Loading...
99-1055ORIGINAL RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, NIIrTNESOTA Presented By Refened To 3� Committee: Date 2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d1b{a Jeraldine's (License 3 ID No. 16299), located at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of 4 $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. The licensee is 5 further ordered to remove any cigarette vending machines from the licensed premises for the 6 violation of permitting the sale of cigarettes from a vending machine in a licensed establishment 7 which was open to individual under the age of 18. 9 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection 10 and any cigazette vending machines shall be removed from the licensed premises within fifteen 11 (15) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the August 3, 1999 Compliance report, the August 11, 1999 Notice of Violation letter and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretary By: � r1- N.��� Approved by Mav Date /�� /��/ By: �.'�{��Wi///J / BY: 1 /`M�J� / + �� -� Foxm Approved y City Att ea� By: � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By: Council File # � � —1�. Green Sheet # ( O � � � � Adopted by Conncil: Date �_��� � Office of LIEP fACT PQ2SON 8 PFIONE .ir,.�, , TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES Ctq - fo,S.S GREEN SHEET No � `?? ; 7 10/08/99 u��� u�� ❑ arv.,,cear ❑ arva.aR ❑ m��r•w�a�ccsoa ❑ wuwew�� ❑wraeWR�scwrl ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR� .:.•_""fii_:.:7 Concexning advexse action against the Cigarette License held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc., dba Jeraldine's, 605 Front Street. (Uncontested) PLANNING CAMMISSWN CIB CAMMITTEE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION Hac fhic P�soNfirm everxarked untler a mmraU forfhis de4artment9 YES NO Hes mis x�Vkm erer teen a dly anpoyee? YE3 NO Dces tlus PersaNfi�m Y?aeeec a skW rwt rwm�allYP� bY arry arreid alY emPbY�? YES MO' Is V�is pe�aoNfim� a tarpefed ventloR YES ' MO AOUNT OF TRANSACT�ON S COETrtIEVpIUE BUDQE7ED (GIRCLE ONE) SOURCE ACTN�T'NUMBER ? YE3 NO OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayton M Robinson, Ja, Crry Attorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemnn, Mayor October 6, 1999 OwnerlManager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117 ��� � � ��� RE: Cigazette license held by 3erry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Jeraidine's for the premises iocated at 605 Front St. in St. Paul License ID No. : 16299 Our File Number: G99-0283 Deaz Sir/t�fadam: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, October 27,1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Raznsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawfiil sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the licensing office is for a$200.00 fine and the removal of the cigazette vending machines from the licensed establishment. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, (/�2��� �JV c�'Me� Virguua Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: �t'adcy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP C(ViI DfYiStOY( qq - (oss 300CiryHa71 Telephone:651266-8710 lSiY¢stKelloggBlvd Facsimile:657298-5619 SaintPaul,MinnesolaSSIO2 _ NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING ���"'�� ����'`°"� �'`� Kathy Co1e, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 R.ice St., St. Paui, MN 55117 Cq-toss UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Jerry Belgea Enterprises, lnc, d/b/a Jeraldine's Address: 605 Front Street Council Hearing Date: October 27, 1999 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn, Stat. § 609.685 Minn. Stat. § 461.18, Subd. 2 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Dates of Violation: Piace: August 3, 1999 Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 Fine and the Removal of Any Cigarette Vending Machines From the Licensed Establishment Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Compliance Report 5. License information OFFICE ^^ THE CITY ATTORNEY Cltryron d. �rnson, Jc, CityAltorney CITY OP SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, M¢yor cNno;�;s;on 400 Ciry Hal! 15 W¢st Kellogg B1vd. Saint Paul, Nfirtnesom 55102 qa - tc�rS TelepFone: 651 2b6-8710 Foc.rimile: 651 ?9$-5679 August ll, 1999 NOTICE OF VIpLATION Owner/Manager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117 RE: Cigazette license held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a 7eraldine's for the premises at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul � License ID #: 1 b299 Deaz SirfMadazn: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the cigazette license held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Jeraldine's for the premises at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as follows: On August 3,1999, an underage person entered Jeraldine's at 605 Front Avenue and asked for change from the bartender to purchase cigarettes from the vending machine located next to the end of the bar. The individua! was given four $1 bills and four qnarters and was able to purchase a package of cigarettes with the change from the vending machine without being asked for any proof of age. The establishment is not posted that individuals under the age of 18 are not permifted to enter and the vending machine is located in an open area of the bar. This sale was in violation of Minn. Stat. §6Q9.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07, both of which prohibit the sale of tobacco to individuals under the age of eighteen, and Minn. Stat. §461.18, subd. 2, which prohibits cigarette vending machines in premises which are open to individuals under the age of 18. Page 2 Jeraldine's August 11, 1999 Ct� — \O SS If you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public heazin� before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your letter by Monday, August 23, 1999. