90-1134 O � I � ` �A�, � Council File � 9� '//��
2
Ordinance #
Green Sheet � �7�7
ORDINANCE
CITY OF SAI T PAUL, MINNESOTA �
' ` � ' 2
Presented By
Referred T� Q� - Committee: Date ��vr �6
An ordinance amending Chapter 61 of the Saint Paul Legislative
Code pertaini g to maintaining the residential and open space
character of p rkways and protecting them from encroachment by
commercial and/ industrial buildings.
The council of th city of Saint Paul does ordain:
Section 1
That Section 61. 103 (g) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is
hereby added to read as follows:;_
jgZ On those lots o arcels ' or ' 'ortions of lots or
arcels which a 'oin a ri ht-of-wa 1'ine of a arkwa
the re ired setb ks from the arkwa ri ht-of-wa
line shall be e a to that re ired for residential
uses or 25 feet whi ever is reater.
That Section 61. 103 (h) of the S "nt Paul Legislative Code is
hereby added to read as follows:
� Those arkwa s and orti ns of arkwa s listed below
� are excluded from the set ack re irements established
in Section 61. 103 (ct) :
Ford Parkwa from Kenneth . to Finn Street and north
side between Finn Street and ount Curve Boulevard. )
,�'a
Gannon Road �
,�
Section 2 .''.
,�
<
That Section 61. 104 (f) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is
hereby added to read as follows: ,
�, On those lots or parcels, or portions of lots or
. parcels, which adjoin a riaht-of-way line of a parkway,
the required setbacks from the parkway right-of-way
line shall be egual to that required for residential
uses or 25 feet, whichever is qreater.
That Section 61. 104 (g) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is
hereby added to read as follows:
� � � , . , . �9oi�3�
ORIGI �I�,AL. � .z
� T ose arkwa s and ort'o s of arkwa s listed below
a excluded from the setback re irements established
in ection 61. 104 f :
Ford rkwa Northern side from Mount Curve Boulevard
to Mis 'ssi i River Boulevard
Lexington,,Parkway (from Pierce Butler Route to the
nearest Bu��lington Northern Railroad tracks)
�, Section 3
This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty days from
and after its passage, approval and publication.
Yeas a s Absent Requested by Department of:
smon
onw Plannin� and` Economic Development
acca ee
e man
�ne � ' J
i son BY�
Adopted by Council: Date Form Approved by City Attorney
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary gy: 6 � , �U
By' Approved by Mayor for Submission to
Approved by Mayor: Date
Council
By: BY' � �.�'�
OEPARTMENT/OFFICEICAUNCIL, , + —' DATE INITIATED ��4 //��
PED - Pl anni ng � 6/4/90 GREEN S N0. $4�4
CONTACT PERSON 6 PHONE I ATE I IAUDATE
Marv Bunnel l 228-3368 . ,��aN ,,. Q DEPARTMENT DIFiECTOR �CITY COUNCIL
NUMBER FOR 0 CITY ATfORNEY �CITY CLERK
MUST BE ON COUNdL AGENDA BY(DAT� ROUTIN3 �BUDGET OIRECTOR �FI 6 MOT.SERVICES DIH.
��R �MAYOR(OR ASSISTANn e 1
TOTAL fi�OF SIGNATURE PAGES 4 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
ACTION REOUESTED:
Adoption by the City Council of three Zoning Ordinance amendments resulting from the Zoning
Text Amendments VII study done by the Planning Commission. ��C�i v `
�� f
RECOMMENDATIONS:Approve(A)a Reject(R) COUNCIL COMMITTEE/RESEAH` �%OPTIONAL
�PIANNiNO COMMISSION _GVIL 3ERVIC�COMMISSION �ALYST PHONE NO. 9OO
..r
_CIB COMMITTEE _ F
11_STAFF _ OOMMENTS: L ol�ql�y
y��Ar�p ��r
_DISTRICTCOURT — '71YS�V�L�S O��I�G;,
SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE4
INITIATING PROBLEM,ISSUE,OPPORTUNITY(Who,What,Whan,Whsre,Why):
The Planning Commission initiated the first and the third nortions of this 40-Acre Study
recognizing that the current Zoning Code doesn't allo�N shared parking between residential
and business zoning districts and doesn't define or satisfactorily regulate recyclinq
facilities in the City. The City Council initiated the second portion of this study
recognizing that the current Zoning Code doesn't require setbacks for commercial and
industrial buildings along parkways to be the same as for residential uses.
