The URL can be used to link to this page

90-545 O � � G � N A L - � Council File ,� D ��sJ , � Green sheet #� 0 3 RESOWTION �, CITY OF S�INT PAUL, MINNESOTA /'rJ ) ; . �,;"� • �i� � , i Presented By ' - Referred To '� Committee: Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the action of the Property Code Enforcement Board (Saint Paul Board of Appeals & Review) pertaining to the following listed property and as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Property Code Enforcement Board, and dated February 13 , 1990 and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference : DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE NO: PROPERTY APPEALED APPELLANT 2/13/90 145-89-F 415 Summit Ave. Dennis Brose BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on a second exit from the third floor , with the condition that the third floor be owner occupied. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Auditor' s Subdivision No. 38 St. Paul , Minn. Lot 6 ----------------------------------------- 3/90 137-8�9�H 368 Duke St. � Familysty��e of St. Paul �� Jeannette ��necek `'�. �\ �, BOARD A ON: Granted a v�iance pertaining t�installing an ��ldition- al bathroom, with the conditi that the 1'�ck on . the 2nd floor oing to the upp r unit be reri�ved, � so there is per nent accessibilit , 24 hours a'��day o the upstairs bat oom. � . PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Stinson and Ramse Subd ot 3 Blk 3 ------------------------------------------ ORIGINAL . _ ��°��s 2/1�/90 143-89-H � 339 Colborne St. � FamilyStyle of St. Paul �� '� Jeannett� Janecek � ,,�`. BOARD ACT`iON: Granted a va ' ance on the ro size on�`�`the second floor, with the condition that o ly one per on occupy `� room, for the life of the current ow er. PROPERTY DESCRIP N: Stinson, Brow and Ramsey' s � addition to St. Paul Lot 26 Blk 14 . 2/13/90 10-90-H 1471 Como Ave. The Salvation Army Carole Brown BOARD RCTION: Granted a variance on deadbolts ; also granted a variance on bathrooms and electrical outlets for only their use of the building for two years . PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Lake Park Addition Saint Paul Lots 1 thru Lot 7 Blk 8 ------------------------------------------ 2/13/90 1-90-F 723 Woodlawn Ave. Clifford C . Sorennson BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on pressure relief valve, with condition that either the piping goes up or to the back by adding an elbow and a nipple. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Saint Catherine Park Lots 1 and Lot 2 Blk 5 -------------------------------------------- 2/13/90 13-90-F 433 Ashland Ave. Michael Winer-Cyr BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on the key box for the two units, with the condition that the building is owner occupied. Also granted a variance on romex, with the condition that the romex is strapped to a 1" x 2" board. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Condominium Number 194 The Ashland Condominium Unit No. 1 thru 5 ------------------------------------------- 2. n � � ORIGI �� L . , �, y° `� � 2/13/90 14-90-F 894 St. Clair Ave. Francoise Jacque BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on the deadbolt locks, with the condition that management be forced to install 1" deadbolt on Mr. Mehegane ' s door immediately, and then replace the other locks with 1" deadbolts as they need replacement. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Ridgewood Park Addition to the City of St. Paul , - Ramsey Co. , Minn. Lots 1 , 2 and Lot 3 Blk 8 -------------------------------------------- 3 as Navs Absent Requested by Department of: imon oswi � � on � SCCfl @ T- e m n un e � i son -, BY� �— Adopted by Council: Date APR 5 1990 Form Ap ed by Ci y Attorney Adoption Fer�tified by Council Secretary -� � By: BY' Approved by Mayor for Submission to Approved by Mayor: Date APR 9 1990 Council � �Jy � By: ��G�'�� By: ��,�-�� PUBtISHED AP R 141990 �SgT RECEiVED n _ 0 �� ommunit ervices (�y 3 DEPAR PNrroFFy N L �3��rgTEg p GREEN SHEET �� 2 7 � S O�� Pro ert�'o�e Enf. Bd. 0 INITIAU pATE INITIAUDATE A Fi N 8 PHONE DEPARTMENT DIRECTOH Jose h 'n P. �92-7775 �� n�N�, ��_j�� MUST 8E ON COUNCII AOENDA BY(DAT� , ROUTINQ BUDOET DIRECTOR �FIN.i MQT.SERVICES DIR. ASAP �M�rora(ora�►es�sr�wn � TOTAL N OF 81tiNATURE PAGES 1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SKiNATUREj ACTION RE�UESTED: Resolution approving the action of- the Property Code Enforcement Board REC�IVE �ooMM�a►raNS:�.w«�t•�+c�� cou� t�t+�ron� _PLANNINO COAAAAISSION _pVIL 8ERV1�COMMI8810N ANALY3T PHONE 1�. _CIB COMMITTEE _ _STAFF _ COMAAENT8: _DI87AIC'T CW1RT _ 8UPP�tT8 WHICN COUNdI OBJECTNE4 INITIATIN(i PFqBLEM.188UE,OPPORTUf�NTY(YVIa,Whei,Whsn,Whsro,Why): Approving the action of the Property Code Enforcement Board for the meeting of February 13, 1990. 1 7 - variances ADVANTAOES IF APPROVE7. Variances granted to the pro�erty o�yner �� the �soarc� will be ratified. as�cv�r�r�s��vEO: None �our�c�i t��s�arch C:enter MAR 2 81990 DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: The action taken by the Board will be returned tc� the Board by the City Council for further action. �CE'�D II�gi9� CITY CLERK TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION a n/a COSTlREVENUE 9UDQETED(CIRCLE ONE) YE8 NO X FUNDII�Ki SOURCE n/a A�ry��N��p 3 3 2 6 3 �� FlNANGAL INFORMATION:(EXPWN) _ _ �i=��-��" cn��, a �r a SAII1r PAtJI. BQ�RD OF APP'EAIS & REVIEW 555 CE�R S'tREET ST. PAUL, N�50�P, 55101 (612) 292-7775 ^�V[TrE'S, I�,TING OF FE�2C�RY 13, 1990 N�RS PRFSIIVr: Rpn Glassn3n. Cha.irn�n Ronald Ar�keny William Tilton Robert Viering Drx�ald weida .Tames Iaughl�n AI�90 PRF�TT: Pat Fish, Fire & Safety DeparGtt�t Cliffon3 Sorensen Sl�e Zbslaey, Fire & Safety Departmerit Car+olyn So� Carrolyn Shephexd, Public Health �s Nbellernr�n Don Miller, Public Health Mir.hael Winer-C�r Clifford Sorenson Jeffrey Siecll Carole B�ooiz Virginia Zink I�ry Kelly John Mf�C'arthY D�uLis Bx�ose John Mehegar�e Ray Fari.cy Mrs. Binse STAE�': BARB KCII,STAD. ,JL�'JY N�. & f�,E C�T Ci�aimt�n Glassn3n called the meeting to order at 1:30 p.m. Febnaa�y 13, 1990. He welocmed the Appellants ar�d explairyad the pmooecbar+es, stating that what the board cbes is �merrl action to the City C�amcil. He also asked t1�at stat.