The URL can be used to link to this page

98-780Council File # p � � � V��C Presented By I;Z3_-i�i't�lIC.7 RESOLUTION Green Sheet # 62174 Commiitee: Date 2 3 RESOLVED, that the licensee, The American Dream Builders, Inc. d/b/a Christine 4 Liquors (License ID No. 21293), located at ll 1 Concord Street in Saint Paul is hereby ordered 5 to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environxnental Protection within thirfy (30) days of the adopfion of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Tobacco Compliance form, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: By: iV / / /'.'� J � Form Approved by City Attor By : `Z / `-� � A� Adoption Cextified by Council 5ecxetary sy: Approved by Mayor: Approved to council &y: Adopted by Council: Date 1 _ c�.�o �\-\� —�-�� City Counc'il Councilmembei Goleman 26, 1998 - Public Hear. TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES �3 1998 I GREEN SHEET LJ?.'.i'—.i�ir �'�Z•: i °I� -'18'0 Na 62174 himuom. carcouKi ❑ fJIYARaNEY ❑ CI1YClfrtK � � wuxctwa�nxFSwe. ❑ nuxc�umm.�cro ❑ INVORIaRAStslAxf) ❑ (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUREj Concerning adverse action against cigarette license held by Christine Liquors, 111 Concord Street. (Uncontested) PLANNING COMMISSION CIB CAMMITTEE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OF TRANSACTION S SOURCE RSONALSERVICE CONiRACfS MUSTANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTiONSi Has ihis PersorJfrm e+erworked untler a conVact (w Nis departmenl� YES NO Has this GaBaMrtm ever been a citY employee? YES NO Dces thie persar�im possess a sldll not rrom�aAypossessetl by any curteM cdy emPloyce? YES NO Is Mis persoNfirtn a targeted vendoR YES NO COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (GRCIE ON� ACTNITY NUMBER VES NO (IXPWN) a�' '� UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: The American Dream Builders, Inc. d/b/a Christine Liquors Address: 111 Concord Street Council Hearing Date: August 26, 1998 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date: May 27, 1998 Place: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penalty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License information 4. Compliance Report OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Claylon M. Robinsom, Jr, Gry Attorney �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Narm Coleman, Ma}�or August 12, 1998 Civil Divisian 400 Ciry Hal1 Telephone: 657 266-8J70 ISWestXetloggBtvd. Facsimile:651298-5619 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55702 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING faOU.T`,�'•' �t8�2��C�? �'^�:?C Mr. Michael Vanderhayden Christine Liquors 111 Concord Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 � ' :: ,!'. RE: Cigazette license held by The American Dream Machine, Inc. d/b/a Christine Liquors for the premises located at 111 Concord St. in St. Paul License ID No. :21293 Our File Number: G98-0250 Deaz Mr. Vanderhayden: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, August 26,1998 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolurion and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report conceming the unlawful sale of cigazettes have not been disputed. You will have an oppornuuty at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remazks as to the penalty, if any, to be nnposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. ' If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very tnily yours, L/G (� L �a-�� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mrryor June 23, 1998 Mr. Michael Vanderheyden Christine Liquors 111 Concord Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Cigarette Sale to a Minor Deaz Mr. Vanderhayden: OFFICF ' THE CITY ATTORNEY �� Peg Birk, �..