Committee: .�i Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVED, that the C u cil of the City�� of Saint Paul does hereby reverse the decisi n f the Planning',�jCommission and does hereby grant the applicat o for modificati n of the provisions of the Zoning Code so as t permit the in�tallation of a sign which exceeds the height r strictions for �I he zoning district and which is located by a pr ximately six fe' t, for the property as described above, the c sion of the Ci��r Council is hereby based on the Council ' s find'n and determinati��n that the Planning Commission did commit an er o in the followlrl� respects: 1 . The proposed siz f the sign is �ot contrary to the general intent of Chapter 6 the Saint PaullZoning Code. 2. The proposed sign an its proposed s! ze would not create any hazard or violate any st te statutes , r�i�.es and regulations developed pursuant thereto. i 3. The proposed si n is not objectulnable to adjacent property owners. ,� I 4. The proposed sign o ld not adversel�llaffect residential property through excessive la e and lighting. 'I 5. The proposed sign i n keeping with ��e general character of the surrounding area. ,I FURTHER RESOLVED, tha e appeal of F��bert L. Walsh be and is hereby granted; and, e it FURTHER RESOLVED, that t e City Clerk hall mail a copy of this Resolution to Rober . Walsh, the Z� ing Administrator and the Planning Commission. �i COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Depa�ltiment of: Yeas Nays � ; Dimond �� In Favo Goswitz , Rettroan � � Sc6eibel A gai n s t BY � Sonnen ' Wilson 1'!HY 3 Q 1:7(79 Form Appr ve by Ciky Att ney Adopted by Council: Date , Certified Yas-e' ou cil , et � BY— _ ,J i By� - �� A►pprov 1�1a ate _ �' '� Appro e by Mayor f t Submission to Council _ _L• — BY —+-- PUBttStED J UN 10198 ' � • • (,it'(�'�6 7 / °��'�. CITY OF SAINT PAUL S"y .310 ��U q; ��, OFFICE OF 7HE CITY ATTORNEY '� wunnm �: `%; "-�� 10° ;� EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY '"��,,,«�°'m��'�� 647 Ciry Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR May 18 , 1989 Albert B. Olson City Clerk 386 City Hall Saint Paul , MN 55102 � Dear Mr. Olson: Enclosed please find a Reso ut on whereby the �ity Council would reverse the decision of t e Planning Commis�ion regarding an application for modification o the zoning prol,risions for a sign to be located at 216 W. Seve th Street, the app]��icant being Robert Walsh. i Would you please prepare t e necessary greenlsheet and process this Resolution for the City Co ncil . 'j Y r very truly 'j J GAL I Ass ' stan• City Attorney j J jr , Enc. � , � � ��- �� ::�� IT OF SAINT PAUL INTERDE AR MENTAL MEMORANDUM �CEIVED MpY 1�71989 C'�TY �L�F�K M E M O R A N D U M DATE : May 16 , 1989 TO: Albert B. Olson City Clerk FROM: Edward P. Starr �', City Attorney I have received your letter f ay 11 requesting a Resolution implementing the action of t e ity Council concerning the appeal of Robert Walsh of a la ning Commission decision regard- ing modification of the sign r inance for propexty located at 216 W. Seventh Street. Jerome Segal of our office ha een assigned to prepare this matter by May 30. Workload, ac tion schedules qr other prob- lems may result in this deadl ne not being met, but if not, I have asked the assigned att rn y to communicate with you in writing as to his or her p og ess with your request. If our proposed deadline does o meet your needs , please advise me or Jane McPeak and we will r to accommodate Circumstances which require special consider t 'on. EPS : jr x - 3 Tt :r r +�: n{ r�, ,: -} $ . .. ,v ^Y i i � :r b },•, N t : � . i i h�� J t M: � "�` �w � x,_� � � . � � '� :l� Arf6 0 y ��r vl � �� 7 xn Y �f, "� fi" :..y e ' � � �� ;t ' � ' � �. �� ix.'�t1� a e r�� r i �. �^h � y�� r � . ° S � rr t l'b � r� �h � � r ��k."4,��i'�.;.. ��. ..�y Z t � ," '� � i "�' � � ..: / � � ;i�. r + x" � � � /- ° � �, � ,, l E . ... s' �'yYy,� .' .� �. � -� �2�, y iy { �l A `1 ��;p j.�. � t � _.a j ` , .f'1 / �� t i ( e._ � �'�{'l4�. f F - C � .� �t � t r ;� �� F . •. G ZR�` '�{� �{ ` I �.. yy .. �a Y 4 . � � � �} �/� ' � �'. ��r�� " �� ,�= �r � �. �X�� i A ff � r �� `� i# .� ..:� � � � � � rrf�" . �� ,y �� 1 ii k� -�. a �"Y'��!`s'�y r,:F- �� y. � � f � : '�) t.. $ ( h;� yt�` Y �i � i \ r v A��: � �' °� �/�� '� J � z ' � 1 � �.Al 1- i;f'{( �.�_t i _�k f � � ��'a '� $'l:t� L �.4 t � - 'E3 1'�-f `*� i f q � ' �'t - �1 . �C v � ti . � � � �,� , , ,, r �p ; A r �� y r,�, � �� 1f� s� , � � t � ; : : � , y+ , � b� :�r Y a t.� r � '�'.." y,�, ..�' '� �� t . ,� ' �-yy _ � j , � J ��,. 4 x �'�~� �",�. �r r �' � �� . � s�.;r '� y ' �� p r . r ��' � 'r �, f+, � .