�ts be bri.ef, and that the board was thPxe as fellaw citizens to help ttran in a fair m3ru�er. CS�airn�n Glasstan has aorre.spo��ce f�xn bath his offioe and t1� city regarding the name charx�e. It has aga�n bein9 Y+equ�st-ed to Oauxil Presic]�t Wilson that the r�ned be charx3ed t�o "Prr�p�eYty C7cx.�e Ehfo�t BaaYrl of Appeals," or the "Pn�pPxty �bcle F3Zforaa�t Appaals Baard." It is felt that sare�tivng in the title shauld relate to propeity. Zl�e Board shauld hear a response to their �t slnrtly. Cl�airnun Glassn�n stated t1�at the Baard i.s still loalQng for oc�e more manber. He thau�t it wruld be beneficial to get scmeor�e relating to general c�nstn�ct.i.on. plutbing, e�tc. Ronald Aril�eny reoamierrled Zlerry rbGraff. Don Weida aarmented that a wac�n may be interested in the positi�. C"h�irman (Claszart�n sai.d that it ra311y didn't t�tter, that ar�yune interes�tsd, should oontact the Mayr�r's Office. 1. Appirov'al af the miryutes af t1�e Jar�aaaiy 9, 1990 maeting as sutmitte,d in writing. Mation n�ede by �on Ar�la�y t�o approve the mirut.es af the January 9. 1990 meeting as sutYnitted in writing. Seao�led by Aabert Vieri.ryg. M7iZCN � UNP�TIl►'DRSGY. -�- 2. CASE F.[EARINC'�S: CAS'E I�: Pf�JPFR'I'Y APPF�IL�D ?�PPE�,IAATr 16-9�-H 1542 GV. Se�venth St. M3rre1 G. Hathaway (1 unit) SL'BJE1Cr: Ap�llant is requesting an extension of ture to ck� the r�eoessaiy � �7Prf_a i n;na t0: E'IRST EZ� - �1E3t1I1CJ �Ul�IClerit �1P.Yit105'tdt Ilot fi�.•tioning pz�erly, cl�efective plaster on aeiling to c�ll of stairway to 3Yi floor. B��II�Tr - inprr�pPxly install�l electrical wiring, illegal spliced lanp con3, q�en electrical jimction box, m sYgzt-off valve on gas line to water heater, water heatex has ryo tgcperature pressut-�e relief valve, heatiryg e�uignerrt ch�t lad�. (�L - pro�vide heat to a minimm of 68 F, insuffici�t outlets, ra�e extension cords, ins•tall snnlse detEx,+tors on a clifferent circuit to prevent m3].ftu�tion due to blc�rn circuits. PF�CEmIlVGS: The �p�el lant stated that his tenants have been a larye problan, arr3 that he didn't realize all the pn�Ians fi�at existed at the prap�ert.y. He claimed that the in.�ect.or wanted everytl�ing bn�x,�ht up to C1-�cl� as if it was naa. He cla�med tl�at it wauld be a fir�ar�ial hardship. Mr. Hathaway stated that it.ans #7, 8 & 9 of the violation list �*�'ai ni rx� to the heating, has now been wrrect,ed. Tl�e tenants rx�w renting this propert..y aaes him 51,625, arid he r�ead.s this mor�ey to aatplete the wnrk. He is willing to cb the work, but needs mc�re time. (�rrolyn Sr�ah�e.td, an irL.�pec.�tor for IIzvirom�ental H�ealth, said she was willing to grant him tmre time, as long as all the illegal wiririg was ramved before an extension of time was granted, as it was a defini.te haza�l. Mr. Hathaway oam�ted if she would get hi.s t�ants azt, tY�en he aould do the work. Mr. Hath3way has sP_rved hi.s tenants with an eviction mtiae to vacate by the end of Fel�naazy. If i�on rein�ection Marr.h 1. 1990, if the t�arYts have rx�t v�cated, then Carrolyn Sh�hexd oail.d initiate a oondamation, and raro�v+e the tenants in that manner. BC1�F�D A�.'�ICN: N1�tion was m-icle by Robert viering to alla�v Mr. Hathaway 60 days (May 1. 1990? to ocnplete the ryaaes.sary �;�, with the provisi� that the P�r't-Y rxyt be rented c�ring that time. Seaonc�ad by Williaan Tilton. M7TICN C�tTFD i�TIl�D[JS1LY. . - � yo -6�� , -,- 145-89-F 415 Slmnit Avesuae Dennis Brose (4 Lmits) SUBJDCT: A�pellant was at the Jar�y meeting ar�d after mrh discussion, the �llant was re�uested to meet with Fire Prevention, and be allc��ed to return to the maeting in Febn�aiy for further discussion pertaining to: having to pravicie a sec.ror�d exit fmn the third floor. PF�JCEmIl�S: Pat Fish, representing Fire Preventi�, stated that she met with Mr. Brose, and that it was Fire Prevention's that he orginally . interr]ed to use alternate protection, in lieu af the 2r�d exit f�xn the 3n3 f loor. Aacarding to the pc�sition of the Fire N]arshal, this means the sprinklirx,� of the �tire buildirig, r�ot just the c7ammn areas. Ms. Fish distir�tly ra�nbers telling Mr. Brose rbt to cb the vrnrk, imtil he had pulled his peLmit. �e Building Dep�rt�ent �uld rx7t issue his pernut, because they didn't und�erstarr.� why the pezmit being pulled, was only for the stairway sprinklers. Mr. Brose h�l r�at yet gotten Board appraval. Mr. Brose has a ca�inatiori heat ar�d snn)se det�tor systen in the stairways. Ms. Fish went on to explain to the Baard that the problan is aoc�ptirig a variarr.� ari sprinkling the stai�way alone mearLS that the sprinkler heads cb r�at go off, wzl.ess the fire is ric�t in the imrodiate ai�. Mr. Brose told the Baat�l that sprinkling the �tire building vrnuld aost approxim3tely $30,000, as it n�eant alot of re-constnaction. Mr. Brose stated that if sarething a�ctivated any one of the sro� detecGors, the entire sys-tsc� �uld go off, which is mxLitored 24 hours a day, by a central i;nnitoring statiaz. BQ�RD ACIZCN: Rpnald Ankeny m�e a mation to grant a variarr�e, as he didn't see a cli.ffer� bet� the 3�c1 floor ar�d the 3rd floor. He stated that Mr. B�rose wpnt tYu�augh alo�t of wnrk to see that there was alat af s�r�ke d�etection ar�d wrater protection for that or�e exit. Seaorrled by Aobert Viering. A frierrlly amerrlment was adcied stating as lorig as the 3n� floor was owner o�ied. Zhis was aa�ted by rtr. Srose. NIIt'Ia�t c�tgD UI�VIl�zSLY. 7-90-F 596 Portlar�d Ave. Raymond Heichel (4 imits) SUBJDC.T: Appellant is r�tiryg a variarr�e on St�ave/Refrigerators in fvur roat�s: light furniture storage � thi�l floor arxl hause repair �terial to be stored in baserent. Pf�JCF�DIl�: Pat Fish. Fire Pr�eventi�, told the board that Mr. Heirhel had a �9 Pt'oblan. cha��n Glass�n told Mr. Harlan Heichel (son of Rayrmrxi Heichel), that he had to talfle care of the zoc�ing problem prior to aanirig to the boand. The buildirig is pr�tly aorr]e�r�ed, but vacate date has been ext-,PSx3ed imtil a cl�acisi.on is �1e. No determination can be n�de, imtil Zonin9 appraves this building as a 4 imit bldg. BC1�,F�D A�.TICN: �ai�n Glassn3n told Mr. Heichel, that if he a7uld fir�d proof �t thic h�i lding was used c�ocit�uly as a 4 tmit building prior to 1956 - -4- 2-90-H 669 E. Third Street Renneth J. Ivelsaon t 2 wlits) SUBJEIC,T: Appellant is appe3ling the "On�er to Vacate." Vacate date was January 15, 1990. F�olved - Case withdrawn. 