The URL can be used to link to this page

89-316 WHITE�. - CITY CLERK PINK - FI '4NCE GITY OF SAINT PAUL Council BLUERY - MA�ORTMENT File NO. I _�� City Attny/PBB CD �cil R�es lution Presented By r � � `� Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date RESOLVED, that all of the lice ses , including on-sale and Sunday on-sale intoxicating liquor and restaurant, issued for the Pacific Garden �testaurant at 3 8 St. Peter Street , are hereby suspended for a period of thirty ( 0) days , but said suspension is stayed for six months under the terms , conditions and require- ments set forth in the Report of t e Administrative Law Judge which is attached; and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the R port of the ALJ dated January 25 , 1989, with its Findings of Fact, onclusions of Law, Recommenda- tions and Memorandum, is expressl ratified and adopted as the written findings and conclusions f the Council with four ex- ceptions : first, that Finding of Fact No . 12 is deleted in its entirety; second, that Recommend tion No . 6 be amended to read as follows : "6 . If at the end af he period of the stay of imposition, the City C uncil finds that the license holder has not achieved a satisfactory level of compliance, o that a se arate vio- lation has occurred e�7�` t ..in t e erio o t e sta , the thirty 3�` �.�v suspension m�_ a��.in��.. t e iscretion of the Council be im osed in accordance with the r uirements of due rocess . ; " third, that Recommendation No . 5-C be amended to require a three- month report by the Division o Public Health as well as a six- month final report; and fourth that the Council may in its c�iscretion impose the thirty, ( 0) day suspension after the six- rnonth period of the stay hag e pired and need not commence or complete any actions in tha� r gard within the six-month period. COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Dimond �ng In Favo soswitz Rettman B Scheibel A gai n s t Y Sonnen Wilson Form Ap oved by Cit Attorney Adopted by Council: Date _ � 2 /ri /iL Certified Passed by Council Secretary B9 ' I ( 7l7 gy, A►pproved by A4avor: Date Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council gy By WHITE - CITV CLERK PINK � - FFNANCE COUflCll �j BI.UERV - MA�V�ORTMENT GITY OF S INT PAUL File NO. „ / �� Council; esolution Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date � -2- This Resolution is based o the record of proceedings before the Administrative Law Judge , i cluding the hearing on January 13 , 1989, the documents and exhibiit introduced therein, the arguments and statements of counsel for t e parties on February 14, 1989, and the deliberation of the Cou cil in open session. The Report of the ALJ is attached hereto a d is expressly incorporated in and made a part of this Resolut on. A copy of this Resolution, as adopted, shall be sent by first class mail to the Administrati e Law Judge, and to counsel for the licenseholder. COUNCIL MEMBERS Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays � Dimond Long In Favo Goswitz Rettmar-� B sche;n�� Against y Sonnea�' Wilson ��g � ;� �g89 Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date . _ 2 -�5��' Certified Yas y Council S a By � sy Appro e by IVIa r. _ �� L 1 ��`� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council � ��n�--� BY �1� i'��l�R - 1989 � f 9-3�.� ' 62-21U1-2972-6 STATE F MINNESOTA OFFICE OF ADM NISTRATIVE HEARINGS FOR THE ITY OF ST . PAUL In the matter of FINDINGS OF FACT, the Restaurant License CONCLUSIONS, AND of the Pacific Garden, INC, RECOMMENDATION d/b/a Pacific Garden Restaurant . The above-entitled matter came on for hearing before Richard k. Mosman , Administrative La � Judge , on January 13 , �9�9 , 9 :00 a .m. , Fourth Floor, St . Paul ublic Library, St . Paul , � Nlinnesota . The record closed on Janua y 20 , 1989 upon receipt of post hearing documents filed by th City of St . Paul . Philip Byrne , Assistant City Attorney , appeared on behalf of the City of St . Paul and th Department of Community Services , Division of Public Health . J hn E . Daubney , Esquire , appeared on � behalf of the Licensee , Pacif c Garden , Inc , d/b/a Pacific Garden Restaurant . The St . Paul City Counci and the Administrative Law Judge has jurisdiction in this mat er pursuant to MSA s . 14 .50 and St . Paul Legislative Code s . 310.0 & 310 .06 . ISSUE Whether the license ho der has operated the Pacific Garden Restaurant in violation of S . Paul Legislative Code s .331 , Food License , during the period ebruary 11 , 1g87 to December 28 , 19$8 ; and if so , whether the restaurant license should be revoked, subject to fine , conditions , suspended, and if suspended, for what period of time . FINDI GS OF FACT 1 . This matter was origi ally scheduled for hearing December 22, 1988 , by Notice to the license holder dated November 25 , 198fi . By Stipulation of the parties , the hearing was continued in an Interim rder dated December 27 , 1988 , with terms that incorporated t at Stipulation . 2 . On January 3, �9�9 the St . Paul City Council under authority of Section 310 05 (a) St. Paul Legislative Code , eleeted to initiate a he ring regarding the Pacific Garden , Inc , d/b/a Pacific Gard n Restaurant , the license holder herein . By Stipulation f the parties, further notice was waived, the hearing sche uled and held on January 13 , 1989, in the St . Paul Public Li rary, St . Paul , Minnesota . 3 . The license holder o ns and has operated since 1982 the - 1- �1= 8�-v/G. � Pacific Garden Restaurant which is located in the Lowry , Building , 338 St. Peter S reet , St . Paul , Minnesota . The establishment has both a 1 quor license and a food license and is open six ( 6) days a eek. The bar is open only during periods the restaurant is o en . 4 . I-Ming Lai , and his wi e , Esther Lai , are the principle shareholders and operators f the Pacific Uarden Restaurant . They have no other busines . Between them, they do nearly all of the food preparation and personally supervise on a daily basis all aspects of he restaurant operation . Mr . Lai has had food handlers training prior to 1982 . 5 . Between February 11 , 19t's7, and December 2$ , 1985 , the Pacific Garden has been subject to thirteen ( 13 ) separate on- site inspectioris by the Cit of St . Paul , Division of Public Health . There were other contacts between the inspectors and the license holder in addi ion to the on-site inspections , relating to corrections and conditions at the restaurant . 6. Deficiencies or viol�tions of St. Paul Legislative Code s . 331 were found on all ' nspections performed during the period cited . 7. On four (4) occasions the establishment was scored according to a method estab ished by the State of Minnesota Department of Public Health . The system has a 0-100 range and is weighted accordin to the seriousness of the deficiency found with the d ficiencies scored and subtracted from 100 . The scores obta ned by the establishment are as follows : DATE SCORE 11/8/88 - $9 6/7/8� - 7� 11/3/87 - 85 2/ 11/iS7 - 65 8. On all on-site inspections made at the establishment , inspectors found evidence o cockroaches on the premises , a violation of St. Paul Legis ative Code s . 331 . 18 , Insect and Rodent Control . 9 . The license holder ha had since 198�4 a professional licensed pest control com any on contract. They have regularly sprayed the premi es at intervals of once to four times per month. The lic nse holder has personally used insect fog bombs to suppleme t the professional spraying done on the premises. 10 . The establishment is locateci on two (2) floors of the Lowry Building, the first loor and a storage room in the basement . The storage room as a door leading to common area outside of its leased premis s . C� 84-3l� " 11 . In one instance , Ma 20 , 1987, the inspector noted that in connection witn the s raying for cockroaches , the license holder should also weath rstrip the storage room door leading outside of the leased pr mises . 12. There are common reas within the Lowry Building that are adjacent to the fo d service areas leased by this and other license holders in the Lowry Building that show evidence of cockroach in estation . 13 . The license holder consistently took corrective action � and follow up inspectio s consistently showed corrections or "abatement" had been d ne on previously noted deficiencies . This includes calls to he exterminating company immediately upon notification that the inspector had found evidence of the presence of cockro ches . The license holder has also made efforts to seal cr cks and openings both in the storage room and in public plac s in the restaurant . 14 . During the time p riod of February 11 , 1987 to December 28, 198$ , there have b en numerous violations noted relative to the thawing method, anitation , and temperature control of food, both stored and prepared, all violations of St. Paul Legislative Code s . 331 . 11 ( 6) , Food Protection . 15 . The license holde has in place a cleaning schedule and plan to be used by th kitchen, bar and waitress personnel . . Cleaning is done twice a day both in the kitchen and the public area. 16. I-Ming Lai is the only employee who has had food. handling training. 17 . The are other food service lieenses located in the Lowry Building. CONCLUSIO NS 1 . The St. Paul City Council and the Administrative Law Judge has jurisdictio in this matter pursuant to MSA s . 14 .50 and St. Paul Legislat ve Code s . 310 .05 & 310 .06 . 2 . The City of t. Paul has fulfilled all relevant substantive and proce ural requirements of law and rule . 3. The license hol er is licensed by the City of St. Paul for on sale liquo as well as food establishment in accordance with St . Paul Legislative Code s . 331 ; and the license holder is, herefore , required to comply with the said Code relating t food licenses. 4. The City of St. aul has proved by a preponderance of the evidence that on n merous occasions between February 11 , ' 19$7, and December 2 , 19�8 , the license holder had violated . the St . Paul Legisla ive Code s . 331 . 11 and 331 . 18 relating to -3- �" �-3/G the operation of a food serv' ce establishment . 5 . As a result of these vio ations over this period of time , some disciplinary action is ecessary. Based upon the foregoing F ndings ot Fact and Conclusions , the Administrative Law Judge mak s the following: RECOMMENDATIONS IT IS HEREBY RECOMMENDED that the City Council take disciplinary action against the license holder as follows : 1 . That a condition be placed upon the license of the Pacific Garden , Inc , to re uire , for a period of three ( 3 ) years, all employees involv d in the preparation of food to have formalized food handle training courses approved by the Division of Public Health nd that such training be within three ( 3) years prior to e ployment or within 45 days after employment; and that copies of completion certificates be maintained on the premises . 2 . That the license be sus ended for a period of thirty ( 30 ) days . 3. That the imposition o the suspension be stayed for a period of six ( 6 ) months c ntingent upon the license holder complying with the followin terms and conditions : a . Within thirty ( 30 ) days of City Council action , the license holder devel p , with the assistance of the Division of Public H alth a formalized and detailed cleaning plan and sch dule that is satisfactory to the Division and that rec rds of daily completion of the schedule be maintained on the premises and available for inspection . b. That the license older assist in developing , with the assistance of the Division of Public Health , the building owner and a p ofessional/licensed extermination company a plan to loc te the source of the cockroaches within the Lowry Bu lding and to comply with any reasonable long term xtermination plan as approved by the Division of Public Health . 4 . That the Division of P blic Health be directed to do the following: a . Make frequent ins ections during the period of stay of imposition of susp nsion to determine compliance by the license holder wi h the terms and conditions of the stay of suspension . b. To score the esta lishment on a monthly basis using the service rating heet developed by the State of �I- � 4 ('�� Minnesota and report t e scores to the City Council at the end of the stay of imposition . c . I'o submit to the ity Council , at the end of the stay of' imposition , a summary of actions taken by the Division and the license holder relating to the conditions on the lice se and the terms of the stay of suspension together wit comments on whether the license holder has achieved s tisfactory compliance with the State and local health laws and regulations . 5 . Because of the pr sence of other food service establishments in the Low y Building and because of the consistent but only partial y successful efforts the license holder has made over se eral years to eradicate the cockroaches , it is recomme ded that the Division of Public Health be directed to work ith the Lowry Building owner and a professional/licensed ext rmination company to attempt to locate the source of the cockroach infestation and to develop with them a long term plan o eradicate the cockroaches from the building. 6 . If at the end of the p riod of the stay of imposition, � the City Council finds t at the lieense holder has not achieved a satisfactory lev 1 of compliance , the thirty ( 30 ) day suspension should be imp sed. 7 . At the end of the six ( ) month period of suspension and with the recommendation of he Division of Public Health, it is recommended that the thir y ( 301 day suspension be lifted . Da t e d : l 4'd-�_ L�'��2wv`rSC.lS'S �� Richard A . Mosman Administrative Law Judge Hearing taped - four (4) cassett s . A request is hereby made for a opy of final action taken by the City Council be served upon the Office of Administrative Hearings , 310-4th Avenue South , inneapolis , MN 55415 . C� S�-3/� f MORANDUM The City of St . Paul h s proved , by a preponderance of the evidence , that the lice se holder has violated certain signiticant provisions of t e St . Paul Legislative Code , Section 331 in the numerous inspect ons done on the establishment over a ten ( 10 ) month period of ti e . Although some of these violations were smaller and housekeepi g in nature , others were significant and related directly to spe ific provisions of the Code relating to the way ana manner i which food was properly stored , refrigerated , tha�aed and pr pared . There also was the consistent problem with cockroaches . The license holder has consistently demonstrated a conscientious and cooperat ve attitude and has made consistent efforts to correct def'icie cies noted by the inspectors . These efforts are demonstrated by the numerous corrections noted on all follow up inspections . COCK OACH VIOLATION The license holder has had a licensed exterminating company that has sprayed on the p emises for several years . Although much effort has been m de to eradicate the presence of cockroaches , their continu d presence suggests that the source may be somewhere outside of the leased premises controlled by the license holder. EvidenCe of cockroaches in adjacent areas and the fact that there is a doorway leading to the storage room would make spraying the sto age room only a short term remedy . The inspectors should work with the professional spraying company employed to ensure proper timing and distribution of effort as well as assistin them in locating the actual source of the cockroaches and t�e est methods of obtaining long term results better than has be n experienced in the past. In order to obtain a ong term solution , it seems apparent that it will be necessary or the inspectors to broaden the area of their inspections to i clude the areas adjacent to the lease holders premises and to work with the building owners to eliminate cockroaches lo ated adjacent to the lease holders premises both for this 1 ' cense holder as well as other food service license holders in the Lowry Building. HOUSEKEEPI G/CLEANING VIOLATIONS Although the license h lder does have a cleaning schedule in place, it is indefinit and inadequate and in need of clarification . A more det iled plan addressing individual duties for individual employees ' s necessary to obtain consistent long term compliance with healt standards . - 1- G� Sq-3/G P , FOOD STORAGE/ REPARATION VIOLATIONS 'I'raining of the employees at the establishment is inadequate and the consistent deficienc � es relative to the thawing , storing and preparation of food cou d be eliminated with education and training . Although Mr . La ' performs a majority of the food preparation , other employees are involved to some degree and all could benefit from additional or "refresher" training . He testified to his willingnes to train his employees as well as himself. The fact that he has a formalized plan at all is evidence of his concern for this aspect of his business . His testimony was that he doe not object to developing a more detailed plan with the Depar ment . Since the license hold r has for years had prof'essional assistance in an attempt to radicate the presence of cockroaches on the premises , it appears evident , that it will be necessary to expand the treatment to the uilding areas outside of the leased premises if the infestation s going to be eliminated long term. This 4ri11 require the inspectors to go beyond the confines of the license holders premises and work with the building owner and the professional exterminating company . The license holder has emonstrated his cooperation in the past and his willingness to work toward a permanent solution to all deficiencies noted . The have also expressed willingness to work with the Division of ublic Health in the future . The establishment is well equip ed and the license holder has the capacity, with assistance fr m the city , to maintain long term compliance with the Leg slative Code relating to his establishment . r Dated : �t-. y� � _ � ichard A . Mosman Administrative Law Judge -2- G� 8�3l� s'��'�• � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL �~� ' OFFICE OF 7HE CITY ATfORNEY �, i, a.