�-/ � x I �'fif j'� +� x( � j1-� , �j, a � t '�`! �'. � x � � V�. A � � ��: �k � �� /'="� -'� ,� �" '�y f �.,��;A� ;�„71 ti e?� y d � -:. •-t� i 1 � t i, � f � '�k � -+r., � � , , , , � , r � �V : C � : r , � '�\ � .� � � i ' : s,7'r+ t 1 k � ��.� � . � , •`'�-1 � r� ' �i f . t `r � �� k �'� r� t� i �,� � �a 't t � + �� !ry � �i�s �}� 't 3� '1�� F �� '1 �Q. �Ec � ..�f=r �� r�� ` � �� '� �� r J � R � ' ° � �� xi 1 a'�' < � .�� ..i�t '� � � � � 6 � �3 �� . i ; a7r 1. � � � 'r� �� - a t " ? �. ' . i �i' a "�', 1 i � A�f'� x, �� A r i � ' r � t r; , . � . !� ; :, r ,' �� , � k " , � � ti� � '� `° y, �Q { f ;� t ��" �.r*'�.•_ , � � j �- �,� �kr y �"�� ' •�/ i�� ^� Frk � i ={ 1 � .' Ay �1 M1 'q] ,� c i1 +�:� t '�4 �y i a.� -� . .� � [ � a _ � . � �,t t 7'l. �� t �f�yA � g,�� ' t i� /'r j- ! 1p� ` 1 � � ' ' l ? � t t `�'t ��- . s n-: r' ��T i�,� � �� l 1: �k . l� x � � �� eL��C,� , r �'_ i , r p h ia f � r � �v� v �3, -r � F '�^� f M� �t � 1 � � r � s� #i t � � -F i .'�� f � � @ .� � �' ,t�r�n ` i e � �! �; �� `. �,�� t> ;� ` t ` � '4� � � � ;" ,�1 y, 1 �y " � ,. ' �' '�� .Z� 3 - 1 1 �, . .�.'r ti {t ' � / � � �: �T '# =x a. .:� . d' s�k �. i.� a . y ,� l: » � d � k� i c �.. � # a 1,�)y�M � ��n k,,f T h"� 9�"} + r �'�:t , � �,. � ��',• � � {� � �� . RT #` �� .n,� }W�* F�,-.S� � � Y � f 'r /� 4'� � ' t �I k � �� 9 r '•r .: � /� �-?� : �' " � f �I'� t r � �_ ( . r ?9i � ,� Y na�.i � �— d . . f. �( '� �..:�[ f r F ' � � f..' _. ,�L+� r� ��.� .s{ i� ' � `C -�ft! �(' J e l r�i 1,� ' S� :i � �ra .� � , ,. 5 �: / � . ��i J} t l i� � � ��k �r � �, t �s '. .�'� �� , :_ i M � � � � l ,_ � .� � t 3Y � �� r L'� � ki � � 7 .. - � in 4" �'�. , t ,, ,.. � ; .. � k # t f , �'� � � '� � �i �y,p� � �"� s � � A � � �',x�� Y� { �, � 3P r ,��. �' �4 ` F � a ��_�. ,t � . �� . '� G � ,�t � r , r �t i F ,. � � � �..-�� I �t �P i�` �� \� �� > � � �� . t �.�v �` `�_� e } � �' � . � ��, t � . .�y .. � - , 1k � .. ,: 1 '. ��. 2 � � . . _ • � �„ _,.w ��hi � t � k � i . t . ' t i'� t � 4 w r �� ,,� S � r ��* . ti �r `h ,�# � r,y��. p $� i f� � � z 'k� �� '� i`�'� K ij� a"� +r � ti� �' e� � F i �r��i �"'^'`�9�� + :�� , r � `. r 3r, „�� i:."�� :'1�.� ��.'2 •. . i a _ .�y� ti �. s � �✓�r �.°�8� �'.4't +�: Q�i*' i��: s� �a�. �,,,' :�, �''��'r,�� ,i t' � i � 4'� !'� �� . Q� �'',�: ��1�' S!�t��. i, � �'t7i�' : '"'#r' t A 1� �� t /�, t.:f i > a i:� i { :�t� �ry ., �Y �r�' ,��SF'�'�.'°�� } `.L��s E��*T �1�� r n�t � �°� "r�� p�' < x � ��y� �p '�,� � � r ,:� � 1 �il�. � 'Q'�"A�r �� . � "�,��. � !�� .�,.,��. s ,�: � 3 . ,� f�� r f'� � � f k � 7' .�� t .� y F�' .,C.. /'Z i�/' ^+1 t . J �.: � s r �R �"� �; �, a•, ��i r � d !� l�� ; �t � a y: 4 iY� '�/ y %� � ra� �� F :s .,� � �. �'°. �:t w., >t'� �' ��, ` S i..1 e 'l �,.� ,� .„ A � . �� ! �� ' a �� '..A'� p �� E � � '�.�� `� �y�x'. ti i :�� t k s I +1 < , , � ' '` f� • � ` p i° � , .:� ,� �-'�`��': � : , �, � � � ` � ; , , r ; 1 � 3 ,a ; C 1 �, � k;: �� x � �� ,, . , �.:. � -� � � -,� ` � �� (, r .,� t i `� r : ; 4 a, F� ,� , ro i {� �",. f y , �� - ,� , �:3,, i'k _,a°� ;? ��,� r:, ,� � ,, .� F �a � ' , 5�.: �y � ;� , y., .°_ �} ;, � � � � � � t�s� + � � �` ��'�i�''� � ' x, � � ` ti '� a ;-+ n '. � � k � s " r"� t � r` �'�4 �., t, r'. Z y � .� l ✓�� ' ' i ��°�� x..d P .-� �' t t ` x . l � p �S r�� t,.�a J'��.• v, '�. _ 'y 7 S� � � j� � � 1� l � . + J/ �� yv '(� tp�t. � �� t� ��, � , � �7, � ; .4� � . n � ��f � � �°( : �� k ��1 '' � �� i � r y�.Y 3n ��- 4 �� .. t (il � ��-i .�\,,, � hj,_ �R. r ks�t� .� . � ��4, m,t�'';c y ... � a {�y • y 0� � '`�.�� !I'�t� �,rpb � ` _r�`� ( ' - �, � � �l a i�v� � � t �y � � �an � ' K b'�.� � I yr d � h�,'�� r w :�` s+ � � !� i,z �� 5 ��3r� ' t �,�' � �xl �} �Y � � � '�i y e -4 i . i e� t � � � �3 d.` ,a �� .�� y ; � �- � r�d �_ i� A� I a :4 �: t �= l � � � f r 5 +. r n� .°1(X �?i t' . Y p � �' '�� p-i'�' 4' � k'� ':/ d�� 7 �. -� r'z .w;�r� 1: :�� 4 � ��afC . ...�� x ° � f 1 � i � .-} ^l,, ��y',.H� .� y ! 4 } � '' � ' � � J.�r ' � f , , F�� ; '�� . s .�, ��' � � . �:� F J i%�a � a 1\'.�- t � � /ti. � � . F my f +J �� : �.. ,¢ � :. �. . .: � . �'- .��.1 a . a r� 1 f w� f i6�� i c,: -�: h � �� .�� d $i. � :y _ � y � er '� c�r� ! �� -%�p�, � i� t �- � r '� �,. �: t ,..(� `�� k: F �d , .+�'� . � �; \ 2 ' , 3 � $ �Y � � � y � • 1 � . rr .. � r�, a r '�s ' }. e+s E� , J : (� � , . ,�1s., 'r l � :t't �i i : � � 7 1'�� ' ��f � � m .� � � � X� 7 � �o � } ro�' � �:�i tr � � , r( 'tt .! - .p � / 7 f,;r r� � i�� d 2 ' r 5� '�� x I . � �. o ' � �:e � �� y,, X. � ': T�' g r � . � r � 4 �f 7 �K�. ,r .- �'�la.. �r' � '. '� •r r 7 : . �i R � : � �� F ' ! a � � t ; l� � �t fi .K z ��a w ? � r�_t� x { i �.1 � �`� � " ��t � i. � �i .. �. .'