� Altorney � r� V� (� �— Civi1 Divisian 400 City Hal! Telephone: 612 266-8710 IS West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 672 298-56J9 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 As you are aware, a tobacco compliance check was done at Christine Liquors on May 27, 1998, during which cigarettes were sold to a minor. This is a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 and Minn. Stat. § 609.685. Additionally, since you do not have a license to sell cigazettes, this sale was also a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.01(a). Normally, the City would proceed with an adverse action against your cigarette license, but because you do not have such a license, the City could elect to proceed with adverse action against your other licenses. Another option would be for you to obtain a cigarette license, and have the City assess the fine against that license. That option would require you to waive any argument that you did not have such a license, but in zeturn the City would not proceed against your other licenses. I will shortly be preparing a Notice of Violation letter, but I wanted first to provide you with the opportunity to consider the options and to discuss the matter with you. Please contact me at 266- 8710 to discuss this matter in more detail. If I have not heazd &om you witUin 10 days from the date of this letter, I will proceed with adverse action against all licenses held by Christine Liquors. Sincerely, Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ss. AFFIDAVIT OF 5ERVICE BY MAIL COL3NTY OF RAMSEY JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on June 24, 1998, she served the attached LETTER on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Michael Vanderheyden Christine Liquors 111 Concord St. St. Paul, MN. 55107 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unitied States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 24th da�-qf Ju�ye, ]�}9,8. , ��"n'N""" NoTETER P. PAtVGBORN ary Public �.. UBUC—MINNESOiq � ��'��. [xphss J_r ^7 . ^_. --, i� p;� 'al N Wi o � '� � � rn m � � R �� I a � o r O a � C O � R E L � C d N C d V J N �� I �I ; a� � c�a� �� U �i� IJ � U L� Q �iV �N V iQi II� i ' O t-- I�'� N �� I� � U �(6 IJ�� I_;U m ,� � N ;� I � � I,� Z� I�;rn I�� ViN J ;� �i 'a I �J N F- � � N i � � 'Z ap � Q �U a �� N � Z I� Q �(7 �I� 2 U � W � 0 a � Q iZ,w c'g o ` Q a i= � %� � � � U; IU iN �o I� � I�'i m, �I �Q IW I ICi I� !s 1= �T �,U d IU C I� I� N Z � lai �� m i� lo U i� �v c m 3 � C I_ � '� n i� N I j0 � la im ly N I N IC � ��N � I J LL7 m � �� rn �I � V J� F- W O � O U Z O N C � a � N C E � O W � � r 0 � � � 0 U O L O U N L m L a c m � a� s `o N � 0 � � O rn C .� N N .�.. N N a � X N N C U N N H m c � �3 C � U � f0 -� N �6)� o � va � N _1 n' Q NJ N C �� C t`') ! N Q C (n y 6�'� '6 O � N N � � � O v n3 V —F-� �Z L O N� N L, y O_y N 5 Q W p�jC�NC NJU N 6� (0 tn _ � �Q� o- �QO N�# � j�� U tq U�LL c'�� a" �>U °z coornprnYrnmrn � Z�- CO 7.� �-� r LN O�.'mr jN c �g.1�� q� "� — I� roi D� �i N W i 0 � � N � m y U � R ,_'� ,O a � o � 0 a � C O R 8 L 0 W � d N C d V J i n i�l� � I � � 'a � � Ni> U V jJ i i �N i� � I~ 'tn I !