90-2089 i I ��
(
�
I �
i
CITY OF S . PAUL� COUNCI FILE�10. ' D
FINAL � RD � R
, i gy � , ���%' _ �;,,,.
,
ile No. �$S98
I
Votin In the Matter bf t � Z� e 11rea Stas7a Srrar Pro ect
9 co�strae iag t I'tar� /D�t1 j
Ward ( ed ��r Cottags l�►�m�e, iiestern �ir�s, !'ront �treat :nd
s Yic oria Streat)
I
,
�
�
� I I
e I
I�
I i
I
i
I II
I i
under Preliminary (prder �0 —1�g v approved �� ���—`v
! I
The Council 'of the City of Saint Paul has conducted a public hearing upon the above improvement, due notice
thereof having bee given as prescribed by the City Charter; and
WHEREAS, he Cou cil has heard all persons, objections and recommendations pertaining to said proposed improve-
ment and has fullyj consid�red the same; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That t�e Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby order that the above-described improvement
be made, and the proper Qity officers are hereby directed and authorized to proceed with the improvement; and be it
FURTHER I�ESOL�'ED, That upon the completion of said improvement, the proper City officers shall calculate
all expenses incurre�l therei�and shall report the same to the City Council in accordance with Chapter 14 of the City Charter.
� �
i
COUNCIL PEI�SON Adopted by the Council: Date nFC 11 1990
Yeas Ditoed 'Nays �
GOaVits Certified s Council Secretary
I.ong � ,
MtCCS C" � In Favor By
g!t
�� I � Against
Wi�'sou I DEC � 2 �991lMayor
�
PUBUSHED U t C 2 2 1990,
I
I ;
I I
. � a �.� ,�
� .RE 9/28/90 ��aa �y
DEPARTMENT/qFFICE/COUNCIL DATE INITIATED N�i _11711
Finance/Real Esta e Div sion 9�26�90 GREEN SHEET
CONTACT PERSON&PHONE INITIAUDATE INITIAUDATE
Peter �'1�t 298-5317 �DEPARTMENT.DIRECTOR �CITYCOUNCIL
ASSIGN �GTY ATTORNEY �CITY CLERK
NUMBER FOR
f,�UST BE QN COj1NCIl�qpENDApy DA )� ROUTINO �BUDGET DIRECTOR . �FIN.&MGT.SERVICES DIR. _
MUSt b2 1T1 Glty Gl r S 0 f ice L10 ORDER �MAYOR(OR ASSISTANT) � (',rnmri 1
han n n We nesd 10 10 90
TOTAL#OF SIGNATURE AGES 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
ACTION RE�UESTED:
Set Hear'ng Da e.
Approve he se aration of Sanitary and Storm Sewer Systems in the
MARYLAND DALE rea (Finance File No. 18598) (See Green Sheet 11708)
RECOMMENDATIONS:Approve(A)or Re)ect(R) PERSONAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS:
_ PLANNINO COMMISSION CIVI SERVICE COMMISSION �• Has this personlfirm ever worked under a contract for this depertment?
_CIB COMMITfEE YES NO
2. Has this person/firm ever been a city employee?
• A STAFF YES NO
_ DIS7RICT COUR7 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessed by any current city employee?
SUPPOHTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJE IVE? YES NO
Wgrd 5 Explain all yes answers on separate aheet and attach to green sheet
Sewer Separati n
INITIATINQ PROBLEM,13SUE,OPP RTUNITY Who,What,When,Where,Why):
Federal over ent has mandated the separation of storm and Sanitary
Sewer Sy tems.
ADVANTAGES IF APPROVED:
City wil fulfil its obligation to separate the storm and sanitary
water. reat ent costs will be less since only sanitary sewer
water be trea ed. Chance of sewer backups into basements and
surface lood g will be reduced, and after rainleader
disconne tion , sewer backups into basements will be eliminated.
Combined sewe overflows into Mississippi River will be reduced.
DISADVANTACiES IF APPROVED:
Property owne s will incur assessments against their properties at`
a rate o $0. 35/square feet for residential and $0.09/square foot.
commerci 1.
�uur��.;, ►�c��ai Ci'I ��1"1�r�r
S�r � � 19�0
DISADVANTAGES IF NOTAPPROVE :
City wil be nable to fulfil the Federal Government mandate.
RECEIVED
OCT0419,90
C:YY G!ER}�
TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSA ION $ 1 �-H3 ZSO.ZO COST/REVENUE BUDGETED(CIRCLE ONE) YE NO
FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER
FINANCIAL INFORMATION:(EXPLAI ) AS essments ,000 ��
Se er Revenue Bonds $1,039,150.20
- ,. . , ,. . ,.
CITY OF S�INT PAUL �b�rst
u111M1i�'d f Rog�r J. Goswitz. ehair
� �°�� _�� OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL David Thune, ���. chair
�., ,' �
Tom Dimond
' Bob Long
ROGER GOSWITZ KATHY GELAO
Counc7member . ' Legislative Aide
COMMITTEE REPOR�'
PUBLIC WORKS�, UTI�ITIES AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITfEE
Hearinq D�te Action
Approval of Minutes of November 7, 1990 APPROVED
1. 11/27/90 , , VACATION: Petition of the Port Authority APPROVED
' to vacate a 30-foot and a 50-foot easement 4-0
in Lots 3 and 4, Block 1, Energy Park West
located between Energy Park Drive and the
Burlington Northern Railroad west of
Snelling Avenue. Purpose is to vacate
existing easements and rededicate a new
easement. �
2. 12/11/90 ', VACATION: Petition of Como Foundry Partners SENT TO
for the vacation of Mackubin Street between COUNCIL
Como Avenue and Atwater and Atwater Street WITHOUT
between Mackubin and Como. Purpose is for RECOMMENDATION
' ' new development purposes.