6-90-H 1022 James Ave. Michael Pbgue (2 tuLits) S[ID,7F7LT: App�ellant is appealiryg the "Ord�r to vacate." vacate date was Deaenber 31, 1989. Talsen Carn of. 137-89-H 368 Duke St. F�nilys•tyle of St. Paul (Rocming Haase) Jeanriette Jartecelt SUBJDCT: �.pellant is requesting a vari.arx�e on having to install an additional bathroan. Pf�JC�IlVGS: Jeannette Janecek stated there �re 7 residents on the first f loor, 2 residents �Sta�rs tocx.�ied by mentally ill m�) F1�11 bathroan on first floor, and full bathrocm on Znd floor. Drm Miller, Health Dqaartment, stated that the �tairs bathroan is within the oonfiryes of the �stairs Lmi.t, tl,P„Pfore, all 7 resider�ts dawnstairs, only have use of the dawnstairs laathnnoun. (2 av+ex� the limit). BC�iRD A�CTICN: Mation was macle by Ron Aril�ry to renr�ve tl�e lock fn�n the 2nd floor door going irYto �,aer imit, so thP�+e is pernnr�ent aooessibility, 24 haurs a day to the i�stairs battu�oar►, and the variarx�e waald thsn be grarited. Seoor�d by �tt Viering. M7IZCN �gD i�1V�7S[,Y. 143-89-H 339 �lborne St. F�nilystyle of St. Paul (Roaning Hoils�e) Jeanr�tte Janeoek St7BJF7C.T: Appellarit is r�ag�,irig a variarx�e � the sleeping irocm heic,�t af only 6'6" ar�d t1�e ir�a�deqi�ate window size, as thi.s wauld cause finar�ial ha.rdsY�i�• PFd'XX�Il�: Jearu�tte Jar�ek stated tl�at there is a full size cbor on �xl f loor, with aooess to a fire e..qcape fran the sleepi�g i�ocm, so a persori aould escape in ca_�e of anergerx_y. BQ�2D AGTICN: Mo�tion t�s m3de by C��aitm�ri Glassnari to allaa one persaz to oa�a��y this roani.ng imit on 2rrl floor, for the life af the current c�wnPS. seoar.]�d by Ro�bert vieririy. M7lzav � []��ivn►�DtzS[�t. _ , (� yo-6�5� -5- 144-89-H 1596 Hewitt Avenue Rachel �Ielson (Rocmirig Ebu,se} SUB7DCT: Aplaellant is reques-ting a variar�e on the nunb�er of kaaths for the rnunb�er of ooc�nts. Withdrawn - re�cY�,ile. Chairn�n Glassit3n stated that Ms. Nelson shr�uld be sent a st.ea�-n letter requesting her to a�r at the next tre�ting, as she has alra3dy rx�t appeared the last t� meet�rigs. T#�exe was a brief discussion rega.�3ing an additional filirYg fee applied wl�z applicants cb mt shaw �. It was ac�eed that it wauld be delayed Lmtil Josie was lx�k r�xt m�nth, aryd c�ould go th�rxxgh the p�re. 10-90-H 1471 Ctam Averaa� �he Salvation P,imy (Rpaning Iiouse) Carole Baaon S[IDJDC.T: A��aellant is reque.sting a variance on the deadbolts on n�aniryg �mit cbors, also a variance on having se�rate toilet and bathroan facilities for each sex. P�CX�IlV6: Carole Baaon stated this was a residential f�cility for amtionally ar�d mentally disturbed acblescents. Zl�ere are 3 imits set up for 8 to 10 residents, 11 to 17 t1�at are su�aervised 24 hours a day by staff, for 8 haur shifts. 1�. B�.�i stated that with amtionally and mentally dist�irbed �tients, tl��ey cb mt want than to be able to lock staff azt of their roaY�s. Zl�ey mast have visual verification every 30 mir�. S1�e feels �olts would be vexy imnecessary. Do� Miller, Health De�t., stated that she had a valid point and probably should be cganted a variar�oe. BQ�tD AiCTICN: Matiori kas nade by Robert Viering to grant the variarrr.e for d�olt lorks. Seaor� by &ill Tilton. M7i'ICN tnY3S �'� i�,DTIl�D[JaLY. F[�II�R DI9CT�ZCN: Carole B�aon went on to discuss bathroan facilities. Each imit i►�cltr]es a bathroan, with 3 sinks, 2 shaw�-s & 2 toilets. She stated that the La�its were ao-ed, but wt�en m�les �ae�.e oacupying the la3throan, t1'tie.Y uti17 7P a sicyl ori the door, ar�d the wr,nr� have the sa¢� proo�ure. Ms. Baaon stated that the cx�rr+�nt wiryg being used �y be disoorxtiruaed, and arwtY�er v�cant wiryg rarodeled. �i.ch �uld allaa nnst of tl�e nx.��s to hav� a private bathrocm. BCl� A�TICN: Nbtion was m�cie by Bill Tiltfln to grant a 2 ya3r variarr�e osi the bath��ats for o�ly their use af the buildirig. Seoor�ded by Don Weida. NI7►�ICN cn�,S c�gn c��m�csr.y. M�ZE DI9C[7SSICN: Ms. B�oon als� discaas�ed the r�eed to have irore electrical aitlets installed. 5�e stat;e,d tY�at there would be a gx+eater o�ortimity to have t-hese reside�rts eleettocute thanselves. ESct.ensiaz aord had been rarr�ved frcm one resi,d�Yt`s roan. Resid�ts can anly plug in a radio, so the ryaed for exten.sion aon�s i.s tmr�essaxy. BQ�FiD AICTICN: M�tio�n was m3cie by Bill Tilton to c�ant a 2 year vari.anoe on the electrical cutle�ts for or�ly tl�eir use of the building. Seo� by D� Weida. -6- � 1-90-F 723 W�odlawn Ave. Cliffo�l C. Soren_�en (32 tmits) SUH7DCT: A�ellant is r�sting a �ariar�e pe.rt.airLing to: extend ta�erature pressure relief valve on boiler to 12 irr.hes frcm floor. PFdJCF.EDINGS: Cliffo�l Sorensen, Owner, and Cazvlyn Sorensen, Attorney, �re present. NL�. Sorensen stated that the reg�irerent is only that the piping be safe, t1� was no sp�ific specification. State Goc�e allaws the current �enting, arr3 the City int-.erprets "safe" to inaozporate the icl� of venting dawra.�d. She wpnt on to say, that the pr�lan with v�ting dawratiatd, is that it �uld be vented into a wal}a�ray alongsi.de t1� boiler, and l�ders,etc. are carried back and forth in this area. Also the PiPin9 �uld have to be very heavy, ar�d if it was accidently hit, it �xzld prc�ably n�ture. TY�e current venting is cl�cked fr�uently, and has never failed. SZae Zbskey, Fire Prevention, stated that the State Mechar�ial Ca1e c�vers this issue, and it.is clirect.ed to l9ae�p hr�t ste�n away fxYm the f_ace, arxl vented � tawasds the floor. Bc]�RD ACTICN: Mation was m�r1e by James Iaughlin to grant variance if either the P�P�9 � � or to the h�ck by adding an elbaw and ni�ple, at lea.�t a minunm of 7' high. Seoorx�ed by Dr�n Weida. MJTICN 4�iS (�tgD t]n�iNl'NDt1SLY. 3-90-F 21 tl�uu 27 S. St. Albans Elizabeth KruegP_r (7 tmi.ts) Resolved-Ca..�e withdrawn. 4-90-F 271 SZmnit Averaae Zhan�s Nbelle.rnn3n (9 Lmits) S[IDJ�X.T: Appellant is Y,e�uestirYg an ext.ension of time for one year to design and finarice a secorxl exit f�xn the thircl floor. Pf�JCE'EDIlVGS: Mr. Moellexm3ri �u.ld like a 1 year extension to provicle a 2rr1 floor exit frcm the thit�d floor. Sta�e 7�osk�y, Fire Prewention, oa�ent,ed that she didn't have arry objection to Mr. Moellernt�n's raquest. BQ�1RD A�.'�tCN: Nbtion was m�e by Bill Tilton to grant one ya3r e�ct�sio�n frcm July 1, 1990 to July 1,' 1991. Se�nded by Robert Vier�rig. M7�ICN t�3S C�tIID L]N AI�TIl�'DL]S'[.