ADVANTAC�ES IF APPqOVED:
The City of Saint Paul and its citizens will benefit from each of the three proposals in the
40-Acre Study: (1) providing additional options for businesses to meet off-street narkinq
requirements, (2) maintaining and preserving the residential and open space character_of its
parkways, and (3) recognizing the existence of recycling facilities through Zoninq Code ��
revisions and regulating their location and operation within the City. : ;
��
, :, ., .
. ;.
_ y�
„ ,
. , - -;.
DISADVANTAOES IF APPROVED: - �.. .,,. r:;. . : ,;�:
. . . . . .. ;��.. ; . :... , ,.,,:'. :.':::, . .��.-� �.� � r
Each of the three proposals may raise concerns on the part of particular nropert,y owners: :�.
(1) Shared r�arking arrangements may have some tax .liability and insurance�,liability � � �
conceros._�etwe�n;pa�r_ti:�ipan�s. (2) Some businesses with property along parkways;may be �
restricted in how they may utilize their property. (3) Some recycling facilities mav, �
have difficulty in meeting required setbacks from nearby residential properties. �
. ;',
. _ _�:
. . . . . . . .
. ,
,
.,
_ . �- . � _
_ . .: _ • ..t
, x
DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: -., _ : � :. � . �
, ,, � :.x �
• On each proposal , the status quo causes problems: - (1) Shared parking between businesses and =
institutional lots in residential zones will � continue to` be prohibited. (2) Businesses �
located along parkways will continue to be able' to build �out to `the property line with no ,�
special parkway setback. (3) The existing confusion regarding zoning regulations for �
recycling businesses will continue� similar operations may co�d�j�o�g����v��j ��� �.
different regulations applied to them. �� � '�
JU�I 2 ��yyu � � 5�
. ,�r,
t����� . . . �-- =
, , .., .,
TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRAN8ACTION s � ` � COST/REVENUE BUDQETED(CIRCLE ON� YES NO �.
. Y
. FUNDING SOURCE �� (� 'ACTIVITY NUMBER �
FlNANGAL INFORMATION:(EXPWN) C,"�� V� . _ .
�� �
s
� . . , � � ��a-i :�
. �
��
,uiii�iiu CITY O�F+ SAINT PAUL
• ��tl !I It
O�'FICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL
CITY HALL-7th FLOOR-SAINT PAUL,MINNESOTA 55102
612-298-5506
TOM DIMOND
COUNCILMEMBER
Members:
Tam Dimond, Chair
Paula Maccabee
Dave Thune
Date: August 29, 1990
COMMITTEE REPORT
HOUSING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
1. Approval of the Minutes of the August 8, 1990, Housing and Economic
Development Committee meeting.
COMMITTEE APPROYED, 3-0
2. rdinance 90-1134 - An ordinance amending Chapter 61 of the Legislative Code
pertaining to maintaining the residential and open space character of
parkways and protecting them from encroachment by cammercial and/or
industrial buildings - Text Amendments VII (Laid Over in Committee 8-8-
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED
3. Ordinance 90-1135 - An ordinance amending Chapters 60 and 62 of the
Legislative Code pertaining to allowing the shared use of institutional
parking spaces in residential zones with nearby businesses - Text Amendments
VII (Laid Over in Committee 8-8-90) .
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROYAL AS AMENDED, 3-0
4. Resolution 90-1202 - Approving Chapter 470, Minnesota Laws 1990, relating to
the issuance of performance bonds (Referred from Council 7-17-90) . �
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL, WITH DIRECTION TO THE CITY ATTORNEY TO DRAFT
_ A LETTER TO STAFF, 3-0
5. Authorization to acquire and transfer HUD/VA Repossessed Property to local
Non-Profit Development Group: Parcel 608 Bates Street, Dayton's Bluff,
District 4 (Referred from HRA 8-14-90) .