� �� O i � j O i V ; 3 J ; O' �� J m � I 1 W I�j Zj I N I � � N � U Ir I r N G�O �� a' �i �N F- � � N � l a I z �� ,Q I �U o �h= u � 2' � � �� IZ iZ Im I� IJ U a w � � Z E V N I� I�� Q a `s IF- c' O U' L; N M O o �� I I I� ia i� Q X �W ,p� l �rn iC � i I� O I__ O I� IC � � i U I O n- ,� I � � i � c ', O I� � I� Im Li� � iE ;� � �z �4 �g jc�;0 a�Z Q I � �' iU iLL m �� IN'd '�F � 1 ` I� � I� � I Z N !��m � I� I N !�� I�,� i31� �� m�� t- ';a �i � � � � W 0 J � m � w � 0 F-� � 0 � Q U Z O � � � 0 � :� � 0 U O L O U m '� rn I� a c I � i � n I � i d 0 � N I � m C i "� N I � L N N � � X N N N c U i N N L � F�- � ,�3 N C O a C O N E � O � f�i1 O C � � m� V a 0�_ J N Q)•� � � vN i 3 � � � � CD N J a Q dJ N C �� C M � O C(� N rn� 'a o m c �� Eow U r a�i .c � y� �Z amd �no � Q�� M LL N N d �� V C N J V � a N �6 `�'_� c`"Q°'r a �nQO N�� 0 J U � U�ti c ��au �>U yz MUv ° '�n cu� co OrnprnYrn a>rn oZ� (VLN LlO 7N <aw4�2�ntq�p �:. �-� s.:ni��»:.� _.�. l.cX✓�C�! Z � . 3 at TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CHECK FORM DATE: "S �•� "1 1 = � � TIME: �+�. US LICENSE I.D. NUMBER: �� ''/ ° i NAME OF COMPLIA23CE CHECY.ER: _ - j NAME OF OFFICER: �n,.�,�, NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSID VENDOR: l_ h, �-, �,..,� .�L_:. a\, �.;,nt: o.- C.� c ,i- _ , - � i�f ' -r r -• , �� ST WAS TF� TOBACCO: SELF-SERVE7 _ ASSISTED7 X Mp�F�INE7 DID THE MACHINE HAVE THE pROPER REMOTE DE VICE7 SALE WAS MADE: YES � " \ 1`� x NO "F� BRAND: �� t G,{�t h� � r � trt5 NAME OF CLERK: _ C� L.J'l-+ .'�,� ,. ��—.X' SEX: M X F DESCRIPTION: I11 � P �� . ,�Q VC� sY� - �t ti.-+L�,-� CI�CKABORTID: YES NO . ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: _ ; _. - �� - - - - � 11Q.;c:rE, �� I�-s �L/ � ��?�,� - � �� ' � � - _ � � } � 4 � ( �� /'r � pp 1 j /�� ,,� � �_.. � a + 2,.�r a a ry r.�. h I�W \.lv�W>� " \ �LSLMra�C,. . 7 r � y✓�T. a�� 4��+} '�� - $ _ � . d+ � ` . . ,A�•y. 3 r Y � . _ , e } � t . .. ,_. _ .'� -_ed^S. ��N Sa..". �.L-}. . ai __ .. al.c� . �: � •y - � ��w� ' -' r :i �, �-' v1 9 `�'' �� _s 1 J: z.= _ _ s" __ _" _ _ o - -. . • � � W � �''2 � ` ` 1 G _ ' i > .�,-.t. n' n'n-.�, h _ s � .� 4 . s.. . -. . � - �. �M'. 2 _ .., a _ _._ _ �..Y �1 . S ..�v Y. .2 � � ._ .._ e' - � � � �, y:." - - . '- - 1 - � ., '. ' , `ai;y �""w A a. a° _S' - ..��. . ' " - _ ' xf� '- � ' � ;.�� r �_ Y - �y �S Z S -! 2�" �'��,�� v:> s �� .;,,... . Council File # p � � � V��C Presented By I;Z3_-i�i't�lIC.7 RESOLUTION Green Sheet # 62174 Commiitee: Date 2 3 RESOLVED, that the licensee, The American Dream Builders, Inc. d/b/a Christine 4 Liquors (License ID No. 21293), located at ll 1 Concord Street in Saint Paul is hereby ordered 5 to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environxnental Protection within thirfy (30) days of the adopfion of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Tobacco Compliance form, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: By: iV / / /'.'� J � Form Approved by City Attor By : `Z / `-� � A� Adoption Cextified by Council 5ecxetary sy: Approved by Mayor: Approved to council &y: Adopted by Council: Date 1 _ c�.�o �\-\� —�-�� City Counc'il Councilmembei Goleman 26, 1998 - Public Hear. TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES �3 1998 I GREEN SHEET LJ?.'.i'—.i�ir �'�Z•: i °I� -'18'0 Na 62174 himuom. carcouKi ❑ fJIYARaNEY ❑ CI1YClfrtK � � wuxctwa�nxFSwe. ❑ nuxc�umm.