�Y. 5-90-F 2105 Stillwater Aver�e Donald Ha�cling (Ct�ur.h Ptrperty) c1�nc�h of St. ZY�ac�as the �ostle S[IDJEX.T: Appellant is requestiryg a variar�ce on the cYx�rh having to install ganic bars on all five �ets of dauble cbors, becau�e of the aost. As per Steve 7ac�card - Ftesolved - withdrawn. � y _ 90 -6 -�- 9-90-F 168 �nit Av�nue John F. Sauro SIIDJDC,T: A�ellant is requesting a variar�ce on the exit ctioor on the north side of kazilding to ren�in locked at all times. Pf�JC�Il�7GS: Mr. Sauro stated that he has 4 e�trar�ces, but he wants to keep the cbor on the New Kellogg sic� locked at all tiires. There are only 2 apts. that wr�uld use that door (the rest af the building have three exits). In ca..�e of fire, he said that the glass in the cbor c�aald be broken. He �t on to say, that t1�e c]oor has been left cyper►, ar�d in the colder te�eratzzre, his PiI� froze �ich was very c+�s'tly to repair. Also pec�le have the tenderx..�y to t,respa.,ss. If rer�uired exit, a panic laar alaim aazld be in.stalled. Mr. Sauro agreed to have Sue Zbskey chec-k to see if this was a required exit► and if so, he was agreeable to installing a g�nic bar alarm. His m�in oor�cern was to keen that door lor3sed, ar�d cb whatever ctias ryaaessai.y to acaa�plish tl�at. BC1�2D A�C'�ICN: M7tion was � by Bill Tilton tA qrant him a 30 day e�ension Lu�til April 1, 1990, imtil Fire cletennir�es what should be cbne. Ser�orxl�ad by Ron Ankeny. M7�ICN 4�1S C�2IID LA�NIl�DU5LY. 11-90-F 293 N. Wilclex Street Jeffrey J. Seidl SUBJ�Cr: �ppellant is r�ting a variar�ae � having to install a seaond exit o�n the thircl floor because of the cast. PF�JC�INGS: There Has rr� curr�t Certificate of �x.y on builcling, and Mr. Seidl raqu�rted an in_��ection. ITT Finar�cial tprevious awt�.rs) told him that there �re rr� aode deficiencies on the c�lling. Stae �oslaey, Fire Prevention, stated tl�at she r+enanbers the biailding, arrl has been thraigh the building before. Mr. Seidl has taken care of most of tl� c7�efici.�ies, but in oraer to install a sec�orxl exit, he clefinitely wazld regaire a substantial ama.mt of time b�ynrxi the M�r-h 20, 1990 d�eadlirye. BC1�F�D A�C'�ICN: M�tion was m3ctie by Bill Tilton to d�y variaryce, but cgant him imtil July 1, 1991 to cxnplete work. Seaxr.�d by Rpbert Vieririg. NU�ICN 4�iS . • CARR�D L�NIl�DU5LY. -8- 13-90-F 433 Ashlar�d Avenue Michael Winer-Cyr (4 i,uiits) SUHTECT: r�ellant is r�uesting a variat�e on havirx� to provicle a K�y Box, fire se�ration aver furnace, secorxl e.�cit f�xn thitd floor, rarove n�mex wiring, provic� dirt leg. Also r�aecl an extension of time to ocn�lete the re�irs pertaini.rig to r�ir front stq�. Install outside rails, clean rear fiirnaae, ranave ar�stible storage, provide c�wner info. pas°t C af O, tes°t tag fire extirx�uishers, plane clpor, r�ir autlets, re.place tile, rerove h3tteries, & raise fir�od. P�I1�S: Niike Wi.ner�r stated that m�st of the itans are �leted, outsi.�e itgcu have been � until �aeather pexmits, arid that he is rr�t a�ling mc�st of the itst�s mentior�cl. Iie is, ha�ver, appealing the key box. 'r1,;� is a 4�lex, bu�t 2 imits have their awn private entrance fran the cxitside. Zi�e front cbors are large glass cbors, arr3 to enter Mr. Wirtier-C�r's �mit ar�d the neic��bors Lmit, are larc,�e glass doors. Slae Zbslsey. Fire Pre�rention, had rx� objection to gra►�ting thi.s variar�ce for tr�ese t� Lmits. BCY� A�.TICN: Nbtion was m� by Bill Tilton to grant a variar�ae � the key box for the t� tmits, as long as the buildirig is aw►�er occ�ied. Seaorr]ed by C�airn�n Gla.�st�n. M7rICN G�1S CAF1EtIID iIl�iDTlNDUSC,Y. E�ffR DISCUSSICN: Mr. Winer-C�r discussed the two fire se�rations aver the furr�ce, and the dirt legs on the water haater ar�d furr�ace. Slae Zbskey, Fire Prevention, stated tl�at the furnace that serves itself, cbesn't neecl any fire s�ration. S�he also said that the roan that serves tw� fu�xr-ices is adequate in size for one sprinkl.er head, and is rr�t in violation. It was cleleted frcm the list of deficiencies, and Sue sai.d she waild check further to m3ke sure. Mr. Winer-�r thaught it was �mfair, as �11 as expensive, to prnvide a dirt leg. Mr. Tilton s�tated that it was a safe�ty feature, ar�d not that expensive. BO�RD A�.TICN: M�tiorc� was � by Bill Tilton to deny the vari.arx:e on the dirt leg. Seoonderl by Don Weida. MmICN 4�S CALdtIID L1I�iIl�DiI.SLY. NLRE DI9C[JSSICN: Mr. Winer�r stat,ed t1�at t1� rarex wiring goes fmn tl�e j�u�c.�tioci box. iur3er the joist to a cxawl sp�e in the back furrr�e roan. 13obocly really ccmes in clirect aontac:t with this wiring. It's stapled to the iux3ersi�d�e af the joists. Mr. Hlirtier-C'�r agreed to strap the mrex to a 1" by 2" bo�aYrl, ratl�_r than disc�onnecting it cxnple�tely. BC�FtD A�.'�IQJ: Nbtion was ma�le by James Laughlin t,o c�ant variar�ce as loryg as a the rcmex i.s str�ped to a 1" by 2" bo�an3. S�eoonctiad by Bill Tilton. M7TICN inP�S � UN��C. DI9CUSSICN C?�TTIlWID: Ser�orxl exit frcm the third floor - there are twu bedr�oans which op� irYtfl pait of the 2rr1 and 3rd floor, �ich is ooca�i�d by 1�. Winer-Cyr. Z'her+e is a��oxicn3tely 300 or 400 sq. ft. of usable �e. There are srralfle detect.ors prnse�t. T�e Baan� did rx�t thiuil{ that he r�e�ded to have a vari�, ber.ause it kas part of his imit, ar�d the bedt�+oatB are nat i��ci�e,d to be rented aut. It was reocYmnerr]ed that S�e Zbslaey verify tl�e i�oan size, and no�tify the Board and Mr. iniixye�,.r-�C�r af the axt.c�ane. He asked ttye Baatd to grant an extensioa� af t�me far the autside it.ens. Ae has a March 22nd deadline. BC]�7D A�CTICN: rbti�on was m3de by Bill Tilton to grarYt an extensio�n of time to «nplete autside itens �t,il ,ha�e 30. 19'90. Seoorr3ed by Don Weida. Mri'ICN (�iIID i]NANlNDU.SC,Y. , � 6� 90-6� -a- 14-90-F 894 St. Clair Avenue Francoise Jaac�ae (33 imits) SUBJDCT: Appellant is regaestirig a variarre on the preserit deac�olts. P�X.'F.EDIlNGS: Jcahn Mr;Carthy, NY�nager & John Ni3hegar�e, Tenant of 894 St. Clai r Averu�e attended. Mr. N3�Y�egane read a letter to the Baarcl stating haa �ny times he has baen ro�ed ar�d what it.ens �aexe stol�. He �rants a better security systsn. Mr. Nnarthy stated that all the a�artment imits have c�cmolt locks that are 5/8", rather than the 1" �olt rer�aired by the Ca.ty. Stae �bskey. Fire Prevention, stated that the 1" deaclbolt requir�t�ent is a Fbusizig Oocle requi�t, Fire has to call it, and rr� variance can be cyranted by than. Mr. McCa.Ythy thaught the existing deadbolts �_.re sufficient, and that the mex�ey to re�ir then, c�au.ld go to a better use. BQ�FtD ACTICN: Nbtion was m3d�e by Ron Arilseny to grant variar�ae, ex� that �nagere�t be fozved to in.s�tall 1" dr�adbolt on Mr. Mal�egane's door to start with, artid thPn repla�ce then as tY�ey �r aut to 1" �lts. Seoor�l by Bill Tilton. M7iZCN 4�S CAF�2IID i]L�i�III�DUSLY. Ti�exe being no further busir�ess, meeting adjaurnad at 3:30 p.m. i �� 0 � � � N v a� � . � � rn rn �r w � � � .. a o � � w o N � � � � 1--- � � Z � � O W � � � w w O � � � � � m O � � •� �� o ro � 3 .