3. 12/11/90 FINAL ORDER: Improve the Wly North-South LAID OVER
, alley in Block 74, Dawson's Earl Street INDEFINITELY,
! Addition (bounded by Earl, Frank, York, 5-0
I and Sims) by grading and paving with
bituminous material . Also, slope
; construction in the grading and paving
! of the alley.
4. 11/27/90 FINAL ORDER: Improve Sylvan Street from APPROVED,
Ivy Avenue to the proposed cul-de-sac 5-0
! north of Ivy Avenue by grading, paving
and constructing concrete curb and gutter.
_ Also, for slope construction in the grading
and paving of Sylvan Street.
5. 11/27/90 ! FINAL ORDER: Acquiring and taking of APPROVED,
property for the Wheelock Parkway Bluff 5-0
Preservation Project, part of Block 11,
' Edwin M. Wares Cumberland Addition Plat 2
located on Wheelock Parkway between Nebraska
and Arlington.
.
(continued)
CITY HALL SEVENTH FLOOR SAINT PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102 612/298-4475
, , s�ae
I Printed on Recyded Paper
.. . .. , ,. , � � .
1
6. 12/11/90 FINAL ORDER: Improving the following Streets APPROVED AS
Streets with a bituminous roadway, concrete AMENDED, 5-0
curb and gutters, concrete driveway aprons and
outwalks, boulevard restoration and a lantern-
style street lighting system for parts of
Charles, Sherburne, Galtier, Farrington,
Virginia, Aurora and Fuller. All to be known as
the University/Marion Area Street Paving and
Lighting Project.
7. 12/11/90 FINAL ORDER: For constructing the Marion/ APPROVED AS
University Area Storm Sewer Project. Bounded AMENDED, 5-0
by Como Avenue, Rice Street, Aurora Avenue,
and Cedar Street. Also, installing sanitary,
storm and water service connections, if
requested by property owners.
8. 11/27/90 FINAL ORDER: For improving the following APPROVED AS
streets with a bituminous paving, concrete AMENDED, 4-0
curb and gutters, concrete driveway aprons
and outwalks, boulevard restoration and
installation of a lantern-style street
lighting system for parts of Arundel , Cook,
� Danforth, Edgar, Geranium, Grotto, Jessamine,
Kent, Lawson, Loeb, Maryland, Maywood Place,
Maywood Street, Norton, Orange, Rose,
St. Albans and Simon. All to be known as
the Maryland/Dale Street Paving and Lighting
Project.
. 11/27/90 FINAL ORDER: For constructing the Maryland/ APPROVED A
Dale Area Storm Sewer Project. Area bounded AMENDED, 4-0
by Cottage, Western, Front and Victoria Street.
Also, installation of sanitary, storm and water
service connections, if requested by the property
owner.
10. 12/11/90 FINAL ORDER: For acquiring properties and APPROVED AS
easement for the Maryland/Dale Area Storm AMENDED, 4-0
Sewer Project to allow for pond construction.
11. 12/11/90 FINAL ORDER: For acquiring permanent utility APPROVED, 3-0
easements and temporary construction easements
_ under and across Lot 9, Block 54, Irvine's
Enlargement for the Seventh/Kellogg Area Storm
Sewer Project.
12. 12/13/90 RATIFICATION OF AWARD OF DAMAGES: For acquiring APPROUED, 3-0
permanent and temporary easements for sanitary
sewer extension at 464 Pt. Douglas Road S.
13. RESOLUTION 90-1904 - Authorizing permission APPROVED, 3-0
to subordinate city easements to the MWCC
easements in the Middle Beltline Interceptor.
(Referred to Committee 10/30/90) .
(continued)
� �"--�a���i
�� y
c.��-�..
ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL �
PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE
PUBLIC IIWIPROVEMENT CONSTRUCTION
RECEIVED City Council District 4�5
Dear Property Owner: Plannin District #6 & ��10
N�"����0 File No. 18598
CiTY CLERK and 18597
To decide whether to proceed with the construction of the Maryland/
PURPOSE Dale Area Sewer Project, bounded on the north by Wheelock Parkway;
on the east by Arundel Street; �an the south by Como Avenue and on
the west by Lake Como. Also, to decide whether to improve the
AND streets listed on the reverse with a bituminous paving, concrete
curb and gutter, concrete driveway aprons and outwalks, and a lantern
LOCATION style street lighting system.
Tuesday, November 27, 1990, at 9:00 a.m.