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and make a statement on you own behalf. If , on the other hand, you dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appeaz and present witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please send me a letter requesting the administrative heazing. If we have not heard from you by Monday, August 23,1999, we will assume that you do not contest the facts and will schedule this before the City Council for hearing. if you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, � tc � �c�('�� � Virginia D, Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN 55117 ctq - �os$ STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANS3E G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on August 11, 1999, she served the attached NOTICS OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55117 (which is the last known address of said person? and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the i3nited States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. r�� „ l—�--�-+..� � Ce71 Subscribed and sworn to before me this llth day of Auqust, 1999. Notary Pu C � _. _ � �� �Atres Jan. 3i. �nv cZq_ tosS � � 0 : x N � N O r � O m V � G7 _.1 � � a n 0 Y 0 G m K t O Y t4 � Y W � d N C V ..J m T � N 3 � � N a�i > U U J Q N C N � a fl- �, E-' � N � �a V � J R 4 � p � � Z U � ', O � N u� ��� � Q � N z � O a Q n <- O � � � � � W mz Z q m Q � � � Q. � w F- Z W w N � � J ` w Z o � a � W � U C 3 O U i N � � o d Y � � Q W N C L � � L 7 Z U O U c � � N c � � c N d E O U U C m � N C � Q � 7 z N C M O c7 L � a a , y � N � C � m � � � F- � N � w Q F- Z O � � � O � � O � �U '�6 � N � � � a� - N � x Q U � U U O N U C � � m N�p .� �� 7 U ��o U O� U "' U �O °U� �� m m�a � � �Lrn M N �-~- W �V� O � U G J JlL � � � C N N N .Q r, C ti s Q � NO JN � �N ro�y ~� �71� N � C 4.-(DtNO d�N 'QW ��U QO_ N � 3 ��'i6�iQ���L 1 Z lL N� N O� f¢ U Z ` � � � � � �..- N Q g u� U LL fl.�'- � cr4 4 � ° O �N�' N�N 4 ¢p0 � C C C O. U��LL (y uJ� N� D.,f�� V C;6 c� a p a� cu "'a- � o u_Ocna �rn o ct°�`U � � � m �o?arn a� �yrnrn NN�cRO)UCOO) ��• M � UNJ�� d�� ��VJOZ�MF-C�'JM aq_�oss' � � 0 � x iD � y O N � N d U �, � J m a ; 0 r O a � C O w R � i w _ d N C d U J m � io � � V � J Q U N ro U G N O f�l U F 1 N C c n U J ( N a+ � � n rn � I� �Z = N U � J � � N � w ¢ w �' Z d O �� a � ¢�� �t� d � N Z Z 0 I O� Q I � W -a a K W F- Z W w � � � J iZ m �� � 'a w � �U C � O V � N �o m m ❑ a y c `m a E 7 Z U 0 a V C @ 7 N c � m Z c � a 0 U U @ N c N n � � Z N c m o m L � a Q , Nm N � C � m � � � N � rn � � w ¢ F- Z � � LL � O � @ p � O N � V � C C J jLL E � - Q c c�m � = m .fl �- � � N (7 £ '6 (6 Q t N � N N J J m t N U y.� � t� a� LG V �� a Q/ 6�C NO V V�-.(�DN N � �ULL � m m Oo�U a� m� o� m 3 N O_N E �IL N� N� O� @ � 7 � Z Cj Z � �� � � � p-a � a �<� a� a;U o� t �' R � a4 a� U, p C QC�JM OJ W�R Q �Ua�i ��ccn.��' � O N �O U OQ N�k'^ N f0 . t-�Q �nL_,.c��u,;Ov�a @ N �' � ,fy.aCaNO N � �t� �M p�j�W �� N M Ns�- �"M� UNJ�� N1�� o Ev 3�w`t'v�oZ.°-'itL-irN1i a`� - �°SS m � 0 a x � � O vi p M � O � V N � '- r' rt{ M C. M O � O C N � c O i: R � L � W C d C V J m � �� N N N > U U .J Q N f0 N y O O N � @ N T � F- � c C O d O U J p' J � 19 � ��I IZ d � ._! I� � N � W Q N N Z � 0 '� � � 4LL� � � � � N � N Z Z Q m � W � a � H Z W W °' c7 � J ` w z O � a W � �U C � O U i N � �O N N � a W o y o C O _ � 0 'V' O � N � � 7 U O � ch c�i � c � N � N a c � m m ci �I �I� o �Z U � J i ¢ C W _a � N � � 3 Z N C M o � r � 0.� N � N � c �? m � o� F" � � � � W Q Z � � LL � � N � c O � N � � O m � � ° 0 � C N�Y �y Q U �V� t C V V O N O .� C J t6 O J {L � c N U1 m a � c lf_ � Q � N O � m tn � p N � N („) �..,, � �:. � m� am �� � wm m °' N vii �WV � 3 °j � °' ° C ' � N 3 �Q C L 4 �u_m�n Z�jz ; a��.=_ � rn � ��a�fl.�mU W O_ �� V QQ �p a N fl'�"� C CV rn c N �QyQ�O�a�ILtn coc�caN�V� UJ O U O..- # N(6 w �,_�.� �LLocna rof6�°rna�ir°��U �n� N�Mt60�!?t0���� M � CJNJ�� � r�NttJOZ�(h�--Mf`') o�q - �oss � � � x � 0 � O � � V N q '� f` a r, 0 � C � C O :� R E a. w Q� N C d c� J � � � � N > V U �i Q � a C 3 � N N a � F - tn c NO c � U � J Q J � � m � m � 00 Z m rn U � '' ° o ' @ � w ¢ � N Z �O Q LL � � � O � N � m Z Z 0 m� W ' a � t�- Z W W m � � J �w m O� N (�' a W "� U C 7 O � N �o m m Q : x O ,� o c � N O 'V' 0 L Q� � E � Z T U O � d M �� U � c � �'+ a C � E m Z ?. C m Q � p Z U � U c Q N _ G W a � L Q � � Z N C M O M �� rn N � m � c �' 3 � m � O� F M � W rn � W Q F- Z O � L1. � 0 � � O � � �U (6 N � U @ C � J (0 O £ � � � JLL m o E � �� � Q LL N�Y � m co `�° m c'�iU � N � N <`+ � J N V y (� F�-� � N UO� ��� b� �� �:-. U �� � N�N aLL U NN O�(� �'p �d C . {y f6Na. 3�3rnQE� �a � �c a� li a� �n y — o L] m p Np Z Za-�� Ci m � u �U � m a��U V � O li � l� O� �- �' N O U � (�j 0 -�p_ LL 6M � ¢ U co I- a� s� � �C �Q�ON N GN °Ua� ���caN�'� � � a-' 'n'na"o �Q�ou>a LLai ° .�3 cay=LL� 0�=0� �M �W �p� N � U 1�, i�(n (h ( p � U C� CA t] N' N � � i7 (0` �O�ff` OW � EV' �ie-OD'7JOZvt7I"'(`7M cl�l - �°SS � � O n x �p W � a� o N � � N d U � J � a � 0 � � a m � C O .� � i O ��.. c m m c d U J y � � � a� N U � J Q c ro � � � N � � m F � N �p U "�" J d � m `- � o�i � � Z N � C N U � - o 0 a N � W Q N ~ d O a� U Q s � �� N � �z Z Q Q Q � W � a � w H Z w W m � � J � W z m O � a � W �U c � 0 U C N �o N N ❑ a W C � � a E � Z U O a N U C N 7 N C E m Z c a � 0 U U C W 3 N c d a E � Z N C � L � a � y � N m C � � � m �o � � f" � � > Q F- Z � � � � 0 m m o � o "' �U N y � U R C C 1 � 7 ,Q � O N� � � y Q U ¢ � UU � N � � t N U sc� @� voa� Uina V C N f6 �6�J(J c°Na 3 £� � Zt�a�` o z, ov� �U�r 0 ° � o u.��°� U p � aQQLL � � � a Q a U oQ t�¢ yQ0 w�c �apN �nOa �~ �0 � d LL NO" rq�' Catn O)t�CM ���W N 01 Ur R�� ": � UN � Ev 3° J LL N N ` Il N O O� I-- � � � J _ T � �q _�osS � � � o� a � W O �� � � �N y U � � � M a 'o � 0 C � C O i7 R � � O r-. C N N C V 1 m m � � fA I N � � J Q N � I�� ,~ C N � N C � U N J m �U I Z I U � J Q � R u� > N F-. � � � Q n � O � N � m z Z Q m Q � W � a � N Z W w E � m -� Z W o a a� � C � O U U ..�+ N OO m m � a x N C � N � � 7 Z U O a U C f 7 � G E m Z T C n 0 U U C N 3 h C N .O � 3 Z N C M o� t� a a, N � N � C � m � 0 � @ � � � � > ¢ F- Z � � � O N O �p � �U (4 N +�- U � C � � J LL � � � C N N N c � � `" � n � � '� N S� yQ U 'Q � NO �J oU� fn � pN � � L L �/y E9 GV fO �N ~� �� N� V ,r(pN Ny �tl C . "mm O�U��° ��' a�� a � m o z�z� a�a.