�cro ❑ INVORIaRAStslAxf) ❑ (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUREj Concerning adverse action against cigarette license held by Christine Liquors, 111 Concord Street. (Uncontested) PLANNING COMMISSION CIB CAMMITTEE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OF TRANSACTION S SOURCE RSONALSERVICE CONiRACfS MUSTANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTiONSi Has ihis PersorJfrm e+erworked untler a conVact (w Nis departmenl� YES NO Has this GaBaMrtm ever been a citY employee? YES NO Dces thie persar�im possess a sldll not rrom�aAypossessetl by any curteM cdy emPloyce? YES NO Is Mis persoNfirtn a targeted vendoR YES NO COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (GRCIE ON� ACTNITY NUMBER VES NO (IXPWN) a�' '� UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: The American Dream Builders, Inc. d/b/a Christine Liquors Address: 111 Concord Street Council Hearing Date: August 26, 1998 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date: May 27, 1998 Place: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penalty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License information 4. Compliance Report OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Claylon M. Robinsom, Jr, Gry Attorney �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Narm Coleman, Ma}�or August 12, 1998 Civil Divisian 400 Ciry Hal1 Telephone: 657 266-8J70 ISWestXetloggBtvd. Facsimile:651298-5619 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55702 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING faOU.T`,�'•' �t8�2��C�? �'^�:?C Mr. Michael Vanderhayden Christine Liquors 111 Concord Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 � ' :: ,!'. RE: Cigazette license held by The American Dream Machine, Inc. d/b/a Christine Liquors for the premises located at 111 Concord St. in St. Paul License ID No. :21293 Our File Number: G98-0250 Deaz Mr. Vanderhayden: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, August 26,1998 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolurion and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report conceming the unlawful sale of cigazettes have not been disputed. You will have an oppornuuty at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remazks as to the penalty, if any, to be nnposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. ' If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very tnily yours, L/G (� L �a-�� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mrryor June 23, 1998 Mr. Michael Vanderheyden Christine Liquors 111 Concord Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Cigarette Sale to a Minor Deaz Mr. Vanderhayden: OFFICF ' THE CITY ATTORNEY �� Peg Birk, �..� Altorney � r� V� (� �— Civi1 Divisian 400 City Hal! Telephone: 612 266-8710 IS West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 672 298-56J9 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 As you are aware, a tobacco compliance check was done at Christine Liquors on May 27, 1998, during which cigarettes were sold to a minor. This is a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 and Minn. Stat. § 609.685. Additionally, since you do not have a license to sell cigazettes, this sale was also a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.01(a). Normally, the City would proceed with an adverse action against your cigarette license, but because you do not have such a license, the City could elect to proceed with adverse action against your other licenses. Another option would be for you to obtain a cigarette license, and have the City assess the fine against that license. That option would require you to waive any argument that you did not