H EA RIN G City Council Chambers, Third Floor City Hall - Court House
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Flease note that the Public Works Committee of the City Council will
discuss this item and develop a recommendation to the full City
Council. Please bring any unresolved concerns that you may have to
, .. . . .. .... _ . . . ..�_ _ . . . . _.. . . __ , , . �,----L_� ni i nnn �., r•...,,,.,;1 !'t+�m},crc
', •aui�� szu� �E suoi��auuo� asau�
��na�suo� �M �E � �sanbaz no� �su� �sa��ns aM `uoos doTanap o� uETd nof u�iqM ��aado�d
�ZIE�EA ur�o no� �I •uoz��auuo� zad �so� TEil�JE �s passassE aq TZzr, �i �uoi��auuo�
.za�EM zq uoi �auuo� .zaMas �3E�ZIIES �uoz��auuo� .zar►as m.zo�s riau s �sanba.z no�C pTnouS
•(���ado�.d TE��.zamuio�) L�iZ9-Z6Z �o (��.zadoad Tsi�uapzsa.z) +�Z09-Z6Z �E uoisin�Q .zaMaS
aq� TTs� �uoi��iu�o3uz auios .zo3 •.za�E1 paTTE�sui �i anBu o� �so� .zauSZt� �jTsZ�uE�sqns
E pZOAE o� aIIIZ� STLj� '�E ei�aadozd au� o� .zaMas ui�u au� vioz� qn�s uoi��auuo� s �sanba�
pTnoqs r,�o� p�E �uot��auuo� aaMas uuo�s a�sasdas s a�inba� jTiM s�uZpTinq T2Z��snpui
pus �TET�.za�no� �S'�UaUI�3EdE amos •�uzpTinq .zno� 3o ao�.za�ui au� u�no.zq� sutsap �ooi
�no� �i ao adid punq.z�aapun us o� ��auuo� s�nodsuriop zoi.za�xa 3i pa��auuo� aaE s.zapsaTuis.z
s��uiplinq ,zno� '', •.zaMas �Cas�iues aq� mo.z3 pa��auuo�sip aq �snn� (s�nodsuMOp) saapEaTuiE� TTE
6sa�Epusm TB.zapa� �uE a�e�s q�iM �Tdmo� o� pus msa�o.zd uoi�E.zEdas zaMas ant��a��a us a.znsui oZ
�
I ' •�Tuo s�uamano�d�i �ui�q�iT zo3 passasse aq T1iri anuany pu�T�t.z� �
a�u��p o� pusT�C.z�
a�BQ o auimsssaf ��A�' NOYZIS pus an� omo� o� auimBSSar :yS ZHS?I
�----- ------_---... ,._ - --�_.. ._.. ,..__�.�_ _.------ ------ --- ------
Cottage Ane " ' '
� ;Y Q�e,
LAI�VIEW AVENUE '� � � !� �
� ' ' � � PROPOSED
nn nvewue � ����—��— � POND
� ,,. 4� �
OFANGE � AVE � •S. � �.
� pqANGEr:•{,-:i: ;IM��i�4r 7 i=:�. ��.•�ir�• G�. �
� � .�... v �
� =D �q . � � _
� � rww�o� �4 � ��
� �� , � � AVF�IUE � _
i� � �: _
—
'- :� � � —
i . —
� —
��������������~ ��ip;�nl!y!1r1 .._�!11Mii!jrr :.:.:.,� .AAqqyLANp AVE
� �
!fiOSEAVE �'.�« � •
�AV U '
t ��� ��� � � �
:i.o�.s�a� � �; �
'1.....�"" ��
��� � _ .. .. � � � �: _
s�x�' ��,,,,,�°°. :.�: .,�.�,►� � � �; <
�:•.:vA+ .y�FS1 � � f
JESSAMINE AVE g � ,,, �
" s �
:�. Z � �.
D • ::.. � � ..,;.,::..._:�y �
� t.r ' A
''L'�� � � � N T S
� � � � �'•` �
1 � � � �` w�i,;- LA1N90N AVENUE
� aoa ,� �� _.
:� - 0 Cl
_
_
, � �� _. IIIIIir ��A�
FFlOHiAYENUE �
�n - o�
!4 i� �
`\ (
MARYLAN D-DALE
..... .. . ... .. PAVING AND LIGHTING IMPROVEMENTS
\\\\\\\� STREET PATCHING (NO ASSESSMENTS)
���� SEWER CONSTRUCTION
111""""' STORM SEWER ASSESSMENT
BOUNDARY
STREETS TO BE IMPROVED
ARUNDEL ST: Maryland to Lawson LAWSON AVE: Dale to Mackubin
COOK AVE: Dale to Kent and LOEB ST: Jessamine to Lawson
Norton to Cumberland MARYLAND AVE: Dale to Western*
DANFORTH ST: Maryland to Wheelock Pkwy MAYWOOD PLACE: Jessamine to Jessamine
EDGAR AVE: Jessamine to Dale MAYWOOD ST: Maryland to Wheelock Pkwy
GERANIUM AVE: Dale to 1 Block East NORTON ST: Marvland to Cook
GROTTO ST: Jessamine to 1 Block North ORANGE AVE: Ala�eda to Mackubin
JESSAMINE AVE: Como Ave to Dale and ROSE AVE: Dale to 1 Block West
� � . xs _ � � [�ATLTT AT�A1�T[� L+T. A.���...� a..� �T.TL.....�....�� D�s�.e.
, �a ����
'
SiT�vIMARY OF ENGINEERING RECOMIVVIEENllATIONS �tEC�IV�D
Mt�,�tYLAND/DALE COMBINED SEWER SEPARATION n
' AND PAVIl�TG PROJECT NU�2�-��O
' C{TY CLERK
Project No. 91-S-8075 and 91-P-8056
, Report Prepared September 19,1990
Neighborhood Information Meeting, November 1, 1990
' Public Works Committee, November 21, 1990
Public Hearing, November 27, 1990
PROJECT:
Construct a separate storm sewer system, an MWCC Sanitary Sewer interceptor (Trout Brook
West Fxtensiot�),water and sewer service connections and reconnections, a storm water retention
pond in the V�illow �teserve District, street improvements, and an ornamental lighting system
in a portion di the Trout Brook watershed. The project azea is bounded on the north by
Wheelock Pazkway �nd the Burlington Northern Railroad line; on the east by Farrington Street
north of Maryland Avenue and Arundel Street south of Maryland Avenue; on the south by Como
Avenue and o� the v�rest by Lake Como. A vicinity map showing the location of the project and
a detailed site map showing the project limits aze attached. (Exhibits A and B)
INITIATING,ACT'�jON:
The Maryland/Dale project is a part of the City's CSSP Program and was identified in the 1984
Comprehensiv� Sew�r Plan -Part 1 Stormwater Management Plan. The Maryland/Dale project
is a combinati�n of�the TRT-1 and part of the TRT-2 drainage areas and the Lake Como
overflow.