=_ � p-a U p �.a� LL Q�wCJ � � o ti�� �'-¢ mo U O O C QCIl �M �J �O(6 O"ap,UCNNCO ¢ �'QflO � N °U m�ccQ��°'� �o o v, �ti0 Np fl-.N�t� c.- dt"mp inL',. �Ci�'m ��c �ja� � � ��W �M���W NrI�Uj�� �V�LN��NQ�V(OOl ^ �(7 VN ln �a-N � �'73�C0'QJOZ�i+7fL-MM OFFiCE OF L{CE�SE, I�SFECTtO\S A\D E\'VIRON\tE\TACPROTECTIO\ Robe.�1 Kusler, Direcro� saaxr PAD1 � �ee CITY OF SAIiJT PAITL No�m Co7eracn, blcya� TOB �CCO CO�IPLTANCE CHECK Y'OR�I c{�-1oSS Te1 e�F. o r, e: 6! 2-? 66-S090 Fccsimi!e: 61?-?56-SG99 6/?-?66-91?; � �� - C � � a � - �,`.,�- . _ �� DATE: Yi I��, TIME: �{�. � S LICE\SE I.D. T:�"L'MBER: 1�A`vtE OF CO\4PLLANCE CHECKER: ��c�.Ic,r. ?�A?�4E OF �DULTSUPERVISOR: Il�t�v� \A�4E & ADDRESS OF LICE'�SED VEr`DOR: �E�LDINE'S � 605 FRONT AVE —ST PAU�, MN 55117 - License Type: license # TYPE OF EST:.BLIS:iV1E\T: Cigaretteliobacco Ooi629s <<'AS TFIE TOBACCO: SELF-SER��_ �t'HERE Si'.4S THE'�1.4CH1�E DOES THE ES7ABLISfIA4E\T SALE WAS hL4DE: YES� \0_ WAS AN I.D. REQUESTED? I�A.4fE OF 1) I.D. VdAS CFiECIiED DESCRIPI70N: �0.C1L I'� a � DRIVER'S LICENSE Rt OTHER I.D. TYPE OF I.D. I.D. AMOUNT SPENT O:d PURCHASE: IF A SALE ��'AS NOT MAUE: REASON (CHECK OiVE) - ❑ ❑ 0 0 ❑ 2) BUSt\'ESS CLOSED 3) OUT OF BUSINESS 4} [I1�SATISFACTORYCO:�'DITIO\S LOii'RYPROFESS/0.4dL BUILDI.\'G Suife 300 350 St. Peter S:rzet Sr.ir.t Pcul, .dlir.r.uo:a 55102-I SIO ASSISTPD? SEX: M_ Fl! • i� c1�4,-- as[�-C� -�� C�" - �" r n�c��.�. . � � � � �; �l5 , �f��s . �1a� �� �:c.�e w � ��� �� �.�:�� �- 5) \1'ERE NOT ALLOR'ED TO E\'TER THE ESTABLISH'b1EA'T MACHIi�'E?, .� License Group Comments Text l.icensee: JERRY BELGEA ENTERPRISES INC DBA; JERALDiNE'S License #: 0016299 �3/3/99 Failed tobacco compliance check -sale made from a machine. To CAO for adverse acGon. CAR 4/17/g9 passed alcohol compliance check; no "unoffiaal" waming-DL �0323 85 Seats 55-87 4-13-89 Ph On Appn For New Of Class A Gambling Location License App'D C.P. 89-655 082991 Ph On Appn Fcr New Class C Gambling Locatio N License App'D C.F. 91-1596 7996- 7% Disc On Liq Fees Applied To 2nd 1l2d.ap 3/5/97 C.f. #97-233 App'D Imposing $200 Fine For 7he Sale Of Ci9s To A Minor 3/� 7/97 - Sent Fine �etter (DUe 4/4/97) - Lab 3/25/97 - Paid $200.00 Cigarette Fine - Lab 08/0471999 �q_�oss �c�_��ss �+'� � Licemee j CorM1eci � License) CardhoiBer � Type: t' Property C Licensee C� Unofficial C` p,p SYreet #� �5 S[reet Name. RONT Stred Type � Diredion. <Alls �,`; . Wd#: f—r_ i Cdy <AAI> �; On �,�: o r ,� �� � . f .����., . �� G ''C`�-t� s y .. � � Stra � : Stre � Stre= _� Qire�? L1nd { Cdy; License C•� Property Street # Street Neme: Stree} Type: Unft Ind. CdY: State: �fard' Dist Cauncil � Licensee: DBA' ( Sales Tax Licenoee � l(c. Type� � licensee �' Unoffival i5 ;ONT AVE D"uediort � Und# � 'PAUL DBA }JERqLpME'S - � Nis�nrmce � Bontl � Repuiremerds� j Projed Faaidator. ROZEK, CHRISTINE i � Adverse Action CommeMs Zip: 55777 . aamaa raneq moacco comp0ance check - sale made ,. €from a machine. To CRO for ativerse action. CAR : �4f17199 psssed alcahoi comp{iance check; � , ("unofficial" warning-DL I CommeMs ' — —_-'-" '--_' -'_- q q - t �ss i ?'a"���^�'=«„�:.:=°a�u����ci DBA NEftALDINE'S � � Stre: � �cense �censee � Lic. Types � Insurance , Bond 1 RequiremeNS � i Stre � ��censee Neme: ERRY BELGEA ENTERPRISES WC +._� ��.,y�,;.�:€ .�"z �F��.: pi OBA: ERALDINES � � SalesTaxtd 8532fi NonRrofR YWrkeYS ����`` Un@ : S ComP: NON000 !�P.�.L�-z,. : AA CoMred Rec'd ONOA009 qA 7rau�ing ftec'd NON�66 �� AA Fee Collected: Ol��ND00 Discourd fteNd � � Othu A enc Licenses Fnencial Hold Reasons QU5F�1; .�.t�9.'. ..Yp���,�ti"��"`:�$�`.�td�" ' .-,...-,.-u;�. ...e�. � -t � PAaI License To: — �` Mal Ta Contact C �icense Address -Maii imoice 70: — �' Matl To Cornact r License Atldress 8eckground Check Required r ORIGINAL RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, NIIrTNESOTA Presented By Refened To 3� Committee: Date 2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d1b{a Jeraldine's (License 3 ID No. 16299), located at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of 4 $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. The licensee is 5 further ordered to remove any cigarette vending machines from the licensed premises for the 6 violation of permitting the sale of cigarettes from a vending machine in a licensed establishment 7 which was open to individual under the age of 18. 9 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection 10 and any cigazette vending machines shall be removed from the licensed premises within fifteen 11 (15) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the August 3, 1999 Compliance report, the August 11, 1999 Notice of Violation letter and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretary By: � r1- N.��� Approved by Mav Date /�� /��/ By: �.'�{��Wi///J / BY: 1 /`M�J� / + �� -� Foxm Approved y City Att ea� By: � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By: Council File # � � —1�. Green Sheet # ( O � � � � Adopted by Conncil: Date �_��� � Office of LIEP fACT PQ2SON 8 PFIONE .ir,.�, , TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES Ctq - fo,S.S GREEN SHEET No � `?? ; 7 10/08/99 u��� u�� ❑ arv.,,cear ❑ arva.aR ❑ m��r•w�a�ccsoa ❑ wuwew�� ❑wraeWR�scwrl ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR� .:.•_""fii_:.:7 Concexning advexse action against the Cigarette License held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc., dba Jeraldine's, 605 Front Street. (Uncontested) PLANNING CAMMISSWN CIB CAMMITTEE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION Hac fhic P�soNfirm everxarked untler a mmraU forfhis de4artment9 YES NO Hes mis x�Vkm erer teen a dly anpoyee? YE3 NO Dces tlus PersaNfi�m Y?aeeec a skW rwt rwm�allYP� bY arry arreid alY emPbY�? YES MO' Is V�is pe�aoNfim� a tarpefed ventloR YES ' MO AOUNT OF TRANSACT�ON S COETrtIEVpIUE BUDQE7ED (GIRCLE ONE) SOURCE ACTN�T'NUMBER ? YE3 NO OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayton M Robinson, Ja, Crry Attorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemnn, Mayor October 6, 1999 OwnerlManager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117 ��� � � ��� RE: Cigazette license held by 3erry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Jeraidine's for the premises iocated at 605 Front St. in St. Paul License ID No. : 16299 Our File Number: G99-0283 Deaz Sir/t�fadam: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, October 27,1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Raznsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawfiil sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the licensing office is for a$200.00 fine and the removal of the cigazette vending machines from the licensed establishment. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, (/�2��� �JV c�'Me� Virguua Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: �t'adcy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP C(ViI DfYiStOY( qq - (oss 300CiryHa71 Telephone:651266-8710 lSiY¢stKelloggBlvd Facsimile:657298-5619 SaintPaul,MinnesolaSSIO2 _ NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING ���"'�� ����'`°"� �'`� Kathy Co1e, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 R.ice St., St. Paui, MN 55117 Cq-toss UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Jerry Belgea Enterprises, lnc, d/b/a Jeraldine's Address: 605 Front Street Council Hearing Date: October 27, 1999 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn, Stat. § 609.685 Minn. Stat. § 461.18, Subd. 2 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Dates of Violation: Piace: August 3, 1999 Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 Fine and the Removal of Any Cigarette Vending Machines From the Licensed Establishment Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Compliance Report 5. License information OFFICE ^^ THE CITY ATTORNEY Cltryron d. �rnson, Jc, CityAltorney CITY OP SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, M¢yor cNno;�;s;on 400 Ciry Hal! 15 W¢st Kellogg B1vd. Saint Paul, Nfirtnesom 55102 qa - tc�rS TelepFone: 651 2b6-8710 Foc.rimile: 651 ?9$-5679 August ll, 1999 NOTICE OF VIpLATION Owner/Manager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117 RE: Cigazette license held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a 7eraldine's for the premises at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul � License ID #: 1 b299 Deaz SirfMadazn: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the cigazette license held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Jeraldine's for the premises at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as follows: On August 3,1999, an underage person entered Jeraldine's at 605 Front Avenue and asked for change from the bartender to purchase cigarettes from the vending machine located next to the end of the bar. The individua! was given four $1 bills and four qnarters and was able to purchase a package of cigarettes with the change from the vending machine without being asked for any proof of age. The establishment is not posted that individuals under the age of 18 are not permifted to enter and the vending machine is located in an open area of the bar. This sale was in violation of Minn. Stat. §6Q9.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07, both of which prohibit the sale of tobacco to individuals under the age of eighteen, and Minn. Stat. §461.18, subd. 2, which prohibits cigarette vending machines in premises which are open to individuals under the age of 18. Page 2 Jeraldine's August 11, 1999 Ct� — \O SS If you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public heazin� before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your letter by Monday, August 23, 1999. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and make a statement on you own behalf. If , on the other hand, you dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appeaz and present witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please send me a letter requesting the administrative heazing. If we have not heard from you by Monday, August 23,1999, we will assume that you do not contest the facts and will schedule this before the City Council for hearing. if you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, � tc � �c�('�� � Virginia D, Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN 55117 ctq - �os$ STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANS3E G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on August 11, 1999, she served the attached NOTICS OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55117 (which is the last known address of said person? and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the i3nited States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. r�� „ l—�--�-+..� � Ce71 Subscribed and sworn to before me this llth day of Auqust, 1999. Notary Pu C � _. _ � �� �Atres Jan. 3i. �nv cZq_ tosS � � 0 : x N � N O r � O m V � G7 _.1 � � a n 0 Y 0 G m K t O Y t4 � Y W � d N C V ..J m T � N 3 � � N a�i > U U J Q N C N � a fl- �, E-' � N � �a V � J R 4 � p � � Z U � ', O � N u� ��� � Q � N z � O a Q n <- O � � � � � W mz Z q m Q � � � Q. � w F- Z W w N � � J ` w Z o � a � W � U C 3 O U i N � � o d Y � � Q W N C L � � L 7 Z U O U c � � N c � � c N d E O U U C m � N C � Q � 7 z N C M O c7 L � a a , y � N � C � m � � � F- � N � w Q F- Z O � � � O � � O � �U '�6 � N � � � a� - N � x Q U � U U O N U C � � m N�p .� �� 7 U ��o U O� U "' U �O °U� �� m m�a � � �Lrn M N �-~- W �V� O � U G J JlL � � � C N N N .Q r, C ti s Q � NO JN � �N ro�y ~� �71� N � C 4.-(DtNO d�N 'QW ��U QO_ N � 3 ��'i6�iQ���L 1 Z lL N� N O� f¢ U Z ` � � � � � �..- N Q g u� U LL fl.�'- � cr4 4 � ° O �N�' N�N 4 ¢p0 � C C C O. U��LL (y uJ� N� D.,f�� V C;6 c� a p a� cu "'a- � o u_Ocna �rn o ct°�`U � � � m �o?arn a� �yrnrn NN�cRO)UCOO) ��• M � UNJ�� d�� ��VJOZ�MF-C�'JM aq_�oss' � � 0 � x iD � y O N � N d U �, � J m a ; 0 r O a � C O w R � i w _ d N C d U J m � io � � V � J Q U N ro U G N O f�l U F 1 N C c n U J ( N a+ � � n rn � I� �Z = N U � J � � N � w ¢ w �' Z d O �� a � ¢�� �t� d � N Z Z 0 I O� Q I � W -a a K W F- Z W w � � � J iZ m �� � 'a w � �U C � O V � N �o m m ❑ a y c `m a E 7 Z U 0 a V C @ 7 N c � m Z c � a 0 U U @ N c N n � � Z N c m o m L � a Q , Nm N � C � m � � � N � rn � � w ¢ F- Z � � LL � O � @ p � O N � V � C C J jLL E � - Q c c�m � = m .fl �- � � N (7 £ '6 (6 Q t N � N N J J m t N U y.