have such a license, but in zeturn the City would not proceed against your other licenses. I will shortly be preparing a Notice of Violation letter, but I wanted first to provide you with the opportunity to consider the options and to discuss the matter with you. Please contact me at 266- 8710 to discuss this matter in more detail. If I have not heazd &om you witUin 10 days from the date of this letter, I will proceed with adverse action against all licenses held by Christine Liquors. Sincerely, Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ss. AFFIDAVIT OF 5ERVICE BY MAIL COL3NTY OF RAMSEY JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on June 24, 1998, she served the attached LETTER on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Michael Vanderheyden Christine Liquors 111 Concord St. St. Paul, MN. 55107 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unitied States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 24th da�-qf Ju�ye, ]�}9,8. , ��"n'N""" NoTETER P. PAtVGBORN ary Public �.. UBUC—MINNESOiq � ��'��. [xphss J_r ^7 . ^_. --, i� p;� 'al N Wi o � '� � � rn m � � R �� I a � o r O a � C O � R E L � C d N C d V J N �� I �I ; a� � c�a� �� U �i� IJ � U L� Q �iV �N V iQi II� i ' O t-- I�'� N �� I� � U �(6 IJ�� I_;U m ,� � N ;� I � � I,� Z� I�;rn I�� ViN J ;� �i 'a I �J N F- � � N i � � 'Z ap � Q �U a �� N � Z I� Q �(7 �I� 2 U � W � 0 a � Q iZ,w c'g o ` Q a i= � %� � � � U; IU iN �o I� � I�'i m, �I �Q IW I ICi I� !s 1= �T �,U d IU C I� I� N Z � lai �� m i� lo U i� �v c m 3 � C I_ � '� n i� N I j0 � la im ly N I N IC � ��N � I J LL7 m � �� rn �I � V J� F- W O � O U Z O N C � a � N C E � O W � � r 0 � � � 0 U O L O U N L m L a c m � a� s `o N � 0 � � O rn C .� N N .�.. N N a � X N N C U N N H m c � �3 C � U � f0 -� N �6)� o � va � N _1 n' Q NJ N C �� C t`') ! N Q C (n y 6�'� '6 O � N N � � � O v n3 V —F-� �Z L O N� N L, y O_y N 5 Q W p�jC�NC NJU N 6� (0 tn _ � �Q� o- �QO N�# � j�� U tq U�LL c'�� a" �>U °z coornprnYrnmrn � Z�- CO 7.� �-� r LN O�.'mr jN c �g.1�� q� "� — I� roi D� �i N W i 0 � � N � m y U � R ,_'� ,O a � o � 0 a � C O R 8 L 0 W � d N C d V J i n i�l� � I � � 'a � � Ni> U V jJ i i �N i� � I~ 'tn I !� �� O i � j O i V ; 3 J ; O' �� J m � I 1 W I�j Zj I N I � � N � U Ir I r N G�O �� a' �i �N F- � � N � l a I z �� ,Q I �U o �h= u � 2' � � �� IZ iZ Im I� IJ U a w � � Z E V N I� I�� Q a `s IF- c' O U' L; N M O o �� I I I� ia i� Q X �W ,p� l �rn iC � i I� O I__ O I� IC � � i U I O n- ,� I � � i � c ', O I� � I� Im Li� � iE ;� � �z �4 �g jc�;0 a�Z Q I � �' iU iLL m �� IN'd '�F � 1 ` I� � I� � I Z N !��m � I� I N !�� I�,� i31� �� m�� t- ';a �i � � � � W 0 J � m � w � 0 F-� � 0 � Q U Z O � � � 0 � :� � 0 U O L O U m '� rn I� a c I � i � n I � i d 0 � N I � m C i "� N I � L N N � � X N N N c U i N N L � F�- � ,�3 N C O a C O N E � O � f�i1 O C � � m� V a 0�_ J N Q)•� � � vN i 3 � � � � CD N J a Q dJ N C �� C M � O C(� N rn� 'a o m c �� Eow U r a�i .c � y� �Z amd �no � Q�� M LL N N d �� V C N J V � a N �6 `�'_� c`"Q°'r a �nQO N�� 0 J U � U�ti c ��au �>U yz MUv ° '�n cu� co OrnprnYrn a>rn oZ� (VLN LlO 7N <aw4�2�ntq�p �:. �-� s.:ni��»:.� _.�. l.cX✓�C�! Z � . 3 at TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CHECK FORM DATE: "S �•� "1 1 = � � TIME: �+�. US LICENSE I.D. NUMBER: �� ''/ ° i NAME OF COMPLIA23CE CHECY.ER: _ - j NAME OF OFFICER: �n,.�,�, NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSID VENDOR: l_ h, �-, �,..,� .�L_:. a\, �.;,nt: o.- C.