89-760 WHITE -�-'CITV CLERK .
PWK - FINANCE GITY OF' S I T PAUL Council /j /'')
BIUERr-MAYORTMENT File NO. �` ` • �O
• /
Or Z Ce Ordinance N 0. � �(v ��
�- _
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
-8-
ec ion 7 .
This ordinance shall take f ect and be in force thirty (30)
days from and after its passage, pproval and publication. City
Assisted Projects which have b n approved by the City Council prior
to its effective date shall no b subject to the provisions of this
ordinance.
EXHIBIT A. AFFORDA LE RENTS BY BEDROOM SIZE : 1989
Maximum
Bedroom Size Monthly Gross Rent
SRO $332
EFF 444
1 BR 444
2 BR 507
3 BR 571
4 BR 634
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
�� [n Favo
Goswitz
Rettman p g
Scheibel A gai ns t Y
Sonnen
—i�ilcu�.
v1J�. 2 5 Form Approved by City Atf ney
Adopted by Council: Date � /
B p l �!O°
Certified Pa s Council S reta Y
By
Appr y Mayor: Date �u� 2 8 Approved y Mayor for Submission to Council
.�
By
p�g�� AU G -5 19 9
. � �_ ��U
� �� �� GITY O AINT PAUL
OFFICE O T E CITY COUNCIL
WILLIAM L. WILSON MARK VOERDING
Councilman Legislative Aide
M M RANDUM
To: City Council President Jim h bel and Members of the City Council
From: Councilmember Bill Wilso � .
Qu
Subject: Committee Recommendatio o Housing Replacement Ordinance
Date: July 10, 1989
The ordinance language which was pr e ed to Council as amendments recommended
by the Housing and Economic Develo m t Committee accurately reflected the
outcome of the committee discussion. ta drafted the language and circulated it to
committee members before senciing th a endments to the City Clerk's office. The
consensus was that the draft was acce ab e; however, Councilmember Sonnen indicated
to staff that there were additional ame d ents she planned to introduce before Council.
I will not be able to be at tomorrow's o ncil meeting, but I encourage you to adopt
this version as the committee recomm nd tion and then consider any further
amendments to be brought forward by an Councilmembers.
CITY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 612/298-4646
9 46
-------
• - - —_..--
!M/MITE - CITV GLERK � - ---'
PINK � F�NANCE ��. . .- .
CANARV -OEPARTMENT
BLUE - Mq�rOR CITY OF
City Attny/JTH INT PAUL �O��i1 p
�� File N 0. O � ���
Presen � Ce
ted�By � Ordinance N O.
�
/iP�eferred To`` ' � �� `
Out of Committee gy Committee: Date �-��-�f p�
d !
Date
An administrati e ordinance enacti
�eplacement housi ng a
p�`ocedures for it g P°licy and providing
\
' plementation, �t
THE CO�TN(;IL OF THE C�
�Y OF SAINT A DOES ORDAIN;
� �� Sec io 1 , ,
Section A� �1 Inte t.
is in the public interest The i y of Saint Paul finds that '
of an adequate su ° promo e the it
rental housin p�ly of de ent Production and .
g for low-incom ' S ni ary, safe and affordableVation �;C
effect a polic resi en s . The Cit � x'� �
rental housin y and roced r wher b Y desires to
g due to a Cit Y the potential loss of such y► � � '{
reviewed in relation to y a sis d develo ment b
housin the ove all s p ProJect will be �,p� ,
g in the City; and, where �°p1Y of affordable rental
mination of the Cit P� o riate,
be developed to re la��uncil of t e Cit based upon the deter- �� �'�
the current needs of e lost renta y °f St • Pau1V'a plan will ti��
the Cit ' ho sing with housin 1
y s low in ome residents , g that meets �
g�
Sectio ,s�
Section 93 . p2 Definitions .
$� .