� { �s' 1 a �}.0 '�� a x � �� ur � � , �� 1 �, � * � ,� � ��4r '� s�� Y� d �� 7 Y ti! k ,� � ��:; ^ � �� j . . ;1 � c�.s i ��i � ��R � 4 i rr ��dD k:' 1��'� Z � 1;7 Y. :• ,�J/ y 1 ��✓ I ;.� � I � 1/`� l�Y y " !� ,'� � 1 x ��g� � � " } `.. J :i t� t/ , I � ,:1 �/. i , � � , � , ^yx}� } . L J i :r ;.li �;r I t ,� i��:, l� ti 4� �� , -� � � 1- �� !� , r.; ! . � R `r i - > r' 4 y"' � k� !- ! o ! I �" � 1 � i � � � � � U�-� y 4d � ( � � � E �. ,t:;°' , � �4,. 42: 7� � S ti t . r,�r' �' �a i - �. ;j / i f .S�C etii" f � c.4 . , -' i• e k"' � 1 i,� � : �° : � � �`- k r. � �..� 5 ,; . :Y4r' F / � �. . 4 . l Y f 1: ./, 'CM1 � � !t f� �/ � r ,I} � { t�, ��\ '�� i_i J ��? r;,� � �'�.t � i; { r .'a t F' r}}br�� _ Y Yi f ] 'k �{, '� i .. {� .e�4� i�1� � ,f ,,,� F �4,� } �, � .{ �,~ t > a ; �� y p A t ..l � �E 4 C1 t J .5 r (� l ��a � � !t � f v � �� ,"ti'i�� '7�, � � , i. , i _ �v t� 6 �" � r � ,`�\ -y ' f �`� �i_ � .,�, a � -. I < . k � I � � 4 � �' F + .. r � ' '{ F � : � l �� b � tf J- � ✓ i �� ; � y� "� � r %r � � r <% � j� n !� "4 y �� I 1 � �' - ! ! . � ar�� , _ �,f �� Y L $y� . � � k' '� ! 1� y�� ..��F �` ' �t �..♦ ! . .� �. `M 1 �f. 4�' f �G +� ` ' :.J ` t � � J : �t � �' Y '�� i�\ � �. J � k 1 t��£ �G,:�� .��.sl � �'! � ' � ';� : \ ."k- f� (9'Y ��'K 1 r �,�r � �� [. {. J;.9x } 4 J S � � �a f � ~ �.{i i ��;� ` � i n � t A /t��. � -.f.4' �f / .I� ; „y!'�.� �� 7�� Y k,' 7^ � �(?s Y 4�'�� ft� � ; � at�� W. �`�� t' " # \ ��.�h • �� '�t + 1 � 1` T !� r� � r t�� : } f .� � �' .� �^� � i�'. �'� �� a '� '_, a r Y,. � . F t �� t� . � r . y 3 , Y+ �,: I ` id .3r �. $ " ; � `,� � s < ' �i ! � ��! t .. . 1 .�t / r i .. � � 4 � '} :� �ri .� : - s �.t r, �� ' c� , � � F �� r� ,, b �. � �� ;f � • ' � 'd K��„i 1 / ��, y r �'s"� �� p�„ r '�k�:, ?� .`. •. , y R � -1 �" k. ^ j � �y�- `y� � , s �' , { y '7^ - y V i 1 .e.✓ � � '! � 1� � '� t .. ..:� .�,�. t� ' -f� ;�� ,A . <� .� . �S� ... �� ' � �`;. ..,y� � ._� � �""�� ? r � �- � r �t . Y. � � y�` i r. f ,�7 �'� �. 1�. J �'& � � �.. �� ' i �. > � � . e ��, f r� 1�- 1`� � '} -�C ,��,. _i:b. ,_�,.i:. ., �..,r �"�.,. � r . .. i.,.>. r. . . .. , . . �.�� . `�� i '� .��.,i��c . .1 _. ._ :i{.. . 4 t , c ,...5 .n ..p,3 .l.<'r .r� ,ar. ` ��CITY �p 9� , 4 x CITY OF SAINT PAUL ° ��„��°,,, b DEP R MENT OF PLANNINC AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT wm °11 �� hC DIVISION OF PLANNING 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 786� 612-228-3270 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR May 3, 1989 Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386, City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File #10435 - Robert Wa sh City Council Hearing: May 1, 1989 PURPOSE: To permit the installa io of a sign which ex�eeds height restrictions for the zoning dist ict by approximately s'�x feet. PLANNING COMMISSION DECISION: De y 8-6-1) �'� ZONING COMMITTEE DECISION: De y 5-1) '�'�i � STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deny SUPPORT: Two people spoke; two le te s received. OPPOSITION: None. Dear Sir: On March 23, 1989, the Zoning Commi te of the Planning Co�nmission held a public hearing on this sign varianc . The petitioner testified. At the close of the public hearing, the Committe vo ed 5 to 1 deny thelsign variance based on staff findings and evidence prese te to the Committee alt the public hearing (1) that the applicant has failed to de onstrate that the p',roposed sign is unique; and (2) that the applicant w 11 still be able to er�ct a sign to adequately identify his place of bus ne s without need for a modification of the sign height requirements. On March 31, 1989, the Planning Commi si n upheld the Zoning Committee's recommendation on a vote of 8 to 6 wi h ne abstention. This appeal is scheduled to be heard y he City Council on May 11, 1989. Please notify me by May 9, 1989, if a mber of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at t e ublic hearing. Sincerely, (\ f r• .,�� . ��_� .��,��;`,i.lc�.z� �� Peggy A. Reichert �CEIVED Deputy Director for Planning ,�I PAR:rm ��Y �8 �QQ9 Attachments �v cc: Mayor Latimer C''� C�� city of saint paui pianning commission r lution file number 89-22 �te March 31 , 1989 i�'HEREAS, Robert Walsh, file it10435 h s applied for a Sig,n Variance under �he provisions of Section 66.409 of th S int Paul Legislati�e Code, for the �urpose o� permitting �he installation of a s'gn which e:cceeds heigtp�t restrictior.s �or the zoning district by appro:cimately s' et on property lod��ted at 216 i.