� � t� a� LG V �� a Q/ 6�C NO V V�-.(�DN N � �ULL � m m Oo�U a� m� o� m 3 N O_N E �IL N� N� O� @ � 7 � Z Cj Z � �� � � � p-a � a �<� a� a;U o� t �' R � a4 a� U, p C QC�JM OJ W�R Q �Ua�i ��ccn.��' � O N �O U OQ N�k'^ N f0 . t-�Q �nL_,.c��u,;Ov�a @ N �' � ,fy.aCaNO N � �t� �M p�j�W �� N M Ns�- �"M� UNJ�� N1�� o Ev 3�w`t'v�oZ.°-'itL-irN1i a`� - �°SS m � 0 a x � � O vi p M � O � V N � '- r' rt{ M C. M O � O C N � c O i: R � L � W C d C V J m � �� N N N > U U .J Q N f0 N y O O N � @ N T � F- � c C O d O U J p' J � 19 � ��I IZ d � ._! I� � N � W Q N N Z � 0 '� � � 4LL� � � � � N � N Z Z Q m � W � a � H Z W W °' c7 � J ` w z O � a W � �U C � O U i N � �O N N � a W o y o C O _ � 0 'V' O � N � � 7 U O � ch c�i � c � N � N a c � m m ci �I �I� o �Z U � J i ¢ C W _a � N � � 3 Z N C M o � r � 0.� N � N � c �? m � o� F" � � � � W Q Z � � LL � � N � c O � N � � O m � � ° 0 � C N�Y �y Q U �V� t C V V O N O .� C J t6 O J {L � c N U1 m a � c lf_ � Q � N O � m tn � p N � N („) �..,, � �:. � m� am �� � wm m °' N vii �WV � 3 °j � °' ° C ' � N 3 �Q C L 4 �u_m�n Z�jz ; a��.=_ � rn � ��a�fl.�mU W O_ �� V QQ �p a N fl'�"� C CV rn c N �QyQ�O�a�ILtn coc�caN�V� UJ O U O..- # N(6 w �,_�.� �LLocna rof6�°rna�ir°��U �n� N�Mt60�!?t0���� M � CJNJ�� � r�NttJOZ�(h�--Mf`') o�q - �oss � � � x � 0 � O � � V N q '� f` a r, 0 � C � C O :� R E a. w Q� N C d c� J � � � � N > V U �i Q � a C 3 � N N a � F - tn c NO c � U � J Q J � � m � m � 00 Z m rn U � '' ° o ' @ � w ¢ � N Z �O Q LL � � � O � N � m Z Z 0 m� W ' a � t�- Z W W m � � J �w m O� N (�' a W "� U C 7 O � N �o m m Q : x O ,� o c � N O 'V' 0 L Q� � E � Z T U O � d M �� U � c � �'+ a C � E m Z ?. C m Q � p Z U � U c Q N _ G W a � L Q � � Z N C M O M �� rn N � m � c �' 3 � m � O� F M � W rn � W Q F- Z O � L1. � 0 � � O � � �U (6 N � U @ C � J (0 O £ � � � JLL m o E � �� � Q LL N�Y � m co `�° m c'�iU � N � N <`+ � J N V y (� F�-� � N UO� ��� b� �� �:-. U �� � N�N aLL U NN O�(� �'p �d C . {y f6Na. 3�3rnQE� �a � �c a� li a� �n y — o L] m p Np Z Za-�� Ci m � u �U � m a��U V � O li � l� O� �- �' N O U � (�j 0 -�p_ LL 6M � ¢ U co I- a� s� � �C �Q�ON N GN °Ua� ���caN�'� � � a-' 'n'na"o �Q�ou>a LLai ° .�3 cay=LL� 0�=0� �M �W �p� N � U 1�, i�(n (h ( p � U C� CA t] N' N � � i7 (0` �O�ff` OW � EV' �ie-OD'7JOZvt7I"'(`7M cl�l - �°SS � � O n x �p W � a� o N � � N d U � J � a � 0 � � a m � C O .� � i O ��.. c m m c d U J y � � � a� N U � J Q c ro � � � N � � m F � N �p U "�" J d � m `- � o�i � � Z N � C N U � - o 0 a N � W Q N ~ d O a� U Q s � �� N � �z Z Q Q Q � W � a � w H Z w W m � � J � W z m O � a � W �U c � 0 U C N �o N N ❑ a W C � � a E � Z U O a N U C N 7 N C E m Z c a � 0 U U C W 3 N c d a E � Z N C � L � a � y � N m C � � � m �o � � f" � � > Q F- Z � � � � 0 m m o � o "' �U N y � U R C C 1 � 7 ,Q � O N� � � y Q U ¢ � UU � N � � t N U sc� @� voa� Uina V C N f6 �6�J(J c°Na 3 £� � Zt�a�` o z, ov� �U�r 0 ° � o u.��°� U p � aQQLL � � � a Q a U oQ t�¢ yQ0 w�c �apN �nOa �~ �0 � d LL NO" rq�' Catn O)t�CM ���W N 01 Ur R�� ": � UN � Ev 3° J LL N N ` Il N O O� I-- � � � J _ T � �q _�osS � � � o� a � W O �� � � �N y U � � � M a 'o � 0 C � C O i7 R � � O r-. C N N C V 1 m m � � fA I N � � J Q N � I�� ,~ C N � N C � U N J m �U I Z I U � J Q � R u� > N F-. � � � Q n � O � N � m z Z Q m Q � W � a � N Z W w E � m -� Z W o a a� � C � O U U ..�+ N OO m m � a x N C � N � � 7 Z U O a U C f 7 � G E m Z T C n 0 U U C N 3 h C N .O � 3 Z N C M o� t� a a, N � N � C � m � 0 � @ � � � � > ¢ F- Z � � � O N O �p � �U (4 N +�- U � C � � J LL � � � C N N N c � � `" � n � � '� N S� yQ U 'Q � NO �J oU� fn � pN � � L L �/y E9 GV fO �N ~� �� N� V ,r(pN Ny �tl C . "mm O�U��° ��' a�� a � m o z�z� a�a.=_ � p-a U p �.a� LL Q�wCJ � � o ti�� �'-¢ mo U O O C QCIl �M �J �O(6 O"ap,UCNNCO ¢ �'QflO � N °U m�ccQ��°'� �o o v, �ti0 Np fl-.N�t� c.- dt"mp inL',. �Ci�'m ��c �ja� � � ��W �M���W NrI�Uj�� �V�LN��NQ�V(OOl ^ �(7 VN ln �a-N � �'73�C0'QJOZ�i+7fL-MM OFFiCE OF L{CE�SE, I�SFECTtO\S A\D E\'VIRON\tE\TACPROTECTIO\ Robe.�1 Kusler, Direcro� saaxr PAD1 � �ee CITY OF SAIiJT PAITL No�m Co7eracn, blcya� TOB �CCO CO�IPLTANCE CHECK Y'OR�I c{�-1oSS Te1 e�F. o r, e: 6! 2-? 66-S090 Fccsimi!e: 61?-?56-SG99 6/?-?66-91?; � �� - C � � a � - �,`.,�- . _ �� DATE: Yi I��, TIME: �{�. � S LICE\SE I.D. T:�"L'MBER: 1�A`vtE OF CO\4PLLANCE CHECKER: ��c�.Ic,r. ?�A?�4E OF �DULTSUPERVISOR: Il�t�v� \A�4E & ADDRESS OF LICE'�SED VEr`DOR: �E�LDINE'S � 605 FRONT AVE —ST PAU�, MN 55117 - License Type: license # TYPE OF EST:.BLIS:iV1E\T: Cigaretteliobacco Ooi629s <<'AS TFIE TOBACCO: SELF-SER��_ �t'HERE Si'.4S THE'�1.4CH1�E DOES THE ES7ABLISfIA4E\T SALE WAS hL4DE: YES� \0_ WAS AN I.D. REQUESTED? I�A.4fE OF 1) I.D. VdAS CFiECIiED DESCRIPI70N: �0.C1L I'� a � DRIVER'S LICENSE Rt OTHER I.D. TYPE OF I.D. I.D. AMOUNT SPENT O:d PURCHASE: IF A SALE ��'AS NOT MAUE: REASON (CHECK OiVE) - ❑ ❑ 0 0 ❑ 2) BUSt\'ESS CLOSED 3) OUT OF BUSINESS 4} [I1�SATISFACTORYCO:�'DITIO\S LOii'RYPROFESS/0.4dL BUILDI.\'G Suife 300 350 St. Peter S:rzet Sr.ir.t Pcul, .dlir.r.uo:a 55102-I SIO ASSISTPD? SEX: M_ Fl! • i� c1�4,-- as[�-C� -�� C�" - �" r n�c��.�. . � � � � �; �l5 , �f��s . �1a� �� �:c.�e w � ��� �� �.�:�� �- 5) \1'ERE NOT ALLOR'ED TO E\'TER THE ESTABLISH'b1EA'T MACHIi�'E?, .� License Group Comments Text l.icensee: JERRY BELGEA ENTERPRISES INC DBA; JERALDiNE'S License #: 0016299 �3/3/99 Failed tobacco compliance check -sale made from a machine. To CAO for adverse acGon. CAR 4/17/g9 passed alcohol compliance check; no "unoffiaal" waming-DL �0323 85 Seats 55-87 4-13-89 Ph On Appn For New Of Class A Gambling Location License App'D C.P. 89-655 082991 Ph On Appn Fcr New Class C Gambling Locatio N License App'D C.F. 91-1596 7996- 7% Disc On Liq Fees Applied To 2nd 1l2d.ap 3/5/97 C.f. #97-233 App'D Imposing $200 Fine For 7he Sale Of Ci9s To A Minor 3/� 7/97 - Sent Fine �etter (DUe 4/4/97) - Lab 3/25/97 - Paid $200.00 Cigarette Fine - Lab 08/0471999 �q_�oss �c�_��ss �+'� � Licemee j CorM1eci � License) CardhoiBer � Type: t' Property C Licensee C� Unofficial C` p,p SYreet #� �5 S[reet Name. RONT Stred Type � Diredion. <Alls �,`; . Wd#: f—r_ i Cdy <AAI> �; On �,�: o r ,� �� � . f .