i
E%ISTING CQNDI'�'IONS•
The project aze�a is p�esently served by a combined sewer system. During periods of moderate
to heavy rainfall, storamwater and sanitary sewage combine to flow over a diversion structure and
outlet to the 1V�ssissi�pi River. Reports of sewer backup into basements and surface flooding
have also been'noted'in this azea.
Maryland Ave�ue ea�t of Dale Street is paved with concrete, patched with bituminous pavement
and has concre�e curl�. Maryland Avenue west of Dale Street was reconstructed in 1982 and
paved with deep strer�gth bituminous asphalt. The width of Maryland Avenue is 40 feet. Dale
Street is a conczete street, 46 feet wide, with curb. The remaining streets within the project azea
, �
�
-1-
- _.___ .__ _ _.
_ ,
�
, • Ij / �.
: 9d ��
�
vary from 28 �0 32 feet in width and aze oiled streets except for Wheelock Parkway and Grotto
which are paWed streets. The oiled streets have no curb and gutter or intermittent curb and
gutter throughout th� project area.
Sidewalks exist on t�oth sides of Maryland Avenue, Dale Street, Arundel Street, Norton Street,
Simon Avenu�, Ed�az Avenue, Maywood Place, Loeb between Lawson and Cook, Danforth
between Maryrland t�venue and Orange Avenue, St. Albans between Wheelock Parkway and
Orange Street, Partial sidewalks exist on; Maywood between Wheelock Pazkway and Orange
Avenue, and Loeb between Cook and Jessamine. Sidewalk exists only on one side of the
following streets: 7essamine between Dale Street and East Como Avenue, and Kent Street
between Cook'Avenue and Front Avenue.
Trees are located within the boulevard areas of most of the project streets. Some streets have
narrow boulev�ards dr no boulevards. The boulevard trees are mature elms, ash, maple and
cottonwoods (�xhibi E). The proposed retention pond planned for the Willow Reserve District
contains box e�der, �illow and cottonwood trees (Exhibit F).
All streets in tl�e proj�ect area have non-ornamental lights mounted on wooden poles. There are
bent straw light pole� and lantern style poles located around Lake Como.
PRQPOSED I�VIPROVEMENTS:
Storm sewer canstruction, street paving and curb and gutter are proposed in the following streets
which are presently ailed:
St. Albans fram Orange Avenue to Wheelock Parkway
Maywood fro� Maryland Avenue to Wheelock Pazkway �
Orange Avenue from Alameda Street to Mackubin Street
Danforth from Maryland Avenue to Wheelock Parkway
Kent St�eet frQm Maryland Avenue to Orange Avenue
Kent Srireet frqm Jessamine Avenue to Fast Como Boulevazd
Lawson Avenue from Dale Street to Mackubin Street
Arundel Street from Maryland Avenue to Cook Avenue
7essamine Av�nue from Maywood Place West to Dale Street
Jessamine Avenue from Loeb Street to Kent Street
Maywooid Plaae from 7essamine Avenue to 7essamine Avenue
Edgar Avenue from Jessamine Avenue to Dale Street
Simon Avenue from Jessamine Avenue to Dale Street
Geranium Avenue from Dale Street to Marydale Park
Rose Av�enue from Dale Street to 200' West
Cook Avenue �rom Dale Street to Kent Street
I
' -2-
i
---e.... _ _ ______ __ i
. � I ��-����
Street paving and curb and gutter aze proposed on presenfly oiled streets beyond the limits of
the storm sewtr con�truction for the following streets:
Loeb 5�treet i�rom Jessamine Avenue to Lawson Avenue
Norton Street from Maryland Avenue to Cook Avenue
Arund�l Stre�t from Cook Avenue to Lawson Avenue
Jessamine Av�enue from East Como Boulevazd to Maywood Place West
Grotto Street from Jessamine Avenue to BN Railroad
Cook �l.venu� from Norton Street to Cumberland Street
Street patching and s�torm sewer construction aze proposed on the following streets:
Wheeldck Patkway from Dale Street to Mackubin Street
Schletti Street from Orange Avenue to 200' North
Dale S�reet frbm Simon Avenue to 7essamine Avenue
See Exhibits B'� and C.
�
Grotto Street s�uth of Maryland Avenue is proposed to have sanitary sewer constructed in the
street and stree patch4ing. In Maryland Avenue west of Dale Street to Lake Como it is proposed
to place a n M�VCC interceptor sewer inside of the existing combined sewer pipe.
Intersections ai ng lv�aryland Avenue will be reconstructed where sewer separation is necessary
from the side eets.' Total street reconstruction is proposed for Maryland Avenue from Dale
Street to Wes rn Str�et. See Sketch Plan (Exhibit D).
Redesigned lantern style street lighting is proposed for all the streets that are recommended for
reconstruction.