� iiii�i�ii ii �= %,. �= EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY ��"'�,o.°,;��''�� 647 City Hall, Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 612-298-512� GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR February 15 , 1989 RECEIVED FEB 151989 Ms . Kathleen Stack CITY CLERK Director of Department of Co�►un ty Services City of St . Paul City Hall St. Paul , MN. 55102 Mr. John E. Daubney Attorney at Law 700 Landmark Tower 345 St. Peter Street � St. Paul , MN. 55102 Mr. I-Ming Lai Pacific Garden Restaurant 338 St. Peter Street St. Paul, MN. 55102 RE: In re the matter of the lic nse of the Pacific Garden, Inc . dba Pacific Garden Restaura t Dear Sir/Madam: Enclosed is a copy of the resolu ion I have drafted for Council consideration, reflecting their ecision on February 14, 1989 . It will in all likelihood be on he Council agenda for February 23, 1989. Very truly yours, PHILIP B. BYRNE Assistant City Attorney Enc. cc: Albert B. Olson City Clerk � �` ��..�/� s��- --.. CITY OF SAINT PAUL �•"� '�, � OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY �� wu�imn „ `?� �nt IIl lt ^� '�;. EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY �,'''"�,o•;�,.'-'� 647 City Nall, Saint Paul,Minnesota 55102 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR RECEIVED .Tanuary 26 , 1989 JAN 2�71989 CITY CLERK Mr. John E. Daubney, Esq . 700 Landmark Towers 345 St. Peter Street Saint Paul , MN. 55102 RE: In re the Licenses of the acific Garden Restaurant Dear Mr . Daubney: This will confirm that the hear ng before the Council on the ALJ' s Report in the above matter wi11 be on February 9 , 1989 , at 9 :00 a.m. (or thereafter as it may be pIa ed on the agenda) . You could check the day before to see how far d it is on the agenda. As I indicated to you in my office, do not intend to file exceptions to the Report, and unless some etail overlooked on first reading occurs to need correction, I will simply ask the Council to adopt the findings , conclusions and re onunendation of the Report . � Very truly yours , PHILIP B. BYRNE Assistant City Attorney cc : Albert B. Olson City Clerk Kathleen Stack, Director Department of Community Se vices Joseph F. Carchedi License Inspector William Gunther Environmental Program Maha er ��•\6D��/�(�� :�.6t0 _'Np��•.��s) ( _ . . .'•*�o#. a�o STAT E Q F M I N N ESOTA RECEIVED OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS JAN 3 01989 FIFTH FLOOR,FLO R EXCHANGE BUILDING CITY CLERK 310 FOURTH AVENUE SOUTH MINNEAPOLIS,MINNESOTA 55415 (612)341-7600 January 27, 1989 St. Paul City Council Attn: Albert B. Olson City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: In the Matter of the License of !Pac'fic Garden Restaurant; OAH Docket No. 62-2101-2972-6. Dear Mr. Olson: Enclosed is the original copy of, th Findings of Fact in the above- referenced matter, copies of which w�ere served on all parties on January 25, 1989. It is my understanding from Aldmi istrative Law Judge Richard Mosman that he returned the official record' to Philip Byrne. The documents whick� are enclosed are also part of the record,. t the request of Mr. Byrne, I am also enclosing copies of the tapes from the earing on January 13. incerely, ��'l��.�'C� � '��i'��`�'-��"1_/ ANDRA A. HAVEN ffice Services Supervisor elephone: 612/341-7642 sh Encs. AN EQUAL OPPOR UNITY EMPLOYER il. '-� , . i ,�` �'-� �,�� . , � � . � • I�' 62-2101-2972-6 t ST 'TE OF MINNESOTA OFFICE OF 'AD INISTRATIVE flEARINGS I FOR '�HE CITY OF ST. PAUL i. "'��S OF FACT, �un OFF/CE ST'4TE OF M� 5th �o��M�NISTRqTESpTA �our VE FjEA S�LD 7-� Mi h ap I srth qvenUe So uild�g�NGs Mi�nes 55ih 5 • Phi l l p B (6�2�34� �sotoa 41 . Assi yrne ci an . St 7 pauY H 11 y AttOrn� 1� �• 551�2 y 'nV O/�e No.: 3171 Billin9 Date. 1_2�_89 Quantity Fil e No.: 62_ 2j pl_2972_ 4 Td p Rev. Code: 359 3 peS eSCriPCip� MR. 33g I�MINE LAI ST LZCENSE Ac�i N STR��• .S�AC, FIC Unit pr��e Tor 1'12� T' AU GARDEN a�AmO�nt � 89 L LrQUpR � INC. No nu�ers TaPes on $6, 6� Thes �dPes e ta re�ord1�9' o fd�e a cop Tr Fee er he hedr n �f the o l�• �0 g• ri9ind1 S1 60 Do nO� pay from A68 APID term5 .._ �h1s lnVOi�� 98��' ��-90 � se 2 . On January 3, �>__ _ mO�thly b . authority of Section 31 ;.0 ��_ ll ing, elected to initiate a he r ng regarar�t Inc , d/b/a Pacific Gar n Restaurant, the �_ herein. By Stipulation pf the parties, further n waived, the hearing sche ul d and held on January 13 , 19 y, in the St . Paul Publie Li r ry, St. Paul , Minnesota. 3. The license holder o�rns and has operated sinee 1982 the ,' : , - ; I • Pacific Garden Restauranti w ieh is located in the Lowry - Building, 338 St. Peter S�tr et, St . Paul , Minnesota . The establishment has both a l�iq or license and a food license and is open six ( 6) days a �ae k. The bar is open only during periods the restaurant is o�e . 4 . I-Ming Lai , and his wi'fe Esther Lai , are the principle shareholders and operators � of the Pacific Garden Restaurant . They have no other busine�s . Between them, they do nearly all of the food preparatipn and personally supervise on a daily basis all aspects of �th restaurant operation. Mr. Lai has had food handlers train,in prior to 1982. , 5 . Between February 11 , �19 7, and December 28, 1988, the Pacific Garden has been sub;je t to thirteen ( 13) separate on- site inspections by the Ci y f St. Paul , Division of Public Health. There were other c • n acts between the inspectors and the license holder in add ti n to the on-site inspections , relating to corrections and; c nditions at the restaurant . 6. Deficiencies or violatio s of St. Paul Legislative Code s . 331 were found on all ;in pections performed during the period cited. i i 7. On four (�4) occasiops the establishment was scored according to a method esta�l ' shed by the State of Minnesota Department of Public Healt . The system has a 0-100 range and is weighted accordi g to the seriousness of the defieiency found with the ef ' ciencies scored and subtracted from 100 . The scores obt in d by the establishment are as follows: DATE SCORE � 11/$/88 - $9 I 6/7/88 - 7�+ ; 11/3/87 - 85 � 2/ 11/87 - 65 � 8. On all on-site inspe ti ns made at the establishment, inspectors found evidence f cockroaches on the premises , a violation of St. Paul Legi l tive Code s. 331 . 18 , Insect and Rodent Control . ' 9 . The license holder h is had since 198�4 a professional licensed pest control co p ny on contract. They have regularly sprayed the prem �se at intervals of onee to four times per month. The li e se holder has personally used insect fog bombs to supplem 'n the professional spraying done on the premises. 10 . The establishment is �o ated on two (2) floors of the Lowry Building, the first ifl or and a storage room in the basement . The storage room h s a door leading to common area outside of its leased premi e . ' i-2 I . i . � . � . i • 11 . In one instance, May 2�1 , 1987, the inspector noted that - in connection with the spra i g for cockroaches, the license holder should also weatherstri the storage room door leading outside of the leased premis s i 12. There are common area ithin the Lowry Building that are adjacent to the food s�er ice areas leased by this and other license holders in t e Lowry Building that show evidence of cockroach infest t on. 13 . The license holder co si tently took corrective action and follow up inspections c nsistently showed corrections or "abatement" had been done n reviously noted deficiencies . This includes calls to the x erminating company immediately upon notification that the �inspector had found evidence of the presence of cockroache . The license holder has also made efforts to seal cracks an openings both in the storage room and in public places in t e restaurant. I 14 . During the time period � of February 11 , 1987 to December 28 , 1988, there have been n merous violations noted relative to the thawing method, sanit t ' on , and temperature control of food, both stored and prep re , all violations of St. Paul Legislative Code s . 331 . 11 ( 6) , ood Protection . i 15 . The license holder has in place a cleaning schedule and plan to be used by the kit he , bar and waitress personnel . Cleaning is done twice a ay both in the kitchen and the public area. 16. I-Ming Lai is the ��nl employee who has had food handling training. � i 17 . The are other food serv'c licenses located in the Lowry Building. CONCL S ONS 1 . The St. Paul City Cou�cil and the Administrative Law Judge has jurisdiction in th 's matter pursuant to MSA s. 14 .50 and St. Paul Legislative Cod . 310 .05 & 310 .06. E 2 . The City of St. Pa 1 has fulfilled all relevant substantive and procedural r q irements of law and rule . 3. The license holder is ]�ic nsed by the City of St. Paul for on sale liquor as el as food establishment in accordance with St. Paul eg slative Code s. 331 ; and the license holder is, therefo e , required to comply with the said Code relating to food l c nses. 4. The City of St. Paul has ,p ved by a preponderanee of the evidence that on numerous �oc asions between February 11 , 1987, and December 28 , 1988 , Ithe license holder had violated . the St . Paul Legislative Cod � s . 331 . 11 and 331 . 18 relating to I _ . ' the operation of a fo d service establishment . r 5 . As a result of t �s violations over this period of time, some disciplinary ac ao is necessary. Based upon the fore 'oi g Findings of Fact and Conclusions, the Administrative Law J �g makes the following: I�RE OMMENDATIONS IT IS HEREBY REC4MM NDED that the City Council take disciplinary action agai�st the license holder as follows : 1 . That a condit�on be placed upon the license of the Pacific Garden , Inc� o require , for a period of three ( 3) years, all employee$ i volved in the preparation of food to have formalized food� h ndler training courses approved by the Division of Public e lth and that such training be within three ( 3) years pri r to employment or within 45 days after employment; and th t copies of completion certificates be maintained on the p em ses . 2 . That the licensl b suspended for a period of thirty ( 30 ) days . 3. That the imposft on of the suspension be stayed for a period of six ( 6 ) on hs contingent upon the license holder complying with the ol owing terms and conditions : a. Within thi�t ( 30 ) days of City Council action, the license holde evelop , with the assistance of the Division of �b ic Health a formalized and detailed cleaning plan �n schedule that is satisfactory to the Division and h t records of daily completion of the schedule be ma�n ained on the premises and available for inspection. b. That the li ense holder assist in developing, with the assistanc � f the Division of Public Health , the building owne a d a professional/licensed extermination company a pla � o locate the source of the cockroaches within the pw y Building and to comply with any reasonable lo g term extermination plan as approved by the Division f ublic Health. �. That the Divis o of Public Health be directed to do the following: � a . Make fre ue t inspections during the period of stay of impositio � o suspension to determine compliance by the license pl er with the terms and conditions of the stay of suspe s ' on. b. To score th establishment on a monthly basis using the service ra ing sheet developed by the State of I I _!�_ � I . �`�`�-�r/� . . Minnesota and r port the scores to the City Council at • the end of th stay of imposition. c . To submi ` o the City Council , at the end of the stay of impo it on , a summary of actions taken by the Division and he license holder relating to the conditions on t e license and the terms of the stay of suspension to ,et er with comments on whether the license holder has a h' eved satisfactory compliance with the State and loc "1 ealth laws and regulations . i 5 . Because of ' he presence of other food service establishments in t e Lowry Building and because of the consistent but onl artially successful efforts the license holder has made � o er several years to eradicate the cockroaches , it i �, r commended that the Division of Public Health be directed !t work with the Lowry Building owner and a professional/lic ns d extermination company to attempt to locate the source f he coekroach infestation and to develop with them a long t r plan to eradicate the coekroaehes from the building. 6. If at the end �o the period of the stay of imposition, the City Council finds that the license holder has not achieved a satisfa �to y level of compliance , the thirty ( 30 ) day suspension sho �.d be imposed. 7. At the end of he six ( 6) month period of suspension and with the recommend �ti n of the Division of Public Health, it is recommended that' t e thirty ( 30 ) day suspension be lifted . � Da t e d: l4'i ��r-i`r�c ��` Richard A. Mosman � Administrative Law Judge Hearing taped - four (4) assettes . � A request is hereby ma �e or a copy of final action taken by the City Council be ser�ed upon the Office of Administrative Hearings , 310-4th Avenu� outh , Minneapolis, MN 55415 . � I I i II i � � I � I � -5- I . . . � MO ANDUM . � The City of St. Paul ha roved, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the licen�e holder has violated certain significant provisions of th t. Paul Legislative Code , Section 331 in the numerous inspecti�ns done on the establishment over a ten ( 10 ) month period of time�» Although some of these violations were smaller and housekeepin in nature, others were significant and related directly to spec�fic provisions of the Code relating to the way and manner in w ich food was properly stored, refrigerated , thawed and prep�r d. There also was the consistent problem with cockroaches . � The license holder �as consistently demonstrated a conscientious and cooperativ ttitude and has made consistent efforts to correct deficienc 'e noted by the inspectors . These efforts are demonstrated by t e numerous corrections noted on all follow up inspections . � COCRRO�AC VIOLATION The license holder has h d a licensed exterminating company that has sprayed on the pre i es for several years . Although much effort has been mad to eradicate the presence of cockroaches, their continued ` p esence suggests that the source may be somewhere outside of t 'e leased premises controlled by the license holder. Evidence o c ekroaches in adjacent areas and the fact that there is a d o way leading to the storage room would make spraying the stora e room only a short term remedy . The inspectors should w�rk with the professional spraying company employed to ensure pr per timin� and distribution of effort as well as assisting t�e in locating the actual source of the cockroaches and the be t methods of obtaining long term results better than has been �x erienced in the past. In order to obtain a lo �g term solution, it seems apparent that it will be necessary fo� t e inspectors to broaden the area of their inspections to incl�de the areas adjacent to the lease holders premises and to w rk with the building owners to eliminate cockroaches locat .d adjacent to the lease holders premises both for this licehs holder as well as other food service license holders in th ' L wry Building. HOUSEKEEPING/ LE NING VIOLATIONS Although the license hold�r does have a cleaning sehedule in place, it is indefinite n inadequate and in need of clarification. A more detail d lan addressing individual duties for individual employees is iec ssary to obtain consistent long term compliance with health s an ards . i I �' _ �_ I i � rl I � � • � � ' �� ♦ � FOOD STORAGE/ RE ARATION VIOLATIONS Training of the employee , at the establishment is inadequate and the consistent deficienc e relative to the thawing, storing and preparation of food cou `d be eliarinated with education and training. Although Mr . La erforms a majority of the food preparation , other employees a e involved to some degree and all could benefit from additiona or "refresher" training . He testified to his willingnes t train his employees as well as himself. The fact that he as a formalized plan at all is evidence of his coneern forj, t is aspect of his business . His testimony was that he doe ' ot object to developing a more detailed plan with the Depart. e t. Since the license hold � has for years had professional assistance in an attempt to e a icate the presence of cockroaches on the premises , it appears e i ent , that it will be necessary to expand the treatment to the ui ding areas outside of the leased premises if the infestation ' s oing to be eliminated long term. This will require the inspect r to go beyond the confines of the license holders premises and o k with the building owner and the professional exterminating co�pany. I The license holder has em nstrated his cooperation in the past and his willingness to o k toward a permanent solution to all deficiencies noted. They h ve also expressed willingness to work with the Division of ,ub ic Health in the future . The establishment is well equipp�d and the license holder has the capacity, with assistance fr m the city, to maintain long term compliance with the Legi�sl tive Code relating to his establishment . � � t �� ! � Dated : �-• �� ichard A. Mosman Administrative Law Judge I i i � �i , � �4 I� I I-2 . . ; � � � . � � �� j� � STATE OF MINNESOTA) )ss . COUNTY OF HENNEPIN) Laura S. Schwartz of the City o Minneapolis , County of Hennepin, in the State of Minnesota , be n duly sworn, says that on January 25, 1988, she served the an ex d Findings of Fact, Conclusions and Recommendations by mail 'r�g a copy thereof, enclosed in an envelope, postage prepaid, an y depositing the same in the post office at Minneapolis , Minne o a, directed to the following at the last known address of thels id parties: I Ms. Kathleen Stack Director of Department of Comc�unity Services City of St . Paul � City Hall �,' St. Paul , MN 55102 'I Office of the City Attorney ' Mr. Philip Byrne 647 City Hall St . Paul , MN 55102 Mr. John E. Daubney, Esq . 