� c ,i- _ , - � i�f ' -r r -• , �� ST WAS TF� TOBACCO: SELF-SERVE7 _ ASSISTED7 X Mp�F�INE7 DID THE MACHINE HAVE THE pROPER REMOTE DE VICE7 SALE WAS MADE: YES � " \ 1`� x NO "F� BRAND: �� t G,{�t h� � r � trt5 NAME OF CLERK: _ C� L.J'l-+ .'�,� ,. ��—.X' SEX: M X F DESCRIPTION: I11 � P �� . ,�Q VC� sY� - �t ti.-+L�,-� CI�CKABORTID: YES NO . ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: _ ; _. - �� - - - - � 11Q.;c:rE, �� I�-s �L/ � ��?�,� - � �� ' � � - _ � � } � 4 � ( �� /'r � pp 1 j /�� ,,� � �_.. � a + 2,.�r a a ry r.�. h I�W \.lv�W>� " \ �LSLMra�C,. . 7 r � y✓�T. a�� 4��+} '�� - $ _ � . d+ � ` . . ,A�•y. 3 r Y � . _ , e } � t . .. ,_. _ .'� -_ed^S. ��N Sa..". �.L-}. . ai __ .. al.c� . �: � •y - � ��w� ' -' r :i �, �-' v1 9 `�'' �� _s 1 J: z.= _ _ s" __ _" _ _ o - -. . • � � W � �''2 � ` ` 1 G _ ' i > .�,-.t. n' n'n-.�, h _ s � .� 4 . s.. . -. . � - �. �M'. 2 _ .., a _ _._ _ �..Y �1 . S ..�v Y. .2 � � ._ .._ e' - � � � �, y:." - - . '- - 1 - � ., '. ' , `ai;y �""w A a. a° _S' - ..��. . ' " - _ ' xf� '- � ' � ;.�� r �_ Y - �y �S Z S -! 2�" �'��,�� v:> s �� .;,,... . Council File # p � � � V��C Presented By I;Z3_-i�i't�lIC.7 RESOLUTION Green Sheet # 62174 Commiitee: Date 2 3 RESOLVED, that the licensee, The American Dream Builders, Inc. d/b/a Christine 4 Liquors (License ID No. 21293), located at ll 1 Concord Street in Saint Paul is hereby ordered 5 to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environxnental Protection within thirfy (30) days of the adopfion of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the Tobacco Compliance form, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. Requested by Department of: By: iV / / /'.'� J � Form Approved by City Attor By : `Z / `-� � A� Adoption Cextified by Council 5ecxetary sy: Approved by Mayor: Approved to council &y: Adopted by Council: Date 1 _ c�.�o �\-\� —�-�� City Counc'il Councilmembei Goleman 26, 1998 - Public Hear. TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES �3 1998 I GREEN SHEET LJ?.'.i'—.i�ir �'�Z•: i °I� -'18'0 Na 62174 himuom. carcouKi ❑ fJIYARaNEY ❑ CI1YClfrtK � � wuxctwa�nxFSwe. ❑ nuxc�umm.�cro ❑ INVORIaRAStslAxf) ❑ (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUREj Concerning adverse action against cigarette license held by Christine Liquors, 111 Concord Street. (Uncontested) PLANNING COMMISSION CIB CAMMITTEE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OF TRANSACTION S SOURCE RSONALSERVICE CONiRACfS MUSTANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTiONSi Has ihis PersorJfrm e+erworked untler a conVact (w Nis departmenl� YES NO Has this GaBaMrtm ever been a citY employee? YES NO Dces thie persar�im possess a sldll not rrom�aAypossessetl by any curteM cdy emPloyce? YES NO Is Mis persoNfirtn a targeted vendoR YES NO COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (GRCIE ON� ACTNITY NUMBER VES NO (IXPWN) a�' '� UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: The American Dream Builders, Inc. d/b/a Christine Liquors Address: 111 Concord Street Council Hearing Date: August 26, 1998 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date: May 27, 1998 Place: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penalty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Notice of Violation 3. License information 4. Compliance Report OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Claylon M. Robinsom, Jr, Gry Attorney �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL Narm Coleman, Ma}�or August 12, 1998 Civil Divisian 400 Ciry Hal1 Telephone: 657 266-8J70 ISWestXetloggBtvd. Facsimile:651298-5619 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55702 NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING faOU.T`,�'•' �t8�2��C�? �'^�:?C Mr. Michael Vanderhayden Christine Liquors 111 Concord Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 � ' :: ,!'