�a) Affordable Rental Housin ,�
units w ic : �e�idential rental
a have no b er� vacant for housing
two years : (b) are a le a more than
gross rents now or g Z ni use; and �
months which are nottmore 1 e 1 the previous twelve
h n 30'�percent of 60
� percent
COUNCIL MEMBERS �� \\
Yeas Nays '
Dimond Req est d by Departr�ent of:
Long
G°S"''r� —� In Favor
Rettman
Scheibel '+
Sonnen --� Against `
Wilson BY �
Adopted by Council: �`ti
Date Form pp ved b '
Certified Passed b Y City Atto; ey
y Council Secretary
By BY v
�il
Approved by Mayor: Date
By Approv Mayor for Submission to Council
By
� ,
S�o��° ate
SpQ�y°o � �e��c9
b9 �vnG,,• �c,1 Sec \\
CP
�. � Q�� ��gea�dy � � ,
,.� ��E�ea 4 O9te
o�:
8`I a�Ma`J
o�e
PQQc
8y
. . �� . � � . �, � � ;� � ����-��v
��� -z-
:,�
��
�.
ty'
4t
of the metrop litan st tistical area median as such
income may be por ed by the U.S . Department of
Housing and Urba D ve opment ("MSA Median Income") ,
adjusted for fami. si e. (Please see Exhibit A for
1989 rent threshol . )
(b) Affordable Rents . r s rents which are not more than
30 percent o 60 pe ce of the MSA Median Income.
-(c) Agency. Any depart en o division of the City of
Saint Paul, the Por A tho ' ty of the City of Saint
Paul, or the Housin a d Re velopment Authority.
(d) Cit Assisted Pro' e t. A hous g, commercial , office
or in ustria real st te devel ment project in which
the City provides f n cial assi ance or aid in
securing public fin n 'al assistan e including federal
grant administered y the City, an City revenue bond
financing, tax incr m t financing, ax levy, or
revenues controlled b the City, exce t , however ,
projects which eith r: (a) have a valu� of less than
$1, 000, 000, or (b) e ults in a loss o five or fewer
Affordable Rental H u ing units shall no e con-
sidered "City Assis e Projects" for the �urposes of
this ordinance . '0,
,
:
(e) Director. Director m ans the Director, Depar�ment of
Planning and Econo ' c Development . �
``�
�
S ction 3 .
Section 93 . 03 Procedur f r an Affordable Rental Housin `'•,
Analysis . `
(a) Pre aration of an ff rdable Rental �Iousin Anal sis .
Prior to action y t Counci o t e City o Saint
Paul (the "City Co nc 1") to approve financial assistance
. . � � ; � � . . . � �.�i 7foo
-3-
� to a City Assisted P oj ct, which includes either
��, the demolition or th nversion of Affordable
Rental Housing, the e shall be prepared by the
`, agency proposing the Pr ject , an Affordable Rental
'`•Housing Analysis (th " nalysis") . The Analysis
shall include:
(1) . A description o t e number of total rental
' units , includin fordable Rental Housing
units , to be de ol' shed or converted to a
different use i cl ding the following
in�ormation:
(i) number o b drooms
(ii) ', current on ract rent
(iii) '�init siz ( quare feet)
(2) A statemei^l,t of ur ent vacancy rates and market
rents for �:enta u its of similar size in the
City of Sair'iRt P ul .
(3) A statement o��; he number of Affordable Rental
Housing units p od ced in the City of Saint
Paul from Janua � , 198$ , through the date of
the Analysis .
(4) A statement of he ��umber of Affordable Rental
Housing units 1 st 'i� the City of Saint Paul
as a result of it A�sisted Projects from
January l , 1988 th oug�� the date of the Analysis .
°�
(5) A statement of he net g�;in or loss of Afford-
able Rental Hou in units�. based upon items
Number 3 and 4 bo e . `"�
(6) A statement reg rd ng whether the proposed City
Assisted Projec i consisten't with the Saint
Paul Comprehens 've Plan. '`
. , . : ��, 7�a
-4-
�
'\�(b) Review of the Afford bl Rental Housin Anal sis . �
T e Ana ysis s a b r viewed by the Director in
��., Section 93 . 03(a) in rd r to ensure that the items
�';, are addressed. The ir ctor`s review shall also
'�include, but not be im ted to : (1) a summary of
the recent progress ad by the City in meeting
�,ts current goals fo t e production and preser-
v�.tion of Affordable Re tal Housing as such goals
ar`� set forth within th annual housing production
plai�; filed with the it Clerk by the Director by,
or na:t later than, J nu ry 31 of each year, and
such ather nolicies s ay from time to time be
adopte�,, by the City; an (2) an assessment of
current '`��narket condi io s as they may relate to
the cost `'�of developi g dditional Affordable
Rental Ho�ising.