�es� Seven�h Street, legally described as Lots 1 a d 11, Block 26, Ri'c�e and Irvine's Addition; and �,'HEREAS, the Zoning Committee of th P anning Commission p�n March 23, 1989, held a public hearing at which all persons pr sent were given an',� pportunity to be heard pursuant to said application in acc rd ce with the requiz��ments of Section 64.300 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code; nd WHEREAS, Saint Paul Planning Commiss on based on the evid�nce presented to its Zoning Committee at the public heari g s substantially re£,lected in the minutes, made the following findings of fact: 1. That the applicant has failed to em nstrate that the p�!oposed sign is unique; and 2. That the applicant will still be le to erect a sign to, adequately identify his place of business without need for a odification of the' sign height requirements. `�OW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Sa nt Paul Planning Cbmmission, that under the authority of the City's Legis�ativ C de, the application for a Sign :'ariance to allow the installation of a sign which e� eeds height restrictions for t:�a zoning district by appro�imately six feet at 16 West Seventh Street' is hereby danied. 'I ',i '',I moved by � MORTON � SeCOr1Ci�Cl � HIRTE in fav�or� against- ABSTAINED 1 � ' a � �� MIIv'UTES OF THE ZO:�ING CO"LMITT�'E CITY COUNCIL CHA.*�BERS, AI 'T PAUL, MIh*�ESOTA QN N�RCH 23, 19S9 PRESE�T: Mmes . Hirte , Mor�on, -nd Tracy; Messrs. Chr�s�enson, Levy and "nep=:e of the Zoning Comnitt e; Mr. Segal, Assistat�t City Attorney; Ms . Lane o£ the Building ns ection and Design �I,ivision; Mr. McGuire and Ms . Murray of the Pl nning Division sta�''�. ABSE`�T: Ms. Zieman� and Mr. Ne'd� * Ekcused The meeting was chaired by Gladys o ton, Chairman. Robert T.'alsh (#10435) : A Sign Var an e for property loc�ted at 216 West Seven�h Street to permit the insta la ion of a sign whic� exceeds height restrictions for the zoning distri t y approximately siac'ifeet. � The applicant was present; there wa n opposition preseri� at the hearing. �,� Mr. *�cGuire showed slides of the si e nd reviewed the st�ff report with a recommendation for denial. He said th t the West Seventh'',Federation approved the sign based on the fact that the e s no objection frd�n surrounding neighbors. Robert Walsh, 1744 South Mississippi Ri er Boulevard, said','i,that he has been f affiliated with the business since 1 62 and distributed a �.' tter of support � from the West End Business and Profe si al Association (W��PA) and a letter from Seven Corners Ace Hardware, Inc. st ting that four ne'il�hboring business owners support his request for a sign va iance. Frank D. Marzitelli, 1444 North Victo ia, said that he advi��'�d the applicant to seek the advice of the West Sevent C unity Council as '�aell as WEBPA. Concerns regarding sign lighting and i s ffect on residents�',of Panama Flats were resolved. He responded to staff ep rt findings and quqted from sections of the zoning code. Mr. Christenson questioned the maximum re of the proposed sign. Mr. Walsh replied that 720 square feet in total s gn ge is allowed unde� the zoning code and that there is already an approximat ly 230 square foot sign band on the building. Mr. Levy inquired about how the proposed si n would differ fram the former . . Naegele sign and why the additional six ee is needed. Mr. W�lsh explained his contacts with Naegele and the reason f r requesting the va,riance. Ms. Hirte asked about proposed sign ligh in . Mr. Walsh replied that four quartz lights would be used, that there w ul be no moving part� to the sign. Mr. Repke stated that it was his understa di g that during disc�i'�SSion with the Federation, community members agreed that a ign on the back of '. he building was less obtrusive than a sign would be at st eet level, one bla�k from Irvine Park. Mr. Walsh concurred. Fila T10435 P�€a Two ris , yor�on asked for clarifica io regarding the sig� drawings. Mr. kTalsh rE�liad that engineers drew pl ns for the proper stee� work and architectural des��n in order to secure the ig , said that the ste�l work would ba hidden fro:n the face of the wall sign, wo ld blend into the �ack of the buiiding and wculd extend above the three st ry building. :•ir. McGuire stated that accordi t the Building Depa,�tment the sign is cl�ssified as a roof sign, not a wa 1 sign, not substa�tially parallel to the wall, because the sign would ext nd five feet at one em� and be flush with t�e tiall at the other end. He said ha the sign would be �upported on the roof of the three story section of the bu'lding, cantilevere� off the roof of the t'r.ree story section and extend ab ut six feet in excess ',of that section. i � ^:s. Hirte inquired about maintena ce f the sign. Mr. 4� lsh answered that the copy would not be changed, and tha t e proposed sign wo�ld be well n:nintained. „ Dave Cossetta, 756 Stewart Avenue, r of Cossetta's I��lian Market, testified in support