����., . �� G ''C`�-t� s y .. � � Stra � : Stre � Stre= _� Qire�? L1nd { Cdy; License C•� Property Street # Street Neme: Stree} Type: Unft Ind. CdY: State: �fard' Dist Cauncil � Licensee: DBA' ( Sales Tax Licenoee � l(c. Type� � licensee �' Unoffival i5 ;ONT AVE D"uediort � Und# � 'PAUL DBA }JERqLpME'S - � Nis�nrmce � Bontl � Repuiremerds� j Projed Faaidator. ROZEK, CHRISTINE i � Adverse Action CommeMs Zip: 55777 . aamaa raneq moacco comp0ance check - sale made ,. €from a machine. To CRO for ativerse action. CAR : �4f17199 psssed alcahoi comp{iance check; � , ("unofficial" warning-DL I CommeMs ' — —_-'-" '--_' -'_- q q - t �ss i ?'a"���^�'=«„�:.:=°a�u����ci DBA NEftALDINE'S � � Stre: � �cense �censee � Lic. Types � Insurance , Bond 1 RequiremeNS � i Stre � ��censee Neme: ERRY BELGEA ENTERPRISES WC +._� ��.,y�,;.�:€ .�"z �F��.: pi OBA: ERALDINES � � SalesTaxtd 8532fi NonRrofR YWrkeYS ����`` Un@ : S ComP: NON000 !�P.�.L�-z,. : AA CoMred Rec'd ONOA009 qA 7rau�ing ftec'd NON�66 �� AA Fee Collected: Ol��ND00 Discourd fteNd � � Othu A enc Licenses Fnencial Hold Reasons QU5F�1; .�.t�9.'. ..Yp���,�ti"��"`:�$�`.�td�" ' .-,...-,.-u;�. ...e�. � -t � PAaI License To: — �` Mal Ta Contact C �icense Address -Maii imoice 70: — �' Matl To Cornact r License Atldress 8eckground Check Required r ORIGINAL RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, NIIrTNESOTA Presented By Refened To 3� Committee: Date 2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d1b{a Jeraldine's (License 3 ID No. 16299), located at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of 4 $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. The licensee is 5 further ordered to remove any cigarette vending machines from the licensed premises for the 6 violation of permitting the sale of cigarettes from a vending machine in a licensed establishment 7 which was open to individual under the age of 18. 9 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection 10 and any cigazette vending machines shall be removed from the licensed premises within fifteen 11 (15) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the August 3, 1999 Compliance report, the August 11, 1999 Notice of Violation letter and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: Adoption Certified by Council Secretary By: � r1- N.��� Approved by Mav Date /�� /��/ By: �.'�{��Wi///J / BY: 1 /`M�J� / + �� -� Foxm Approved y City Att ea� By: � Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By: Council File # � � —1�. Green Sheet # ( O � � � � Adopted by Conncil: Date �_��� � Office of LIEP fACT PQ2SON 8 PFIONE .ir,.�, , TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES Ctq - fo,S.S GREEN SHEET No � `?? ; 7 10/08/99 u��� u�� ❑ arv.,,cear ❑ arva.aR ❑ m��r•w�a�ccsoa ❑ wuwew�� ❑wraeWR�scwrl ❑ (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR� .:.•_""fii_:.:7 Concexning advexse action against the Cigarette License held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc., dba Jeraldine's, 605 Front Street. (Uncontested) PLANNING CAMMISSWN CIB CAMMITTEE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION Hac fhic P�soNfirm everxarked untler a mmraU forfhis de4artment9 YES NO Hes mis x�Vkm erer teen a dly anpoyee? YE3 NO Dces tlus PersaNfi�m Y?aeeec a skW rwt rwm�allYP� bY arry arreid alY emPbY�? YES MO' Is V�is pe�aoNfim� a tarpefed ventloR YES ' MO AOUNT OF TRANSACT�ON S COETrtIEVpIUE BUDQE7ED (GIRCLE ONE) SOURCE ACTN�T'NUMBER ? YE3 NO OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Clayton M Robinson, Ja, Crry Attorney CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Colemnn, Mayor October 6, 1999 OwnerlManager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117 ��� � � ��� RE: Cigazette license held by 3erry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Jeraidine's for the premises iocated at 605 Front St. in St. Paul License ID No. : 16299 Our File Number: G99-0283 Deaz Sir/t�fadam: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, October 27,1999 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Raznsey County Courthouse. Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawfiil sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the licensing office is for a$200.00 fine and the removal of the cigazette vending machines from the licensed establishment. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, (/�2��� �JV c�'Me� Virguua Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: �t'adcy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP C(ViI DfYiStOY( qq - (oss 300CiryHa71 Telephone:651266-8710 lSiY¢stKelloggBlvd Facsimile:657298-5619 SaintPaul,MinnesolaSSIO2 _ NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING ���"'�� ����'`°"� �'`� Kathy Co1e, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 R.ice St., St. Paui, MN 55117 Cq-toss UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Jerry Belgea Enterprises, lnc, d/b/a Jeraldine's Address: 605 Front Street Council Hearing Date: October 27, 1999 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn, Stat. § 609.685 Minn. Stat. § 461.18, Subd. 2 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Dates of Violation: Piace: August 3, 1999 Licensed Premises Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 Fine and the Removal of Any Cigarette Vending Machines From the Licensed Establishment Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License Information Report 4. Compliance Report 5. License information OFFICE ^^ THE CITY ATTORNEY Cltryron d. �rnson, Jc, CityAltorney CITY OP SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, M¢yor cNno;�;s;on 400 Ciry Hal! 15 W¢st Kellogg B1vd. Saint Paul, Nfirtnesom 55102 qa - tc�rS TelepFone: 651 2b6-8710 Foc.rimile: 651 ?9$-5679 August ll, 1999 NOTICE OF VIpLATION Owner/Manager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55117 