700 Land Mark Tower � 3�5 St. Peter Street St. Paul , MN 55102 Mr. I-Ming Lai � Pacific Garden Restaurant ; 33$ St . Peter Street i St . Paul , MN 55102 I Subs rib d and sworn to before me this ��day of _ �_. , 19� � Q. ��<� � �- - � JODY A KLINE NOTARY PUBLIC—MINNESdT� HENNEPIN COUNiY My Comm�ssion Expnes S�q.U.1g93 �r • � �- 1 i i I �O1LED��OR'. �� _...� ��.� - _ ��,i... ;;�� RECEIVED STATE O F I N N ESOTA JAN 1 � 1989 OFFICE OF ADMINI TRATIVE HEARINGS �IT'Y CLE�2t� FIFTH FLOOR,FIiOUR EXCHANGE BUILDING 310 FOURTH ENUE SOUTH MINNEAPOLIS, INNESOTA 55415 (612)3 1-7600 January , 1989 St. Paul City Council Attn: Albert B. Olson City Clerk 386 City Hall St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: In the Matter of the License of Pacific Garden Restaurant; OAH Docket No. 62-2101-2972-6. Dear Mr. Olson: Enclosed is the original Interim 0 der in the above-referenced matter, copies of which were served on all par ies by Administrative Law Judge Richard A. Mosman on December 27, 1988. A1So nclosed is the official record, and our file in this matter is now being clpse . Sincerely, X �r�'1�� '��''2'. , _r�� cf SANDRA A. HAVEN Office Services Supervisor Telephone: 612/341-7642 sh Enc. AN EQUAL OP RTUNITY EMPLOYER � . City-89-005-CG 62-2101-2972-6 STATE ,O MINNESOTA OFFICE OF ADM N STRATIVE HEARINGS � FOR THE IT OF ST. PAUL In the Matter of the License of Pacific INTERIM ORDER Garden Restaurant I The above-entitled matte as scheduled for hearing before Administrative Law Judge Ric ar A. Mosman on 22 December, 1988 . at 9 :00 a.m. Prior to the' c mmencement of said hearing, the parties entered into negotia io s and a written Stipulation , the terms of whieh are included i a letter from Philip B. Byrne , Assistant St. Paul City Att rn y, dated December 20, 1988 and signed by the attorney for he license holder . The terms and conditions of that document ',ar specifically cited , referenced and incorporated herein. ` In accordance with said Sti u ation entered into between the parties , the hearing in this at er is continued for a period not to exceed one ( 1 ) year of th d te hereof. During that one ( 1 ) year period of time the City of St. Paul will have the right to re-schedule the hearing with pr per notice to all parties . In the event the City of St. P u does not serve notice of the hearing within one ( 1 ) yea rom the date of this Order, jurisdiction by virtue of the N tice of Hearing served November 25, 1988 upon the respondent h r in will terminate . �I Dated: ?, /Q�'� � 7-~-i I' Richard . Mosman Administrative Law Judge Pursuant to Cha,pter 14 .62, a o y of the Interim Order in the above-entitled matter shall b erved upon each party or the party' s representative by first c ass mail . i 1- I V : - � � � 9��/� �'°�""'°� � CITY OF SAINT PAUL `��`�� °•°°�. �� '`.. I �o �.. OFFICE OF 7'HE CITY ATTORNEY �' �iii�i ii n �'-` ";,; � -1-1- �: EDWARD P. STARR. CITY ATTORNEY �••• 647 City Hall. Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 `"'��u��:n:.. 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER ' MAYOR December 20, 1Q88 Mr. Richard A. Mosman Attorney at Law 1040 First �3ank Place West Minneapolis , MN. 55402 � RE: Pacific Garden Restaurant 338 St. Peter Street Dear Mr. Mosman: This letter will confirm the $ti ulation entered into on behalf of the City of Saint Paul and Pa�ific Garden, Inc. , dba the Pacific Garden Restaurant bv myself fpr the City and John E. Daubney, Esq. , for the licenseholder. We first agree and confirm tivat the hearing scheduled for December 22 , 1988 , will be and is cor.tiin ed pending a reinspection of the licensed premises . Ms . Kathl;ee Stack, Director, Department of Community Services , has indiGat d to me that appropriate inspection personnel from the Division of nvironmental Health will reinspect the nremises for evidence of co rection of some or all of previous violations and prohlems , wit�i the next two weeks . If that reinspection shows in he judgment of that departLnent suffi- ciently complete comnliance wi h anplicable code Provisions and good health sanitation pract;ic s , the City will not seek a reschedul- ing of the hearing date at t'hi time. If at the end of a one-year period from this date there ha e been no violations sufficient to warrant a hearing, the City wi 1 ask for dismissal of the complaint and cancellation of the proc�ee ings . On the other hand, if new v�.o ations occur or if old violations remain uncorrected, the City will �y amendment to its Notice of Hea.ring � dated November 25 , 1988 resich dule a hearing upon such grounds as may then exist. The undersigned aoree that an apnropriate Interim Order may be issued by Richard A. Mosma�, sq. , Administrative Law Judge, incor- norating the terms and condit ons of this stipulation. Such Interim Order will continue the he�.ri g pending expiration of one year' s time, or the service of an nded Notice of Hearing by the City, whichever occurs first . i i �i � �' Mr. Richard A. Mosman �' Page Two ,. December 20, 1988 I' Mr. Daubney' s signature below on; b half of his client will evidence their assent to this stipulation. Very truly yours , Pacific Garden, Inc . � ' � � , � , � ,� + PHILIP B. JiY ohn E. D ubn , Esq. Assistant City Attorney Atto ey for Licensee Pac' fic Garden, Inc . � cc : Ms. Kathleen Stack, Director Department of Community Ser�vi es Mr. Frank Staffenson, Direc,�o Division of Environment Hea;lt ;',. P A �� ^ I STATE OF MINNESOTA) )ss . COUNTY OF HENNEPIN) Laura S. Schwartz of the City of Minneapolis, County of Hennepin, in the State of Minnesota, be n duly sworn , says that on December 27, 1988 , she served t e annexed Interim Order by mailing a copy thereof, enclo e in an envelope , postage prepaid , and by depositing the same in : t e post office at Minneapolis , Minnesota , directed to the fo 1 wing at the last known address of the said parties : IJohn E. Daubney, Esq . I Attorney for Licensee 700 Landmark Towers i 345 St . Peter Street St . Paul , MN 55102 � i I I Mr. I-Mine Lai , President j Pacific Garden Restaurant 33$ St . Peter Street St. Paul , MN 55102 Mr. Philip Byrne ` Assistant City Attorney Attorney for the City of St . �P ul License Inspector 647 City Hall St. Paul , MN 55102 ' _ � I � KATHERi�'r ^#-!NEL� � JI NOTApY CU^_IC - . . E'gOTA HENNEE�P� . .. .:,v7Y yl►CO��iNbn Expres Aup.p�,�w _ Subscribed , and swo to bef re me this �Q, 'rl �- da ,.o f % , 19�=�v, � ' ;. � , " ^ — i i I I I I � I I I I °s��'� CITY OF SAINT PAUL s��*� �. �`0 _ '� OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY o �� `;r iiii�i'ii ii �= �;. ,;�' EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY �''`��cti„�,s"„��''� 647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 612-298-5121 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR December 20, 1988 Mr. Richard A. Mosman Attorney at Law 1040 First Bank Place West Minneapolis , MN. 55402 RE : Pacific Garden Restaurant 338 St. Peter Street Dear Mr. Mosman: This letter will confirm the sti.pu ation entered into on behalf of the City of Saint Paul and Pacific Garden, Inc . , dba the Pacific Garden Restaurant b_y myself for th City and John E. Daubney, Esq . , for the licenseholder. We first agree and confirm that th hearing scheduled for Deceml�er 22 , 1988 , will be and is cor�tinued pending a reinspection of the licensed premises . Ms . Kathleen S ack, Director, Department of Community Services , has indicat�d o me that appropriate inspection personnel from the Division of En 'ronmental Health will reinspect the �remises for evidence of correction of some or all of previous violations and problems , within t next two weelcs . If that reinspection shows in the 'ud�ment of that department suf�i- ciently com�lete comnliance with __ plicable code Provisions and good health sanitation practices , the City will not seek a reschedul- ing of the hearing date at this t' e. If at the end of a one-year period from this date there have een no violations sufficient to warrant a hearing, the City will sk for dismissal of the complaint and cancellation of the proceedin s , On the other hand, if new violati ns occur or if old violations remain uncorrected, the City will by ame dment to its Notice of Hea.ring dated November 25 , 1988 reschedul a hearing upon such grounds as may then exist . The undersigned agree that an app opriate Interim Order may be issued by Richard A. Mosman, Esq. , Administrative Law Judge, incor- norating the terms and conditions of this stipulation, Such Interim Order will continue the hearing p nding expiration of one year' s time, or the service of an Amende Notice of Hearing by the City, whichever occurs first . ��. �,�� Mr. Richard A. Mosman Page Two Decerlber 20, 1988 Mr. Daubney` s signature below' o hehalf of his client will evidence their assent to this stinulatzo . Very truly your� , Pacific Garden, Inc . . � � ' � PHILIp B. RY ohn E. D ubn , Esq . Assistant City Attorney Atto ey for Licensee Pac' fic Garden, Inc. cc : Ms . Kathleen Stack, Direc or Department of Community S rvices Mr. Frank Staffenson, Dir ctor Division of Environment H alth 4 r�`t"� fi^�'alyi�si �`�v �'r �� `��' ��'.il ", e' 'r�.�-r �; ic�"G'•i��` s k .. -��., 'C°�j�:,m` - �:��`�� i�'�,� � ��.§p ��:e ,�• .. ,t : # ' ; t �@` -'K k(t '. C� u':. �%�'a a�r: '} �g �.. d a� , n +,�,,� �k'�r � �`�p � �-sf '�T Y '. �` >��r a 8 r' . r �� aw+ �! " '�`� u d Y L�h .�,.: 's� � rt � � `-�� 4: `Z �Y ry � ` .i q t 'k � �u� '' �St,6.t�. 1'� �� t . k � / 9�� i',4 �f h+��a� T�'6�}t,fg�;/ �,�++ �''1�' .rs � i ,ia a � '� 1 .? � � -:. 1 r�.F Y .c t ti9x r i +r r,� .� y y a Y r,�' . y �� y. i�f [� a i '��r y�f,tt� t �. `� . �� ,��."t r� �' 4J� 4 � ' df( T'b.,.� 1 S�' '�f � � �fk.. � j •e'f1E J �f �'_ b��'Fi .,. � . � t� "t.��., h NF�fv��:. i s r -� y I , t �_ r .' �x� ' ,� ro`�41�ki . 'tt e� : t� x e'� r•ac rl. � Lt � .� i., ' s r r$x f a� : 4 �` ' ��t��*k'� .0 -: 1�) +. .. �41 � 3 t :s�,� ;p � -� t" x;. t ��i � :u 1, '�L a i �r ��.,�. F � � ,' ,,�$rv ,,� :.t qt . z : ,,K .w� � �x o � f'�` , of i�,.* s w ��.. r '�. i-��. � Y�� t ;'S, j " ,, t,�,♦ ,�� ., '�,�� !�' ; r .� �, ��:. h ,q�': � � # ;�.�,r'c �' r �-a ro x �' ��' � �> s� t� �:: r .._5 � � ::��, . w:�� y ��t � s *3� � 3� T �'�•4 J'�o ' �. +�!'a T'��' i 3 <4 1 ' '<I �IIE 6i 3- � �� r st,.. n ., � �'� y d.� A�� 7 �� Y' � ;� {: '1sF'ki � ' � s4 t,: f ' y l� -� <k f 1 � � � � , r.i� . �4 �n'�d}',+1hAa� 1 � ��i �t� �� f� F n�i��1t 1 � � cC_ !2 � 1�ti k�"r�t� "'�w } �, s � � n � � �� {� fi�� '� F i i � +�r �:� q /via� �.� n .�'. 1 ti . v1 t�� 1 �j� 't� AS j ?N � 9 � 4p +" k � t . t � '.� � � ��,� �y� _ � � � � i F� ., � p.� ?%�h f � ��.4;5� �;' h-��, k 1 �° .'�� i !� Yr ��fa�"'�i� � 1 +� . s � � h.1 �.-i.,�f� 4 i �: ��1 E i �j W��o- r�' � � 1 r �.it � t � � " �� ' � � �'i r,.p� F,�� < < ,'a p`��`� �r i t � a a a i �. � i r. � ,/ .t`Sr � r �r� � •�,'�� t,t r t t 5. � 1 � i'R k . ,�7 � � t .- i � � "_ " 1 . 1��,��. ' � i :q ��9� � '� �. F �+ �l -r�2.- �.'j `4 tt��_: �` t.-. n�� ;a ._ h� '� � 1 � �u �� r. -Y � r , S�. �� . � �; t � � &r�: 1 r �/ = [? i , � §/�, � ry � %� t L ' ` ; d* k �§� �Pr�g�$�jr�''i«�� Y.1� V. �y d �Y t B�{ ' N.. ' ( tr � rt Y�°4a ..t � �. ' t 'k r �,. a' `ti.� d � . ;� ��. '� � , ` �t � 1": �� '� t � `��a '"3 k' a�, 1' � ` J� t+�:� r ' ,. ^�� y Y �y�.sn'�?.� � ..� 'f :��fi }, ' '� i �' , �.. �- q✓ 7 J r q*'° s �. . .y , ��' i. � . t . r o, � � ,�� c �• r �'� . � : � �., p �.r. .� -+ �=N, jr � �,� a i ��1Q'.� t��`� 1� ��a�� l��'��,,*!�$-�► ' , � � , � x � e,�r, ; � �`� 4` r � F y�y��,y �..,� F�� ' a . a � �r � �'S �� r�� {3'�7. h� j. , f � �i:, i, {.: �� . . , . �, s t, , ��//�tk�S�edir`�/� �i� �'Yy'��' '?�r��',,�✓��r '�!/� '�'�. ' �` � �,.' ��a`a+�� ta�#1cP�ci�1i� r ,�T,��e. .�i -:F .� f 4i��'u � .. .M+�'� M�� -�! �` L ! ' � : 1/-� � �' ' a f r a .,�.7�i� ��,�ii i'L �.� �#�+ .Jt�'s!+�� et r� i�f �`. u � r : .��.� a ati�; ��. ti +.�k ;� - '� �` ,y � 7� i �.{ . �'v� ♦ � I`1 �t# u .:t V 4 .` . �. -. . ..,i �M. �r yg 1 '+ 7 .. ah . i . . -� r.. : , . Y� rn . � � �9: �c'�ttc��',,��$.��8� R�.''i��t�t1"$C1t � � ��'�,'�� .'�'��'"�� ` �' + a �l�:ako��` �`��ss �e��ra��° � �5�2�»��'��7��} �� $ �� . �,� .: : , � . � � 4 �,: iY ! \�v I ,�t 'iM�.. ,l.� � �4 .L'�� 1 �{�{� � 7` i ' � � ��, I) . . +` � I �� '�,�* 9' , F f � � �#�� I�Yr � ':� . . u Y t , `�� i 6 - l ti , �" s� �� '�. �� .i i 4 �� 'ki � 't '. j4 �. .. � i r 1 4) 4. '.� ' .�� A � 4`r � .^ +1-� ,� �Y 5 '� .: ,. I �m:�{��o��Yg "�tit�� L��F1��/`' �� u��P��,y�;�F �z'�,.<4�r�t�t�i.�,,4�`c��r.y� iy�,�' �7, j; f ��V�T�� Y��JI Mi��.,. �. �..L�� 'Y�� M�'aV��A '�+'�H� ��T�A�i� .` A� 4l':�. , , � � � b� $iiK��'"Y�! ��f.�k�^.��18 0��-.•��i��0� � ,.� ;�'�.�,�;�t' �:��! ,��;:'1�'�Y��i� �r�1?ki�" ��+X� ��r'�.b f , 4Ve��` �t., `1��c��es, ri$Ca�3��-�`.� _ ;y u :.�4 �P+�-G�C��'��'��+�;��`i�l�, �F�,��' '� `' 't� �_". � YS'�� daa�ti ��`,�sure t,� �'�r�r�° f� �bz�rc�;dt �`i��a��a� � �� '��`� � }� �, ,� � wY��n �yt�u .'r��xe�'��a ne�� t��'ar�� ' ` " ' � � � `�; l � .�, �' fG�� ', �a d � � '� � � .t , •�� +�9�3 , ?��1�i'�� 't0 0� G�1t�� }'? •i'}.g �t�; �� 4q '��r � . �` � " �7t` !�� " ` y'��3�,' '.p��"�'r�^d �� `� �; �'� t F ��e�� ff �.� aorr�i�ia�'s d�f�'ecer�� ti�n ��i!��'�- ��g:��€��l:ys. �tl�.��# �.� �+ � 5: � � � � , �o�►r. nc�'C f'oe :�►�e .the ba��:s. Fo ;r -��a i�.� �� ^�a��t� ` th �� `} �� i , � � �. �u. ,: S r"�,� �,,�r �, �'_'� ; ,�t��u�d t�..�ar��ul �o �,�+�rrc� � Q��iae� ��' xH:��.��a�# �� ,,�,�i��.tt�d� i;� '' �',�,� ` � �� rt��,�d�$��'':., € � ��..� -:� � �� ` � ' � ��•�� ' `��'�,� �� PiF�'��'��te� yo�r - e�f�'i�i�+�'�� .� rtd�;i�� f ��+�f� ��:'�+�� r��l �� ,� F � �{�3�8$�'�t T;t� b�,;;,�"�a t r' :a�d -r+�s,� '� �,�� r`�+�ca;��G�{e�� 1�'��SeY��t��' �{ k �4 ,� t � , . � �+ ' ' '` a a $ I f , '� � ; �, �t° S ! :[y� {y�� y��( j}�.,� � / j� � x 1 y�4.f +1Ye��^��! ��{�^T� Y _� � j � . .�� 4 ,!� - ,,.4 4 } t "_� tir �h I � 7' � � b I I. /'i '�, r ',.��"� ��}s �;, ��[, e� T t � +- ,t '� ". ?` r , � '" � � � , {. : . , . . ''� :r .,... . , � , z ,�.,�. �.. r` . � .�� '. � .�,. _ . .,.�,... ,y , P x � � .�, .{ * C .;; y ,-C � �.I i 1 / Y � �1.y � �Y � i ,: �.' . . 1 1 ' C 4 �/Y ! 1 � _ � 1 5 . � � � ' � �� Q�1�t;� �� ' � � �� 1�'r ` � �� ( t^ �. a t", r � ' ,` 1 ' �r p /� �} . � 4 { i ' �h �: x =x �; F �� 1��11 �:��7 i.'Y �. ' d 7 i�'� j� .. � � ^�' � n t �.,s . 5.'N t /` �� . � . �' yt . 3' 'ti 'k '�.! i', . �� A t _ 4 y, � S � 1 , ; � � / ' <u. / `� ; � i� �k'.�+, 4 r � �r''�'l�'�C�i��l��'�� „r � c. r ' t' , �� t' ��'� wA � � t� r �"�: r m��s —�"' 'i` i�.,� a� � j � � � r t P �� - �t f �' ' . k y.� 1. �'?, . 