of the sign va ia ce, said that Seve� Corners Ace is one of the most well known hardware sto es in the nation, and'''vouched for the business reputation of the owner. ��,� , Hearing no further testimony, Ms. Mo to closed the public',,'Iportion of the meeting. � ',� Mr. Repke moved to recommend approva o the sign variance ',�ased on findings � that the proposed sign would not crea e hazard, or violat'� State statutes, ' rules and regulations; that it is not ob ectionable to adjacent property owners, that it would not adversely a fe t residentiai prope�ty through excessive glare and lighting and that 't ould be in keeping',with the general character oi the surrounding area. Th m tion died for lack '',of a second. Committee discussion followed regardin t e definitions of w� 1 signs and roof signs , projection from a building, supp rt which would be nel, ded on the roof of a three story building, uniqueness o t e proposed sign an' contact with the West Seventh Federation. Mr. McGuire added that prior to the pres nt meeting he was con�acted in person by a representative from the West Sevent F deration who said that, "They are recommending approval based on the fact ha there was no oppo$ition from surrounding neighbors based on a perspec iv sketch of the site," Mr. Christenson moved to recommend denial of the sign variance b�ased on staff report findings and evidence presented to th Committee at the public hearing (1) that the applicant has failed to demo t te that the propos�d sign is unique; and (2) that the applicant will st'll be able to erect a'sign to adequately identify his place of business it out need for a mod�fication of the sign height requirements. Mr. Levy se on ed the motion which', passed on a roll call vote of S-1 (Repke) . Submitted by: Approved by: � i �� v ,�✓�� C� � �'i�� Charles McGuire Gladys Morton, Chaixman , ' • ' ��1'- �T� ZONIN C ITTEE STAFF REPORfi FILE # 10435 1. APPLICANT: Robert Walsh DATE� OF HEARING: March 23 1989 2. CLASSIFICATION: Sign Variance 3. LOCATION: 216 West Seventh St e (south side betweei� Chestnut & Kellogg) 4. PLANNING DISTRICT: Nine 5. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 10 & 1 B ock 26 Rice and Irv'ine's Addition 6. PRESENT ZONING: B-5 NING CODE REFERENC�: Section 66.409 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND REPORT: D TE: 03/15/89 BY: Charles L. McGuire A. PURPOSE: Permit the installatio o a sign which exceeds height restrictions for the zoning district by appro 'ma ely six feet. B. PARCEL SIZE: The subject propert h s 120 feet of frontage on West Seventh Street and 120 feet of depth alon C estnut. The area o� the parcel is 14,400 square feet. C. EXISTING LAND USE: The property s c rrently occupied by a hardware store. D. SURROUNDING LAND USE: Northeast: A church occupies the dj cent site. There a�� other mixed commercial uses to the no theast. Southeast: Uses to the southeast e ixed commercial/re�idential. South: Uses to the southwest a e rimarily commercial', on the lower floors with some upper story r si ential occupancy. Northwest: Sites to the northwest re predominantly comme�,$cially occupied. E. ZONING CODE CITATION: Section 66.4 o the Zoning Code s�$ates that "The Planning Commission shall have the a th rity to grant vari�nces from the strict applications of this chapter for uni ue signs or unusual c��nditions pertaining to sign needs for a specific buildin o lot, provided suct�� signs would not be contrary to the general intent of th s hapter, would not c eate a hazard, would not violate Minnesota State Statutes or rules and regulatid s developed pursuant thereto, would not be'objectionable jacent property o ', ers, would not adversely affect residential propert th ough excessive gla�e and lighting and provided that the signs would be in k ep ng with the general�� character of the �,I File #10435 Page Two surrounding area. The commis io may not grant a va�iance that would permit the sign within a zoning district wh ch is not otherwise',permitted in that zoning district under the provisions of this chapter. F. DISCUSSION: The applicant pro os s to have a sign m�'�suring 11 feet by 36 feet (396 sq.ft. ) installed above t e econd level of the ,�ection of the building situated at the corner of Ches nu and West Seventh S,$reet. Since the sign as proposed would exceed the heigh o the third story s�ction of the building and would be angled away from the w 11 at the southeaster�� end, the ordinance limits the height of the sign t a maximum of 37' 6" . ', As proposed, the sign would extend to a height of 44' 6" , or 7 feet above t�$ maximum allowed by the code. The sign would carry the name Ac H rdware, the store 4�erated