RE: Cigazette license held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a 7eraldine's for the premises at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul � License ID #: 1 b299 Deaz SirfMadazn: The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection has recommended adverse action against the cigazette license held by Jerry Belgea Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a Jeraldine's for the premises at 605 Front Avenue in Saint Paul. The basis for this recommendation is as follows: On August 3,1999, an underage person entered Jeraldine's at 605 Front Avenue and asked for change from the bartender to purchase cigarettes from the vending machine located next to the end of the bar. The individua! was given four $1 bills and four qnarters and was able to purchase a package of cigarettes with the change from the vending machine without being asked for any proof of age. The establishment is not posted that individuals under the age of 18 are not permifted to enter and the vending machine is located in an open area of the bar. This sale was in violation of Minn. Stat. §6Q9.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07, both of which prohibit the sale of tobacco to individuals under the age of eighteen, and Minn. Stat. §461.18, subd. 2, which prohibits cigarette vending machines in premises which are open to individuals under the age of 18. Page 2 Jeraldine's August 11, 1999 Ct� — \O SS If you do not dispute the above facts, but wish to have a public heazin� before the Saint Paul City Council, you will need to send me a letter with a statement admitting the violation and requesting a public hearing. We will need to receive your letter by Monday, August 23, 1999. The matter will then be scheduled before the City Council for a public hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You will have an opportunity to appeaz before the Council and make a statement on you own behalf. If , on the other hand, you dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appeaz and present witnesses, evidence and cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St. Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please send me a letter requesting the administrative heazing. If we have not heard from you by Monday, August 23,1999, we will assume that you do not contest the facts and will schedule this before the City Council for hearing. if you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, � tc � �c�('�� � Virginia D, Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy Director of LIEP Kathy Cole, Executive Director, District 6 Planning Council, 1061 Rice St., St. Paul, MN 55117 ctq - �os$ STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANS3E G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on August 11, 1999, she served the attached NOTICS OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Owner/Manager Jeraldine's 605 Front Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55117 (which is the last known address of said person? and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the i3nited States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. r�� „ l—�--�-+..� � Ce71 Subscribed and sworn to before me this llth day of Auqust, 1999. Notary Pu C � _. _ � �� �Atres Jan. 3i. �nv cZq_ tosS � � 0 : x N � N O r � O m V � G7 _.1 � � a n 0 Y 0 G m K t O Y t4 � Y W � d N C V ..J m T � N 3 � � N a�i > U U J Q N C N � a fl- �, E-' � N � �a V � J R 4 � p � � Z U � ', O � N u� ��� � Q � N z � O a Q n <- O � � � � � W mz Z q m Q � � � Q. � w F- Z W w N � � J ` w Z o � a � W � U C 3 O U i N � � o d Y � � Q W N C L � � L 7 Z U O U c � � N c � � c N d E O U U C m � N C � Q � 7 z N C M O c7 L � a a , y � N � C � m � � � F- � N � w Q F- Z O � � � O � � O � �U '�6 � N � � � a� - N � x Q U � U U O N U C � � m N�p .� �� 7 U ��o U O� U "' U �O °U� �� m m�a � � �Lrn M N �-~- W �V� O � U G J JlL � � � C N N N .Q r, C ti s Q � NO JN � �N ro�y ~� �71� N � C 4.-(DtNO d�N 'QW ��U QO_ N � 3 ��'i6�iQ���L 1 Z lL N� N O� f¢ U Z ` � � � � � �..- N Q g u� U LL fl.�'- � cr4 4 � ° O �N�' N�N 4 ¢p0 � C C C O. U��LL (y uJ� N� D.,f�� V C;6 c� a p a� cu "'a- � o u_Ocna �rn o ct°�`U � � � m �o?arn a� �yrnrn NN�cRO)UCOO) ��• M � UNJ�� d�� ��VJOZ�MF-C�'JM aq_�oss' � � 0 � x iD � y O N � N d U �, � J m a ; 0 r O a � C O w R � i w _ d N C d U J m � io � � V � J Q U N ro U G N O f�l U F 1 N C c n U J ( N a+ � � n rn � I� �Z = N U � J � � N � w ¢ w �' Z d O �� a � ¢�� �t� d � N Z Z 0 I O� Q I � W -a a K W F- Z W w � � � J iZ m �� � 'a w � �U C � O V � N �o m m ❑ a y c `m a E 7 Z U 0 a V C @ 7 N c � m Z c � a 0 U U @ N c N n � � Z N c m o m L � a Q , Nm N � C � m � � � N � rn � � w ¢ F- Z � � LL � O � @ p � O N � V � C C J jLL E � - Q c c�m � = m .fl �- � � N (7 £ '6 (6 Q t N � N N J J m t N U y.� � t� a� LG V �� a Q/ 6�C NO V V�-.(�DN N � �ULL � m m Oo�U a� m� o� m 3 N O_N E �IL N� N� O� @ � 7 � Z Cj Z � �� � � � p-a � a �<� a� a;U o� t �' R � a4 a� U, p C QC�JM OJ W�R Q �Ua�i ��ccn.��' � O N �O U OQ N�k'^ N f0 . t-�Q �nL_,.c��u,;Ov�a @ N �' � ,fy.aCaNO N � �t� �M p�j�W �� N M Ns�- �"M� UNJ�� N1�� o Ev 3�w`t'v�oZ.°-'itL-irN1i a`� - �°SS m � 0 a x � � O vi p M � O � V N � '- r' rt{ M C. M O � O C N � c O i: R � L � W C d C V J m � �� N N N > U U .J Q N f0 N y O O N � @ N T � F- � c C O d O U J p' J � 19 � ��I IZ d � ._! I� � N � W Q N N Z � 0 '� � � 4LL� � � � � N � N Z Z Q m � W � a � H Z W W °' c7 � J ` w z O � a W � �U C � O U i N � �O N N � a W o y o C O _ � 0 'V' O � N � � 7 U O � ch c�i � c � N � N a c � m m ci �I �I� o �Z U � J i ¢ C W _a � N � � 3 Z N C M o � r � 0.� N � N � c �? m � o� F" � � � � W Q Z � � LL � � N � c O � N � � O m � � ° 0 � C N�Y �y Q U �V� t C V V O N O .� C J t6 O J {L � c N U1 m a � c lf_ � Q � N O � m tn � p N � N („) �..,, � �:. � m� am �� � wm m °' N vii �WV � 3 °j � °' ° C ' � N 3 �Q C L 4 �u_m�n Z�jz ; a��.=_ � rn � ��a�fl.�mU W O_ �� V QQ �p a N fl'�"� C CV rn c N �QyQ�O�a�ILtn coc�caN�V� UJ O U O..- # N(6 w �,_�.