(c) Recommendati'e�n for A fo dable Housin Plan. The �
�Director s a t en a a recommen ation to the
City Council/�r��;gardi g ow the potential loss of
Affordable Rent�,l Ho si g due to the City Assisted
Project relates �o t e verall supply of and demand
for Affordable Reri�a H using in the City. If it
is determined that '� e ffordable Rental Housing to
be lost should be re" la ed, the/�Di:rector shall so
state and shall furt A�� identify the type of
Affordable Rental Ho s�= g which should be developed
(size of unit, numbe o F:, units , target market , time
period for developme t, �hich in no event shall be
longer than three ye rs a��er the commencment of
demolition or conver io o�`�.�the Affordable Rental
Housing units to be os due`�,to the City Assisted
Proj ect) . The°1Direc or shall'��make a recommendation
to replace units to e ost du� to a City Assisted
Proj ect when any of he followii'�g circumstances are
present: ��•
���
(1) If the Affordab e ental Hous��ng Analysis
shows that ther h s been a ne'� loss of
Affordable Rent l ousing units``�, or
(2) If (i) the type of Affordable Reri�al Housing
units related t t e proposed Cit�., Assisted
Project are cur en ly the type of units �ahich
the City has de er ined, through it's housing
. ., . � . . . . ���'`7�'�
-5-
production and r servation goals , to be
needed in the C t ; and (ii) the number
of units to be os due to the proposed
City Assisted P oj ct equals or exceeds
``� twenty units ; o
(��� If Affordable R nt l Housing is lost due to
an activity whi h ' s directly funded from:
�`�. (i) the Communi y evelopment Block Grant
$ntitlement Pro r,a ; or (ii) the Section
1`b,8 Loan Guaran ee Program; or (iii) the
Url�n Developme t ction Grant Program, on
or a���ter Septem er 30, 1988 .
(d) Affordable' ousin R u rements . In recommending a plan (
to replace A ordabl R ntal Housing units to be lost due
to a City Assi�ted P oj ct, the Director shall propose
means by which �`�he r pl cement housing will be :
�,
(1) located �aith�,n he City of Saint Paul or East
Metro Region i�. a anner consistent with the
City' s adopted ' ou ing Assistance Plan and
nei�hborhood re v lopment plans .
�,
(2) sufficient in n b and size (number of
bedrooms) to ho se a�� least the same number
of occupants as co lc�n�,have been, under local
codes , housed i A fordable Rental Housing
units which will b los'�,;
,
(3) provided in sta a d cond�tion, including com-
pliance with all a plicabl�, housing and building
codes ; �'�,
''f�
(4) affordable renta ousing uni�� for at least ten
(10) years from h date of inY,tial occupancy;
(5) either newly con t ucted or reha�;ilitated.
The�[Director shall fu t er set forth estimates of the
total cost to develop t e replacement housing which is
being recommended and a y subsidy cost . Subsidy cost
. . . . . � � � ��7�°
-6-
, is defined as total r acement housi development
��. and o P �r;r� cost m' u costs which can be financed
by an amortizing loa a d/or costs which can be paid
'` by private equity do la s .
Se tion 4.
Section 93__._04 A roval o R lacement Housin Plan.. The
City Counci711sha11 have t e i a responsi i ity or approving,
amending, or rejecting the/lDir ct r' s recommendations .
If the City Council�ldeter in s that the Affordable Rental
Housing units to be `].ost shoul b replaced, adequate funds
to pay for the total 'developme t ost, including any subsidy
cost of the replacement units , sh 11 be identified and approved
by the Agency proposing''the Ci y ssisted Project prior to City
Councilnaction approving''=the p oj ct .
S tion 5 .
Section 93. 05 Im lementa -i of Re lacement Housin Plan.
Upon approval of both a plan a c1 inancing or replacement
housing units , the Director sh 1 , oversee and monitor the
implementation of the plan.
/` S c t i�an 6 .