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED APPROVAL, 3-0 (HRA)
Chair, Housing and Redevelopment Authority,
Committees: Public Works; Housing and Economic Development; Finance.
.��S
1005fo Recycleable
. • . . • � �.C'/.��,�
� a ,��3�
�y
Memorandum
To: Christine Rider, Council Research
From: Jerome J. Segal � V. ` �'
Date: September 7, 1990
Subject: Shared Commercial Parking
Attached are the amendments to the proposed ordinances, as
prepared by Marv Bunnel and as requested by the Housing and
Economic Development Committee.
cc: Jim Hart
Marv Bunnell, Planning Division
. _ _ �,
- - ��� - �._
_ " _ x
� _ , �; ., - _ ��
^ _ -�:
¢ � �
- - - � r h t� 4 fy=.
` �...'. -.:�., .. .. �.' .r_ " . w yL-
s .a �� r- t.a+ �� i.. 1 . S � r.:�. 4 �-.� r � .r �-,�s { s . --- �
� - ;L - � . � < .: r f _^r ..E .s+_a + .� r .7 .
'^. -�� J. o- .s . 'F 5 �r �- S ��ti � . � x�. ,s. �>a1+- f. r . . aw:
K��a � C h ;..Z rY'.. � '1 _ 'F+ii��4�'F'4 l �. '.:5 A' J. <�.���ii� '�...1 .1F¢��M t4 fi0 A!?' t� T�
x.w ,-� ..,�r.yy:Y �Y. .--n. ..r.-s�a,,, e-..�-w .�,a.v...w ..rar.�� r-,�.K-�nY.�.,r.,. +t t .?.r,,.,-Yne'-a r.r+n.(-4.�w:.w atA�5� - L-T,r-.
� r ' 2 _ - •� ..: f �� y� _ � :
� -._ .. �� '� l.� . ..a ��L. ,y�� �.
.•y i � .�i ..R _.� � i .� _ 3 7�� ' ;�Y `;+Yi
r F 2 '
� �,�: { j .., .: > _ 's �. �. � 3 d;���- - :'�
5,4� � J L .,, ;.• ? �: R ��-'� 'J„ "� t _a*, s.« �A e- rY..,tr- �a ,Zy t - � x„r., s�'S:
>-
R .i. � '. t ,e'h�.J � �"� ; �F 4
. .
;
� � .... . . �. '., . , � - �
. y
X . _
��25 r r� ,,. ��.` �� u
k ,�r a ' _ �r � c _,,,. �f. '._- _._...�.�._.s_:<...._.. � - �."`'.>
, a _
�'� _ : ' __..,__ �,�. - _•�.c. �-
, x _ .
_ � : . - , .._e„v... � _ �
. <
. ; . ._ ..... „ _ r
: .,. . >,,.�._ . .._:.. . ,.,. _ _'_•�_....-°--�
�I r�
sr�...._ �-� i:,. ..', F .c
a,+. t �- .. t; /1
5 M L �T • -� - �J a C�v '
� = � , � a�-�_ . 2nd`=� �_
lst � �I
� k � -
Y �" ' �q Adopted
x � ,
u.�.,� 3rd /p _ _ "��
� s ,j. _ - �
� - Nays �
' y = � ' ; Yeas -
s, - f�= Dzr�orm � �/�5 -
k - �x � 9 -
� _ � � -
a, ,
�� �SWZTZ �.�7� 9 -
�
y =
- ,;.; LONG L =- -
,•,; � - ; -
, > �"' MACCABEE - �
�;� � � £
+� � - e-Y ��� .
y , i � ��� '
r' :�,';
�' _
�* ' ,�� '1HfJLQE .
,� <��— �.
� � � , ' . :
- ': WILSON
��*� ,�, �. PRESIDENT� - �
.� _ - �u_> -
� �a f �.
w .
�.s ;�L, -,,k,, �, ,�.,
� y - t'�- r-.�'
5�' -:. .� - � �� ..- x '�—„' "-.'.. - -
s-��1 `i .` �,�,: . ti- i- s �.
., ,`
`5+x,"y'�' 'r"'� a �s�*" _ � ,_-sG^t-^�-^"': 'r—�=�" �'�- "z�a+. �` �r- r.v�+, f ,a-� �r zy3, � ' �,,. ;r�
. . � ..�^x^^—r. .. � �
S
. 'Ff 4.._. :: y � ! �r` 1 } S � F� ` .