A new storm �,sewer outlet is proposed for Lake Como at Maryland Avenue. This is
recommended tp avoid approximately 1,000 feet of sanitary sewer construction along East Como
Boulevard and improve the water quality of the east end of lake. The outiet structure will
have adjustable gates and a bottom-draw type inlet. An easement will be necessary to construct
the inlet and st rm sewer connection to Maryland Avenue. Two deciduous and one evergreen
tree will be re oved to complete this construction.
The St. Paul W�ter U�ility is proposing to replace an existing 36-inch watermain located in the
west half of I�lale St�eet from Jessamine Avenue to Orange Avenue. This work will be
completed by the Watier Utility in early 1991.
i�
�
-3-
_ ____�_.___ _ , _ i
.
' ��' �--����
ALTERNATIVFS:
To reduce do�vnstream flooding, a retention pond is necessary within this project azea. After
a detailed evalluation of alternative locations fc�r the pond, the Willow Reserve District was
selected. Othpr site� evaluated and the reasons for their rejection are listed below. See Sketch
Plan. (Exhibit'F)
Lake Como:, This site is too far west to receive rain water from the
MazylaGnd/Dale area without an expensive pumping system. In addition, it was
felt th�, storn� water would have a negative impact on the lake's water quality.
,
Loeb I;,alce at Marydale Pazk: The water level would rise five to seven feet
during �a heav}► rainfall causing flooding to adjacent park land. Also the water
quality' of th�s lake located within developed and active pazk azea would be
seriously imp�cted.
A small unde I eloped and heavily wooded azea located near Farrington Street and
Cottag�Aven e (Moratorium Area) was also evaluated. Only a small volume of
runoff could e stored on this site without causing adjacent property damage.
Pond c�nstru�tion would also require removal of the mature trees on the site.
Construction of a foulr acre wet pond is recommended on the Willow Reserve District site. The
wet pond will �ttract waterfowl and provide improved aesthetics. During large rainfall events,
three feet of vurater v�rill cover the site protecting properties downstream from flooding. This
proposed retention pdnd is an integral part of a large storm water management system to reduce
construction costs thraughout the Trout Brook watershed. The City of St. Paul will be required
to purchase an�additipnal 12 acres from two property owners. The City presently owns four
acres in this az�ea wh7ch were purchased for the Willow Reserve District in past years. The
existing 96-inc storm sewer lying west and north of the site will be diverted to the retention
pond. A small r outlet pipe will be connected to the downstream storm sewer to reduce flows
leaving the d ' age basin. Approximately 10 trees will be removed for the construction of the
pond. Additio y, a�proximately 15 trees will be removed in areas proposed to be filled along
the east and so�th bo�ndaries of the site (Exhibit F).
'
A new storm wer is proposed to be constructed through Marydale Pazk, west and north of
Loeb Lake. 's will require a construction easement and a permanent utility easement from
the Park Boar . A�proximately 10 trees will either be relocated or removed for this
construction. Aln exislltinng Restroom Building will be removed for the construction of a 66 inch
storm sewer pipe. Also, picnic tables, pazk lighting and a bituminous trail will be removed as
a part of this nstruc�ion. These will be reconstructed following the installation of the storm
ti
sewer. Alterna�'ve alignments were evaluated through the park. The selected alternative has
the least impact I on Lojeb Lake. This alignment parallels an existing combined sewer pipe
,
� -4-
9'� .�;'���
keeping maintenance to a confined azea of the park. Poor soils aze found along the selected
alignment, req�iring,piling in some areas. However, this was not considered a reason to change
the alignment 'since �11 the alternatives also pass through areas of poor soil.
POSITIVE B�NEF�TS:
With the completion of the Maryland/Dale Combined Sewer Separation and Paving Project, the
chance of sew�r backups into basements and surface flooding will be reduced. The likelihood
of combined s�wer a�verflows to the Mississippi River will be reduced.
i
General impro�vemer�ts of the public right-of-way in conjunction with sewer construction will
enhance and add q�ality to the neighborhood. Street oiling will be eliminated on new
bituminous roaidways. Impmved street lighting will enhance safety in the neighborhood.
ADVERSE EFFEC�'S:
Normal problems ass+�ciated with construction, such as noise, dust and general disruption, will
occur. However, by constructing all improvements at this time, future adverse effects will be
eliminated.
Temporary disruptio� of traffic will occur. Maryland Avenue will be closed to traffic for about
two months with traffic diverted to Western Street, Front Street and Dale Street. Temporary
lane closures wXll be r�ecessary on Dale Street during storm sewer construction and replacement
of the waterma�n by �he Water Utility.
Some trees will be re�noved in the project area. However, new trees will be planted to replace
them.
SPECIAL COII�TSIDTRATIONS
Temporary and perm�nent easements will be required from the city for construction at Lake
Como and M dale P!ark. Land acquisition from two property owners is necessary to construct
the Willow Res rve District Pond and provide the required storm water storage.
TIME SCHED�E '
Construction will be�in in April or May of 1991 and all of the storm sewer and street
reconstruction v�ill be completed by November 1991. Over the winter of 1991-1992, the pipe-
in-a-pipe will be const�ructed on 1vlaryland Avenue west of Dale Street. During the same time
frame, the retentionP�nd construction will take place on the Willow Reserve District site. The
entire project w�ll be �ompleted by July 1992.
' -5-
.��_ _.._._.�, _ . __ _ :� ,
J_�����
� �
COST ESTIlI�IATE:
—�
(All costs incllude engineering and administration.)