This ordinance shall take e fect ar�.d be in force thirty (30)
days from and after its passag , approva� and publication. City
WHITE �- CITV CIERK COIl(1C11 /�,
PINK - FINANCE /
CANARV -OEPARTMENT GITY OF INT PAiTL K/D
BIUE -MAVOR File NO. �- �
•
Or n nce Ordinance N0.
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
Out of,Committee By Date
-7-
assisted projects which have b e approved by the City Council
prior to its �effective date sh 11 not be subject to the provisions
of this ordinance .
,
`�
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of:
Dimond
��g In Favor
Goswitz
Rettman
�he;beQ Against BY
Sonnen
Wilson
Form Approv City Attor y
Adopted by Council: Date �
Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY �
By
Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By BY
. .
_ . ,_
_ _ ,., .
- . ,�' _
.. wr��Te��:- c�Tr. cLEftK . . . . . . � � � � ,:k ,
PINW
� CIJNARV -DEP RCTMENT �� � . . :. . � . . � :...� �.� CO1l1IC1L t �r-^ }r� �
.BLUE -MAVOR G�ITY OF IN��PAUL ` � File NO. �� � �` �� .
, . �
� Or i dnce � �inance N O.
. �
�cesent�d By :
� Referred To Committee: Date
Out of Committee By Date
; � __ .
, .._ .._
_ ,.
-� � "�'�' , t
;1 �
� �
� '. r
'i
j
�s�L'#t� �.���l� #� 1lJ�'IA �"�Z�O^I/� �?'�t "t�i! C3.�jr �� ;
p�iar t�o '�1�s +a!`f�ctiv�s dste _ �at be s+�b�s�*t to t�a pst;s3a��aas . ;�
,s of �his .
:,
,,
. _ � .
,..
�s
�� ,�. �r.
� �
, - . . . � . . � ' . �f�.
. .. . . . . . l;�
. ` . . . . . . . '
`.
. � � . .. � � . :5
. .. . . ... � , . . { �-.
} :'.
i',
'-:1
. y-'
. COUNCIL �IEMBERS = � ° : " "
Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: #
Dimond _
�08 �[1 e'aVOi
Goswitz
_ Itettman ' • .
;` s�n�ne� Against By
,' sonnen
Wilson
� orm Approved by City Attorney .
�opted by Council: Date . '¢ � �X`,�
�
Certified Passed by Councal Secretary BY ��" '
By
Approved by Mayor: Date pproved by�Mayor for Submission to Council
_,�,,.
. . By
' � � • �l �` 7cO U
. • ' � . � . . . � � �-,,,�,L� ,a.�.,e.,,,.,-�-�
V�2 C.o l.�w�GkIX e-G�
a�-k 5' �IDI ��
I� �� Cfo u.�.w�,1}-e e._
wc-c.�-� '
�
An administr.ative o di ance enacting a
''�, replacement housing o 'cy and providing
`�., procedures for its ' p mentation.
�
THE COUNCIL OF�'T�HE CITY OF SAINT PAUL OE ORDAIN:
`�.
�`�
Sect on 1.
Section 93.01 I�tent. The City f aint Paul finds that it �
is in the public intere�t to promote t e roduction and preservation of an
adequate suppl,;y of decei�t, sanitary, af and affordable rental housing
for low�income residents. The City de ir s to effect a policy and procedure
whereby the potential loss c�� such ren al housing due to a City assisted
development project will be r�piewed i r lation to the overall supply of
affordable rental housing in th�`e� City; an , where appropriate, based upon
the determination of the City Coii�cil f he City of Saint Paul a plan will
be developed to replace lost renta�,, ho si g with housing that meets the
current needs of the City's low inc� re idents.
Sec iQ 2.
��
Section 93.02 Definitions. �
(a) Affordable Reatal Hous ng Re�idential rental housing
units which: (1) have no been'�vacant for more than two
years; (2) are a legal zo ing use��; and (3) have gross
rents now or at any t' e n the pi�vious twelve months
which are not more tha 3 percent � 60 percent of the
� I� ' .� . � � - . �- � ���- 7l�
metro litan statistic 1 rea median as such income may
be repo ted by the U. , epartment of Housing and
Urban De lopment ("MS M dian Income") , adjusted
for family size. (Ple se see Exhibit A for 1989 rent
thresholds.
v
(b) Affordable Ren'ts. Gro s ents which are not more than
30 percent of 6�, perce t f the MSA Median Income.