1 ;�. ,',� . �'�! � � ��p� �!1 W � d '.. �` ,� � � � i ��L^ �" � � k��:i ti� � r � � yt� � ��r ;� � ` � � �� '.w� �. �,y y i t � �t�, � �,t ;'� �. � �i' q C� ��f r r 51 � '�� i�t � � . y #� a d 3�' y- t �.�� t,� � tt r °� . - �y T � �I ' � ��" ' � E'„N�� t d'j ��,.�� : �. � ..y� ° ��'� �� .�,.A t ' 3 .'�. ,� � � :t�. f ;, � � � Y1 .�.9. , l �- � � � � � � � ' �: . • ��} b'�'��' :s ,� .p �: t, � �' 7 , t � A,�',�,iM 1 a,+'(r��.h� .� o- r.� t er,�/ � �f B � � :� `r i `: J � �.- � � 3 ri f. � � �� ` , i , w � p'�jjt�, jy �{e h � a + �� t � r..1 AFs � c� r t j• �5 7 . t S ��. � �.r F 2 n ,7 � l Y � �' �' .' F� 4�- i��Y l� `� � p F �. f �,`�t .1 � � � r �y i.,�... . .� 4 r' 3'�'a �t,� 2� ��, �= B �1"' _ � . �, � � l. � t d � x • 1S 'S r ' t,S�. J � 5� (� ) � +�� 4 9'r`Y{ iir Ik ` �` �.` �, 3 � �` � � f M. � 7 y ': 1�Y�, +.1 � r a i �` a -+ 'i� . ��4 r� i .` t� F. y,I z r �. t } �, � 1� � �{ f � at�ti�� f� i ; � Y t ! ,� � •�9�r 5-r°' �. ��, �a �' �: .i, ��-_ . .., . i.�� , i�� , 7 � .. �;� ,.,. .� . � `,s i'�`�`:� �� ,��%♦� ' � � i' k '` t xP ,fd. .A�a c.� _ � ��.�e.(,.��k-' ._. .__ -�1: . . .. . ��. �t, , . . .'wr, . .� i . .,. 11NJr,f��?��b,iN �. .r X....^ ..4`t� ,f�'v* _� . ..�.. � .; . s:��°- CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� ''� OFFICE OF 7HE CITY ATTORNEY o �? %� iiii�i;ii ii �� <;s �_ EDWARD P. STARR, CITY ATTORNEY �'''"�zcu,i,n°•�,.�-" 647 City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-5121 MAYOR January 19, 1989 Mr. Richard A. Mosman Attorney at Law 1040 First Bank Place West Minneapolis , MN. 55402 RE: Pacific Garden Restaurant 338 St . Peter Street Dear Mr. r4o sman: Enclosed please find a data sheet r. Gunther requested and received from the Minnesota Department of A riculture. It is submitted in accordance with our stipulation at the conclusion of the hearing. I would point out roman numeral II on the first page; and that at least one page was missing from th Agriculture Department ' s materials (see top of the last p�ge) . Very truly yours , . �. PHILIP . BYRNE Assistant City Attorney Enc. cc : John E. Daubney, Esq. �� A ^° �he d•CUN Company Inc.' � . •' �: 225 Su,�nmlt A.ve�ue EMERGENCY PHONE-24 NOUFIS � . �.0 ,, . izo>> 573-5700 �� ;;; -� . ' Montvale, N.J. 076k5i . � . ' SuQ��aA.w ol'SuM�n�o�u.v �^•� �: . ; . : ,��, -�/� . � � � �O-�I:�1_�-E�l�`IA.L, M1�►T, ,R. �L QAlA �:HE�:T . . � . . ; , . . . . .: . April 1 � �t 983 i � � Da�e ol Itsue , R _. . � � . . E?A �� :.. .ra�ion ,.o. 32_?-07 � I, IUF.IYi'IFIC'ATIOti d-CON BUG KILL R our/gone AUTOMATIC ROOM FOGGER ; , • 1. 'frade �ame d-Con �R� F'olur/''one �A� .Automatic Roam Eo..g�;er, r'cr-:,�i3 .'J, 2. C:eneric Description Solvent-b.ase�1 t ta� rele.asE: aerosol. �,rs�.cti.c.i�° � � 3. lntended Use To kill flying nd crawling insects � � _ �. � I1. /1Pk'AlZ�rT 1�AZAR1)S • Ritin�s* . 1. Skir1 Irr [ation Q Moderate i rri t.an: =,.� (S�cr Safcty and Heailh i ?raeLi�aii� P::.r-�c•r1'.=�if1�". 2. �ye lrri ation ' Infmmation—Sections . . • ' 3. Oral To •icity �] ��on-Tox;.: , . V,Vl and W) P10f1-TaxiC � . 4. Dermal oxicit�� . � • 5. Inh�lati n Toxicity � Kon-T�x:c � •• 6. Is od ct a kno�vn strong skin sensitizer? O 1'e� �� :;��. •Sre zeclion "Guidclines.ind Definitions Pd � Ilt. P{tUf)UG'I' C:OAiYOSI'CION: Does this pro�uct contain materials in the tollowrng cate�ories? if �•�••: �• name each malerial and whether a major oIr m nor portion is present (minor ingredients—less thai� • l 0'-�• of t�tal �•omposition). ' � 1. Pletals or metal compounds llnclud�ng lead, mencu �•, arsenic. silver, beryllium. ❑ Yes �J �o cadmium,chromium, manganese, nickel,aluminulm� ithium). . 4: ... ' _�..'.';,.%. �Z. tnur�;anic compc�unds (lncluding ac�ds, alkalis, si��ca or sil�ca�es� cyanides� halo- 'C7 1'e,=�':-�� '� : �;:: ;;� genated compounds� phosphates. sul fates� or as be�Los _ � ��' � =� . . . . : . . . , ;� . , , , � • , ----. _' 'I', ted Cb7 Yes f� No , 3, Ali��h;ilir ca�bon compounds (Includ�n� carbon l�ira hl�r�de, other halugena li�•drncerb�»+, formaldehyde. methyl alcohol�•acr Ie� � peroxidea. glycols.carbon , • disul[idr. alclrhydes, cstera or kei.ones). j � � � f , # :, Pet�oleum Distillates - Ma,jor plethylene Chloride - Major �, ' 1 �1 ,1 �- Trichlo.roexhane-Ma,�or . • . ' . , Propane/Isobutane Blend-Ma,�or � � � • ' _ -- �- . � � . , � - - id�ul• etort�k'��.��w��,� _ a�'�+� � . - Y��''X`�. - L,�.. N:A � ,- �� .. . . . . , ' *� ,. • �.,, . '�y,�� . . . I�, . 1 j � � i�• . . ti:. , - ` � !, �• • . . . .. .. � � L. .. . . . .. . ,. _ . . � . � � . . � . . . . . . .. ._ . .. � - . , � . . • . � . . __ . �J Yei L] Ir.O . b. Other m�ten�l� of �mportince d-trans allethrin (allyl homolog o c nerin I) - .M�.nor � 3-PhenoxybQnzyl d-cis and trans - ,2 �:-dime��iy.�� . 3-(2-Methylpropenyl) cyclopropanec rb xylat.e -. Minor � - 2,2-dichlorovinyl dimethyl phosoph te : � I�ino� - � ; � . . . � . , . . IV. REACTIVITY DATA � 1. Ia materiel: Liquid O Solid O • Gas ❑ P te O Powder O Aeros�l �] 2. ls material tlammable? The pro�ellant is .extrem ly flammable; otherwise ❑ Y� � h'o 3. Fleah point end method used 170�F tag closed cup (Loa in concentrate) 4. Is materinl explosive?The product is a pressuriz d erosol. � Yes D ho • 5. Are volatile in�redients �iven off at Toom temperature., D Yes �l .No . 'fhe product is a sealed aet�os 1. ' � , , 6. Are voi�tile ineredients given off when heated during nbrm 1 use? . O Yes 0 No Heating is not normal to u$e. • � � ?. Is material known to react violently with other materia�a? t y.es� explain. .0 Yes � ho � , . . . .. ' � V. HANDLING� STORAGE� TRANSPORTATION, DISPOSAL REQUIREI�SENTS • : ; : PRECAUTIONARY STATEMENTS .-HAZAADS TC� H MANS AND DOMESTIC ANI,MAL:: . . CAUT�ON: � Harmful if sWallvwed. Avdid inhalati'on of vapors. Avoid contact . . r+ith skin, eyes,� or clothing. Avoi� c ntamination of food and foodstuffs. d�� Do not use in commercial food proce5si g, preparation, service, or storage �r�$�s• � ' In the home, cover or remove exposec� f od. Avoid contamination of cookin� • utensils and food preparation surf�c�es. AEMOVE pets and cover fish tanks �n�' � . boals; remove or cover food dish?s u ensils, and articles made of cotton !�. � terryCloth. Stay out of rooms.bein� t eated for two hours; ventilate Lhe r��crr�. �. . as directed. , . . . PNYSICAI. AND CHEMICAL HA2ARDS: ��ontien s under pressure. Do n-+t use or s' � ' 4, �� near open flame. Do not puncture �rl i cin�rate c�ntainer•. F.xpoou��'� 'te�- ,��. � erature ahove '• 30°f ma.y ca��se bur:stiing. CI�FO�AL: Do not re-us - pty �;��' a nPr. '�Fap conT'�T�E��J"�TT',rY!+ . . . -�--�--- � . � y ..�� . ► „ . • �. � . •. - . . � � - , f} . .. � . . ��:' � ..-}�.#r�T�ft'"� . . . I � ' - . , ' ,. FIKST AIU PKUCE�UUKES STAiE�ltyTl �F F1�a�.i i�At. �;'�,;:... , . . . . %� ,r. , , � • . � ��' � s��allo::ed: Call a physician or. Poisoh t; r;tf•ol Cert?r :rr,�ti�at�{�}.`�� pr�n,� one cr -tiao r Rtnsses of «ater. Do not induce :�o�itti ;, �r ;,ive an.�:.nin� �y m_�_n -�u..c-ui un'cc�nsc;;c�.�� . �:�rs��. If inhai�•d: Remove ��ictim to fr sh qir. A:�.;• ar:i: ;c 'tal , . - ;:ra iu • �,,� t �t 'if • . _. 1�C'n 91:1n: R�move �ontac�inated clo��hin �t : :i?S'1 3rf'°��@�: ..:'�3S '�:t!'� 30� (iPu� �pt.tle-r, jf�pn eyes: Fl:ish eyPS wiLh plenty of w `te . �:a:i a rn;��iLi�c. : : ;rr:�}�Ctor . . :-_. , - to Fhysici�n: 'ih:s product cor,.,a':n a c:hal :r;��'.�ras� 1^hibitc�r qZroptne �0�� . ._� . • is �:�tidotal and :�hould be adminis�ered � nly if .�if-.rs G`� cht�Itn�ster•a;- ir�i�:-�� ;. „ � appeared. 2-PAM, is a�so antidotal and may b? used in con,;ur,c�;.:,n o:i�h a:,r:.�ir.�. . , ; , . .. _ Vll. SPECIAL PROTECTION [IV'FORKSATION ( ��R LMRvE SiiLa ci;,?��::;.�) � • 1. Ventilation �JStfA es�abl ished s tandard Por 1 ,1 ,1 ,-Tri�ct�l�► oe*.!;ane is � ,�L�O MCa•M' ; for �`rclecs.a� distillates� tne standard is 2,000 ;�GIM . ' T e establisned �-ro�.�r T;;A :or !�!�th�ler�� , Chloride is S��O .�ppm.; the acceptable ceilin� c ncentration .is � ,G"�� p�:�. ':ea;..i�': .,. . should •be adequate to assure that tnese sL�nd rds are notexceedec. , ; 2 Respiratory' Protection ' If the QSHA standards cited above are exceede � a IvIGSn approved organic va;.cr respirator should be worn. ` 3. Other Protective hieasures . Th�� use of �r�tect.ive clothing, goggles or fac shieid, an�. �:n�ervious �l�ves i� s�uggested for protection of skin and eyes. � . � . - � - � � � V11L LABELIi�'G � � , � ; � '• ti�'here applicabte, this product is labeled and pa�ka ed in accordance with lhe regulations of the following agencies. � C�J Deparlment of'Il�ansportation, under the F�ede al Hazardous �laterials'l�ransp��rtaliun .1ct. Q F.n�ironmental Protection Agency under th�e F deral Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide • Act. ' � . . , O Consumer Products Sa[ety�Commi�sion unc�er e Fed�eral Haiardous Subsrances Act. ,� � , . `W. The information herein i� given in good fa�th Ir�it n ��•arranty� exprrss or impli�d, is �nade. .�_ — -- -- • . � ' , • . . , .� . � � i , - .'"- GCC�:m�p '� . . : •- � ' 3/2�/83 � ' � ' . • � � . . . y � , . � . . . : . ... , . . . � . _ . '� ' , . , . . �I . . ... . . . � ,d�ul� e�ord�k c��"��, s ,_ . . . - , :�°es �Lxl:�o: � , , , ,�� :_�. , . . : . , , . „ , � . � . ,n : _ . . . , . � � :1;;: . r ,::• ' . , , : r.�,,,•. , . . , ±i . '•P� . r . . i . � ' ! � _ . , . . . . .. ��riw,.. . ' , . .. . . .��-\�. q. � . . . . ' ' � • . . il'� ... . � b. Other m�teri�L ol importince . � �7 Yes l� No d-trans��allethrin (allyl homolog f inerin I) - Minor 3-Phenoxybanzyl d-cis and trans - ,2, , • -dimethyl- 3-(2-Methylpropenyl) cyclopropane ar oxylate - � Mi.nor 2,2-dichlorovinyl dimethyl phoso ha - I�inor. ' . , . , . • , , � • . r 1V. REACTIVITY DATA • , � I 1. It meterial: Liquid O Solid � � � Gas ❑ �P e ❑ Powder O Aeros�l•�} ` '�� . 2. ls material ftammable? The provellant is .ext�^em ly flammable; otherwise ❑ Y� O No 3. Fla�h point ind method used 170�F tag closed cup (�..oa ing concentrate) � . 4. Is material explosive?The product is a pressuri ed aerosol. � .Yes ❑ ho . • 5. Are volatile in�edients �iven off at room temperadure O Yes � No� • . • . 'fhe product is a sealec� a rosol. � . 6. Are vol�tile jnQredients �iven off when heated dur n� ormal use? O. Yes � No . Heating is not normal �o se. . . ?. ls material known to react violently with other m�te als? It y�,explain. .❑ Yes � No , �. . . 4 � _ .. � . . 'f; V. HANDLINC, STORAGE� TRANSPORTATI N AND DISPOSAL REQUIREMENTS � � � _ ' ?. � . .! . PRECAUTIONARY STATEMENTS .-HAZA DS TO HUMANS AND DOMESTIC�,:ANIMALS: . �� ' • CAUT�ON: Harmful if sxallowed void inhalation of vapors.,. Avoid contact . . � �% - With skin� eyes; or clothing. Av id contamination of food and toodstuffs�:� � ' � Do not use in commercial food �ro essing, preparation, service� or storage areas. tn the home, cover or .remove e po ed tood. Avoid contamination of cooking • • utensils and food preparation ur �ces. �REMOVE pets and cover fish tanks and bas+ls; remove or cover food d sh s, utensils, and articles made of cotton _ • � terryCloth. Stay dut of rooms be ng treated for two hours;� vet�tilate •the roc�s � � as directed.. � . , � . •. � PHYSICAL aND CHEt�fICAL HAZARDS:�� G ntents under pressure.. Do n�t use oc• s^C�re. near open flame. Do not punctivr �r incinerate container. F.xposu�e �^ r°^�� erature ahove ! 30°F' ma,y ca��se ,bu stin��. CISPOSdL: �Do not re-usp es�p..� ��c��: , � . . a n P r. �r:�p'"�T3T�f E� � . T^d51T"'Ct17'tFr , . . --•— .. � .��.�� : ,� -- y . .,. . .. , . � � . • • , , ; .. - - _;._.. ._... . ... •. .�..��`�,� ' , s .e •�:��is i ,+�� if'..', ..`�' - . . +� . �., ��f - ��'�` . � 'w' � .', . y . . � . � . . . • . ' , M ''�. AND DF�TrIT�ONS � aDID � .. ORAL TOXICIT? (C.oatiaued) .. .. .. . - - . , j Koderatel7 Toxic: The probable �et 1 doee oi undilutrd prcduct to 509� of the test � animale det.e in fram ingestion studiee �I.D50) ie greaier thaa 50 milligraaa per kilogram.nnd l sa thaa or equal t.o 500 a�ilLigrama p.er kilogram of bod7 reight. EPA Cetegory II. . 1�, V Toxic: The probeble lethalj do e of the uadiluted product to. 50'� of `h.e teat � animale dete�ined !ir ingestion etudiee (1.D50) ie l.eaa ,the,a o.r equal to 5� milligraae per kilograai o!� b � weight. �A CsteSo='7 I- _ . . . DSRMA�. TO7QCIT'T: Ratinga eorreepon i to tbe ethods aa dciecribed ia�6 CFRl'1500t�m�d data obtained ir t e teat n cateaori�e oi toxicitf as a•acrsbea ia 40 �� 63�.�4�-�►�. . �. Iton-_ To�nes Z'he probabl• l�t do e of Smdiluted �product to' S�'x of the teet an.imals detensiaed Sroe de loxicit� studiea (LDSp) ia greater than 2 gr� � per kilogrsm ot bod,T vei8ht vi sortality obeened vhen this doae ia admiaiatered. �A Categorl I�1• . . � 2. Sli�►tl? Toxic:. Tha probable �.et dose oi uadiluted product to 5� ot the teet � — � anisala deter�ain iroe dersal toxicit� studiee (I.D50) ie greater . thaa 2 6rs,ss per kilograat ot r�ight, althouah sose sortalitT is obs�r+ed �tt thi4 � doa• lr►el. ]�A Cate�or7 In� ' robab I� �thsl doa• of tmdilut ed produ�c t to �5��ot t�e t e,a,� �f�'1, j. Modaratel7 Toxic: Th� p a a i m�l a d• e e d i r o r d e�a l t o x icit 7 stndies (LD�p) �4 �'�'��'', thaa 200 ailligrims aad less or �qual to 2 �aa� p�r kilograa of bod� v�4,�4;�•:;:•,�; . ��.� ;� :., �.. . � t,.',�� A Cat�=^I II. � . . , ' ' ucL to 5� oi tb� tMt 1�►�.�� 1�. Yar7 Toxic: Th� probabl• 1• dos• ot nndilutad prod i d�t�r�.n�d tro� d .toxicitJ sludi� (LD50) is l�a lha� o� ��.� I200 .�l�?;Prr.■a psr kilo�a� t ody r�i�hta. ��: 'S�°r1�' . . • • to the tollovina d�finitioas u� d�i� ZltBIt�ATZOIf TOZIC IT?: Bat iaas c o iroa cat ri s o! taocicitl d�crib�d ia �+0 C� 162.10: _ 1. Non-To�cic: Th� probabl� l�t do�• oi uadilut�d prodvct to 50'� oi the teet aaimala � �tsr thaa 24 eilliar�s d�ta�ia�d tro� tioa stndies (IGSp� i� ar eontiauowl7 tor op� honr ar l�sa. �A Cate�or� IY. per lit�r b� *ol� �rh� . . babl� l� hal do�� o= ua�ilut�d product to 5� oS the teit , r 2. Mildl�ozict Th• pro � e�►ter than i aaiaals d�t �d tro� inh�alatioa stndis� « � i��f rhaa inhal�d 2 silliaraas aad l��a thaa r . ual to 20 ailliarur p�' liter.b) I / for a�� hov=' . Tr?A Cat�cor7 III. . .` coatiauossl7 % . • l�thal dos• oi aadilut�d P'i'od�t to 50'� of the teet 3. Modu�ut e11 Teacic. Th� pro ,� eat er ttua aai�als d� rs�aiaed Srot inhalatiou atudiN (LC ��rhsn inhaled 0.2 silliara�s aad l�sa t �qnal to 2 �illil�'ar Dsr litar b7 cvatianousl7 for ca� l�aiur r �sa. �A Cat�tor� 22. t to " ct th• t�at aaisal 4. �Hi�l Toxic: Th� probab � ha1 d�os� ot uadilut�d ptod�c �, to 0.2 d�ta�ia�d i inhal�tion stndi{s �uous�, tor oa � or l�°i. . =A silli�'sas P�r litsr ot �1 � rh�a inhal�d con in 1J ( Cat r7_I. � . , i � . . � GCD:eh : • • ' � 5.6-8� j. . i _ _ ' • .- 1 "`"} � !�, '`r�' .... .:/ / �, LAW OFFI ES JOHN E. D UBNEY ATTORNEYS AND COU SELORS AT LAW 700 LANDMAR TOWERS 345 ST. PETE STREET JOHN E.DAUBNEY ST. PAUL� MINNE OTA 55102 (612) 224-4345 JANET C.FESLER" "ALSO ADMITTED IN WISCONSIN January 24 , 1989 The Honorable Judge Richard A. Mo man Attorney at Law 1040 First Bank Place West Minneapolis, MN 55402 RE: Pacific Garden Restaurant 338 St. Peter Street Our File No: 9454 Dear Judge Mosman: I have received this date a Data S eet from the St. Paul City Attorney as to the use of an autom tic room fogger to distribute the pesticide D-Con in between reg lar visits of the Adams Pest Control Service. If there is any uestion at all as to whether or not this product should be used in a restaurant the operators will discontinue it. Even though the cooking utensils a d work surfaces are covered during the application of this spr y, it is my recommendation to the operator' s that they discontin e it, because of a possible skin and eye irritant. Very truly ours John E. Daubney • Atto ney at Law J CC: Philip B. Byrne Assistant City At orney PUBLIC HEALTH DIV. NSPECTION REPORTS & FILE DOCIIMENTS 1. Inspection report: 12�-2 -88 �<< N� 2 . Memo : 11-1�-88 3. Inspection report : 11-9 88 (2 pp . ) �'` �+ . Rating Sheet : 11-8-88 �il} 5 . Inspection report : 11-8 88 �lx' -v�'��'� s,� ,�� , ` . �/�}6 . Inspection report : 6-7- 8 (2 pp . )-- 7 . Rating Sheet : 6-7-88 8 . Inspection report : 2-�- 8 �" ,.,�,.Y.�_, ._�.0�. C 2 t m�'� 9 . Inspection report : 12-3-87 ,.,�'`" £`'��... . �� '. �� 10 . Inspection report : 12-1 -87 ` � �`� C � N�11 . Inspection report : 12�-1-87 ' N}�12 . Inspection report : 11�3t�87 �2 pp. }-- r ��? 13. Rating Sheet : 11-3�87 N� l�+ . Inspection report : 7-5-87 � �� 'N�� N�15 . Inspection report : 6-�0-87 �� , �.�-° �� 16 . Inspection report : 6-17-87 -�� `�"`� 17 . Inspection report : �+-�0-87 (� f ,4,. 18 . Inspection report : �+-1.0-87 (2 pp. )" „ 19 . Inspection report : �+-6-$ tF` , 20 . Inspection report : 3-�5- 7 ��+ pp • ) � '� �,�%�--".,c 21 . Inspection report : 3-12- 7 �-',�'t�`'"�" '� �: �'�, j�`"�' �14422 . Letter: 2-17-87 N�23 . Inspection report : 2-11- 7 (�+ pp . ) � ,` 2�+ . Rating Sheet : 2-11-87 �� / �� 1 � �,�. �� INSPECTION REPORT ST. PAUL DIVISION 0�' P BLIC HEALTH eage `=� �� 292-7717 555 Cedar Street DbTB: �p� a� �� St. Paul, Minnesota 5 101 PflONB:aa�`�O v - • !IlIB: C1LL TIPB: 6STlIBL SBM6Nt NB�T IN3PBCTIO�: lrrival 1.Boutine " ue on or after: Od 1.Beinspect � �5 � �� 3.Ot6er °� DDDflBSS . Departure 4.Propoaed �� p� '�, - BS4�,�33 Cr ,�,� � 30 S.Initial Inapection SOSPBC! PBI: 1CTIVIiY 1BM: 8BN6M: � Badge #p� COMPLbIAT: • Order Ao. 1'HB POLLONING I PflOVBlIBBTS lIOSi �CO!!P BTBD INlIBDI114BLY OR MITflI1 TAB 4INB SPBCIFIBD BBLON �, _ � � � ' dd� . 