STREET PA'VING (P-8056) $1,853,518.00
STORIvt SEV�ER (S-8075) 1,183,150.20
LIGHT'ING �V-8056) 295.680.00
TOTAL ' $3,382,348.20
ESTIlVIATED�,FINAINCING•
� PAIJITT
Assess ents $ 512,924.00
Capital�Improvements Bonds 1,038,390.00
Sewer $tevenwe Bonds 302,204.00
;
TOTAI;, $1,853,518.00
STOR11�SEV�ER
Assessments j $ 144,000.00
Sewer Reven�}e Bonds 1.039,150.20
TOTAL $1,183,150.20
LIGHT� T�G �
Assessments $ 88,704.00
Capital Improvement Bonds 206.976.00
TOTAL $ 295,680.00
Assessments wi11 be based on the following rates:
Street p�ving and curb and gutter will be assessed at $19.82 per foot on oiled streets to
be paved. On oiled streets with concrete curb, the assessments for paving will be
reduced �to $17.82 per foot if the existing curb does not need replacement.
Orname�tal lig,hting will be assessed at $3.50 per foot on all reconstructed streets.
Storm se�wwer will be assessed on all properties in the project area at $0.0313 per square
foot resi�lential� and $0.0782 per square foot commerciai.
' ' -6-
� � 9� a���
SOURCE OF ADD�TIONAL INFORMATION:
For additiona� information, contact:
Tom Kuhfeld, St. Paul (292-6276)
Chet Har�ison, HNTB (920-4666)
SUMMARY �►ND RECOMMENDATION:
The Maryland/Dale project includes construction of about 3.3 miles of new storm sewer in the
Marydale Parlc area of the City, and one mile of new MWCC interceptor sanitary sewer in
Maryland Avenue. 'The project also includes street improvements and lighting on about 3.5
miles of presently oiT�ed streets.
1fie Departmeflt of Public Works thinks this is a necessary and worthwhile project and the
engineering reaomme�dation is for approval of the project and financing.
Respectfully submrtteli,
I
Thomas Eggum
Director of Public W�rks
,�.t,�n.�.s� ,
�.�a ivi�so
—7—
I
�
—.----�—.-----.__ __ __r _ ; _ __
. . . ��� -�����
EXHIBIT A
»
> �
_ o
, �
�d
¢'°
, Wo
a �o
�
a
.
'
� .....
� .... .
> �
o �
�
m
.
� �
� _ v }"
O '
i
^ Q � U
, � o o aOW
� � � .
N �
•
W T !-- � O
_ � u. V a
Y JN r Oma
� � a F�- p=�. �
o „ ! _ tn
� � Z ^ V U
�N � �
} N , �
a � �p `:: ¢ a°o
¢
J H � J
O
Wa Yo W ..
� �H � ::;
� m w �
Z N W �
� N .W
�
4
� Z
� o
� �
oa
�
�
Z �
O ;� c
Q ¢ �
U va
�
0
h- , , � �
U �
w z
� J
� S
Q
a � _�/
�
. � �'o �0�'9
STREET PAVING EXHIBIT B
� �
� � � � � � � �
LAKEVIEW NUE � � � U �
t/1 � y .� �
NY AVENUE � �� \\\\\ �
� �ii �ii Gi ry . �4'
ORANGE " AVE � j � � � � ari
�� � OFiA►dB� :.v,. .+.`,:;AVENUE;•; �
� Z� I' N pp �
� � im � � .� ': HAWTH�OQ
� a
iw � �;e A _
' MAfM1WD .:. X AVENLIE
. �
ROSE A i ROSE AVE••:::'•.. �" .;
__ / •\, �� '? �
�EB I.AI�� � �j
,���0� . `.,.,/" ¢ � W .
W
B� ����;; _ � �
�: ,•uu+ •..�ssn�ar�av/�� �
JESSAMINE �3'' �t:' 'AVBJUE•'• � ' �
''• �� ZS .C�C'71ilE1JUE
.,�q �� a ',t
�� `� W N
�. �;; x -Wi N T S
,�. �•� �
1 � � � �'b9 GF... ':}�S� IAWSON AVENUE
� �1 s�� �
� . MATCH AVENUE
� 0 DD ' �:�i o����
FRONTAVENUE %
.�� ���
�n � �:�
� �
MARYLAN D-DALE
STREET PAVING
'�"^��°�:=: ' PAVE EXISTING OILED STREETS 3.5 MILES
...��,:., ... ..
;X X X X X X PA`VE EXISTING PAVED STREETS 0.5 MILES
� ' OIL�ED STREETS-PAVING DELAYED 1.4 MILES
�\\\\\\\ STf�EET PATCHING 1.0 MILES
, SEWER CONSTRUCTION
ON STREETS TO BE RECONSTRUCTED 2.0 MILES
ON' "OTHER"- (REPAIR TRENCH) 1.3 MILES
�
.. _ __ __—.__ _ � _
. � �`� _. °'`,�`��
� STORM SEWER ExHisiT c
� �
� � � � �
w�nt�v vEriue � � �
% N (~IJ
� aNY AVENU� � WM 2 � /
� � � � � m � ,
ORANGE ' AVE � u~i a~i � � � � //
�� � � 4'� i/��
� � q �
o � 4'� /
G O /
n � � � A� � I
N I
..
______...�__.�___'�p_ ______ _ ___.___ AVEI�AJE
.