on the premises. However, in appearance, size, an c nstruction it is mq�e like a billboard than a business identification sign. il boards are not a p�rmitted use in this section of the B-5 zoning distric . Based on the drawi�gs provided, about half of the total area of the sign wou d e devoted to the a��ertising of a product line that is available on the sit . The remaining sign ''�rea would provide additional identification for the st e. Although an oli�er identification sign which hung over the public sidewal s recently removed ',from the front of the store, the remaining signage provi es ample identificatiQ�, through full use of the structure's sign band. Numero s indow signs adverti�e the availability of the store's major product lines. G: FINDINGS: If the commission were t g ant a variance fro� the provisions of the sign ordinance, several findings as no ed in Section 66.408 (see E. Zoning Code Citation above) would be required. Th Commission must fi�d that the proposed sign: 1. Is not contrary to the general i te of this chapter: Although the chapter does not con ai a "general intent '�tatement" , it is clear from Section 66.101. Purpos . hat the elimination'', of visual clutter is a vital consideration of the o di nce. Paragraphs ('�) "To encourage a concern for the visual environment. . . ' and (5) "To proteG,t . . .areas characterized by unique environmen al historical and ar�hitectural resources" speak to the issue of v su 1 clutter. The erection of a smaller sign to i en ify the business i� possible within the limits of the ordinance and wit ou the need for modi��cation of the height requirements. 2. Would not create a hazard, violate at Statutes or rules 'and regulations developed pursuant thereto: It does not appear that the sign as ro osed would be hazar�ous or in violation of State Statutes, Rules, tc. File #10435 Page Three 3. Would not be objectionable to ad�acent property qwners: i Although no objections hav b en indicated by ne��hbors as of the date of this report, we have no ev de ce in hand to find ', hat there would be no objections. I 4. Would not adversely affect es dential property tk�rough excessive glare and lighting, The proposed sign would be ig ted during hours of',darkness, although it is unclear what if any effect is would have on adja�ent residential uses, it does not appear to be benefi ia to adjacent resid ntial uses; and I 5. Would be in keeping with the ge eral character of tt�e surrounding area. Although this area is not de ig ted an historic ar, a there are many old and historic buildings in the ge ra area. The Irvinel� Park Historic District lies one block to the south. Th area is a high ac ivity area and subject to significant congestion wit t e Civic Center just to the northeast. The "advertising sign" charac er stics of the proposl d sign, while they may add to the busyness and conge ti of this portion o. the street, do not appear to be an enhancement. 'I H. STAFF RECOI�IlriENDATION: Based on th se findings, staff reqommends denial of the proposed sign. ,,I �I ,i '�I ',I I ,I ,� �I . � � �9- �� LIST OF A TACHMENTS FILE #10435 � Page ; Sign Variance Application 1 , Proposed Sign Plan 3 ; Proposed Sign Face 5 ; � Location Maps 6 , Land Use Map g I � � � � � � I � ` - � , � . � � '•-� �.�. r� ZONIN4 d0 RD ��$ �Qy� , APP IC TION FOR ZONING �RDINANCE VARIANCE CiTY OF 3AIN�PAUI 0 � 1 T I � , A VARIANCE OF ZON NG COOE CHAPTER l�b�SECTION 66��O�ARAGRAPH IS REQUESTED I C FORMITY WITH TME►OW�6ils VESTED IN THE BOARO OF 20NING AP— PEALS TO PERM T T E �� ON PfiOPERTY OE9CRIBED BE A. Applipnt; NA E: ��rt L• �l�h Ao RESS 216 iiat �s�r�,lC� Stlelt OA TIME TELEPHONE NO. Z��""�SS9 21P CODE SS lO2 1. Prope in wt of applicant: (owr+�►.�t�se�t purd+snr.�te.l i � ' 2. Name t (if dift�nnt) B. Prop�rty i 'a+: ADORESB , 1. L.spd tion: LOT 11 �COCK 26 ADO. z. ��; : 20 Ft. fronta s I 20 Tt da ih , A�ce Hardvase � 3. t 6 Parkia�Lot zo��oac. E-5 C. Reawns f R . - 1. Pro se Install buain siga (eize 11'z 36') on ec ioa "A" of enclo photo and eite plan - ee Bef erence "A". 'i 2. phY ipl charsctaistia of th� pttv�nt ib b�inq uud for�y of tM pxmirnd uses i�y r net (topopnphY,wil ,�and�of lot,Kc.) � 3. th� 'fie wistion nqu�t�d, dttar�wf�spprapritt�- A ariaace of 7'-�� allor iastallation of a bu inass sip at a� tioa o! i�' 6" froa the si avalt �sad� rst� 37� lit. pstaitt�d by law. s. n rw ew.anten�t��=- l�ori� a. itriet rOPlieatlOn ot� arf fM Zoni�p Ordi�na would r�ult in p�wliar a t 'orwl Prscekd diffku�tiw. �wwptia+�l undiM ha►dthi0s. Se ref areace "C" � . _ , � b.' th��MinY of�vMiM�wW � �� • 1 oot w • wanntW dnMm�nt to �109Q 1JARIAhICE �:?D.00 ' 000d«.w�e�nct.