2 �� d2 2�. ' - , . � rh�i� !'h j,� . C�Gd�� > � . `• l� �LG ` .�ti 2L' G G1'� � ` �j/l� G�07L�. � �J1 Dyl , t`� � n (� �=' (/'. J i1 - i 1�• � • o �ti ' � � � c .�-� e 6- - � Re�dily Peri�h�ble lood�: aold tood� �uit be �t 40'� or le� I hot ood� u�t b� �t 1S0'�or 6 �r� "t�h��t too�d��o 16S't or � 6ig6er. � � SAlISP1CtOBI fBIIP OF: Hot [ooda-- Cold Yooda- OBDBBS �!B � � sbEB 1BAPBD: �-� NOfICB flBCBIVBD BY , DISTBIC! IISYBCTO � � s� , p�n� �a PBIIR A�lIB bRD iI?LB OP PBfiSOA RBCBIVING BBPOfl1' , �' ___ __.�� '..�.�....... ...wlw�� wnnw�� /___ ..t I l L_ ___��:ll�1 � i . �� ' ' � �-�. � _ �� _� , CITY F 5 INT PAUL INTERDEPART �N AL MEMORANDUM II, , November 14, 1988 Z�O: Phillip Byrne Assistant City Attorney ++e6sT'^*r,ip^-r �?oseph�Caro_,hedt - 4 edf9w✓.._...... License Inspector EROM: William F. (�anther' W�� EY�vironmental Program Man�ge SUBJECT: License Revocation At �38 St. Peter Street, Pacific Garden Restaur�[tit ; i I am recomner�ding revocation of � e license for Pacific Gardens Restaurant at 338 St. Peter Street. My r ndation is based on: 1. Past history of sig�hif cant food code violations. 2. A continuing and un�ba serious cockroach infestation. 3. Retrieval from a r of a food it�n from Pacific Gardens with a cockroach init food. I am sending you all recent insp�ct onal reports relating to this establishment. Please start the�, li ense revocation as soon as possible and continue the process until ypu re informed otherwise by this office. WFG/ms Enclosure c: Frank Staffenson , E�vironmental Health Directo�r � � Chris Ayoka � Barbara Mc Monigal-St. Denn' Diane Olson EY►vironmental Health Specialist File I '� �,,�� . I i � 1 '� ' 1 II 1 ' - � . �� + � i - • 1 �� I ,� . � � � • 1' ': 1 '� i i �� , � �� ., , � , .: i/� . ..� �'�i/. Li. . I!,'�I./�!r./'� / � , . � II; : / , � �� I �. i ' ��: � � , � _, i i:� ii � I `, ��, I�'_/I.//�./,!/I'�� .��' � • ( 1 � � ' '1 1 ;1' i� f :1 :1 1; :1 1 / � ./� �.i�L�� .it�.�/�11a � �, � � � � .La�� / .�/.;i / !�i � � � �•� .�� .,� �i��. . // /✓. �/�% � �� L� �V � L� _i. �� j . � � .�� Jf � i / �� %/I� ,►�� a��/�/��_i, �i�i� I /�. �� ,L�� A � f �.�1. .� •, � / i � � /_ �_'///S/,/.(L�!/�� ` ��I /_ � 11. � � i �;:� � / �' � .�.� i1�/ i�� .�II/, . � /� �.�l1��// ��%, �`��a� � i�./ ��/_�-_��r�- / � %�LL �� IL�� .'�L ei�� _i�� i / � : � . / I � , � /♦ �L_� �I'� i'�L��L �/ ..� ��L �� -�/_� / c�/I s. J��/. i� //_' /_i,% �L�_�� 1�� .� � " ( r t�..��./LL.�/L �A'/�I:% .�.� �'� /_/- i � � � � i , , � . � � ��/�c/ %/�.i / ,/ii�{,//.�/IL�`�.! �JI i / � � . , / i� �a.t�/. L � � �.r-' - - �� _i./_ � �/ L�/i�� _- � �� ► �� i_� � �' ��., .I✓%%//.'i/� ' "_'!Sr/.'!� ,� ' � �� ' / �� /►�i��f ; .J .��/�� i i�.. I I��/ �� .L �_1 Li. _� :.��`L� ,;� � �i�r. � / � / •.� .' ,< <.`_ _' .� _ :, a�,,. �„_,_ /. . .,�.�� , ., , _G.!_ ! .// � .. .�!��!' , _..� /, // � , . '�/� %� �.1 i i<<� _. ��•i y'�1�i'/�j�/./•�� /. �� /.d'.�L_. . 1/II�/ ..�_��✓_ ��L .�I , '' • - ' " � � . � � .r/I * /� , i /,� .;�I�,i .� i �_ ! / •' � �� '�r„�L I � � ii ' 'I , j� , i� .�r ' // �'� �_%.� � � �ll�:/�� 1 � I / _. _ � � �� i I � � � �� 1 :1 1 � ��i i � '�� 1 I 1 1 I � I i I ��y` / , � 1 I �-��i/!I\7�. � I 1 ^� [i/L/ tL��i'S��'�r �� // �! �/�+ �� 1 1 I '1 � •� ' � �� u � � - � . � ,. � . 1 .� . � ,� � � ,,� , , �� „ , � , . • i . _ �__ . � .GLi � �� i�;: / , �� . � ,��: � ; �, ,, � � �:, ,� �� .,, � �; � � � '� � �1' I � � � � � � � Ii�.:%'�!� ..r! �.'_♦ .�%(.'��! ;1_,IiI ;�Ll_/L��' �L: �� l ' . � r�.< � _�� .�LL./.�„cLI - / ,�/��_i i /�f � ' � >._.�.L�.L:�_ � / i J/. ,� s. �i ,�r.��'_': '_��G�� ' � ,. 1, � ��i%_<t . , � � � � � A �� .'i." ��. i�_'i ;��/I './I,< .l'� � _�� .�.�! �i /./��i.�I.' !� �.%_� . �/. ��:a.i'll.' r+ , r A�i. _��i 1�� //.�� ,:G!i� :�.�l�L ��' ' : � ' r �� , � �. ��.rL �' � i� .�.�/' ��i'_ _ _.� ,! i ,�. — � , � �, //.�� !'/LL. _ � L:�LL../ /�/i.. .'� f � .�i•:l . Ii� � , � / / � ` � ✓. /J. �_�:% i //. ./ '.i it.. �1 �t �/.. ,i..1 � I• i •/ . � / / /' �/ � � , ii . .% _. / / �./ ..�. ':i . i ��.:�L! �'� tL_ ii� ij/ / :.��1�� I I► / , , r , .//.' i!!�i/I.iI. ��,�fr1 ,J.'��►��i , ./',J< :� //,/ /� %,1.��:� �tL,l,«-- • / � �� , ��- � -- �.I' � //. ✓/i�� s � �I !•�.t�:� %1/ ./ �/�/.•�.� ,_/ � � , �� / / !►I. .i�u/,�� 'L //I . �/L,._..-�+'� :; �:� �I _ � '..JI. �L.!. /L �i.i/I �L. � ,.��i�� / � , /� l i i I� r � '►��:�� :1�.�•LL�:.r.��. �.!,,. �-,ir :� �... �. f.a:�:.' �` •' : � � / �A' il.i /.< '_� . I'i. ./lIi �I�i.►/. ,/!�." ;�ii.� .L// �4� �� i . o'�. / .%i1. .1/,.// �� :! � � /L.� . . :' ! ,/ ' �..i ��i i �_�.��i • ;�� , � , � � / � . /, .Gil� . i/ 1L..1.� � . ��/ �. i� % � . ;�'1� ,/1r.� �t.. // i/ �I /� �.� / . .c '/,/ il1 .L� /.I.�� ►�/_II I . . ii�i u,� . /i ._'. �' < � -�' �t/ �� A�I_• �� + �L� _��.'� u `:.i�'�� .:�n� ' ��`�.,:! I � ' `L�'��L��_i ! � � . , / I � vL�� .�!�I1��1til1 / � �� , l . , ll.►•.� __�l..l...� �: �' � � �, �� ,,,�� ,�r �i �y � � ; ,,�. � � • . ,� -- ,= � � �� i � � �,� i , � �� 1; � 1' �� r� . � � 'i��: 1;1; :I :1 � t A 1 I � �/•�• _ I 1' .f�.i_��/I��L(.� 1 1' 1 t'1 � , � ; ,'1 i � .. ';1':1" , , 1: 'll .II 1 . , :t t .�iY I: t:c.. II �� .�� . _ , , ,. ,,,,. � _ , , _ _ ...._ . _. . . .. _ . .. - - -� - -��-- •- � � � /�', .•�� i�9•. VTt�•1$1.I' '1•!r+ 'I:. , .� . e .. , , � ' . ' f . , • ' , . - . .. - .w.;.: - , . Pa9e —F— of . . INSPECTION �tE ��T ' � ST.;�PAUL'�DIVISION�0� P BLIC HEALTH � 292-7717 • j' �•, t .,.'S55�Cedar Street � '� .� D�It6: p,�p� / `'' + ; St.,�Paul,' Minnesotal 5 101 PflOAB: � d � � � �v �� 1'IlIB: .. C�LL TYPB: . 68TABLISfll1 "I . . ��'"Y N61T'IDSPBCTION:'�"�, "'�,� Arrir�l "' � l.Boutiae id� ' �" . . � ' 1 C.�..��:;.�� /�� '`l t,. �;. Due o0 or,a rr., � � 2.8einapecty. U � � "r�' , 3.Ot6er �.. �� ADDflBSB ' � De rture"` �.Propoeed �' . ��3.�"±' .� '��-' R' �i��" • ' . BSTI CT� �,.`�Q S.Initial Inapection • . �.,. . . ,,,, ,:;u.:. .. :�.,: . � t� :. •. • .... �:: ; ..�s . .SOSP6CT FBI: � bCtIVITT � . • ,.,;q'r;" �.r. y 1IB11:��,:.}.,� fiH11SM: Bia9E'��.`� �� COMPLAIIIT: Order No. ' � iHB POLLOMING�IbP60VBM611t3.MOST B .COK LB?BD IMN6DIllTBL1 Ofi,MITHIA THB.TIlIB SP6CIYIBD BBLON. ; ••. �� '� 1 y�- , C.O C o N (�l � S�9- � A r/�T- ; : t N(� . . .••�:��M�''.. .. ... . �,..�u�+':N�.� • 2 o SG L �,t P ..,.: 'N / � � c� - C2��4�'1 FieE E � . � z - os�,: , ;r4-�N • � ... , 1� rV r�t � . r � : � ��Er� � S- . . 'Tv4'i�1 t` • �-1 C.v ' S r tl� t�l�@-�—FL �V C,t� t�.� � Uk�r2A4G' . � IQ�'l ''�I� • � . . . , �,G- �'�s s P�. • �. w4c�. '� , ,v TI • -�,-Q-- . . . c i . F �� F.AN��4-� . �.r, �C�- - . . D rV1• N , �, d F � _' J�ST'i� C,�+PS l��. '�► � . C�-.f a9-�.i : � '�- �1 . . . . , . � � �� n� ��l� N o �n,r G�M�s � � j O �-��" � �F` �F 1/��Kt�'I� � . � Tr � �t 2 £ �� Go� �u-od 2 A`� Re�dil� Peri�h�bl� toodi� aold tood� iu�t be �t 10't o l� ��bot to��u�t be �t 1S0't or 6iq6�r� "��but tood� !016!'1 oc 0 6igher. � I. '"s..�. yi.f_ C.7�8 9 ic ��.�s. SATISPSCtOHI TBMP OP: Hot Pood�— Cold Pood�— OHDBflSID�i �9B ABATBD:-r—�—rf ��-�--r--� 10TICB aHCBIVED BI DI8lBIC! I13PBC1'Oe � PHIIR AAIIB SND TIiLB OP P6880A QBCBIYING HBPOST � �� .�� ..� •....•�.w«. •r,lww.. N..ww�.n.� I__� _.!1] l' _'__'__:LI_1 � � ' . . �OOt� S�� Vl � � RATINC� HEET ST I � ESTABLISI�fENT DA ' �� -C 1 F l L �`�YQ�V�� month da ear ADDRESS ESTABI,ISHMENT CODE 3 �� . � (,Z ��(.� COLUbIN AND WEIGHT NUI�ERS CIRC D AND ITEMS NO IN COMPLIANCE (SUBTRACT WEIGHT POINTS FROM 100) ITEM . COL. ITEM T. COL. ITEM T. COL. ppD 1g GARBAGE AND REFUSE DISPOSAL 01 SOURCE: SOUND CONDITION, NO PRE-FLUSHEDi SC PED, SOAKED 33 CONTAINERS OR RECEPTACLES,CO{F SPOIIAGE 1 48 ERED ADEQUATE NIJhffiER, INSECT/ S 31 19 WASH,RINSE iATEF: CI.EAN,PROPE RODENT PROOF,FREQUENCY,CLEAN 02 ORIGINAL CONTAINER: PROPERLY TEMPERANRE 2 63 IABELED 2 49 34 OUTSIDE STORAGE AREA ENCLO- 1 32 *20 SANITIZATI RI SE: CLEAN,TEM SURES PROPERLY CONSTRUCTED, OOD PROTECTION ERANRE,CON�ENT TION,EXPOSURE CLEAN:CONTROLLED INCINERATION 03 POTENTIALLY HAZARDOUS FOOD TIME,EQUIPI�ENT, TENSILS SANI- L 64 MEETS TEMPERANRE BEQII TI2ED INSECT,RODENT,ANIMAL CONTROL DURING STORAGE, PREPARATION, 3 50 *35- PRESENCE OF INSECTS/RODENTS - DISPIAY,SERVICE,TRANSPORTA- 21 WIPING CLO S: CLEAN,STORED, WTER OPENINGS PROTECTED, NO TION 5 33 RESTRICTED� BIRDS,IURTLES,OTk�R ANIMALS � 04 FACILITIES TO MAINTAIN PRO- 1 S1 3 65 DUCT TEMPERANRE 22 FOOD CONTACT S RFACES OF E- FLOORS,WALLS AND CEILINGS 4 34 QllIPMENT U NSILS CLEAN, 36 FLOORS;CONSTRUCTED,DRAINED, OS TI�RMOMETERS PROVIDED AND FREE OF RASI S,DETERGENTS CLEAN,GOOD REPAIR,COVERING IN CONSPICUWS 2 52 STALLATION,DUSTLESS CLEANING 1 35 23 NON-FOOD ONT CT SURFACES OF METRODS � 06 POTENTLALLY HAZARDOUS FOOD EQUIPMENT AND UTENSILS CLEAN 2 66 PROPERLY THAWED 1 53 37 WALLS,CEILING,ATTACHED EQUIP- 2 36 24 STORAGE, L NG OF CLEAN E- MENT CONSTRUCTED,FOOD REPAIR, 07 iJNWRAPPED AND POTENTIALLY UIPMENT TEN ILS 1 54 CLEAN SURFACES,DUSTLESS CLEAN- HAZARDOUS FOOD NOT RE-SERVED 25 SINGIE-S VIC ARTICLES,STOR- ING METKODS 2 67 � 4 37 �GE,DISP SIN , USED LIGHTING OS FOOD PROTECTION DURING STOR- 1 55 38 LIGRTING PROVIDED AS REQUIRED, AGE,PREPARATION,DISPI.AY,SER- 26 NO RE-US OF SINGLE SERVICE FIZTIJRES SHIELDED VICE TRANSPORTATION ARTICLES' • 1 68 2 38 I 2 56 VENTILATION 09 HANDLING OF FOOD (ICE) WATER 39 ROOMS AND EQUIPPII:NT VENTED AS MINIMIZED *27 WATER SO�IRCE SAFE: HOT AND REQUIRED 2 39 COLD UN�kR P SSURE 1 69 10 IN llSE, FOOD (ICE) DISPENSIN r 5 57 DRESSING ROOMS UTENSIIS PROPERLY STORED SEWAGE 40 ROOMS CZEAN,IACICERS PROVIDED, 1 40 *28 SEWAGE A�TJD STE WATER DIS- FACILITIES CLEAN,IACATED,USED ERSONNEL POSAL 1 70 11 PfiRSONNEL UI1H INFECTIONS RE- 4 58 OTtIER OPERATI Q1S STRICTED PLUMBING *41 NECESSARY TOXIC ITEMS PROPERLY , 5 41 29 INSTAL , INTAINED STORED,IABELED� USED 12 HANDS WASxED AND CLEAN,GOOD 1 59 S 71 HYGIENIC PRACTICES *30 CROSS-C NNE TION, BACK SIPH - 42 PREMISES MAINTAINED, FREE OF 5 42 AGE, B KF "LTTTER,UNNECESSARY ARTICLES, 13 CLEAN CIATHES,HAIR RESTRAINTS 5 60 CLEANING MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT 1 43 TOIIET AND D SRING FACILITIES PROPERLY STORED,AUTHORIZED PE OOD EQUI RfENT AND UTENSILS *31 NUt�ER CO NIENT, ACCESSIBLE, SONNEL 14 FOOD (ICE) CONTACT SURFACES DESI(�1 ,I STALLED 1 72 DESICNATED,CONSTRUCTED,MAIN- 3 61 43 COMPLETE SEPARATIQQ FROM LIV- TAINED,INSTALLED,IACATED 2 TOILET R00lS ENCLOSED,SELF- VING/SLEEPING QUARTERS IAUNDRY 2 44 CLOSIN DO RS,FIXIVRES,GOOD 1 73 15 NON-FOOD CONTACT SURFACES,DE- PAIR, : NAND CLEANSER, 44 CLEAN,SOILED LINEN PROPERLY SIGNED,CONSTRUCTED, MAINTAIN- SANIT Y T LS/TISSUE/NAND- STORED ED,INSTALLED,IACATED DRYIN DE CES PROVIDED�PROP- 1 74 2 45 ER 41A fiE CEPTACLES 45 MCIAA 16 DISHWASHING FACILITIES,DESI 2 62 Non Com liance 0 75 ED,CONSTRUCTED,MAINTAINED,IN- i STALLED,LOCATED� OPERATED 2 46 1� ACCURATE TE�RMOMETERS,CHEM- B �� RATING SCORE: Qr ' ICAL 1EST KITS PROVIDEA, � GAUGE COCK 1}" IPS VALVE 1 47 � � O�ier tor � * Critical Items ! Foxm E3/Rev. Nov., 1981 H�al h Sanitarian .M-�..t� i J �. 1 '� ' 1 � 1 ' • � . � � I : . 1 � � I ;1 • �� o'• 1. .� .. . , �, ,� �. '�/ / I, ri i, � ; i:�� '�Lti�i ��L��.�� I 1 � I • I1; : 1 � ' ��: � � `// , �� .,� i�ii�� • i i:� �i �i �� _�� :.�� ,. :I ;: 1 � � 1 1 '1' I' 1 ;1 :I 1' ;1 1 � _�///:/�/./ � . L � L�• � '� � � � ./�La t:��L /. ,i�� . ,// ' �. ,r�[ � l �� wr ' I�it�.�i � �/ ' .i� �"�- I/ � - ��i ! � , .j1d�z�• , �i �i i .. i � .1%. .��./_� i �i _ � . �. �.� .�. .. � �� ii .�� _' .�� .�i�_ . . 1 � I ' ��_! /.• � .�/. •:� . ,:'t /, .� i ��✓,�.. . . 'i. /. � �G�� _/_ � - � , , � ��"/-' / / / � / i /. � o..�./l�� :� ./� �� ,I � / � � �i i ,/��.!.��/.i _ /. ��L��.IiL.: ...i .I'/.. . �� .�/�. ./I/ /�.!�� I1 i . ` t / � / ' � i � / :I.! ,/ '�.• �/// .l. �iI_i1/� A.1.'�IL. � � � � . �� ! I/..'/ � :��_II� �� .�..�� / d ��I � ' � / � i1 ' �Ly//L � � .�� :�1�L��.�:�.. ��/.111.I ��i f r �• vi'- . � i � rL�i.'/ !. ..! I/..' �' �!� , �L.� i�_.� � � '.� � / � /.-��.!L� _ . I �/ � ' /l. /�.��/ �I♦ .L' �//��...�I �� , ��,�. � ��/.I . �� l�l/:La::r .� i�� / /�.1� ' �LL/ � � �� 1�� .i�% ' � I rLS.�t.1�� ' ' , �r � %��./�.!'.%I/..� - I/ /.I �U ��. . J. �.•�./ �_�._tL.:i' _ �� ,/� /.� � �� ►� � �1�� • �ti. . , . /�'� �i /.'. // / � �,�.[L! ��- �n� � �! � � � 1, � ' � / � I � I L!/I.I� .!7 . _ �.�L,��.�L�l� �-�;;� - ��' �. ` � ___ _ 11 I/� ;�i� i'_:t' L;... I.%Ii�r�!%� !. .��!_�1.%� . _� � � ' � / ,i� I i/ `r . � � " I .�. � I�� .. i � L. ,c_'.� .l ur.� . ' �' :L. �.'i� ..��. �1..��' .�: /..�t� • � N � • � ,,, � i �� .i � _ � �� . . 1; :1 1' ;� t�� '��i: i:t; I :I ,� � I //��l I .I �� I, � �� IIYIL.�I. /I�.�/./17. /I LI � _ ' 1 1' 1 '�� 1: '1; .II I '1' '1'� 1 �� , � �� • � " . � � • . � _ ' • . -• 1 �� • �I ,� . � � �' '� � � �/ . 1 � ✓/'� // � � " '' �: I1;: ' , ' �� I �. ' ��: i : �. ��.�� /i , �:. ,, , � �� ,.,. �� •� � ;i � � i:� :i �� :i � i .� �ii ��i.��ri �. �, � int�_.%� .�, ii : . 1�� - _•.c��_.� � � � .'�.�1 : l. .�. �L L_' i��'� !../.: /. �i .d.�G i � ./_'/�/ �il�. . � � 'j , � � � � :�.//�/ .� �� J�. �/. � / �. / _ . l� � r / i � - � ��''� � ,/ � � /L�� / . .._.� �,:��. ��. � / /�/I./)/L./. �_I � � � _ /I , .►�L.'/ �.�� . . _ �/� � <!��'// ' �� I��L� ��.'�I ./ ' ' O� �� 1�LI% �' ' �� ' � � � � '/�' // � � : � / i �� ' I' j / / ' � I �.il� "_ � / � � � � ' JI �� ..��wL��/ �L.f/.'� � r �•I �:- -'' �L!L� i � / � � i I' �. ,/ i .�. .e'� _��i .�/./ I�',(L ••: � � ►� � � % � //�1�i../.�� I/ d � �/�./.ill��e % � I � ,� � ,;. ��. � / �/..L�c`�/ , // � �,/A� / ._I' � � /�� /. � �..�1 .. � � � , / � I �■r��- �� •�� - - �� '� �' i: i � � ' � i � �, �, s�� / I � � - ' 1' ► • • :�r�.r.i � �� ' �1.:u� . � � '' � � � ' �! �' ' �'�, ��1� � • /L.L. ' % � , � - / ' � i /i �� : / • ; � � / , / � I il�'ii %-. !� �� _, . /.d�' ��/.r'' _'r�. � �� L � / � � , // . , , �� -- L' �//_' "' / `��. i �%� ' /��1. �i ��_�� __... �� ._ � , , I.' /. II.L«.� I 111 /.�/iI,// / 1L'�L/�%1L�/ I I � � ' / � � � /��' ... .L_!. `/....' 'IL�% ,I /[:.� � �� .�� ♦ /.�i.��L // II/� � I•� �� ' ,/f/ �I.%L ' /�'� ��i ��L�� .«LL�' �.l• �� 'Ii� � � � ; � „� � „� � �„ � , �� 1' 1' ;� ��i : � � '��r: 1;1; 1 :1 ;I 1 :1 w_-�• � I 1; � � �. �, �. .��, , ,,,: -�.. .:�_,:.m. ..._. .. .;.:... : :,. _.._ ... . FOOD SERVICE RATIN HE �� . P L ' LIC HEALTH STABLISFIlKENT � � DATE � � ��i , • _ � C�U � month da ear DRESS '� ESTABZISHMENT CODE �� -- I /�• �� COLUI�T AND WEIGHT Ni1MBERS CIRCLED AND ITEM N IN COMPLIANCE (SUBTRACT WEIGHT POINTS FROM 100; ITEM . COL. ITEM , COL. ITEM . COL. OOD 18 GARBAGE AND REFVSE DISPOSAL , O1 SOURCE: SOUND CONDITION, NO PRE-FLUSHE ,, S RAPED, SOAKED 33 CONTAINERS OR RECEPTACLES,CO� SPOILAGE 1 48 ERED ADEQUATE NUMBER, INSECT/ S 31 19 WASH,RINS WA' R: CLEAN,PROPE RODENT PROOF,FREQllENCY,CLEAN 02 ORIGINAL CONTAINER: PROPERLY TEMPERATUE�E 2 63 IABELED ' 2 49 34 OUTSIDE STORAGE AREA ENCLO- 1 *20 SANITIZA ON INSE: CLEAN,TE SIIRES PROPERLY CONSTRUCTED, OOD PROTECTION ERATURE,C CE TRATION,EXPOSU CLEAN:CONTROLLED INCINERATION 03 POTENTULLY HAZARDOUS FOOD TIME,EQIII�PME ,UTENSILS SANI- 1 64 HEETS TEMPERANRE BEQIIBEMENTS TIZED INSECT,RODENT,ANIMAL C�iTROL DURING STORAGE, PREPARATION, 3 50 *35 PRESENCE OF INSECTS/RODENTS - DISPIAY,SERVICE.TRANSPORTA- � 21 WIPING C TH : CLEAN.STORED, OUTER OPENINGS PROTECTED, NO TION 5 33 RESTRIC BIRDS,NRTLES,OTHER ANIMALS 04 FACILITIES TO MAINTAIN PRO- - 1 S1 3 65 DUCT TEMPERANRE 22 FOOD C fACT SURFACES OF E- FLOORS,WALLS AND CEILINGS 4 34 QUIPMEN'� AND UTENSILS CLEAN, 36 FLOORS;CO�tSTRUCTED,DRAINED, OS 'IF�RMOMETERS PROVIDED AND FREE OF,'AB SIVES,DETERGENTS . '� CLEAN,GOOD REPAIR,COVERING IN CONSPICiJOUS - � 2 52 STALIATION,DUSTLESS CLEANING 1 3 23 NON-F00 CO TACT SURFACES OF ' - METHODS � =`- �—� � 06 POTENTIALLY AAZARDWS FOOD EQU7 T fD UTENSILS CLEAN 2 66 PROPERLY THAWED 1 53 37 WALLS,CEILING,ATTACHED EQUIP- 2 36 24 STORA ,HA LING OF CLEAN E- MENT CONSTRUCTED,FOOD REPAIR, Ot UN4lRAPPED AND YOTENTIALLY UIPME U NSILS 1 54 CLEAN SURFACES�DUSTLESS CLEAN- NAZARDOUS FOOD NOT RE-SERVED 25 SINGLE 5ER ICE ARTICLES,STOR- ING METHODS 2 67 4 37 1GE,DI PEN ING, USED LIGHITNG OS FOOD PROTECTION DURING STOR- 1 55 38 LIGRTING PROVIDED AS REQUIRED, AGE,PREPARATION,DISPLAY,SER- 26 NO RE SE F SINGLE SERVICE FIZTURES SHIELDED ,: r+- � VICE TRANSPORTATION -- ARTIC�,ES 1 68 ' � 38 2 5fi VENTIIATION 09 NANDLING OF FOOD (ICE) WATEx 39 ROOMS AND EQUIP�II:NT VENTED AS MINIMIZED *27 WATER� SOU CE,SAFE: HOT AND REQUIRED 2 39 COLD tJNDE PRESSURE 1 69 10 IN USE, FOOD (ICE) DISPENSIN � 5 57 DRESSING ROOMS UTENSILS PROYERLY STORED SEWAGE 40 ROOMS CLEP+N,I.C)CKERS PROVIDED, 1 40 *28 SEWA WASTE WATER DIS- FACILITIES CLEAN,LOCATED,USED ERSONNEL pOSA� 1 70 11 PERSONNEL WI2H INFECTIONS RE- 4 58 OTk�R OPERATI Q1S STRICTED PLUFB ING *41 NECESSARY TORIC ITEMS YROPERLY 5 41 29 INS'#NL ^ , MAINTAINED STORED,IABELED� USED ' ""� 12 HANDS WASHED AND CLEAN,GOOD 1 59 5 71 HYGIENIC PRACTICES *30 CRO -C NNECTION, BACK SIPHON- 42 PREMISES MAINTAINED, FREE OF -� 5 42 AGE BA KFIAW "LTTTER,UNNECESSARY ARTICLES, 13 CLEAN CLOTHES,HAIR RESTRAINT 5 60 CLEANIN6 MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT 1� 43 TOILET �PD dDWASHING FACILITIES PROPERLY STORED,AUTHORIZED PE OOD EQUIPMENT AND UTENSILS *31 ER, ONVENIENT, ACCESSIBLE, SONNEL 14 FOOD (ICE) CONTACT SURFACES DE�IGN ,INSTALLID 1 72 DESIGNATED,CONSTRUCTED,MAIN- 3 61 43 COHPLETE SEPARATIQI FRQS LIV- TAINED,INSTALLED,IACATED 32 TO LET ROOMS ENCLOSED,SEI.F- VING/SLEEPING QUARTERS IAUNDRY 2 44 C SIN DOORS,FIXNRES,GOOD 1 73 15 NON-FOOD CONTACT SURFACES,DE- P IR, LEAN: HAND CLEANSER, 44 CLEAN,SOILED LINEN PROPERLY SIGNED,CONSTRUCTED, MAINTAIN- 5 NIT Y TOWEIS/TISSUE/HAND- STORED ED,INSTALLED,IACATED D IN DEVICES PROVIDED,PROP- 1 74 2 4 E WA TE RECEPTACLES 45 MCIAA 16 DISHWASHING FACILITIES,DESI ' 2 62 Non Com liance 0 75 ED,CONSTRUCTED,MAINTAINED,IN- STALLED,LOCATED, OPERATED 2 46 i i� accURnx� �xrior�xExs,cxEri- ; B GE �� . RATING SCO . ICAL TEST KITS PROVIDEp, I C�1UCE COCR 1}" IPS VALtiE 1 47 • � � perator ��,�� * Critical Items ' _�",��"�:.,/1� • Form E3/Rev. Nov., 1981 � ealth Sanitarian�a �. ��Ct�7 ZC�LI./�C1Y �� -- �� r�� 1, � '�► /NSP�' � T ON REPOR �� `�' i �� d cr L'1 N.., ST. PAUL D IS CN OF PUBLIC �ALTH ` 3j��_ �R� 555 Cedar S re t 292-7717 ��Z•�gn� _ - f/ :�s /..2�.Sr � ar` riv � e`�art;�zeJ AD Dt� Oti aP. AF'lER:. 