. RE: Cigazette license held by The American Dream Machine, Inc. d/b/a Christine Liquors for the premises located at 111 Concord St. in St. Paul License ID No. :21293 Our File Number: G98-0250 Deaz Mr. Vanderhayden: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 5:30 p.m., Wednesday, August 26,1998 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolurion and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts contained in the report conceming the unlawful sale of cigazettes have not been disputed. You will have an oppornuuty at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remazks as to the penalty, if any, to be nnposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. ' If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very tnily yours, L/G (� L �a-�� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Community Organizer, West Side Citizens Organization, 127 Winifred St. W., St. Paul, MN 55107 CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mrryor June 23, 1998 Mr. Michael Vanderheyden Christine Liquors 111 Concord Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55107 RE: Cigarette Sale to a Minor Deaz Mr. Vanderhayden: OFFICF ' THE CITY ATTORNEY �� Peg Birk, �..� Altorney � r� V� (� �— Civi1 Divisian 400 City Hal! Telephone: 612 266-8710 IS West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 672 298-56J9 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 As you are aware, a tobacco compliance check was done at Christine Liquors on May 27, 1998, during which cigarettes were sold to a minor. This is a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 and Minn. Stat. § 609.685. Additionally, since you do not have a license to sell cigazettes, this sale was also a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.01(a). Normally, the City would proceed with an adverse action against your cigarette license, but because you do not have such a license, the City could elect to proceed with adverse action against your other licenses. Another option would be for you to obtain a cigarette license, and have the City assess the fine against that license. That option would require you to waive any argument that you did not have such a license, but in zeturn the City would not proceed against your other licenses. I will shortly be preparing a Notice of Violation letter, but I wanted first to provide you with the opportunity to consider the options and to discuss the matter with you. Please contact me at 266- 8710 to discuss this matter in more detail. If I have not heazd &om you witUin 10 days from the date of this letter, I will proceed with adverse action against all licenses held by Christine Liquors. Sincerely, Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ss. AFFIDAVIT OF 5ERVICE BY MAIL COL3NTY OF RAMSEY JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on June 24, 1998, she served the attached LETTER on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Michael Vanderheyden Christine Liquors 111 Concord St. St. Paul, MN. 55107 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the Unitied States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 24th da�-qf Ju�ye, ]�}9,8. , ��"n'N""" NoTETER