�&�o�- � :�ft *170.00 of tht i�nN►t and pu�Pora�[ QE� � *17B.i� tfa irq0►d�re�. I Q� *.� � R�� I , � _ � NOT : IS YVII PR It P SITE PLAN��O�� i . ; Sipn� n ' �'� ; o.a A.�r.d 10 Februarv 1989 - REFERENCE "A" Photo of building, showing location o pr osed business sign. REFERENCE "B" We request an 11' x 36' (396 sq.ft. b iness sign. Such sign would identify, promote and advertise the place of business and some br ds of products/commodities o6fered/sold therein. Such sign would be floodlit at night. Please note: Overhanging "SEVE C RNERS HARDWARE - �v1ASOIVRY SUPPLIES" business sign has been permanently remo ed ce photo was taken. REFERENCE "C" Proposed business sign would res lt ' no peculiar or exceptiona� practical difficulties, and would create no undue hardships. ; REFERENCE "D" 'i i h The antin of a variance for t ' b iness si would in no wa''Icreate an detr ment to t e � g 8n Y� Y City of St. Paul, or to its citizens. ; 'i The business sign would not be bje 'onable to adjacent proped owners. Residential property in the area oul not be adversely impacted y the position of the business sign. '� The proposed sign is not of a Co mercial Billboard" nature;�but a business sign erected against/upon the 3rd story wall of the pro erty it identifies, promotesi�nd advertises. , � .. � � ' " � ' fl R / � a I�.x?�o�'�[:� " � s � . �rM. , _ �4: ,K ». , ` W � ,�. b�' � � . �c *+ ►- , � ,o'��+b � - i r T$$ k , 3.=�� j � a � 1 , • � � � v I 1 ' 'r :�x R/` � r� d�1 x� � ' �Y�i �,i - - _. , .. ' _ _ _ • � . , � �' j h 0 � � I� T1 Y k�� -- --- ,1 � ,� � Z�_ � y� �-t/' � � � ��—- �- �' � . � �� ", � v i x s t i�� X, h � r � ? � i � 2��t s • +: � � � , � � ' � 7 �; . f , y � � , �: �► �� ; � � �� : � �� ; ,� � � . � �;, � . 3 x � j _�l �� x � � ti st s * 0 D �a t � '+� � i ; � % �i � r; �. ,�;'' '"; ; � : : . � '� � ` �l � � , �� ! � ip� � � , � � j � ,� � i, � , g � < ps" s- t � s� �. ! + �� ; - ' � j ' . , { � � � 2y ----_�____ . � l.4ac x S! � � `'0 I __ -� i n. ��L� �, j � I - R,Eq„f��, p�C,)c i►.1 W ALL.. � -�t � �71J�11�� _�.-- - - i �" WA►�.i. I f��►iL StituGruR.�OF S14lJ 1 SE V�N GOR NER S _ A��:- ��lV�t, �h��- �.- ' - �u�ry.. �wo�c��a - NARD IAIAq� .�C�C�...�--- �- �.vo�o�� .. sT. .�.,�«�os,�r„� r �zi �-�eoo � � �j � ?� , . �9- � +�q•`c�o�+� rg �P ��4 � Ls 3%3 x�i� - . 1E 10 � � 'S1 b �4 �'�3x'/A � � � s��aJ(Lo�a.�ECt,o�J s�6a ZTt� LS O� 'rS � aETb-�� __ , ' io'-ce., � � � - �� sEr� � ' L��'` � � . � ; C � ; , a �F�y_ YbR�ES Qy�� •�� _3p Ta 'g�S'' � 2-s �� + �� .'n" . ; �_ 7� ., 1t k ��'y 1� � _2L��S°tS[{" j �-, —�13` 1� �- a� s�at�t ' � . �, _.. �i �----- 'I L �R '� I : ��N �� ; i �"�' 4 e.►► � P�r�S� � --- ' ._ - --- ---- - - --r - - --- , o; - TS$xqk�/, � __.� � _. _ - - - - _ - . PJ►YA.� 3t�'� `p � �f s�+��'i4 � ! � � c� � - �Y�, � __ S.C_ GY'P. �O� C Gi1 tN '�� _. � � !E3 =$„ ! _ . ,.-- - -- ------ —-- �_�� ` 3Y3.c`�ti�t�vA�t�� l►Z1Ct�l W�►�.�. I '��T"� 5 iTo1V 3�4•`�. A-3�o�C3o�T , � c a oss ' s �ri o�t � ----r- �FVE N COR�JFR�� BREI�fflC E , �RS. I�C. ��Q£ .� STIItK'TIJItAI.CtVtll i0AE1�iG ENC�tNiEEA1NG 2M�YOAKTON dlVOi ST. �AIA. MiHNESOTA SSt t 7 14 ?1 1�?-�600 � . � � � '��-T•--��-__. � "._ �� _" ��'__ ' � � � , 1 O �j v'/ ` ��J7J—/ � ...�_ �l{ / , ` n li � � _ � � � � � � . o Q ; ' o � � j � �--� � , ; � � i ^ ► , � p � i i ; , , � ° � I o c.� i ° � o - d ' , • �, _ � � � , o � � i I � � I '� ° � � ° --�� a __ 3 ,� . I � — -- -�- ---�f o , IU `J � �� a ., � � � � � • . � � � � � � .. ' �� !I x ' ` 'ti ; 0 � ' � .; ' � ---� � :r � �.J , �� ,j ' � • e i I �. � � �' f � � I e �+—L� I I L,J ' i • 1 � � o �� e � i`�� a � � , o . , l�-- - -- . . , � , � � I�� ' ' � _ � o ; � ; ►, I r �� p � iI ,� I � I _ � 'I • J � O � < � N I I � l I I ` . �� - i-- _ . , a . . y . / .w • 'e w' � �� " � O � I�W ^ I �o � �`t � `'' � � � � � � � � ) � �� o � � �Q � � (�j i � � � � � � 11 I1 � � ' � ° ° � � ' �� _ � , � � � . . . � _ �-- - '_ _ _ _ _ - _. _ _ _ _ - � -f �[N- - - _ - ' ' - � J _ n- ' _ _ - - _ -. .� '' '� ,- .�� _ . •, . ` • I I . CITIZEN PAR CI ATI DIS I S ,oec+•e F ..c �y F . ...- _ t _ � y � - �w. ° E .�.' Z ` y 9 .�C++• •O _ p i � \ E �! 1� S '.wC rE� i � S �I �YMVlUO �( y„/�� { ~ L 4 - 7 1 :>Y.' ' z - a5E i i �, UR R � �fotf i ; � - m s* E 2 �F-��, � 11 ; = -� r - ' � � ,. _ ..ee.w .�t f 5' ; .�+ww S s �� n i t �- F - '' � e e�. s. M = " _ # -z - � � VtiE�'� - _ E 3 3 i � . -� ! � � ; w..s..... .�c,• � �bT�•� ewe +� ; SE.B" wE l� f S E i,y� �F4 4� 3 �• t i � _, L• _ '��' �i8� � ; 1�} ' � •� �' 8 e �j r 5' _.�� rE S ~ �� . ao�0 14 w� � e,'d 4rvEaSJ� �E F it! �� t • �OwlP e9 .�'/ � '�. � � •��OO�w v( � ? � _ �� Sr �I � L ,j � F i _ _ _ �_ s 4 �� 1 !i s � s ! F - � - ii �� 4 = s � ; .�e � s J`J 'e ...wo.o / , j •Op � �Mw. ' _ w� � wE �. � %� T �� _ E �� al�'E�i N � � .