1-Routine � ` �' . �� 2-Rninepect I .�l ; CTIV �. yo �-0ther �—� � �330 �'� � montl da ear °��z TI� FOLLOWING Il�RCNEMENZS MUS� BE 0� D Il��DIATELY OR �llTfiIld TF� T� SPECIFIED :t�. . -----_ ; � . � i ?COD TF2�FF'2r,TURF3: • I T:�� QRDER3 r.tTED lp� — r— ,�j� ARE 118AgD:-� �`� . 9eEoz• an aziating establiahoent is alterod, dacaiLd draxinqv �Nev arsi u.ed equipoent to be installed r..ist be �and equipa�nt epeciliaations �hall ba su2mitt�d and approved by►' biSF' a�pzvved or squivalent (3es Sa.nitnzisn). the 9t. Pnul Division of Public Health. YOTI� Ry�IYED BY: , — TTA12Lt2;: Form 82/Jaa 1980 . . � . � �� r . /NSPECTI REPO�� cr [.'i x.�. ST. PAUL DNISI PUBLIC HEALTH ' ��. � � �� R�� 555 Cedttr Stzeelt 292-��1� �ont� �a—'� _ � aa8 - �090 es� e1`— ar Jture E � �i � DUE Qi OP. AF'IER: O� 1-Routine { � 2-Relnspact�� , J-0iher . 3�� `moacl' da eas ' °��= TF� FOLLOGTIldG Il�RaVEMENTS Mtb�T D Il�iEDIATELY 0 � TI� TIME SPECIFIED :to. 1 � � � �� i"� , n � . ?COD TB�F.�JITIJR�7: T."SL ORDF3i9 MTED ARE ASlI�D: , � 8efora an aziatlnq satablisks�t is nitasod, dn�ailad dsaxifiqs �Nev ard used equipment to be installed �st be and equi�asnt epecilSoation.s •hall be suLmittri and appzove�! by LSF xppro.ed or oquivsleat f3ae Sar.itaria.n). the 9t. Paul Division of Public Health. t�xy,rx - �x YOTI� REGIYED BY: 3ANITARTJl2tt�, C�YZGs�G �/�iln ,il Form E2/Jan 198� � � I � � � •� • • � � • • �:� � � •, . . . � �• • � - � � . .. • t• I 1 . r � � : � • • u r � : � � : � � � � � / 1' •' � �' : • 1 / � �I I � iI 1 �/ �_: .►�' / �/1L`L�� /r �'!�%. ,/ �.�i ��►��,.�� ::1 rl..-.. .�,�� , � , . r. , ►.1,�:�•• `,1�I,, �r .�l' � , , . . .�� ;, . . ,. . ,, �•�•. �I� � , �� ,.. n, . � ��'j ��' j:/./�..I �,I11�.'/i i �// �iICV��..'� �LI,l!!'/ � /I l.�� J�..: i / l�I:!, � � / J � i ��/' S�►� ��.�///`-I� _/% Ii�1/I�r � � �� / / � r i / , � � � , �J.��.�L / i��-��►- -_� .n �'. /L �%.._ �� i%.� / �„�.�/ .r! . ' .1,'/. .L ../ i�/.i�l.//��i s✓. �t// /� ' / . I/ % ��s . ,. � r �� L�� I�/�/L .I.. L51/I� �.�� ' ��I/�� • a�� t!��a � / / / ► � , � � � �./ I� / . I��. �l ��/i�/ I � �I� / �.� .�%./1 . I� ...��/�t��. � Lr/./.._� � /.��. . �� ..d� �. , i/i . .��_,/. /I� / �O'' ' , � ' �►!�_.• .��;►�7!�� i�' ' %:��..,.�.�f� . .,.c. r , _ � ./. . .'1.� . /i i,[�J�_�� N i �i� /1I I,-t�. .,a�. � �ti ! a: : . '� . . . . � - � � �: • • • - , , � :. . • . i � ■ - - �:�n■;;-�..,,.- ,,�,� r�. I/. _. . �iii '.i / � � {'i��: � 'PI� 1�< �Y i` t?fi ✓1 , `/ �/ , � � • •• ��• � � / f- � , � � �`�!�:�L�:�L� � � � � . •r �• � . . i • • � � i� •• �1 ia� �: . •• i• � � i � r � •• � i i ' • 1 � � 2►�_ , i� � .//./ �/��././ � �`r _ .�� ..•i / .,��% � :�._...�.�' ,.,.,.'�'J , ,� � �l!�� . _.. , �: �!,:.., ,�'i1 _�>.,,. �:. .., /'.'..:��_�_��% , ,�_• .•_�_•i�� ' :��r � ' , <� , � , / �. .��.�/� , .L �� , ,5��, �L. '�� ./ i� �. . /�:�.� ' /,:� �_ - �/��./i i/ �/�/ � � ��/ � /`it�✓% l,LL1� , /�� / / � � • � i �' /�" ./� " .: ..i.�i .L ii�I i i �� i� /,/. , t ...Li� � /./..I_/ � _/� i �� i �� ,I.r�% .a� . ,/_' /. . !1/�l�.i . _,'i1../%/� /,� _/�..L`�_"`�/ . .L!� �i�I/i ,, � � � +��/ �I./�t I i.i _ it ' i!�r,..• i �r G..�,L��L�. / ii _' . ///. . '/ . /. !Ii � :� r,�� i • � �� - ►,��.�L/_'L / .// �',� ' L'I�//. . // /. .�I ' Il/�L /IL �.� . �i�� ...,i . � ///. //.�/r��! � �///i ,I'/.� I►_ '.iI' /,I� -/.�'i/, � / � ��•.�� I1�.1 '� � :�� / �iu�� /ll.�.�./, //i � �r� �/! / /r. � /.Ii/ , � � �� /.� / �� ,� / .�./. .i/� / i . I/, ,� �c!i/ii�, , /. ii.ii ��/.G. .il�L�%I ' / / i iI '.// ` ..�/ � . I.� �•!.II.�i� I�='��!/ , ii/.i' i�.�/.i ��, �� , . / . � N �� / .�� ,I i� ,/,i/. . �� / , � �.Ui�.' � /!/.!�' �� ' 1./ .�/.�s��'�'�� .ni�I /.I r��J. _��,:_._'�//, . II /,� �� L. .' �I► .'/i%,/1..� ,�:.� � .II/!� .. _�/� /. �I,��'//�I'/•'�� —� '� , I , • `/� . ./. S ,/l. !�/ �LI /L�ae�I /��/�. �.� ��''�� ../ .►��---..t i1 � �I/ �%L� ` �//.i1� ./. '.I,�/ „ /'� �. _��.•1 i�/ . /!/ .� . .i. �L��%�' �;.►� / � � , � � � .. � - � / - /. . l � � . I �. �� . 1 ri .i � r: J�� ./ _ _�! � S � l�L� I i ..� a �.,,. . .,, �x � v•�a•.: � � . � � � ;,. � _ � / • •� « ' � �� .i � ' , / / �� .1J!.la/� ••• 1� � ' . , . � , . �I��,�, i, � �{'i' I � � ' ' � IL�' • • ` 1 ♦ - . I � � ��i : F�: �aT ..�.i 1 .. , , r • �ii . � .�i:J � � � � i / / ► � • �� / . i� •TY: � � � �Av ��t,Y ti� tiii ✓M T,• ! �� ,■ � � �- �a• , : -, � � ' � - � / � ��/ /I..li/ I� ��'/► / 1 �� / •• �• � � r i�.. • • I • • 1 1 I' -• I F. . : �• ,t• 7 1 1 I I 1 • •• 1 I I ' 1 1 � i � r��i�_.�9(I., J. /�:/t _L/�...� /t / .! .. /Iii/� ��/�% : � //I.. ' • i `_� l�� . , - , e,,._,�,�, --� .... .;._-. �.,' �.�r...�. . s ,.i'�-.:.�.- ---s -=-` �!�►L� � ,� � ' . � �� I.�L I�✓��.� IIL i� . I�►��/// �I� ��.�t i�I�/,i .i� _IL�/��_A '. � � ��I�`��. • � �� . �/� r� � .� i L ��t�%r i . . / � • / I�,�.� � ,i / . � . �� i�'�� ! �.�/L v �. 1�.._' �_i ii �. �. . ../!L_'� i � �1.. . � /t�/./�. �� '� � �.. <<� � //�/� .I/-- =11 !'I� , , � i�. �i .;. '. / � II../. � '.� /.�� %�!./'� s/ ��. sG! / . �f�i .�i. !/_� r/�.;�/I.,/ss.c �.:[_� /' . /iI �_/�.� � � � / �-��vi, �/� �/��_�// =- r�a�%/ _I/// _�i 1 � �� - i � � � � / � ��j�< t�.� A�l.�.il .�f��rl_ ,. .:�..j�.L.!� �! i �/ / �..� %nn _f� � i ► / / //_� � � � /I. �L/./..�!/ sriN/I . /I�l �i _//_a. ./�/ � .! /I /!: ��317�f� � � � !.��. ' %.' �� _/..� � ii /" � i, i. / �J%1, � ' �/� //,/ !�__/� . :./!/!�S •�d.'. �' � �!� � � /� " / / �:�. • /._/. ��/.i , �L �� ' / i �� _/� i/ / !.��/_ .i I. "1.� � �/��I ._ � �/. _: � / � �,_�.: _/ /� ► � , - � � , �.i�. i �/ .�i ��. . .ti. i .��/�L,/�i�L/.�,�.�� '� / �/�� , ��i .�/.�L_ / / _ / � ' / I �,/JI�� // � �� ' r • i � � • /illl/.� �//L�I�I � / I, � � � , � ,, / � � � , .�N�': ♦I�i!:L� � t.. .t ,ii• �II.s ,) � � � . /' ` I � � � I �/ ' I� ./1 /��%J:L_��/_,il. I.►/.I/ �i/� ��i� � e .//. . � i '• �/ .� �.L/ ,��./� r � � / � . � �/ /./ /. _ i � �L �a:/I' . ,�_ , /. �.� �. �.� • �_�I e, 1.1 _ . .ii .'.:/r� /. � � . � � ' �� l��i'�'� ' ' ..� � �.a. . .,. 1 �� . . � . , �x ••�a•a � � �•� : r►o� � � . i ♦ � n •i • �/ .� � s. . ,-, - � � � ► � • • • r � : � \� i► � � �'_ ; i��.u.. . � . . � • /', .... . •. , � � , _ ■ . � � 1. • • • � I ■ _• . ■ � ♦ ! : Iiw �a� ..�.� 1 .. • / � � ��. /� � / � '✓/' i /1 ��•i I I . �, • J• • �YY I�G '9 i` 1��i V111 ��•. � / . r • •• ►a• � / ,j �'�� '� ,� � . • •r �• � � . I � • 1 1 1"� 1 1C � �• 1• I 1 f I 1 •' 1 ( t � • 1 1 �'�!i .�'.�I_'v.. �� -� �� _. ...r � � .ii. � � ' " � ' _/ :. !L=G �i/.' _ ..1. �!''.%_i �� !�L:i . 'I .�` .� . , i �� ..: :/./I , .L 'i �r%I ./.�.:/I // � � !•,.% _/. .r/ �ii .� /.�;'/. � . . . / / �.c%.� i ./ � /, , �L�! // / / .,/.,� / /IL `�/. �.. '.�.'� � � I � C�/��/� / �/�LJISi't►Y. ./I. /i I��!„ �_i�/./��/ �i.i. i/L ��LL��a !a I//.,: ./t , ,i. ,/ /_ !/.//.I�. � /'�. � / ./.%/// / � ��//� Ii � //��/ / �i /J' .//� :• �IfL/ ' � �� . �/ ��.I!/1/.� // .�.� //.'L % ♦��/. I..�� /� I' ��'��'—-� -�� _��- r��.//L�/ /_i--//,/._,._ i✓ �� • � , i /. --- -- i zi.�e�i ��. .��«� .�� t i/! . �iJ. �.'i /��/./I /.�! �ri'.��.�i - f1�--��.. i /� . .✓. i .��/.sii� • � � %"/,�� • � r � i I►� /�/_/L /./. /�" ;I_' . /i • /�s�.t_t" �//... �/.. �� _ /iri_� _ .I / i�i/' � � � `� / .� /L/. !�/!Ii..'i /i .//. ��I/!�� /�/._! %. � � / - � - � //� . �.�i �i . � ,�/ .�/.� �.i/. /, 1�1. / �. / ,,� ;.--.1/ - `- . / � , �� .I�.�. // ./,/. .1�� •� I�.�i �� _ �tI � �.Ia�� t �.��,///, i .ii / I,��.i/�. ./,�_� �� ./�///./ .✓ . i / . � . � � ^ i ��, � � / � w�/ � � .J/.. •.�i�•/%l,i� i ��. L. _!./A //��i.�:%./_' �/.'..! % : ��//L�/t. ��! r � / ;�� ' � � ��///. . .�� 1/ I �_ �L,��rJ /� � . � %. �./.!�/ /�i/ // "_ I �'�-'•� //�' :. � _� � ./ / /./i%/I:� �_/_'_% ��.� , � / � t'i �./. . //. .�.%�! I.�i' �.i��/7_:/_" �..�I i� �� !� / i � � � �/I//�L.�.��_./. .��i�� L•.�' . � �i L_i' �L� �L/L_�t!_ �L � �/ / /, i , i . / / / . � /�I.//� � ' ;/L �/�.. i!��Li�l' Lf�: / %c�� •_�./,�/.�L,. ��%... � , ' ��1 i 1•71• . •7► 1?. •'1 il'w 1� 1 � 1 ■ ■ .�r. 1 � � ' / • • ' Y 1 : ��j .� � � I]�. �,i.�/ - F O O D S E R V 1 C E R A T I N G H E E T ST. PAU DIVIS ON OFlPUBLI HEALTH S TABLI S�IIKENT , DAT � , _ month da ear DRESS ESTABI.ISHI�IENT CODE ' 3.�� ,�. �� ,�. �L.�..�D COLUMN AND WEIGHT NUMBERS CIRCLED AND ITEMS N T N COMPLIANCE (SUBTRACT WEIGHT POINTS FROM 100) ITEM . COL. ITEM T. COL. ITEM T. COL. OOD 18 GARBAGE AND REFUSE DISPOSAL O1 SOURCE: SOUND CONDITION, NO PRE-FLUSHED, $C�tAPE , SOAKED 33 CONTAINERS OR RECEPTACLES,COi� SPOIIAGE 1 48 ERED ADEQUATE NUMBER, INSECT/ 5 31 19 WASH,RINSE WATE : C �AN,PROPE RODENT PROOF,FREQUENCY,CLEAN 02 ORIGINAL CONTAINER: PROPERLY TEMYERATURE 2 63 IABELED 2 49 34 OUTSIDE STORAGE AREA ENCLO- 1 32 0 SANITI2ATION RI SE: LEAN,TEM SURES PROPERLY CONSTRUCTED, OOD PROTECTION ERANRE,CONCEN TI ,EXPOSURE CLF.AN:CONTROLLED INCINERATION 03 POTENTIALLY HAZARDOUS FOOD TIME,EQIIIPMENT, TENS LS SANI- 1 64 MEETS TEMPERANRE BEQlIBEMENTS TI2ED INSECT,RODENT,ANIMAL CONTROL DURING STORAGE, PREPARATION, 3 50 *35 PRESENCE OF INSECTS/RODENTS - DISPIAY,SERVICE,TRANSPORTA- 21 WIPING CLOTHS: C STORED, OUTER OPENINGS PROTECTED, NO TION 5 33 RESTRICTED BIRDS,TURTLES,OTHER ANIMALS 04 FACILITIES TO MAINTAIN PRO- 1 S1 3 65 DUCT TEMPERANRE 22 FOOD CONTACT SUR ACE OF E- FLOORS,WALLS AND CEILINGS 4 34 QUIPMENT AND UTE SI CLEAN, 36 FLOORS;CONSTRUCTED,DRAINED, 05 THERMOMETERS PROVIDED AND FREE OF ABRASIVE ,DE RGENTS CLEAN,GOOD REPAIR,COdERING IN CONSPICUOfIS � 2 52 STALIATION,DUSTLESS CLEANING 1 35 23 NON-FOOD CONTACT SUR CES OF METHODS � 06 POTENTLALLY HAZARD011S FOOD EQUIPMENT AND UT$NSI CLEAN 2 66 PROYERLY THAWED 1 5 37 WALLS,CEILING,ATTACHED EQUIP- 2 36 24 STORAGE,HANDLING F C E- MENT CONSTRUCTED,FOOD REPAIR, 07 UNWRAPPED AND POTENTIALLY UIPMENT/UTENSI 1 54 CLEAN SURFACES,DUSTLESS CLEAN- � HAZARDOUS FOOD NOT RE-SERVED 25 SINGIE-SERVICE IC S,STOR- ING METHODS 2 67 ' 4 37 AGE,DISPENSING, U ED LIGHTING OS FOOD PROTECTION DURZNG S�TOR- 1 55 38 LIGHTING PROVIDED AS REQUIRED, AGE,PREPARATION,DISPIAY,SER- 26 NO RE-USE OF SING S RVICE FIZTfTRES SHIELDED VICE TRANSPORTATION ARTICLES + ' 1 68 2 38 2 56 VENTIIATION 09 HANDLING OF FOOD (ICE) WATE& 39 ROOMS AND EQUIPMENT VENTED AS MINIMIZED *27 WATER SOURCE,SAFE� HO AND REQUIRED 2 39 COLD UNDER PRESSUAE 1 69 10 IN USE, FOOD (ICE) DISPENSIN 5 57 DRESSING ROCRiS UTENSILS PROPERLY STORED SEWAGE 40 ROOMS C1.EAN,IACKERS PROVIDED, 1 40 *28 SEWAGE AND WASTE i,�ATE DIS- FACILITIES CL£AN,IACATED�USED ERSONNEL POSAL 1 70 11 PERSONNEL NI1H INFECTIONS RE- 4 58 OTHEA OPERATIINS STRICTED YLUMBING � *41 NECESSARY TO]CIC ITEMS PROPERLY • 5 41 29 INSTALLED, MAINTAI}�iIED STORED,LABELED, USED 12 FUINDS WASHED AND CLEAN,GOOD 1 59 5 71 HYGIENIC PRACTICES *30 CROSS-CONNECTION, ACK SIPHON- 42 PREMISES MAINTAINED, FREE OF S 42 AGE, BACKFL(xl "LTTTER,UNNECESSARY ARTICLES, 13 CLEAN CIATHES,HAIR RESTRAINTS 5 60 CLEANING MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT 1 43 TOILET AND HANDWASHING ACI ITIES PROPERLY STORED,AllTHORIZED PE OOD EQUIPMENT AND UTENSILS *31 NUMSER,CONVENIENT, ACC SSIBLE, SONNEL 14 FOOD (ICE) CONTACT SURFACES DESIGNED,INSTALLED�, 1 72 DESICNATED,CONSTRIICTED,MAIN- 3 61 43 COMPLETE SEPARATIQI FROM LIV- TAINED,INSTALLED,IACATED 32 TOILET ROOMS ENCLO D,S �.F- VING/SLEEYING QUARTERS LAUNDRY • 2 44 CIASING DOORS,FIX S, OOD 1 73 15 NON-FOOD CONTACT SURFACES,DE- PAIR, CLEAN: HAND ER, 44 CLEAN,SOILED LINEN PROPERLY SI(�IED,CONSTRUCTED, MAINTAIN- SANITARY TO'WEI.S/TIS UE/ - STORED ED,IIVSTALLED,IACATED DRYING DEVICES PRO DED PROP- 1 74 2 45 ER WASTE RECEPTACLE� 45 MCIAA 16 DISHWASHING FACILITIES,DESI 2 62 Non Com liance 0 75 ED,CONSTRUCTED,MAINTAINED,IN- STALLED,IACATED, OPERATED ' 2 46 i� nccuanre x�xriar�Texs,cx�- g��Q�� RATING SCOR�: ICAL 1EST KITS PROVIDEA, � C�UGE COCK 1�" IYS VALVE 1 47 � Operator * Critical Items � Form E3/Rev. Nov., 1981 Health Sanita ia , i � � i v . ;A � : • �:�t I li. � ll � 1' i � 1 � • • • �k • 1' 1 1 • � . � • : � � • - � • � • � v • � • _ r : � t • • ' • � : � ' •' � �. . : � 1 / • �ll�i:/L� �� 1�� / � _/. �./.� i/ Jj I . � � ' . � . �/��/�/ /. �.S �� `�� /' /, , / � t�� /. I _a � / .1/ I y / � i � r � � �.�I/.�I� . /L .�. /I�fi/ �it��,/� I�I �. �� .�:� / � i �� 4� �// .a�/ �/ . / �� :1 �� l � / / L_� / � . !/. � / v.��./I '/� i . �� . i / � // �ifA'i/� .I./ � L� �i/�� `.� I � � � � � � / i i !i/.I� �I /�. / .' I� r �/.�./. _II��. : � .►�d•� ��.__� � /t�� / , � - � . � I.L��•�'1//l I .,1��i /1 � I �.I�/ /i//. t' 51.�./ .IL .. ././// r/ �/ /�i��i _.( /� � � � � / � � / � / � / � �� ',I_' ��/. �..a! ./,r�s � . ' •[�. . l .II I/ �.1�/.�.�/iL_� . II ! r►_. � .�'/i l � r / � � � � t�.`.�.�' /.' /I�.0 � . <iL� i. �/ . ,�./� � !s �� ; t' ./l� .� ' /. .� � . //_I..(."� , . .._.�� 1./� �/ I / /..�il!/. /.� . � i� ./ � . � .. / � �i. 1 / .t�.v�. � // , • a: I � , • I , I 1 ■ • ' I • �� • i I i ■ , _� : � _ � / � � - •, � ' : 1: ia � .t��ID . � � —��I i�/ �i ��. .�� ./ / �i//� ' � � . �, – � T. / � y"Y 1�t'Y i� i�•U v ''• � � r r • •• �• I �•/ � �/ .r` � I - — • _ i `� � ///�� • , •Y �• � 1 I ��IL:/LL�` il��a/i� . I�.t�L/ • ._ / , I � • 1 1 1"• I ♦ : •�1 1• / 1 I I 1 •' 1 I i ' 1 1 i � ., �.�_/./. . � / � � .1 .�% � �� /. I /e,� .i.i i�i .//•' L_�_ _�I[ � /�[! �i°•�:..�.��//y ,/_� .iI/I'//� ►I�� '' / .� �- � �� '/. �,� _'. " �� / / / / / /, ! /./.. I.1/: ��!. . . /.�/�r�/� ��. � . �` .:`. � � � � J! � � ��/_�...i.�.: i. I ��, • / i �_�_ , i�.. _'�a..� / I��.I�.i i' _i � ..�i .I� :'i ir , ! � �/ _ • /�t; /. .�i�� '�.!u■ /i ./ / .1��i� � .fii . ♦ %�i ' • � � + //.�1L./I , � I - i . ' / . ,/ � � �►, / i, ,. � �I/.%. ,/. //.� . �� /� �/� „// , � _/ / .. ' � I. �.�_ .. / / � (_� �/. I � 'i�s �rL �/�_% . •�� a r�• •�► a. ••��o: r• � j ' � 3 • i" - � , � • • M 1 �� / I � �� ,I i� , I - � �� INSPEC 7rl N REPOR T ��YPUN c� �N.,,, ST. PAUL DNI,�I OF PUBLIC HEALTH � /- �i1 �R� 555 Cedar Str$et 292-7717 �� d� LLYHI� T /, /� ,/ ' Q�, � , � �a� -io9� �-��:,�� `nrture , DUE ON OP, APTER: • oQ 1-Routine v 2-Reinspect � IV '-- J-0ther �-- � � �33b °°"�'� ��' o � mon[h da ear Order � ;ro, FOLLOWING IN�RCNEME.'NT5 M[b� BE COMP D Il��DIATELY OR WITHIN THE TIME SPECIFIED � . � ,i � _ . FCOD TE2�ERATfJi2F3: i ;� �:�� oRn�s nAx�n — ,u� �n: '� . � Before an azietinq establiehment ie altezod, data a �Hew ar,d u:ed equipment to be iastalled �st be and oquip�rsnt epecitioationn shall be euLmlttad and approved �iSF apprvved or eciuivalent (See Sanitarian). the 9t. Paul Diviaion of Public Naalth. NOTICE RE(�IVED HY: 3ANTTARLI.�: � �d � J� �� "' ' ��✓I - Fo� E2/Jen 198A , . �� . , � . . . , r u � � : i � -.. � . . J ' ., . : � � �� , .�� !I � • , : // / � I / , i.� � �-L�iI .[� ' /�. �� . � t .� i.r . i�'�.�t: � �Y 1t'7T -i �•li` ✓1� ' r r • �- ��• / • ✓ / �_L 1. :� � - • � � � � i � , •�' t• � i � �� 1 �!.� � / � .�I .: a. �! i • . I i � � 1 1 I"� I � �• I' : I 1 I I 1 ' •' 1 I I ' 1 1 � / i I ' `y-=- f i/ .".� i tL_4i f �. _ 49 I! ' I .�. �� .I f � , � �i! <L� r � � � ..�.,_. . �.�. . , � ,.��r,. . �. ..�_ - � _ , . . �;. ...�, •'. „ .. , .,. �_- _., e - . . _!- . � ,._ _: - �e _ .� i , i � / �l .1 �_. ',.e� /�ri., ii.� . .i s � ��.i.� . I�'. . r . .� L�i ��, a� ,J♦ �.�.1,� � ..5� . I `ii / //.�)/.I,�i�� i -I • . //. �i/%L�i .� � '� ../ /✓. _�'.//. iI ,/. / : i/L_'iL _✓//_.s 'i� i -. .L� ✓ /,/. ,// . .� �i �/. 1 s: �� / /� . _�! �� _�� ! t�L . / / ,� /.�iL / 1'G . � l � . .�'.�L ✓/� �./f/ ,�` ..��/ ..I. / �iL��iliii/r�� /�r / . �� iLJ � - r �� / � / //.1L��L �/ � '/ :� ��// ��.�/�.I./•�//�,!. � �/.� %. / // / . � " '� i _/� ' � % / :r .i L.ifi . �II./ ' � � / �� _'��/ � t. Li/. ��. /i�l//i i��R. . i /r/ �� !/.��/� `� � � ��1 . i/ , � 1� / � ��r ` , /'�': �" %�1)It , �,�� ' /. �. .•a. rr!/,�/. �il 1�' i�� 1 . � Ir i� �� /I iiI , � � � �rI� • �'�lL/.