�� � �.��.\ �
, ���� � �
��,T�� �' f � �
B�1'`' � �
INE AVENUE � �
n
JESSAMINE � '
F Z
� COOK AVEI�NJE
�H
I �I � �� ' ❑ ❑ ❑ NTS
, � a �a �9� IAWSON AVENUE
� � Z� '�
� HATCH AVENUE
� � �a {� � ��
FFlONiAVENUE �'
�n a o o�
�� �
�
�� MARYLAN D - DALE
STORM SEWER
�
•------- EXISTING STORM SEWER
�
' PROPOSED STORM
I / �y�RE R�
/ D�NTIONSPOND.
i
II /
-------____�� ___..__ __ ___� __ ______ _ ---- _
. � �a -�o��'
SANITARY SEWER EXHIBIT D
� �
� �
� � LAKEVIEW VENUE W �
w �
NY AVENU � MMEELOCK pAfiKWAY
� ❑� � � � � � � � m �� � /
ORANGE " AVE � y � � � � � � /
�� �
� ORANCiE AVENUE c'�
� _� q `,
� � � �p4� I
n � � � � �
� �
������N.��N.���■.e�■u.��� �v�
_ /
�KvEwue - �� .�..
i r-- � _� �
- -:���� �
�.1G'1�� l''f � �
B�' � C � � �
,,,"�'°� i ^� � �
JESSAMINE AVENUE �
FC�._ i
�iq � COOICAVENUE
�II � '�� � �
�� � I � D � a NTS
� � � �a' � �'F I LAWSON AVENUE
� ���GF �I �� �
� � W1TCH AVENUE
� �� � ���
FRONiAVENUE
�� Qo �
�� �
�
MARYLAN D - DALE
' SANITARY SEWER
+------ IXISTING SANITARY SEWER
PROPOSED SANITARY SEWER
I
■������ MWCC INTERCEPTOR SANITARY
� SEWER INSIDE EXISTING SEWER PIPE
__�._.._.._____ _.__ _ __. _,�__.__ . ______-_ -- --_._
. I EXHIBIT E
MARYLAND/DALE PROJECT C�6 =a���
TREE REMOVALS
LOCATION ' IZE TYPE
598 MARYLAND ' 4" MAPLE
576 MARYLAND � ' 3"&4" MAPLE
496 MARYLAND i 2" MAPLE
478 MARYLAND , 3" MAPLE
472 MARYLAND 6" MAPLE
464 MARYLAND 4" MAPLE
464-1/2 MARYLAND � 6" MAPLE
444 MARYLAND ! 4" MAPLE
COMO PARK i 2-8" ASH
772 MARYLAND , 8" MAPLE
1005 MARYIAND 6"&8" MAPLE
1055 ARUNDEL ' S" ELM
(SW COR COOK/ARUINDEL)' S" ELM
8" ELM
10" ELM
5" ELM
563 FRONT ' 27" BOX ELDER
992 KENT 30" COTTONWOOD
1060 KENT 3-6" ELMS
LOEB&JESSAMINE, SE CO�t 10" (dead)
(vacant lot) ' 10" (dead)
' 10" ELM
MARYDALE PARK 6" ASH
3-10" ASH
1-5" ASH
' 6" ASH
12" ASH
8" ASH
, 12"&8" ELMS
,
13" ELM
8" ELM
T' MAPLE
� ' 6" ASH
i 2-12" POPLAR
' , 6" BOX ELDER
DALE 8�GERANIUM ' - - - 2-12" ELMS
(NE COR) '' 3-16" ELMS
DALE&ORANGE 4" ASH
649 ORANGE , 8" ASH
1255 DANFORTH 14"&20" ASH
4 MAYWOOD PLACE 14" ASH
*WILLOW RESERVE (S�E PA6E 4)
__..._.. . _ .._,---___._..._._ .
_ ,
EXHIBIT F
�d ���
PLANT LIST
.,��.. . „ . .. ._.,, :. . -.....��...�,.�.�. — ��
� � �.
� .,.:,�.��,....,,�,;
�.
�........,�o.�.,�,..._�..�,�,.,_ .. ,. .,.....,, ,,......,,..,.,....,.. �.�..�.,�.,��...n ...,._.. �— -—.
�.._�.
�
_- �
�..�,..,,_�..���..�.r,__. ` ' .....«.� - �.�r,.,_r.,,,,W.._. . .�i
�.�...,W.��..�., . ,.�.,,a...,.���.� ,_ _ _
,�. ,..N.,�,�.,.�t�:� -
,�
,.......�.,.d.,o....��.. � ,.__.���,x.. _..� .,�,.�.,.... :....<..,.,_,�.,. ,r _.�;�,,., -
,v� �..� .,,.,. . ,_, >
-- �-
:�-. ...:.... �.. .. ____-
. ,,. ..:..,. � .,. .r-- =,x,. �
-T ' -
I eHee. � -.�' '-/ ��-
,- - -_ � � _.._. .
*t[e r�mac oM �-�—�
,(', �1 ����(/ _ � �, _„��� _ � _ ---`
, �, , „ ,
� � .�� ._�.�� �,\ ,- _. s �� r u�.,
� _
i
i� �) �������� � �' � � �
',' i I i f 'I �I'11 1 /____��, i � _ �--'�� I . ..
� � .i ( I` 11 � - �� ` -- �� -� .
� . / .'r�J -... �- x
� � ,i ._. � " - • � f Jb A[ � � I :
�i Eewr -
��� fIl lP7oR � y
/ '7„ � , a,t�RR `� i �� � I' i
F �,,. # r �
,
/ � �;, ��-_ , � �- . �
, ,
��`
� � . EfLAMpT AILOW\0\ �'' ,I'\� � ���-r,l�
r � '����011FY 11i!IYlU11KlY � � i �\ '.� �` < � �
.