(c) Agency. Any departmen o division of the City of Saint
Paul; t�te i�er� t}��}���� � � �}�e 6��� e€ 6s��� gg�}; er ��te
�Fe�s�ag sae� �e�e�e�e�ffi a� ��i�e����.
(d) City Assisted Project. A ousing, commercial, office or
industrial real estate de lopment project in which the City;
�F�A e� Se#a� �a�} �er� e3 e�g�� provides financial assistance
or aid in securing pub ic inancial assistance including any
federal grant a�in,�'st ed by the City, er any egeae�* er �e��
esa�e� ��s eea���,''*Cit re e�ue bond financing, tax increment
financing, tax levies, un s''�r revenues controlled by the Se�a�
- g$�� ge�� ����e����* e� i�e Ci,ty, e� �}�e �sse�er�es e€ ea�r �e��
eb��gs��ea e� seer����� � �� e.�eae� e� �e��► ee��re��e� ��* �i�e
6���; except, however, ro ects'which e��i�e�: (1) have a value
of Iess than $1,000,000 0 (2) esult in a loss of five or
fewer Affordable Rental Ho sing u its; or (3) are
provided to individuals fo urcha e, remodeling, or
renovation of single fa il dwellin s; shall not be considered
"City Assisted Projects ' f r the pur oses of this ordinance.
(e) Director. Director mea s he Directo Department of
Planning and Economic D ve opment.
(f) Publicly Assisted Pro'e t. A housing, c ercial, office
or industrial real esta e_ evelo ment ro ect in which
the Saint Paul Housing nd Redevelo ment A thorit , Port
Authoritv or Public. Hou in A enc provide financial
assistance including an r enue bond finan in , tax
increment financing, ta 1 or revenues co trolled �
the Authority or A enc , o � ro'ect which is not a
City Assisted Pro'ect rs nt to Section 93.02 (d) (1)
or (d) (2) , above. Fin c' 1 assistance provided to
individuals for urchas , r modelin , or renovation of
sin le family dwellings ha 1 not be considered "Publicly
Assisted Projects" for e ur oses of this ordinance.
Secti n .
Section 93.03 Procedure for an Af or able Rental Housing Analysis.
(a) Preparation of an Afford bl Rental Housing Analysis.
Prior to action by the C un il of the City of Saint
Paul (the "City Council" t approve financial assistance
. '� �� _� . .� , � , � . : ��-�� 7�
�� a City Assisted Pro'ec �which includes either
the� emolition or the on ersion of Affordable
- Renta Housing, there ha 1 be prepared by the �
agency oposing the oj ct, an Affordable Rental
Housing A lysis (the An lysis") . . The Analysis
shall inclu
(1) A descript'on of he umber of total rental
units, incl ing ff rdable Rental Housing
units, to be emo is d or converted to a
different use c ud' g the following
inf o rma t'_on:
�i) aumber of ed ooms
(ii) current e e� ross rent
(iii) unit size (sq ,,are feet)
,,�
(2) A statement of cu en `�acancy rates and market
rents for rental u it of, similar size in the
City of Saint Paul
(3) A statement of the nu ber of',tAffordable Rental
Housing units prod ce in the ,City of Saint
Paul froa January , 188 1989;. through the date of the
Analysis. '.�
�
(4) A statement of the nu ber of Affordable Rental
Housing units Iost in the City of Saint Paul
as a result of Cit A isted and Pub�icly
Assisted Projects ro January 1, ��38&., 1989,
through the date o t Analysis. �
,`l
(5) A statement of the et gain or loss of Afi�ordable
Rental Housing uni , ased upon items Num�r 3
and 4 above. �;�
(6) A statement regardi g hether the proposed Cit�
Assisted Project is co sistent with the Saint ��
Paul Comprehensive la . `�
�
(b) Review of the �ffordable Re tal Housing Analysis. `�•
The Analysis in Section 3. 3 (a) shall be reviewed by tH�e
Director in order to ens re that the items are addressed. `�, The
Director's review shall ls include, but not be limited ta:
(1) a summar� of the re en progress made by the %
City in meeting its cu ent goals for the production
and preservation of Af rdable Rental Housing as
such goals are set or within the annual housing
production plan fil 'th the City Clerk by the
Director by, or not at r than, January 31 of each
year, and such othe po icies as may from time to
ti.me be adopted by t e ity; and
, •
• - � .� . _ � . • , � ��y� ��d
(2) an assessment of ur ent market conditions as they
may relate to the co t of developing additional
Affordable Rental Ho sing.
tThe annual housing r du tion lan, to the extent
�-readily ascertainable w 11 include the net number of
tAffordable Rental Hou in units ained or lost �
rprivate action.