�. �� /..�� , .�i / t� � '� i �.1. /i �. .� _ i. ..i. �� t.i •� /../.�/. .i� , . i .�i, i�� .il�� / i. ,:� . I � . r �/ u I�� 'a�� ,�I � �i�/� .•� a�•r• •o. - r � - % s �a. ••��•.: � � � s � � � I , � _ , � i� � ,.'ti - - _ � • • • w � : / � / � / � � .I/ IL�1L. Ii � • � � � � t� � i � , � � . � .� � • �, ' I . / i - -J f•\�c..a. - •,� �. .�aJ�� I�.�/�/ • b:�.�� r► �e• �.� Oar w�� , ' ' • •- ►s- � I . � � �/ - � r . `� % � /�, / �, / / 1/� / + •• � • . 1 � � I � 1• � 1 � � �� i' � 1. • •' •1 1 ' ► • • � �"�� .Ii��. ! � I.'/1/.�./_�//._s.... .'. �� ! i I . .1�i �'� �'.� �t►ii�ii� / / ��/ �� II!/1,i.�i." /L%1i �..�i� /!,�//. i �ilf'i,i / � �i. _ �� .ii_'i _� I�i�7�1..I.r / / / .Ji/. / �� '<I I."�� . /./,/!I �,.• �iit _h�_�/ `%1L./!/,.� 'L LS�. � .�, ' _ �� - , , II� �i.'i �� . � � /. _�LLI.�./. / i s' /_' .�L��. ! �C L _ �I /.��ii �' � � / % / ��/ .✓.�/L. /_iL� !�/.�r�G/'./_•I , / / /, .� ..�, iI /L�G.�l� �� i� �r �,/ Ir �s�_�� :_:!_%r ��. I .►;ii. _ � .�G�:� � /L! ��i , . . ' � _ 1ii.i/.'♦ i`, ��/. . �Ji_ /i'.'v �%.�� /.`ii �. � �iii..��i ,� �' L, .�' ��/L�/"7,j//.� �. ,�` �/��i// '. .t / :r:�c�= � . 1�1L<<' /� I ..'i_ , •`��...! � � � ! i .i' . ��./'� . .�i. ��L' ��.I.r_'i �r i ' /!•_�::� . . �.� �� .�. �i ��i�'►%�%1��:1 .��// .� � �L� �a .i_Ii� i�� . I(�./ � � �� / ��/ �� r// , � ' - / . .i�iii � /./1.��/r I �/. / � .ri. . � �.�1 ! /.�:i // i' /� � � /.�, ii_I.,�%�_ / � ► �/t./.� ..IL_/�.t.r ./_ _..�1� L i! �u[�! � � /�.L�� //. . ./ � '_... - � -o�L�/-'' � /�, /. . . I:1_'./ �/I�/ // ' �/��.' I►.%. �/ ' -/� /,��/ .�'/ /i /,i� ' � I/.l .�i./ i /� '.I�. �.i� ��' . .� /,I��// /, iI/�.��L.��.LL'/U �/ /I ' l .•_'� i � ��'/�. . . �I. .ii• � .: � ' I..'.� .i'.1.� ....��i.�/� /.�'/.�� ,I. % /.'ir.', .� �� ' �.�!, / / / / ... -�- .-.�: ,> .-.a-= . y� . � - . � - . . . 4 : .� �.. ,.., : �i �1:.... . .. I - - � , � . �� . . � . .� y � b � 11. ' � � / � � � i h\Ac-�r�. , !��q �� „ � � ��i J�. � i'_�� • — . b�:. / , ;y �e• �•� Jb� r�� -, • •• •a� ` ' ' � � ,� . . . . • �. /l ��.I: �( . / / , / •• �- �' . � i � • � � i• ♦ i �. i . �• i•, ; � � o •- �� i - � � � � � � • '' I `� .��.- _ .�., -- -r` - �.t_� ..,, ..[_ . 'r-._- �.,J. � i i � % / � i ri . ..i.' ��. _�-.1-�i_i // i �. i t i� . /.i:. � i/. .1 I:I_I'L� �!!1/�/' .c. . I/.'i • '�_ ��i i .i�_'iL �.' �� .!. . //iL. I.'.9.•r. i .�� ./ ,��i "iIt .�� ,�I./'L� tLL�� . _I .ii i� �i � .. � . _'d �� i /I/li.r ' � ,y� :J��,il/.. //1 ;i!�.:��'_�%I //�' /% � I ' /. !:�� l�, ii/hf '1 /�... 1 /� � - - - � � � � �� lt.�. :�/_'.R_ .,L./.i /l.��./�'��! I.' .�I s1a..� '�/.�)/ t/_' � 1 L' � � / � �..Ia-�.. /„//L / I_ . ///� .�/...�.a�' ./ ti�%� �a�/..��I� /►•�_/� / �/ / �:� � I�i!t�li/.�/L.'i . // ./ _i �' .t� L .� ././,I.�_'�// �// /, /: r ,� i �.I� ./��.��%�� i �r� �. ..�/.a_ ,i' /. � i�_:..�/_Jl_.t1►�1../.. ��i�I�61 �i�. �i.��.. i.._ ,. r. �`.,��.! �.�.' /. .'�rs./_;! :�_rl.�� i_� i_., � ��...�. ��' �.��J�� _ � ,��,�i..�/� ��_�i � ,_`�/L.�,. i� _ , _ , /�/ .��:��. _, / /.� , / �� . r' /.� :�� . ./ �I.��/. /L ,��. :� //,/� ��I .11��.� /I S 1 / � L./ /, i -� - ' � � •' r�•s—�-°w. � / � • '� �_5��!�1!/�� •�. 'a- r.> ��. •' �:.-- a. . � � - - i •: /� • �. � j /��1t.�1� � l�i��—! ; . � . . � . u i • �. � .�- i i � . +-7 T-�Ac'''a' ..��y �� ,l , �l.la��a / / ' %'� � �I / iI .. � I � � / , \Pi�.�� i f�f� - iy •e• w� Ja� ��w / , /�� . • •- ►a� i . � r • r • � / ' �� i � � •• �. � • . / 1 � • 1 1' � 1 �. � ��,P � 1 � ' •' �� I ' � � � 't�r� • ! ..� '� � � .1/�� / / � �. � I i -- ��.i�►. . <ti� �i. ��I � � /i . /'�i�� ' • • / � , � �L� I � _��L..2 ii:� //�G '� � , � � / � i � � �.i. _ _ � �.. � / �! L.� � � .•.1/_ � � i r � �_✓/��itL i i� i, .y � ��I.iC �� L � �a.�1 � � t I/_'�ii _I / / / ; . . � i • �� SII . �.ir ,JLL Ii:i i LL.. � / � i _L�I� �i ! r / ' � /l A��i�� / /`�/ � ri/.L./ �/ . // ia1 t t� I ,�/ ' L�a �a�:�r./ I�II� �I./.-'I' ../ .lI �•�_�I_� � � rL. , . . �/t ./_ _,/ .S_�� :� / ,I..�� t�' � :.( i/�/ � 1. :� . 'flr l / / I I � / i ��t. _ L.'.�.! ,.I� � I�. . /. ' s � / � ' � �s _I ;.... ,� � ',��i i�.. i �:�_>i. .� .� �, � � .� � U � - /�.'_ , i,i. ..� i<_. � /. ' i'� ',l� � � � L!�..s . L ,�/�.�'aalr . . % d�i.�� // �11'.,, � �i � � / r� / ./� •.• ., r._ . �.i. /.� /i/ , i s. i i i, .�/ _1 �i � �� , � , � ,�, � � ' �. / _I.f. . �. . 11 �.1.�'/ � � .� i � i �IA_'.�� / ... ,•.�: ,� .-.r� y. - '� ■ - ��. � - .. . � � /� � � , . � , � /,I I �-� � � � +r . . � � I� • ' : 1 ' i i � �•- � ' - � � I � w � i�� - �� % .,' �'J!..,' �..c Iw� ,•., ,,, �� _• � : �• - . ��•�: `' � ' A-Y ��t�Y -�"� ��ii r� Yi.. � ! �, �� ., . � r � •• �r• I ' �li ► 0 r i � - 1 � r9 1I." ,.�t ._I�I� . /�,� , •• �� ,� . .: ►" I • �' 1 1 I`-• I . : �� 1•I 1 1 I I' 1 � •• 1 I I ' 1 1 U// .�1.�i_ /I �! . i�'.i �! ii� i .��. « i �1.i�/� !s�i.�fi' .�ii�.!� .,i ' % � � , iI! � '�/��1,�/�.�_ � ' i.� �L!_' -I�i�%iL.I�,, // %.�i. . /i� il, i !. .�lii�� • � � � � � / � , ' , .' �iI. rlli ' i�/��/�1�� T17��/,�,� '_�!�/ .,,_�i// � � . ��/ �t !�_i_� / ' ►� /.iS � i ii � /�� I ' �� /.�7.J.��L� �� I / J• , / ' a //. L� /. _� i/ . ." / .�_.// /./i i/t % �� `�-i_ ��1� _� � �. .i � �//!!�`I L�/ // ./ .I /' � ' � � - ►� I '�._LI'�J if ;.i/ iri�. ii. r[� I .. '�� .�J. /. . � / / � Jw/ i•i[ir.r ii � , ; . _�1�� i � / � .i. �.i ,/,d �� i.. , t �... I . �> � � ' � r � J/. ,I/.'� '/ ♦ / /�! , ��_/ �a �I A �]I�[iR�!�� II�� ...� ii1�. �I� / �r/f/ �� / �ild � � �/ � ` - I.i � II � / � %I� I �I, i/i . J ...a�//./i Ii .I / ' %L_� I� f `�i, i , .�. .//./.��i � � .►�. r��,G_. i� AI :�� !.�// , i♦ L��.� i�'�/ / � �_/L/"/ / .' �/. /_�_ � _ I � � % : � / _ •� � �� '� /,� � / .� !� �I / /L►. �c i �/I /,/.I /� . _1 .L //.L��' � � ' ; - �1/. ' .... .� / /L . . . � �'�/��'/ �/� .�i/ : t_'_-.. . �,�r�� ;/.�..;�/, L�,/►�i�ril . ✓./i .i � , /L�� ..L7, ,/' �//� /A �r/. � [./_'.:r njr1�/�I , , r �.LLLti"tr" �,i ii �.�.[� / � �i�//_�� _d .. . .� :�.'I///./,//.' / . /L '_ �r►.-/. �� /�is.I.��y � // 'i _� ' � / . � . ." • !/_ ,�J_'�1.:11. � / G__ _� �.i /.c�ii!��. .� . . !�. /..• ,� i /_ ..�. �, i/•. i �/_J�r __ / � /�c�_'�� s_ � / �i � � s�� ■ � /'�irI. � _ �� .. �� •/. % III � !� .I/, /� / L:v. ./. �a i ///// 'I �1_.� ✓ �./ / / .IIJ �� i�" � /I� L,��/l.' •��. �. �i I �.►./ .li. _� !. .��L. /L. � � i!I'i i!' . /. �i!,� �i./ � L.... � ' j ', / � -/ ��.._t . ' � � �.. . . �� .�Iri� � /� . i/. ,�' /� � .. � �L1LL:�1.�.�. t ' L.L. � � �r, ••� arr• •�. �x ••�a•.: �� z r � i � � � � ,�. � ,� - - - � - - - � �, �� • M � '�, L � . . . ' ` ..� .��i ;�� , � . . � . � , , ,� � , � v � / • , � 1�' • • C I ' ■ • . ' • • M l _ � :-1i. . r: ir . .r�� / � /� , �./.�ir� !�_� /s .. �r•�::: v►Y ��t�Y 'i� ►�•� ✓\II Y,•. /� , . � r • �• ��' I I/ � �I �� ` / ♦ " . • / •• r � � • .- I • � 1 1 I•'• � � : �• I• ? I 1 I I 1 ' •• 1 I I ' 1 1 .��i .��/ .iI/ . / I /1� :�/ �/ // . �I. I./� �.i► � // � :��_/ • . L.1/.. ./ �I _, / � ��Ll. _i.1 : �� ,'J/�.� �L �L! ..'_._�� i�_ �L.ii. i'/ .� � �/i� I �i/ J `.�� . .� /,�s . � / � a�/.',i/i / �/,,/. L .�1. // , !i . L�' .i,/ , / � / . .:I�/.�1 � .. : !/.� . �� .�1/�.i�i I � � � I � � • �• � //.��/ �� !� /.�f :� i�� i,i .: _ i�.�' �t . � ' . i�i . _-. :.ir._. � _� �� . � � ��I/'7`.i - - / - / �./l w � /, . �////�3/_ i/. � /ii . i .�� dt ��J��l'. 'i / 1 / . _ _ �l. ..� �� .I '�.�a_'.rR.�.r �t� ..� �l/��..� / /' i1' / I��f/.�.� � � � � � � � � � .i :i.i1'_ f �.! //.' :�ilff!� .. � �' • //./. .�_ � � � � /• ��+':,• �G�'�� ,v �,� !!G ��. ..- _� ,.I.7J�'�[.�'��C�!�/i% ./. ��1.Ii��i�.L � . ��r .� .�/ •� ��1� iI/ ��/iy.�.. i �_ri/.� iii i�„�/j _%r,��'s�. i . ., �� / I / / [�/�! / .iL1 / . / � // /. //.I/I�/� �I �I,._i �I�.� .1_ I _I�/. /.w'�� L _�: � I � I � - , � - /II � , ,� �/ �./`� :17 , , / / ' �� ///. . �.i�I!/.��! i/ // � .r:�ii�� :..i�/_� l�.�l�l � . i. _/•.'��_/.1 i/: t:. � . �r:.._� � . � �� _ / � � � � , / � l /, � �� i � ar. .. ,. . � .r1_ .�.�.J:..�. ._ .. , i �...r .1 ... , � . �.� , � I �. /� _ �I.' /.�' '_ 1� / i.� nJ�,7��/% .�'/ .:�:ir� i �� L'L.i� i � / �, � � '� �' it�.�.1,I� . .� .IIII./ /ii. /I. . .j/[ — / i ..�.i� / I �iJ.. , /= �[�i. '� I.IL� �! . .�. ��JI. L �.. ..�'� �r��.L ! iL . , �� / , ./ /.1 ! .si:,L_ ./, i1i � L.' / ��,::�%[�i�C�.r_' ��. _� /r ,,� ' i' .��ri�i ="- - / � � � / � — I/.�' �'_sIl�.�J / . � - - � /,l. :� ' / �t ,� ..� l.' � �_�r« �_�%% ` �_'�I �/�� :.� .� : /.i � �i.�. .�i71. .lis"��. � �.:� '�,/Ki, ii !i� ..� � � � �� I , � .►��, � !/�.. � � / / ' /I/�'/ �/ I . , . / .�i . �II� . '.�//� �/I . .' /1�'lL'!� . - � / i I,/,�� I„' t ',�)�/, 'i� � I.i /..rt. , ii/i.i.i/.�:� :/1� % '/" /i�.� w�/, 1��.1��. . .i .'. ` !'.i :��i,I�l.�. r�i � . % ! . i. . i i.l�l A ei iJ�i)i.i �%.1..�j!1:,�illi ��.0_ .�� .i ::�� _�w �i�, _�. . � �,,,�j�• , , �► . /.� '..►�L ...I/I1.�/,/. //I��t I .� �r.� . I�/��./ � .�/.�. �/ /L t� 1� .!//L.�`/ �� i � '� i�/l�i+J/ .� /, � ,/l. � / / /.� . �/ !. . �� .� � i - / ' I '/ . .i i /'sI ' i'L �i /.I . �✓ sJII . .� r�i . . :..II11L I.I'.. ��.I. _��_:�/� /_/I i� �'�.�. � '� iJ� � . ,�� .- . .� .r� . .� , . .., �,.�.. .,. �. ..,�•� , , � , ■ - - ■ ..� - - - � - � r , ' � � . . • « , : � , � ` . . : // / ,i. .i.c.�� , . � / , � �, , . I �! ./I I , i r • � r r. n • � : � i � ■ -. . - - . � ► � : ►: � �'' /j� �/• / 1 ��/ ,.///� �� .�/�ii Lif /�'.� � •��e: � � ;�1-� ��t�Y -i� t�� ✓\II � � �,�� /L . r � � •• ��• �1 - - � • ■ � •• r ! / • . 1 • • I 1 I• '� I ti ; �11 I' I 1 1 I I 1 ' •' 1 1 I � • 1 1 � /. I./� �L�l /G ! 1.�1_'�✓/ � L � �'L'. � � . �= .��/_��.. � .��l�l _�L � . / ' � / i� � / • �1/' � //�.i1. ' ._.///i.i/! /,' :i/.J/I ■✓.' ��/-' -� : � �l/ / � r : �_ � � . ��/ �'�i , :,. . i��r ' i(__ ' /.'. .« . ��.��% � !�_ �r_'..ri� . � , "� �. I . •. � . / � . / � .�i .i .� � i�// �I �L..t ��i . I� r _I � i// i . � � / � I��_ .I.�t/ . `. / I I .I / //. / .ii /,��/� �.�i.i�`��1 I�. . ..�� /�/. . , �i/ �i .i.� .. � i r / � � , � / � � �r �. .�: � !, �r. ./�I .i��. � '/�i � � � � / � / ..� . .� _I� uI_.�s � i !//v/ �L. �-• .L_�. _i ��//��, I/� i�_ / � •1.►/r .�. . �_' I�! 1��/_i�� ► � L � / , , . / ��i,�'i� . �I.Tr'., r.[.�L_� i ,. ,.. _� �i. ' ,� '.•r.<<t � ' .!�..— -'-�� , , � , -� ,. , -�. ,�:T1.' ,.�/7�� .�ft r.i �� . � - i�l .;- / / ./ /I �'��.�L �t � � �Gi�/�1/.l �� /'�t ' i iI L.:�, l.i�./ ��i � 1 I , ' . �. _ � / / �! '.� . �l//// "i/i /i/I. _//I, . t' ��/. � //� ,If �� I�e1 'I !/I�i� '��.',/� .:� _ / � �I� !�� . u. /. i' '/ ,-�i � ��,�� . :Il. _� ! L.%� / '�r�.� . � / .�.i!r�,c � • '% ' i ./l '' �/ / ..��I� II �//I. � � � .I - .I�I�l� .�� i ! .i��ll� I_.. �' �' !�'.. /� � /I � i/� � � �� • I.� i�/r I iL .� � , l /�.� iI ./1��.! �.� � �. �i�! � ��.i�� .�� _1 �_:� ..: _ � � __� .�.� .�J . _� � I I aI �� ►_ I. / /� c_� /i_ ' � /1�/.:�� ' i I_', i / � % L.I� _ � _,.. /.� / . I . L' tL._ � • � �_• 1/ LI�/ �. . . .�� / G,�.� ��1/I� .� 7t:� / �� / i1 �' �I/ 1 ,/ I � � � I / �' / � ./ I I � l. / `1. � �. / �i/. ! .�I/ / ./.✓. //, � / ,� �' � I•i,, i � l . � � � �� . , I , . . . . • �r . /. ��/.r_.�.. t ,I.ifi ,.-� �. /. .� �/. � .� . � , � , � %.: /� /. �, ; �/ .r . I ��. ..'I �l � �._:1 . .L_'. ��I .' •��.i . .. ��! �l- � � /� � �R� � � � ./.� // / f/I /�' �/,� . • _� .•� a i•�• •�. ia. ••��•.: ► � r � � s. - - � .c� - � _ �� f� • . • « � : ,��r y ' � � � � �.�#�'�1��i ' . �( , � � , � ,/' ,/ ._ � , ►�" � r " 1 I i1' � ' : � • _� . � J ■ � i�' ' I I.'� •t' i �� / �. , . _Jr. i��i ��_��.��_ �, ..�.: �� •��c � % olY �jt�X i� �•fi ✓�11 �'• I � ■ � r • •• �• � � �� / i ■ • .• �• � � • . � � • ,� i �• •• � y�,ti : �� • n;r�° � � � t � �• � � � � �� / /// � I//1/.� .��i 1 I �� . • � / ' // /1�I� / :�L%� /, � .�.i .�I�.� /. �I.�'�, iI I' /.y. �•.�c . � �/.:. � . . - - /I / i. /./� .�J . � � / /, i1 . � ! . �.� � . I_ d�� '.J/.." ,/ / .� ♦�.� ii a I /.I .i/. � � // " — �I � � .,� i // +� �.• �. � .., _ .. . ♦�� '.�� ! . �� ,r�l. I/�.1: � L. .� ./. .� �111 i /1�/ . ' Il. I � ./I- / �. . � / � ► � ' - -� � / ! nh .l.' � �I7.'L I'.� .�r/ ' �/. // i ! I '..!.r� .IJ/1L� �� r . �./ �- i I i .�� _•■-/!.( � ,�. / ! .S / •'�/ � i � �I �ir f . / ',, �'i / '.t t , �l� ii' .�II_' �/ .I.'// "//. '�._'_.�i�i! _-_�1.�ii_'.� %. . �/. t I./ i�. �I/ './'//i �''I/I�'! �I/..:.� ./.�.:�.� . �,� � � � I .► ��i.r �/ � . �.�///t. . . .'� i ��' . � �. i//1 i/i /, ' i� • � •,i i " / �.�/ ,/ 1/.►� l!, i i + � � / ' �.�'1� . ./ . ./!� ,/ ./.:.r ,i ��. .�/ . f. t1/.��A .I� � .I_; � i_ //i .i '1 � � �� . //�// I //, .._. i/ // �� i/_��/I I///.' ; � iia�/ �/., / L��!/.�.:� �� ' /l� --� - ./,�. �� / � L! � � _rli.��I �� I,. i i . �I �. .:�. _I I. . ��// / / s , � � ��/ _' r/. , � . �� ✓.��/ �r��1./. .I �/�/././ e�I/ /_� �/.�L.. �� i�/_��1'� �• �!_..� I , -� �+-LL"—S4 , �. .i�R� _I �. ;//I.�i. �,l //i.� . . /I �'. . _./ �II/!!� /� e ♦ i� , �L �I 1/%L' / � . .i �i��I�G iI / ��, /. .� , , // i .ir _.� � !`' _LJ�'/ �.� ; ',V ii /. ♦;!/ . ./.4l, ,� I.�:.•:� /!,i /'� i�rL _' � - �:, � ' Tr L'J ' ! / � - / .L.� �L f/. % � 'i I.A ',,d. .i ./ ,/ /.' i / �i/�� .I. ��/. /. .l , /, .•! /.l:.r _ ��///. % ,/. , I �i 1 �1.'�� .!� ' //,y/��// / _ - , � • - � ' / � �` +� ` ..� � �•�• -�. ��. .•�a•.: � � � � ■ - - � ..-, - - - - , - - - - , , /� ,I � o. / . � . . N , , G .! //,� ,�. �,�._ r!r .� . .,.�,�r- - � ��1'�J 1N� H INSPECTYO REPOR T K L '(_„1 x.,�, ST. PAUL DNI�ICN OF PUSLI� �ALTH 3 Iv� � 3�a �R-� 555 Cedar Stre'et 292-7717 �nc,"''�_"� � � � � c-r�z aaS - �D 90 ` /��a� �o ° so I .�-��. o �-:�. 33 8 . � � «� � �: �_Ro�t�,. r-- i , :-�t.�:,sp.cs � � � �-0[h�r � � �nta •ar �� UlWf1 Cj ��'` F'OLLOWIldG II�SPc20V�.5 'sibT Hn D L'..�DIATELY OR +rlT:IIl�1 T:.�"r. TL*� SPECIFIED �. — ' �ei� GU� �-rz� K d rr� �� . � D ' , � - . � � �ooD��za�s: r�sa � tytrm u� �D: . QB�foz� aa �zirtit+q ��tablS�hr�►t !i altered, c'ataiLd �t �T7�rr ar� us�d �quipm�nt t� b� instal:�d �st b� +utid �uip�nt sp�cii:oatiosu shall b� n�mitt�d and ap�roe ' b� I8t �pso+d or puival�t (9�� Sar.:tazisa). tl+� 3t. Paul Dtrltion ot Asbllc H�a2th. • YC:Z� 1LC�MD 87: 3hHILlRSAFS�� •m�/YLff)'LCO,��'��'L�i�' - Fo�t Lt/.'an 19eQ - r _ I '---` I �O � :� / � . , . � �:�"�"': � CITY OF SAINT PAUL �� DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICES � i�iir% :� il �'� � e � DIVISION OF PUBUC HEALTH e�"� I SSS Cedu Street,Saint Paul,Minnesots 55101 George lotimer ', . (612)292•7711 Mayor F�ebruary 17, 1987 � . . Mr. Joseph Carchedi License Division 203 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Uaar Mr. Carchedi: � I am recotm�ending deni�l of the lic�ns renewal for Pacific Garden Restaurant at'�338'St:';Pet�'Stree�+. rec�nendation is based on past inspectional history, the most rece�t spection of February 11, 1987 and in particular: 1. General sanitation has beed� r peatedly lacking (7th notice). 2. P+otentially hazardous food� e being kept at img�roper tec�eratures (4th notice). . 3. The sheer number of noted �io ations from February 11, 1987 inspection. 4. Failure to co�ply with the�f code, dispite repeated tags being issued. I request yrxir action in this matte.�. � Yvurs ly, t�� ; � 2 , �� ' F k A. Staffenson Environmental Aealt irectar FAS:jr Enclvsures c: William Gunther � , � . . � � ' , � � , � � �/ �i. � � � ■ • i ' _•� ' � ' � . . , _� : � / � A1: �� - �� .��y /1 / I � � .. i I � � �' � �.�1� .�i!I./. .'/ ,�.'_I./�.. ./.:.rLj I • I I , 6 •Tr`s: / Y-v 1 t�Y i� t�•fi ✓� • '•. � � - � • •• ��• / � � n i�� / � - . - • / ' � , •rr . � � �' ��l.yi �� i� . ��.��// � � I • • 1 1 I"� I ♦ : ►• I' 1 1 1 1 1 ' •' 1 I I • 1 1 . // ' / �rL:/ .�- -/. ,r. ' �/./i/i iI .' .I,;_L .I/_' //. .� � ��L_� �L✓/../'I.I . I/. _�1 ' Ii�'.�<L � / .��/..�1.%..i" I.�l/1%i1�L.� � _��ii11/.� � .../� ��,i!'. �� i.�.�_ I, � , ,� �!�ta� �J,'! i� �1� �� .r_i �iii�.� ./1_ � ' ��:�1' / � �,� ' _ . . /. .� � i✓/L:� � // ! I.1'l.J� � � /.' .�'tv .�. i � '�� ./_�..[:i[�' �_/L� " t�i .//L� �.�, _�..� L�L� �iG�..�' . . �I, �,!/, . .ilt �/ �!/L ` �1��!.. � ' // '' • , L / /�: I ii. //. i // /_, . .. . .i .///� ././ � �. i� �/�t i /, /-' ..S1L�I_= L�.'/. .. • ..1.._ � ..� /� -� I.'. d �_'��d...c�i. J/��.�� i .I.(i.�.�ii.� � il,ii��i � � � . , � . � , ��.i�.i�.� //.��I. �.i. % .� ./'!t.//_'..��..�� ./, % .�/ � i i � • •_ii �i� I i.. � :� �'!/.I�%I%1,� �/i .�/.' � �.i!<� :. i � �" if�_�_ /, L,LI � i fr �L�:�^ ��L.'' � /I .�./i_�L� ��I/ /��< � � �/ Is /./� -�! ' I , � �/, I,� ' �'_' e� : r' Ji1'.� I� � � � t/ '� ��i i �/ � / L�/.�I . iL./. .• � . . UiL�LL�/. ► � , �/. '�... . �I,// /L,�/ �, ii ` /:I/�/%Jr/. i�./t �:�// �� / / / ' ./'�/it:��i �....J.' / :� i� i.� . !I.�.. ii, _i � � L_,.l.�i �,/. .i�.� gii �.� , � �'�� ► , , � ��,!�J�'r��J,R�� i � .� .��. �I � /// II/ :I. / �!I�/ � / � .I� / .�� /� � . .� � I�`.�/ . ./ � r � ; �i111�� . / � i/ � i� %.�� , i/I� i / / � �� /�LI' ' / � `` �.// . _ , �I�./�� iLi� . . J " . .�1, i �.�� r..2� .[_'!� � i i i f�'�� .I.. � • � ./ .✓,._ . � �I-�` - ��.�i%7'/.� I��i_� .� � � / �, � � '�.,.�'i. .. . - i I.� . :. _.. .. ��1. ..il i1/. i � iJl�/� . � _ / ; � , i'[�u�./ /.'.%`.I L.�/.. �.. � .ii /.I. .t�. /�/ � i � /�% , %/.'. �� :� �/!..�� . i �i,i��.� �. i<' I L� . .i L / �I/ / • / � �/1'. � .' . r:.. � .�_ . � ... , /..�. �l �� . _ i!�S► / .�� i� / /. / � t i !..�1 /� /.!. . ./ / , i i / •�i a r�. . .