� � � U � � . N O fYi � � �C Q �0 � � N � � i � � `� �i � L�i N ''" O F� d' tt1 v J (Z _ Q � a. —t o J t/1 S.. Y F-= N .a � N S� p„ � W >- Q1 UO � � +� Z C.> > � N >- >- Z +� C F- F- t0 C O r-� �-+ 00 O t U U M V d � �e - �s�� . � ; ,� . _ ��,. �:: � .�i.: . • ��'. � ��.n � R�CORDCD ON � �� :� ,,=. � MAR 7 g �� :� 19 �, :�.�. .- . �� ,�''°. �. � f ,. y� �ti� ��"' ,�;`` . X� � �� `� � �� or� � . C�� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) Albert B: Olson. I, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the attached copy of Council File No. 90�545 as adopted by the City Council. . . . Apri1. 5:. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .19 90 . . . and approved by the Mayor. . . . . . . . . Apri1. 9:. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 19 90 . , , with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy . of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul,. Minnesota this . . . . . . .?6th. . , day of . , , ,FebruarX. . , . , ,A.D. 19. 91. . . . . . . .. . . . . . .J.�:. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . """�--�-t- City Clerk. "�i� � ,��:;'',. � _t y �J � f'y ' 1 w' � � �w-.za�� s ... - �.�.� � � . • . "wa , 1 � � �` ... �'�� ...n.,l,� . s� ' i 'c• ... ._ .,,e,..,, . �''i�' r; . � J..� ` s , . _ , � M`2°•-'fT 1 �ir�� j ' , .� e � . � �. ,� , � .. ' �.� .: . �- i .... �: . . � , , _. a � `.� . � �ti � .� �, � b; . �� \. �_ . •` ... a ,0 - �� ar'i" �'a. ♦..�..v acz.. . �/ �� c;� \ � �..9 $� � , � �{y � . . a . =, ��i�, a � ::, .� ., 4� �� i �� , . . . . .. ;L. 'x'1' Y "'11..' ..,..__. O. R ! G ! N A L , � r Council File # � �S�-sJ ' ��38��$ 1 Green Sheet # � .3 RESOLUTION � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA �\ . ; `� . � i, �, � Presented By - Referred To Committee: Date BE IT RESOLVED, That the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the action of the Property Code Enforcement Board (Saint Paul Board of Appeals & Review) pertaining to the following listed property and as shown by the Excerpted Minutes of said Property Code Enforcement Board, and dated February 13, 1990 and marked EXHIBIT A, and attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference: DATE OF BOARD MINUTES CASE NO: PROPERTY APPEALED APPELLANT 2/13/90 145-89-F 415 Summit Ave. Dennis Brose BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on a second exit from the third floor, with the condition that the third floor be owner occupied. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Auditor ' s Subdivision No. 38 St. Paul , Minn. Lot 6 ----------------------------------------- 3/90 137-$'9-H 368 Duke St. Familysty e of St. Paul Jeannette�anecek BOARD A ON: Granted a v iance pertaining t �installing a\ddition- . al bathroom, with the condit i bn that the lack on the 2nd floor �going to the uppe`r unit be removed, � so there is permanent accessibilityr, 24 hours a�day o the upstairs bat�h��oom. \ � PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Stinson and Ramse �bd ot 3 Blk 3 � ------------------------------------------ . � O �,IGI �IAL c,�� `��S � 2�8`70'78 2/1�0 143-89-H � 339 Colborne St. �, Familystyle of St. Paul �� '•,,� Jeannette Janecek �,,. � '•., BOARD ACTION: Granted a var�' ance on the roo�n size on��`the second '�.� floor, with the condition that o ly one per'son occupy room, for the life of the current ow� er. PROPERTY DESCRI� N: Stinson Brow and Ramse ' s � Y , addition to St. Paul Lot 26 Blk 14 ------------------------------------------ 2/13/90 10-90-H 1471 Como Ave. The Salvation Army Carole Brown BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on deadbolts ; also granted a variance on bathrooms and electrical outlets for only their use of the building for two years. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Lake Park Addition Saint Paul Lots 1 thru Lot 7 Blk 8 ------------------------------------------ 2/13/90 1-90-F 723 Woodlawn Ave. Clifford C. Sorennson BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on pressure relief valve, with condition that either the piping goes up or to the back by adding an elbow and a nipple. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Saint Catherine Park Lots 1 and Lot 2 Blk 5 -------------------------------------------- 2/13/90 13-90-F 433 Rshland Ave. Michael Winer-Cyr BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on the key box for the two units, with the condition that the building is owner occupied. Also granted a variance on romex, with the condition that the romex is strapped to a 1" x 2" board. PROPERTY DESCRIPTIOIV: Condominium Number 194 The Rshland Condominium Unit No. 1 thru 5 ------------------------------------------- � � 0 �.� � 1 �l� , u=yo �� L z�8�o�8 2/13/90 14-90-F 894 St. Clair Ave. Francoise Jacque BOARD ACTION: Granted a variance on the deadbolt locks , with the condition that management be forced to install 1" deadbolt on Mr. Mehegane' s door immediately, and then replace the other locks with 1" deadbolts as they need replacement. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Ridgewood Park Addition to the City of St. Paul , � Ramsey Co. , Minn. Lots 1 , 2 and Lot 3 Blk 8 -------------------------------------------- 3 Y� Navs Absent Requested by Department of: imon oswitz � ' on � acca ee � et man -. un e � i son BY� _ � Adopted by Council: Date APR 5 195Q Form Ap ed by City Attorney Adoption Cer,tified by Council Secretary By: �/ � � 1 �By� �- Approved by Mayor for Submission to � �R � �gg0 councii Approved by Mayor: Date � , t7�.1��/�='��'�/ gy; `�j,''`�'i��.