(c) Recommendati for Aff rd ble Housing Plan. The
Director shall hen ma e recommendation to the
City Council rega ding ho the potential loss of
Affordable Rental us'ng due to the City Assisted
Project relates to t ov rall supply of and demand
for Affordable Rental u ing in the City. If it
is determined that the A ordable Rental Housing to
be lost should be repl ce the Director shall so
state and shall furthe i e tify the type of
Affordable Rental Hous'ng wh h should be developed
(size of unit, number f nits target ma.rket, time
period for development, w ich i no event shall be
longer than three year a ter th commencment of
demolition or convers' n f the A ordable Rental
Housing units to be lo t ue to the City Assisted
Project) . The Directo s all make a recommendation
to replace unis to be os due to a C y Assisted
Project when anp of t f llowing cire stances are
present:
�1) If the Affordable Re tal Housing Anal�sis
shows that there as been a net loss of,,
Affordable Renta Ho sing units; or �'`,
�
(2) If (i) the type A fordable Rental Housing
units related to he proposed City Assisted
Project are curr tl the type of units which
the City has det i ed, through its housing
production and p se vation goals, to be . -
` needed in the Ci ; nd (ii) the number
of units to be 1 t ue to the proposed
City Assisted Pr 'ec equals or exceeds
twenty units; or
(3) If Affordaole Re tal Housing is lost due to '',�
an activitp whic is directly funded from:
(i) the Communit De elopment Block Grant ``�
Entitlement Prog m; or (ii) the Section
108 Loan Guarant e ogram; or (iii) the
Urban Developmen A ion Grant Program, on
or after Septemb r 3 , 1988.
The Director mav reco e an Affordable Housing Plan
for a City Assisted P o ' t in circumstances other than
those recited in (1) , (2) or (3) above, if, in his/her
determination other c're stances relating to the City
- '� � - . . _ � . . : : �%���� y�d
� - -
Assisted Pro'ect exist hi h indicate that an Affordable
Housing Plan should be on idered in connection with the
project. — —
�d) Affordable Housing Requ re ents. In recommending a plan
to replace Affordable R nt 1 Housing units to be lost due
a City Assisted Proj ct the Director shall propose
me s by which the repl ce ent housing will be:
��} } s�e� w��i��s ��e 6� � e€ 8e�rc� �s�s� e� �ss� P4e��a �eg�ea
'�� sa � eeas�s�ea� #� �i�e 6���*'e a�eg�e� He�s#ag
As� snee �sn ane ae� i�� i�ee� �e�e�e�e�mer�� ��sas-
(� 1) suffici t in nu e and size (number of
bedrooms) house t east the same number
of occupants'�s co d ave been, under local
codes, housed�Af or able Rental Housing
units which wil be lo t;
4
`j
�3 2) provided in stan rd condition, including com—
pliance with all ap �li able housing and building
codes; �
(4 3) Affordable Rental Ho s.ing units for at least ten
(10) years from the da e 'of initial occupancy;
(3 4) either newly cons ru ted `or rehabilitated.
The Director shal.l furth r et forth estimates of the
total cost to develop th r placemet�t housing which is
being recommended and an s bsidy co�t. Subsidy cost
is defined as total repl ce ent housing development
and operating cost minus co ts which c�n be financed
' by an amortizing loan an /o costs whicti., can be paid
by private equitp dollar .