P. PAtVGBORN ary Public �.. UBUC—MINNESOiq � ��'��. [xphss J_r ^7 . ^_. --, i� p;� 'al N Wi o � '� � � rn m � � R �� I a � o r O a � C O � R E L � C d N C d V J N �� I �I ; a� � c�a� �� U �i� IJ � U L� Q �iV �N V iQi II� i ' O t-- I�'� N �� I� � U �(6 IJ�� I_;U m ,� � N ;� I � � I,� Z� I�;rn I�� ViN J ;� �i 'a I �J N F- � � N i � � 'Z ap � Q �U a �� N � Z I� Q �(7 �I� 2 U � W � 0 a � Q iZ,w c'g o ` Q a i= � %� � � � U; IU iN �o I� � I�'i m, �I �Q IW I ICi I� !s 1= �T �,U d IU C I� I� N Z � lai �� m i� lo U i� �v c m 3 � C I_ � '� n i� N I j0 � la im ly N I N IC � ��N � I J LL7 m � �� rn �I � V J� F- W O � O U Z O N C � a � N C E � O W � � r 0 � � � 0 U O L O U N L m L a c m � a� s `o N � 0 � � O rn C .� N N .�.. N N a � X N N C U N N H m c � �3 C � U � f0 -� N �6)� o � va � N _1 n' Q NJ N C �� C t`') ! N Q C (n y 6�'� '6 O � N N � � � O v n3 V —F-� �Z L O N� N L, y O_y N 5 Q W p�jC�NC NJU N 6� (0 tn _ � �Q� o- �QO N�# � j�� U tq U�LL c'�� a" �>U °z coornprnYrnmrn � Z�- CO 7.� �-� r LN O�.'mr jN c �g.1�� q� "� — I� roi D� �i N W i 0 � � N � m y U � R ,_'� ,O a � o � 0 a � C O R 8 L 0 W � d N C d V J i n i�l� � I � � 'a � � Ni> U V jJ i i �N i� � I~ 'tn I !� �� O i � j O i V ; 3 J ; O' �� J m � I 1 W I�j Zj I N I � � N � U Ir I r N G�O �� a' �i �N F- � � N � l a I z �� ,Q I �U o �h= u � 2' � � �� IZ iZ Im I� IJ U a w � � Z E V N I� I�� Q a `s IF- c' O U' L; N M O o �� I I I� ia i� Q X �W ,p� l �rn iC � i I� O I__ O I� IC � � i U I O n- ,� I � � i � c ', O I� � I� Im Li� � iE ;� � �z �4 �g jc�;0 a�Z Q I � �' iU iLL m �� IN'd '�F � 1 ` I� � I� � I Z N !��m � I� I N !�� I�,� i31� �� m�� t- ';a �i � � � � W 0 J � m � w � 0 F-� � 0 � Q U Z O � � � 0 � :� � 0 U O L O U m '� rn I� a c I � i � n I � i d 0 � N I � m C i "� N I � L N N � � X N N N c U i N N L � F�- � ,�3 N C O a C O N E � O � f�i1 O C � � m� V a 0�_ J N Q)•� � � vN i 3 � � � � CD N J a Q dJ N C �� C M � O C(� N rn� 'a o m c �� Eow U r a�i .c � y� �Z amd �no � Q�� M LL N N d �� V C N J V � a N �6 `�'_� c`"Q°'r a �nQO N�� 0 J U � U�ti c ��au �>U yz MUv ° '�n cu� co OrnprnYrn a>rn oZ� (VLN LlO 7N <aw4�2�ntq�p �:. �-� s.:ni��»:.� _.�. l.cX✓�C�! Z � . 3 at TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CHECK FORM DATE: "S �•� "1 1 = � � TIME: �+�. US LICENSE I.D. NUMBER: �� ''/ ° i NAME OF COMPLIA23CE CHECY.ER: _ - j NAME OF OFFICER: �n,.�,�, NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSID VENDOR: l_ h, �-, �,..,� .�L_:. a\, �.;,nt: o.- C.� c ,i- _ , - � i�f ' -r r -• , �� ST WAS TF� TOBACCO: SELF-SERVE7 _ ASSISTED7 X Mp�F�INE7 DID THE MACHINE HAVE THE pROPER REMOTE DE VICE7 SALE WAS MADE: YES � " \ 1`� x NO "F� BRAND: �� t G,{�t h� � r � trt5 NAME OF CLERK: _ C� L.J'l-+ .'�,� ,. ��—.X' SEX: M X F DESCRIPTION: I11 � P �� . ,�Q VC� sY� - �t ti.-+L�,-� CI�CKABORTID: YES NO . ADDITIONAL COMMENTS: _ ; _. - �� - - - - � 11Q.;c:rE, �� I�-s �L/ � ��?�,� - � �� ' � � - _ � � } � 4 � ( �� /'r � pp 1 j /�� ,,� � �_.. � a + 2,.�r a a ry r.�. h I�W \.lv�W>� " \ �LSLMra�C,. . 7 r � y✓�T. a�� 4��+} '�� - $ _ � . d+ � ` . . ,A�•y. 3 r Y � . _ , e } � t . .. ,_. _ .'� -_ed^S. ��N Sa..". �.L-}. . ai __ .. al.c� . �: � •y - � ��w� ' -' r :i �, �-' v1 9 `�'' �� _s 1 J: z.= _ _ s" __ _" _ _ o - -. . • � � W � �''2 � ` ` 1 G _ ' i > .�,-.t. n' n'n-.�, h _ s � .� 4 . s.. . -. . � - �. �M'. 2 _ .., a _ _._ _ �..Y �1 . S ..�v Y. .2 � � ._ .._ e' - � � � �, y:." - - . '- - 1 - � ., '. ' , `ai;y �""w A a. a° _S' - ..��. . ' " - _ ' xf� '- � ' � ;.�� r �_ Y - �y �S Z S -! 2�" �'��,�� v:> s �� .;,,... .