� / .� . .� ��i ��p �! ��,� .
� � �?o��y�yc,�..," ��� �..---. � �� � � `�-��� ' _
'7� �' �� /�% LX/!1/NJ W.'?t �� ~ �� �n I
7�, i ,,�,Clfo ' Caasr,vro StMT , ��__� -� I
,� . � �j� n I' � u.ao.r..c caa I _ 7[IY�u.a.. '
�,/'� .�. ° � �,_�
� yc
i; -
i . . � . .' ,r .
�zrs
���/ � �.., '�� wM
) c�' `� _
�'�
±C h
O . -'�'!� � �--
_.. _. S � Q � •�� ,.
- J I •
' � i�; I , y i
,� � _
' -- >aa> �
`�g��
I il TO 11lVEO[T�T!RlEll ....�% _� � ., ._....__
.i ��'..i. . . -. . ., . __
� N LllflB(tYP1CIL1 , � I � — Iy/�•
1TIIM 1 ( LfN ��i �'. �
\ � r 1� `+ .
)
(�� '\ / ��II� y�,
1 i �
' _
'� '+ I 6,
� �r , <
� — �J �
1
.,�1 ��..�/
i I " %'.
, � �- ;—� ; i � < <�
^ �E�., � I \' �. I�'I ��'S'
�
n��
,, ---- -I 'I __ r,
:� _ —_ _ ___ � �\ �,-�/` • Iti� • �`i
� � qW�( �1; ��,o � ;
�. ,,�'; u.K�x,no �(! � "y �.
.t. o�ro ruw �' 1�,
�an �d'.�, -.� i �= ,�4.��
. �—� I�•� —1---
I i � �{ —_
r��
j:�` ' � .— f ��� r.—�
� � � �_ << . � � �—
� F
I� �o I � i
. �� �, c� rnucraw ur � urwMYUn cor�wcrow un� 1 •\�''" O� C � �d i
` � ' . ���� ,,.,� ..,, , • � '�,
_JL I I,. • I I S I � .y
+ — -- ._. - —
� �.wr , .. ,.M -: -.:.;� i -
,k' �. .._, � —,, •w �..r �t,�»�---.. . �_ ,-�." Mue-----�" ���' � ,..t� '���x i.a�
� _ � _. _ .;. . _,. :.to�u�,"" ,.
�
_ � _ _ . .:: .
, _
NOTES � *a�aurt uer ax t�c�� _��� . �:r.
.��,.�Y -,.w _..._— -— �.__ ___—����
. P . r��.��...,u.....u. ..♦ ...... . I
ou.N..��se,e���n�.s.,-.��.. ��� L
`TM� � CITY 0(S�iM P�LL.YIML�OT�-OE�MT1ENf Of PUlLIL MRS
"° �'°"°' WILLOW RESERVE
�:s�;= K,o, �.ZS,a _.�,,..,�.. �.�.�.�.,.8..��0,�.�.
� ---- - ..i
�90�a�1
PRELIMINARY ORDER
Council Ftle No.90-1790—By Janice Rettman—
In the Matter oC constructing the Maryland/Dale Area Storm Sewer Project
(tounded by Cottage Ave.,Western Ave..Front St.and Victoria St.)tn Voting Ward 5.
Tht Councii of the City of Satnt Pau]having received the report of the Mayor upon
lhe above improvement,and having considered said report,hereby resolves:
1.That the said report and the same is hereby approved with no alternatives,and
lhat the esUmated cost thereof is S 1,183,150.20,ilnanced by Assessments S 144.000.00:
Sewer Revenue Bonds S 1,039,150.20.
2.'Chat a public hearing be had on said improvement on the�?rh dav of Novembe�,
�990,at 9:00 o'clock a.m.,in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House
Buildirug in the City of Saint Paul.
3.That notice of said public hearing be given to the persons and in the manner
provided by the Charter, stating the time and place of hearing, the nature of the
improvement and the totai cost thereof as estimated.
File No. 18598
Adopted by Council October 11, 1990.
Approved by Mayor October 12, 199d.
(October 20-27, 1990)
�
I
I
I
�r��-�o�
PRELII1�11TARY ORDER
/Councl!F11e No. 90-1790— �_-- '
By Janice Rettman—
In ttye Matter of constructtng the Mar�,land/Daie Area Storm
(bounded by Cottage Ave., Westem Ave., Sewer Pro�ect
The Council of the City of ga►nt Paul aving recei ed ithe eport,of the Mayor upon
the above lm rovement,and havi❑ considered sald re g azd 5.
p g
1.That the sald report and the s p°Tt•hereby resolves:
that the es�imated cost thereof 1s S1,1&3,150 20 eby approved with no alternatives,a�d
Sewer Rev�nue Bonds S1,039,150.20. �����'��ments gig4,ppp pp;
2'���'���Nt����8aF1 on said improvem"ei3't�bt��{2�� i
1990,at 9:00 o'clock a.m, n the Council Chambers of the City Hal'and Cou ouse�
r �.,• 9�a`_. ob�mber,
�u'�c�'i`g'iA,�e C�t�'�Paul. ������` ,
3.ThaQ notice of said public hearing be given to the persons and tn the manner
provided by the Charter, stating the time and place of hearing, the nature of the
improvement and the total cost thereof as esUmated.
File No. 18598
AdopteQ by Counci]Oetober 1 l, 1990.
Approv¢d by Mayor October 12, 1990.
(October 20-27, 1990)
�I