�-�� By° �t��11SNED AP R 141990 � - �=�o'� ��_ � �� a �r a SAIlJI' P�LZ BQ�RD OF APPFALS & REVIELV 555 CFiIAFt S'IRE�,'I' ST. P�UL, l�v'�9CTi'A 55101 ��5,��,,78 - (6121 292-7775 ;�i[,�ES, 1�I'II�G OF FE�t[�RY 13, 1990 N�F�2S PRESEiJr: Rc�n Glasst�n, Chairn�r� Ronald Ankeny William Tilton Rcbert Viering Donald Weida James Iaughl�n AL9� PRFSFNr: Pat Fish, Fire & Safety D�aertrr�ent Clifford Sorensen SUe Zbskey, Fire & Safety Depar�t Carolyn Sorensen Carrolyn Sh�herrl, Public Health Than3s Nbellerm3n Don Miller, Public Health � Michael Winer�r Clifford Sorenson Jeffrey Siecll Carole B�aon Virg.inia Zink M�ry Relly J� M�Y �ni G Bi�ose JoYui Mehegane gay Faricy Mrs. Binse SIP,F'F: fl�iB KCfI.STAD, JL�I'JY i�i5'1'FFd�'�,N. & N�E C�2EEN Chairnt3n Glass�an called the meetirYg to ordex at 1:30 p.m. Febnr�y 13, 1990. He �lc�crc�ed the Appellants ar�d explained the nznoediu�+es, stating that what the baard cbes i.s reaarmerrl action to the City da�il. He also asked that statsre�ts be brief, ar�d that the bc�.rd w�as there as fellaw citizens to help than in a fair �an�r. �n Glassnan has aorrespor�d�e frcm b�th his office and the city rega�li.rig the nacne c1�+nge. It ha5 again bein9 r��est'red to Oa�cil Presid�t Wilson that the named be char�ed t�o "Prq�erty Cbcle ElZfore�erpnt Board of A�ls," or the "Praperty Oode Ehforoere.nt Appaals Bo�alxl." It is felt that �thing in tl� title shauld relate to pn�p�erty. Ti�e �oard should hear a response to the.ir recg�est shortly. Cfiairnt�ri Glassn3n stated that the Boarcl is still loo�rig for one m�re n�nber. He tlxxzght it wu�ld be b�-ficial to get sareAne relatirig to general oor�.stn�ction. Plunbin9, etc. Ror�ald Arilseny reoam�r.�ed Terry NbGraff. Don Weida oc�[ireSlt'�ed th3t a �n It�ay be interested iri tl�e �o.sit„i.On. Cl,airm:�n (,la�.�n �;d t1�at it really di�'t m3tter, that anyrx� interested, should oontact the Nl3yor's Office. 1. A�.pn�val of the minutes of the Jarnaaxy 9. 1990 rneetixrg as sukmitbed in writuyg. Nbtion � by I�ori Ankeny to apprnve the minutes of the Jar�uary 9. 1990 meeting as su}�nitted in writir�g. Seaar]ed by Robert Vierir�g. M7iZCN CAFt12gD L]L�,NIl"DUSLY. � 2�8�0�8 -�- �. � �: C�.SE 1�: A�fJPEF1TY �.PPEAL�D ?�PPEI��Tf 16-90-H 1542 W. Seventh St. �irrel G. Hathaway (1 unit? S[.�H7ECT: Appellant is r�uesting an ea�tension of time to do the r�essary re�iu-s �rt�;n�ig to: FIRST FID�2 - Y�eating �ui�nerit thetimstat rr�t fimctioning properly, defective plast�er on ceiling to wall of stairway to �r1 floor. B�SII�gNr - inpropP�ly installed electrical wiririg, illegal spliced la� co�3, operi electrical j�uyction box, rio shut-off valve on gas lir�e to water heater, water heater has rx> ts�cperature pressure relief valve, ha3tirig �uigrent cbast laden. c�AL - prnvide heat to a minunm of 68 F, insufficient � outlets, rgrove ext.ension ao�is, ins�tall snoke detectors on a clifferent cir�.�it to prevent ma].f�u�tion chie to blawn circ.uits. PFtOC�Il�7GS: The A�ellant stated that his te.nants have beeil a large problan, ar�d that he didn`t ra3lize all the problens that exis�ted at the p�-ty. He claimed that the inspect�or v�anted eve.rything b�vught t� to � as if it was r�esa. He claimed that it wwld be a finar�ial hardship. Mr. Hathar�aay stated that it.ens #7, 8 & 9 of the violation list Ferta?��ng to the heating, has now been corre�t-.ed. The tenants mw rentirig this prr�pert.y owes him $1,625, and he r�eed.s this �roney to cxrcplete the �rk. He is willing to cb the work, but needs rrore time. Carrolyn Shephe�l, an ins�ecbor for Ehvirormental Health, said she was willirrg tA grant him m�re time, as lorig as all the illegal wiring was rsroved before an ext-.ension of time �as granted, as it was a definite ha�ard. Mr. Hathakay ccmrented if she �uld get his t�ants out, then he auld cip the wc�rk. Mr. Hath�.�ay has served his tenants with an eviction rr�tice to vacate by the erxi of Felan�Y- If u�on rei�ection March 1. 1990, if the t.enarits have r�at vacated, then Carrolyn St��d could initiate a cond�tion, ar�d racvve the t�enants in that m�nner. BQ�2D A�.fiICN: l�btion was m-x1e by Rpbert viering to allav Mr. Hathaway 60 days (Nl�y 1, 1990) to aatplete the r�ecessary *�?*-�, witll tl�e pravision that the P�Y rx�t be rented c�ririg that time. Seoorx3�d by William Tilton. M7�ICN C�?IID iII�TAN.QrDiJSLY. � yo -6�� -�- 2�8'�0'�8 145-89-F 415 �cniit Avenue Dennis Eirose (4 wzits) SUB�7E�r: appellant was at the January meeting ar�d after mrh discussion, the �ellant was requested to meet with Fire Prevention, and be allawt�d to return to the meetirYg in Febrvary for furt.hex discussion gertaining to: havirx� to provide a sec�r�d �xit frcm the third floor. PROCEmIlVGS: Pat F`ish, re�resentir�g Fire Prevention, stated that she met with Mr. Birose, and that it was Fire Prevention's that he org�*�lly . - interrled to use alternate prot�tion, in lieu of the 2nd exit f�xn the 3rd floor. Ac�aording to the position of the Fire Marshal, this n�ean.s the sprinkling of the entire building, tx�t just the aarnrxi areas. Ms. Fish distinctly ra��ber-s telling Mr. Bmse rbt to do the r,.ork, imtil he had pu].led his pP..nnit. Zf�e Builcting De�rtrnent would n�t issue his pemut, because they didn't unders-tar�d why the pexmit beirig pul led, w�s only for the stairway sprinklers. Mr. Brose had nat yet gotten Baa�l appraval. Mr. Brose has a ca�ination ha3t ar�d sroke detector systan in tt� stairways. Ms. Fish caent on to expla in to the B�3 that the problen is ao�ing a variar�ce on sprin}tlirig the stain�y alorie means that the sprin}sl.er heads cb rx�t g� off, unless t1�e fire is right in t1� imrediate area. Mr. Brose told tl�e Boa�l that sprinkling the entise builcling wYx�ld aost aFproxi�tely $30,000, as it m9ant alot of re-aonstn�ction. Mr. Brose stated that if sa�thing activated any or�e of the sroke ��ors, the entire systsn wtiuld go off, wizich is nx>nitored 24 haurs a day, by a central r.nnitoring station. BC,I�RD ACTICN: Ronald Aril�eny m�e a m�tion to grant a vari,ar�ce, as he didn't see a differesre betw�l the 2r�d floor aryd the 3rc1 floor. He stated that Mr. Birose c�t thcr��c}h alat of �rk to see that there was alot af sroke de�tection ar�d water prate�tion for that one exit. Seoorr3ed by Rd�st Viering. A frieixlly ame�rent was � stating as long as the 3rd floor was owner occl�ied. Zhis was aocepted by t�It-. Brose. rrli'Ia�T cA�tIEn In�lvn►�DUS�.,Y. 7-90-F 596 Fbrtlar�d Ave. Rayirond Heichel l 4 imi.ts) SUBJDC.T: Appellant is requestirig a variar�oe on Stove/Refrigerators in faur roat�s: 1 ight furniture storage on thind f loor arni hause repair m3terial to be stored in bas�t. �IlVGS: Pat Fish. Fire Pievention, told the kz�n�i that Mr. HeichQl had a zoriing Problan. (�a?