� ��ri .��Y �_ : i 4Y T . 1 ) ,!..' �.... LY y. 4 Y' _ .� ., �:.
` �,
�sy"T i _ .,+
Y*'�.�''�"'4""i' £:, a� ��$"t''i+l w ti'". � 'x '�� ta+�'t,l �.... w�..r� r r vyi;','- t�`z x :.t+u�r-g,�' .L..vrc�+.r ��a +..� x�R
7 :.:Ly � .'+��y}i � � t- .t I�s' � r ' �i. �-2`_ _- .\ �'A '! ,�,. �N+4' .�
. ��, .r .' . s 5 E- .r t z �. .. a. .' � : t : e� ,F's �.5 ?..
b� 'y .X ' � � 1'~ Y r4 � t.. .ca� ^S � ' , �
�.t f�.. . �. 5 i ; �; � . z �c � £ � P .. . �� � . . __
�,.a7E�� � � k .} +. ... u .� �' � s :i z� ' t v e,- s���A'.�qs f n .. �.v. a .-� i �.
r'�Ci '�a� � 'k.�°. �s -�,^ �:^+� 2 . ° t: ; 2 �. k ; - r .�.��+�... � k...`�. 'tn� r�� �. � }'.) r }� t' i, a a
.iF s�"a+N c t.f�- .�_ �.r lrs >3 v' 1 , r �^v- -p, -` s„.,y 4 ti.� � .rt + �r v x�.� i � � � :- t�'
+' .�ii_"� � �.�. �. .i, x, i �.-.c }. rr r'- ` .�� .; x 1 a� # .-� 2
.�..�*-'SS.� �y -t��v�s.c�l�scw: .:.ssL x r r.G f x.. ,� �L S ..+ �t s `"�d..x y+�'�w.�.cw-.��� i 3a � � c-R�. cvi'..
a. -N•s, t - �. ,'m 4 :M�z �- �S r v. - � _ c' �,>,^ 4 . ,,�
.. . � �
r.HS`v aM•a yx x'-�y r �' �`.a� w'�+�.'r1 .. >,.,,.q�.t,'F � �� � s �' a „} � ..-..a a r Y�.3f... ,t'`. a_-x ,�i.. ,� .:1v ��-r -
'�w�".y i ,.�- < , � ,-e 1 ' r ¢ .�."''ej_ ye ii�. �r..' ��, ✓� s Fz:��r f ..��w,t Y j a � ' ��� ` r � �. �-F'
�
�. 'Y � 4:. � � J. J r '.Y 1 .
j r. '�.- � �s..i x .. ...:i' �,�; Yr�: ,.L- . j'Y :� n', � ��,„3 yC :�t �?
} 3'
{X� rr �.':° _ z '�,' � _'�5 y,�: �` ,� 1 { .� � Y � �` .,7 i
r��(a�" "� a.y.�.� Y' Y � g,1 t.. �, 5 -� .t- 4 � C - �..
�1 ` 4 j' h!� 3 4-. Q'F�j T �_ y.
'� � ����' ' ; � � �, �'
h� h S .J �.!_
f �
J �S'N'. -' . L - f'i� �,a � "
\�'� �' .'k.�
4 .;.� i l 5� ' y,. �.:3
� t _ _ �t } ' , _
�Y _ S - _
Z t�- S.
{ 5 ) _
y' - " " _- _ -__ _
v
_ _ •.s
'�. ��..:. ),_ �>' -�-.. �:;- . :- - _
� �_
l : - � : . _ ... ._ ' ' .:
:., ._ �, �-. . . . , .
����%.1 ,� : S�� ,,;rWe.4�� �. ., i 1�) ...s r;..'+: � .w,F,cr;_ �-S+n>.r.�'ua .ta � , . . ;`.v..^x:�,n," �� �.vi u..,..> r�
� ... _ .,... ....r..� , , . ... ., .. �.. . ,,. _, r,.._ . _, . . .-}�:Y e. . . . h:-• r;' ' ,. .. . , _ ?^5;�!_, , _ . . . :�' . ....