^4 _ � 'c :� torr.✓.� x -'y n �,. l 1 � \ � ' . � . _ �. �� ow�[ `y� � — r[ i � � — - � iooc �000 eono. . �uhE I CITIZEP� PAR IC PATIOPJ PLANNING DI� RICTS 1. SUNRAY- AT LE CREEK-HIGHW000 'I 2. HAZEL P RK HAYDEN-PROSPERITY H�IGNTS HILLCREST 3. WEST SI E 4. DAYTON' B UFF 5. PAYPJE-PI AL N 6. NORTH E D I 7. THOP4AS- AL 8 U - NI ERSITY 9. :JEST SE Er� H 11. HAMLINE MI AY 12. ST. ANT OP� 13. MERRIAM PK. LEXINGTON HAMLINE- NELLING HAMLINE 14. GROVELA D- CALESTER 15. HIGHLAN 16. SUMMIT HILL ��""- �`- 17. DOWNTOWN Z�''�y� � �.�� I`y .�S � � � � � i . � - I i � - '� `� +--- ` �- �=- �`--��_, .,� . � W� "N ._ _ • ' '°` .�� . . j_�.'"' �_'`_�_�T—"�___�_ '�-- - _ . - . / . - ��.. /a \---� - - _$—.`__1--�.:..� � � ' $ _�l % — � � ... �.��^-- __._��—_ n �� — �_ T—\'' ��L 7 •� / � � �� - . ��... _��_ __._ .. •� � $� .� - � -T: �` —— _— _ —_--: —_ - `�`.� � �T� —��" � �-� ____ —�—�_ _ ,.___�__ .;� :c� _ �a=�-�� ,, � �. _ �.—;_— _ � =,�_ - _'�� -_ � � �� — �_ _� �� , :_�- �"-�� ;�1 _� �, __ 1�_��1_. ^ y....i�lTfJ,'lf^��f��/ �r^�j/ ��/ \ �� _ •�_� —_ -e _ i�f_"+�� ',.�ilJ..'�/�� / t i�J, �/ ..�•R�� +"�. —�� t� I^^7 i` �C��.....�y��. �___�l ._.'� �rs��yL�� . �'�L �� ;� �:,' �� Y��T - — `�r�'--- (�; a f /, /',. L ''-�— �7 ��y7�^tL_ . ^� � __-. ,.�` �`:��x � ��;L� ;� // '' ��° -�_� -- , SLiL7.,�;��LLJL.�� 4r • ��-�- .... i_�.—.`+1••_- ---— ;-u�-'= --• r' %� '��..��.°••,�,.,,�,'r��.I�= �_ _ � I r,' , i . � �� ^Ti � -'^- =-�'—='�`-�'�. ��, � ::��—' �,!i� ^ —i � i••�•Ty�--=��ar '_�-.�'- �=��^~�j��31� r-^ _ -I ��_�_�..—'•'—`— _ s � ^ L� !'7 0� -� �� ✓ L� �' �� ,..�_�t_..L �ci`u...�� =_� i — �u�� ' :i �� ;;,�I-7��!�-y--.^�� , �—_ �= r: `��--=�•--,, �� .. . � / t i�—^.L:�"^�I—:�,;��,�—�_ �—�� _ ... �— '.� � � � 'I��LL_,^ �� ..�Qyc� .�`� �— �— � � r �q� � � - _ � � : . RM• . - , �� !�" 7 � � p, 'l � � i c.r.� � � ` Cj'` • �' �s �.Z r� . � �� I-35 � '�! � ��f T �v� � S�XT H S� P � � V � J � ' ' c.��C' W' F�F T� _5 ��L _ zo ',G MUN/CjPA( I C�V/C 4U0/Tp,S,�UM � CF.�y;c,9 '"' f a I b� �~ , -�' ♦ �, �O I •�. . � � ` � — �' � C, y"O/ ' � - O ' �� tiFs ., � • `a .l o ` � �',LG �,, !r`� ? c��` , O �` `'�' ' � - �. . � ;V ��; P � �... _- , �� ?� � �y . � ., _ �� ,,y - G � /_ � L . . . ��• ,� , �. �` ' �' Q � � . . � � � O � r �. ^ , . � J�,� FqG � < , � i;, ;: , � • �' '� ' � P , � � ' • � I ' Q ,' , , , . � ` � �. , o , . . � � s . � �� ,ti3O• .. .� �, , � • , <'�i � K �,�• � 1 q,y , S, � ► ,, ,/ , . /,... � , . �. , � ,' � / � • ,</ ' � \� `�, �• ' � 0 � �Q�� ,Q .��, . , . � ., T ' - ...-_ -- - -- -- , � � P� t .�" ;' � � � � .� I � P' , , ,��: '�_tiy ,o i` \ �. , /. i � � ; 3.� �`. � ,� . p r 1 .� ,� 20 � • �� i �, ,. / � �" ,.: :,`Q•P, .;� __ �'� �� .� �'��T ROBERT �IALSH LEGEND �R� SIGN VARIAIVCE �� ZOM�1�diStriCt bOU�ldary F1lE� 10435 DA� 2-14-89 � g�bje�t Prppe�y �� PLNG. DIST 9 MAP#t 21 �� o one f�mily • • ^ commetiial - � twp f�mily ♦ �� industrial SCALE t• .400' �;�4 multi�le family v vacant ` , . - ITY COUI�CIL ST. PAUL �� PUBLIC H RING NC�TICE RECEIVED NING ; ol� 9 MAY sa C1TY CLERK To: Property owners within 350' ; �L E N Q. 10469 Representatives of Planning D st ict 9 AGE PURPOSE To consider an ap eal of a Planning � mmission Denial of a modification o t e Sign Ordinance t� permit a sign to extend above the maxi um 37 foot 6 inch hei�ht limit. � � LOCATION 216 W. 7th Str et (Southeast side be� ween Chestnut & Kellogg) PETITIONER ROBERT WALSH HEARING Thursday, Ma,, 11, 1989 9:0o a.�. . Citv Council C am ers, 3rd Floor Cit Hall - Court House Q U E S TIO N S Zoning Contact Chuck McGuire (228-3364) Contact the Z in Section of the P1 nning and Economic Development D ar ment, Room 1101, C ty Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Str t, St. Paul, Minnesoi 55102 Legal Descrip io : On file i � i f Notice �ent 4/28/89 � • . �� - GtrY �P R �, � CITY OF SAINT PAUL e ��;��,,,� � DEPART E T OF PLANNING AN� ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT �� hr � DIVISION OF PLANNING 25i West Fourth Streef,Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 786� 612-228-3270 GEORGE LATIMER � MAYOR � R�ECEIVED �� APR 18�sag April 17, 1989 � � C17�Y CLt�tn � Mr. Albert B. Olson, City Clerk � Room 386, City Hall ' Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 , Dear Mr. Olson: � This letter is written to confirm t e earing date for the� appeal of Mr. Robert Walsh, 216 West Seventh Stre t, to the City CounciL. Mr. Walsh is appealing an action of the Planning Co ission which denie'd a permit for the construction of a nonconforming sig . The appeal will be �eard by the City Council on May 11, 1989. i Sincerely, ��• �5 Daniel K. Bayers Zoning Section DKB:rm 'I I , '� l � � i