�n Glassn3n told Mr. Harlan Heichel (son of Raymorrl Heichel), that he had to take care of the z.ociing problen prior to oanixYg to the bc�rd. 24�e building is pr�tly ooa�decned, but v�cate date has be� ext.erided wYtil a decision is m-x�e. No detemur�ation can be n�cle, imtil Zoni.ng a��raves this building as a 4 Lmit bldg. � BC�D A�.TICN: Ct�ai�n Glassn3n t�old Mr. HeicYyel, that if he aould firxi proo�f � that ttiis building was used aontirnxxLSly as a 4 Lmi.t building prior to 1956 • 2�8�078 -4- 2-90-H 669 E. Thi.rd Street henr�eth J. Ivelson (2 imits) SUBJECT: A��ellant is a�ealing the "Or�der to Vacate." Vacate date was Januazy 15, 1990. Resolved - Ca._�e witlxlras..-n. 6-90�I 1022 James Ave. Michael Fbg►ae (2 tmits) SUH7DC'T: A�ellant is appealing the „order to v�cate." vacate date was _ D�anber 31, 1989. TakP� Care of. 137-89-H 368 U�ke St. Familys�tyle of St. Paul (Roanirig Ekxa.se) Jeannette Janeoelc SUB�DCT: Appellant is requestirig a var�ar�ce on havirig to install an additior�al bathtrocm. �IlVGS: Je3nnett�e Jar�ecek stated there w�ere 7 resid�ts on the first f loor, 2 residents �stairs (oocvpied by mentally ill men) Ft�ll l�throan on firs�t floor, arYi full bathirocm on 2rr3 floor. Don Miller, H�lth D�t, stated that the upstairs l�throan is withi.n the c�onfines of the upstairs imit, tl�esefore, all 7 residents dawr�stairs, only have use of the dawnstairs batYiroan. (2 aver tl�e limi.t). BC�RD FLTICN: l�btion has ma�de by Ron Arilseny to rgc�ave the lock fmn the �d floor cbor going int-:o �r umi.t, so there is pern�t �cessibility, 24 haurs a day tA the ,�'ai*� batturocm, ar�d the variarx�e wwld then be c,�anted. Seoarrlecl by lb�bert viering. NL7�ICN CAF�tIFD IR�NIlN�TSGY. 143-89�-H 339 Qolborne St. Familystyle of St. Paul (Roaning fY�qe) Jeanr�ette Jar�eae]c SC�7FX.T: Appellant is r�ues-t,irig a variarx�e on the sleeping iroan heic�t of only 6'6" and the irsac�aquate wirxbw size, as this woul.d cause fir�ar�ial }�arr7chi P• PFdOC�Il�]GS: Jearu�ette Janacek stated that there is a full size door on �rl (j floor, with ar�oess to a fire escape frcm the sleeping roan, so a pei-sor► oauld ]( escape in case of energency. � BC1�tD A�,TICN: Nbtion was t�cie by Ci�aiim3n GlassYnan to allaw one person to oaca�y this roaiung uni.t on 2rr1 floor, for the life of the curr�t awner. seaorx�ed by Ro�be.rt viering. rrnzav CA�tgD L��. � yo-6�s.� . , . z�s7o�e -5- 144-89-H 1596 Hewitt �venue Rachel tielson (Roaning Hr.xa,.�e) SUB,7�C.T: A��ellant is r�uesting a vari�e on the r�unber of h3ths for the rn�nber of ooc�ants. Withdrawn - r�e. �n Glass�ri stat,ed that Ms. Nelson shcxald be sent a stP_arn letter r��ting her to a�r at the ne.�ct meeting, as she has already mt appeared the last twn meetim3s. Z�se was a brief di.scussion regas�ling an ac3ditional filirYg fee applied w� aFplicants do mt shaw �. It was agreed that it wauld be delayed Lmtil Josie was bac�k r�ext month, and oould go th�ugh the prooe�re. 10-90-H 1471 Ccnn Avern�e Zl�e Sal�ation Arniy (Rrxming Hou,se) Carole B�con S[IB�7DCT: Appellant is reques-tirig a variarx�e on the d�olts on rocmirig imit clr�ors, also a variance on having sep�rate toilet ar�d kx�thrnan facilities for � each se�c. �IlVGS: Carole Baaon stated this was a resid�tial fa,cility for amtionally ar�d mentally dis�turbed �leyoents. Zl�ere are 3 �its set`� for 8 to 10 resider►ts, 11 to 17 that are su�aexvised 24 haurs a day by staff, for 8 hour shifts. M5. Ba�oon stated that with erotior�ally and m�tally disturbed patients, tt�ey cb not want t-han to be able to lock staff aut of their rocins. Zfiey m�,st have vi.sual vpsification eveYy 30 minut.es. She feels de�cibolts wnuld be very �u�r�ec�essary. Dor� Miller, Health Dept., stated t1�at she h�d a valid poirct and prob�bly struld be granted a variarre. BCl�'D A�.TICN: M�tion Has � by Robert Vi.erir�g to grant the variarx� for c�olt loc}cs. Seoorx�d by Bill Tilt.on. M7�ICN i+�,S ('ARR.iID Lfl�P,IVINDUSGY. � DI9C'�SICN: Carole Baa�n w�nt on to cli.scuss bathroan facilities. Far-h imit ir�cludes a bathroan, with 3 sinks, 2 shac�-s & 2 toile�ts. She stated that the Lmits were oo-ed, but when m�les c�aere oac�ying the bathroccn, th�Y utilize a sicg� on the door, and the �n�en have the sa��e prooedure. Ms. Baoon stated that the current wing being u_5ed re�y be disaontiniaed, and anather vacant wirig rerodeled, r�ich waztd allaw m�-t of the roac�s to have a private bathroan. BC� A�.TICN: Nbtion was m-�ie by Bill Tilton to grant a 2 year varianae on the bathroa� for only their use of the building. Seoorrled by Don Weida. N1nICN V�,S Cp,�tIID i1�il�TIl�DUSI.Y. M.12E DISCUSSICN: IKs. Baoon also dis�ed the need to have m�re electrical aztlets installed. She stated tl�at there wr�a.l.d be a greater opp�rt�uLity to have t�tese residents eleckrocut-.e thanselves. Ektension oord had be� remv�ed fn�n one resi,d�t's roan. Resi,c�nts can only plug in a raclio, so the need for exten.sion vords is imr�ecessaiy. BCY�F�'D A�.'�ICN: Mation was n� by Bill Tilt,on to grant a 2 year variance on the electrical cutlets for only their use of the }aa.ilding. Seoorx3ad by Don Weida. -6- 238`70'7.& . 1-90-F 723 4tioodlawn Ave. Clifforr] C. Sorensen (32 imits) � SGBTDCT: A�ellant is r�sting a �ariar�ce pertaining to: e.xt��d taYperature pressure relief valve on boiler to 12 is�s fr� f loor. PF�OCF,EDIlVC�: Cliffo�l Sorensen, Owr�er, and CarolY-n Sorensen, Attorr�, �aere present. Ms. SorensP� stated t1�at the requirarerit is only that the piping be safe, there was no specific spacification. State C�ode allaws the current ��nting, arxl the City intP�rets "safe" to ir�orporate the idea of venting down�rd. She wpnt on to say, that the problen with venting dawc�ran�i, is that it �uld be vented into a walltway alongside the boiler, and lack�rs,etc. are carried back ar�d forth in this area. Also the PiPincJ �uld have to be veiy heavy, ar�d if it was aacidently hit, it would probably n�b.ire. The current venting is checke�l fr�aently, and has r�ever fai.led. S�ae 7.bskey, Fire Prevention, stated that th�e State Mecl�ncial Qode aovers this issue, ar�d it.is direct.ed to keep hot ste�acn away f�xn the face, ar�d vented daHna�rd tawaYds the floor. BC�RD ACizaQ: rbti.on was m�de by Jaares Iau�lin to grant variance if either the P1P�3 9� � or to the l�ck by addiryg an elbaw and nipple, at le��t a mininun of 7' high. Seooix3�ec� by Den W�ida. NU�ICN tn�S CAI�t'�D L�iNIl�'Di1SLY. 3-90-F 21 thru 27 S. St. Alh�ns Elizabeth Knaeger (7 wlits) Res�lved-Ca.