� ia. ••��•.: �� • � � �� .i � � .�� - � / � A . • « ► : � � � �l � � ,. . �� . � � . � � �� , rr ,� ' ■ . , � - -�� • � i _ . _. , • . ■ ., � � ;a ..,,, � G_^ !� �' �� . . � �./ �.i . i � :��I � .� .�.� ,. ��•ix. � �Y'Y � t��► i� i�� r• � ' � � • •- r• I � � ��.�'t ■ � / - ■ • .•� �• � ■ . . i � •' 1 / r•� i . �• ,i� • � � i i r � •• 1 i i � I � / i� �. .� � '.i� .%1L. .i . �L.�� i/ I ii, �I/.'..!'!L ►�% i � ./._. � _ -� - iL_'�A ' � / / - / I /i ` '.11i�i��/. i • `'"� I�/�� ! .,: . ,�� `i �_l "'iIlll I/ .�!. // �I� I I�� I� _��/1 �i1/.�. i/ � ��1 i/ �.�ahLa._. �/ � �.i.� �'./_� I �.i/L L�.t�� .��i, �� /�L / � � Ly I . �� / � !��/f�/ � � i��r� ��I.�L///� ./ L_�� L�It�<� � � � � � / � � � / ��////11 / . ;I '..►�L i�//I//� % //L.. %�/.I ��/ /1 . �L '.��./.�i � ./'/L� �� i / � � 11 / ./!t_�:j/L. �i . Lr./ �I .� . /,/.�i�/.i'�� //'. . �i� �a: � L � _ . � .�.�i � / /, .�� _�:�//. /%r w ;I� .� !.: . d/. . /! .I,/. � / � ��r_ ► � <�� i ./ .�/ I ��/_'.� /L. i/i ./_' rn..� ! � ,/t.� ./�%/./. !L_�L �i/%..! � �./I, ��/ ��%.'_�� .Iii//,� �!I/. d� �. �:..7.�i'%J�. ./�' � i/�� % �� . � _ �. .� �i '�il��i._� �.� ...� . .L.� � ! �� 'i I� � . � � / . , � :� -; � /,ii,� ��t.�. �..�- :-' � �� ' � i - ' .!. .. :./.i! ii.� � ..riili .��i' / �: / ' /�:/�'�� lj s � ' j ' / li7��t/ �i � / � /r i / � � � �.S /L. i • ' i / i I � � i � / /�. �.�/. . L / _ � � �./.l. /L��I �L...d �� _� �� ' � � � /�, // � / � ' «� �. r �u /�//�� . I �i� .e��. / i�.:/. . �.� �• i/ �� _'I � �I. Iii�i s / �I I � �� / II . .� �i � / ,� /� � � /I.�� / �/ i � �/ I' � /I � � % � / i i / '��/!�L t �/�` = � / , / :�i!/.[� �/L� /i /� ' / / i LLi � � i L ,/,/ ' ,�.�//I� _ - - i � � __f_'i i ,% /�� I� � i /�� _' �� % �' /�I_, / ,� / � , / . . . , , �l. ./J. / /.:�i.�/ ��. ./,►t � . �L' ' ..�r. � i�_ �' - .i /t.� i ' � i . //.� i . .r//r/. � ../.[�%L�..L_'��l ,/ � � ✓l. '_//. .I. _� 'L...�.�i � � �1/!'' .1�i. �•�� _' �f/ �'� /�� ..iI�1�� I. ,u(��,�[_/�� .:.�1 ��1L. � I �/.' � � / �/ / :��%�� . � ' � ��Ii/. ..t/ _i � �� <. .lr i. ��/ _� / / ��. _ i � ��. /L_:. i�vL. �. � �� - ' - - .•� a rr• •�. �x ••�a•.: � � ► � � j� � ,.� - � / i • • • M � : � "�� /� L � �t...I/.��L...j. .,.� 'LQ � � ,r � " � � , � � r -/ / � / / ■ • � � �, � • � / � ' c� c - ' i •' � / � ■ • •� � ti i �a �� / �/. L /.I ��/ �.� � �I� �/� �.��/, � � ��i>t: ' �?IY It�Y i� bTe r ��• . r • •- ��• - . • I •• �� • . I � � 1 1 I"• 1 � i •� I`I 1 I 11 1 •' 1 1 1 � � � 1 • / / / � :.. iI ,. � ../ iL.'. l. . �! � i�� ir. � �.' �/�� `�:.1�/ys.�.' � , j ,� i � (/ . :�% �.il i/.�, �ti /.� ! /1L /L ' , r/,�[%/Iii ��%Ji ' .�/ � �_9.1:..._ �� / / ; r�� //:�.' • .�1.'i /.i��. LL'i .� �tJ� ,..� , .�li�� . � �� _i_! �. «� �i/. /✓t/.�!'�,�'..L� !. �..�[iii., , . _ � ' . '��i�! i � �,i . . / .� !!'/�/ . _�i /� /I� _' ! %.� � :I ...�_ . .% � t��/L � .�1.. ..! E / . . .: � � v / . .i� ►'I /. . .��. .� : . / /./ /L,.i. ��/r . .' � / /,i .��i%, ��.' ��'/� !✓�.i��I �/iC��I�. .�i t.' :1i/L`_.� -�=�� /I i � / � /��I .i � �� / �L/ //�� ♦ � / !/ ' I / �/./1 . /.:/�:�il.�,� !I/_��✓ .�/ ��./�.s:�L��.' / IL � � / � * � I :nt. '/i ,/i '/./_ �i��lA ��►.� • /:I .�.l� I / ► � * / - .� �Il/♦ /1 /./: L.�.�� '/ ��i1_� /. / �� _�� /.�: /� � /, , / � r /� /` ;i � .?,//�l�l�/� - �. .�,t .�. .�i.i.�%ii��: L'' /. .� ..' .. � . ��_ - �� • � � � /L�� /!L✓/I . // �1� iL_'L .r� i:/l/!/_� �� / � I / I � �/ L. it � � � � a� . ./� :/1 . /./1. ./' � [��/.;G�7t/ �1L._.� � ��I.'_�/� 'i / i - . .I:/..'/ '/,/1/1// �il�./ �� !/ � 'L ./L�J.d1. '� � . i � , �►,� - ,"�i'/��/�!! ' i /I �i, i�.� _��I._ iV.L /� ' i /�L�'.i • / // � i� � /. '�! ��, .� . i.f//L�/. �dL_�� a��!'i �L � � ./LtLa-�' � � /a ��-'� '� � � l-r// � ✓ //. . ��/. �:.�w�i,/� i// .�//. :U./_✓J ..i _� !� .�LI //. / I � �• � � �A%.'/LL.��' � � / - . � _ . . Il/1/� I.'_ � .'i /�il..ii i i. . /:��i ♦ i / I i � _i/ - i` . i � � � , � • , / / , , / i �l/1 L ✓." ��= / �.� L"�i� _ / �� / � i .� — -i�� `�� ' / I .�.sI �� _ .I.i ��"� • I � / �I A ►�:�I .�/�� i�it_ /� I �' �y �I i �,i`.�L�iri � . I �L_, �.�� . �:L/n � - i � � �j� /.�. �l �'� � .•�-�1� � / � a�� Ill �)/i � �i .i� i / , i� i � � . i. . / r � / , • � i � / ..� � �•�• •�. : �. .•�a•.: �� • � ■ '� � .� - � ' /, . . M � � �,� `_ � b .Z / � �c�/ r � . � � . � S� i � � l � - • 1 , - -• • • I I _• : ' � _ . �� .� ■ •T�,� �I . . � . ��.//✓./.� LL ��i��''.L�.�� b Zae: � �Y"� 1l�Y i� i�b ✓ • �•. ■ � r • •• ►�• i � �%�.�� , .. �• � -��. . . i • • � � ►• -• � . ��,.i� ;�� t � � � •• � i � i ' � 1 � ��I' I "��/�i%r � / .i�i� �. . _i ■� � il� � •, ,i_ ; . � . , i��'?.�-��-�i_r.�'i.7,cltLTr;►i�� , r � � / , ��i �� , � I e// '�. i�. �a�/,.t �'�/. ., . �✓/�/�LL.rJ� / ..�.//I// .I i ' f1 i///.' /. 1:I�/..�1. i:.:.� • �i�/'_i•' /�� / .. .. ... , /-.. ��i�� . i !.i1.'... � �1 ' � � . ' '/f��✓!L'i� /6/L.��:rlLi �L�t�r_.-�- - � . �.Il�/ /. i /. .� � i ii� ',e � / �./ /,/�I� �L� � ��/. ildl. /.r,�I� �/ A� i/.i1 /Q_ � � � /�,.,�� ' ��/� '� / L�/_ �./L... � /,/✓//. .%' I/ �I_:'_/��!.L d �/.' i.riL�.. �. ii i %.�i ./ %.T!. . ./�!�i�s� _�� /��1.I� � iL_� i[�. . � ' , ♦ //.!t� , iL.ii� .�/ /. i.i ./ � . ., , i .Ii �` � ��.�//L�/1.�. �/� ,/_I. ./ � / �//. I�/ . / %. . / � .'� � .�I . . �i . � � _ /i�_. _/� � , ./ _ /: ./� !. _�� /.I ! . 1.�,�._�_ � / �,.: .._, _: ' . � � /i� ii.► /.�i�' i' �' tr.� ��<i' ' t:�� / _ ..:ii� . �ii_ �� i .i� !!!(�., /. // ,L//// ! /. i �. �f_�li � /- -'� .�i /I%/ /A� /:i . %..�el.' I' lL. � � // / . / ��_� fr,� .I.L_".�/r"w i � i � -:, :il%/ /j' IlU.� . /i� .�. . :;�i� . ,�,. .• • , j %, I r�/ _ '� yi. � ' //. � ! �/. �� i! r1 .� � ..f + � � �..�.�i% � / i � , �� n, 1/ ' �i:[. �/. '�/ � /.�'. .� '_� .i,�1. ' �P!�s. ./ '!' � --�- -��' � '�-- / � �/. / �✓!i2� � ./L �� i/ �/. .r.� �� //L //i � � . /._I /,�:' .l_iri _ � � / /, .�ii. � /. . ' AI/.�.!��i. ��►'��:, _� ii '� ' .i� � / / ' ' ..� ��•�• •�. ,�. .•,�•.: � , z . . ■ '� • � - ,� , . • « � : . �fic�� / . .,. . � � FOOD SERVICE RATING SHEET �� '�� PAUIE; D VIS ON OF PUBLIC HEALTH STABLISHIKENT DATE • � // � � month da ear DDRESS , ESTABLISHMENT CODE 3 3 $ ,C�. �� , � COLiJMrT AND WEIGHT NUMBERS CIRCI�ED AND ITEMS NO I COMPLIANCE (SUBTRACT WEIGHT POINTS FROM 100) ITEM . COL. ITEM T. COL. ITEM T. COL. OOD 18 GARBAGE AND REFUSE DISPOSAL O1 SOURCE: SO[1ND CONDITION, NO PRE-FLUSHED, .SC PED, SOAKED 33 CONTAINERS OR RECEPTACLES,COV- SPOIIAGE 1 48 ERED ADEQUATE NUMBER, INSECT/ 5 31 19 WASH,RINSE WATER: CLE ,PROPE RODENT PROOF,FREQUENCY,CLEAN 02 ORIGINAL CONTAINER: PROPERLY TEt9pERANRE 2 63 IABELED �� 2 49 34 OUTSIDE STORAGE AREA ENCLO- 1 32 'k20 SANITIZATION RIN E: C •AN,TEM SURES PROPERLY CONSTRUCTED, OOD PROT'ECTION ERANRE,CONCEN ION,E%POSURE CLEAN:CONTROLLED INCINERATION 03 POTENTIALLY HAZARDOUS FOOD TIME,EQUIPMENT,U NSI S SANI- 1 64 MEETS TEMPERANRE REQIdBEMENTS TIZED INSECT,RODENT,ANIMAL CONTROL DURINC STORAGE, pREpARATION, 3 50 *35 PRESENCE OF INSECTS/RODENTS - DISPIAY,SERVICE,TRANSPORTA- �"'� 21 WIPING CLOTNS: C , TORED, OUTER OPENINGS PROTECTED, NO � TION 5 33 RESTRICTED BIRDS,NRTLES,OTf�R ANIMALS 04 FACILITIES TO MAINTAIN PRO- 1 51 3 65 DUCT TEMPERANRE 22 FOOD CONTACT SUR• CES OF E- FLOORS,WALLS AND CEILINGS 4 34 QUIPMENT AND UTEN ILS CLEAN, 36 FLOORS;CONSTRUCTED,DRAINED, 05 'fF�RMOMETERS PROVIDED AND FREE OF ABRASIVESI,DE RGENTS CLEAN,GOOD REPAIR,COVERING IN- CONSPICllOUS 2 52 STALIATION,DUSTI.ESS CLEANING 1 35 23 NON-FOOD CONTACT URF CES OF METHODS ' "-' �� 06 POTENTIALLY HA2ARDOUS FOOD EQUIPMENT AND UTE�iSIL' CLEAN 2 66 PROPERLY THAWED 1 53 37 WALLS,CEILING,ATTACHED EQUIP- 2 36 24 STORAGE,HpNDLING F C EAN E- MENT CONSTRUCTED,FOOD REPAIR, 07 UNWRAPPED AND POTENTIALLY lUIPMENT/UTENS_ILS__ 1 54 � CLEAN SURFACES,DUSTLESS CL =� � HA2ARDOUS FOOD NOT.R$-SERVED 25 SINGLE-SERVICE AR IC S,STOR- � ING METHODS 2 67 � 4 37 AGE,DISPENSING, U$ED LIGHTING OS FOOD PROTECTION DURING STOR- ' 1 55 38 LIGHTING PROVIDED AS REQUIRED, AGE,PREPpRATION,DISPLAY,SER- 26 NO RE-USE OF SING S RVICE FRTURES SHIELDED /' VICE TRANSPORTATION �- ARTICLES , ' 1 68 � 2 38 2 56 VENTIIATION _/ 09 HANDLING OF FOOD (ICE) ATER 39 ROOMS AND EQUIPMENT VENTED AS MINIMIZED *27 WATER SOURCE,SAFE� HO AND REQUIRED 2 39 COLD UNDER PRESSU�E 1 69 10 IN USE, FOOD (ICE) DISPENSIN 5 57 DRESSING ROOMS UTENSILS PROPERLY STORED SEWAGE 40 ROOMS CLEAN,LOCKERS PROVIDED, 1 40 *28 SEWAGE AND WASTE WATE DIS- FACILITIES CLEAN,LOCATED.USED ERSONNEL ' POSAL 1 � 70 11 PERSONNEL WITti INFECTIONS RE- 4 58 OTHER OPERATIQIS STRICTED PLUMBING *41 NECESSARY TORIC ITEHS PROPERLY ' S 41 29 INSTALLED, MAINTA�NED STORED,IABELED, USED 12 HANDS WASHED AND CLEAN,GOOD , 1 59 5 �i HYGIENIC PRACTICES °� 0 CROSS-CONNECTION, BACK SIPHON- 42 PREMISES MAINTAINED, FREE OF S 42 AGE, BACKFLOW `LITTER,llNNECESSARY ARTICLES, 13 CLEAN CLOTHES,HAIR RESTRAINTS _� 5 60 CLEANING MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT 1 43 TOILET AND NANDWASHING FACI ITIES PROPERLY STORED,AUTHORIZED pE OOD EQUIPMENT AND UTENSILS *31 IVIMBER,CONVENIENT,' ACC SSIBLE, SONNEL � —�, 14 FOOD (ICE) CONTACT SURFACES DESIGNED,INSTALLEDI 1 72 DESIGNATED,CONS'IRUCTED,MAIN- 3 61 43 COMPLETE SEPARATIQJ FROM LI TAINED,INSTALLED,LOCATED � --' 32 TOILET ROOMS ENCLO ED, EI.F- VING/SLEEPING QUARTERS IAUNDRY 2 44 CIASING DOORS,FIX RES GOOD 1 73 15 NON-FOOD CONTACT SURFACES,D PAIR, CLEAN: F�1ND LEA SER, 44 CLEAN,SOILED LINEN PROPERLY SIGNED,CONSTRllCTED, MNINTAIN- SANITARY TOWELS/TI S1JE HAND- STORED ED,INSTALLED,LOCATED DRYING DEVICES PRO IDE ,PROP- 1 74 2 45 ER WASTE RECEPTACL S 45 MCIAA 16 DISlIWASHING FACILITIES,DESI 2 62 Non Com liance 0 75 ED,CONSTRUCTED,MAINTAINED,IN- STALLED,LOCATED, OPERATED — � 2 46 1� accvRnn�re THERMOMETERS,CHEM- $�� Q RATING SC(�RE• ICAL TEST KITS PROVIDEA, { ' GAUGE COCK 1}" IYS VALVE - - 0 ✓ 1 47 Operator �l L � * Critical Items � _ Form E3/Rev. Nov., 1981 Health Sani ar an ��_ �.��7C�r1�yi.C-i�.Q�� ta- _ . g_5-82 Western Surey �o. Bond # 7886 Exp. 1-31-83 � -7-82 Appn. Pacific Garden, Inc. � _ • . _ ,,t;. _ppn. for trfr. On Sale Liquor & PACIF�IC AROEN, INC. �� ' � ?38 St. Peter St. 55102 :ut7da�* On Sale Liquor License from dba P��ci i c Garden Rest�urant ID# �+�+97752 .ain, Inc. �.�41� ` I >: On S te iquor Trfr a�pn. R 4138 1-31-83* �.-18-83 St Paul Fire & Marine :�� , Sund y iquor Trfr Appn. R 4138 1-31-83* �nd #400C�0736 E�p 1-31-84 FRON� ; * Tlan erred from Rain, Inc. dba The Rain, C.F�.2g7_9276 ./�/84 St. Paul Fire & Marine pp $ sond #400GP0736 Exp. CONT. �pRD , On S�le iquor R �873 1-31-84 ,iq. Lia. Ideal Mutual Ins. Co. Sund y iquor R 5873 1-.,1-84 # =GA83-23527 Ex 1/31/85 # (Refund) Pay voucher V-46071 1-14-8� P• On S le Ltquor R11318 1/31/85 2;`31/84 Liq. Lia. John H. Crowther On S le Liquor �316277 1-31-86 _nc./Columbia Casualty � Qn S'lale LiquO�' ,� S00881 1-31-87 -�CCP168-39-31 Exp. 1/31/86 pn �5a1 Liquor-B ` -.16277 1-31-88 /30/8b Liq Lia Transcontinental � � � r CCP 066 16 75 Exp. 1/31/87 � � fB) i6277 1-31-89 1-31-87 Liq Liab-Transcontinental ;::: .�. � ' #CCP 0061675, Exp. 1-31-88 �� - — - - - " - - �- - - -- . �. .. . . , - -_ 2/L3/87 Liq. Lia. Transcontinental . #CCP1666705' Expires 1/3I/88 �422g7 PH on susp. of rest. lic due , ;.o failure to comply w/food ordin. . . NO ACTION NECESSARY • 338 St. Pe*er St. 5;;;.02 1-25-88 Continental Ins. PA IFI GARD�I, INC. �;� #gy� 3709794 Exp. ��1-89 DB P IFIC GARDEN RESTAURANT ID 4497752 1-28-88 Liq Liab-Transcontinental #CGP2738333 Exp. 1-3].-89 j'� ; BACK OF C� i . _ -_ -88 Tho Continental Ins Co. Bond #3709794 . � �� , 1-31-90 �� I I �� I � �� . ; , �. .I _ � . 3�i8 t. Peter St 55102 ID 4497752 Pal�if c Garden Inc dba Pacific Garden Restaurant Restaurant D 16277 1/31/88 �D�SS �� Restaurant(D) 16277 1-31-89 CAR� i � 1/13/88 ' ' I certify that this is a true and e actl' co y of the records of th� License and Permit Division o� the City of St. Paul fo Palcif'c Garden, Inc. dba Pacific Garden Restaurant at 338 St. Peter Street. ' M � ' • ��'�",",'�� KRISTINA L.VAN HORN ' `� �'�NOTARY PUBUC—MINNESOTA �t alen �� DAKOTA COUNTY ermit � License Clerk II My Commission Expires Jan.2, 1992 � � rvVwVWVWIM� * ; l�- i --.�.� <. . :�s � a� • , � ; ,� �,., -��t,:.�, ..,��• o . �;,. o , , " w? a� � A,i a�i *�� f6 � � c ;-�, � � �i On .� � m � � � c � . � d a� •� � _ N . a ~ � a . ` � °' t ° (� - °> c + � a> m � � � � ;�� •�� o- ' m t,�. a fl' � � � . _ � . E r.: .. _m � 0 . l0 - . . . . a � a� � a �s' z � '- o � w `�-� `° c 0 o a . p ._ c o .,.,.� N v � N � � +. � p, � s� � � � ,,( ��r�,r�� -` C . . 7 N .t.., m O M �+ � N .' �; �: � L `�--� � . C L F �� y � � . C .b.. .� _`�.0 . � d � ' . 1 � y U U ,p N � 3 r (A .i � c � �f. ui � W � 'd cQ clf C c0 ... L O C� :� � �p _f`rp t� N � U.�. � = -�C _. . M - Rl O Q � E - 'u� �° w + m J � u, c W � >. c o � 3 ..I � � ° y > � o _ rn m Q o.� 'u� � � co c «. C y vi c� �-v.'a. �C N V aN..L. �.�+. � . � LN .�� r.�'� � C � ,.� � � � .T ? .� �.- +�+ � . r�.. -� . �� .a .. a �«- s � rn c ° — a � c � Q � -� -- � � ,c aci � � � O�. ° � � Z � � r � m � � � «s � �c � F- '3 3�,.. 'i .. ,. �° � Q � E �: . � ;.. m .� Z u, � ''', 13 U o o ,�;��° V c-� � � � � ; m > � � � . o c°o � U . E = o� 'w y •- o � . ; >' � �o � ��a,� �� "_ � W a��i .� � � '�� ^i E �°, •� �, m ° — m '; _ Z N � '� ,: , � ° o ►a� � � °' . � � 3 0 �, o e, " - r. � � s� � oo v� � v � s � � � .0 d (C .d . xf� � �y t 7 0 2 � �f;} . � . . � a � � � � � U � N � �` '� .� p u) � c0 U � � L O u) y � � C w � w ! ,� � � � C U L " � i � ` � � .� n,. � O � . �� p � N O C .. d•- O � � y -1 m � � � � O p « y � � � � ` � � 1 U O � � O � � m N � � � � > � �+ > N ... '- V •> ` L C N •�.�? O a C .�.. F� y� C ;C O U v�i O �� O � C r�- � O O_ . O � � .. vi � � � � � � �_ � � _ � ... c : �" �3 � � �- c� �• o �'3 w� � ' � � �"" . .. m N � � N a� � > � G� � � � V � � N � O� I— 7 O C C t � � �<� V1 L r *" g. 3 � � . j � � N � a � � d. � i � i �, � C '; ; N C L � C N. �� C� / � C � �. __.� >. � � ;�, .. , .E � °' c a`6i �!' y '� _ � � ai � � a � p �:,.� .� ,.sr..�� .7 � m V � � 'i , _y�., � y m 0 a � a a c ¢�`;Q c� �' � � v� _'� � O1 � Q � � _�,� a� � '� � �, ro �� }' 3 �' co �' � � c0 C �U � � � N M tt �� CO ha..,..a� � � N . ��: G 7 3 p d ��. . .� �G t�0 T O U' � � � U Y 'O p ., F � Q Q ,_.....y,.._ _ . ',`� ,. �_ �� _ �,, � *��,_ ,,w,�_ — _ ; ,�� _ �.,. :�r�� '' '�� , �,.';� - �+ N!� � � �� " � �. + `;'r�'"�.�,�. ��+� � •w, , ; ,c "��„Ln�� ,� ;�y � ..��.�.�� I ie , � —� ��x�•r��,. .��, �� ,- � I �, `�`' ,' � , s. � ,.. « ,�; >-�w y, � u � � �� _ �" � i�• ..:, .... � �1 - , - i �� ' � ' - -- � ��: �'�. !�� N ' � � ... � �� P �... � . Y ��59�. . . ' , f-. f (�� ( p��.�. � : Y f�41�. 3, . ..�......u� �. .r �� IIY� kr � ��. M ;A � � � � °�,�A �� ` 'R� !yo � — �e `�� `�' � � .— y� �rr i .�"'"'�_.:— _ .- - _�_ I;� �__,.,_.,��; .� _.-� -��i _ _ -_ ��., �:f, ��° • ' ` _ _�„i +�. ;- ,� `, .�..t..� " � �,�� .�.�" � �1M65"s;� '� � �� _ �, . .� . , , . � , .Pn . .�-� � � . _.. _ - , '_ � � T�� ,,�`\ "_ _ � �:� � � � - � -_ _ _ .,, r �- ��} � � � � • . . - �;\ c . \ ' �,; �,.;< ;..�': �� .�- .t�, ,�'., �� r�� A. , �� y� �, � � � _,. . „�, ��, 'i �,,, i , �. r i ;�y t h � ' (." a y ��. � � '� rv ` �� . �. ��,� `�, � ..,�, , ��M �, ,� . �.+.� - ` . F� ., ." � �..•...•��' �.�. �.. . ;� -- � � �� „w �. M'O`�;� ,� ( - y ��ik'�F+rc.° �. � � �: \�:�� - ► �.��- �� , ,�'� `�. _ , ,...�� _�, ''�, � - � �� , � � � _ t� �Ww, _� , �. t, ��. � _ . . _ . , ...� ��_ -, ; ,�,..� . ��. , :tir: � , �, �' � � - � ,..f„�,. i � �, �:, , x � u� ` ia� - .....,. .. L�wi�- � ' :J�+�.�w. -... i t�� . � . _.� ��R , +, .. � ` �t+ti " , `�-. . . . . ._ .. -�. ... 1 I � r__.,..,,,�� ,� , i � � ` •y••A ' '� --T—'--�� :: � � � , .� i •...' 'r..�� '. . u�°� I� � ��R , �. � --- �` �� i . : �'� ��. �� .,4 �:.., .i � •{�� ` � . . � . . r , ...._ .� _ � 4,�� °,; . ry.:�... :.�r..�. _ _:�...� `�s� . ._ ��„� . • ^.. ..,�. .. �"�i . . � � � � . � _�p�' . {r __ � �r�° � .t; _ � -�,.�..-.,�"'+"'` ; :" .�.. A..r�M►� �� ,,�� . . /I��, �� ,��1• ,�.� � _ ��` ��;.:,; � , � ' - , ; , � ,. � r.;1- '� d� � 1 � I` '�""'""' , ,� ., ,... ,r �. . _ , � .� � ;. ,- , l : . �- - � � ,... � , ,, , ,� � ,r ,- �' ; • � � ; _. ;' � : ,� �� --�.'_'�• - .:�..�s +e,;.,�..� -..1� - ��AlOM, �.,�M:.. g I�� . •� 11�aD"� �1 � . � .. i �� t �� -�! � "�.r -�,�i. �'� I 1 � V��. - . �iSiZi ►L�'r��'� f J r_�„ ^ - ` � ._..._._ -.� ; � �� _ � �' " � �_ �- �� x�b��1�� ..��' i �! , -r*3r ��Y j � I • " �M..` � ��i� �,� m . �- — � ,t. � _ . „ _ �- �..-�--� — ._ � — ../' — � �� , n,.w �� j '\ ` � `� , « i � _� . .- ��,,.. ,. . , � � � si , � � . , � s�� , � <_, �.._ - �. � 7.. ".,.< � � � � � �^, � � . �. � ` �� .::. �`�'\_ . � ` �� i��, '�.� � � � — ....��.... „�,�;��lv � .� .,.. , ��:a� _ ��:_ � - � ,��p .�. a�F', iRR'� S�R�=�..� i (�v�� . ...,,....��I�'�a .,� .y,�._ I w ,� �' �'�'`�'f+� li�1� Mk �� i�"'."� `�Le Fy ,. .� I � I � �4,�. r��,` •�� ° v �' I I _ I �, ��.. �...V I�I � �3 s,R'.� y�IJ+ .�'" '% �,.... � � .4 � , Sc � s: � �a.�� ,`�--�I'� �' I �►� ��.I . �-�- „r , ! - �, � _ # � ..,;r � ,; � _ I� ' :�: ` -�^ � <, � a' . , � I �` _ ,. . �, - - .._ „�w: __ � , � , -- ; {� ,�_, ._ : - �_— � . , a;: .�:, �� ,' ��,_ � � ��:. �; � . .,. - � �, �:� � - _ �