� �LLocna rof6�°rna�ir°��U �n� N�Mt60�!?t0���� M � CJNJ�� � r�NttJOZ�(h�--Mf`') o�q - �oss � � � x � 0 � O � � V N q '� f` a r, 0 � C � C O :� R E a. w Q� N C d c� J � � � � N > V U �i Q � a C 3 � N N a � F - tn c NO c � U � J Q J � � m � m � 00 Z m rn U � '' ° o ' @ � w ¢ � N Z �O Q LL � � � O � N � m Z Z 0 m� W ' a � t�- Z W W m � � J �w m O� N (�' a W "� U C 7 O � N �o m m Q : x O ,� o c � N O 'V' 0 L Q� � E � Z T U O � d M �� U � c � �'+ a C � E m Z ?. C m Q � p Z U � U c Q N _ G W a � L Q � � Z N C M O M �� rn N � m � c �' 3 � m � O� F M � W rn � W Q F- Z O � L1. � 0 � � O � � �U (6 N � U @ C � J (0 O £ � � � JLL m o E � �� � Q LL N�Y � m co `�° m c'�iU � N � N <`+ � J N V y (� F�-� � N UO� ��� b� �� �:-. U �� � N�N aLL U NN O�(� �'p �d C . {y f6Na. 3�3rnQE� �a � �c a� li a� �n y — o L] m p Np Z Za-�� Ci m � u �U � m a��U V � O li � l� O� �- �' N O U � (�j 0 -�p_ LL 6M � ¢ U co I- a� s� � �C �Q�ON N GN °Ua� ���caN�'� � � a-' 'n'na"o �Q�ou>a LLai ° .�3 cay=LL� 0�=0� �M �W �p� N � U 1�, i�(n (h ( p � U C� CA t] N' N � � i7 (0` �O�ff` OW � EV' �ie-OD'7JOZvt7I"'(`7M cl�l - �°SS � � O n x �p W � a� o N � � N d U � J � a � 0 � � a m � C O .� � i O ��.. c m m c d U J y � � � a� N U � J Q c ro � � � N � � m F � N �p U "�" J d � m `- � o�i � � Z N � C N U � - o 0 a N � W Q N ~ d O a� U Q s � �� N � �z Z Q Q Q � W � a � w H Z w W m � � J � W z m O � a � W �U c � 0 U C N �o N N ❑ a W C � � a E � Z U O a N U C N 7 N C E m Z c a � 0 U U C W 3 N c d a E � Z N C � L � a � y � N m C � � � m �o � � f" � � > Q F- Z � � � � 0 m m o � o "' �U N y � U R C C 1 � 7 ,Q � O N� � � y Q U ¢ � UU � N � � t N U sc� @� voa� Uina V C N f6 �6�J(J c°Na 3 £� � Zt�a�` o z, ov� �U�r 0 ° � o u.��°� U p � aQQLL � � � a Q a U oQ t�¢ yQ0 w�c �apN �nOa �~ �0 � d LL NO" rq�' Catn O)t�CM ���W N 01 Ur R�� ": � UN � Ev 3° J LL N N ` Il N O O� I-- � � � J _ T � �q _�osS � � � o� a � W O �� � � �N y U � � � M a 'o � 0 C � C O i7 R � � O r-. C N N C V 1 m m � � fA I N � � J Q N � I�� ,~ C N � N C � U N J m �U I Z I U � J Q � R u� > N F-. � � � Q n � O � N � m z Z Q m Q � W � a � N Z W w E � m -� Z W o a a� � C � O U U ..�+ N OO m m � a x N C � N � � 7 Z U O a U C f 7 � G E m Z T C n 0 U U C N 3 h C N .O � 3 Z N C M o� t� a a, N � N � C � m � 0 � @ � � � � > ¢ F- Z � � � O N O �p � �U (4 N +�- U � C � � J LL � � � C N N N c � � `" � n � � '� N S� yQ U 'Q � NO �J oU� fn � pN � � L L �/y E9 GV fO �N ~� �� N� V ,r(pN Ny �tl C . "mm O�U��° ��' a�� a � m o z�z� a�a.=_ � p-a U p �.a� LL Q�wCJ � � o ti�� �'-¢ mo U O O C QCIl �M �J �O(6 O"ap,UCNNCO ¢ �'QflO � N °U m�ccQ��°'� �o o v, �ti0 Np fl-.N�t� c.- dt"mp inL',. �Ci�'m ��c �ja� � � ��W �M���W NrI�Uj�� �V�LN��NQ�V(OOl ^ �(7 VN ln �a-N � �'73�C0'QJOZ�i+7fL-MM OFFiCE OF L{CE�SE, I�SFECTtO\S A\D E\'VIRON\tE\TACPROTECTIO\ Robe.�1 Kusler, Direcro� saaxr PAD1 � �ee CITY OF SAIiJT PAITL No�m Co7eracn, blcya� TOB �CCO CO�IPLTANCE CHECK Y'OR�I c{�-1oSS Te1 e�F. o r, e: 6! 2-? 66-S090 Fccsimi!e: 61?-?56-SG99 6/?-?66-91?; � �� - C � � a � - �,`.,�- . _ �� DATE: Yi I��, TIME: �{�. � S LICE\SE I.D. T:�"L'MBER: 1�A`vtE OF CO\4PLLANCE CHECKER: ��c�.Ic,r. ?�A?�4E OF �DULTSUPERVISOR: Il�t�v� \A�4E & ADDRESS OF LICE'�SED VEr`DOR: �E�LDINE'S � 605 FRONT AVE —ST PAU�, MN 55117 - License Type: license # TYPE OF EST:.BLIS:iV1E\T: Cigaretteliobacco Ooi629s <<'AS TFIE TOBACCO: SELF-SER��_ �t'HERE Si'.4S THE'�1.4CH1�E DOES THE ES7ABLISfIA4E\T SALE WAS hL4DE: YES� \0_ WAS AN I.D. REQUESTED? I�A.4fE OF 1) I.D. VdAS CFiECIiED DESCRIPI70N: �0.C1L I'� a � DRIVER'S LICENSE Rt OTHER I.D. TYPE OF I.D. I.D. AMOUNT SPENT O:d PURCHASE: IF A SALE ��'AS NOT MAUE: REASON (CHECK OiVE) - ❑ ❑ 0 0 ❑ 2) BUSt\'ESS CLOSED 3) OUT OF BUSINESS 4} [I1�SATISFACTORYCO:�'DITIO\S LOii'RYPROFESS/0.4dL BUILDI.\'G Suife 300 350 St. Peter S:rzet Sr.ir.t Pcul, .dlir.r.uo:a 55102-I SIO ASSISTPD? SEX: M_ Fl! • i� c1�4,-- as[�-C� -�� C�" - �" r n�c��.�. . � � � � �; �l5 , �f��s . �1a� �� �:c.�e w � ��� �� �.�:�� �- 5) \1'ERE NOT ALLOR'ED TO E\'TER THE ESTABLISH'b1EA'T MACHIi�'E?, .� License Group Comments Text l.icensee: JERRY BELGEA ENTERPRISES INC DBA; JERALDiNE'S License #: 0016299 �3/3/99 Failed tobacco compliance check -sale made from a machine. To CAO for adverse acGon. CAR 4/17/g9 passed alcohol compliance check; no "unoffiaal" waming-DL �0323 85 Seats 55-87 4-13-89 Ph On Appn For New Of Class A Gambling Location License App'D C.P. 89-655 082991 Ph On Appn Fcr New Class C Gambling Locatio N License App'D C.F. 91-1596 7996- 7% Disc On Liq Fees Applied To 2nd 1l2d.ap 3/5/97 C.f. #97-233 App'D Imposing $200 Fine For 7he Sale Of Ci9s To A Minor 3/� 7/97 - Sent Fine �etter (DUe 4/4/97) - Lab 3/25/97 - Paid $200.00 Cigarette Fine - Lab 08/0471999 �q_�oss �c�_��ss �+'� � Licemee j CorM1eci � License) CardhoiBer � Type: t' Property C Licensee C� Unofficial C` p,p SYreet #� �5 S[reet Name. RONT Stred Type � Diredion. <Alls �,`; . Wd#: f—r_ i Cdy <AAI> �; On �,�: o r ,� �� � . f .����., . �� G ''C`�-t� s y .. � � Stra � : Stre � Stre= _� Qire�? L1nd { Cdy; License C•� Property Street # Street Neme: Stree} Type: Unft Ind. CdY: State: �fard' Dist Cauncil � Licensee: DBA' ( Sales Tax Licenoee � l(c. Type� � licensee �' Unoffival i5 ;ONT AVE D"uediort � Und# � 'PAUL DBA }JERqLpME'S - � Nis�nrmce � Bontl � Repuiremerds� j Projed Faaidator. ROZEK, CHRISTINE i � Adverse Action CommeMs Zip: 55777 . aamaa raneq moacco comp0ance check - sale made ,. €from a machine. To CRO for ativerse action. CAR : �4f17199 psssed alcahoi comp{iance check; � , ("unofficial" warning-DL I CommeMs ' — —_-'-" '--_' -'_- q q - t �ss i ?'a"���^�'=«„�:.:=°a�u����ci DBA NEftALDINE'S � � Stre: � �cense �censee � Lic. Types � Insurance , Bond 1 RequiremeNS � i Stre � ��censee Neme: ERRY BELGEA ENTERPRISES WC +._� ��.,y�,;.�:€ .�"z �F��.: pi OBA: ERALDINES � � SalesTaxtd 8532fi NonRrofR YWrkeYS ����`` Un@ : S ComP: NON000 !�P.�.L�-z,. : AA CoMred Rec'd ONOA009 qA 7rau�ing ftec'd NON�66 �� AA Fee Collected: Ol��ND00 Discourd fteNd � � Othu A enc Licenses Fnencial Hold Reasons QU5F�1; .�.t�9.'. ..Yp���,�ti"��"`:�$�`.�td�" ' .-,...-,.-u;�. ...e�. � -t � PAaI License To: — �` Mal Ta Contact C �icense Address -Maii imoice 70: — �' Matl To Cornact r License Atldress 8eckground Check Required r