Secti 4. ''�,
:�
Section 93.04 Approval of Replace nt Housing Plan. The City
Council shall have the final responsibi 'ty for approving, ameilding,
or rejecting the Director's reco�endati ns
`;
If the City Council. determines that th Affordable Rental Hoi�sing
units to be lost should be replaced, ade ua e funds to pay for the �total
development cost, including any subsidy os of the replacement unit�,
shall be identified and approved bv the ge cy proposing the City \
Assisted Project prior to City Council a ti n approving the project. �
�
Sectio 5 �
Section 93.05 Implementation of Re la ement Housing Plan.
Upon approval of both a plan and financi g or replacement housing
units, the Director shall overs2e and mo it r the implementation of the
• � ' - -
� . " . � • . ' , � ' ' � ��''�` 7�od
Sec io 6.
Section 93.06 Sur lus Production; us ension of Ordinance Requirements.
In � ear in which the annual hou in production lan referred to in
Section 93.03 (b) hereof indicates ha there are sufficient units of
Affordable Rental Housing of all t es, then the provisions of this
ordinance shall be suspended until he ubmission of the subsequent annual
housing production lan under Secti 9 .03 (b) .
Se ti n 7.
This ordinance shall ta,ke effec a d be in force thirty (30) days
from and after its passage, approval an publication. City Assisted
Projects which have been appro�d by th City Council prior to its
effective date shall not be subj�a�ct o he provisions of this
ordinance. °��
EXHIBIT A. AFFORDABLE S BY BEDROOM SIZE: 1989
Maximum
Bedroom Size Monthly Gross Rent
SRO �
�,� $332
EFF ��� 444
1BR 444
2BR 507
3BR �;, 571
4BR �'� 634
�,
,y�
,�
�
�
. - � . - � � � � �-�i-7(v
' _ - , ' " � Members:
� ,--. .'� Biil Wiison, chair
' GITY OF NT PAUL Tom Dimond
� �x`"""'"' ` . Kiki Sonnen �
�� s�3� ;
OFFICE OF TFI ITY COIINCIL
. Date: May 10, 1989
WILLIAM L. WILSON � Commi e Report MARK VOERDING
COUnCilmaII Legislative Aide
To: Saint Paul City Councii
From : Housing and Econo ic Development Committee
Bili Wilson, Chair
1. Approval of Minutes
Minutes of APRIL 12, 1989, meeting er APPROVED.
2. Ordinance amending the Legislative od by adding a new chapter pertaining
to replacement housing (C.F. 89-54 )
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED WITHDRAWAL 0 TA ORDINANCE
3. Resolution establishing policy stat me t pertaining to replacement housing �
(C.F. 89-662)
COirIl�'IITTEE RECOMMENDED WITHDRAWAL OF TH RESOLUTION
. Administrative Ordinance enacting a re lacement housing policy and �
providing procedures for its implem nt tion (C.F. 89-760)
CUIrHriiTTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL, WI NDMENTS
(amended ord�nance attached)
SUSPENSION ITEM:
Resolution asking the HRA and Port ut ority to consider adopting
replacement housing policies and pr ce ures
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL
(original resolution and green shee a tached)
� 5. Resolution amending the 1989 budget by adding $9,000 to the Financing &
Spending Plans for PED to hire cons lt nt to conduct intensive survey of
the Lower Bluff and Swede Hollow ar as to determine eligibility for
possible national regist2r and/.or 1 ca heritage preservation district '
designation. (C.F. 89-498)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL
- CONTNUD -
CITY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR AI T PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 612l298-4646
g 6
� � � . � �� ���
COMMITTEE REPORT - Housing and Economic Development Committee
May 10, 1989
Page Two
6. Resolution supporting the location of future state office expansion to be
in and near the Capitol area and central core, requesting City
administration work with state officials to foster said expansion into the
targeted area and requesting the State to formally establish policy giving
priority consideration to locating state offices in the target area
(C.F. 89-572)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED LAYOVER
7. Resolution amending the CDBG Years XI and XII programs by transferring
$288,000 from Year XII Rental Rehabilitation to Year XI Housing
Development Opportunity for the acquisition of property for low income
rental housing (C.F. 89-664)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL
8. Approval of Revenue Bond Issue for General Pump/U.S. Inc.
Referred by Port Authority 4/26/89
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL
(original resolution attached)
_ . � . . , � _ ���`��a
COMMITTEE REPORT
Page Two
Housing and Economic Development Co it e
Meeting Date: June 28, 1989
the St. Paul Civic Center for hl tic events, and requesting the Mayo'r
to form an ad hoc committee of ep esentatives as listed to study the
feasibility of cooperation with th U of M to host hockey games
(C.F. 89-946)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL
7. Hearing to consider the Appeal f aurel Ann March to a Summary
Abatement Order for property lo te at 230-240 Dale
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED TO DENY T E PPEAL AND TO PROCEED WITH THE
ASSESSMENT
8. Appeal of Charles Rafferty to a de ision of the Heritage Preservation
Commission regarding the west w ng of Gillette Hospital located at
1003 E. Ivy Street
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED THE APPEA B LAID OVER IN COMMITTEE UNTIL AFTER
AUGUST 31, 1989, AND THAT IT AL 0 E REFERRED TO THE HERITAGE
PRESERVATION COMMISSION FOR FUR HE ACTION
9. Resolution requesting the HRA a d ort Authority consider and adopt
replacement housing policies si il r to St. Paul' s (C.F. 89-867)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL
__ - _.
______ _
_. ___ --
10. Ordinance enacting the replacem t ousing policy and providing
procedures for its implementati (C.F. 89-760)
CO1�Il�IITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL ________..-_...____�_
.»______---.__,..____----
11. Resolution to bring city to comp ia ce with the new state law on
replacement housing (C.F. 89-1 38
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED WITHDRAWA OF THE RESOLUTION
12. Ordinance amending Section 189.0 ( ) of the Legislative Code pertaining
to Truth in Housing forms and re ui ing a zoning classification
(C.F. 89-1045)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED AN INDEFIN TE LAYOVER IN COMMITTEE, PENDING A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
, . r , ' �����d
•Mem6ers: -
CITY OF SAINT PAUL Bili Wiison, chair
�����► ��n Tom Dimond
��� �� �
OFFICF OF THE CITY COIINCIL Kiki Sonnen
Date:
WILLIAM L. WILSON Committee Repor� RECEIVED MARK VOERDING
COUnCiiman Legisiative Aide
JUN 2 91989 �
To: Saint Paul City Council ci�rY c�EK�c �
From : Housing and Eco o ' Development Committee
Bill Wilson, Chair
l. Approval of Minutes
MINUTES of the MAY 10, 1989, committee meeting were APPROVED.
2. Consent to issuance of $2,890,000 tax exempt Port Authority revenue
bonds for Source, Inc.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL OF PROPOSED RESOLUTION (original
resolution and green sheet attached)
3. Summary presentation on Economic Development Strategy
COMMITTEE RECOrSMENDED APPROVAL OF THE PROPOSED REVIEW PROCESS
(no Council action required)
4. Approval of bonds for COPCO, sublease to Colder Products Company
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL OF PROPOSED RESOLUTION (original
resolution and green sheet attached)
5. Resolution accepting the Near East Side Neighborhood Improvement
Strategy, requesting the shorter list of priority strategies be
incorporated into the City' s Administration' s work program, requesting
said Strategy be used as background information for updating the
Comprehensive Plan and to evaluate private development proposals to
guide city and neighborhood action and investments on the Near East Side
(C.F. 89-844)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL, AS AMENDED
(map clarifications listed on attached sheet)
6. Resolution supporting the position of Governor Perpich pertaining to the
U of M sports facilities, encouraging the continued and expanded use of
CI'TY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 � 612/298-4646
9�48
t -
... .. . .. _ .. _
. -:. _ . , ��. :.; .... -
�.:. .A . .. . . : . . .:: '
_ . - " - _ - '1 .
a
_ - �1st 7 �y� � _ . _ .. .
_ �2nd
-,.
3rd '
Adopted
, _
� Yeas
�- ' D� Nays
y_ t �..� j V/ O � 7W /
- _ {
-; Nxcos2A
X ?` � xE���v
,
�
SCHEIBEL
- � S ON\TEN
_ 5-;� .
_ ;
�
WILSO�T
# t - - �a 4r�IpA
- - - ` RSIDENT: '
� ��
��` �
r;=,
( - fY _ -
. _
.. �. ., -: ...,.
. .
!.•.. l. .� , -' :. J'. . �". . �'.'. -
_ - _ l