�e withdrawn. 4-90-F 271 S�nmit Avernae Tix�s Moellenn3n (9 imi.ts) S[IDJDC.T: Appellant is requesting an eXtension of time for one year to de.sign and finaryce a s�aorxi exit f�xn the third floor. PF�INGS: Nh�. Nl�elle.rn�n wruld like a 1 year ext�sion to provide a �d floor exit fmn the third floor. St�e �bskey, Fire Prevention, ocrccrented that she clidn't have any �jecti� to Mr. M�eller�n's ra�uest. BCI� �ICN: Nbtion was m3de by Bill Tilton to grant one year ext�,sion frcm July 1, 1990 to July 1; 1991. Seoor�ded by Robert Viering. M�ICN V�S C�2IED [Il3A�[�DUS[,Y. 5-90-F 2105 Still�rater Avergae Dor�ald Hazd.ing (Ctn�mh Pt�qaerty) C�nzt�ch of St. Ztr.m�s the Apos-tle SC�JDC.T: A�ellant is rer.��-�g a variar�ce on the crn�+ch having to irLStall panic l�ars on all fiv�e sets of dauble cloors, because of the o�st. As per Steve Zaacard - Resolved - withdrawn. �v � � y f0 �6 . � , � 2�8'70'78 -�- 9-90-F 168 Sw.mnit Aveniae John F. Sauro SL�BJDC,T: �ellant i.s r�uesting a variar�ae on the exit cbor on the r�orth sictie of building to ran�.in locked at all times. PFtOCF�EDIl�IGS: Mr. Sauro stated that he has 4 entrar�ces, but he ctiants to keep the dr�or on the New Kellogg side locke3 at all times. There are only 2 a�s. that �xald use that door (the rest of the buildirig have three exits). In case of fire, he said that the glass in the door cr�uld be broken. He �aent cn to say, that the cbor has been left qa�n, ar�d in the aolder t�cperata�re, his PiPes froze which �as c�ry oostly to re�aair. Also peo��le have the t�x.y to trespass. If rer��i red exit, a g3riic bar alaxm cz�uld be installed. Mr. Sauro agreed to have S1ae Zbskey ct�eck t�o see if this was a recnaired exi.t, ar�d if so, he was agreeable to installing a g3nic l�ar alarm. Hi.s m3in oonaern was to kee�� that door locked, ar�d clo wi�atever t�as rr�cessary to ac�ornplish that. BC�2D A�.TICL�I: M�tion was m�e by Bill Tilton to grant him a 30 day extension w�til �pril 1, 1990, �til Fire deterniir�s what should be cbr�e. Sepor�cled by Ron Ankeny. M7TICN V�S C�ftIID L�TANlI�Di75LY. 11-90-F 293 N. Wilder Street Jeffrey J. Seidl SUH7DCr: A�Qellant is rer�ue.sting a variarr�e on having to install a seoor�d exit . on the thinl floor because of tl� cost. Pi�C�Il�S: There �as rx� current Certifi.cate of Oac�arx.y on b�a.ilding. arxi Mr. Sr�idl r�uest.ed an inspection. ITT Fir�rycial (previous awners) told him that there �aere rx� oale clefici�cies on tl�e cka�lling. Slae �bskey, Fire Prevention, stated that she rana�ers the building, ar�d has be� thraugh the building before. Mr. Seidl has taken care of most of the deficiencies, but in or�der to install a seoocrl exit, he c1efinitely wauld r�uire a s��bstantial ama�t of tin� b�yrmd the N�m.h 20, 1990 da�dli.ne. BC1��D px(.TICN: I�btion was n�de by Bill Tilton to d�y variance, but 3rant him imtil July 1, 1991 to c�nlete wc�rk. Seoorx3�d by Rr�bert Viering. iK7I'ICN tn�,S . - � L�iNIlKXJSI,Y. I � , . 2�8�0'78 -8- 13-90-F �33 AshlarXl Avenue i�lichael Winer�.�r (� i.m.its) SU"R7ECT: r��ellant is re�uesting a variance on ha��ing to provide a E�e�- Box, fire sep3ration aver furnace, se,cond e.xit frrz� third floor, ra:nve mrex wir�ng, provide clirt leg. Also r�l an extension of t�me to ccr,plete the r�aairs pertainirig to repa.ir front ste�s. Install outside rails, clean rear furnace, rezr�ve ca�us-tible storage, pravide a�r�r info. post C of O, i-.�st tag fire e.�ctinguishers, plane cir�r, r�ir autlets, replace tile, ra:nve �itteries, & raise fire�od. PRt�C�L�]GS: Nlike Winer-C�r stated that most of the itats are a.c�leted, outside it� have been exte.rr.3ed until �ather pemuts, ar�d that he is rr�t a�gealing m�st of the it.sns mentioned. He is, ha�ver, appa3ling the key box. Z#iis is a 4�lex, but 2 u�its have their awn private entrarx� fmn the out.sicle. The front cbors are large glass doors, and to enter Mr. Winer-Cyr's imit arid the ne.ighbors Lmit, are lazge 91ass doors. Stae Zbsk�y. Fire Prevention, had r�o objection to granting this variance for these twn tmits. BC,1�,RD A�I'ICN: Nbtion was m�e by Bill Tilton to grant a variame on the key box for the t� Lmits, as long as the building is awr�er oa.�ied. Sec�or�Cl by Chairn�n Glass�n. 1�7PICN 4�LS CA1�2IID LIl�TIM.X;SC,Y. FL'RZI�R DISCUSSICN: Mr. Wires-C�r discussed the tun fire s�rations aver the furnaoe, and the dirt legs on the water heater ar�d furr�aae. 51ae Zbskc.-y. Fire Prevention, stated that the furnaoe that serves itself, doesn't need any fire se��ration. She also said that the ivan that sexves i.�ao furn�es is �te in size for � sprinkler t�d, ar�d is rnt in violation. It was cleleted fraY► the list of c]eficiencies, ar�d S1ae said she wail.d check furthPS to m3ke sure. Mr. Winer-Cyr thaught it was unfair, as c�,�ll as experLSive, to prnvide a clirt leg. Mr. Tilton stated that it was a safety featau-e, and rbt that expensive. BoAEtD ACfiICN: Mation was m�le by Bill Tilton to c3e�y the variance on the dirt leg. Seoo�r�ded by Dcm Weida. M7TICN i�iS C�E2gD L]L�TIl�DUSLX. MZZE DISC[FSICN: Mr. intir�er�r stated t1�at the r�anex wiririg goes fran the j�u�ction box, iur3er the joist to a crawl s�oe in the bac.k fiu-r�e roan. Nobaly really arnes in dire�t c�ntact with this wiring. It's stapled to the iu�dersi.cle af the joists. Mr. tti�r�er-{.yr aqreer3 to strap the �xrelx to a 1" by 2" boaxrl, rather than disaonr�ecting it c�npletely. BC�2D ACTICN: Nbtion was m3cle by James Iaughlin to grant variarx�e as lcxyg as a the mrn_x is s-traraped to a 1" by 2" board. Seoor�cled by Bill Tilton. M7�ICN G�S C�Et[tIID iA�NIlrDUSLY. DISC�)SSICN Q:iV�Il�UID: Seoo�x3 exit f�n the third floor - there are two bedroat�s which q�en intJo pait of the 2r�c1 ar�d 3r+d floor, which is �ied by Mr. tnFi�x-(,�r. Z'here is approxi.m�tely 300 or 400 sq. ft. af i�sable s�ce. �re are smke detect.ors present. Z'he Ho�an3 di.d rx�t think that he needed to have a variar�ae, bacause it was part of hi.s imit, arxl the bed��s are t�at ir�t-.e�c]ed to be rented cxit. It was reoat�d that S1�e Zbsl�y v�rity the rocro size, and � � tr� �a � r�. r�,�-c� of � «�,e. � �ar� �a � �t J an ext-.ensi�c► of time far the cutside it-,gns. He has a March 22rxi deadline. HC]�1i.2D AL'PICN: bbti�on was m� by sill Tilton to grarYt an extension of t�me to cxnplete aztside itans w1ti1 Jime 30, 1990. Seoor�cl�ad by Don Weida. M?i'ICN Cp,REtgD L]NAN�'DUSCy.